Functional versus structural matching: can the CTLp test be replaced by HLA allele typing?

HLA Matching in Unrelated Stem Cell Transplantation up to Date

Unrelated hematopoietic stem cell transplantation (HSCT) has evolved from an experimental protocol to a potentially curative first-line treatment in certain disease instances. Factors enabling this transformation were the optimization of treatment protocols and supportive care as well as the availability of a large number of donors worldwide along with the higher quality and reliability of HLA typing. The main criterion for donor selection is HLA compatibility. In this review we discuss the current clinical evidence of HLA matching in unrelated HSCT. In this context, we address methodical aspects of transplantation immunobiology research and discuss the impact of locus and resolution of HLA differences. Furthermore, we address special constellations such as unidirectional mismatches or the presence of nonexpressed alleles as well as HLA alloimmunization and describe the perspective for HLA typing and matching strategies in the future, given the implementation of novel complete or near-complete gene typing approaches using next-generation sequencing short read technology, which are now entering the standard of clinical care.

Selection of unrelated donors and cord blood units for hematopoietic cell transplantation: guidelines from the NMDP/CIBMTR

Allogeneic hematopoietic cell transplantation involves consideration of both donor and recipient characteristics to guide the selection of a suitable graft. Sufficient high-resolution donor-recipient HLA match is of primary importance in transplantation with adult unrelated donors, using conventional graft-versus-host disease prophylaxis. In cord blood transplantation, optimal unit selection requires consideration of unit quality, cell dose and HLA-match. In this summary, the National Marrow Donor Program (NMDP) and the Center for International Blood and Marrow Transplant Research, jointly with the NMDP Histocompatibility Advisory Group, provide evidence-based guidelines for optimal selection of unrelated donors and cord blood units.

In silico prediction of nonpermissive HLA-DPB1 mismatches in unrelated HCT by functional distance

In silico prediction of high-risk donor-recipient HLA mismatches after unrelated donor (UD) hematopoietic cell transplantation (HCT) is an attractive, yet elusive, objective. Nonpermissive T-cell epitope (TCE) group mismatches were defined by alloreactive T-cell cross-reactivity for 52/80 HLA-DPB1 alleles (TCE-X). More recently, a numerical functional distance (FD) scoring system for in silico prediction of TCE groups based on the median impact of exon 2-encoded amino acid polymorphism on T-cell alloreactivity was developed for all DPB1 alleles (TCE-FD), including the 28/80 common alleles not assigned by TCE-X. We compared clinical outcome associations of nonpermissive DPB1 mismatches defined by TCE-X or TCE-FD in 8/8 HLA-matched UD-HCT for acute leukemia, myelodysplastic syndrome, and chronic myelogenous leukemia between 1999 and 2011 (N = 2730). Concordance between the 2 models was 92.3%, with most differences arising from DPB1*06:01 and DPB1*19:01 being differently assigned by TCE-X and TCE-FD. In both models, nonpermissive mismatches were associated with reduced overall survival (hazard ratio [HR], 1.15, P < .006 and HR, 1.12, P < .03), increased transplant-related mortality (HR, 1.31, P < .001 and HR, 1.26, P < .001) as well as acute (HR, 1.16, P < .02 and HR, 1.22, P < .001) and chronic (HR, 1.20, P < .003 and HR, 1.22, P < .001) graft-versus-host disease (GVHD). We show that in silico prediction of nonpermissive DPB1 mismatches significantly associated with major transplant outcomes is feasible for any DPB1 allele with known exon 2 sequence based on experimentally elaborated FD scores. This proof-of-principle observation opens new avenues for developing HLA risk-prediction models in HCT and has practical implications for UD searches.

Paternal HLA-C is a risk factor in unexplained recurrent miscarriage

PROBLEM

HLA-C is the only classical HLA-I antigen expressed on trophoblast. We hypothesized that the alloimmune response to paternal HLA-C plays a role in unexplained recurrent miscarriage.

METHOD OF STUDY

In a case-control design, we included 100 women with at least three unexplained consecutive miscarriages along with their partners and children. For the first control group, we included 90 women with an uneventful singleton pregnancy without pregnancy complications in their history along with their children. The second control group consisted of 425 families. HLA-C*07 and HLA-C*17 frequencies, which are the most immunogenic HLA-C antigens, along with HLA-C mismatches, and the presence of specific HLA antibodies in the mother were determined.

