Comparative study of three methods of resuscitation: closed-chest, open-chest manual, and direct mechanical ventricular assistance

Cardiac arrest in the perioperative period: a consensus guideline for identification, treatment, and prevention from the European Society of Anaesthesiology and Intensive Care and the European Society for Trauma and Emergency Surgery

INTRODUCTION

Cardiac arrest in the operating room is a rare but potentially life-threatening event with mortality rates of more than 50%. Contributing factors are often known, and the event is recognised rapidly as patients are usually under full monitoring. This guideline covers the perioperative period and is complementary to the European Resuscitation Council guidelines.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

The European Society of Anaesthesiology and Intensive Care and the European Society for Trauma and Emergency Surgery jointly nominated a panel of experts to develop guidelines for the recognition, treatment, and prevention of cardiac arrest in the perioperative period. A literature search was conducted in MEDLINE, EMBASE, CINAHL and the Cochrane Central Register of Controlled Trials. All searches were restricted to publications from 1980 to 2019 inclusive and to the English, French, Italian and Spanish languages. The authors also contributed individual, independent literature searches.

RESULTS

This guideline contains background information and recommendation for the treatment of cardiac arrest in the operating room environment, and addresses controversial topics such as open chest cardiac massage, resuscitative endovascular balloon occlusion and resuscitative thoracotomy, pericardiocentesis, needle decompression, and thoracostomy.

CONCLUSIONS

Successful prevention and management of cardiac arrest during anaesthesia and surgery requires anticipation, early recognition, and a clear treatment plan. The ready availability of expert staff and equipment must also be taken into consideration. Success not only depends on medical knowledge, technical skills and a well-organised team using crew resource management, but also on an institutional safety culture embedded in everyday practice through continuous education, training, and multidisciplinary co-operation.

Cardiac arrest in the perioperative period: a consensus guideline for identification, treatment, and prevention from the European Society of Anaesthesiology and Intensive Care and the European Society for Trauma and Emergency Surgery

INTRODUCTION

Cardiac arrest in the operating room is a rare but potentially life-threatening event with mortality rates of more than 50%. Contributing factors are often known, and the event is recognised rapidly as patients are usually under full monitoring. This guideline covers the perioperative period and is complementary to the European Resuscitation Council (ERC) guidelines.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

The European Society of Anaesthesiology and Intensive Care and the European Society for Trauma and Emergency Surgery jointly nominated a panel of experts to develop guidelines for the recognition, treatment and prevention of cardiac arrest in the perioperative period. A literature search was conducted in MEDLINE, EMBASE, CINAHL and the Cochrane Central Register of Controlled Trials. All searches were restricted to publications from 1980 to 2019 inclusive and to the English, French, Italian and Spanish languages. The authors also contributed individual, independent literature searches.

RESULTS

This guideline contains background information and recommendation for the treatment of cardiac arrest in the operating room environment, and addresses controversial topics such as open chest cardiac massage (OCCM), resuscitative endovascular balloon occlusion (REBOA) and resuscitative thoracotomy, pericardiocentesis, needle decompression and thoracostomy.

CONCLUSION

Successful prevention and management of cardiac arrest during anaesthesia and surgery requires anticipation, early recognition and a clear treatment plan. The ready availability of expert staff and equipment must also be taken into consideration. Success not only depends on medical knowledge, technical skills and a well organised team using crew resource management but also on an institutional safety culture embedded in everyday practice through continuous education, training and multidisciplinary co-operation.

Left ventricular simulation of cardiac compression: Hemodynamics and regional mechanics

Heart failure is a global epidemic. Left ventricular assist devices provide added cardiac output for severe cases but cause infection and thromboembolism. Proposed direct cardiac compression devices eliminate blood contacting surfaces, but no group has optimized the balance between hemodynamic benefit and excessive ventricular wall strains and stresses. Here, we use left ventricular simulations to apply compressions and analyze hemodynamics as well as regional wall mechanics. This axisymmetric model corresponds with current symmetric bench prototypes. At nominal pressures of 3.1 kPa applied over the epicardial compression zone, hemodynamics improved substantially. Ejection fraction changed from 17.6% at baseline to 30.3% with compression and stroke work nearly doubled. Parametric studies were conducted by increasing and decreasing applied pressures; ejection fraction, peak pressure, and stroke work increased linearly with changes in applied compression. End-systolic volume decreased substantially. Regional mechanics analysis showed principal stress increases at the endocardium, in the middle of the compression region. Principal strains remained unchanged or increased moderately with nominal compression. However, at maximum applied compression, stresses and strains increased substantially providing potential constraints on allowable compressions. These results demonstrate a framework for analysis and optimization of cardiac compression as a prelude to biventricular simulations and subsequent animal experiments.

[Mechanical resuscitation assist devices]

