Induction of suppressor cells and cells producing antigen-specific suppressor factors by haptens bound to self carriers

Syngeneic red blood cell-induced extracellular vesicles suppress delayed-type hypersensitivity to self-antigens in mice

BACKGROUND

At present, the role of autologous cells as antigen carriers inducing immune tolerance is appreciated. Accordingly, intravenous administration of haptenated syngeneic mouse red blood cells (sMRBC) leads to hapten-specific suppression of contact hypersensitivity (CHS) in mice, mediated by light chain-coated extracellular vesicles (EVs). Subsequent studies suggested that mice intravenously administered with sMRBC alone may also generate regulatory EVs, revealing the possible self-tolerogenic potential of autologous erythrocytes.

OBJECTIVES

The current study investigated the immune effects induced by mere intravenous administration of a high dose of sMRBC in mice.

METHODS

The self-tolerogenic potential of EVs was determined in a newly developed mouse model of delayed-type hypersensitivity (DTH) to sMRBC. The effects of EV's action on DTH effector cells were evaluated cytometrically. The suppressive activity of EVs, after coating with anti-hapten antibody light chains, was assessed in hapten-induced CHS in wild-type or miRNA-150^-/- mice.

RESULTS

Intravenous administration of sMRBC led to the generation of CD9 + CD81+ EVs that suppressed sMRBC-induced DTH in a miRNA-150-dependent manner. Furthermore, the treatment of DTH effector cells with sMRBC-induced EVs decreased the activation of T cells but enhanced their apoptosis. Finally, EVs coated with antibody light chains inhibited hapten-induced CHS.

CONCLUSIONS AND CLINICAL RELEVANCE

The current study describes a newly discovered mechanism of self-tolerance induced by the intravenous delivery of a high dose of sMRBC that is mediated by EVs in a miRNA-150-dependent manner. This mechanism implies the concept of naturally occurring immune tolerance, presumably activated by overloading of the organism with altered self-antigens.

Antibody Light Chains Dictate the Specificity of Contact Hypersensitivity Effector Cell Suppression Mediated by Exosomes

Antibody light chains (LCs), formerly considered a waste product of immunoglobulin synthesis, are currently recognized as important players in the activation of the immune response. However, very little is known about the possible immune regulatory functions of LCs. Recently, we reported that hapten-specific LCs coat miRNA-150-carrying exosomes produced by CD8+ suppressor T cells downregulating the contact hypersensitivity (CHS) reaction in an antigen-specific manner, in mice tolerized by intravenous administration of a high dose of hapten-coupled syngeneic erythrocytes. Thus, the current studies aimed at investigating the role of hapten-specific LCs in antigen-specific, exosome-mediated suppression of CHS effector cells. Suppressor T cell-derived exosomes from tolerized B-cell-deficient µMT^-/-, NKT-cell-deficient Jα18^-/-, and immunoglobulin-deficient JH^-/- mice were nonsuppressive, unless supplemented with LCs of specificity strictly respective to the hapten used for sensitization and CHS elicitation in mice. Thus, these observations demonstrate that B1-cell-derived LCs, coating exosomes in vivo and in vitro, actually ensure the specificity of CHS suppression. Our research findings substantially expand current understanding of the newly discovered, suppressor T cell-dependent tolerance mechanism by uncovering the function of antigen-specific LCs in exosome-mediated, cell⁻cell communication. This express great translational potential in designing nanocarriers for specific targeting of desired cells.

From Mysterious Supernatant Entity to miRNA-150 in Antigen-Specific Exosomes: a History of Hapten-Specific T Suppressor Factor

Soon after the discovery of T suppressor cells by Gershon in 1970, it was demonstrated that one subpopulation of these lymphocytes induced by i.v. hapten injection suppresses contact sensitivity response mediated by effector CD4+ or CD8+ T cells in mice through the release of soluble T suppressor factor (TsF) that acts antigen specifically. Our experiments showed that biologically active TsF is a complex entity consisting of two subfactors, one antigen specific and other non-specific, produced by differently induced populations of cells. In following years, we found that the antigen-specific subfactor is a light chain of IgM antibody that is produced by B1a lymphocytes. However, the exact nature of non-specific part remained a mystery for about 30 years. Our current studies characterized TsF as regulatory miRNA-150 carried by T suppressor cell-derived exosomes that are antigen specific due to a surface coat of IgM antibody light chains produced by B1a cells. The present communication briefly summarizes our studies on TsF that led to discovery of regulating miRNA that acts antigen specifically to suppress immune response.

