Nucleotide binding to the chaperonin GroEL: non-cooperative binding of ATP analogs and ADP, and cooperative effect of ATP

Functional diversity in archaeal Hsp60: a molecular mosaic of Group I and Group II chaperonin

External stress disrupts the balance of protein homeostasis, necessitating the involvement of heat shock proteins (Hsps) in restoring equilibrium and ensuring cellular survival. The thermoacidophilic crenarchaeon Sulfolobus acidocaldarius, lacks the conventional Hsp100, Hsp90, and Hsp70, relying solely on a single ATP-dependent Group II chaperonin, Hsp60, comprising three distinct subunits (α, β, and γ) to refold unfolded substrates and maintain protein homeostasis. Hsp60 forms three different complexes, namely Hsp60αβγ, Hsp60αβ, and Hsp60β, at temperatures of 60 °C, 75 °C, and 90 °C, respectively. This study delves into the intricacies of Hsp60 complexes in S. acidocaldarius, uncovering their ability to form oligomeric structures in the presence of ATP. The recognition of substrates by Hsp60 involves hydrophobic interactions, and the subsequent refolding process occurs in an ATP-dependent manner through charge-driven interactions. Furthermore, the Hsp60β homo-oligomeric complex can protect the archaeal and eukaryotic membrane from stress-induced damage. Hsp60 demonstrates nested cooperativity in ATP hydrolysis activity, where MWC-type cooperativity is nested within KNF-type cooperativity. Remarkably, during ATP hydrolysis, Hsp60β, and Hsp60αβ complexes exhibit a mosaic behavior, aligning with characteristics observed in both Group I and Group II chaperonins, adding a layer of complexity to their functionality.

Dissecting the Thermodynamics of ATP Binding to GroEL One Nucleotide at a Time

Variable-temperature electrospray ionization (vT-ESI) native mass spectrometry (nMS) is used to determine the thermodynamics for stepwise binding of up to 14 ATP molecules to the 801 kDa GroEL tetradecamer chaperonin complex. Detailed analysis reveals strong enthalpy-entropy compensation (EEC) for the ATP binding events leading to formation of GroEL-ATP₇ and GroEL-ATP₁₄ complexes. The observed variations in EEC and stepwise free energy changes of specific ATP binding are consistent with the well-established nested cooperativity model describing GroEL-ATP interactions, viz., intraring positive cooperativity and inter-ring negative cooperativity (Dyachenko A.; Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A.2013, 110, 7235-7239). Entropy-driven ATP binding is to be expected for ligand-induced conformational changes of the GroEL tetradecamer, though the magnitude of the entropy change suggests that reorganization of GroEL-hydrating water molecules and/or expulsion of water from the GroEL cavity may also play key roles. The capability for determining complete thermodynamic signatures (ΔG, ΔH, and -TΔS) for individual ligand binding reactions for the large, nearly megadalton GroEL complex expands our fundamental view of chaperonin functional chemistry. Moreover, this work and related studies of protein-ligand interactions illustrate important new capabilities of vT-ESI-nMS for thermodynamic studies of protein interactions with ligands and other molecules such as proteins and drugs.

Temperature Regulates Stability, Ligand Binding (Mg2+ and ATP), and Stoichiometry of GroEL-GroES Complexes

Chaperonins are nanomachines that harness ATP hydrolysis to power and catalyze protein folding, a chemical action that is directly linked to the maintenance of cell function through protein folding/refolding and assembly. GroEL and the GroEL-GroES complex are archetypal examples of such protein folding machines. Here, variable-temperature electrospray ionization (vT-ESI) native mass spectrometry is used to delineate the effects of solution temperature and ATP concentrations on the stabilities of GroEL and GroEL-GroES complexes. The results show clear evidence for destabilization of both GroEL₁₄ and GroES₇ at temperatures of 50 and 45 °C, respectively, substantially below the previously reported melting temperature (T_m ∼ 70 °C). This destabilization is accompanied by temperature-dependent reaction products that have previously unreported stoichiometries, viz. GroEL₁₄-GroES_y-ATP_n, where y = 1, 2, 8 and n = 0, 1, 2, 8, that are also dependent on Mg²⁺ and ATP concentrations. Variable-temperature native mass spectrometry reveals new insights about the stability of GroEL in response to temperature effects: (i) temperature-dependent ATP binding to GroEL; (ii) effects of temperature as well as Mg²⁺ and ATP concentrations on the stoichiometry of the GroEL-GroES complex, with Mg²⁺ showing greater effects compared to ATP; and (iii) a change in the temperature-dependent stoichiometries of the GroEL-GroES complex (GroEL₁₄-GroES₇ vs GroEL₁₄-GroES₈) between 24 and 40 °C. The similarities between results obtained by using native MS and cryo-EM [Clare et al. An expanded protein folding cage in the GroEL-gp31 complex. J. Mol. Biol. 2006, 358, 905-911; Ranson et al. Allosteric signaling of ATP hydrolysis in GroEL-GroES complexes.Nat. Struct. Mol. Biol. 2006, 13, 147-152] underscore the utility of native MS for investigations of molecular machines as well as identification of key intermediates involved in the chaperonin-assisted protein folding cycle.