In Germany 100,000-160,000 people suffer from out-of-hospital cardiac arrest (OHCA) annually. The incidence of cardiopulmonary resuscitation (CPR) after OHCA varies between emergency ambulance services but is in the range of 30-90 CPR attempts per 100,000 inhabitants per year. Basic life support (BLS) involving chest compressions and ventilation is the key measure of resuscitation. Rapid initiation and quality of BLS are the most critical factors for CPR success. Even healthcare professionals are not always able to ensure the quality of CPR measures. Consequently in recent years mechanical resuscitation devices have been developed to optimize chest compression and the resulting circulation. In this article the mechanical resuscitation devices currently available in Germany are discussed and evaluated scientifically in context with available literature. The ANIMAX CPR device should not be used outside controlled trials as no clinical results have so far been published. The same applies to the new device Corpuls CPR which will be available on the market in early 2014. Based on the current published data a general recommendation for the routine use of LUCAS™ and AutoPulse® CPR cannot be given. The preliminary data of the CIRC trial and the published data of the LINC trial revealed that mechanical CPR is apparently equivalent to good manual CPR. For the final assessment further publications of large randomized studies must be analyzed (e.g. the CIRC and PaRAMeDIC trials). However, case control studies, case series and small studies have already shown that in special situations and in some cases patients will benefit from the automatic mechanical resuscitation devices (LUCAS™, AutoPulse®). This applies especially to emergency services where standard CPR quality is far below average and for patients who require prolonged CPR under difficult circumstances. This might be true in cases of resuscitation due to hypothermia, intoxication and pulmonary embolism as well as for patients requiring transport or coronary intervention when cardiac arrest persists. Three prospective randomized studies and the resulting meta-analysis are available for active compression-decompression resuscitation (ACD-CPR) in combination with an impedance threshold device (ITD). These studies compared ACD-ITD-CPR to standard CPR and clearly demonstrated that ACD-ITD-CPR is superior to standard CPR concerning short and long-term survival with good neurological recovery after OHCA.

Monitoring of cerebral oxygen saturation during resuscitation in out-of-hospital cardiac arrest: a feasibility study in a physician staffed emergency medical system

Background

Despite recent advances in resuscitation algorithms, neurological injury after cardiac arrest due to cerebral ischemia and reperfusion is one of the reasons for poor neurological outcome. There is currently no adequate means of measuring cerebral perfusion during cardiac arrest. It was the aim of this study to investigate the feasibility of measuring near infrared spectroscopy (NIRS) as a potential surrogate parameter for cerebral perfusion in patients with out-of-hospital resuscitations in a physician-staffed emergency medical service.

Methods

An emergency physician responding to out-of-hospital emergencies was equipped with a NONIN cerebral oximetry device. Cerebral oximetry values (rSO₂) were continuously recorded during resuscitation and transport. Feasibility was defined as >80% of total achieved recording time in relation to intended recording time.

Results

10 patients were prospectively enrolled. In 89.8% of total recording time, rSO₂ values could be recorded (213 minutes and 20 seconds), thus meeting feasibility criteria. 3 patients experienced return of spontaneous circulation (ROSC). rSO₂ during manual cardiopulmonary resuscitation (CPR) was lower in patients who did not experience ROSC compared to the 3 patients with ROSC (31.6%, ± 7.4 versus 37.2% ± 17.0). ROSC was associated with an increase in rSO₂. Decrease of rSO₂ indicated occurrence of re-arrest in 2 patients. In 2 patients a mechanical chest compression device was used. rSO₂ values during mechanical compression were increased by 12.7% and 19.1% compared to manual compression.

Conclusions

NIRS monitoring is feasible during resuscitation of patients with out-of-hospital cardiac arrest and can be a useful tool during resuscitation, leading to an earlier detection of ROSC and re-arrest. Higher initial rSO₂ values during CPR seem to be associated with the occurrence of ROSC. The use of mechanical chest compression devices might result in higher rSO₂. These findings need to be confirmed by larger studies.

Compression of the left ventricular outflow tract during cardiopulmonary resuscitation

OBJECTIVES

This prospective observational study was performed to investigate if the hand position used for external chest compressions is in an optimal position for compressing the ventricles during standard cardiopulmonary resuscitation (CPR).

METHODS

Transesophageal echocardiography (TEE) was performed during standard CPR in 34 patients with nontraumatic cardiac arrest (24 males, mean +/- standard deviation [SD] age = 56 +/- 12 years). On the recorded image of TEE, an area of maximal compression (AMC) was identified, and the degree of compression at the AMC and the left ventricular stroke volume was calculated.

RESULTS

A significant narrowing of the left ventricular outflow tract (LVOT) or the aorta was noted in all patients, with the degree of compression at the AMC ranging from 19% to 83% (mean +/- SD = 49 +/- 19%). The AMC was found at the aorta in 20 patients (59%) and at the LVOT in 14 patients (41%). A significant narrowing of more than 50% of the diameter at the end of the relaxation phase occurred in 15 patients (44%). On linear regression, the left ventricular stroke volume was correlated with the location of the AMC (R(2) = 0.165, p = 0.017).

CONCLUSIONS

The outflow of the left ventricle is affected during standard CPR, resulting in varying degrees of narrowing in the LVOT and/or the aortic root.

Emergency department thoracotomy for the critically injured patient: Objectives, indications, and outcomes

In the past three decades there has been a significant clinical shift in the performance of emergency department thoracotomy (EDT), from a nearly obligatory procedure before declaring any trauma patient to select patients undergoing EDT. The value of EDT in resuscitation of the patient in profound shock but not yet dead is unquestionable. Its indiscriminate use, however, renders it a low-yield and high-cost procedure. Overall analysis of the available literature indicates that the success of EDT approximates 35% in the patient arriving in shock with a penetrating cardiac wound, and 15% for all penetrating wounds. Conversely, patient outcome is relatively poor when EDT is done for blunt trauma; 2% survival in patients in shock and less than 1% survival with no vital signs. Patients undergoing CPR upon arrival to the emergency department should be stratified based upon injury and transport time to determine the utility of EDT. The optimal application of EDT requires a thorough understanding of its physiologic objectives, technical maneuvers, and the cardiovascular and metabolic consequences.

Are US informed consent requirements driving resuscitation research overseas?