Free Extracellular miRNA Functionally Targets Cells by Transfecting Exosomes from Their Companion Cells

Lymph node and spleen cells of mice doubly immunized by epicutaneous and intravenous hapten application produce a suppressive component that inhibits the action of the effector T cells that mediate contact sensitivity reactions. We recently re-investigated this phenomenon in an immunological system. CD8+ T lymphocyte-derived exosomes transferred suppressive miR-150 to the effector T cells antigen-specifically due to exosome surface coat of antibody light chains made by B1a lymphocytes. Extracellular RNA (exRNA) is protected from plasma RNases by carriage in exosomes or by chaperones. Exosome transfer of functional RNA to target cells is well described, whereas the mechanism of transfer of exRNA free of exosomes remains unclear. In the current study we describe extracellular miR-150, extracted from exosomes, yet still able to mediate antigen-specific suppression. We have determined that this was due to miR-150 association with antibody-coated exosomes produced by B1a cell companions of the effector T cells, which resulted in antigen-specific suppression of their function. Thus functional cell targeting by free exRNA can proceed by transfecting companion cell exosomes that then transfer RNA cargo to the acceptor cells. This contrasts with the classical view on release of RNA-containing exosomes from the multivesicular bodies for subsequent intercellular targeting. This new alternate pathway for transfer of exRNA between cells has distinct biological and immunological significance, and since most human blood exRNA is not in exosomes may be relevant to evaluation and treatment of diseases.

Macrophages play an essential role in antigen-specific immune suppression mediated by T CD8⁺ cell-derived exosomes

Murine contact sensitivity (CS) reaction could be antigen-specifically regulated by T CD8(+) suppressor (Ts) lymphocytes releasing microRNA-150 in antibody light-chain-coated exosomes that were formerly suggested to suppress CS through action on macrophages (Mφ). The present studies investigated the role of Mφ in Ts cell-exosome-mediated antigen-specific suppression as well as modulation of Mφ antigen-presenting function in humoral and cellular immunity by suppressive exosomes. Mice depleted of Mφ by clodronate liposomes could not be tolerized and did not produce suppressive exosomes. Moreover, isolated T effector lymphocytes transferring CS were suppressed by exosomes only in the presence of Mφ, demonstrating the substantial role of Mφ in the generation and action of Ts cell regulatory exosomes. Further, significant decrease of number of splenic B cells producing trinitrophenyl (TNP) -specific antibodies with the alteration of the ratio of serum titres of IgM to IgG was observed in recipients of exosome-treated, antigen-pulsed Mφ and the significant suppression of CS was demonstrated in recipients of exosome-treated, TNP-conjugated Mφ. Additionally, exosome-pulsed, TNP-conjugated Mφ mediated suppression of CS in mice pre-treated with a low-dose of cyclophosphamide, suggesting de novo induction of T regulatory (Treg) lymphocytes. Treg cell involvement in the effector phase of the studied suppression mechanism was proved by unsuccessful tolerization of DEREG mice depleted of Treg lymphocytes. Furthermore, the inhibition of proliferation of CS effector cells cultured with exosome-treated Mφ in a transmembrane manner was observed. Our results demonstrated the essential role of Mφ in antigen-specific immune suppression mediated by Ts cell-derived exosomes and realized by induction of Treg lymphocytes and inhibition of T effector cell proliferation.

Antigen-specific, antibody-coated, exosome-like nanovesicles deliver suppressor T-cell microRNA-150 to effector T cells to inhibit contact sensitivity

BACKGROUND

T-cell tolerance of allergic cutaneous contact sensitivity (CS) induced in mice by high doses of reactive hapten is mediated by suppressor cells that release antigen-specific suppressive nanovesicles.

OBJECTIVE

We sought to determine the mechanism or mechanisms of immune suppression mediated by the nanovesicles.

METHODS

T-cell tolerance was induced by means of intravenous injection of hapten conjugated to self-antigens of syngeneic erythrocytes and subsequent contact immunization with the same hapten. Lymph node and spleen cells from tolerized or control donors were harvested and cultured to produce a supernatant containing suppressive nanovesicles that were isolated from the tolerized mice for testing in active and adoptive cell-transfer models of CS.

