Patterns of cellular activation after tendon injury

Epitenon-derived cells comprise a distinct progenitor population that contributes to both tendon fibrosis and regeneration following acute injury

Flexor tendon injuries are common and heal poorly owing to both the deposition of function- limiting peritendinous scar tissue and insufficient healing of the tendon itself. Therapeutic options are limited due to a lack of understanding of the cell populations that contribute to these processes. Here, we identified a bi-fated progenitor cell population that originates from the epitenon and goes on to contribute to both peritendinous fibrosis and regenerative tendon healing following acute tendon injury. Using a combination of genetic lineage tracing and single cell RNA-sequencing (scRNA-seq), we profiled the behavior and contributions of each cell fate to the healing process in a spatio-temporal manner. Branched pseudotime trajectory analysis identified distinct transcription factors responsible for regulation of each fate. Finally, integrated scRNA-seq analysis of mouse healing with human peritendinous scar tissue revealed remarkable transcriptional similarity between mouse epitenon- derived cells and fibroblasts present in human peritendinous scar tissue, which was further validated by immunofluorescent staining for conserved markers. Combined, these results clearly identify the epitenon as the cellular origin of an important progenitor cell population that could be leveraged to improve tendon healing.

Cell autonomous TGFβ signaling is essential for stem/progenitor cell recruitment into degenerative tendons

Understanding cell recruitment in damaged tendons is critical for improvements in regenerative therapy. We recently reported that targeted disruption of transforming growth factor beta (TGFβ) type II receptor in the tendon cell lineage (Tgfbr2^ScxCre) resulted in resident tenocyte dedifferentiation and tendon deterioration in postnatal stages. Here we extend the analysis and identify direct recruitment of stem/progenitor cells into the degenerative mutant tendons. Cre-mediated lineage tracing indicates that these cells are not derived from tendon-ensheathing tissues or from a Scleraxis-expressing lineage, and they turned on tendon markers only upon entering the mutant tendons. Through immunohistochemistry and inducible gene deletion, we further find that the recruited cells originated from a Sox9-expressing lineage and their recruitment was dependent on cell autonomous TGFβ signaling. The cells identified in this study thus differ from previous reports of cell recruitment into injured tendons and suggest a critical role for TGFβ signaling in cell recruitment, providing insights that may support improvements in tendon repair.

•

Targeted deletion of TGFβ signaling led to degenerative changes in mouse tendons

•

Stem/progenitor cells were recruited into the degenerative mutant tendons

•

The recruited cells are different from the ones so far reported in tendon injury

•

Recruitment was dependent on cell autonomous TGFβ signaling in the recruited cells

Biomaterials strategies to balance inflammation and tenogenesis for tendon repair

Adult tendon tissue demonstrates a limited regenerative capacity, and the natural repair process leaves fibrotic scar tissue with inferior mechanical properties. Surgical treatment is insufficient to provide the mechanical, structural, and biochemical environment necessary to restore functional tissue. While numerous strategies including biodegradable scaffolds, bioactive factor delivery, and cell-based therapies have been investigated, most studies have focused exclusively on either suppressing inflammation or promoting tenogenesis, which includes tenocyte proliferation, ECM production, and tissue formation. New biomaterials-based approaches represent an opportunity to more effectively balance the two processes and improve regenerative outcomes from tendon injuries. Biomaterials applications that have been explored for tendon regeneration include formation of biodegradable scaffolds presenting topographical, mechanical, and/or immunomodulatory cues conducive to tendon repair; delivery of immunomodulatory or tenogenic biomolecules; and delivery of therapeutic cells such as tenocytes and stem cells. In this review, we provide the biological context for the challenges in tendon repair, discuss biomaterials approaches to modulate the immune and regenerative environment during the healing process, and consider the future development of comprehensive biomaterials-based strategies that can better restore the function of injured tendon. STATEMENT OF SIGNIFICANCE: Current strategies for tendon repair focus on suppressing inflammation or enhancing tenogenesis. Evidence indicates that regulated inflammation is beneficial to tendon healing and that excessive tissue remodeling can cause fibrosis. Thus, it is necessary to adopt an approach that balances the benefits of regulated inflammation and tenogenesis. By reviewing potential treatments involving biodegradable scaffolds, biological cues, and therapeutic cells, we contrast how each strategy promotes or suppresses specific repair steps to improve the healing outcome, and highlight the advantages of a comprehensive approach that facilitates the clearance of necrotic tissue and recruitment of cells during the inflammatory stage, followed by ECM synthesis and organization in the proliferative and remodeling stages with the goal of restoring function to the tendon.

Efficacy of Single-Dose Radiotherapy in Preventing Posttraumatic Tendon Adhesion

Background and Aim

Posttraumatic peritendinous adhesion is the greatest obstacle to achieve normal tendon function following lacerations of extrinsic flexor tendons of the hand. In this study, we aimed to evaluate whether single-dose radiotherapy (RT) has the potential to modulate intrasynovial tendon adhesions.

Materials and Methods

A total of 80 tendons from the third to fourth flexor profundus of both hind paws of 20 adult New Zealand rabbits were used in this study. Rabbits in the RT group received 3 Gy of X-irradiation in a single fraction. Histopathological evaluation of longitudinal sections of tendons was made using the Tang grading system for peritendinous adhesions. Intratendinous quality of the healing tissue in the laceration zone was assessed using a modified Movin scale.

Results

Adhesion and inflammatory response were greater in the RT group (p˂0.001). Tendon healing in the radiation group was found to be more uniform and organized compared with the control group. However, this difference was not statistically significant. The nuclei of the tenocytes in the radiation group showed a closer resemblance to normal tendon tissue when compared with the control group (p=0.007).