Following a 2-year federally imposed moratorium on acute resuscitation research due to concern regarding the inability of patients in cardiac arrest to provide prospective, informed consent to participate in such research, the United States federal government in 1996 released regulations with provisions for exemption of prospective informed consent in certain types of emergency research. While very few acute resuscitation research studies have been attempted in the United States since that time, such research has continued overseas. We discuss one large multi-center, out-of-hospital trial of a device intended to improve the hemodynamics of cardiopulmonary resuscitation. After pilot implementation overseas, this trial could not be conducted in the United States, largely due to the difficulties and costs involved in implementing the requirements of the 1996 regulations. A recent European Union directive on the conduct of clinical trials may halt European research on patients who are unable to provide prospective, informed consent. The directive contains no provisions for exceptions or waiver of informed consent, and may hinder acute resuscitation research in Europe to an even greater degree than the 1996 regulations have in the United States.

Open-chest CPR improves survival and neurologic outcome following cardiac arrest

STUDY OBJECTIVE

To determine if 15 min of open-chest cardiac massage (OC-CPR) versus closed-chest compressions (CC-CPR) improves 72-h survival and neurologic outcome (behavioral and histologic) after 5 min of untreated cardiac arrest.

METHODS

Mongrel dogs were anesthetized and instrumented. Cardiac arrest was induced by KCl injection and after a 5-min period of non-intervention, dogs were randomized to receive either CC-CPR (N = 7) or OC-CPR (N = 5) performed for 15 min. The dogs were then resuscitated and physiologic data was recorded. Surviving dogs were scored at 72 h using canine neurodeficit score of Safar et al. (NDS; 0 = behaviorally normal, 500 = brain death). Dogs that could not be resuscitated or died before 72 h were assigned a score of 500. Brain histology was performed on all survivors.

RESULTS

All OC-CPR dogs were successfully resuscitated and were behaviorally normal at 72 h (NDS = 0). Histology in OC-CPR dogs showed little to no injury. Only three out of the seven CC-CPR dogs survived to 72 h. Of the survivors, one dog exhibited minor ataxia (NDS = 15), and two had incapacitating deficits (both NDS = 180). Two dogs died within 24 h after extubation, and one could not be resuscitated and the other could not be weaned from the ventilator (each NDS = 500). Histology of the CC-CPR survivors revealed moderate to severe lesions. NDS between groups was statistically significant (p < 0.0079).

CONCLUSION

In our canine model of cardiac arrest, OC-CPR significantly improved 72-h survival and neurologic outcome when compared to CC-CPR.

Open-Chest Cardiopulmonary Resuscitation after Cardiac Arrest in Cases of Blunt Chest or Abdominal Trauma: A Consecutive Series of 38 Cases

BACKGROUND

According to the literature, the overall outcome in a patient population with chest or abdominal injury with initial cardiac arrest has to be rated as poor. In cases of penetrating injuries, open-chest cardiopulmonary resuscitation (CPR) has been recommended as a treatment option to improve the survival rate. The aim of this study was to prove equal outcome for patients with blunt chest or abdominal trauma.

METHODS

During a 5-year period, a consecutive patient series admitted to an urban Level I trauma center was examined. Only patients with blunt trauma and witnessed cardiac arrest, who had a documented, uninterrupted closed-chest CPR (CCCPR) of less than 20 minutes were included in this study (n=38). Exclusion criteria were age over 70 years, penetrating injuries, CCCPR of more than 20 minutes, as well as nonprofessional bystander resuscitation.

RESULTS

Four of 38 patients survived. In comparison with the group of nonsurvivors, both groups showed a similar age and gender ratio (mean age, 28, 32, respectively). The mean Injury Severity Scale was 54 (range, 42-66) in the survivor group and 66 (range, 29-75) in the nonsurvivor group, respectively. The time of CCCPR was on average 13 minutes (range, 11-15 minutes) for the survivors and 16 minutes (range, 1-20 minutes) for the nonsurvivors.

CONCLUSION

Patients with blunt trunk trauma and cardiac arrest after hemorrhagic shock may benefit from open-chest CPR with the same probability as shown for patients with penetrating injuries. This is especially true if the procedure is started as soon as possible, but at the latest within 20 minutes after initial CCCPR.

Selective aortic arch perfusion with hemoglobin-based oxygen carrier-201 for resuscitation from exsanguinating cardiac arrest in swine

OBJECTIVE

The prospects for resuscitation after blunt traumatic cardiac arrest are dismal. Selective aortic arch perfusion (SAAP) with a hemoglobin-based oxygen carrier (HBOC-201) offers a potentially effective therapy. This study evaluated the acute cardiovascular and metabolic effects of SAAP with HBOC-201 in an exsanguination model of cardiac arrest.

DESIGN

Randomized, controlled, laboratory investigation.

SETTING

University research laboratory.

SUBJECTS

Domestic swine, 25-39 kg.

INTERVENTIONS

Partial resection of four liver lobes rapidly led to profound hemorrhagic shock and subsequent cardiac arrest at 10-13 mins. At 15 mins, swine were randomized to receive either SAAP with oxygenated lactated Ringer's (LR) solution (n = 6) or SAAP with oxygenated HBOC-201 (n = 6) at a rate of 10 mL x kg(-1) x min(-1) until return of spontaneous circulation with a mean aortic pressure of 60 mm Hg (8.0 kPa) was achieved. Epinephrine (0.005 mg/kg) was given via intra-aortic route every 30 secs as needed to promote return of spontaneous circulation beginning at 18 mins after onset of liver injury (3 mins after beginning SAAP).

MEASUREMENTS AND MAIN RESULTS

Mean aortic pressure, cardiac output, total blood loss, and time of arrest were similar for both groups before SAAP therapy. In the SAAP-HBOC group, return of spontaneous circulation with a sustained mean aortic pressure of 60 mm Hg (8.0 kPa) was achieved in six of six swine at 1.9 +/- 0.3 mins of SAAP, and none of these swine required epinephrine. In the SAAP-LR group, no swine (from a total of six) achieved return of spontaneous circulation before intra-aortic epinephrine administration, and only two of six swine had brief return of spontaneous circulation with an mean aortic pressure of 60 mm Hg (8.0 kPa) after intra-aortic epinephrine that was sustained for <10 mins. One-hour survival was five of six in the SAAP-HBOC group and none of six in the SAAP-LR group (p <.05, Fisher's exact test).