RESULTS

Tolerance was shown due to exosome-like nanovesicles in the supernatants of CD8(+) suppressor T cells that were not regulatory T cells. Antigen specificity of the suppressive nanovesicles was conferred by a surface coat of antibody light chains or possibly whole antibody, allowing targeted delivery of selected inhibitory microRNA (miRNA)-150 to CS effector T cells. Nanovesicles also inhibited CS in actively sensitized mice after systemic injection at the peak of the responses. The role of antibody and miRNA-150 was established by tolerizing either panimmunoglobulin-deficient JH(-/-) or miRNA-150(-/-) mice that produced nonsuppressive nanovesicles. These nanovesicles could be made suppressive by adding antigen-specific antibody light chains or miRNA-150, respectively.

CONCLUSIONS

This is the first example of T-cell regulation through systemic transit of exosome-like nanovesicles delivering a chosen inhibitory miRNA to target effector T cells in an antigen-specific manner by a surface coating of antibody light chains.

Subpopulations of Mouse Testicular Macrophages and their Immunoregulatory Function

PROBLEM

Testicular macrophages (TMf) participate together with Sertoli cells in formation of blood-testis barrier. The present experiments were aimed to test their immunoregulatory functions in vivo and in vitro.

METHOD OF STUDY

TMf were purified by glass adherence, rosetting with opsonized erythrocytes and fractionation on discontinuous Percoll gradient (over 95% purity). Their antigen-presenting capacity in humoral and cell-mediated responses was tested in vitro (Mishell-Dutton cultures, proliferation assay) and in vivo (induction of contact sensitivity reaction).

RESULTS

TMf represent a heterogeneous cell population. Heavier Percoll fractions produce little transforming growth factor (TGF)-beta and are efficient antigen-presenting cells in humoral and cell-mediated immune responses. Lighter fractions produce high amounts of TGF-beta and are rather tolerogenic than immunogenic. Their immunosuppressive activity can be prevented by treatment of TMf donors with cyclophosphamide or in vitro by anti-TGF-beta monoclonal antibody. In non-separated TMf population the immunosuppressive activity prevails.

CONCLUSIONS

Subpopulation of TMf able to trigger specific immune responses is present in the testis but remains under control of other TMf subpopulation which minimizes the risk of development of autoimmune reactions.

IL-12 reverses established tolerance mediated by TCRalphabeta+ but not by TCRgammadelta+ suppressor T cells

Topical cutaneous painting with chemically reactive haptens induces the ability to subsequently elicit contact sensitivity (CS) responses in the skin. These CS responses are in vivo examples of acquired, antigen (Ag)-specific T cell immunity, and are a form of delayed-type hypersensitivity (DTH). In contrast, high dose i.v. administration of the hapten can induce Ag-specific tolerance. In some instances this specific immune hyporeactivity is due to suppressor T cells. We investigated the effect of IL-12 on reversal of tolerance due to suppressor T cells that were induced by i.v. administration of hapten in either normal TCRalpha+/+, or in immunodeficient TCRalpha-/- mice. In the TCRalpha+/+ mice, tolerance is mediated by TCRalphabeta+ suppressor T cells, while in the TCRalpha-/- mice the tolerance is due to suppressive TCRgammadelta+ cells. Treatment with IL-12 reversed suppressor mediated by the TCRalphabeta+ cells, but did not affect tolerance due to TCRgammadelta+ suppressor cells. Another difference was that the alphabetaTCR+ suppressor cells produced a soluble suppressor factor that could replace the surppressor cells, while gammadeltaTCR+ suppressor cells did not. We hypothesized that IL-12 may strengthen responses of target CS-effector T cells influenced by the hapten-MHC-specificity of alphabeta suppresssor cells, or suppressor factor. On the other hand, gammadeltaTCR+ suppressive cells likely have specificity for the hapten alone, and are not MHC-restricted, and therefore probably do not operate via peptide-MHC interactions, that could be strengthened by IL-12. The ability of IL-12 to strengthen the resistance of CS-effector T cells to alphabeta TCR suppressor cells, may be due to the ability of IL-12 to increase T cell costimulation mediated by signaling mechanisms acting via B7.1 and B7.2. In contrast, gammadeltaTCR+ suppressor cells, that are largely hapten-specific, probably do not interact with peptide/MHC complexes on APC, and thus are not affected by IL-12 strengthening of co-stimulation.

