Hypothesis: immunogenetic analysis of spontaneous autoimmune thyroiditis in obese strain (OS) chickens: a two-gene family model

Avian models with spontaneous autoimmune diseases

Autoimmune diseases in human patients only become clinically manifest when the disease process has developed to a stage where functional compensation by the afflicted organ or system is not possible anymore. In order to understand the initial etiologic and pathogenic events that are generally not yet accessible in humans, appropriate animal models are required. In this respect, spontaneously developing models--albeit rare--reflect the situation in humans much more closely than experimentally induced models, including knockout and transgenic mice. The present chapter describes three spontaneous chicken models for human autoimmune diseases, the Obese strain (OS) with a Hashimoto-like autoimmune thyroiditis, the University of California at Davis lines 200 and 206 (UCD-200 and -206) with a scleroderma-like disease, and the amelanotic Smyth line with a vitiligo-like syndrome (SLV). Special emphasis is given to the new opportunities to unravel the genetic basis of these diseases in view of the recently completed sequencing of the chicken genome.

Expression of nonspecific esterase (NSE) by thyroid follicular epithelium as a marker for the target organ susceptibility to immune system attack

Spontaneous autoimmune thyroiditis in obese strain (OS) chickens provides an excellent animal model for the study of Hashimoto's autoimmune thyroiditis in humans. The data presented in this paper indicate that nonspecific esterases (NSE) may play a role in or serve as a marker for the target organ susceptibility. Experiments have shown that follicular epithelial cells and interfollicular macrophages in connective tissue stain positively for NSE as early as the first day after hatching, a time at which infiltrating lymphocytes are not yet observed. We also have observed NSE positivity of follicular cells in the vicinity of mononuclear cell infiltration in all OS chickens, as well as weaker positivity in 6-month-old, avian leukosis virus free, Brown Leghorn outbred chickens, which appears in each case to correlate with infiltration of lymphocytes. In F2 hybrids between OS and healthy CB inbred chickens, the intensity of NSE staining was more variable than in OS chickens. Using specific inhibitors eserine, Na-taurocholat and p-hydroxymercuribenzoic acid, we were able to inhibit in vitro the NSE positivity of thyroid gland follicular epithelium, indicating that this staining was not an artifact. Experiments are currently in progress to clarify the relationship between the presence of NSE in follicular epithelium and the predisposition to spontaneous autoimmune thyroiditis.

Analysis of the effect of endogenous viral genes in the Smyth line chicken model for autoimmune vitiligo

The Smyth line (SL) chicken, an animal model for autoimmune human vitiligo, is characterized by a spontaneous posthatch pigment loss, determined to be the result of an autoimmune phenomenon. Because endogenous virus (EV) genes have been reported to be associated with a number of autoimmune diseases of human and animal models, we designed this experiment to investigate the role of EV in the SL vitiligo by using the complete sequence of Rous-associated virus-2 as a probe for EV. An F(2) resource population was developed by the matings of SL and parental control (BL) chickens. Linkage disequilibrium between vitiligo and EV was apparent (16.2-kb SacI fragment, P Collapse

Key Words Collapse

MESH Headings

• Animals
• Autoimmune Diseases/genetics
• Autoimmune Diseases/virology
• Azacitidine/pharmacology
• Blotting, Northern
• Chickens/genetics
• Chickens/virology
• DNA/analysis
• DNA/chemistry
• DNA Fingerprinting
• DNA Methylation
• Deoxyribonuclease HindIII/metabolism
• Deoxyribonucleases, Type II Site-Specific/metabolism
• Disease Models, Animal
• Endogenous Retroviruses/genetics
• Female
• Fibroblasts/drug effects
• Fibroblasts/metabolism
• Genes, Viral
• In Situ Hybridization, Fluorescence
• Male
• Pedigree
• Polymorphism, Restriction Fragment Length
• RNA Viruses
• RNA, Viral/analysis
• Vitiligo/genetics
• Vitiligo/virology

Collapse

Grants

• Wellcome Trust

Collapse

Affiliation(s)