RESULTS

HLA-C and HLA-C*07 mismatches were significantly increased in couples with recurrent miscarriage compared to control subjects (P = .016, P = .008, respectively). The incidence of child-specific HLA-C*07/HLA-C*17 antibodies was increased in women with recurrent miscarriage (P = .007).

CONCLUSION

The results show that HLA-C incompatibility between couples is significantly associated with unexplained recurrent miscarriage.

What compatibility in 2017 for the haematopoietic stem cell transplantation?

The diversification of potential donors to perform stem cell allografts now enables to propose a compatible graft cell source adapted to the different clinical situations. Transplants with a geno-identical sibling donor, otherwise with the most HLA-compatible unrelated donor, remain the first-line solutions. Alternative transplants allow to graft patients having no donors in international registries, owing to the rarity of their HLA typing. They are carried out with fairly incompatible grafts and are therefore limited by the existence in the recipient of preformed anti-HLA antibodies which predispose to their rejection. The simple prevention of acute Graft-versus-host disease in haplo-identical transplants, as well as the availability of donors, explain why they have very often replaced placental stem cell transplants. These latter remain useful for pediatric patients or in the absence of family donors.

How to select the best available related or unrelated donor of hematopoietic stem cells?

Recognition of HLA incompatibilities by the immune system represents a major barrier to allogeneic hematopoietic stem cell transplantation. HLA genotypically identical sibling donors are, therefore, the gold standard for transplantation purposes, but only 30% patients have such a donor. For the remaining 70% patients alternative sources of stem cells are a matched unrelated adult volunteer donor, a haploidentical donor or a cord blood unit. The definition of 'HLA matching' depends on the level of resolution and on which loci are tested. The development of HLA molecular typing technologies and the availability of more than 27 million donors in the international database has greatly facilitated unrelated donor searches. The gold standard is high resolution typing at the HLA-A, -B, -C, -DRB1, and -DQB1 loci (10/10 match). Single disparities for HLA-A, -B, - C, or -DRB1 are associated with increased risk of post-transplant complications, but less so in patients with advanced disease, and in those undergoing T-cell-depleted allografting. HLA-DQB1 mismatches seem to be better tolerated and some HLA-C, -DRB1 and -DPB1 disparities are potentially less immunogenic. HLA typing by next-generation sequencing methods is likely to change matching algorithms by providing full sequence information on all HLA loci in a single step. In most European populations a 10/10 matched donor can be found for at least 50% of patients and an additional 20-30% patients may have a 9/10 matched donor. Genetic factors that help in identifying donors with less immunogenic mismatches are discussed. Haploidentical donors are increasingly used as an alternative source of stem cells for those patients lacking a matched unrelated donor.

Identification of high-risk amino-acid substitutions in hematopoietic cell transplantation: a challenging task

Allogeneic hematopoietic cell transplantation (HCT) offers the potential to cure hematologic malignancies. In the absence of an HLA-matched donor, HLA mismatched unrelated donors may be used, although risks of GvHD and treatment-related mortality (TRM) are higher. Identification and avoidance of amino-acid substitution and position types (AASPT) conferring higher risks of TRM and GvHD would potentially improve the success of transplantation from single HLA mismatched unrelated donors. Using random forest and logistic regression analyses, we identified 19 AASPT associated with greater risks for at least one adverse transplant outcome: grade III-IV acute GvHD, TRM, lower disease-free survival or worse overall survival relative to HLA-matched unrelated donors and to other AASPT. When tested in an independent validation cohort of 3530 patients, none of the AASPT from the training set were validated as high risk, however. Review of the literature shows that failure to validate original observations is the rule and not the exception in immunobiology and emphasizes the importance of independent validation before clinical application. Our current data do not support avoiding any specific class I AASPT for unrelated donors. Additional studies should be performed to fully understand the role of AASPT in HCT outcomes.