Soluble T cell receptors modulate cytokine production and oxygen metabolism by peritoneal macrophages

Preincubation of peritoneal macrophages and their subsequent culture with recombinant soluble T cell receptor (sTCR) results in significant increase of: TNF-alpha, IL-1beta, IL-6, IL-10, IL-12 production and nitric oxide (NO) synthesis and this phenomenon was dose dependent. Moreover, treatment of macrophages with sTCR showed two to three fold increase of luminol dependent chemiluminescence (LCL) when compared to untreated macrophages (Mf). In contrast, in our study we did not find any influence of sTCR on co-stimulatory (B7.1 and B7.2), adhesion molecule (ICAM-1) or FcRII/III expression by macrophages. However, macrophages treated with control supernatants received after phosphatidylinositol-specific phospholipase C (PI-PLC) treatment of BW1100 cells or thymocytes termed s-BW or s-Th did not influence their biological activity.

IL-12 Reverses Established Antigen-Specific Tolerance of Contact Sensitivity by Affecting Costimulatory Molecules B7-1 (CD80) and B7-2 (CD86)

Cutaneous painting with reactive haptens induces contact sensitivity (CS) responses that are in vivo examples of T cell immunity. In contrast, high dose i.v. administration of the hapten can induce tolerance. We investigated the effect of IL-12 on reversal of this tolerance and attempted to determine in vitro the mechanism of this reversing effect by measuring proliferation and IFN-γ production by CS effector T cells stimulated with hapten-conjugated APC, and we also measured CS ear swelling in vivo. The in vitro responses of T cells to hapten-APC became absent in tolerized mice, paralleling impaired in vivo CS responses. Addition of IL-12 to cultures manifesting this fully established in vitro tolerance completely restored impaired responses of tolerized T cells. The reversing effects of IL-12 were not blocked by anti-IFN-γ mAb, but were blocked by mAbs against B7-1, more strongly by anti-B7-2, and by both Abs together. Additional in vivo ear-swelling response experiments confirmed the reversing effects of IL-12 on established tolerance. To examine whether the IL-12 effect depended on stimulation of IFN-γ, we directly injected IFN-γ into tolerized mice. This partially mimicked but did not fully reconstitute the effects of IL-12. In summary, IL-12 abrogation of established tolerance of CS may have been partially due to endogenous production of IFN-γ, but appeared mainly due to direct activation of the tolerized T cells by affecting signaling through costimulatory molecules B7-1 and B7-2.

Aggregated immunoglobulin protects immune T cells from suppression: dependence on isotype, Fc portion, and macrophage FcgammaR

We determined the regulatory properties of heat-aggregated immunoglobulins (HA-Ig) that possess many activities of immune complexes (IC), such as binding and activation of cells via immunoglobulin Fc gamma receptors (FcgammaR). HA-Ig protected contact sensitivity (CS) effector T cells from antigen-specific immunosuppression, while monomeric IgG were inactive. This anti-suppressive activity of HA-Ig was antigen non-specific, and depended on the species from which Ig was derived, i.e. mouse and rat HA-Ig were protective in mice, and of other species were inactive. The protecting activity of HA-Ig was confined to IgG2a and IgG3, and to a lesser degree to IgG1 isotypes, and resided in the Fc domain. Removal of phagocytic cells from the CS-immune target cells, or blocking with anti-FcgammaR mAb, abolished HA-Ig protection of CS-effector T cells from suppression. We suggest that HA-Ig multimers acted via Fc domains, in one of two ways: by binding to FcgammaR of macrophages to produce positive-acting cytokines, or by blocking FcgammaR on macrophages, to compete with suppressive factors that can also bind to FcgammaR. If HA-Ig protection of T cells is generalized, it is likely that IC in vivo may non-specifically overcome suppression of responses to antigen that normally are under the control of T suppressive cells, and thus may contribute to the development of autoimmunity.