G P Sreekumar Department of Veterinary and Animal Sciences, University of Massachusetts, Amherst, Massachusetts 01003, USA
J R Smyth
S Ambady
F A Ponce de Leon

Collapse

The natural history of the obese strain of chickens--an animal model for spontaneous autoimmune thyroiditis

Chickens of the Obese strain (OS) are hereditarily affected with spontaneous autoimmune thyroiditis that resembles Hashimoto's thyroiditis of humans in clinical, histopathological, serological, and endocrinological aspects. In this review, the natural history of the OS, reflecting the development and maintenance of the stock and its improvement of productivity over many years at Cornell University, is summarized. To underline the value and usefulness of this animal model, the concept of the multifactorial pathogenesis of autoimmune diseases, which was mainly established at the University of Innsbruck, Austria, is briefly outlined. This detailed analysis on the natural history of the OS was only made feasible by the availability of four decades of records on this chicken line at Cornell University. The report starts with the initial occurrence of a few pullets within the Cornell C-strain (CS) flock that showed obesity, long and silky feathers, and small body size, which, therefore, caused these birds to look notably different than the other CS birds. Experimental findings indicated an autoimmune basis for these characteristics, and the objectives of matings were initially focused on increasing the number of obese individuals for studies on the etiopathology and the mode of inheritance. In subsequent years, matings were directed toward increasing the penetrance and severity of the obese trait in the population. In recent years, the reproductive capability of the obese stock was improved by mating only the best breeders of the population in terms of body weight, egg weight, egg production, fertility, hatchability, and the expression of the obese phenotype. Housing conditions for OS chickens at Cornell and the qualification standards and selection procedures for breeders are described in detail, and results of blood typings are shown. A specific recent finding in OS hens is the high incidence of residues of the right Mullerian duct with cyst formation.

Effect of genetic selection and MHC haplotypes on lymphocyte proliferation and interleukin-2 like activity in chicken lines selected for high and low antibody production against sheep red blood cells

Chickens from third generation matings of lines of chickens selected for high (HA) and low (LA) antibody production to sheep red blood cells (SRBC) and typed for MHC genotypes B13/13, B13/21, and B21/21 were used in this study. Chickens from both lines carried all the three genotypes B13/13, B13/21, and B21/21. To study T- and B-lymphocytes mitogenic activity, 12-week-old female chickens were injected intravenously with 0.2 ml of 9% SRBC and spleens were collected at 0, 6 h, and 6 day post-antigen injection (pAg). Isolated lymphocytes were incubated with either Concanavalin-A (Con-A) for T-cell activity, or Pokeweed mitogen (PWM) for B-cell activity and thymidine 3H uptakes were measured. To study the Interleukin-2 (IL-2)-like activity in the same lines and genotypes, splenic lymphocytes from 12-week-old chickens were passed through nylon wool columns to enrich the T-cell population. After a 24 h incubation with Con-A, the conditioned media (CM) were collected. The CM were tested for IL-2 like activity by determining whether they altered the proliferation of Con-A stimulated T cells. This proliferation effect was then compared to that of a reference conditioned media (RCM) prepared from K-strain birds and that were used as the standard for the assay. There was no significant difference (p > 0.05) in IL-2 like activity between HA and LA lines, however, the LA was significantly higher than HA (p < 0.05) in T- and B-cell mitogenic activity. The genotype B13/13 had significantly higher (p < 0.05) IL-2 like activity than the B21/21. The genotype B13/13 was also significantly higher (p < 0.05) in T- and B-cell mitogenic activity than the B21/21. At 0 h, pAg T- and B-mitogenic activity was significantly higher (p < 0.05) than 6 h. In summary, our results indicate that although the birds were selected for high antibody production to SRBC, their lymphocyte mitogenic activity was lower than those selected for low antibody production. Hence, humoral and cell-mediated immune responses appear to be under different genetic controls, and that selection for greater humoral response may be at the expense of cellular responses. Our results also suggest differences in IL-2 like activity production between chickens carrying different MHC B-haplotypes, and that genetic control of such activity is possibly linked to the MHC genes.

