High affinity as a disease determinant factor in anti-GM(1) antibodies: comparative characterization of experimentally induced vs. disease-associated antibodies

Therapeutic potentials of adoptive cell therapy in immune-mediated neuropathy

Immune-mediated neuropathy (IMN) is a group of heterogenous neuropathies caused by intricate autoimmune responses. For now, known mechanisms of different IMN subtypes involve the production of autoantibodies, complement activation, enhanced inflammation and subsequent axonal/demyelinating nerve damages. Recent therapeutic studies mainly focus on specific antibodies and small molecule inhibitors previously approved in rheumatoid diseases. Initial strategies based on the pathophysiologic features of IMN should be explored. Adoptive cell therapy (ACT) refers to the emerging immunotherapies in which circulating immunocytes are collected from peripheral blood and modified with killing and immunomodulatory capacities. It consists of chimeric antigen receptor-T cell therapy, T cell receptor-engineered T cell, CAR-Natural killer cell therapy, and others. In the last decade, ACT has demonstrated extraordinary potentials in treating cancers, infectious diseases and autoimmune diseases. Versatile combinations of targets, chimeric domains and effector cells greatly empower ACT to treat complicated immune disorders. In this review, we summarized the advances of ACT and envisioned suitable strategies for different IMN subtypes.

Interplay between Liposomes and IgM: Principles, Challenges, and Opportunities

Liposomes have received tremendous attention as a class of versatile pharmaceutical vehicles of great potential over the past several decades. However, the application of liposomes encounters major challenges due to the knowledge gaps in their in vivo delivery process. Immunoglobulin M (IgM) displays both pervasiveness and complexity in regulating the biological functions as well as eliciting adverse effects of liposomes. Understanding, mitigating, and exploiting the duality of IgM are prerequisites for achieving various biomedical applications of liposomes. In this review, the intricate relationship between liposomes and their biological environments has been summarized, with an emphasis on the regulatory effects of IgM on in vivo performance of liposomes. Corresponding solutions have also been discussed to evade IgM-mediated opsonization for safe and efficient drug delivery.

Molecular disease mechanisms of human antineuronal monoclonal autoantibodies

Autoantibodies targeting brain antigens can mediate a wide range of neurological symptoms ranging from epileptic seizures to psychosis to dementia. Although earlier experimental work indicated that autoantibodies can be directly pathogenic, detailed studies on disease mechanisms, biophysical autoantibody properties, and target interactions were hampered by the availability of human material and the paucity of monospecific disease-related autoantibodies. The emerging generation of patient-derived monoclonal autoantibodies (mAbs) provides a novel platform for the detailed characterization of immunobiology and autoantibody pathogenicity in vitro and in animal models. This Feature Review focuses on recent advances in mAb generation and discusses their potential as powerful scientific tools for high-resolution imaging, antigenic target identification, atomic-level structural analyses, and the development of antibody-selective immunotherapies.

Most of anti-glycolipid IgG-antibodies associated to neurological disorders occur without their IgM counterpart

Background

Different neurological disorders frequently display antibodies against several self-glycans. Increasing evidence supports their pathogenic role; however, far less is known about their origin. Meanwhile, antibodies recognizing non-self glycans appear in normal human serum during immune response to bacteria.

Methods

Using high performance thin layer chromatography-immunostaining, we comparatively evaluated humoral immune response (IgG and IgM immunoreactivity) against glycolipids carrying self-glycans (GM3/GM2/GM1/GD1a/GD1b/GD3/GT1b/GQ1b) and non-self glycans (Forssman/GA1/“A” blood group/Nt7) in sera from 383 patients with neurological disorders along with 87 healthy controls.

Results

In contrast to no healthy controls having anti-self glycan IgG antibodies, one-fifth of patients’ sera had anti-self glycan IgG antibodies: remarkably, 60% of these occurred without IgM antibodies of the same specificity. Contrary to this unusual fact (anti-self glycan IgG occurrence without simultaneous presence of IgM having the same specificity ~ IgG/IgM discordance), all IgG antibodies against non-self glycans occurred simultaneously with their IgM antibody counterpart (i.e. 0% discordance). When analyzed closer, the IgG/IgM discordance frequency for anti-self glycans exhibited a dual trend: below 40% for IgG antibodies against GM2, GM1 and GD1b, and greater than 53% for IgG antibodies against the remaining self glycans. Interestingly, this discordance behavior was common to several different neurological disorders.