Chaperonin-assisted protein folding: a chronologue

This chronologue seeks to document the discovery and development of an understanding of oligomeric ring protein assemblies known as chaperonins that assist protein folding in the cell. It provides detail regarding genetic, physiologic, biochemical, and biophysical studies of these ATP-utilizing machines from both in vivo and in vitro observations. The chronologue is organized into various topics of physiology and mechanism, for each of which a chronologic order is generally followed. The text is liberally illustrated to provide firsthand inspection of the key pieces of experimental data that propelled this field. Because of the length and depth of this piece, the use of the outline as a guide for selected reading is encouraged, but it should also be of help in pursuing the text in direct order.

Formation of the chaperonin complex studied by 2D NMR spectroscopy

We studied the interaction between GroES and a single-ring mutant (SR1) of GroEL by the NMR titration of ¹⁵N-labeled GroES with SR1 at three different temperatures (20, 25 and 30°C) in the presence of 3 mM ADP in 100 mM KCl and 10 mM MgCl₂ at pH 7.5. We used SR1 instead of wild-type double-ring GroEL to precisely control the stoichiometry of the GroES binding to be 1:1 ([SR1]:[GroES]). Native heptameric GroES was very flexible, showing well resolved cross peaks of the residues in a mobile loop segment (residue 17–34) and at the top of a roof hairpin (Asn51) in the heteronuclear single quantum coherence spectra. The binding of SR1 to GroES caused the cross peaks to disappear simultaneously, and hence it occurred in a single-step cooperative manner with significant immobilization of the whole GroES structure. The binding was thus entropic with a positive entropy change (219 J/mol/K) and a positive enthalpy change (35 kJ/mol), and the binding constant was estimated at 1.9×10⁵ M⁻¹ at 25°C. The NMR titration in 3 mM ATP also indicated that the binding constant between GroES and SR1 increased more than tenfold as compared with the binding constant in 3 mM ADP. These results will be discussed in relation to the structure and mechanisms of the chaperonin GroEL/GroES complex.

Allosteric Mechanisms in Chaperonin Machines

Chaperonins are nanomachines that facilitate protein folding by undergoing energy (ATP)-dependent movements that are coordinated in time and space owing to complex allosteric regulation. They consist of two back-to-back stacked oligomeric rings with a cavity at each end where protein substrate folding can take place. Here, we focus on the GroEL/GroES chaperonin system from Escherichia coli and, to a lesser extent, on the more poorly characterized eukaryotic chaperonin CCT/TRiC. We describe their various functional (allosteric) states and how they are affected by substrates and allosteric effectors that include ATP, ADP, nonfolded protein substrates, potassium ions, and GroES (in the case of GroEL). We also discuss the pathways of intra- and inter-ring allosteric communication by which they interconvert and the coupling between allosteric transitions and protein folding reactions.

Dynamics, flexibility, and allostery in molecular chaperonins

The chaperonins are a family of molecular chaperones present in all three kingdoms of life. They are classified into Group I and Group II. Group I consists of the bacterial variants (GroEL) and the eukaryotic ones from mitochondria and chloroplasts (Hsp60), while Group II consists of the archaeal (thermosomes) and eukaryotic cytosolic variants (CCT or TRiC). Both groups assemble into a dual ring structure, with each ring providing a protective folding chamber for nascent and denatured proteins. Their functional cycle is powered by ATP binding and hydrolysis, which drives a series of structural rearrangements that enable encapsulation and subsequent release of the substrate protein. Chaperonins have elaborate allosteric mechanisms to regulate their functional cycle. Long-range negative cooperativity between the two rings ensures alternation of the folding chambers. Positive intra-ring cooperativity, which facilitates concerted conformational transitions within the protein subunits of one ring, has only been demonstrated for Group I chaperonins. In this review, we describe our present understanding of the underlying mechanisms and the structure-function relationships in these complex protein systems with a particular focus on the structural dynamics, allostery, and associated conformational rearrangements.

Evaluation of the stability of an SR398/GroES chaperonin complex

The stability of an SR398/GroES chaperonin complex was examined. As was expected, based on the finding of previous studies, the SR398/GroES complex was extremely stable in the presence of an excess amount of free adenosine 5'-[γ-thio]triphosphate (ATPγS) or adenosine 5'-(β,γ-imido)triphosphate (AMPPNP). However, the complex was not stable in the absence of nucleotides. These results indicate that ATPγS and AMPPNP repeatedly associated to and dissociated from the complex in a non-cooperative manner. This nucleotide exchange did not induce the dissociation of GroES and substrate from SR398, suggesting the importance of the cooperative dissociation of nucleotides from the cis-ring to release GroES and substrate proteins in the GroEL/GroES reaction cycle.

