Insulin autoantibodies before and after carbimazole therapy in Asian Indian patients with Graves' disease

Approach to the patient with spontaneous hypoglycemia

Hypoglycemia is common in daily clinical practice and often occurs during the treatment of diabetes mellitus. However, a small minority of hypoglycemia encountered in clinical practice is spontaneous and thus not induced by glycemic lowering agents. These spontaneous hypoglycemic events confront the clinician with a diagnostic enigma. Although the trained clinician can recognize the autonomic and neuroglycopenic symptoms of hypoglycemia even in a patient not on insulin, it remains challenging to decipher the etiology of a spontaneous hypoglycemic event. A logical and stepwise approach to the spontaneous hypoglycemic event allows for a conclusive diagnosis. This diagnostic process consists of adequately diagnosing hypoglycemia by fulfilling Whipple's triad, stratifying patients according to their clinical status and analyzing a full hypoglycemic blood panel. A complete hypoglycemic blood panel should include the analysis of glucose, insulin, C-peptide, pro-insulin, insulin antibodies and the presence of oral hypoglycemic agents. For patients with episodes of hypoglycemia induced by excessive endogenous insulin, additional imaging is often required to detect the presence of an underlying insulinoma. By diagnosing the underlying cause of the spontaneous hypoglycemia, the physician also diagnosis the mechanism by which the hypoglycemic event occurs. Allowing for a problem orientated therapeutic approach.

METHODOLOGY

The present review is based upon a comprehensive PubMed search between 1985 and 2013. This uses search terms of spontaneous hypoglycemia, insulinoma, nesidioblastosis, insulin auto-immunity, noninsulinoma pancreatogenous hypoglycemia syndrome, hormone deficiency, pro-IGF II, and pro-insulin growth factor II, and cross reference searching of pivotal articles in the subject.

Insulin Autoimmunity and Hypoglycemia in Seven White Patients

OBJECTIVE

To report the clinical, biochemical, and immunologic characteristics of 7 white patients with the rare disorder of hyperinsulinemic hypoglycemia in association with spontaneously generated high titers of antibodies to human insulin.

METHODS

We reviewed the clinical data, history, and symptoms of the 7 study patients and summarized the biochemical findings during a spontaneous episode of hypoglycemia. Insulin antibody binding was measured in all patients, and antibody affinity, capacity, and clonality were analyzed in 4. A mixed meal study was conducted in 2 patients. A potential mechanism for postprandial hypoglycemia is presented.

RESULTS

In all 7 patients (6 women and 1 man), symptoms were neuroglycopenic, occurring primarily postprandially but during fasting in some patients. During hypoglycemia, concentrations of insulin, proinsulin, and, in most patients, C peptide considerably exceeded those observed in patients with insulinoma. These concentrations were spuriously elevated as a result of interference by the autoantibodies in the immunoassays. No patient had evidence of an insulinoma on various radiologic localization procedures directed at the pancreas. Insulin antibodies showed a high percentage of binding to human insulin--50 to 90%. Heterogeneity of antibodies regarding clonality and antibody binding sites was noted; some patients had polyclonal and some had monoclonal IgG class antibodies. Most patients had two categories of binding sites: high affinity/low capacity and low capacity/high affinity. Although the mechanism for postprandial hypoglycemia remains conjectural, prolonged elevations of postprandial concentrations of total and free insulin are consistent with the putative mechanism of a buffering effect of insulin antibodies.

CONCLUSION

Insulin autoimmune hypoglycemia, although rare in any racial group and especially in white subjects, can be readily detected by high titers of insulin antibodies. Such a determination should be done in all patients undergoing evaluation for hypoglycemia.

Insulin antibody response to bovine insulin therapy: functional significance among insulin requiring young diabetics in India

The majority of young diabetics in India prefer to use low-cost bovine insulin for economic reasons. Therefore, the question of insulin antibody response to bovine insulin and its functional significance is still relevant in the Indian context. We assessed insulin antibody response in 52 young diabetics (type 1, n=25, malnutrition modulated form of diabetes, n=19 and fibrocalculous pancreatopathy (FCP) n=8) on bovine insulin therapy (mean duration 3.0+/-2.1 years) using an internationally standardised in-house radioligand assay. The functional significance of insulin antibody was assessed by calculating their affinity constant, maximum binding capacity and total insulin binding power by Scatchard analysis (type 1, n=14, malnutrition modulated form of diabetes, n=11). All the patients treated with bovine insulin showed high titers of insulin antibodies with S.D. score ranging from 5.1 to 42.0. No significant difference was observed in the mean S.D. score of insulin antibodies in the three diabetic groups. The mean daily insulin dose, maximum insulin binding capacity and total insulin binding power were significantly higher in type 1 when compared to the malnutrition modulated form of diabetes (36+/-8 vs. 26+/-11 IU/day, P<0.05; 9. 7+/-7.8 vs. 4.0+/-3.9 nmol/l, P=0.03 and 59+/-29 vs. 29+/-43, P=0.01, respectively). Insulin antibodies S.D. score and its affinity did not show significant relationship with daily insulin dose and glycemic control (HbAl) at admission. Only 24+/-7% variations in daily insulin requirement were accounted for by total insulin binding power. There was a significant inverse relationship between insulin antibody S.D. score and duration of insulin therapy (r=-0. 4172, P<0.0004). To conclude, insulin antibody response following bovine insulin therapy is not different among type 1, malnutrition modulated form of diabetes and FCP diabetes. The insulin antibody response to bovine insulin therapy does not contribute significantly to increase in daily insulin requirement in bovine insulin treated insulin requiring young diabetics.