CONCLUSION

SAAP with oxygenated HBOC-201 rapidly restored viable cardiovascular function after exsanguinating cardiac arrest in this swine model of liver injury with profound hemorrhagic shock.

Open chest cardiopulmonary resuscitation in out-of-hospital cardiac arrest

Because closed chest cardiopulmonary resuscitation (CCCPR) achieve restoration of spontaneous circulation (ROSC) in less than 50% of cases, and because of the apparent physiological superiority of open-chest cardiopulmonary resuscitation (OCCPR), we evaluated OCCPR in out-of hospital cardiac arrest in cases who did not respond to standard external cardiopulmonary resuscitation with advanced life support. Over a period of 12 years, OCCPR was performed in 33 patients with out-of-hospital cardiac arrest arising from different causes, after unsuccessful attempts to achieve ROSC with CCCPR efforts over 7-121 min (median 25 min). With OCCPR, ROSC was achieved in 13/33 patients. Of these, two recovered to discharge (one with no neurological deficit and one with mild brain damage). The other 11 rearrested either in the emergency department after a median period of 70 min of resuscitation, or in the intensive care unit after a median period of 104 h. One case of iatrogenic cardiac injury was observed. The OCCPR attempts were well accepted by the public. Our data suggest that OCCPR is more effective than CCCPR in achieving ROSC outside hospital in patients with major cardiac disease and prolonged arrest. OCCPR is feasible in the out-of-hospital setting. Survival without neurological deficit cannot be expected when CCCPR with no-flow is continued beyond 25 min.

Selective aortic arch perfusion using serial infusions of perflubron emulsion

OBJECTIVE

To determine whether selective aortic arch perfusion (SAAP) using serial infusions of oxygenated perflubron emulsion combined with aortic epinephrine (AoE) administration is more effective than conventional therapy in treating cardiac arrest.

METHODS

An experimental cardiac arrest model (10 min ventricular fibrillation and 2 min CPR) was used with 12 mixed-breed canines, randomized into 2 groups: control (n = 6), CPR and IV epinephrine, 0.01 mg/kg, at 12 min and then every 3 min; or AoE-SAAP (n = 6), CPR and aortic epinephrine, 0.01 mg/kg, at 12 min and then every 3 min, and serial SAAP with oxygenated 60% weight/volume (w/v) perflubron emulsion as follows: 300 mL over 30 sec at 12 min as continuous SAAP without CPR; 150 mL over 20-30 sec at 15 min and 18 min as pulsed diastolic SAAP during CPR.

RESULTS

AoE-SAAP resulted in increased coronary perfusion pressure (CPP) and return of spontaneous circulation (ROSC) compared with control. CPR-diastolic (release phase) CPP during pulsed diastolic SAAP was similar to or greater in magnitude than the CPP generated during the initial SAAP infusion without CPR. ROSC for control was 0/6 and for AoE-SAAP was 4/6 (p < 0.05, Fisher's exact test). Time from initiation of CPR to ROSC with a sustained systolic aortic pressure > 60 mm Hg was 8.0 +/- 1.2 min in the 4 resuscitated AoE-SAAP animals.

CONCLUSION

The combination of AoE with SAAP infusions of oxygenated perflubron emulsion was more effective than conventional resuscitation therapy. Pulsed diastolic SAAP is a promising method for performing SAAP.

Open-chest cardiac massage without major thoracotomy: metabolic indicators of coronary and cerebral perfusion

OBJECTIVE

To compare the coronary and cerebral perfusion achieved using a novel method of minimally-invasive, direct cardiac massage to that obtained using bimanual, open-chest cardiac massage.

DESIGN

Prospective, controlled animal study with repeated measures.

SETTING

University research laboratory.

SUBJECTS

Large domestic swine.

INTERVENTIONS

Aortic, coronary sinus, jugular venous and pulmonary artery catheters were placed. Following an equilibration period, ventricular fibrillation was induced. After 4 min of untreated ventricular fibrillation, animals underwent bimanual, open-chest cardiac massage (N = 6) or minimally-invasive, direct cardiac massage using a novel device for direct cardiac compression (N = 6). Adrenaline was administered at a dose of 1 mg intravenously every 5 min.

MEASUREMENTS

Systemic metabolic parameters, (arterial PO2, PCO2 and lactate concentration) and coronary sinus and jugular venous metabolic parameters (pH, PVO2, SVO2, PVCO2 and lactate concentration) were measured and calculated (coronary sinus/jugular-arterial SVO2, coronary sinus/jugular-arterial PCO2 and lactate differences) at baseline and at 10, 20 and 30 min following induction of ventricular fibrillation. Animals were euthanised after 30 min with no attempt at defibrillation.

MAIN RESULTS

Oxygen tension and oxygen saturation of coronary sinus blood declined significantly during the experimental period, but no differences were noted between treatment groups. The coronary sinus-arterial oxygen saturation difference increased during the study with no significant differences between groups. Coronary sinus PCO2 and the coronary sinus-arterial PCO2 difference increased significantly in both experimental groups during cardiac massage. No inter-group differences were noted. A similar relationship was noted in coronary sinus lactate values. The coronary sinus-arterial lactate difference displayed a positive balance at all intervals with no differences noted between group values. The oxygen tension and oxygen saturation of jugular venous blood, were reduced from baseline levels with both treatments. The jugular-arterial oxygen saturation difference increased in both groups compared to baseline values. Between group values were significantly different only at the 20 min interval. Both the jugular venous PCO2 and the jugular-arterial PCO2 gradient were elevated at all intervals, but no inter-group differences were noted. Jugular venous lactate concentration rose steadily with time in both groups. No significant increase in the jugular-arterial lactate gradient was noted at any time point.