Conclusions

Classic immunology principles indicate this anti-self glycan IgG/IgM discordance should not occur in an antibody response; its unusual presence is discussed within the “binding site drift hypothesis” context, where anti-self glycan IgG antibodies could originate from pre-existing IgG recognizing structurally-related non-self glycans.

Electronic supplementary material

The online version of this article (10.1186/s12929-019-0562-5) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.

Affinities of human NMDA receptor autoantibodies: implications for disease mechanisms and clinical diagnostics

Anti-N-methyl-d-aspartate receptor (NMDAR) encephalitis is a common autoimmune encephalitis presenting with psychosis, dyskinesias, autonomic dysfunction and seizures. The underlying autoantibodies against the NR1 subunit are directly pathogenic by disrupting synaptic NMDAR currents. However, antibody titers correlate only partially with the clinical outcome, suggesting the relevance of other factors such as antibody affinity. We thus determined the binding curves of human monoclonal autoantibodies and patients’ cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) against NR1-expressing HEK293 cells using flow cytometry. Antibody affinity was highly variable with binding constants (half-maximal concentration, c₅₀) ranging from 1 to 74 µg/ml for monoclonal antibodies. Comparing values of individual monoclonal antibodies with human CSF samples suggested that the CSF signal is predominantly represented by higher-affinity antibodies, potentially in a concentration range of NR1 antibodies between 0.1 and 5 µg/ml, roughly reflecting 1–10% of total CSF IgG in NMDAR encephalitis. Binding curves further depended on the CSF composition which must be considered when interpreting established clinical routine assays. Normalization of measurements using reference samples allowed high reproducibility. Accurate and reproducible measurement of NR1 antibody binding suggested that biophysical properties of the antibody might contribute to disease severity. Normalization of the data can be an elegant way to allow comparable inter-laboratory quantification of CSF NR1 antibody titers in autoimmune encephalitis patients, a prerequisite for use as surrogate markers in clinical trials. Based on our calculations, low-affinity antibodies can easily remain undetected in routine cell-based assays, indicating that their relation to clinical symptoms should be analyzed in future studies.

Experimental Guillain-Barre syndrome induced by immunization with gangliosides: Keyhole limpet hemocyanin is required for disease triggering

An experimental model of Guillain-Barré Syndrome has been established in recent years. Rabbits develop disease upon immunization with a single dose of an emulsion containing bovine brain gangliosides, KLH and complete Freund's adjuvant. Within a period of four to ten weeks after immunization, they began to produce anti-ganglioside IgG-antibodies first, and to show clinical signs of neuropathy afterwards. In addition to gangliosides, KLH is a requirement for antibody production and disease triggering. Although KLH is commonly used as an immunological carrier protein, an anti-KLH-specific immune response was necessary for induction of both events. KLH is a glycoprotein carrying most of the immunogenicity in its glycan moiety. Between 20% to 80% of anti-ganglioside IgG-antibodies present in sick rabbit sera cross-reacted with KLH, indicating that both immune responses are related. The terminal Gal-ß(1,3)-GalNAc glycan (present in gangliosides and KLH) is proposed as "key" antigenic determinant involved in inducing the anti-ganglioside immune response. These results are discussed in the context of the "binding site drift" hypothesis.

Individual Restriction Of Fine Specificity Variability In Anti-GM1 IgG Antibodies Associated With Guillain-Barré Syndrome

Elevated titers of serum antibodies against GM1 ganglioside are associated with a variety of autoimmune neuropathies. Much evidence indicates these autoantibodies play a primary role in the disease processes, but the mechanism for their appearance is unclear. We studied the fine specificity of anti-GM1 antibodies of the IgG isotype present in sera from patients with Guillain-Barré syndrome (GBS), using thin-layer chromatogram-immunostaining of GM1, asialo-GM1 (GA1), GD1b and GM1-derivatives with small modifications on the oligosaccharide moiety. We were able to distinguish populations of antibodies with different fine specificity. Remarkably, individual patients presented only one or two of them, and different patients had different populations. This restriction in the variability of antibody populations suggests that the appearance of the anti-GM1 antibodies is a random process involving restricted populations of lymphocytes. With the origin of disease-associated anti-GM1 antibodies as a context, this finding could provide explanation for the “host susceptibility factor” observed in GBS following enteritis with GM1 oligosaccharide-carrying strains of Campylobacter jejuni.