Conclusions

Despite RT’s certain advantages such as extracorporeal use, anti-inflammatory effect, and homogenous tissue penetration, 3-Gy X-irradiation resulted in increased peritendinous posttraumatic adhesion, possibly due to dose imbalance. Increased roundness in the tenocyte nuclei was present in the RT group. Studies with different dosing regimens and a higher number of subjects are necessary to establish an ideal dose suppressing the synovial response without compromising tendon healing.

The cellular basis of fibrotic tendon healing: challenges and opportunities

Tendon injuries are common and can dramatically impair patient mobility and productivity, resulting in a significant socioeconomic burden and reduced quality of life. Because the tendon healing process results in the formation of a fibrotic scar, injured tendons never regain the mechanical strength of the uninjured tendon, leading to frequent reinjury. Many tendons are also prone to the development of peritendinous adhesions and excess scar formation, which further reduce tendon function and lead to chronic complications. Despite this, there are currently no treatments that adequately improve the tendon healing process due in part to a lack of information regarding the contributions of various cell types to tendon healing and how their activity may be modulated for therapeutic value. In this review, we summarize recent efforts to identify and characterize the distinct cell populations involved at each stage of tendon healing. In addition, we examine the mechanisms through which different cell populations contribute to the fibrotic response to tendon injury, and how these responses can be affected by systemic factors and comorbidities. We then discuss gaps in our current understanding of tendon fibrosis and highlight how new technologies and research areas are shedding light on this clinically important and intractable challenge. A better understanding of the complex cellular environment during tendon healing is crucial to the development of new therapies to prevent fibrosis and promote tissue regeneration.

Biologic and mechanical aspects of tendon fibrosis after injury and repair

Tendon injuries of the hand that require surgical repair often heal with excess scarring and adhesions to adjacent tissues. This can compromise the natural gliding mechanics of the flexor tendons in particular, which operate within a fibro-osseous tunnel system similar to a set of pulleys. Even combining the finest suture repair techniques with optimal hand therapy protocols cannot ensure predictable restoration of hand function in these cases. To date, the majority of research regarding tendon injuries has revolved around the mechanical aspects of the surgical repair (i.e. suture techniques) and postoperative rehabilitation. The central principles of treatment gleaned from this literature include using a combination of core and epitendinous sutures during repair and initiating motion early on in hand therapy to improve tensile strength and limit adhesion formation. However, it is likely that the best clinical solution will utilize optimal biological modulation of the healing response in addition to these core strategies and, recently, the research in this area has expanded considerably. While there are no proven additive biological agents that can be used in clinical practice currently, in this review, we analyze the recent literature surrounding cytokine modulation, gene and cell-based therapies, and tissue engineering, which may ultimately lead to improved clinical outcomes following tendon injury in the future.

The comparison of macroscopic and histologic healing of side-to-side (SS) tenorrhaphy technique and primer tendon repair in a rabbit model

INTRODUCTION

The side-to-side (SS) tenorrhaphy technique has been used in tendon transfer surgery. The mechanical properties of SS tendon suture have been studied previously. However, the histo-pathological healing of the SS tenorrhaphy of the tendons is unknown. The aim of this study was to assess the gross and histological effects of SS tenorrhaphy in a rabbit model.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Twenty New Zealand rabbits were used. The extensor hallucis longus and tibialis anterior tendon were sewed SS at the level distal to the ankle joint. The patellar tendon (PT) at the same side was used as control group. A unilateral midline incision was made and repaired with a single suture. The animals were killed at the 12th week postoperatively. The histological sections were obtained from the side of surgery from each group. Each sample was stained with hematoxylene and eosin (H&E). Gross and microscopic healing was compared between the two groups.

RESULTS

Gross examination of the control group showed complete healing with a thin peri-tendinous sheath formation around the suture site, whereas in the study group, a thick peri-tendinous sheath was formed around the area of the tendon-tendon anastomosis. In the control group, at the 12th week after surgery, the healing was almost completed in all samples. In the study group, a thick fibro vascular sheath has formed around the side of anastomosis. In all specimens few inter-digitations were observed between the tendons;however, the trough was still present.

CONCLUSION

The result of the current study showed that histological healing and union of SS tenorrhaphy differ from that in primary tendon injury and healing. Further studies are required to clarify the healing stages at the tenorrhaphy site.

Flexor tendon healing within the tendon sheath using bioabsorbable poly-L/D-lactide 96/4 suture. A histological in vivo study with rabbits

The bioabsorbable poly-L/D-lactide (PLDLA) 96/4 suture has good biomechanical and knot properties, and sufficient tensile strength half-life for flexor tendon repair. In the present study, the biocompatibility of PLDLA suture was compared with that of coated braided polyester suture in the rabbit flexor digitorum profundus tendon repaired within the tendon sheath. Postoperative unrestricted active mobilization was allowed. The tendons were studied histologically after 1-, 3-, 6-, 12-, 26-, and 52-week follow-ups. No differences were found in the biocompatibility between the suture materials, with only scattered multinuclear giant cells near the sutures in both groups from 6 weeks onwards. At 52 weeks, most of the PLDLA material was absorbed and the histological structure of the tendon appeared normal, whereas in the polyester repairs the suture knots filled the repair site, causing bulking of the tendon surface, and the collagen alignment appeared disoriented. The results suggest that the PLDLA 96/4 is a suitable suture material for flexor tendon repair.