CONCLUSIONS

Minimally-invasive, direct cardiac massage provides coronary and cerebral perfusion similar to that achieved using standard open-chest cardiac massage. This method may provide a more effective substitute for standard, closed-chest cardiac massage in cases of refractory cardiac arrest.

Selective aortic arch perfusion during cardiac arrest: enhanced resuscitation using oxygenated perflubron emulsion, with and without aortic arch epinephrine

STUDY OBJECTIVE

To evaluate selective aortic arch perfusion (SAAP) with an oxygenated fluorocarbon emulsion, with and without aortic arch epinephrine during cardiac arrest.

METHODS

This randomized, controlled study, undertaken at a university research laboratory, involved 15 mixed-breed dogs. After 10 minutes of ventricular fibrillation and 30 seconds of CPR, the dogs were randomized to three groups, each comprising five dogs. Group 1 (controls) dogs were given CPR and intravenous epinephrine, .01 mg/kg, at 10.5 minutes and then every 3 minutes. Group 2 dogs (IVE-SAAP) were treated with CPR and intravenous epinephrine (IVE) in the same fashion as the control group but were also subjected to SAAP with 275 mL of oxygenated 60% wt/vol perflubron emulsion over 30 seconds. Group 3 dogs (AoE-SAAP) received the same treatment as the IVE-SAAP group, except that the first epinephrine dose was given intraaortically.

RESULTS

Coronary perfusion pressure (CPP) increased during SAAP in both the IVE-SAAP and AoE-SAAP groups but was greater in the AoE-SAAP group. CPR diastolic CPP after SAAP was significantly greater in the AoE-SAAP group than in the control group. Return of spontaneous circulation (ROSC) occurred in two control dogs, all five IVE-SAAP dogs, and all five AoE-SAAP dogs. The time elapsed from the initiation of CPR to ROSC was 6.1 +/- 1.9 minutes in the AoE-SAAP group, compared with 11.0 +/- 5.8 minutes in the IVE-SAAP group.

CONCLUSION

SAAP with oxygenated perflubron emulsion improved ROSC, both with and without aortic arch epinephrine. The combination of SAAP with perflubron emulsion and aortic arch epinephrine resulted in higher CPP and more rapid ROSC.

Sodium bicarbonate in cardiac arrest: a reappraisal

The routine use of sodium bicarbonate in patients with cardiac arrest has been discouraged, with the benefit of outcome evaluation. Current recommendations include an elaborate stratification of circumstances in which bicarbonate is to be used. The physiological and clinical aspects of bicarbonate administration during cardiopulmonary resuscitation in animal and human studies were reviewed. The onset of significant acidemia or alkalemia is associated with adverse system specific effects. The administration of bicarbonate may mitigate the adverse physiological effects of acidemia, improve response to exogenously administered vasopressor agents, or simply increase venous return due to an osmolar effect, resulting in increased coronary perfusion pressure. Likewise, bicarbonate may have adverse effects in each of these areas. The preponderance of evidence suggests that bicarbonate is not detrimental and may be helpful to outcome from cardiac arrest. An objective reappraisal of the empirical use of bicarbonate or other buffer agents in the appropriate "therapeutic window" for cardiac patients may be warranted.

A physical analog of the failing left ventricle for in vitro studies of mechanical wall actuation

Mechanical repowering of a failing heart with devices or skeletal muscle could circumvent blood-pump lining problems. Requirements are complex: indefinite support with preservation of valve competence and coronary flow, avoidance of wall coaptation, and allowance of both rapid low impedance refilling and independent left and right pressures. An accurate in vitro physical failing-heart analog could facilitate the choice and screening of surgical and engineering approaches in mock circulation experiments. Prosthetic models, transplant recipient hearts, normal animal hearts, existing in vivo animal failure models, and failing cadaver hearts all have serious limitations. One hundred and four excised porcine hearts were dilated and fixed by three iterative protocols. Geometric and passive mechanical parameters were assessed and compared with targets expected for an end-stage failing heart. For Protocol 3, Subgroup 2 (reinforcing valve support, dilatation by compliant ventricular balloon, and ethyl alcohol fixation), the left ventricular shape and capacity (ellipsoid, 201-377 ml/500 g of heart weight), passive valve function, wall flexural rigidity (Et3 range 0.101-0.331 Nm), and refilling mechanics (99 +/- 17.46 ml during 200-400 ms at < or = 10 mm Hg transmural gradient) were all within goal criteria.

Direct cardiac massage without major thoracotomy: feasibility and systemic blood flow

BACKGROUND

Open-chest cardiac massage (OC-CM) provides higher blood pressure and flow than closed-chest compression and may improve the probability of successful resuscitation from cardiac arrest. Its clinical use has been limited by its requirement for a major thoracotomy. The present pilot study tested the technical feasibility of performing effective direct cardiac massage without a major thoracic incision, by using a simple, manually-powered plunger-like device, inserted through a small thoracic incision, to cyclically compress the cardiac ventricles. The method was termed minimally-invasive direct cardiac massage (MID-CM). Systemic blood flow using MID-CM was compared to that with OC-CM, by both direct systemic hemodynamic measurements, cumulative metabolic indicators of the ratio of whole body oxygen delivery and oxygen consumption, and a metabolic index of pulmonary blood flow.