Cellular targets and mechanistic strategies of remyelination-promoting IgMs as part of the naturally occurring autoantibody repertoire

Immunoglobulins with germline sequences occur in invertebrates and vertebrates and are named naturally occurring autoantibodies (NAbs). NAbs may target foreign antigens, self- or altered self-components and are part of the normal immunoglobulin repertoire. Accumulating evidence indicates that naturally occurring antibodies can act as systemic surveillance molecules, which tag, damaged or stressed cells, invading pathogens and toxic cellular debris for elimination by the immune system. In addition to acting as detecting molecules, certain types of NAbs actively signal in different cell types with a broad range of responses from induction of apoptosis in cancer cells to stimulation of remyelination in glial cells. This review emphasizes functions and characteristics of NAbs with focus on remyelination-promoting mouse and human antibodies. Human remyelination-promoting NAbs are potential therapeutics to combat a wide spectrum of disease processes including demyelinating diseases like multiple sclerosis. We will highlight the identified glycosphingolipid (SL) antigens of polyreactive remyelination-promoting antibodies and their proposed mechanism(s) of action. The nature of the identified antigens suggests a lipid raft-based mechanism for remyelination-promoting antibodies with SLs as most essential raft components. However, accumulating evidence also suggests involvement of other antigens in stimulation of remyelination, which will be discussed in the text.

Simultaneous measurements of auto-immune and infectious disease specific antibodies using a high throughput multiplexing tool

Considering importance of ganglioside antibodies as biomarkers in various immune-mediated neuropathies and neurological disorders, we developed a high throughput multiplexing tool for the assessment of gangliosides-specific antibodies based on Biolpex/Luminex platform. In this report, we demonstrate that the ganglioside high throughput multiplexing tool is robust, highly specific and demonstrating ∼100-fold higher concentration sensitivity for IgG detection than ELISA. In addition to the ganglioside-coated array, the high throughput multiplexing tool contains beads coated with influenza hemagglutinins derived from H1N1 A/Brisbane/59/07 and H1N1 A/California/07/09 strains. Influenza beads provided an added advantage of simultaneous detection of ganglioside- and influenza-specific antibodies, a capacity important for the assay of both infectious antigen-specific and autoimmune antibodies following vaccination or disease. Taken together, these results support the potential adoption of the ganglioside high throughput multiplexing tool for measuring ganglioside antibodies in various neuropathic and neurological disorders.

Novel antibodies reacting with two neighboring gangliosides are induced in rabbits immunized with bovine brain gangliosides

Immunization of rabbits with bovine brain gangliosides induced an experimental neuropathy, with clinical signs resembling Guillain-Barré syndrome. All the immunized animals developed immunoglobulin G immunoreactivity to GM1 ganglioside. In a few (4 of 27) animals, an additional anti-ganglioside antibody population showing an unusual binding behavior was detected. Enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay and thin-layer chromatography immunostaining analyses showed that the binding of these unusual antibodies required the presence of two co-localized gangliosides. Maximal interaction was observed to a mixture of GM1 and GD1b, but the antibodies also showed "density-dependent" binding to GD1b. The antibodies were purified by affinity chromatography and displayed the ability to target antigens in biological membranes (rat synaptosomes).

Plasma exchange and intravenous immunoglobulins: mechanism of action in immune-mediated neuropathies

Immune-mediated neuropathies are a heterogeneous group of peripheral nerve disorders, which are classified by time course, clinical pattern, affected nerves and pathological features. Plasma exchange (PE) and intravenous immunoglobulins (IVIg) are mainstays in the treatment of immune-mediated neuropathies. Of all treatments currently used, IVIg has probably the widest application range in immune-mediated neuropathies and efficacy has been well documented in several randomized controlled trials for Guillain-Barré syndrome and chronic inflammatory demyelinating polyneuropathy (CIDP). Beneficial effects of IVIg have also been proven for multifocal motor neuropathy (MMN). Likewise, PE is an established treatment for GBS and CIDP, whereas it is considered to be ineffective in MMN. Different mechanisms of action are sought to be responsible for the immunemodulatory effect of PE and IVIg in autoimmune disorders. Some of those might be important for immune-mediated neuropathies, while others are probably negligible. The aim of this review is to summarize the recent advances in elucidating disease-specific mechanisms of actions of PE and IVIg in the treatment of immune-mediated neuropathies.