Physiochemical disparity of mismatched HLA class I alloantigens and risk of acute GVHD following HSCT

We determined whether assessment of the immunogenicity of individual donor-recipient HLA mismatches based on differences in their amino-acid sequence and physiochemical properties predicts clinical outcome following haematopoietic SCT (HSCT). We examined patients transplanted with 9/10 single HLA class I-mismatched grafts (n=171) and 10/10 HLA-A-, -B-, -C-, -DRB1- and -DQB1-matched grafts (n=168). A computer algorithm was used to determine the physiochemical disparity (electrostatic mismatch score (EMS) and hydrophobic mismatch score (HMS)) of mismatched HLA class I specificities in the graft-versus-host direction. Patients transplanted with HLA-mismatched grafts with high EMS/HMS had increased incidence of ⩾grade II acute GVHD (aGVHD) compared with patients transplanted with low EMS/HMS grafts; patients transplanted with low and medium EMS/HMS grafts had similar incidence of aGVHD to patients transplanted with 10/10 HLA-matched grafts. Mortality was higher following single HLA-mismatched HSCT but was not correlated with HLA physiochemical disparity. Assessment of donor-recipient HLA incompatibility based on physiochemical HLA disparity may enable better selection of HLA-mismatched donors in HSCT.

Association between CTL Precursor Frequency to HLA-C Mismatches and HLA-C Antigen Cell Surface Expression

Previous studies showed the relevance of the cytotoxic T-cell precursor (CTLp) frequency assay for prediction of the outcome of HLA mismatched hematopoietic cell transplantation (HCT). Recently, it has been shown that HLA-C cell surface expression is correlated with virus specific cytotoxic T-cell responses and viremia control in HIV patients. The aim of the current study was to investigate the association between HLA-C antigen expression and the CTLp frequency to the mismatched HLA-C antigen. In total 115 recipient-donor pairs, for whom a successful CTLp assay was performed, were evaluated for this pilot study. All donor-recipient pairs were matched at 9/10 alleles with a single mismatch at the HLA-C locus. Antigen expression level of the mismatched HLA-C allele for each recipient and donor was based on the mean fluorescence intensity (MFI) values as described by Apps et al. (1). The cell surface expression of recipient's mismatched HLA-C antigen was significantly lower among CTLp negative (n = 59) compared to CTLp positive (n = 56) pairs (154 and 193 MFI units, respectively, p = 0.0031). This difference was more pronounced in donor-recipient pairs that were mismatched for amino-acid residue-116 located in the groove of the HLA-C antigen, suggesting that the importance of peptide binding in the allo-recognition. Furthermore, in the particular case of low expression of the recipient mismatched HLA-C antigen (MFI < 115), CTLp reactivity depended on HLA-C expression level in the donor, the median MFI of donor's mismatched HLA-C antigen was 114 in CTLp negative cases (n = 26), while in CTLp positive cases (n = 15) the median MFI of donor's HLA-C antigen was 193 (p = 0.0093). We conclude that the expression level of the donor and recipient mismatched HLA-C antigens affect CTLp outcome. HLA-C antigen expression levels in combination with the CTLp assay may prove useful for the prediction of the clinical outcome of HLA-C mismatched HCT.

HLA-C Incompatibilities in Allogeneic Unrelated Hematopoietic Stem Cell Transplantation

An increasingly larger fraction of patients with hematological diseases are treated by hematopoietic stem cells transplantation (HSCT) from HLA matched unrelated donors. Polymorphisms of HLA genes represent a major barrier to HSCT because HLA-A, -B, -C and DRB1 incompatibilities confer a higher risk of acute graft-versus-host disease (aGVHD) and mortality. Although >22 million volunteer HLA-typed donors are available worldwide, still a significant number of patients do not find a highly matched HSC donor. Because of the large haplotypic diversity in HLA-B–C associations, incompatibilities occur most frequently at HLA-C, so that unrelated donors with a single HLA-C mismatch often represent the only possible choice. The ratio of HLA-C-mismatched HSCT over the total number of transplants varies from 15 to 30%, as determined in 12 multicenter studies. Six multicenter studies involving >1800 patients have reported a 21–43% increase in mortality risk. By using in vitro cellular assays, a large heterogeneity in T-cell allorecognition has been observed. Yet the permissiveness of individual HLA-C mismatches remains poorly defined. It could be linked to the position and nature of the mismatched residues on HLA-C molecules, but also to variability in the expression levels of the mismatched alleles. The permissive C*03:03–03:04 mismatch is characterized by full compatibility at residues 9, 97, 99, 116, 152, 156, and 163 reported to be key positions influencing T-cell allorecognition. With a single difference among these seven key residues the C*07:01–07:02 mismatch might also be considered by analogy as permissive. High variability of HLA-C expression as determined by quantitative RT-PCR has been observed within individual allotypes and shows some correlation with A–B–C–DRB1 haplotypes. Thus in addition to the position of mismatched amino acid residues, expression level of patient’s mismatched HLA-C allotype might influence T-cell allorecognition, with patients low expression-C alleles representing possible permissive mismatches.