The H/D-exchange kinetics of the Escherichia coli co-chaperonin GroES studied by 2D NMR and DMSO-quenched exchange methods

We studied hydrogen/deuterium-exchange reactions of peptide amide protons of GroES using two different techniques: (1) two-dimensional (1)H-(15)N transverse-optimized NMR spectroscopy and (2) the dimethylsulfoxide-quenched hydrogen-exchange method combined with conventional (1)H-(15)N heteronuclear single quantum coherence spectroscopy. By using these techniques together with direct heteronuclear single quantum coherence experiments, we quantitatively evaluated the exchange rates for 33 out of the 94 peptide amide protons of GroES and their protection factors, and for the remaining 61 residues, we obtained the lower limits of the exchange rates. The protection factors of the most highly protected amide protons were on the order of 10(6)-10(7), and the values were comparable in magnitude to those observed in typical small globular proteins, but the number of the highly protected amide protons with a protection factor larger than 10(6) was only 10, significantly smaller than the numbers reported for the small globular proteins, indicating that significant portions of free heptameric GroES are flexible and natively unfolded. The highly protected amino acid residues with a protection factor larger than 10(5) were mainly located in three β-strands that form the hydrophobic core of GroES, while the residues in a mobile loop (residues 17-34) were not highly protected. The protection factors of the most highly protected amide protons were orders of magnitude larger than the value expected from the equilibrium unfolding parameters previously reported, strongly suggesting that the equilibrium unfolding of GroES is more complicated than a simple two-state or three-state mechanism and may involve more than a single intermediate.

Nucleotide-induced conformational changes of tetradecameric GroEL mapped by H/D exchange monitored by FT-ICR mass spectrometry

Here we employ hydrogen/deuterium exchange mass spectrometry (HDX-MS) to access E. coli chaperonin GroEL conformation. The ~800 kDa tetradecameric GroEL plays an essential role in the proper folding of many proteins. Previous studies of the structural dynamics of GroEL upon ATP binding have been inconsistent, showing either minimal or major allosteric changes. Our results, based on the native, non-mutated, protein under physiological conditions in solution demonstrate substantial changes in conformation and/or flexibility upon ATP binding. We capture the pivotal step in its functional cycle by use of a non-hydrolyzable ATP analog, ATPγS, to mimic the ATP-bound GroEL state. Comparison of HDX-MS results for apo GroEL and GroEL-ATPγS enables the characterization of the nucleotide-regulated conformational changes throughout the entire protein with high sequence resolution. The 14-mer GroEL complex is the largest protein assembly yet accessed by HDX-MS, with sequence resolution of segments of as few as five amino acids.

Chaperonin-affected folding of globular proteins

We studied the effect of GroEL on the kinetic refolding ofα-lactalbumin by stopped-flow fluorescence techniques. We usedwild-type GroEL and its ATPase-defficient mutant D398A, and studied thebinding constants between GroEL and the molten globule foldingintermediate at various concentrations of ADP and ATP. The results arecompared with titration of GroEL with the nucleotides, ADP, ATP-analogs(ATP-γS and AMP-PNP) and ATP, which have shown that bothADP and the ATP analogs are bound to GroEL in a non-cooperativemanner but that ATP shows a cooperative effect. Similarly, the bindingconstant between GroEL and the folding intermediate decreased in acooperative manner with an increase in ATP concentration although itshowed non-cooperative decrease with respect to ADP concentration. Itis shown that the allosteric control of GroEL by the nucleotides isresponsible for the above behavior of GroEL and that the observeddifference between the ATP- and ADP-induced transitions of GroEL isbrought about by a small difference in an allosteric parameter (the ratio ofthe nucleotide affinities of GroEL in the high-affinity and the low-affinitystates), i.e., 4.1 for ATP and 2.6 for ADP.

Expression and functional characterization of the first bacteriophage-encoded chaperonin

Chaperonins promote protein folding in vivo and are ubiquitously found in bacteria, archaea, and eukaryotes. The first viral chaperonin GroEL ortholog, gene product 146 (gp146), whose gene was earlier identified in the genome of bacteriophage EL, has been shown to be synthesized during phage propagation in Pseudomonas aeruginosa cells. The recombinant gp146 has been expressed in Escherichia coli and characterized by different physicochemical methods for the first time. Using serum against the recombinant protein, gp146's native substrate, the phage endolysin gp188, has been immunoprecipitated from the lysate of EL-infected bacteria and identified by mass spectrometry. In vitro experiments have shown that gp146 has a protective effect against endolysin thermal inactivation and aggregation, providing evidence of its chaperonin function. The phage chaperonin has been found to have the architecture and some properties similar to those of GroEL but not to require cochaperonin for its functional activity.

Dissecting a bimolecular process of MgATP²- binding to the chaperonin GroEL

Although allosteric transitions of GroEL by MgATP(2)(-) have been widely studied, the initial bimolecular step of MgATP(2-) binding to GroEL remains unclear. Here, we studied the equilibrium and kinetics of MgATP(2)(-) binding to a variant of GroEL, in which Tyr485 was replaced by tryptophan, via isothermal titration calorimetry (ITC) and stopped-flow fluorescence spectroscopy. In the absence of K(+) at 4-5 °C, the allosteric transitions and the subsequent ATP hydrolysis by GroEL are halted, and hence, the stopped-flow fluorescence kinetics induced by rapid mixing of MgATP(2)(-) and the GroEL variant solely reflected MgATP(2)(-) binding, which was well represented by bimolecular noncooperative binding with a binding rate constant, k(on), of 9.14×10(4) M(-1) s(-1) and a dissociation rate constant, k(off), of 14.2 s(-1), yielding a binding constant, K(b) (=k(on)/k(off)), of 6.4×10(3) M(-1). We also successfully performed ITC to measure binding isotherms of MgATP(2)(-) to GroEL and obtained a K(b) of 9.5×10(3) M(-1) and a binding stoichiometric number of 6.6. K(b) was thus in good agreement with that obtained by stopped-flow fluorescence. In the presence of 10-50 mM KCl, the fluorescence kinetics consisted of three to four phases (the first fluorescence-increasing phase, followed by one or two exponential fluorescence-decreasing phases, and the final slow fluorescence-increasing phase), and comparison of the kinetics in the absence and presence of K(+) clearly demonstrated that the first fluorescence-increasing phase corresponds to bimolecular MgATP(2)(-) binding to GroEL. The temperature dependence of the kinetics indicated that MgATP(2)(-) binding to GroEL was activation-controlled with an activation enthalpy as large as 14-16 kcal mol(-1).