Guillain-Barré syndrome after exposure to influenza virus

Guillain-Barré syndrome (GBS) is an acute, acquired, monophasic autoimmune disorder of peripheral nerves that develops in susceptible individuals after infection and, in rare cases, after immunisation. Exposure to influenza via infection or vaccination has been associated with GBS. We review the relation between GBS and these routes of exposure. Epidemiological studies have shown that, except for the 1976 US national immunisation programme against swine-origin influenza A H1N1 subtype A/NJ/76, influenza vaccine has probably not caused GBS or, if it has, rates have been extremely low (less than one case per million vaccine recipients). By contrast, influenza-like illnesses seem to be relevant triggering events for GBS. The concerns about the risk of inducing GBS in mass immunisation programmes against H1N1 2009 do not, therefore, seem justified by the available epidemiological data. However, the experiences from the 1976 swine flu vaccination programme emphasise the importance for active and passive surveillance to monitor vaccine safety.

Passive transfer of IgG anti-GM1 antibodies impairs peripheral nerve repair

Anti-GM1 antibodies are present in some patients with autoimmune neurological disorders. These antibodies are most frequently associated with acute immune neuropathy called Guillain-Barré syndrome (GBS). Some clinical studies associate the presence of these antibodies with poor recovery in GBS. The patients with incomplete recovery have failure of nerve repair, particularly axon regeneration. Our previous work indicates that monoclonal antibodies can inhibit axon regeneration by engaging cell surface gangliosides (Lehmann et al., 2007). We asked whether passive transfer of human anti-GM1 antibodies from patients with GBS modulate axon regeneration in an animal model. Human anti-GM1 antibodies were compared with other GM1 ligands, cholera toxin B subunit and a monoclonal anti-GM1 antibody. Our results show that patient derived anti-GM1 antibodies and cholera toxin beta subunit impair axon regeneration/repair after PNS injury in mice. Comparative studies indicated that the antibody/ligand-mediated inhibition of axon regeneration is dependent on antibody/ligand characteristics such as affinity-avidity and fine specificity. These data indicate that circulating immune effectors such as human autoantibodies, which are exogenous to the nervous system, can modulate axon regeneration/nerve repair in autoimmune neurological disorders such as GBS.

Monospecific high-affinity and complement activating anti-GM1 antibodies are determinants in experimental axonal neuropathy

It has been difficult to replicate consistently the experimental model of axonal Guillain-Barré syndrome (GBS). We immunized rabbits with two lipo-oligosaccharides (LOS1 and LOS2) derived from the same C. jejuni strain and purified in a slightly different way. LOS1 did not contain proteins whereas several proteins were present in LOS2. In spite of a robust anti-GM1 antibody response in all animals the neuropathy developed only in rabbits immunized with LOS1. To explain this discrepancy we investigated fine specificity, affinity and ability to activate the complement of anti-GM1 antibodies. Only rabbits immunized with LOS1 showed monospecific high-affinity antibodies which activated more effectively the complement. Although it is not well understood how monospecific high-affinity antibodies are induced these are crucial for the induction of experimental axonal neuropathy. Only a strict adherence to the protocols demonstrated to be successful may guarantee the reproducibility and increase the confidence in the animal model as a reliable tool for the study of the human axonal GBS.

Differential endocytic trafficking of neuropathy-associated antibodies to GM1 ganglioside and cholera toxin in epithelial and neural cells

Gangliosides are glycolipids mainly present at the plasma membrane (PM). Antibodies to gangliosides have been associated with a wide range of neuropathy syndromes. Particularly, antibodies to GM1 ganglioside are present in patients with Guillain-Barré syndrome (GBS). We investigated the binding and intracellular fate of antibody to GM1 obtained from rabbits with experimental GBS in comparison with the transport of cholera toxin (CTx), which binds with high affinity to GM1. We demonstrated that antibody to GM1 is rapidly and specifically endocytosed in CHO-K1 cells. After internalization, the antibody transited sorting endosomes to accumulate at the recycling endosome. Endocytosed antibody to GM1 is recycled back to the PM and released into the culture medium. In CHO-K1 cells, antibody to GM1 colocalized with co-endocytosed CTx at early and recycling endosomes, but not in Golgi complex and endoplasmic reticulum, where CTx was also located. Antibody to GM1, in contraposition to CTx, showed a reduced internalization to recycling endosomes in COS-7 cells and neural cell lines SH-SY5Y and Neuro2A. Results from photobleaching studies revealed differences in the lateral mobility of antibody to GM1 in the PM of analyzed cell lines, suggesting a relationship between the efficiency of endocytosis and lateral mobility of GM1 at the PM. Taken together, results indicate that two different ligands of GM1 ganglioside (antibody and CTx) are differentially endocytosed and trafficked, providing the basis to gain further insight into the mechanisms that operate in the intracellular trafficking of glycosphingolipid-binding toxins and pathological effects of neuropathy-associated antibodies.