Positive regulatory gamma delta T cells in contact sensitivity: augmented responses by in vivo treatment with anti-gamma delta monoclonal antibody, or anti-V gamma 5 or V delta 4

Contact sensitivity (CS) responses, induced by skin painting with reactive haptens like picryl chloride or oxazolone, are classical examples of in vivo immunity mediated by alpha beta T cells. Our previous studies showed that gamma delta T cells were required to assist the alpha beta CS-effector T cells in the successful adoptive cell transfer of CS responses. These spleen and lymph node-derived gamma delta+ CS-assisting regulatory cells were CD3+, CD4-CD8+, non-antigen-specific, and non-MHC-restricted, and preferentially expressed V gamma 5 and V delta 4 variable regions. In the current study we show that systemic treatment of mice in vivo with anti-gamma delta mAb, produced a similar positive influence on CS responses in two different systems: i.e. active sensitization, or adoptive cell transfer. In addition to augmented CS responses produced by treatment with pan anti-gamma delta TCR mAb, anti-gamma delta-V region mAb were examined, and augmentation of CS also was produced by anti-V gamma 5 and anti-V delta 4 mAb, the V regions determined previously to be preferentially expressed on gamma delta CS-assisting cells. We speculate that the positive influence of anti-gamma delta mAb was not caused by quantitative changes in gamma delta T cells, because FACS studies demonstrated a lack of in vivo depletion of peripheral blood and lymphoid gamma delta T cells, and also no depletion of epidermal dendritic gamma delta T cells (DETC), in mice treated with anti-gamma delta TCR mAb. Instead, our data favor the hypothesis that CS-assisting gamma delta T cells can be activated in vivo by anti-gamma delta TCR mAb interacting with their gamma delta TCR, at least with the short term protocols we employed, resulting in augmentation of CS responses perhaps by releasing positively-acting factors, such as certain cytokines.

Gamma delta T cells from tolerized alpha beta T cell receptor (TCR)-deficient mice inhibit contact sensitivity-effector T cells in vivo, and their interferon-gamma production in vitro

Contact sensitivity (CS) responses to reactive hapten Ag, such as picryl chloride (PCl) or oxazolone (OX), are classical examples of T cell-mediated immune responses in vivo that are clearly subject to multifaceted regulation. There is abundant evidence that downregulation of CS may be mediated by T cells exposed to high doses of Ag. This is termed high dose Ag tolerance. To clarify the T cell types that effect CS responses and mediate their downregulation, we have undertaken studies of CS in mice congenitally deficient in specific subsets of lymphocytes. The first such studies, using alpha beta T cell-deficient (TCR alpha -/-) mice, are presented here. The results clearly show that TCR alpha -/- mice cannot mount CS, implicating alpha beta T cells as the critical CS-effector cells. However, TCR alpha -/- mice can, after high dose tolerance, downregulate alpha +/+ CS-effector T cells adoptively transferred into them. By mixing ex vivo and then adoptive cell transfers in vivo, the active downregulatory cells in tolerized alpha -/- mice are shown to include gamma delta TCR+ cells that also can downregulate interferon-gamma production by the targeted CS-effector cells in vitro. Downregulation by gamma delta cells showed specificity for hapten, but was not restricted by the MHC. Together, these findings establish that gamma delta T cells cannot fulfill CS-effector functions performed by alpha beta T cells, but may fulfill an Ag-specific downregulatory role that may be directly comparable to reports of Ag-specific downregulation of IgE antibody responses by gamma delta T cells. Comparisons are likewise considered with downregulation by gamma delta T cells occurring in immune responses to pathogens, tumors, and allografts, and in systemic autoimmunity.

Regulation of contact sensitivity reaction: contrasuppressor T cells and contrasuppressor factor downregulate efferent T suppressor cells

Contact sensitivity (CS) reaction mediated by CD 4+8- Th 1 cells is under the control of several antigen-specific regulatory lymphocytes. Reaction is downregulated at the induction stage by T afferent suppressor T cells (Ts-aff) that prevent immunization and at the effector stage by efferent T suppressor cells (Ts-eff) that made immune Th 1 cells inoperative. Both suppressor cells are CD 4-8+ Th 1 effector cells and are protected against the suppressive action of Ts-eff cells by CD 4+8- contrasuppressor T cells (Tcs). As has been already shown there are also regulatory interactions between regulatory cells themselves and Ts-aff cells in addition to their effect on precursors of Th 1 cells, also preventing the induction of Ts-eff cells. The present experiments extend these findings and demonstrate that Ts-eff cells are also under negative control of Tcs lymphocytes. Likewise, antigen-specific factor produced by contrasuppressor T-T cell hybridoma, used in lieu of Tcs cells, impedes the activation of Ts-eff cells. In both cases regulation is aimed at the precursors of Ts-eff cells. Our experiments demonstrate that the outcome of immunization is dependent not only on the balance between immune cells and regulatory cells, but also on interactions between regulatory cells themselves.

