Mutations affecting ligand specificity of the G-protein-coupled receptor for the Saccharomyces cerevisiae tridecapeptide pheromone

Detection of a Peptide Biomarker by Engineered Yeast Receptors

Directed evolution of membrane receptors is challenging as the evolved receptor must not only accommodate a non-native ligand, but also maintain the ability to transduce the detection of the new ligand to any associated intracellular components. The G-protein coupled receptor (GPCR) superfamily is the largest group of membrane receptors. As members of the GPCR family detect a wide range of ligands, GPCRs are an incredibly useful starting point for directed evolution of user-defined analytical tools and diagnostics. The aim of this study was to determine if directed evolution of the yeast Ste2p GPCR, which natively detects the α-factor peptide, could yield a GPCR that detects Cystatin C, a human peptide biomarker. We demonstrate a generalizable approach for evolving Ste2p to detect peptide sequences. Because the target peptide differs significantly from α-factor, a single evolutionary step was infeasible. We turned to a substrate walking approach and evolved receptors for a series of chimeric intermediates with increasing similarity to the biomarker. We validate our previous model as a tool for designing optimal chimeric peptide steps. Finally, we demonstrate the clinical utility of yeast-based biosensors by showing specific activation by a C-terminally amidated Cystatin C peptide in commercially sourced human urine. To our knowledge, this is the first directed evolution of a peptide GPCR.

Variable Dependence of Signaling Output on Agonist Occupancy of Ste2p, a G Protein-coupled Receptor in Yeast

We report here on the relationship between ligand binding and signaling responses in the yeast pheromone response pathway, a well characterized G protein-coupled receptor system. Responses to agonist (α-factor) by cells expressing widely varying numbers of receptors depend primarily on fractional occupancy, not the absolute number of agonist-bound receptors. Furthermore, the concentration of competitive antagonist required to inhibit α-factor-dependent signaling is more than 10-fold higher than predicted based on the known ligand affinities. Thus, responses to a particular number of agonist-bound receptors can vary greatly, depending on whether there are unoccupied or antagonist-bound receptors present on the same cell surface. This behavior does not appear to be due to pre-coupling of receptors to G protein or to the Sst2p regulator of G protein signaling. The results are consistent with a signaling response that is determined by the integration of positive signals from agonist-occupied receptors and inhibitory signals from unoccupied receptors, where the inhibitory signals can be diminished by antagonist binding.

Evolution of a G protein-coupled receptor response by mutations in regulatory network interactions

All cellular functions depend on the concerted action of multiple proteins organized in complex networks. To understand how selection acts on protein networks, we used the yeast mating receptor Ste2, a pheromone-activated G protein-coupled receptor, as a model system. In Saccharomyces cerevisiae, Ste2 is a hub in a network of interactions controlling both signal transduction and signal suppression. Through laboratory evolution, we obtained 21 mutant receptors sensitive to the pheromone of a related yeast species and investigated the molecular mechanisms behind this newfound sensitivity. While some mutants show enhanced binding affinity to the foreign pheromone, others only display weakened interactions with the network's negative regulators. Importantly, the latter changes have a limited impact on overall pathway regulation, despite their considerable effect on sensitivity. Our results demonstrate that a new receptor–ligand pair can evolve through network-altering mutations independently of receptor–ligand binding, and suggest a potential role for such mutations in disease.

Co-evolution of a new receptor-ligand pair will affect the downstream signal transduction network. Here, the authors use experimental evolution of yeast mating receptor Ste2 to show the effect of enhanced binding affinity and weakened interactions with the network's negative regulators on protein evolution.

Differential interactions of fluorescent agonists and antagonists with the yeast G protein coupled receptor Ste2p

We describe a rapid method to probe for mutations in cell surface ligand-binding proteins that affect the environment of bound ligand. The method uses fluorescence-activated cell sorting to screen randomly mutated receptors for substitutions that alter the fluorescence emission spectrum of environmentally sensitive fluorescent ligands. When applied to the yeast α-factor receptor Ste2p, a G protein-coupled receptor, the procedure identified 22 substitutions that red shift the emission of a fluorescent agonist, including substitutions at residues previously implicated in ligand binding and at additional sites. A separate set of substitutions, identified in a screen for mutations that alter the emission of a fluorescent α-factor antagonist, occurs at sites that are unlikely to contact the ligand directly. Instead, these mutations alter receptor conformation to increase ligand-binding affinity and provide signaling in response to antagonists of normal receptors. These results suggest that receptor--agonist interactions involve at least two sites, of which only one is specific for the activated conformation of the receptor.