Structural requirements of anti-GD1a antibodies determine their target specificity

The acute motor axonal neuropathy (AMAN) variant of Guillain-Barré syndrome (GBS) is associated with anti-GD1a and anti-GM1 IgG antibodies. The basis of preferential motor nerve injury in this disease is not clear, however, because biochemical studies demonstrate that sensory and motor nerves express similar quantities of GD1a and GM1 gangliosides. To elucidate the pathophysiology of AMAN, we have developed several monoclonal antibodies (mAbs) with GD1a reactivity and reported that one mAb, GD1a-1, preferentially stained motor axons in human and rodent nerves. To understand the basis of this preferential motor axon staining, several derivatives of GD1a were generated by various chemical modifications of N-acetylneuraminic (sialic) acid residues (GD1a NeuAc 1-amide, GD1a NeuAc ethyl ester, GD1a NeuAc 1-alcohol, GD1a NeuAc 1-methyl ester, GD1a NeuAc 7-alcohol, GD1a NeuAc 7-aldehyde) on this ganglioside. Binding of anti-GD1a mAbs and AMAN sera with anti-GD1a Abs to these derivatives was examined. Our results indicate that mAbs with selective motor axon staining had a distinct pattern of reactivity with GD1a-derivatives compared to mAbs that stain both motor and sensory axons. The fine specificity of the anti-GD1a antibodies determines their motor selectivity, which was validated by cloning a new mAb (GD1a-E6) with a chemical and immunocytochemical binding pattern similar to that of GD1a-1 but with two orders of magnitude higher affinity. Control studies indicate that selective binding of mAbs to motor nerves is not due to differences in antibody affinity or ceramide structural specificity. Since GD1a-reactive mAb with preferential motor axon staining showed similar binding to sensory- and motor nerve-derived GD1a in a solid phase assay, we generated computer models of GD1a based on binding patterns of different GD1a-reactive mAbs to different GD1a-derivatives. These modelling studies suggest that critical GD1a epitopes recognized by mAbs are differentially expressed in motor and sensory nerves. The GD1a-derivative binding patterns of AMAN sera resembled those with motor-specific mAbs. On the basis of these findings we postulate that both the fine specificity and ganglioside orientation/exposure in the tissues contribute to target recognition by anti-ganglioside antibodies and this observation provides one explanation for preferential motor axon injury in AMAN.

Anti-GM1 antibodies as a model of the immune response to self-glycans

Glycans are a class of molecules with high structural variability, frequently found in the plasma membrane facing the extracellular space. Because of these characteristics, glycans are often considered as recognition molecules involved in cell social functions, and as targets of pathogenic factors. Induction of anti-glycan antibodies is one of the early events in immunological defense against bacteria that colonize the body. Because of this natural infection, antibodies recognizing a variety of bacterial glycans are found in sera of adult humans and animals. The immune response to glycans is restricted by self-tolerance, and no antibodies to self-glycans should exist in normal subjects. However, antibodies recognizing structures closely related to self-glycans do exist, and can lead to production of harmful anti-self antibodies. Normal human sera contain low-affinity anti-GM1 IgM-antibodies. Similar antibodies with higher affinity or different isotype are found in some neuropathy patients. Two hypotheses have been developed to explain the origin of disease-associated anti-GM1 antibodies. According to the "molecular mimicry" hypothesis, similarity between GM1 and Campylobacter jejuni lipopolysaccharide carrying a GM1-like glycan is the cause of Guillain-Barré syndrome associated with anti-GM1 IgG-antibodies. According to the "binding site drift" hypothesis, IgM-antibodies associated with disease originate through changes in the binding site of normally occurring anti-GM1 antibodies. We now present an "integrated" hypothesis, combining the "mimicry" and "drift" concepts, which satisfactorily explains most of the published data on anti-GM1 antibodies.