Regulatory responses in contact sensitivity: afferent suppressor T cells inhibit the activation of efferent suppressor T cells

Two types of suppressor cells regulate the contact sensitivity (CS) response to picryl chloride (PCL). Afferent suppressor T cells (Ts-aff) inhibit the generation of CS responses to PCL, while efferent suppressor T cells (Ts-eff) inhibit the activity of Th 1 cells that mediate CS reaction. Intravenous injection of mice with TNP-substituted peritoneal exudate cells (TNP-PEC) induces Ts-eff cells that block the adoptive transfer of contact sensitivity. The induction of Ts-eff cells is prevented by the presence of Ts-aff cells, which in turn are induced by the injection of TNP-PEC coupled with antibodies of the IgG2a and IgG2b isotype (TNP-PEC-Ab). If an animal is injected with TNP-PEC prior to or simultaneously with TNP-PEC-Ab, it generates only Ts-aff cells, while if it is injected with TNP-PEC alone or TNP-PEC prior to TNP-PEC-Ab, it generates Ts-eff cells. Ts-aff cells effect only the generation of Ts-eff cells, as the addition of Ts-eff cells to assays for Ts-eff cells has no inhibitory effect on the suppressive effects of Ts-eff cells in adoptive transfer. Our experiments show that Ts-aff cells induced by TNP-PEC-Ab are phenotypically either Lyt 1+2- or Lyt 1-2+, but only the latter inhibit the generation of Ts-eff cells in vivo. The Ts-aff cells that inhibit Ts-eff activity adhere to the lectin Vicia villosa (VV), while Ts-eff cells are VV nonadherent. In addition, Ts-aff cells can prevent the generation of Ts-eff to linked haptens presented on the same PEC. It appears that a cascade of Ts cell interactions are involved in the regulation of CS responses.

Suppression and contrasuppression in athymic nude mice: nude mice produce the antigen-specific component of a T suppressor factor that inhibits the late 24-hr phase of DTH but do not generate suppression nor contrasuppression of the early initiating phase of DTH

Previous studies demonstrated that the initiation of murine delayed-type hypersensitivity (DTH), as exemplified by contact sensitivity induced by picryl chloride (PCI) or oxazolone (OX), is due to antigen-specific, T cell-derived, DTH-initiating factors called, respectively, PCl-F and OX-F. These factors participate in the extravascular recruitment of CD4+, Th-1, DTH effector T cells in the elicitation of DTH. Related factors also participate, together with nonantigen binding factors derived from CD8+ T cells, to constitute an antigen-specific T cell-derived suppressor factor (TsF) that can down regulate the ability of Th-1 effector T cells to mediate DTH. Since it was shown recently that athymic nude mice can make antigen-specific, DTH-initiating T cell factors, the current study tested whether nude mice also could produce the antigen-specific component of the TsF that suppresses DTH effector T cells. We found that antigen-specific factors from nu/nu mice could complement the nonantigen-binding subfactor produced in normal mice to constitute the whole antigen-specific TsF. Additional studies showed that the successful adoptive cell transfer of DTH-initiating T cell activity from nude mice into normal mice required cyclophosphamide treatment of the recipient. In contrast, transfer of DTH-initiating cell activity from nu/+ mice did not require cyclophosphamide treatment of the recipients. We hypothesized that nude mice lacked contrasuppressor cells. Although nude mice were able to manifest the early, initiating phase of DTH, we found that there was no suppression of early DTH-initiating T cells in nude mice, compared to nu/+. Therefore the production of DTH-initiating T cell factor could be boosted in nude mice. The ability to boost DTH-initiating cells in nude mice should facilitate the development of cell lines and clones with the ability to initiate DTH.