Affinity purification and characterization of a G-protein coupled receptor, Saccharomyces cerevisiae Ste2p

We present an example of expression and purification of a biologically active G-protein coupled receptor (GPCR) from yeast. An expression vector was constructed to encode the Saccharomyces cerevisiae GPCR alpha-factor receptor (Ste2p, the STE2 gene product) containing a 9-amino acid sequence of rhodopsin that served as an epitope/affinity tag. In the construct, two glycosylation sites and two cysteine residues were removed to aid future structural and functional studies. The receptor was expressed in yeast cells and was detected as a single band in a western blot indicating the absence of glycosylation. Ligand binding and signaling assays of the epitope-tagged, mutated receptor showed it maintained the full wild-type biological activity. For extraction of Ste2p, yeast membranes were solubilized with 0.5% n-dodecyl maltoside (DM). Approximately 120 microg of purified alpha-factor receptor was obtained per liter of culture by single-step affinity chromatography using a monoclonal antibody to the rhodopsin epitope. The binding affinity (K(d)) of the purified alpha-factor receptor in DM micelles was 28 nM as compared to K(d)=12.7 nM for Ste2p in cell membranes, and approximately 40% of the purified receptor was correctly folded as judged by ligand saturation binding. About 50% of the receptor sequence was retrieved from MALDI-TOF and nanospray mass spectrometry after CNBr digestion of the purified receptor. The methods described will enable structural studies of the alpha-factor receptor and may provide an efficient technique to purify other GPCRs that have been functionally expressed in yeast.

Double-mutant cycle scanning of the interaction of a peptide ligand and its G protein-coupled receptor

The interaction between the yeast G protein-coupled receptor (GPCR), Ste2p, and its alpha-factor tridecapeptide ligand was subjected to double-mutant cycle scanning analysis by which the pairwise interaction energy of each ligand residue with two receptor residues, N205 and Y266, was determined. The mutations N205A and Y266A were previously shown to result in deficient signaling but cause only a 2.5-fold and 6-fold decrease, respectively, in the affinity for alpha-factor. The analysis shows that residues at the amine terminus of alpha-factor interact strongly with N205 and Y266 whereas residues in the center and at the carboxyl terminus of the peptide interact only weakly if at all with these receptor residues. Multiple-mutant thermodynamic cycle analysis was used to assess whether the energies of selected pairwise interactions between residues of the alpha-factor peptide changed upon binding to Ste2p. Strong positive cooperativity between residues 1 through 4 of alpha-factor was observed during receptor binding. In contrast, no thermodynamic evidence was found for an interaction between a residue near the carboxyl terminus of alpha-factor (position 11) and one at the N-terminus (position 3). The study shows that multiple-mutant cycle analyses of the binding of an alanine-scanned peptide to wild-type and mutant GPCRs can provide detailed information on contributions of inter- and intramolecular interactions to the binding energy and potentially prove useful in developing 3D models of ligand docked to its receptor.

The first extracellular loop of the Saccharomyces cerevisiae G protein-coupled receptor Ste2p undergoes a conformational change upon ligand binding