METHODS

In 12 large swine, baseline systemic and pulmonary hemodynamic measurements were performed. Arterial and mixed venous blood gases and metabolic indicators of systemic blood flow were measured. Ventricular fibrillation was induced and after 4 min, animals underwent either bimanual OC-CM (N = 6) or MID-CM (N = 6). At 10, 20 and 30 min, hemodynamic and metabolic measurements were repeated.

RESULTS

Systemic Blood Pressure: Aortic systolic and diastolic blood pressures were reduced from baseline levels with both OC-CM and MID-CM. No difference in pressure was noted between OC-CM and MID-CM groups. Pulmonary Artery Pressure: Pulmonary artery systolic pressure was elevated from baseline during OC-CM and MID-CM. Pulmonary artery diastolic pressures remained constant throughout the resuscitation period in both groups. No differences in pulmonary systolic or diastolic pressure were noted between OC-CM and MID-CM groups. A trend towards higher pulmonary systolic pressures appeared with MID-CM. Thermodilution Blood Flow: Cardiac index fell from baseline levels with OC-CM and MID-CM. No difference in cardiac index was noted between OC-CM and MID-CM groups. Metabolic Indices: Mixed venous O2 saturation decreased from baseline levels during resuscitation in both experimental groups, with a further decrease at 30 min compared to 10- and 20-min levels. No difference was noted between OC-CM and MID-CM groups at any point. Arterial pH was reduced from baseline levels at 30 min in both groups compared to baseline but no difference was noted between groups.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)

A technique revisited: hemodynamic comparison of closed- and open-chest cardiac massage during human cardiopulmonary resuscitation

OBJECTIVE

To compare the hemodynamics of closed-chest cardiac massage vs. open-chest cardiac massage in patients resuscitated from cardiac arrest that occurred outside of the hospital.

DESIGN

Prospective, non-outcome, case series.

SETTING

Large urban emergency department.

PATIENTS

Ten adult, normothermic, nontraumatic, out-of-hospital, cardiac arrest patients who failed advanced cardiac life support (ACLS) therapy.

INTERVENTIONS

Patients presenting to the hospital in cardiac arrest were managed according to the ACLS protocol at the clinician's discretion. Proximal aortic and central venous pressure catheters were placed to measure arteriovenous compression- and relaxation-phase pressure gradients. After 5 mins of baseline measurements during closed-chest cardiac massage, patients underwent a left lateral thoracotomy, and open-chest cardiac massage was performed for 5 mins.

MEASUREMENTS AND MAIN RESULTS

The mean coronary perfusion pressure and compression-phase pressure gradients were 7.3 +/- 5.7 and 6.2 +/- 5.4 mm Hg, respectively, during closed-chest cardiac massage, while increasing to 32.6 +/- 17.8 and 32.6 +/- 29.9 mm Hg, respectively, during open-chest cardiac massage. The differences between both measurements were statistically significant (p < .05).

CONCLUSIONS

Open-chest cardiac massage is superior to closed-chest cardiac massage in providing relaxation-phase and compression-phase pressure gradients during cardiac arrest in patients failing current ACLS protocols. During open-chest cardiac massage, all patients exceeded the minimum coronary perfusion pressure of 15 mm Hg, which is recommended to obtain a return of spontaneous circulation. Further outcome studies are needed to determine the timeliness and appropriate indications for open-chest cardiac massage.

Sodium bicarbonate may improve outcome in dogs with brief or prolonged cardiac arrest

OBJECTIVE

Despite the absence of outcome evaluation, the use of sodium bicarbonate in cardiac arrest has declined based on advanced cardiac life-support guidelines. The effects of bicarbonate therapy on outcome in a canine model of ventricular fibrillation cardiac arrest of brief (5-min) and prolonged (15-min) duration were examined.

DESIGN

Prospective, randomized, controlled trial.

SETTING

Experimental animal laboratory in a university medical center.

SUBJECTS

Thirty-two adult dogs, weighing 10 to 17 kg.

INTERVENTIONS

The animals were prepared with ketamine, nitrous oxide/oxygen, halothane, and pancuronium. Ventricular fibrillation was then electrically induced and maintained in arrest for 5 mins (n = 12) or 15 mins (n = 20). Canine advanced cardiac life-support protocols were instituted, including defibrillation, cardiopulmonary resuscitation (CPR), and the administration of epinephrine (0.1 mg/kg), atropine, and lidocaine. The bicarbonate group received 1 mmol/kg of sodium bicarbonate initially, and base deficit was corrected to -5 mmol/L with additional bicarbonate, whereas acidemia was untreated in the control group. Cardiopulmonary values were recorded at intervals between 5 mins and 24 hrs, and the neurologic deficit score was determined at 24 hrs after CPR.

MEASUREMENTS AND MAIN RESULTS

The treatment group received an additional 2 to 3 mmol/kg of bicarbonate in the early postresuscitation phase. Compared with controls, the bicarbonate group demonstrated equivalent (with brief arrest) or improved (with prolonged arrest) return of spontaneous circulation and survival to 24 hrs, with lessened neurologic deficit. The acidosis of arrest was decreased in the prolonged arrest group without hypercarbia. Improved coronary and systemic perfusion pressures were noted in the bicarbonate group with prolonged arrest, and the epinephrine requirement for return of spontaneous circulation was decreased.

CONCLUSIONS

The empirical administration of bicarbonate improves the survival rate and neurologic outcome in a canine model of cardiac arrest.

Selective aortic arch perfusion during cardiac arrest: a new resuscitation technique

STUDY OBJECTIVES

To demonstrate the technique of selective aortic arch perfusion during cardiac arrest and to observe the hemodynamic effects of volume infusion and aortic epinephrine administration.