Out-of-equilibrium conformational cycling of GroEL under saturating ATP concentrations

The molecular chaperone GroEL exists in at least two allosteric states, T and R, that interconvert in an ATP-controlled manner. Thermodynamic analysis suggests that the T-state population becomes negligible with increasing ATP concentrations, in conflict with the requirement for conformational cycling, which is essential for the operation of molecular machines. To solve this conundrum, we performed fluorescence correlation spectroscopy on the single-ring version of GroEL, using a fluorescent switch recently built into its structure, which turns "on," i.e., increases its fluorescence dramatically, when ATP is added. A series of correlation functions was measured as a function of ATP concentration and analyzed using singular-value decomposition. The analysis assigned the signal to two states whose dynamics clearly differ. Surprisingly, even at ATP saturation, approximately 50% of the molecules still populate the T state at any instance of time, indicating constant out-of-equilibrium cycling between T and R. Only upon addition of the cochaperonin GroES does the T-state population vanish. Our results suggest a model in which the T/R ratio is controlled by the rate of ADP release after hydrolysis, which can be determined accordingly.

Thermodynamics of the protein translocation

Many proteins synthesized in bacteria are secreted from the cytoplasm into the periplasm to function in the cell envelope or in the extracellular medium. The Sec translocase is a primary and evolutionary conserved secretion pathway in bacteria. It catalyzes the translocation of unfolded proteins across the cytoplasmic membrane via the pore-forming SecYEG complex. This process is driven by the proton motive force and ATP hydrolysis facilitated by the SecA motor protein. Current insights in the mechanism of protein translocation are largely based on elaborate multidisciplinary studies performed during the last three decades. To understand the process dynamics, the thermodynamic principles of translocation and the subunit interactions need to be addressed. Isothermal titration calorimetry has been widely applied to study thermodynamics of biological interactions, their stability, and driving forces. Here, we describe the examples that exploit this method to investigate key interactions among components of the Sec translocase and suggest further potential applications of calorimetry.

Design of an optical switch for studying conformational dynamics in individual molecules of GroEL

We describe the design of an optical switch in the chaperonin GroEL that is opened and closed by its ATP- and cochaperonin GroES-driven conformational changes. The switch, based on a fluorophore and a quencher, is engineered into the single-ring variant of the chaperone, and shows dramatic modulation of its fluorescent intensity in response to the transition of the protein between its allosteric states. It, therefore, forms a sensitive probe for the dynamics of the allosteric transitions of this machine, both in the bulk and in single molecules.

Allostery and cooperativity revisited

Although phenomenlogical models that account for cooperativity in allosteric systems date back to the early and mid-60's (e.g., the KNF and MWC models), there is resurgent interest in the topic due to the recent experimental and computational studies that attempted to reveal, at an atomistic level, how allostery actually works. In this review, using systems for which atomistic simulations have been carried out in our groups as examples, we describe the current understanding of allostery, how the mechanisms go beyond the classical MWC/Pauling-KNF descriptions, and point out that the "new view" of allostery, emphasizing "population shifts," is, in fact, an "old view." The presentation offers not only an up-to-date description of allostery from a theoretical/computational perspective, but also helps to resolve several outstanding issues concerning allostery.

Asymmetry of the GroEL-GroES complex under physiological conditions as revealed by small-angle x-ray scattering

Despite the well-known functional importance of GroEL-GroES complex formation during the chaperonin cycle, the stoichiometry of the complex has not been clarified. The complex can occur either as an asymmetric 1:1 GroEL-GroES complex or as a symmetric 1:2 GroEL-GroES complex, although it remains uncertain which type is predominant under physiological conditions. To resolve this question, we studied the structure of the GroEL-GroES complex under physiological conditions by small-angle x-ray scattering, which is a powerful technique to directly observe the structure of the protein complex in solution. We evaluated molecular structural parameters, the radius of gyration and the maximum dimension of the complex, from the x-ray scattering patterns under various nucleotide conditions (3 mM ADP, 3 mM ATP gamma S, and 3 mM ATP in 10 mM MgCl(2) and 100 mM KCl) at three different temperatures (10 degrees C, 25 degrees C, and 37 degrees C). We then compared the experimentally observed scattering patterns with those calculated from the known x-ray crystallographic structures of the GroEL-GroES complex. The results clearly demonstrated that the asymmetric complex must be the major species stably present in solution under physiological conditions. On the other hand, in the presence of ATP (3 mM) and beryllium fluoride (10 mM NaF and 300 microM BeCl(2)), we observed the formation of a stable symmetric complex, suggesting the existence of a transiently formed symmetric complex during the chaperonin cycle.