Cell migration after synovium graft interposition at tendon repair site

BACKGROUND

We have recently reported that interpositional synovium grafts from tendon sheath have a potential to accelerate tendon healing when implanted at the repair site. The purpose of this study was to investigate the effect of orientation of the synovium after synovium graft transplantation, by comparing the ability of cells from the visceral and parietal surfaces to migrate into the tendon in a canine tissue culture model.

METHODS

The synovium graft was placed within a complete tendon laceration, with either the visceral or parietal surface facing the proximal end of the lacerated tendon. The number of migrating cells was quantified by a cell migration assay. Qualitative immunohistochemistry and confocal laser microscopy were also used at day 10.

RESULTS

Many labeled synovial cells were observed within the tendon to which the visceral surface of the synovium graft was facing. Migrated cells were also observed on the parietal side, but there were fewer cells compared to visceral surface cells. Migrating cells all expressed α-smooth muscle actin.

CONCLUSION

We found that graft orientation affected cell migration. Whether this finding has clinical significance awaits in vivo study.

The mechanics of flexor tendon adhesions

The mechanics of adhesions at a local tissue level have not been extensively studied. This study compared microstrains and macrostrains in adhesions of immobilized and mobilized partially lacerated flexor digitorum profundus tendons in a New Zealand White rabbit model. At 2 weeks, 50 digits were randomized to either gross tensile testing or micromechanical assessment, in which the movement of fluorescently labelled cell nuclei, acting as dynamic markers, was visualized using real-time confocal microscopy. The structural stiffness and load at failure of immobilized adhesions were 140% and 160% of that of mobilized adhesions, respectively, and both differences were statistically significant. Micromechanically, different patterns of loading and failure were observed. Mobilized adhesions exhibited over a three-fold higher local strain, which was less uniformly distributed. Confocal microscopy provided an accurate measure of local strain. For the first time, it has been possible to visualize, define, and quantify local adhesion tissue mechanics. Mobilization appears to favour the formation of sites expressing increased local strain responses or those predisposed to heterogeneity and localized failure.

The attachment of intrinsic and extrinsic, mobilized and immobilized adhesion cells to collagen and fibronectin

This study investigated the attachment of intrinsic and extrinsic, mobilized and immobilized adhesion cells to the extracellular matrix. Five New Zealand White rabbit forepaws were dissected to isolate the flexor tendon core, tendon surface and synovial sheath, which were explanted separately. A further 10 animals were subjected to flexor tendon injuries, randomized to either mobilization or immobilization, and adhesions were explanted at 2 weeks. Cell groups were tested for attachment to collagen type-I or fibronectin and morphometric analysis was made. The attachment of intrinsic tendon cells and adhesion cells from mobilized tendons to both matrix proteins was statistically significantly greater than that of extrinsic tendon cells and adhesion cells from immobilized tendons. Adhesion cells from mobilized tendons were statistically significantly more elongated, which may correlate with the deposition of a more organized matrix. Because the synovial sheath cells were least attached to matrix proteins, selective treatments that reduce cell attachment may be used to exclude them, without inhibiting intrinsic tendon healing.

Short and long terms healing of the experimentally transverse sectioned tendon in rabbits

Background

The incidences of tendon injuries in certain sections of human or animal populations such as athletes are high, but every human or animal, regardless of age or level of activity experiences some degree of tendon injury. In spite of the various investigations of injuries and treatment, comprehensive studies dealing with the histological, ultrastructural and biomechanical aspects of healing of load-bearing tendons are rare. This study was designed to compare the outcome of healing of the transverse sectioned superficial digital flexor tendon (SDFT) after 28 and 84 days post injury (DPI) in rabbits.

Methods

Forty white New Zealand mature female rabbits were randomly divided into two equal groups of 28 and 84 DPI After tenotomy and surgical repair of the left SDFT, the injured legs were casted for 14 days. The weight of the animals, tendon diameter, and clinical, radiographic and ultrasonographic evaluations were conducted at weekly intervals. The animals were euthanized on 28 and 84 DPI and the tendons were evaluated for histopathological, ultrastructural, biomechanical and percentage dry weight parameters.

Results

Although the clinical, ultrastructural, morphological and biomechanical properties of the injured tendons on day 84 showed a significant improvement compared to those of the 28 DPI, these parameters were still significantly inferior to their normal contra-lateral tendons.

Conclusions

This study showed that tendon healing is very slow and at 84 days post-injury the morphological and biomechanical parameters were still inferior to the normal tendons and many collagen fibrils still had the same diameter as those seen at 28 DPI.

TIEG1-null tenocytes display age-dependent differences in their gene expression, adhesion, spreading and proliferation properties

The remodeling of extracellular matrix is a crucial mechanism in tendon development and the proliferation of fibroblasts is a key factor in this process. The purpose of this study was to further elucidate the role of TIEG1 in mediating important tenocyte properties throughout the aging process. Wildtype and TIEG1 knockout tenocytes adhesion, spreading and proliferation were characterized on different substrates (fibronectin, collagen type I, gelatin and laminin) and the expression levels of various genes known to be involved with tendon development were analyzed by RT-PCR. The experiments revealed age-dependent and substrate-dependent properties for both wildtype and TIEG1 knockout tenocytes. Taken together, our results indicate an important role for TIEG1 in regulating tenocytes adhesion, spreading, and proliferation throughout the aging process. Understanding the basic mechanisms of TIEG1 in tenocytes may provide valuable information for treating multiple tendon disorders.