In this study of the Saccharomyces cerevisiae G protein-coupled receptor Ste2p, we present data indicating that the first extracellular loop (EL1) of the alpha-factor receptor has tertiary structure that limits solvent accessibility and that its conformation changes in a ligand-dependent manner. The substituted cysteine accessibility method was used to probe the solvent exposure of single cysteine residues engineered to replace residues Tyr(101) through Gln(135) of EL1 in the presence and absence of the tridecapeptide alpha-factor and a receptor antagonist. Surprisingly, many residues, especially those at the N-terminal region, were not solvent-accessible, including residues of the binding-competent yet signal transduction-deficient mutants L102C, N105C, S108C, Y111C, and T114C. In striking contrast, two N-terminal residues, Y101C and Y106C, were readily solvent-accessible, but upon incubation with alpha-factor labeling was reduced, suggesting a pheromone-dependent conformational change limiting solvent accessibility had occurred. Labeling in the presence of the antagonist, which binds Ste2p but does not initiate signal transduction, did not significantly alter reactivity with the Y101C and Y106C receptors, suggesting that the alpha-factor-dependent decrease in solvent accessibility was not because of steric hindrance that prevented the labeling reagent access to these residues. Based on these and previous observations, we propose a model in which the N terminus of EL1 is structured such that parts of the loop are buried in a solvent-inaccessible environment interacting with the extracellular part of the transmembrane domain bundle. This study highlights the essential role of an extracellular loop in activation of a G protein-coupled receptor upon ligand binding.

Interacting Residues in an Activated State of a G Protein-coupled Receptor

Ste2p, the G protein-coupled receptor (GPCR) for the tridecapeptide pheromone alpha-factor of Saccharomyces cerevisiae, was used as a model GPCR to investigate the role of specific residues in the resting and activated states of the receptor. Using a series of biological and biochemical analyses of wild-type and site-directed mutant receptors, we identified Asn(205) as a potential interacting partner with the Tyr(266) residue. An N205H/Y266H double mutant showed pH-dependent functional activity, whereas the N205H receptor was non-functional and the Y266H receptor was partially active indicating that the histidine 205 and 266 residues interact in an activated state of the receptor. The introduction of N205K or Y266D mutations into the P258L/S259L constitutively active receptor suppressed the constitutive activity; in contrast, the N205K/Y266D/P258L/S259L quadruple mutant was fully constitutively active, again indicating an interaction between residues at the 205 and 206 positions in the receptor-active state. To further test this interaction, we introduced the N205C/Y266C, F204C/Y266C, and N205C/A265C double mutations into wild-type and P258L/S259L constitutively active receptors. After trypsin digestion, we found that a disulfide-cross-linked product, with the molecular weight expected for a receptor fragment with a cross-link between N205C and Y266C, formed only in the N205C/Y266C constitutively activated receptor. This study represents the first experimental demonstration of an interaction between specific residues in an active state, but not the resting state, of Ste2p. The information gained from this study should contribute to an understanding of the conformational differences between resting and active states in GPCRs.

The alpha-factor mating pheromone of Saccharomyces cerevisiae: a model for studying the interaction of peptide hormones and G protein-coupled receptors

Mating in Saccharomyces cerevisiae is initiated by the secretion of diffusible peptide pheromones that are recognized by G protein-coupled receptors (GPCR). This review summarizes the use of the alpha-factor (WHWLQLKPGQPMY)--GPCR (Ste2p) interaction as a paradigm to understand the recognition between medium-sized peptide hormones and their cognate receptors. Studies over the past 15 years have indicated that the alpha-factor is bent around the center of the pheromone and that residues near the amine terminus play a central role in triggering signal transduction. The bend in the center appears not to be rigid and this flexibility is likely necessary for conformational changes that occur as the receptor switches from the inactive to active state. The results of synthetic, biological, biochemical, molecular biological, and biophysical analyses have led to a preliminary model for the structure of the peptide bound to its receptor. Antagonists for Ste2p have changes near the N-terminus of alpha-factor, and mutated forms of Ste2p were discovered that appear to favor binding of these antagonists relative to agonists. Many features of this yeast recognition system are relevant to and have counterparts in mammalian cells.

Expression analysis of PCSTE3, a putative pheromone receptor from the lung pathogenic fungus Pneumocystis carinii

The fungal pathogen Pneumocystis carinii remains the most prevalent opportunistic infection in patients infected with HIV. Fungal pheromone receptors are seven transmembrane domain G-protein-coupled receptors which are expressed on specific mating types, and have ligand-binding extracellular domains for specific pheromones from cells of the opposite mating type. We have cloned and characterized PCSTE3 from P. carinii, which encodes a seven transmembrane domain protein orthologous to the Saccharomyces cerevisiae pheromone receptor Ste3. We detect PCSTE3 by indirect immunofluorescence using antibodies designed to extracellular domains of the receptor in yeast expressing the protein. Using a downstream Fus1-lacZ reporter gene, we determined that PCSTE3 does not recognize a- or alpha-factor pheromones as ligands for the receptor. We isolated P. carinii life cycle stages and examined PCSTE3 expression by immunofluorescence microscopy and flow cytometry, and found PCSTE3 expression exclusively on a population of trophic forms. PCSTE3 receptor expression was not found on cysts.