Predicting alloreactivity in transplantation

Human leukocyte Antigen (HLA) mismatching leads to severe complications after solid-organ transplantation and hematopoietic stem-cell transplantation. The alloreactive responses underlying the posttransplantation complications include both direct recognition of allogeneic HLA by HLA-specific alloantibodies and T cells and indirect T-cell recognition. However, the immunogenicity of HLA mismatches is highly variable; some HLA mismatches lead to severe clinical B-cell- and T-cell-mediated alloreactivity, whereas others are well tolerated. Definition of the permissibility of HLA mismatches prior to transplantation allows selection of donor-recipient combinations that will have a reduced chance to develop deleterious host-versus-graft responses after solid-organ transplantation and graft-versus-host responses after hematopoietic stem-cell transplantation. Therefore, several methods have been developed to predict permissible HLA-mismatch combinations. In this review we aim to give a comprehensive overview about the current knowledge regarding HLA-directed alloreactivity and several developed in vitro and in silico tools that aim to predict direct and indirect alloreactivity.

Translating in vitro prediction of cytotoxic T cell alloreactivity to hematopoietic stem cell transplantation outcome

INTRODUCTION

Previously we developed a weighted amino acid (AA) mismatch score predictive for cytotoxic T cell (CTL) alloreactivity (in vitro CTLp assay) based on the structure of the HLA class I molecule. The aim of this study is to confirm the clinical relevance of the CTLp assay and to validate the AA mismatch score as an alternative and easy to use tool to predict permissible mismatches in hematopoietic stem cell transplantation (HSCT).

METHODS

We selected patients transplanted with a 9/10 single HLA class I mismatched graft (n=171) at three Dutch HSCT centers. A CTLp assay was performed in 73 donor-recipient pairs. As a control we selected 168 10/10 HLA matched pairs that were matched to the 9/10 single HLA class I mismatched pairs for HSCT year, donor type, patient age and diagnosis.

RESULTS

We observed that pairs with negative a CTLp assay had statistically significant decreased incidence of mortality after HSCT comparable to that of 10/10 HLA matched pairs. However, the weighted AA mismatch score did not significantly predict any HSCT end point of interest.

CONCLUSION

Further investigation is needed to unravel the mechanisms involved in causing the beneficial effect of a negative CTLp assay, before other alternative tools to predict HSCT outcome may be developed.

Identification of a permissible HLA mismatch in hematopoietic stem cell transplantation

In subjects mismatched in the HLA alleles C*03:03/C*03:04 no allogeneic cytotoxic T-lymphocyte responses are detected in vitro. Hematopoietic stem cell transplantation (HSCT) with unrelated donors (UDs) showed no association between the HLA-C allele mismatches (CAMMs) and adverse outcomes; antigen mismatches at this and mismatches other HLA loci are deleterious. The absence of effect of the CAMM may have resulted from the predominance of the mismatch C*03:03/C*03:04. Patients with hematologic malignancies receiving UD HSCT matched in 8/8 and 7/8 HLA alleles were examined. Transplants mismatched in HLA-C antigens or mismatched in HLA-A, -B, or -DRB1 presented significant differences (P < .0001) in mortality (hazard ratio [HR] = 1.37, 1.30), disease-free survival (HR = 1.33, 1.27), treatment-related mortality (HR = 1.54, 1.54), and grade 3-4 acute graft-versus-host disease (HR = 1.49, 1.77) compared with the 8/8 group; transplants mismatched in other CAMMs had similar outcomes with HR ranging from 1.34 to 172 for these endpoints. The C*03:03/C*03:04 mismatched and the 8/8 matched groups had identical outcomes (HR ranging from 0.96-1.05). The previous finding that CAMMs do not associate with adverse outcomes is explained by the predominance (69%) of the mismatch C*03:03/03:04 in this group that is better tolerated than other HLA mismatches.