Bioreconstructive poly-L/D-lactide implant compared with Swanson prosthesis in metacarpophalangeal joint arthroplasty in rheumatoid patients: a randomized clinical trial

It was hypothesized that the bioresorbable interposition implant might offer a viable alternative to conventional silicone implant arthroplasty in rheumatoid metacarpophalangeal joint destruction. A randomized clinical study was performed to compare a stemless poly-L/D-lactide copolymer 96 : 4 (PLDLA) implant with the Swanson silicone implant. Results in 52 patients (53 hands and 175 joints) at a mean follow-up of 2 years (minimum 1 year) showed that the improvement in clinical assessments was comparable in both groups, except for better maintenance of palmar alignment in the Swanson group. The lack of implant fractures and intramedullary osteolysis were advantages of the PLDLA implant. The bioresorbable PLDLA interposition implant may offer an alternative tool for tailored reconstruction of rheumatoid metacarpophalangeal joints.

Effects of antisense transforming growth factor-beta1 gene transfer on the biological activities of tendon sheath fibroblasts

Recent studies have shown the importance of transforming growth factor-beta (TGF-beta) in flexor tendon wound healing. Decreased adhesion formation and increased range of motion after the administration of TGF-beta antibodies after tendon repair have been shown. But TGF-beta antibodies have a short biologic half-life, and continuous supplementation of exogenous TGF-beta antibodies is not practical. Transfer of growth factor genes to tenocytes provides an alternative to protein therapeutics, and a gene therapy approach will prolong the availability of therapeutic proteins.We investigated the biological activities effects of rabbit tendon sheath fibroblasts transfected by antisense TGF-beta1 gene. Tendon sheath fibroblasts were isolated from New Zealand white rabbits and transfected by antisense TGF-beta1 gene with Lipofectin (Invitrogen, Carlsbad, California). Reverse transcription polymerase chain reaction was used to measure collagen I, collagen III, and TGF-beta1 expression, and Western blot was used to measure collagen protein I expression in tendon sheath fibroblasts after being transfected by antisense TGF-beta1 gene. Reverse transcription polymerase chain reaction displayed that tendon sheath fibroblasts transfected with antisense TGF-beta1 gene showed marked decrease collagen I, collagen III, and TGF-beta1 mRNA expression. Western blot showed that tendon sheath fibroblasts transfected with antisense TGF-beta1 gene showed marked decrease expression of collagen I protein, and there was significant difference compared with the untransfected and empty transfected groups (P<.01). Tendon sheath fibroblasts can transfect with antisense TGF-beta1 gene successfully and can decrease production of collagen I, collagen III, and TGF-beta1, which were factors of tendon adhere formation.

A new barbed device for repair of flexor tendons

We split 100 porcine flexor tendons into five groups of 20 tendons for repair. Three groups were repaired using the Pennington modified Kessler technique, the cruciate or the Savage technique, one using one new device per tendon and the other with two new devices per tendon. Half of the tendons received supplemental circumferential Silfverskiöld type B cross-stitch. The repairs were loaded to failure and a record made of their bulk, the force required to produce a 3 mm gap, the maximum force applied before failure and the stiffness. When only one device was used repairs were equivalent to the Pennington modified Kessler for all parameters except the force to produce a 3 mm gap when supplemented with a circumferential repair, which was equivalent to the cruciate.

When two devices were used the repair strength was equivalent to the cruciate repair, and when the two-device repair was supplemented with a circumferential suture the force to produce a 3 mm gap was equivalent to that of the Savage six-strand technique.

Effects of synovial interposition on healing in a canine tendon explant culture model

PURPOSE

To investigate whether synovium interposition between repaired tendon ends can integrate into the tendon repair and improve tendon healing strength in a canine tendon explant culture model.

METHODS

We used 80 flexor digitorum profundus tendons from 10 mixed-breed dogs for this study. The flexor digitorum profundus tendons were assigned to 2 groups: repaired tendons with synovium implanted between the cut tendon ends and repaired tendons without any implantation between the tendon ends. The repaired tendons were cultured for either 2 or 4 weeks and then assessed mechanically for rupture strength and histology.

RESULTS

The strength of the repaired tendons with the synovium interposition was significantly higher (p < .001) than the repaired tendons without interposition at both 2 and 4 weeks. The strength of the repaired tendons at 4 weeks was significantly higher than that at 2 weeks in both groups.

CONCLUSIONS

Interpositional synovial grafts have the potential to accelerate tendon healing when they are implanted at the repair site. The exact mechanism of this effect remains to be elucidated.

The cellular biology of flexor tendon adhesion formation: an old problem in a new paradigm

Intrasynovial flexor tendon injuries of the hand can frequently be complicated by tendon adhesions to the surrounding sheath, limiting finger function. We have developed a new tendon injury model in the mouse to investigate the three-dimensional cellular biology of intrasynovial flexor tendon healing and adhesion formation. We investigated the cell biology using markers for inflammation, proliferation, collagen synthesis, apoptosis, and vascularization/myofibroblasts. Quantitative immunohistochemical image analysis and three-dimensional reconstruction with cell mapping was performed on labeled serial sections. Flexor tendon adhesions were also assessed 21 days after wounding using transmission electron microscopy to examine the cell phenotypes in the wound. When the tendon has been immobilized, the mouse can form tendon adhesions in the flexor tendon sheath. The cell biology of tendon healing follows the classic wound healing response of inflammation, proliferation, synthesis, and apoptosis, but the greater activity occurs in the surrounding tissue. Cells that have multiple "fibripositors" and cells with cytoplasmic protrusions that contain multiple large and small diameter fibrils can be found in the wound during collagen synthesis. In conclusion, adhesion formation occurs due to scarring between two damaged surfaces. The mouse model for flexor tendon injury represents a new platform to study adhesion formation that is genetically tractable.