Sex differences in regulation of contact sensitivity reaction in mice. 1. Influence of sex on the generation of contrasuppressor and afferent suppressor cells

It is well known that humoral and cell-mediated immune responses are better in females than in males. Females also develop autoimmunity more easily than males. Contact sensitivity, one of the forms of cell-mediated immunity, is controlled at the afferent and efferent phases by complex interactions of regulatory T cells. Our present experiments indicate that T suppressor afferent (Ts-aff) and T contrasuppressor cells (Tcs) are generated in the mouse in a sex-dependent fashion. These two types of regulatory cells are induced by antigen-antibody complexes containing various immunoglobulin isotypes. Females require fewer antigen (Ag)-IgG1 complexes to produce Tcs cells, but more Tcs cells after antigenic stimulation in females tips the balance toward better immune responsiveness. It remains to be established whether the peculiarities in generation of regulatory cells in female mice are relevant to the pathogenesis of autoimmune diseases which predominantly affect females.

Deficiency of contrasuppressor lymphocytes in alloxan-diabetic mice

Ly 1 immune cells of alloxan diabetic mice are inferior to cells of normoglycemic PCl sensitized animals in transferring adoptive responses into recipients. A new regulatory activity, contrasuppression, that prevents suppressor cells from influencing activity of immune cells, has been recently described. Two types of Ly 1 contrasuppressor (Tcs) cells modulate contact sensitivity reactions in mice. A non-specific Tcs cell, which by itself has no immune activity, helps Ly 1 immune effector cells in adoptive transfer to bypass, in the recipient, the suppressor cell barrier. The antigen-specific Tcs cell induced by immune complexes makes Ly 1 effector cells resistant to specific suppression. Both Tcs cell, in contrast to Ly 1 effector cells, adhere to Vicia villosa lectin and can easily be separated (VV+ and VV-, respectively). Our experiments show that diabetic mice are deficient in nonspecific Tcs cells. The most important finding was that when immune Ly 1 cells of diabetic mice, which otherwise transfer little immunity, were injected together with Ly 1 VV+ cells of normoglycemic animals (these cells have no ability to transfer immunity whatsoever), the adoptive transfer was significantly augmented. We also demonstrate that diabetic mice are unable, upon appropriate immunization, to produce antigen-specific Tcs cells. Since a hypoinsulinemic environment abolishes the function of promiscuous Tcs cells and prevents the development of antigen-specific Tcs cells, this may suggest that contrasuppressor cells have insulin receptors which make them particularly sensitive to insulin deficiency.

The induction of oxazolone-specific T suppressor afferent cells in mice by hapten-modified isologous IgG

Injection of isologous 4(ethoxymethylene)-2-phenyl-oxazolin-5-one (oxazolone; OX)-substituted thymocytes or OX-labeled IgG (OX-IgG) into mice produces specific unresponsiveness in which immunization with homologous (OX), but not heterologous (picryl chloride), hapten on the skin does not result in significant contact sensitization. However, while injection of OX-substituted thymocytes triggers suppressor cells which inhibit the effector stage of contact sensitivity reaction, OX-IgG induces cells which suppress exclusively the afferent stage of reaction. In contrast to OX-IgG, OX-substituted F(ab')2 fragments, IgM, and albumin are ineffective. T suppressor afferent cells have Ly-2 and I-J surface markers and their precursors are resistant to cyclophosphamide treatment and adult thymectomy. We assume that T suppressor afferent cells recognize antigen in conjunction with intact IgG molecules, although the exact mechanism is unclear.

Induction of "allogeneic effect"-like reaction by syngeneic TNP-modified lymphoid cells

TNP-substituted SRBC-immune spleen cells, when injected into cyclophosphamide-treated recipients, are recognized by T lymphocytes and produce, in the presence of specific antigen (SRBC), significantly more PFC than nonsubstituted cells. Labeling of immune B cells is more important in producing the augmented responses than is the labeling of immune T cells. TNP determinant has to be bound directly to the transferred immune cells to produce enhanced antibody responses, as when recipients were injected with non-substituted immune cells and TNP-substituted non-immune cells simultaneously, no increase in PFC number was noted (lack of a bystander effect). When recipients were rendered tolerant to TNP, two separate effects were observed, dependent on the mode of inducing unresponsiveness. In mice which were treated with TNP over an extended period of time, lack of recognition of TNP was demonstrated, such that TNP-substituted cells failed, when transferred, to produce an augmented response. When a short-term tolerogenic regime was used, the adoptively transferred TNP-labeled cells gave a very poor response (greater than 95% inhibition) due to in vivo suppression and/or killing. These results, together with the lack of influence of tolerance induced to unrelated hapten (DNP or OX), confirm the antigen specificity of the phenomenon. The reaction observed by us shows a striking resemblance with, but not identical to, the "allogeneic effect" produced by MHC encoded alloantigens. Our results extend the list of analogous immune reactions induced by MHC encoded alloantigens and TNP-derivatized self.