Residues in the first extracellular loop of a G protein-coupled receptor play a role in signal transduction

The Saccharomyces cerevisiae pheromone, alpha-factor (WHWLQLKPGQPMY), and Ste2p, its G protein-coupled receptor, were used as a model system to study ligand-receptor interaction. Cys-scanning mutagenesis on each residue of EL1, the first extracellular loop of Ste2p, was used to generate a library of 36 mutants with a single Cys residue substitution. Mutation of most residues of EL1 had only negligible effects on ligand affinity and biological activity of the mutant receptors. However, five mutants were identified that were either partially (L102C and T114C) or severely (N105C, S108C, and Y111C) compromised in signaling but retained binding affinities similar to those of wild-type receptor. Three-dimensional modeling, secondary structure predictions, and subsequent circular dichroism studies on a synthetic peptide with amino acid sequence corresponding to EL1 suggested the presence of a helix corresponding to EL1 residues 106 to 114 followed by two short beta-strands (residues 126 to 135). The distinctive periodicity of the five residues with a signal-deficient phenotype combined with biophysical studies suggested a functional involvement in receptor activation of a face on a 3(10) helix in this region of EL1. These studies indicate that EL1 plays an important role in the conformational switch that activates the Ste2p receptor to initiate the mating pheromone signal transduction pathway.

Study of the binding environment of alpha-factor in its G protein-coupled receptor using fluorescence spectroscopy

Mating in Saccharomyces cerevisiae is induced by the interaction of alpha-factor (W1H2W3L4Q5L6K7P8G9Q10P11M12Y13) with its cognate G protein-coupled receptor (Ste2p). Fifteen fluorescently labeled analogs of alpha-factor in which the 7-nitrobenz-2-oxa-1,3-diazol-4-yl (NBD) group was placed at the alphaN-terminus and in side-chains at positions 1, 3, 4, 6, 7, 12 and 13 were synthesized and assayed for biological activity and receptor affinity. Eleven of the analogs retained 6-60% of the biological activity of the alpha-factor, as judged using a growth arrest assay. The binding affinities depended on the position of NBD attachment in the peptide and the distance of the tag from the backbone. Derivatization of the positions 3 and 7 side-chains with the NBD group resulted in analogs with affinities of 17-35% compared with that of alpha-factor. None of the other NBD-containing agonists had sufficient receptor affinity or strong enough emission for fluorescence analysis. The position 3 and 7 analogs were investigated using fluorescence spectroscopy and collisional quenching by KI in the presence of Ste2p in yeast membranes. The results showed that the lambda max of NBD in the position 7 side-chain shifted markedly to the blue (510 nm) when separated by 4 or 6 bonds from the peptide backbone and that this probe was shielded from quenching by KI. In contrast, separation by 3, 5, 10 or more bonds resulted in lambda max ( approximately 540 nm) and collisional quenching constants consistent with increasing degrees of exposure. The NBD group in the position 3 side-chain was also found to be blue shifted (lambda max=520 nm) and shielded from solvent. These results indicate that the position 7 side-chain is likely interacting with a pocket formed by extracellular domains of Ste2p, whereas the side-chain of Trp3 is in a hydrophobic pocket possibly within the transmembrane region of the receptor.