Spontaneous conformational changes in the E. coli GroEL subunit from all-atom molecular dynamics simulations

The Escherichia coli chaperonin GroEL is a complex of identical subunit proteins (57 kDa each) arranged in a back-to-back stacking of two heptameric rings. Its hallmarks include nested positive intra-ring and negative inter-ring cooperativity in adenosine trisphosphate (ATP) binding and the ability to mediate the folding of newly transcribed and/or denatured substrate proteins. We performed unbiased molecular dynamics simulations of the GroEL subunit protein in explicit water both with and without the nucleotide KMgATP to understand better the details of the structural transitions that enable these behaviors. Placing KMgATP in the equatorial domain binding pocket of a t state subunit, which corresponds to a low ATP-affinity state, produced a short-lived (6 ns) state that spontaneously transitioned to the high ATP-affinity r state. The important feature of this transition is a large-scale rotation of the intermediate domain's helix M to close the ATP binding pocket. Pivoting of helix M is accompanied by counterclockwise rotation and slight deformation of the apical domain, important for lowering the affinity for substrate protein. Aligning simulation conformations into model heptamer rings demonstrates that the t-->r transition in one subunit is not sterically hindered by t state neighbors, but requires breakage of Arg(197)-Glu(386) intersubunit salt bridges, which are important for inter-ring positive cooperativity. Lowest-frequency quasi-harmonic modes of vibration computed pre- and post-transition clearly show that natural vibrations facilitate the transition. Finally, we propose a novel mechanism for inter-ring cooperativity in ATP binding inspired by the observation of spontaneous insertion of the side chain of Ala(480) into the empty nucleotide pocket.

Glu257 in GroEL is a sensor involved in coupling polypeptide substrate binding to stimulation of ATP hydrolysis

The ATPase activity of many types of molecular chaperones is stimulated by polypeptide substrate binding via molecular mechanisms that are, for the most part, unknown. Here, we report that such stimulation of the ATPase activity of GroEL is abolished when its conserved apical domain residue Glu257 is replaced by alanine. This mutation is also found to convert the ATPase profile of GroEL, a group I chaperonin, into one that is characteristic of group II chaperonins. Steady-state and transient kinetic analysis indicate that both effects are due, at least in part, to a reduction of the affinity of GroEL for ADP. This finding indicates that nonfolded proteins stimulate ATP hydrolysis by accelerating the off-rate of the ADP formed, thereby allowing more rapid cycles of ATP binding and hydrolysis.

Allosteric regulation of chaperonins

Chaperonins are molecular machines that facilitate protein folding by undergoing energy (ATP)-dependent movements that are coordinated in time and space by complex allosteric regulation. Recently, progress has been made in describing the various functional (allosteric) states of these machines, the pathways by which they interconvert, and the coupling between allosteric transitions and protein folding reactions. However, various mechanistic issues remain to be resolved.

Protein structural transitions and their functional role

Living cells are a collection of molecular machines which carry out many of the functions essential for the cell's existence, differentiation and reproduction. Most, though not all, of these machines are made up of proteins. Because of their complexity, an understanding of how they work requires a synergistic combination of experimental and theoretical studies. In this paper we outline our studies of two such protein machines. One is GroEL, the chaperone from Escherichia coli, which aids in protein folding; the other is F(1)-ATPase, a motor protein which synthesizes and hydrolyses ATP.

The unfolding action of GroEL on a protein substrate

A molecular dynamics simulation of the active unfolding of denatured rhodanese by the chaperone GroEL is presented. The compact denatured protein is bound initially to the cis cavity and forms stable contacts with several of the subunits. As the cis ring apical domains of GroEL undergo the transition from the closed to the more open (ATP-bound) state, they exert a force on rhodanese that leads to the increased unfolding of certain loops. The contacts between GroEL and rhodanese are analyzed and their variation during the GroEL transition is shown. The major contacts, which give rise to the stretching force, are found to be similar to those observed in crystal structures of peptides bound to the apical domains. The results of the simulation show that multidomain interactions play an essential role, in accord with experiments. Implications of the results for mutation experiments and for the action of GroEL are discussed.

Functional consequences of single:double ring transitions in chaperonins: life in the cold