Unrelated hematopoietic stem cell donor matching probability and search algorithm

In transplantation of hematopoietic stem cells (HSCs) from unrelated donors a high HLA compatibility level decreases the risk of acute graft-versus-host disease and mortality. The diversity of the HLA system at the allelic and haplotypic level and the heterogeneity of HLA typing data of the registered donors render the search process a complex task. This paper summarizes our experience with a search algorithm that includes at the start of the search a probability estimate (high/intermediate/low) to identify a HLA-A, B, C, DRB1, DQB1-compatible donor (a 10/10 match). Based on 2002–2011 searches about 30% of patients have a high, 30% an intermediate, and 40% a low probability search. Search success rate and duration are presented and discussed in light of the experience of other centers. Overall a 9-10/10 matched HSC donor can now be identified for 60–80% of patients of European descent. For high probability searches donors can be selected on the basis of DPB1-matching with an estimated success rate of >40%. For low probability searches there is no consensus on which HLA incompatibilities are more permissive, although HLA-DQB1 mismatches are generally considered as acceptable. Models for the discrimination of more detrimental mismatches based on specific amino acid residues rather than specific HLA alleles are presented.

Cleavage of transaldolase by granzyme B causes the loss of enzymatic activity with retention of antigenicity for multiple sclerosis patients

Multiple sclerosis (MS) is an autoimmune demyelinating disease of the CNS resulting from a progressive loss of oligodendrocytes. Transaldolase (TAL) is expressed at selectively high levels in oligodendrocytes of the brain, and postmortem sections show concurrent loss of myelin basic protein and TAL from sites of demyelination. Infiltrating CD8(+) CTLs are thought to play a key role in oligodendrocyte cell death. Cleavage by granzyme B (GrB) is predictive for autoantigenicity of self-proteins, thereby further implicating CTL-induced death in the initiation and propagation of autoimmunity. The precursor frequency and CTL activity of HLA-A2-restricted TAL 168-176-specific CD8(+) T cells is increased in MS patients. In this paper, we show that TAL, but not myelin basic protein, is specifically cleaved by human GrB. The recognition site of GrB that resulted in the cleavage of a dominant TAL fragment was mapped to a VVAD motif at aa residue 27 by N-terminal sequencing and confirmed by site-directed mutagenesis. The major C-terminal GrB cleavage product, residues 28-337, had no enzymatic activity but retained the antigenicity of full-length TAL, effectively stimulating the proliferation and CTL activity of PBMCs and of CD8(+) T cell lines from patients with MS. Sera of MS patients exhibited similar binding affinity to wild-type and GrB-cleaved TAL. Because GrB mediates the killing of target cells and cleavage by GrB is predictive of autoantigen status of self proteins, GrB-cleaved TAL-specific T cell-mediated cytotoxicity may contribute to the progressive destruction of oligodendrocytes in patients with MS.

T-cell precursor frequencies and long-term outcome following unrelated hematopoietic stem cell transplantation

Functional assays measuring alloreactivity of donor cells are desired to detect either cryptic epitopes inducing graft-vs.-host disease (GvHD) after human leukocyte antigen (HLA)-identical hematopoietic stem cell transplantation (HSCT) or permissible HLA mismatches. However, their value in predicting GvHD and survival is still limited. We determined the cytotoxic and helper T-cell precursor (CTLp and HTLp) frequencies by limiting dilution analysis (LDA) in 40 unrelated recipient/donor combinations. The median observation period at the time of this writing was 4.44 years (range from 0.1 to 11.28). Better overall survival was observed in patients with rather low host-specific CTLp and HTLp frequencies, whereas a trend toward high CTLp frequencies was seen in patients with higher incidence of acute GvHD, especially in patients mismatched in HLA-C. CTLp and HTLp frequencies did not correlate with the incidence of chronic GvHD and relapse. In conclusion, we detected a trend toward better overall survival of patient/donor pairs with low CTLp and HTLp frequencies, however, recommend to use LDA as an additional tool for identifying the most suitable donor when more than one fully HLA-matched stem cell donor is available.

Optimal HLA matching in hematopoietic cell transplantation

Only 30% of patients in need of a hematopoietic cell transplant will have an HLA identical sibling to serve as the donor. Advances in the field of immunogenetics together with the growth of donor registries and cord blood banks worldwide have provided many of these patients the opportunity for a life saving transplant. Current data demonstrate the importance of matching the unrelated donor for HLA alleles and antigens. When a matched volunteer donor is not available, use of mismatched donors may be considered. New concepts in the selection of mismatched donors include consideration for the locus, the number of mismatches, differences between alleles and antigens, the location and nature of amino acid mismatches that define class I epitopes, and the presence of haplotype mismatching. When cord blood transplantation is an option, both cell dose and HLA matching are important variables. Optimizing the overall outcome of hematopoietic cell transplantation requires an appreciation for the relative importance of HLA factors with respect to other non-genetic factors that also influence transplant outcome.