Immunological agnosis: a state that derives from T suppressor cell inhibition of antigen-presenting cells

The biologically active mediators of antigen-specific T suppressor cells can combine with antigen on cells that are specialized to present antigen (APC) and render these APC incapable of presenting not only the specific antigen that the product of the T suppressor cell sees but also any other antigen in or on the APC. Thus, antigen-bearing suppressed APC fail to activate either the helper or suppressor system involved in the regulation of contact sensitivity responses. These results demonstrate that APC are targets of T suppressor cells. They also imply that a metabolic event is required for functional antigen presentation and that T suppressor cells can block that metabolic pathway.

Immunoregulatory circuits which modulate responsiveness to suppressor cell signals: contrasuppressor cells can convert an in vivo tolerogenic signal into an immunogenic one

The intravenous injection of 2,4,6-trinitrophenyl (TNP)-labeled peritoneal exudate cells (TNP-PEC) into CBA mice fails to produce a state of hypersensitivity; rather, it renders recipient mice incapable of mounting a contact hypersensitivity response when they are subsequently immunized with a reactive form of the specific hapten. However, if precultured neonatal spleen cells are injected along with the cells that induce tolerance (TNP-PEC), not only is the development of tolerance inhibited but sensitization to TNP develops. The neonatal spleen cell responsible for turning the tolerogenic signal into an immunogenic one is I-J+ and adheres to the Vicia villosa lectin. Thus, it expresses markers that distinguish contrasuppressor effector cells from helper cells (D. R. Green et al., Eur. J. Immunol. 1981. 11:973), indicating that activated contrasuppressor cells can act as potent, helpful regulatory cells in vivo.

Isolation and partial characterization of an antigen-specific T-cell factor associated with the suppression of delayed type hypersensitivity

Antigen-specific factors associated with immunosuppressive activity, released by cultured T cells from mice tolerant to the haptens trinitrophenyl, dinitrophenyl and oxazolone, were purified by hapten affinity chromatography. Their binding specificity for antigens paralleled their immunoregulatory activity. Like some immunoglobulin molecules, these factors had blocked NH2 termini and could be bound to Fc-like receptors on macrophages. However, neither immunoglobulin constant region determinants (isotypes) nor antigens encoded by the major histocompatibility complex were detected on the suppressive factors. The purified factors occurred as 68,000-dalton proteins and non-covalently linked dimers. No associated immunoglobulin light chain molecules were detected. The factors showed a marked propensity toward degradation with major breakdown products of 45,000-50,000 and 25,000-30,000 daltons. These results suggest that these molecules are the T-cell products analogous to B-cell immunoglobulin (equivalent to heavy chains) and that they may be the antigen-specific components which act in conjunction with major histocompatibility-controlled gene products to perform antigen-specific suppression.

Regulation of delayed-type hypersensitivity. V. Suppressor cell memory in antigen-specific suppression of delayed-type hypersensitivity to sheep erythrocytes

Mice printed i.v. wit 10(9) sheep red blood cells (SRBC) produce antigen-specific T suppressor (Ts) cells which inhibit both the induction and the expression of delayed-type hypersensitivity (DTH). These Ts cells are detectable in the spleen and lymph nodes 3-5 days after priming but are largely absent by 6 days. The transient detectability of the Ts cells contrasts sharply with the profound antigen-specific suppression which persists in primed donor mice for at least a year. Evidence is presented that this long-term impairment of DTH is maintained, at least in part, by memory Ts cells which are Thy-1+, cyclophosphamide-resistant and antigen-specific. Although they appear to be co-induced with the short-lived primary Ts cells and localize initially in the lymphoid organs, they are present in the long-lived circulating pool of T cells and can be adoptively transferred by celomic parabiosis. Memory Ts cells are readily reactivated by lower doses of SRBC which would induce T effector cells rather than Ts cells in naive animals. Reactivated memory Ts cells seem to generate a population of antigen-specific secondary Ts cells which again localizes in the lymphoid organs and can adoptively suppress the induction and expression of DTH to SRBC.