The cpn60 and cpn10 genes from psychrophilic bacterium, Oleispira antarctica RB8, showed a positive effect in Escherichia coli growth at low temperature, shifting its theoretical minimal growth temperature from +7.5 degrees C to -13.7 degrees C [Ferrer, M., Chernikova, T.N., Yakimov, M., Golyshin, P.N., and Timmis, K.N. (2003) Nature Biotechnol 21: 1266-1267]. To provide experimental support for this finding, Cpn60 and 10 were overproduced in E. coli and purified to apparent homogeneity. Recombinant O.Cpn60 was identical to the native protein based on tetradecameric structure, and it dissociates during native PAGE. Gel filtration and native PAGE revealed that, in vivo and in vitro, (O.Cpn60)(7) was the active oligomer at 4-10 degrees C, whereas at > 10 degrees C, this complex was converted to (O.Cpn60)(14). The dissociation reduces the ATP consumption (energy-saving mechanism) and increases the refolding capacity at low temperatures. In order for this transition to occur, we demonstrated that K468 and S471 may play a key role in conforming the more advantageous oligomeric state in O.Cpn60. We have proved this hypothesis by showing that single and double mutations in K468 and S471 for T and G, as in E.GroEL, produced a more stable double-ring oligomer. The optimum temperature for ATPase and chaperone activity for the wild-type chaperonin was 24-28 degrees C and 4-18 degrees C, whereas that for the mutants was 45-55 degrees C and 14-36 degrees C respectively. The temperature inducing unfolding (T(M)) increased from 45 degrees C to more than 65 degrees C. In contrast, a single ring mutant, O.Cpn60(SR), with three amino acid substitutions (E461A, S463A and V464A) was as stable as the wild type but possessed refolding activity below 10 degrees C. Above 10 degrees C, this complex lost refolding capacity to the detriment of the double ring, which was not an efficient chaperone at 4 degrees C as the single ring variant. We demonstrated that expression of O.Cpn60(WT) and O.Cpn60(SR) leads to a higher growth of E. coli at 4 degrees C ( micro (max), 0.22 and 0.36 h(-1) respectively), whereas at 10-15 degrees C, only E. coli cells expressing O.Cpn60 or O.Cpn60(DR) grew better than parental cells (-cpn). These results clearly indicate that the single-to-double ring transition in Oleispira chaperonin is a wild-type mechanism for its thermal acclimation. Although previous studies have also reported single-to-double ring transitions under many circumstances, this is the first clear indication that single-ring chaperonins are necessary to support growth when the temperature falls from 37 degrees C to 4 degrees C.

Phi value analysis of an allosteric transition of GroEL based on a single-pathway model

There are currently two contradictory models for the kinetics of the ATP-induced GroEL allosteric transition occurring around 20 microM ATP. One model, proposed by Horovitz et al. demonstrates the existence of two parallel pathways for the allosteric transition and an abrupt ATP-dependent switch from one pathway to the other. The other model, which was proposed by the present authors, shows no need to assume the parallel pathways, and a combination of the transition-state theory and the Monod-Wyman-Changeux model of allostery can explain the kinetics as well as the equilibrium of the transition. The discrepancy appears to be due to whether we regard the transition as reversible or irreversible. Thus, here we have investigated the reversibility of the allosteric transition between 0 microM and 70 microM ATP by the use of a stopped-flow double-jump technique, which has allowed us to monitor the kinetics of the reverse reaction from the relaxed state at a high ATP concentration to the tense state at a low ATP concentration. The tryptophan fluorescence of a tryptophan-inserted variant of GroEL was used to follow the kinetics. As a result, the allosteric transition was shown to be a reversible process, supporting the validity of our model. We also show that the structural environment around the ATP-binding site of GroEL in the transition state is very similar to that in the relaxed state (Phi=0.9) by using a Phi value analysis in the kinetic Monod-Wyman-Changeux model, which is analogous to the mutational Phi value analysis in protein folding.

Stopped-flow Fluorescence Analysis of the Conformational Changes in the GroEL Apical Domain

GroEL undergoes numerous conformational alterations in the course of facilitating the folding of various proteins, and the specific movements of the GroEL apical domain are of particular importance in the molecular mechanism. In order to monitor in detail the numerous movements of the GroEL apical domain, we have constructed a mutant chaperonin (GroEL R231W) with wild type-like function and a fluorescent probe introduced into the apical domain. By monitoring the tryptophan fluorescence changes of GroEL R231W upon ATP addition in the presence and absence of the co-chaperonin GroES, we detected a total of four distinct kinetic phases that corresponded to conformational changes of the apical domain and GroES binding. By introducing this mutation into a single ring variant of GroEL (GroEL SR-1), we determined the extent of inter-ring cooperation that was involved in apical domain movements. Surprisingly, we found that the apical domain movements of GroEL were affected only slightly by the change in quaternary structure. Our experiments provide a number of novel insights regarding the dynamic movements of this protein.

Role of the gamma-phosphate of ATP in triggering protein folding by GroEL-GroES: function, structure and energetics

Productive cis folding by the chaperonin GroEL is triggered by the binding of ATP but not ADP, along with cochaperonin GroES, to the same ring as non-native polypeptide, ejecting polypeptide into an encapsulated hydrophilic chamber. We examined the specific contribution of the gamma-phosphate of ATP to this activation process using complexes of ADP and aluminium or beryllium fluoride. These ATP analogues supported productive cis folding of the substrate protein, rhodanese, even when added to already-formed, folding-inactive cis ADP ternary complexes, essentially introducing the gamma-phosphate of ATP in an independent step. Aluminium fluoride was observed to stabilize the association of GroES with GroEL, with a substantial release of free energy (-46 kcal/mol). To understand the basis of such activation and stabilization, a crystal structure of GroEL-GroES-ADP.AlF3 was determined at 2.8 A. A trigonal AlF3 metal complex was observed in the gamma-phosphate position of the nucleotide pocket of the cis ring. Surprisingly, when this structure was compared with that of the previously determined GroEL-GroES-ADP complex, no other differences were observed. We discuss the likely basis of the ability of gamma-phosphate binding to convert preformed GroEL-GroES-ADP-polypeptide complexes into the folding-active state.