Immunodominance hierarchies and gender bias in direct T(CD8)-cell alloreactivity

Allogeneic solid organ transplantation often occurs across multiple donor-recipient HLA mismatches with consequent risk of allograft rejection. However, there is growing evidence that not all HLA mismatches are equivalent in their stimulation of allogeneic T cells making it important to determine which of these might be more significant as predictors of allograft rejection. To this end, we used defined antigen-presenting cell (APC) transfectants expressing single MHC-I allotypes as target cells that could discriminate the relative contribution of individual mismatched MHC-I allotypes to direct T-cell alloreactivity. We demonstrate remarkably reproducible patterns of immunodominance in reactivity across mismatched MHC-I allotypes. These patterns are HLA context-dependent, partly reflecting alloantigenic competition in responder cell responses. In strong alloresponses, we also observed an increased percentage of alloreactive T(CD8) cells in female responders, regardless of the stimulator gender, highlighting HLA-independent factors in the potency of the alloresponse. This approach provides a potential measure of specific alloreactive T cells that could be used in clinical practice for selection of donors, assessment of posttransplant outcomes, modulation of immunosuppression and detection of rejection episodes.

Highly diverged MHC class I mismatches are acceptable for haematopoietic stem cell transplantation

A fully major histocompatilbility complex (MHC) matched donor is not available for the majority of patients in need of a haematopoietic stem cell transplantation (SCT), which illustrates the need for a tool to define acceptable MHC disparities. Previously, we noticed that a variety of single MHC class I mismatched allogeneic donor-recipient pairs did not elicit an allogeneic cytotoxic-lymphocyte (CTL) response in vitro if the MHC amino-acid sequences had five or more differences in the alpha-helices plus five or more differences in the beta-sheet (> or =5alpha5beta) (7). To address the clinical relevance of this observation, we analysed CTL precursor (CTLp) assay outcome and SCT outcome in 53 Dutch recipients of a single MHC class I mismatched graft from an unrelated donor. Overall patient survival was 44% after 4 years. In multivariate analysis, recipients of a > or =5alpha5beta mismatched graft with negative CTLp frequencies in vitro before transplantation demonstrated superior survival: survival at 4 years was 80% as compared to 47% in recipients of other mismatched grafts with negative CTLp frequencies (hazard ratio=0.131; 95% CI=(0.03-0.61); P=0.009). This option of acceptable mismatches may enlarge the pool of potentially acceptable stem cell donors.

High-resolution analysis of HLA class I alterations in colorectal cancer

Background

Previous studies indicate that alterations in Human Leukocyte Antigen (HLA) class I expression are frequent in colorectal tumors. This would suggest serious limitations for immunotherapy-based strategies involving T-cell recognition. Distinct patterns of HLA surface expression might conceal different immune escape mechanisms employed by the tumors and are worth further study.

Method

We applied four-color multiparameter flow cytometry (FCM), using a large panel of alloantigen-specific anti-HLA-A and -B monoclonal antibodies, to study membranous expression of individual HLA alleles in freshly isolated colorectal cancer cell suspensions from 21 patients.

Results

Alterations in HLA class I phenotype were observed in 8 (38%) of the 21 tumors and comprised loss of a single A or B alleles in 4 cases, and loss of all four A and B alleles in the other 4 cases. Seven of these 8 tumors were located on the right side of the colon, and those showing loss of both HLA-A and -B membranous expression were all of the MSI-H phenotype.

Conclusion

FCM allows the discrimination of complex phenotypes related to the expression of HLA class I. The different patterns of HLA class I expression might underlie different tumor behavior and influence the success rate of immunotherapy.

Hematopoietic Stem Cell Donor Selection: the Europdonor Experience

International collaboration is essential for the optimal selection of unrelated hematopoietic stem cell donors. This review focuses on the benefit of a joint worldwide donor file called Bone Marrow Donors Worldwide and the experience of the Europdonor Foundation in selecting strategies to identify the best human leukocyte antigen-matched donor in the shortest time.