Neuroendocrine-immune disturbances in animal models with spontaneous autoimmune diseases

According to our concept, the development of autoimmune disease depends on the presence of two sets of essential genes, one coding for an abnormal autoreactivity of the immune system, the other for a primary susceptibility of the target organ/structure for the immune attack. The final outcome of the disease in a given individual is then fine tuned by modulatory factors, such as diet or hormones. With regard to the latter, the immuno-endocrine interaction via the hypothalamo-pituitary-adrenal (HPA) axis has proven to be of special importance. Investigating the so-called Obese strain (OS) of chickens, an animal model with a spontaneously occurring Hashimoto-like autoimmune thyroiditis, we have first shown an impaired surge of glucocorticoid hormones after stimulation of the HPA axis by antigens or certain cytokines (glucocorticoid-increasing factors--GIFs). More recently, we have found a similar behavior in models with systemic autoimmune diseases, that is, murine lupus erythematosus and avian scleroderma. More detailed studies have, however, proven that the mechanisms underlying this altered immuno-endocrine communication via the HPA axis differs in different models. Finally, recent data point to the possibility that the classical pathways of glucocorticoid-T-cell interactions also take place in the thymus itself, which has been shown to be a site of steroid hormone production.

The detection of melanocyte autoantibodies in the Smyth chicken model for vitiligo

Smyth line (SL) chickens are phenotypically characterized by a posthatch depigmentation (vitiligo) of the feathers. The destruction of melanocytes in the feather follicle as well as in other tissues such as the choroid is genetically determined. Previous studies have shown that bursectomy or treatment with immunosuppressive agents decreases the incidence and severity of SL depigmentation (1). These observations implicate a role for the immune system, specifically the humoral component, in melanocyte destruction. In this study we show that there are circulating melanocyte-specific autoantibodies in the sera of depigmented SL chicks which are not present in sera from Light Brown Leghorn (LBL) control chicks. By immunoblots and by immunoprecipitation of radiolabeled melanocyte proteins, SL autoantibodies were shown to bind to multiple melanocyte proteins between 65 and 80 kDa. These proteins are not detected in SL fibroblasts. By immunoblotting, the incidence of autoantibodies for these 65- to 80-kDa proteins was determined to be 95% in depigmented SL chicks (n = 20), 0% in normally pigmented SL chicks (n = 8), and 5% in LBL chicks (n = 20). Melanocyte autoantibodies are detectable in the sera of affected chicks at or several weeks prior to the expression of depigmentation. This information, plus previously published data, implicate melanocyte autoantibodies in the depigmentary phenomenon of vitiligo observed in Smyth line chickens.

Target organ susceptibility and autoantibody production in an animal model of spontaneous autoimmune thyroiditis

F1-hybrids of Obese strain (OS) chickens, afflicted with spontaneous autoimmune thyroiditis (SAT), and normal, inbred CB chickens, do not develop severe thyroiditis. About 50% of these crosses show circulating autoantibodies to thyroglobulin (TgAAb), but the thyroid glands are only slightly infiltrated, suggesting that the target organ is not susceptible to autoimmune attack. In the present study we show that despite this mild infiltration TgAAb are only synthesized by lymphoid cells within the thyroid gland. Furthermore, we demonstrate that immunization with chicken thyroglobulin (Tg) in complete Freund's adjuvant causes severe experimental autoimmune thyroiditis (EAT) in F1(OSxCB) hybrids.