Conversion of the allosteric transition of GroEL from concerted to sequential by the single mutation Asp-155 -> Ala

The reaction cycle of the double-ring chaperonin GroEL is driven by ATP binding that takes place with positive cooperativity within each seven-membered ring and negative cooperativity between rings. The positive cooperativity within rings is due to ATP binding-induced conformational changes that are fully concerted. Herein, it is shown that the mutation Asp-155 --> Ala leads to an ATP-induced break in intra-ring and inter-ring symmetry. Electron microscopy analysis of single-ring GroEL particles containing the Asp-155 --> Ala mutation shows that the break in intra-ring symmetry is due to stabilization of allosteric intermediates such as one in which three subunits have switched their conformation while the other four have not. Our results show that eliminating an intra-subunit interaction between Asp-155 and Arg-395 results in conversion of the allosteric switch of GroEL from concerted to sequential, thus demonstrating that its allosteric behavior arises from coupled tertiary conformational changes.

The allosteric transition of GroEL induced by metal fluoride-ADP complexes

To understand the mechanism of a functionally important ATP-induced allosteric transition of GroEL, we have studied the effect of a series of metal fluoride-ADP complexes and vanadate-ADP on GroEL by kinetic fluorescence measurement of pyrene-labeled GroEL and by small-angle X-ray scattering measurement of wild-type GroEL. The metal fluorides and vanadate, complexed with ADP, are known to mimic the gamma-phosphate group of ATP, but they differ in geometry and size; it is expected that these compounds will be useful for investigating the strikingly high specificity of GroEL for ATP that enables the induction of the allosteric transition. The kinetic fluorescence measurement revealed that aluminium, beryllium, and gallium ions, when complexed with the fluoride ion and ADP, induced a biphasic fluorescence change of pyrenyl GroEL, while scandium and vanadate ions did not induce any kinetically observed change in fluorescence. The burst phase and the first phase of the fluorescence kinetics were reversible, while the second phase and subsequent changes were irreversible. The dependence of the burst-phase and the first-phase fluorescence changes on the ADP concentration indicated that the burst phase represents non-cooperative nucleotide binding to GroEL, and that the first phase represents the allosteric transition of GroEL. Both the amplitude and the rate constant of the first phase of the fluorescence kinetics were well understood in terms of a kinetic allosteric model, which is a combination of transition state theory and the Monod-Wyman-Changeux allosteric model. From the kinetic allosteric model analysis, the relative free energy of the transition state in the metal fluoride-ADP-induced allosteric transition of GroEL was found to be larger than the corresponding free energy of the ATP-induced allosteric transition by more than 5.5kcal/mol. However, the X-ray scattering measurements indicated that the allosteric state induced by these metal fluoride-ADP complexes is structurally equivalent to the allosteric state induced by ATP. These results suggested that both the size and coordination geometry of gamma-phosphate (and its analogs) are related to the allosteric transition of GroEL. It was therefore concluded that the tetrahedral geometry of gamma-phosphate (or its analogs) and the inter-atomic distance ( approximately 1.6A) between phosphorus (vanadium, or metal atom) and oxygen (or fluorine) are both important for inducing the allosteric transition of GroEL, leading to the high selectivity of GroEL for ATP about ligand adenine nucleotides, which function as the preferred allosteric ligand.

Denaturation and reassembly of chaperonin GroEL studied by solution X-ray scattering

We measured the denaturation and reassembly of Escherichia coli chaperonin GroEL using small-angle solution X-ray scattering, which is a powerful technique for studying the overall structure and assembly of a protein in solution. The results of the urea-induced unfolding transition show that GroEL partially dissociates in the presence of more than 2 M urea, cooperatively unfolds at around 3 M urea, and is in a monomeric random coil-like unfolded structure at more than 3.2 M urea. Attempted refolding of the unfolded GroEL monomer by a simple dilution procedure is not successful, leading to formation of aggregates. However, the presence of ammonium sulfate and MgADP allows the fully unfolded GroEL to refold into a structure with the same hydrodynamic dimension, within experimental error, as that of the native GroEL. Moreover, the X-ray scattering profiles of the GroEL thus refolded and the native GroEL are coincident with each other, showing that the refolded GroEL has the same structure and the molecular mass as the native GroEL. These results demonstrate that the fully unfolded GroEL monomer can refold and reassemble into the native tetradecameric structure in the presence of ammonium sulfate and MgADP without ATP hydrolysis and preexisting chaperones. Therefore, GroEL can, in principle, fold and assemble into the native structure according to the intrinsic characteristic of its polypeptide chain, although preexisting GroEL would be important when the GroEL folding takes place under in vivo conditions, in order to avoid misfolding and aggregation.

Equilibrium and kinetics of the allosteric transition of GroEL studied by solution X-ray scattering and fluorescence spectroscopy

We have studied the ATP-induced allosteric structural transition of GroEL using small angle X-ray scattering and fluorescence spectroscopy in combination with a stopped-flow technique. With X-ray scattering one can clearly distinguish the three allosteric states of GroEL, and the kinetics of the transition of GroEL induced by 85 microM ATP have been observed directly by stopped-flow X-ray scattering for the first time. The rate constant has been found to be 3-5s(-1) at 5 degrees C, indicating that this process corresponds to the second phase of the ATP-induced kinetics of tryptophan-inserted GroEL measured by stopped-flow fluorescence. Based on the ATP concentration dependence of the fluorescence kinetics, we conclude that the first phase represents bimolecular non-cooperative binding of ATP to GroEL with a bimolecular rate constant of 5.8 x 10(5)M(-1)s(-1) at 25 degrees C. Considering the electrostatic repulsion between negatively charged GroEL (-18 of the net charge per monomer at pH 7.5) and ATP, the rate constant is consistent with a diffusion-controlled bimolecular process. The ATP-induced fluorescence kinetics (the first and second phases) at various ATP concentrations (< 400 microM) occur before ATP hydrolysis by GroEL takes place and are well explained by a kinetic allosteric model, which is a combination of the conventional transition state theory and the Monod-Wyman-Changeux model, and we have successfully evaluated the equilibrium and kinetic parameters of the allosteric transition, including the binding constant of ATP in the transition state of GroEL.