Differential Immunogenicity of HLA Class I Alloantigens for the Humoral versus the Cellular Immune Response: “Towards Tailor-Made HLA Mismatching”

The immunogenicity of an individual human leukocyte antigen (HLA) class I mismatch is different for the cellular and the humoral alloimmune responses. The consequence is that the same antigen can induce a strong antibody response and no cytotoxic T lymphocyte reactivity, but the reverse can occur also. Exact knowledge of the immunogenicity of an HLA mismatch for an individual patient can lead to a strategy of tailor-made HLA mismatching if no HLA identical donor is available. Depending on the clinical situation, one should select a donor with HLA mismatches according to the humoral or cellular mismatch algorithm.

CD8+ T cell-mediated HLA-A*0201-restricted cytotoxicity to transaldolase peptide 168-176 in patients with multiple sclerosis

Transaldolase (TAL) is expressed at selectively high levels in oligodendrocytes and targeted by autoreactive T cells of patients with multiple sclerosis (MS). Among 14 TAL peptides with predicted HLA-A2 binding, TAL 168-176 (LLFSFAQAV, TALpep) exhibited high affinity for HLA-A2. Prevalence of HLA-A2-restricted CD8+ T cells specific for TALpep was increased in PBMC of HLA-A2+ MS patients, as compared with HLA-A2- MS patients, HLA-A2+ other neurological disease patients, and HLA-A2+ healthy donors. HLA-A*0201/TALpep tetramers detected increased frequency of TAL-specific CD8+ T cells, and precursor frequency of TAL-specific IFN-gamma-producing T cells was increased in each of seven HLA-A2+ MS patients tested. Stimulation by TALpep or rTAL of PBMC from HLA-A2+ MS patients elicited killing of TALpep-pulsed HLA-A2-transfected HmyA2.1 lymphoma cells, but not HLA-A3-transfected control HmyA3.1 targets. Without peptide pulsing of targets, HLA-A2-transfected, but not control MO3.13 oligodendroglial cells, expressing high levels of endogenous TAL, were also killed by CD8+ CTL of MS patients, indicating recognition of endogenously processed TAL. TCR Vbeta repertoire analysis revealed use of the TCR Vbeta14 gene by T cell lines (TCL) of MS patients generated via stimulation by TAL- or TALpep-pulsed APCs. All TAL-specific TCL-binding HLA-A*0201/TALpep tetramers expressed TCR Vbeta14 on the cell surface. Moreover, Ab to TCR Vbeta14 abrogated cytotoxicity by HLA-A2-restricted TAL-specific TCL. Therefore, TAL-specific CTL may serve as a novel target for therapeutic intervention in patients with MS.

Allogeneic MHC Class I Molecules With Numerous Sequence Differences Do Not Elicit a CTL Response

CD8+ T cell-mediated alloreactivity is generally believed to involve recognition of the alpha1/alpha2 domains of donor-type class I MHC molecules as well as the peptides they bind. Using the CTLp assay outcome as a parameter for the induction of alloreactivity, we have retrospectively surveyed 80 haematopoietic stem cell donor/patient pairs that feature a range of allelic differences at single HLA-A, -B, and -C loci in an attempt to probe the predictive value of such mismatches. In contrast to the expectation that greater degree of allelic disparity would lead to more alloreactivity, we found that in a substantial number of cases, class I MHC molecules with numerous sequence differences did not elicit an allogeneic CTL response. We propose that in generating a T cell repertoire with a sufficiently narrow responsive for self-MHC, positive thymic selection limits the capacity to recognize allogeneic MHC molecules whose structure and sequence have diverged extensively. These findings are important for donor and patient MHC matching strategies and our understanding of T cell-MHC interaction after haematopoietic stem cell transplantation.

Role of NK cells in mismatched unrelated haematopoietic stem-cell transplantation: fact or fiction?

The role of alloreactive NK cells in haematopoietic stem-cell transplantation is a controversial topic. Different studies come up with different conclusions. This is mainly due to heterogeneous patient populations, differences in the sources of haematopoietic stem cells and various conditioning regimens. International collaboration is essential to reveal in which situation NK cell alloreactivity plays a role and, if so, whether it is beneficial or detrimental for patient survival.