Peptide interactions with G-protein coupled receptors

Peptide recognition by G-protein coupled receptors (GPCRs) is reviewed with an emphasis on the indirect approach used to determine the receptor-bound conformation of peptide ligands. This approach was developed in response to the lack of detailed structural information available for these receptors. Recent advances in the structural determination of rhodopsin (the GPCR of the visual system) by crystallography have provided a scaffold for homology modeling of the inactive state of a wide variety of GPCRs that interact with peptide messages. Additionally, the ability to mutate GPCRs and assay compounds of similar chemical structure to test a common binding site on the receptor provides a firm experimental basis for structure-activity studies. Recognition motifs, common in other well-studied systems such as proteolytic enzymes and major histocompatibility class receptors (MHC) are reviewed briefly to provide a basis of comparison. Finally, the development of true peptidomimetics is contrasted with nonpeptide ligands, discovered through combinatorial chemistry. In many systems, the evidence suggests that the peptide ligands bind at the interface between the transmembrane segments and the extracellular loops, while nonpeptide antagonists bind within the transmembrane segments. Plausible models of GPCRs and the mechanism by which they activate G-proteins on binding peptides are beginning to emerge.

Identification of residues of the Saccharomyces cerevisiae G protein-coupled receptor contributing to alpha-factor pheromone binding

The Saccharomyces cerevisiae pheromone, alpha-factor (WHWLQLKPGQPMY), and Ste2p, its G protein-coupled receptor, were studied as a model for peptide ligand-receptor interaction. The affinities and activities of various synthetic position-10 alpha-factor analogs with Ste2p expressing mutations at residues Ser47 and Thr48 were investigated. All mutant receptors were expressed at a similar level in the cytoplasmic membrane, and their efficacies of signal transduction were similar to that of the wild-type receptor. Mutant receptors differed in binding affinity (Kd) and potency (EC50) for gene induction by alpha-factor. One mutant receptor (S47K,T48K) had dramatically reduced affinity and activity for [Lys10]- and [Orn10]alpha-factor, whereas the affinity for Saccharomyces kluyveri alpha-factor (WHWLSFSKGEPMY) was increased over 20-fold compared with that of wild-type receptor. In contrast, the affinity of [Lys10]- and [Orn10]alpha-factor was increased greatly in a S47E,T48E mutant receptor, whereas the binding of the S. kluyveri alpha-factor was abolished. The affinity of [Lys10]- and [Orn10]alpha-factor for the S47E,T48E receptor dropped 4-6-fold in the presence of 1 m NaCl, whereas the affinity of alpha-factor was not affected by this treatment. These results demonstrate that when bound to its receptor the 10th residue (Gln) of the S. cerevisiae alpha-factor is adjacent to Ser47 and Thr48 residues in the receptor and that the 10th residue of alpha-factors from two Saccharomyces species is responsible for the ligand selectivity to their cognate receptors. Based on these data, we have developed a two-dimensional model of alpha-factor binding to its receptor.

Structure and topology of a peptide segment of the 6th transmembrane domain of the Saccharomyces cerevisae alpha-factor receptor in phospholipid bilayers

A detailed analysis of the structure of an 18-residue peptide AQSLLVPSIIFILAYSLK [M6(252-269, C252A)] in 1,2-dimyristoyl-sn-glycero-phosphocholine bilayers was carried out using solid state NMR and attenuated total reflection Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy. The peptide corresponds to a portion of the 6th transmembrane domain of the alpha-factor receptor of Saccharomyces cerevisiae. Ten homologs of M6(252-269, C252A) were synthesized in which individual residues were labeled with (15)N. One- and two-dimensional solid state NMR experiments were used to determine the chemical shifts and (1)H-(15)N dipolar coupling constants for the (15)N-labeled peptides in oriented dimyristoylphosphatidylcholine bilayers on stacked glass plates. These parameters were used to calculate the structure and orientation of M6(252-269, C252A) in the bilayers. The results indicate that the carboxyl terminal residues (9-14) are alpha-helical and oriented with an angle of about 8 degrees with respect to the bilayer normal. Independently, an attenuated total reflection Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy analysis on M6(252-269, C252A) in a 1,2-dimyristoyl-sn-glycero-phosphocholine bilayer concluded that the helix tilt angle was about 12.5 degrees. The results on the structure of M6(252-269, C252A) in bilayers are in good agreement with the structure determined in trifluoroethanol/water solutions (B. Arshava et al. Biopolymers, 1998, Vol. 46, pp. 343-357). The present study shows that solid state NMR spectroscopy can provide high resolution information on the structure of transmembrane domains of a G protein-coupled receptor.