DESIGN

Sequential series, nonrandomized, noncontrolled.

TYPE OF PARTICIPANTS

Fourteen mongrel dogs weighing 21 to 36 kg.

INTERVENTIONS

Animals had midaortic arch pressure, right atrial pressure, and descending aortic arch balloon occlusion catheters placed. After ten minutes of ventricular fibrillation, balloon inflation and aortic arch infusions were initiated as follows: group 1 (six), 30 mL/kg/min of 0.9% NaCl for two minutes; group 2 (four), 30 mL/kg/min of oxygenated lactated Ringer's with 2 mg/L epinephrine for two minutes, followed by CPR; and group 3 (four), 20 mL/kg/min of oxygenated perfluorochemicals with 4 mg/L epinephrine for one minute, then CPR.

MEASUREMENTS AND MAIN RESULTS

Midaortic arch pressure, right atrial pressure, and coronary perfusion pressure each rose significantly in all groups. Midaortic arch pressure and coronary perfusion pressure increases were greater in groups 2 and 3 than in group 1. In groups 1 and 2, right atrial pressure increases at end-selective aortic arch perfusion were excessive as midaortic arch pressure and right atrial pressure increased linearly and similarly after 20 to 30 seconds. In groups 2 and 3, CPR-diastolic midaortic arch pressure and coronary perfusion pressure after selective aortic arch perfusion were good and similar to midaortic arch pressure and coronary perfusion pressure at end-selective aortic arch perfusion.

CONCLUSION

Selective aortic arch perfusion is technically feasible, but excessive right atrial pressure increases limit maximal infusion rates and volumes. Selective aortic arch perfusion infusates with epinephrine produce greater midaortic arch pressure and coronary perfusion pressure during infusion than infusate without epinephrine. Controlled studies are needed to determine if selective aortic arch perfusion improves resuscitation outcome.

Regional cerebral blood flow with manual internal cardiac massage versus direct mechanical ventricular assistance

STUDY HYPOTHESIS

Previous studies have not discerned the best method for generating regional cerebral blood flow during internal cardiac massage. We hypothesized that regional cerebral blood flow generated by a mechanical method--direct mechanical ventricular assistance (DMVA)--would be superior to manual internal cardiac massage (MAN).

STUDY POPULATION

Twelve adult Yucatan minipigs weighing more than 44 kg each were studied.

METHODS

Swine were instrumented for regional cerebral blood flow measurements using tracer microspheres. After 15 minutes of ventricular fibrillation, swine were randomized to receive either MAN or DMVA. Regional cerebral blood flow was measured during normal sinus rhythm and at one minute (VF-1) and six minutes (VF-2) after initiation of circulatory support. Regional cerebral blood flow values were compared using a Wilcoxon rank sum test.

RESULTS

During VF-1, there was a tendency for DMVA to produce greater regional cerebral blood flow than MAN, although these differences were not statistically significant (DMVA vs MAN as mL/min/100 g): cerebral cortex, 28 versus 11; cerebellum, 49 versus 22; midbrain, 43 versus 16; pons, 55 versus 18; medulla, 55 versus 19; and spinal cord, 33 versus 10. During VF-2, DMVA produced greater regional cerebral blood flows than were produced by MAN: cerebral cortex, 39 versus 12 (P less than .06); cerebellum, 58 versus 20 (P less than 0.5); midbrain, 50 versus 18 (P less than .05); pons, 52 versus 22 (P less than .06); medulla, 53 versus 20 (P less than .05); and spinal cord, 31 versus 12 (P less than .05).

CONCLUSION

DMVA produces greater regional cerebral blood flow than is produced during MAN after 15 minutes of ventricular fibrillation. DMVA is effective at maintaining regional cerebral blood flow after a prolonged cardiac arrest.

Limitations of open-chest cardiac massage after prolonged, untreated cardiac arrest in dogs

STUDY OBJECTIVES

Open-chest cardiac massage is an effective method of resuscitation if instituted within 15 minutes of normothermic cardiac arrest that has failed to respond to ongoing closed-chest CPR efforts. The usefulness of invasive forms of CPR after various periods of untreated cardiac arrest is less certain. This study was performed to determine the effectiveness of open-chest resuscitation after prolonged periods of untreated cardiac arrest.

SETTING AND DESIGN

Prospective, controlled laboratory investigation using an animal model of cardiac arrest. Open-chest cardiac massage initially was compared to standard closed-chest compression CPR. The efficacy of open-chest CPR then was evaluated after ten and 40 minutes of untreated ventricular fibrillation.

TYPE OF PARTICIPANTS

Twenty mongrel dogs (24 +/- 1 kg).

MEASUREMENTS AND MAIN RESULTS

After 20 minutes of untreated ventricular fibrillation, open-chest resuscitation was significantly better than closed-chest efforts for the production of coronary perfusion pressure (58 +/- 14 vs 2 +/- 1 mm Hg; P less than .05) and initial resuscitation success (five of five vs one of five; P less than .03). Open-chest cardiac massage was equally effective for initial resuscitation if begun after ten or 20 minutes of untreated ventricular fibrillation (five of five vs five of five), but if untreated ventricular fibrillation continued for 40 minutes prior to instituting open-chest massage, no resuscitation benefit was found (none of five; P less than .005). There were marked differences in 24-hour survival depending on the length of time untreated cardiac arrest continued prior to instituting open-chest resuscitation efforts. After 20 minutes of ventricular fibrillation, initial resuscitation was successful with open-chest massage, but long-term survival was poor.

CONCLUSION

Open-chest cardiac massage did not produce long-term survival if untreated cardiac arrest persisted for 20 or more minutes prior to invasive resuscitation efforts.