A novel biomimetic material for engineering postsurgical adhesion using the injured digital flexor tendon-synovial complex as an in vivo model

BACKGROUND

Many surgical procedures are complicated by adhesions. These restrictive fibrotic bands form between normally separate gliding tissue layers, potentially impairing function. The authors tested the adhesion-modifying effect of a novel fibronectin-derived biomimetic biomaterial in a tendon-synovial complex injury model.

METHODS

The deep flexor tendons of digits 2 and 4 in the right forepaw of 15 New Zealand White rabbits were subjected to 5-mm-long partial tenotomies. Animals were randomized to receive biomaterial tubes enveloping the tendon injuries or left untreated. Digits, amputated at 2 weeks, were randomized to mechanical pullout assessments of adhesion strength or to quantitative histologic cellularity and immunohistochemical proliferation (Ki67) assessments.

RESULTS

The mean peak pullout force required to break the adhesions was reduced from 7.70 N (n = 6) in untreated digits to 0.31 N (n = 7) in biomaterial-treated digits (p = 0.001). The mean structural stiffness of the adhesions was also significantly reduced (p = 0.001). Histologically, treated and untreated digits demonstrated an equal incidence of adhesions. The treated adhesions were 55 percent less cellular at their surface than the untreated injured controls (p = 0.003). Treated tendons were 8 percent more cellular (with equal numbers of proliferating cells) at their surface and significantly more cellular within their bulk than positive controls (p <or= 0.05).

CONCLUSION

This study suggests a significant reduction in the restrictive nature of postsurgical adhesions following treatment with the antiadhesive biomaterial without compromising tendon cellularity.

Tendon: biology, biomechanics, repair, growth factors, and evolving treatment options

Surgical treatment of tendon ruptures and lacerations is currently the most common therapeutic modality. Tendon repair in the hand involves a slow repair process, which results in inferior repair tissue and often a failure to obtain full active range of motion. The initial stages of repair include the formation of functionally weak tissue that is not capable of supporting tensile forces that allow early active range of motion. Immobilization of the digit or limb will promote faster healing but inevitably results in the formation of adhesions between the tendon and tendon sheath, which leads to friction and reduced gliding. Loading during the healing phase is critical to avoid these adhesions but involves increased risk of rupture of the repaired tendon. Understanding the biology and organization of the native tendon and the process of morphogenesis of tendon tissue is necessary to improve current treatment modalities. Screening the genes expressed during tendon morphogenesis and determining the growth factors most crucial for tendon development will likely lead to treatment options that result in superior repair tissue and ultimately improved functional outcomes.

Effects of monofilament nylon coated with basic fibroblast growth factor on endogenous intrasynovial flexor tendon healing

PURPOSE

We developed a monofilament nylon thread that can release various growth factors to enhance intrinsic reparative processes after flexor tendon injury. We evaluated the properties of this thread in vitro and in vivo.

METHODS

Nylon threads were coated with gelatin that subsequently was cross-linked in glutaraldehyde. The thread was soaked in basic fibroblast growth factor (bFGF) solution (400 microg/mL). Exogenous bFGF in the thread was released constantly over the course of 1 week. The biologic activity of bFGF and the biomechanical strength of the thread were examined in vitro and its efficacy was investigated in an in vivo rabbit tendon repair model after early flexion exercises. The sutured sites were examined histologically (hematoxylin-eosin, immunohistochemistry, in situ hybridization), biochemically (Western blot test), and biomechanically (ultimate load) after surgery.

RESULTS

This gelatin-coated thread absorbed iodine 125-labeled bFGF in a time-dependent manner. The total amount of bFGF absorbed by the thread within the tendon tissue was between 3 and 15 mug depending on the concentration of bFGF solution. Basic fibroblast growth factor protein was delivered selectively-not in the surrounding scar but in the repaired tendon-for 3 weeks. Histologic analysis showed that the cellular density at the repaired site increased in accordance with the expression of bFGF messenger RNA and protein in the tendon. Endogenous bFGF expression seemed to be enhanced transiently by exogenous bFGF during the first few weeks. The epitenon showed a vigorous fibroblastic response to the coated thread and the ultimate load also was increased significantly at 3 weeks after surgery.

CONCLUSIONS

This bFGF-coated nylon suture gave excellent results in delivering a drug selectively to tendon; it also induced an increase of biomechanical strength and a thickening of the epitenon layer in vivo during a 3-week period, thereby accelerating cellular proliferation, initially peripherally and later centrally. This system may become a therapeutic tool to be used in hand surgery.

The scientific basis for advances in flexor tendon surgery

During the last 40 years, there has been an enormous amount of basic scientific research designed to improve our knowledge of the structure of tendons, the biomechanics of their action, their biologic response to injury and repair, the mechanical characteristics of various tendon suture methods, and the effect of postrepair motion stress on tendon strength and healing. These investigative efforts have given rise to improved methods of tendon repair and protocols for the early application of passive and active wrist and digital motion as a means to more rapidly increase the strength and gliding of repaired tendons. The surgical techniques of hand surgeons and the rehabilitation protocols of hand therapists have improved enormously from these scientific efforts and the results of flexor tendon repair have become much more reliable. This article attempts to review many of the important scientific reports dealing with flexor tendons that have been published during the last three-plus decades and indicate how those works have improved our management of these difficult injuries.