Nested MWC model describes hydrolysis of GroEL without assuming negative cooperativity in binding

Folding assistance and ATPase activity of GroEL are based on the existence of different conformations. In order to characterise these conformations, published data on steady state ATPase activity in the absence of GroES were reanalysed simultaneously in terms of the Nested MWC model. This model is a hierarchical extension of the symmetry-model of Monod et al. [J. Mol. Biol. 12 (1965) 88]. An unique set of GroEL specific parameters was obtained. This set was supported by comparison of predictions arising from this set of values with experimental data for hydrolysis of ATP in the presence of ADP and ATPgammaS, binding of ATPgammaS and ADP to GroEL in the absence of ATP, and binding of ATP as monitored by fluorescence labelling. Thus, for the first time, multiple data sets for the interaction of nucleotides with GroEL are described quantitatively by an allosteric model. A noteworthy feature of our model is that no negative cooperativity in ATP binding occurs in accordance to experimental observations. Furthermore, the model also includes the existence of a conformation with very high ATPase activity. Such a conformation might be of importance at a certain stage in the folding cycle.

New aspects on the mechanism of GroEL-assisted protein folding

The mechanism of assisted protein folding by the chaperonin GroEL alone or in complex with the co-chaperonin GroES and in the presence or absence of nucleotides has been subject to extensive investigations during the last years. In this paper we present data where we have inactivated GroEL by stepwise blocking the nucleotide binding sites using the non-hydrolyzable ATP analogue, (Cr(H2O)4)3+ATP. We correlated the amount of accessible nucleotide binding sites with the residual ATP hydrolysis activity of GroEL as well as the residual refolding activity for two different model substrates. Under the conditions used, folding of the substrate proteins and ATP hydrolysis were directly proportional to the residual, accessible nucleotide binding sites. In the presence of GroES, 50% of the nucleotide binding sites were protected from inactivation by CrATP and the resulting protein retains 50% of both ATPase and refolding activity. The results strongly suggest that under the conditions used in our experiments, the nucleotide binding sites are additive in character and that by blocking of a certain number of binding sites a proportional amount of ATP hydrolysis and refolding activities are inactivated. The experiments including GroES suggest that full catalytic activity of GroEL requires both rings of the chaperonin. Blocking of the nucleotide binding sites of one ring still allows function of the second ring.

Nucleotide-induced transition of GroEL from the high-affinity to the low-affinity state for a target protein: effects of ATP and ADP on the GroEL-affected refolding of alpha-lactalbumin

We studied the refolding kinetics of alpha-lactalbumin in the presence of wild-type GroEL and its ATPase-deficient mutant D398A at various concentrations of nucleotides (ATP and ADP). We evaluated the apparent binding constant between GroEL and the alpha-lactalbumin refolding intermediate quantitatively by numerical simulation analysis of the alpha-lactalbumin refolding curves in the presence and absence of GroEL. The binding constant showed a co-operative decrease with an increase in ATP concentration, whereas the binding constant decreased in a non-co-operative manner with respect to ADP concentration. For the D398A mutant, the ATP-induced decrease in affinity occurred much faster than the steady-state ATP hydrolysis by this mutant, suggesting that ATP binding to GroEL rather than ATP hydrolysis, was responsible for the co-operative decrease in the affinity for the target protein. We thus analyzed the nucleotide-concentration dependence of affinity of GroEL for the target protein using an allosteric Monod-Wyman-Changeux model in which GroEL underwent an ATP-induced co-operative conformational transition between the high-affinity and low-affinity states of the target protein. The transition midpoint of the ATP-induced transition of GroEL has been found to be around 30 microM, in good agreement with the midpoint evaluated in other structural studies of GroEL. The results show that the observed difference between ATP and ADP-induced transitions of GroEL are brought about by a small difference in an allosteric parameter (the ratio of the nucleotide affinities of GroEL in the high-affinity and the low-affinity states), i.e. 4.1 for ATP and 2.6 for ADP.

Review: allostery in chaperonins

Chaperonins mediate protein folding in an ATP-dependent manner. ATP binding and hydrolysis by chaperonins are subject to both homotropic and heterotropic allosteric regulation. In the case of GroEL and CCT, homotropic regulation by ATP is manifested in nested cooperativity, which involves positive intra-ring cooperativity and negative inter-ring cooperativity in ATP binding. Both types of cooperativity are modulated by various heterotropic allosteric effectors, which include nonfolded proteins, ADP, Mg2+, monovalent ions such as K+, and cochaperonins in the case of type I chaperonins such as GroEL. Here, the allosteric properties of chaperonins are reviewed and new results of ours are presented with regard to allosteric effects of ADP. The role of allostery in the reaction cycle and folding function of chaperonins is discussed.