Direct mechanical ventricular actuation for cardiac arrest in humans. A clinical feasibility trial

Direct mechanical ventricular actuation (DMVA) is a non-blood-contacting method of biventricular cardiac massage which may be applied expediently for total circulatory support. The purpose of this study was to assess the feasibility of DMVA application for patients suffering refractory cardiac arrest. Following informed consent, DMVA was applied in 22 patients. Vascular access for hemodynamic monitoring was possible in only 12 patients, whose outcomes serve as the basis for this report. The mean age of the patients was 48.2 +/- 4.2 years (seven men; five women). The average time from witnessed cardiac arrest to DMVA application was 81 +/- 9 minutes. Application took less than two minutes from the time of skin incision and resulted in immediate hemodynamic improvement. Systolic and diastolic blood pressures averaged 78 +/- 4 and 41 +/- 4 mm Hg, respectively, with a mean cardiac output of 3.14 +/- 0.18 L/min during a mean of 228 +/- 84 minutes of circulatory support (range, 25 minutes to 18 hours). In selected cases the device was temporarily removed for 2 to 3 minutes and open-chest cardiac massage (OCCM) performed at similar compression rates. DMVA increased arterial pressures 65 percent and cardiac output 190 percent compared to OCCM. Initial arterial pH (7.12 +/- 0.04) improved by the time the device was removed (7.24 +/- 0.05). Serum lactate levels decreased from 18.0 +/- 2.3 mumol/L to 14.9 +/- 2.9 mumol/L. Four patients were successfully defibrillated: two had inadequate cardiac function and died within 1 h, and two were successfully resuscitated, but later died from cardiac failure and respiratory insufficiency. Another patient regained normal neurologic function during DMVA and was successfully bridged to cardiopulmonary bypass for emergent coronary artery bypass grafting, but died later from myocardial infarction. There were only two complications: (1) a cardiac laceration during pericardiotomy (1/22 patients); and (2) a ventricular rupture during OCCM (1/22). No complication resulted from the device. We found DMVA to be a feasible method for acute cardiovascular stabilization in victims suffering refractory cardiac arrest. Human clinical trials employing earlier DMVA application are required to determine its resuscitative potential.

Open-chest cardiac massage. The possible rebirth of an old procedure

Open-chest cardiac massage was widely and successfully used for many decades before its virtual abandonment 25 years ago. Both experimental evidence and basic physiologic evidence indicate that it has many advantages over closed-chest massage (especially increased cardiac output). Both resuscitation techniques have specific and unique advantages and disadvantages: They are not mutually exclusive. However, significant increases in rates of survival after cardiac arrest cannot be expected with variations of closed-chest cardiac massage and standard advanced life support services. Therefore, physicians must be willing to support controlled human studies that can definitively determine the proper role of each in resuscitation after cardiac arrest.

Open cardiac resuscitation. A surgeon's viewpoint

Open cardiac massage yields better hemodynamic results in the laboratory than does closed cardiac massage. However, reported survival rates with the two methods are similar, except in postcardiotomy patients and patients with penetrating injury. Implementation of resuscitation within several minutes of cardiac arrest is far more important than the specific method used. Closed cardiac massage can be instituted more universally and more quickly than open massage and thus should remain the mainstay of cardiac resuscitation. Open cardiac massage can be performed by trained surgical personnel in appropriate situations.

Hemodynamic effects of the intra-aortic balloon pump during experimental cardiac arrest

The low flow states and limited coronary perfusion provided by conventional cardiopulmonary resuscitation (CPR) have prompted investigations into alternative, more invasive, methods of resuscitation. Previous case reports and limited animal evidence have suggested that the intra-aortic balloon pump (IABP) may have a role in resuscitation. We used a canine cardiac arrest model to study the hemodynamic effects of the IABP during closed-chest CPR. A sensor attached to the chest plate of a Thumper was used to time a Datascope Model 3520 ventricular assist console such that the balloon inflated on the upstroke and deflated on the downstroke of the Thumper. There was no increase in systolic blood pressure with the balloon pump. Diastolic blood pressure and coronary perfusion pressure were significantly higher with the IABP. Circulation times were shorter and end-tidal CO2 was higher with the IABP. It was concluded that the IABP improves hemodynamic parameters during experimental cardiac arrest.

Long-term survival with open-chest cardiac massage after ineffective closed-chest compression in a canine preparation

The ultimate goal of cardiopulmonary resuscitation (CPR) is long-term, neurologically intact survival. This study examined whether open-chest cardiac massage could improve 7 day survival and neurologic function when instituted after the failure of standard closed-chest compression CPR. Twenty-nine mongrel dogs were anesthetized and then instrumented with catheters to monitor right atrial and ascending aortic pressures. Ventricular fibrillation was induced and after 3 min standard CPR was begun. Standard CPR was performed with a Thumper programmed for 2 inch chest compressions at 60/min with a 50% duty cycle. External defibrillation was attempted twice after 15 min of ventricular fibrillation. Unsuccessfully defibrillated animals were randomly assigned to either an additional 2 min of continued closed-chest compressions, or 2 min of open-chest cardiac massage. All animals underwent a period of advanced cardiac life support and were followed until they were resuscitated or died. Follow-up care, including scoring of neurologic deficit, was performed for 7 days. In dogs receiving open-chest cardiac massage there was significantly more immediate resuscitation success (14/14 vs 5/14; p less than .005), 24 hr survival (12/14 vs 4/14; p less than .005), and 7 day survival (11/14 vs 4/14; p less than .02) than in those receiving continued closed-chest compression. Open-chest cardiac massage significantly improved long-term outcome when instituted after 15 min of ineffective closed-chest compression.