Mechanism of cell death in inflamed superficial digital flexor tendon in the horse

The aim of the present study was to clarify the presence and determine the role of apoptosis in the degenerative process of the superficial digital flexor tendon (SDFT) in the horse. Samples were obtained from normal and inflamed SDFTs of horses. To detect apoptosis and to identify apoptotic cells, the samples were subjected to immunohistochemical labelling and Western blot analysis. Although a large number of cells in degenerate areas showed positive reactions with caspase-3 and single stranded DNA antibodies, cells in normal tendon samples showed very weak reactions. Excessive apoptosis was confirmed by the results of Western blot analysis, which showed a significant increase in activated caspase-3 protein in the inflamed SDFTs, suggesting that apoptosis occurred in the tendinocytes via a caspase-3-dependent pathway. This is the first report of excessive apoptosis in inflamed SDFT of the horse. The results indicate that apoptosis may play an important role in the process of degeneration of the tendon as well as other tissues.

The future of flexor tendon surgery

Clinical outcomes following flexor tendon repair have made significant improvements in the last 50 years. In that time standard treatment has evolved from secondary grafting to primary repair with postoperative rehabilitation protocols. Unfortunately, excellent results are not yet attained universally following treatment. Improving understanding of tendon healing at the cellular, molecular, and genetic levels will likely enable surgeons to modulate the normal repair process. We now look toward biologic augmentation of flexor tendon repairs to address the problems of increasing tensile strength while reducing adhesion formation following injury and operative repair.

Clinical implications of growth factors in flexor tendon wound healing

Recent research has focused on the role of growth factors in flexor tendon wound healing. These basic science reports have described the identification and quantification of various growth factors in in vitro and in vivo models. Although these reports have begun to piece together the cascade of events involved in flexor tendon wound healing, the clinical relevance for the practicing hand surgeon is unclear. Growth factors are cell-secreted proteins that regulate cellular functions. These growth factors are involved in cell differentiation and growth, including the normal processes of development and tissue repair. Several growth factors recently have been identified as playing roles in tendon healing including vascular endothelial growth factor (VEGF), insulin-like growth factor (IGF), platelet-derived growth factor (PDGF), basic fibroblast growth factor (bFGF), and transforming growth factor beta (TGF-beta). In addition, the transcription factor NF-kappaB has been implicated in the signaling pathways of these growth factors. The purpose of this article is to describe what is known about the molecular basis of flexor tendon wound healing, to review the most commonly studied growth factors, and to summarize likely clinical applications of these growth factors to flexor tendon repair.

Promoting the proliferative and synthetic activity of knee meniscal fibrochondrocytes using basic fibroblast growth factor in vitro

BACKGROUND

Meniscal tears situated within the inner avascular region do not heal despite suturing. New approaches need to be developed to augment surgical repair.

HYPOTHESIS

To demonstrate that basic fibroblast growth factor, used as a single agent or in combination with serum, stimulates the activity of fibrochondrocytes by enhancing proliferation and extracellular matrix synthesis in all meniscal zones, including the inner (avascular) zone of the meniscus.

STUDY DESIGN

Controlled laboratory study.

METHODS

Monolayer cell cultures were prepared from the inner, middle, and outer zones of the lateral meniscus. Various concentrations of basic fibroblast growth factor were used in the presence or absence of 10% fetal calf serum. The authors measured the uptake of radiolabeled thymidine to assess cell proliferation and radioactive sulfur and proline to assess extracellular matrix formation.

RESULTS

Overall, basic fibroblast growth factor-stimulated cells from all meniscal zones to proliferate and to form new extra-cellular matrix (P <.05). The basic fibroblast growth factor (in the absence of serum) increased DNA formation and protein synthesis by cells from the inner meniscal zone by 7- and 15-fold, respectively (P <.001).

CONCLUSIONS

These results indicate that meniscal cells and, more important, cells from the avascular zone are capable of responding favorably to the addition of basic fibroblast growth factor by expressing their intrinsic potential to proliferate and generate new extracellular matrix.

CLINICAL RELEVANCE

The results suggest that it may be possible to augment surgical repair of the meniscus in the future.

Inhibition of TGF-beta-induced collagen production in rabbit flexor tendons

PURPOSE

Postoperative adhesions frequently compromise the success of flexor tendon repair. Manipulation of growth factors responsible for scar formation may be a method of decreasing adhesion formation. Transforming growth factor beta (TGF-beta) is a key cytokine in the pathogenesis of tissue fibrosis. The purpose of this study was to examine the effectiveness of TGF-beta neutralizing antibody in blocking TGF-beta-induced collagen I production in rabbit flexor tendons in vitro.

METHODS

Sheath fibroblasts, epitenon tenocytes, and endotenon tenocytes were obtained from rabbit flexor tendons. Each cell culture was supplemented with 1 ng/mL of TGF-beta along with increasing doses of TGF-beta neutralizing antibody (0.1-2.0 microg/mL). Collagen I production was measured by enzyme-linked immunoabsorbent assay and TGF-beta bioactivity was measured by the luciferase assay. Results were compared with TGF-beta alone and unsupplemented controls.

RESULTS

The addition of neutralizing antibody significantly reduced TGF-beta-induced collagen I production in a dose-dependent manner in all 3 cell cultures. TGF-beta bioactivity was also reduced by its neutralizing antibody.

CONCLUSIONS

This study shows that TGF-beta inhibition through its neutralizing antibody was effective in cultured flexor tendon cells. The results encourage further experiments that use such agents to modulate flexor tendon wound healing in in vivo models in the hope of eventually blocking the effect of TGF-beta on flexor tendons clinically.

Synovial sheath cell migratory response to flexor tendon injury: an experimental study in rats

PURPOSE

We aimed to investigate the degree of participation of synovial sheath cells in the process of tendon healing by selective cell labeling and direct observation of migrational pathways.