Lewis rats immunized with GM1 ganglioside do not develop peripheral neuropathy

Elevated levels of anti-GM1 antibodies are associated with motor nerve syndromes. Although there is a lot of circumstantial evidence that anti-GM1 antibodies may be causing the disease, their precise role remains unclear. In order to study the role of anti-GM1 antibodies in the pathogenesis of peripheral neuropathy, eight Lewis rats were injected with GM1 ganglioside mixed with keyhole limpet hemocyanin (KLH) and emulsified with Freund's adjuvant and three rats were immunized with GM1 in liposomes. Although IgM class anti-GM1 antibodies were detected in all animals immunized with GM1, none of the animals exhibited overt signs of neuropathy during 6 months after initial immunization. IgG antibody to GM1 was not produced in any of the animals. There was no pathological evidence of nerve damage. These studies suggest that elevated levels of IgM anti-GM1 antibodies by themselves do not cause nerve damage in rats.

Leukocyte and complement activation by GM1-specific antibodies is associated with acute motor axonal neuropathy in rabbits

Acute motor axonal neuropathy (AMAN) in humans is associated with the presence of GM1-specific antibodies. Immunization of rabbits with GM1-containing ganglioside mixtures, purified GM1, or Campylobacter jejuni lipo-oligosaccharide exhibiting a GM1-like structure elicits GM1-specific antibodies, but axonal polyneuropathy only occurs in a subset of animals. This study aimed to dissect the molecular basis for the variable induction of AMAN in rabbits. Therefore, we analyzed the pro-inflammatory characteristics of GM1-specific antibodies in plasma samples from ganglioside-immunized rabbits with and without neurological deficits. GM1-specific plasma samples from all rabbits with AMAN were capable of activating both complement and leukocytes, in contrast to none of the plasma samples from rabbits without paralysis. Furthermore, GM1-specific IgG-mediated activation of leukocytes was detected before the onset of clinical signs. These data suggest that AMAN only occurs in rabbits that develop GM1-specific antibodies with pro-inflammatory properties.

Ganglioside-specific IgG and IgA recruit leukocyte effector functions in Guillain-Barré syndrome

The capacity of ganglioside-specific autoantibodies to recruit leukocyte effector functions was studied. Serum samples from 87 patients with Guillain-Barré (GBS) or Miller Fisher syndrome (MFS), containing GM1-, GQ1b-, or GD1b-specific IgG or IgA, were tested for leukocyte activating capacity. Ganglioside-specific IgG antibodies generally induced leukocyte activation, irrespective of specificity. The magnitude of leukocyte degranulation correlated with GM1- and GQ1b-specific IgG titers, but not with disease severity. Finally, GM1-specific IgA activated leukocytes through the IgA receptor, FcalphaRI (CD89). Therefore, both ganglioside-specific IgG and IgA can recruit leukocyte effector functions, which may be relevant in the pathogenesis of GBS and MFS.

High affinity of anti-GM1 antibodies is associated with disease onset in experimental neuropathy

High antibody affinity has been proposed as a disease determinant factor in neuropathies associated with anti-GM1 antibodies. An experimental model of Guillain-Barré syndrome, induced by immunization of rabbits with bovine brain gangliosides or GM1, was described recently (Yuki et al. [2001] Ann. Neurol. 49:712-720). We searched plasma from these rabbits, taken at disease onset and 1 or 2 weeks prior to onset, for the presence of high-affinity anti-GM1 IgG antibodies. Affinity was estimated by soluble antigen binding inhibition. High-affinity antibodies (binding inhibition by 10(-9) M GM1) were detected at disease onset but not before. No such difference was found for other antibody parameters such as titer, fine specificity, and population distribution. These findings support the proposed role of high affinity as an important factor in disease induction by anti-GM1 antibodies.

Unusual presence of anti-GM1 IgG-antibodies in a healthy individual, and their possible involvement in the origin of disease-associated anti-GM1 antibodies

Anti-GM1 antibodies of the IgG isotype are found in serum from patients with Guillain-Barré syndrome. In normal human sera, anti-GM1 IgM-antibodies are commonly present, but their IgG counterpart has not been previously demonstrated. During routine screening, we found a normal human serum with a high titer of anti-GM1 IgG-antibodies (IgG1 subclass). Affinity estimation by soluble antigen-binding inhibition indicated that they are low-affinity antibodies with IC50 values between one and two orders of magnitude higher than those of anti-GM1 IgG-antibodies from Guillain-Barré patients. Various antibody parameters remained fairly constant for 1 year, in additional serum samples taken at 4-month intervals. Such anti-GM1 IgG1-antibodies were not detected in > 100 other normal serum samples tested, indicating a very low frequency in the general population. The low affinity of these unusually present antibodies could explain the absence of disease, despite their relatively high titer. The significance of this finding in the origin of disease-associated anti-GM1 antibodies is discussed.