Molecular analysis of genetically determined target organ abnormalities in spontaneous autoimmune thyroiditis

We have shown in earlier studies, that the development of spontaneous autoimmune thyroiditis (SAT) in chickens of the Obese strain (OS) depends on the presence of both, two dominant genes coding for an altered immune regulation and one recessive gene responsible for the susceptibility of the target organ for the autoimmune attack. The product(s) of the latter is (are) still not known. The present study was aimed at identifying possible candidates of cellular components of the thyroid gland of OS chicken and its SAT susceptible parental Cornell C-strain (CS) by high resolution 2-dimensional (2D) gel electrophoresis. For this purpose organ cultures of the thyroid, bursa, thymus and liver were established and the synthesized polypeptides were labelled by 35S-methionine. OS and CS organs were compared with those of healthy normal White Leghorn (NWL) controls. The autoradiographs of the 2D-gels obtained from individual samples after various labelling periods were subjected to comparative analysis. We have found both quantitative and qualitative differences of polypeptide spots between OS/CS and NWL organ samples, some of them specific for the thyroid gland. Although one has to be aware that in this multidimensional analytical approach numerous, still elusive pattern differences are revealed, the thyroid specific phenomena will be further scrutinized.

Effects of gender and sex steroids on the immune response

Elevated immune responses and the higher incidence of autoimmune diseases in female (compared to male) humans and animals have been known for a long time. However, the scientific interest in this interrelationship has been limited both amongst immunologists and endocrinologists. It is mainly in the last ten years that investigations in this area have been intensifying. A number of fairly recent review articles confirm the increased interest in various aspects of this "interdiscipline" [1-4]. In the present paper we should like to make a new assessment of the state of knowledge. We shall firstly discuss heteroimmune response differences between males and females in humans, rodents and birds and then the roles of gender and sex hormones in autoimmune disease in various species. The general conclusions are the following. Gender and sex hormones have a clear effect on various hetero- and auto-immune responses but the mechanisms of action are still unknown; starting from sex hormones, steroids can be devised which have favourable effects on immune processes but lack undesirable hormonal effects; such hormonomimetics should be, in principle, applicable for the treatment of autoimmune disease.

Immunogenetic analysis of spontaneous autoimmune thyroiditis of obese strain chickens

A variety of immunological, endocrinological, and virological abnormalities have been implicated in the etiopathogenesis of spontaneous autoimmune thyroiditis (SAT) of Obese strain (OS) chickens, e.g., a general T cell hyperreactivity, an increased uptake of iodine into the thyroid gland, a diminution of the glucocorticoid tonus, and an OS-specific endogenous virus. In crosses of the close-bred OS B15/B15 subline with the inbred normal CB B12/B12 strain we have studied the mode of inheritance of these aberrations and their putative association with SAT. The results indicate that none of these OS-specific characteristics alone is an absolute prerequisite for the development of thyroid infiltration, which appears to be governed by one autosomal recessive gene.

Genetic analysis of extrathyroidal features of Obese strain (OS) chickens with spontaneous autoimmune thyroiditis

The Obese strain (OS) of chickens, which is afflicted with Hashimoto-like spontaneous autoimmune thyroiditis (SAT), displays elevated T cell proliferation, interleukin (IL)2 production and IL2 receptor expression upon mitogen stimulation, and defects in the neuroendocrine control of the immune system including elevated corticosteroid-binding globulin (CBG) and a deficient increase of serum corticosterone (CN) upon cytokine injection. Recently this strain has further been shown to harbor retrovirus-related sequences (endogenous virus no. 22, ev22) absent in healthy control strains. To determine the number of genes responsible for SAT-associated immunodysregulation and to unravel possible ev22 associations, we analyzed the above immune and endocrine parameters in F1 hybrids and backcrosses of the autoimmune OS B15B15 with healthy inbred CB B12B12 chickens. OS-like T cell hyperproliferation and IL2 hypersecretion in response to both concanavalin A and phytohemagglutinin were transmitted as autosomal dominant traits and co-segregated in backcross animals. In vivo hyporesponse of the OS to the corticosterone-inducing effect of cytokine preparations was inherited dominantly and the elevated CBG serum levels recessively. None of these traits appeared to be major histocompatibility complex (MHC) linked. However, while T cell abnormalities and elevated CBG serum levels were not associated with the autosomal ev22 locus, in vivo hyporesponsiveness to glucocortocoid-inducing cytokines co-segregated with this OS-specific provirus. These results add to the concept of SAT as a polyetiological and plurigenetic disease and do not support our previous hypothesis that T cell hyperreactivity and immunoendocrine dysfunction might be functionally related.