Differential immunogenicity of HLA mismatches in clinical transplantation

Although HLA matching is beneficial in clinical transplantation, it is not feasible to select a completely HLA matched donor for every potential recipient because of the enormous polymorphism of the HLA system. As a consequence, the majority of the recipients will be transplanted with a mismatched donor organ or hematopoietic stem cell transplant. For this large group of patients it is important to take advantage of the differential immunogenicity of HLA mismatches and to select for them a donor with HLA mismatches of low immunogenicity, the so-called acceptable mismatches. The differential immunogenicity of HLA mismatches can be determined by either retrospective analysis of graft survival data or by in vitro assays measuring T-cell and B-cell alloreactivity. A recently developed computer algorithm (HLAMatchmaker) can be instrumental in selecting donors with HLA mismatches, which do not lead to alloantibody formation. The theoretical background and practical implications of this acceptable mismatch approach are discussed.

How to improve the search for an unrelated haematopoietic stem cell donor. Faster is better than more!

Many patients do not reach haematopoietic stem cell transplantation. Shortage of unrelated donors (UDs) is still seen as the main cause. However, with a worldwide UD pool containing more than 8 million donors, it is possible that other impediments are becoming more important. We analysed 549 UD searches for Dutch patients, performed between 1987 and 2000, in order to find the reasons for failure or success to reach transplantation. Between 1996 and 2000, 59% of the patients of Northwest European origin received a graft from an UD with a median time span of 4.4 months from the start of the search. In all, 11% of the patients lacked a compatible donor, while 30% became medically unfit for transplantation. This is in contrast to the patients of non-Northwest European origin for whom UD shortage is still the most important impediment; only 32% were transplanted while 50% lacked a compatible donor. We conclude that the shortage of donors is no longer the biggest constraint in unrelated stem cell transplantation for patients of Northwest European origin. It may be more effective to optimize the chance on transplantation by making the search process more efficient.

HLAMatchmaker Algorithm is not a Suitable Tool to Predict the Alloreactive Cytotoxic T-Lymphocyte Response in vitro

Both donor-specific anti-human leukocyte antigen (HLA) antibodies and cytotoxic T lymphocytes are important mediators of graft rejection. HLAMatchmaker determines the amino acid triplets on antibody-accessible sites of the HLA molecule that are not shared between patient and donor. A previous study showed a strong positive correlation between the number of triplet mismatches and the percentage of individuals producing HLA antibodies. In the present study, we tested whether the number of triplet mismatches is predictive for the cytotoxic T-lymphocyte precursor (CTLp) frequency in vitro. The analysis was performed on 108 HLA-DRB1 and DQB1 identical patient-donor combinations registered by the Europdonor foundation, with a single HLA class I mismatch and in healthy responder-stimulator combinations mismatched for at least one HLA class I antigen. The results show that there is no strong correlation between the number of triplet mismatches and the CTLp frequency. Even in the case of zero triplet mismatches, a high CTLp frequency can be found. This lack of correlation is probably caused by the fact that HLAMatchmaker considers only triplets on antibody-accessible positions, whereas CTLs also recognize other epitopes on the HLA molecule, including the bound peptides.

Low incidence of severe acute graft-versus-host disease in children given haematopoietic stem cell transplantation from unrelated donors prospectively matched for HLA class I and II alleles with high-resolution molecular typing

We evaluated the outcome of 63 children given haematopoietic stem cell transplantation from unrelated donors (URD-HSCT) prospectively selected using DNA high-resolution typing of both HLA class I and class II loci. Thirty patient/donor pairs (48%) were fully matched. Among the others, HSCT was performed in the presence of one (n=22), two (n=9), or three (n=2) HLA disparities. Patients had either malignant (n=46) or non-malignant (n=17) disease. In all cases, graft-versus-host disease (GVHD) prophylaxis consisted of cyclospor-in A, short-term methotrexate and pretransplant anti-thymocyte globulin. The probability of haematopoietic recovery at day 100 was 97%. Two patients experienced primary graft failure. The cumulative probability of grades III-IV acute GVHD and of extensive chronic GVHD equalled 8 and 14%, respectively. A total of 12 patients died of transplant-related complications. The probability of transplant-related mortality (TRM) at 100 and 180 days was 10 and 15%, respectively, whereas the cumulative incidence of TRM was 22%. The probability of GVHD-related mortality equalled 6% at 2.5 years. The overall and disease-free survival rates were 67 and 65%, respectively. URD-HSCT with donor selection based on high-resolution HLA typing is associated with low incidence of both severe acute GVHD and graft failure. The observed outcome is comparable to that of children transplanted from HLA-identical siblings.