A new type of anti-ganglioside antibodies present in neurological patients

High titers of anti-GA1 antibodies have been associated with neurological syndromes. In most cases, these antibodies cross-react with the structurally related glycolipids GM1 and GD1b, although specific anti-GA1 antibodies have also been reported. The role of specific anti-GA1 antibodies is uncertain since the presence of GA1 in the human nervous system has not been clarified. A rabbit was immunized with GD1a and its sera were screened for antibody reactivity by standard immunoassay methods (HPTLC-immunostaining and ELISA). Anti-GD1a antibodies were not detected but, unexpectedly, anti-GA1 IgG-antibodies were found. Antibody binding to GA1 was inhibited by soluble GA1 but also by GD1a. These results indicate that the rabbit produced antibodies that recognize epitopes present on the glycolipids, that are absent or not exposed on solid phase adsorbed GD1a. We investigated the presence of these unusual anti-ganglioside antibodies in normal and neurological patient sera. Approximately, 10% of normal human sera contained low titer of specific anti-GA1 IgG-antibodies but none of them recognized soluble GD1a. High titers of IgG-antibodies reacting only with GA1 were detected in 12 patient sera out of 325 analyzed. Of these, 6 sera showed binding that was inhibited by soluble GD1a and four of them also by GM1. This new type of anti-ganglioside antibodies should be considered important elements for understanding of the pathogenesis of these diseases as well as their diagnosis.

An anti-ganglioside antibody-secreting hybridoma induces neuropathy in mice

Immune responses against gangliosides are strongly implicated in the pathogenesis of some variants of Guillain-Barré syndrome (GBS). For example, IgG antibodies against GM1, GD1a, and related gangliosides are frequently present in patients with post-Campylobacter acute motor axonal neuropathy (AMAN) variant of GBS, and immunization of rabbits with GM1 has produced a model of AMAN. However, the role of anti-ganglioside antibodies in GBS continues to be debated because of lack of a passive transfer model. We recently have raised several monoclonal IgG anti-ganglioside antibodies. We passively transfer these antibodies by intraperitoneal hybridoma implantation and by systemic administration of purified anti-ganglioside antibodies in mice. Approximately half the animals implanted with an intraperitoneal clone of anti-ganglioside antibody-secreting hybridoma developed a patchy, predominantly axonal neuropathy affecting a small proportion of nerve fibers. In contrast to hybridoma implantation, passive transfer with systemically administered anti-ganglioside antibodies did not cause nerve fiber degeneration despite high titre circulating antibodies. Blood-nerve barrier studies indicate that animals implanted with hybridoma had leaky blood-nerve barrier compared to mice that received systemically administered anti-ganglioside antibodies. Our findings suggest that in addition to circulating antibodies, factors such as antibody accessibility and nerve fiber resistance to antibody-mediated injury play a role in the development of neuropathy.

Normally occurring human anti-GM1 immunoglobulin M antibodies and the immune response to bacteria

Anti-GM(1) antibodies of the immunoglobulin M (IgM) isotype are normal components of the antibody repertoire of adult human serum. Using a sensitive high-performance thin-layer chromatography (HPTLC) immunostaining assay, we found that these antibodies were absent in the umbilical vein and children <1 month of age but could be detected after 1 month of age. Although most of the children older than 6 months of age were positive, there were still a few negative children. The appearance of anti-GM(1) IgM antibodies showed a perfect concordance with two well-characterized antibacterial antibodies, anti-Forssman and anti-blood group A, which indicates a similar origin. We also studied IgM reactivity with lipopolysaccharides (LPSs) from gram-negative bacteria isolated from stool samples from healthy babies and from Escherichia coli HB101 in serum from individuals of different ages. We found a positive reaction with both LPSs in all the children more than 1 month of age analyzed, even in those that were negative for anti-GM(1) antibodies. Anti-GM(1) IgM antibodies were purified from adult serum by affinity chromatography and tested for the ability to bind LPSs from different bacteria. This highly specific preparation showed reactivity only with LPS from a strain of Campylobacter jejuni isolated from a patient with diarrhea. We conclude that normally occurring IgM antibodies are generated after birth, probably during the immune defense against specific bacterial strains.