Self-compatible B mutants in coprinus with altered pheromone-receptor specificities

A successful mating in the mushroom Coprinus cinereus brings together a compatible complement of pheromones and G-protein-coupled receptors encoded by multiallelic genes at the B mating-type locus. Rare B gene mutations lead to constitutive activation of B-regulated development without the need for mating. Here we characterize a mutation that arose in the B6 locus and show that it generates a mutant receptor with a single amino acid substitution (R96H) at the intracellular end of transmembrane domain III. Using a heterologous yeast assay and synthetic pheromones we show that the mutation does not make the receptor constitutively active but permits it to respond inappropriately to a normally incompatible pheromone encoded within the same B6 locus. Parallel experiments carried out in Coprinus showed that a F67W substitution in this same pheromone enabled it to activate the normally incompatible wild-type receptor. Together, our experiments show that a single amino acid replacement in either pheromone or receptor can deregulate the specificity of ligand-receptor recognition and confer a self-compatible B phenotype. In addition, we use the yeast assay to demonstrate that different receptors and pheromones found at a single B locus belong to discrete subfamilies within which receptor activation cannot normally occur.

Interaction between transmembrane domains five and six of the alpha -factor receptor

The alpha-factor pheromone receptor (STE2) activates a G protein signal pathway that induces conjugation of the yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae. Previous studies implicated the third intracellular loop of this receptor in G protein activation. Therefore, the roles of transmembrane domains five and six (TMD5 and -6) that bracket the third intracellular loop were analyzed by scanning mutagenesis in which each residue was substituted with cysteine. Out of 42 mutants examined, four constitutive mutants and two strong loss-of-function mutants were identified. Double mutants combining Cys substitutions in TMD5 and TMD6 gave a broader range of phenotypes. Interestingly, a V223C mutation in TMD5 caused constitutive activity when combined with the L247C, L248C, or S251C mutations in TMD6. Also, the L226C mutation in TMD5 caused constitutive activity when combined with either the M250C or S251C mutations in TMD6. The residues affected by these mutations are predicted to fall on one side of their respective helices, suggesting that they may interact. In support of this, cysteines substituted at position 223 in TMD5 and position 247 in TMD6 formed a disulfide bond, providing the first direct evidence of an interaction between these transmembrane domains in the alpha-factor receptor. Altogether, these results identify an important region of interaction between conserved hydrophobic regions at the base of TMD5 and TMD6 that is required for the proper regulation of receptor signaling.

Position 13 analogs of the tridecapeptide mating pheromone from Saccharomyces cerevisiae: design of an iodinatable ligand for receptor binding

Analogs of the alpha-factor tridecapeptide mating pheromone (WHWLQLKPGQPMY) from Saccharomyces cerevisiae in which Tyr13 was replaced with Phe, p-F-Phe, m-F-Phe, p-NO2-Phe, p-NH2-Phe or Ser were synthesized and purified to >99% homogeneity. These analogs were bioassayed using a growth arrest assay and a gene induction assay and evaluated for their ability to compete with binding of tritiated alpha-factor to its receptor Ste2p. The results showed that the phenolic OH of Tyr13 is not required for either biological activity or receptor recognition. Analogs containing fluorine, amino, nitro or a hydrogen in place of OH had 80-120% of the biological activity of the parent pheromone in the gene induction assay and had receptor affinities from nearly equal to 6-fold lower than that of alpha-factor. In contrast, substitution of Ser or Ala at position 13 resulted in a >100-fold decrease in receptor affinity suggesting that the aromatic ring is involved in binding to the receptor. The lack of a strict requirement for Tyr13 allowed the design of several multiple replacement analogs in which Phe or p-F-Phe were substituted at position 13 and Tyr was placed in other positions of the peptide. These analogs could then be iodinated and used in the development of a highly sensitive receptor-binding assay. One potential receptor ligand [Tyr(125I)1,Nle12, Phe13] alpha-factor exhibited saturable binding with a KD of 81 nM and was competed by alpha-factor for binding in a whole-cell assay. Thus a new family of radioactive ligands for the alpha-factor receptor has been revealed. These ligands should be extremely useful in defining active site residues during mutagenesis and cross-linking studies.