Thyroid hormone levels before unsuccessful antidepressant therapy are associated with later response to T3 augmentation

Subclinical thyroid dysfunction and major depressive disorder

PURPOSE

This review attempts to investigate the link between subclinical thyroid dysfunction (SCH) and major depressive disorder (MDD). It has been speculated that SCH may be related to MDD through an autoimmune mechanism.

METHODS

A comprehensive literature search was conducted in the PubMed database for relevant research and review articles.

RESULTS

There appears to be an association between an autoimmune mechanism, possibly involving the thyroid gland, and depressive disorders, but the available evidence is so far inconclusive.

CONCLUSION

Lifetime prevalence of depression is significantly higher in patients with SCH, a finding reflecting a possible effect of SCH in lowering the threshold for the emergence of MDD. The relationship between SCH and MDD is, however, not clear, with large and well-designed studies investigating possible links between reference-range thyroid hormone levels and MDD having as yet found no relation between the two.

Free T4 index and clinical outcome in patients with depression

INTRODUCTION

Many studies of patients with major depression have reported that a significant decrease in serum free T(4) index is associated with specific treatments; what has been unanswered is whether these observations are generalizable. This study evaluated baseline thyroid function and its relationship to rapidity of treatment response as measured by hospital length of stay (HLOS).

METHODS

Admission thyroid indices and HLOS data were harvested from the medical record of patients hospitalized for depression, both unipolar and bipolar. The relationship between admission thyroid indices and HLOS was evaluated using survival models.

RESULTS

Controlling for age and year of discharge, an inverse relationship between FT(4) index (FT(4)I) and HLOS was present in men, but not in women. The mean HLOS stratified by gender and median FT(4)I was 50% shorter in men with a relatively high FT(4)I in comparison to the other three groups.

LIMITATIONS

This is a retrospective study limited by the absence of a structured diagnostic psychiatric interview and prospective controlled antidepressant evaluation.

CONCLUSION

These data would suggest that a relatively elevated FT(4) index in depressed men is associated with a faster antidepressant response time. Prospective study is encouraged to further clarify this potential thyroid/gender relationship and whether thyroid supplementation can accelerate the improvement in depression as measured by HLOS.

Predictors of antidepressant response: A selective review

Modern antidepressant drugs have response rates in the 65% range. Considerable effort has been made to predict which patients would be more likely to respond to antidepressant treatment. Some progress has been made, more in finding psychological predictors than biological predictors of antidepressant response. In spite of slow progress, these findings have made a valuable contribution towards the understanding of antidepressant response. In future it may be possible for psychiatrists to use a more broad-based approach, tailoring therapies to the clinical profile of individuals.

Association between lower serum free T4 and greater mood instability and depression in lithium-maintained bipolar patients

OBJECTIVE

This investigation evaluated the relationship between changes in thyroid indices and mood stability during lithium and carbamazepine prophylaxis for bipolar disorder.

METHOD

In the first 2 years, 30 patients with bipolar mood disorder were randomly assigned to 1 year of lithium and then 1 year of carbamazepine, or vice versa; in the third year, they received lithium plus carbamazepine. By stepwise regression analysis, the degree and timing of lithium- and carbamazepine-induced thyroid changes and their subsequent relationship to long-term mood stability were evaluated.

RESULTS

During the lithium phase, there was a significant inverse relationship between morbidity and mean serum level of free T4, i.e., a lower mean serum level of free T4 was associated with more affective episodes and greater severity of depression as shown by the Beck Depression Inventory. During the carbamazepine phase, there was an inverse relationship between mean level of total T4 and global severity rating. During the combination phase, no relationships between thyroid indices and clinical outcome were significant.

CONCLUSIONS

In the lithium phase, a low level of free T4 was associated with more affective episodes and greater severity of depression. Whether this mood instability is causally related to low free T4 levels and whether it can be attenuated with T4 replacement remain to be studied in a controlled setting.

Blunted TSH response to TRH and seizure duration in ECT

The relationship between the thyrotropin (TSH) response to thyrotropin-releasing hormone (TRH) and the duration of seizures induced by electroconvulsive therapy (ECT) in depressed patients was investigated. In a balanced-order cross-over design, 16 depressed women were given 0.4 mg TRH or placebo intravenously, 20 min before ECT in the first two sessions. In the third ECT session TRH was given just prior to ECT. Thyrotropin (TSH) levels at various sampling times, as well as the duration of seizures, were measured. There was a significant inverse correlation between plasma TSH concentrations 20 min after TRH administration (deltaTSH) and seizure duration. Furthermore, when patients were categorized according to their TSH response to TRH, the group with blunted responses (deltaTSH <6 microIU/ mL, n = 7) had a longer seizure time during ECT than the group with non-blunted responses (deltaTSH > 6 microIU/mL, n = 9). Finally, the seizure duration in the group with blunted TSH responses was reduced significantly when TRH was co-administered, while it remained unchanged in the group with non-blunted TSH responses. It is concluded that a blunted TSH response to TRH might indicate a seizure susceptibility as measured by the duration of seizures induced by ECT. The fact that TRH pre-administration had a reducing effect suggests that this substance might be involved in the pathophysiology of ECT-induced seizures.