Induction of human IgM and IgG anti-GM1 antibodies in transgenic mice in response to lipopolysaccharides from Campylobacter jejuni

Campylobacter jejuni lipopolysaccharides (LPS) are implicated in the development of autoantibodies to GM1 ganglioside in patients with neuropathy following C. jejuni infection. CjLPS bears oligosaccharides that are cross reactive with GM1 ganglioside and presumably exerts its effects via molecular mimicry. To study the mechanisms that are involved in development of the autoantibody response, a transgenic mouse line was developed that expresses an IgM anti-GM1 antibody derived from a patient with multifocal motor neuropathy (MMN). In vivo stimulation of the transgenic mice with C. jejuni lipopolysaccharides (CjLPS), but not of wild-type mice readily elicited high serum titers of anti-GM1 IgM antibodies, followed by IgG anti-GM1 antibodies after two booster injections. In in vitro experiments, CjLPS stimulated the transgenic B-cells at lower concentration than control LPS. The increased sensitivity to CjLPS and the induction of IgG anti-GM1 by CjLPS but not control LPS are consistent with a mechanism of B-cell activation that involves both the LPS and the antigen-specific surface Ig receptors, with possible participation of T-cells.

Pathogenicity of anti-ganglioside antibodies in the Guillain-Barré syndrome

Guillain-Barré syndrome (GBS) is a postinfectious inflammatory polyradiculo-neuropathy characterized by flaccid paralysis. Antibodies directed against glycolipid structures (gangliosides), which are highly expressed in the peripheral nervous system, are frequently detected in sera from GBS patients. These antibodies interfere with nerve conduction and have been shown to activate phagocytes via IgG receptors (FcgammaR). These findings support an important role of glycolipid-specific antibodies in the pathogenesis of GBS.

Anti-GM1 IgG antibodies induce leukocyte effector functions via Fcgamma receptors

Guillain-Barré syndrome (GBS) is an immune-mediated neuropathy, in which leukocytes and humoral components of the immune system proposedly initiate localized inflammation. An important pathogenic role for anti-GM1 ganglioside antibodies has been suggested. Therefore, we evaluated anti-GM1 IgG antibody-induced leukocyte effector functions such as degranulation and phagocytosis using serum of 24 GBS patients. Serum without anti-GM1 antibodies of 9 GBS patients as well as pooled serum from healthy individuals served as controls. Ten out of 15 (67%) of anti-GM1 IgG positive sera were capable of inducing leukocyte degranulation, and 8 out of 15 (53%) of anti-GM1 IgG positive sera were capable of inducing phagocytosis of GM1-coated beads. In all of these sera anti-GM1 antibody titers were >or=1:800. No leukocyte degranulation or phagocytosis was observed in control sera. Leukocyte activation was completely abrogated in the presence of IgG receptor (FcgammaR) blocking antibodies, suggesting a crucial role for leukocyte FcgammaR in GBS pathogenesis. No correlation of antibody titers with the extent of leukocyte activation, or severity of disease was observed. These data document the capacity of anti-GM1 IgG antibodies to activate leukocyte inflammatory functions, and suggest an important role for anti-ganglioside IgG antibodies in the pathogenesis of GBS.

The origin of anti-GM1 antibodies in neuropathies: the "binding site drift" hypothesis

Elevated titers of serum antibodies against GM1-ganglioside are associated with a variety of autoimmune neuropathies. The origin of these autoantibodies is still unknown, although there is evidence that they are produced by CD5+ B-lymphocytes and that antigen mimicry is involved. Anti-GM, IgM-antibodies in the normal human immunological repertoire are low affinity antibodies that cross-react with other glycoconjugates carrying Gal beta1-3GalNAc and probably do not have GM1-mediated biological activity. Other anti-GM1 IgM-antibodies with higher affinity and/or different fine specificity are present in patients with motor syndromes. Based on our studies of structural requirement for binding, we hypothesize that disease-associated anti-GM1 antibodies originate at random by mutations affecting the binding site of naturally-occurring ones. The hypothesis is conceptually similar to the established phenomenon of "genetic drift" in species evolutionary biology and is therefore termed "binding site drift".