METHODS

We designed a novel rat animal model that employed vital dye staining of synovial sheath cells. The flexor digitorum profundus (FDP) tendon was removed from its sheath and vital dye was applied directly to the synovial sheath cells. A window was cut in the removed tendon before being returned to the sheath, thus placing a tendon injury adjacent to the labeled synovial sheath cells. The synovium remained intact at all times, and labeling was confirmed to be localized to the synovium. The migrational response of the synovial sheath cells to the tendon injury was observed by harvesting the tendons at 1, 3, 5, and 7 days (n = 6 for each time period) after injury and assessing tendon response with frozen sections under ultraviolet microscopy.

RESULTS

Labeled synovial sheath cells were observed within the substance of the healing tendon 24 hours after injury, with numbers increasing with time for up to 5 days, but decreasing by day 7.

CONCLUSIONS

This study confirms that in the rat model synovial sheath cells move into the healing tendon area and then migrate into the tendon core.

Tissue engineering of flexor tendons

Despite technical advances in suture methods and rehabilitation protocols, challenges remain in the field of flexor tendon repair. This article reviews the state-of-the-art research in the tissue engineering of flexor tendons. These early published data will hopefully lay the foundation for molecular methods and materials that can be used to reconstruct tendons to restore normal form and function in the hand.

Differences in morphology, cytoskeletal architecture and protease production between zone II tendon and synovial fibroblasts in vitro

Fibroblast migration is an integral component of the processes resulting in the formation of restrictive adhesions in the injured tendon, especially in Zone II. Pre-requisites for cell migration are an intact cytoskeleton and an ability to biochemically degrade the extra-cellular matrix. The relative characteristics of fibroblasts from the fibro-osseus sheath (SC), the tissue surrounding the tendon in Zone II, and the endotenon (TC) with respect to morphology, cytoskeletal structure and ability to produce matrix metalloproteinases (MMPs) 2 and 9 were compared in vitro. It was found that SCs were larger in size and demonstrated greater amounts of intra-cellular alpha-smooth muscle actin (alpha-SMA) and intra-membranous vinculin. Filamentous actin (F-actin) fibres in SCs were more densely packed and concentrated, resulting in stress fibres. The SCs also produce greater amounts of MMP-2 and MMP-9 compared to TCs. These observations imply that SCs play an active role in adhesion formation and should be specifically targeted to inhibit or treat tendon adhesions.

Tendon cells produce gelatinases in response to type I collagen attachment

Cells that carry out wound healing must be able to perform catabolic as well as anabolic functions. As the tendon is a tissue rich in extracellular matrix (ECM) proteins, we hypothesized that cells which participate in tendon healing should be able to produce proteases that would allow the remodeling of such a tissue. To this end, we assessed the ability of endotenon cells isolated from canine flexor digitorum profundus tendon and from surrounding parietal sheath to produce the gelatinases MMP-2 and MMP-9. Endotenon and sheath cells cultured in vitro on polystyrene produced small amounts of MMP-2 and MMP-9 was not detectable. When cultured on polystyrene coated with type I collagen, the cells upregulated MMP-2 production and MMP-9 production was induced. No other ECM protein elicited this response nor did other cell lines respond in this way after attachment to type I collagen. The two gelatinases were identified by immunological methods, ability to bind gelatin, size, metal ion requirement, serine protease inhibitor insensitivity, and APMA activation. For cells grown on collagen-coated plastic, gelatinase upregulation was proportional to the amount of ligand present until saturation was reached. For any group of fresh tendon cells, MMP-2 and MMP-9 upregulation was greater in a three dimensional collagen gel than the highest response from the same group under two dimensional culture conditions. Attachment of the cells to type I collagen increased the ratio of active to inactive MMP-2. Dexamethasone inhibited the upregulation of both MMP-2 and MMP-9. These results show that ECM proteins can influence both the production and the state of activation of these matrix metalloproteinases.

The early surface cell response to flexor tendon injury

PURPOSE

The migratory response of surface fibroblasts to flexor tendon injury was studied by their selective labeling with a vital dye.

METHOD

The surfaces of 30 rat deep flexor tendons were bathed in 1,1'-dioctadecyl-3,3,3',3'-tetramethylindocarbocyanine percholate (DiI), a vital dye for 5 minutes. The residual dye was removed by thorough irrigation. A partial tenotomy was made in the stained section by cutting out a central window. Semiquantitative cell counts and position of stained fibroblasts were noted by examination under fluorescent light at 0, 1, 3, 5, and 7 days.

RESULTS

The surface fibroblasts readily took up the vital dye at day 0. By day 1 dyed cells had moved into the cut. By day 3 they had migrated laterally into the core substance of the tendon. Core dyed cell counts at days 1, 3, 5, and 7 were significantly different compared with day 0 core dyed cell counts.

CONCLUSIONS

This cell migration from the surface of the cut to the tendon core is likely to be vital in the early stages of tendon healing.

Biomimetic approaches to tendon repair

The linear organization of collagen fibers in tendons results in optimal stiffness and strength at low strains under tensile load. However, this organization makes repairing ruptured or lacerated tendons extremely difficult. Current suturing techniques to join split ends of tendons, while providing sufficient mechanical strength to prevent gapping, are inadequate to carry normal loads. Immobilization protocols necessary to restore tendon congruity result in scar formation at the repair site and peripheral adhesions that limit excursion. These problems are reviewed to emphasize the need for novel approaches to tendon repair, one of which is the development of biomimetic tendons. The objective of the empirical work described here was to produce biologically-based, biocompatible tendon replacements with appropriate mechanical properties to enable immediate mobilization following surgical repair. Nor-dihydroguaiaretic acid (NDGA), a di-catechol from creosote bush, caused a dose dependent increase in the material properties of reconstituted collagen fibers, achieving a 100-fold increase in strength and stiffness over untreated fibers. The maximum tensile strength of the optimized NDGA treated fibers averaged 90 MPa; the elastic modulus of these fibers averaged 580 MPa. These properties were independent of strain rates ranging from 0.60 to 600 mm/min. Fatigue tests established that neither strength nor stiffness were affected after 80 k cycles at 5% strain. Treated fibers were not cytotoxic to tendon fibroblasts. Fibroblasts attached and proliferated on NDGA treated collagen normally. NDGA-fibers did not elicit a foreign body response nor did they stimulate an immune reaction during six weeks in vivo. The fibers survived 6 weeks with little evidence of fragmentation or degradation. The polymerization scheme described here produces a fiber-reinforced NDGA-polymer with mechanical properties approaching an elastic solid. The strength, stiffness and fatigue properties of the NDGA-treated fibers are comparable to those of tendon. These fibers are biocompatible with tendon fibroblasts and elicit little rejection or antigenic response in vivo. These results indicate that NDGA polymerization may provide a viable approach for producing collagenous materials that can be used to bridge gaps in ruptured or lacerated tendons. The tendon-like properties of the NDGA-fiber would allow early mobilization after surgical repair. We predict that timely loading of parted tendons joined by this novel biomaterial will enhance mechanically driven production of neo-tendon by the colonizing fibroblasts and result in superior repair and rapid return to normal properties.

Thermal preconditioning prevents peritendinous adhesions and inflammation

Adhesion formation is one of the foremost obstacles to a reliably good outcome in tendon and joint surgery. Thermal preconditioning has been found to reduce the inflammatory response through the induction of molecular chaperone expression, a recently described family of cytoprotective intracellular proteins. The authors analyzed the effect of thermal preconditioning on the inflammatory response to surgery, on tendon healing, and on the formation of peritendinous adhesions in 16 New Zealand White rabbits. Very significant decreases in adhesion formation and in the gliding and dimensions of tendons in animals that had thermal preconditioning were found. Tendons from these animals also showed a decreased level of adhesion formation and a significantly diminished inflammatory response on histologic examination with no biomechanically significant deleterious effect on the strength of tendon healing on testing load to failure. These findings are consistent with induction of heat shock proteins by hyperthermic pretreatment. Such prevention of peritendinous adhesions and the inflammatory response to injury and surgery without compromising healing are findings that have significant implications for tendon surgery and all surgery involving joints and soft tissues.

Early breaking strength of repaired flexor tendon treated with 5-fluorouracil

This study investigated the effect of a single intraoperative application of 5-fluorouracil, which may diminish peritendinous adhesion formation, on the tensile strength of repaired digital flexor tendons after 7, 14 and 21 days of healing. Twenty-seven deep flexor tendons from 14 rabbits were exposed to 5-fluorouracil (50 mg/ml) for 5 minutes immediately after repair whereas matched control tendons were exposed to normal saline. Tensile testing at 7, 14 and 21 days revealed no significant differences in the gap or ultimate strengths of the 5-fluorouracil treated and control tendons.

Reduction in matrix metalloproteinase production by tendon and synovial fibroblasts after a single exposure to 5-fluorouracil

This study investigated the effect of treatment with 5min exposures to 5-fluorouracil (5-FU) on the production of matrix metalloproteinases (MMPs) by endotenon and synovial fibroblasts. Fibroblasts were grown from the flexor tendons of New Zealand White rabbits and were then exposed to varying concentrations (ranging from 0.25 mg x ml(-1)to 25 mg x ml(-1)of 5-FU for 5 min. The treated fibroblasts were suspended in a three-dimensional collagen lattice. The conditioned media from these collagen lattices were then analysed for MMP production using gelatin zymography on days 1, 3 and 7 after treatment. In the majority of cases this treatment produced a dose- and time-dependent reduction in total MMP production by both cell lines, specifically in the production of MMPs 2 and 9. This reduction was significant for most concentrations (P< or =0.01-P< or =0.05) when compared to phosphate-buffered-saline-treated controls. We conclude that 5-FU may reduce adhesions by limiting the migratory capacity of synovial fibroblasts (extrinsic healing).

Suppression of fibrous adhesion by proteoglycan decorin

Small proteoglycan decorin is known to suppress the bioactivity of TGF-beta through a competitive binding with the cell surface receptors for the cytokine. Based on this knowledge, we hypothesized that decorin could reduce the formation of fibrous adhesion, because our previous study showed the neutralizing antibody to TGF-beta1 has that effect. An intra-articular adhesion model in the rabbit knee joint was employed in this study, and decorin was administered into the joint cavity continuously during the 4 weeks of the experiment. The results of the dose-response study demonstrated that decorin suppresses formation of fibrous adhesion in a dose-dependent manner. When the administration of decorin was limited to shorter periods, this effect was considerably impaired and the necessity of long-term administration was demonstrated. On the other hand, when administered together with TGF-beta1, decorin still suppressed adhesion but to a lesser extent, and it was suggested that this proteoglycan could have other significant mechanism(s) to suppress adhesion besides the neutralization of TGF-beta. Thus, the present study showed that decorin could inhibit adhesion formation by both TGF-beta dependent and independent mechanisms. Considering that decorin exists ubiquitously in the body, its administration might be a promising approach to suppress adhesion.

Neutralization of fibroblast growth factor-2 reduces intraarticular adhesions

Adhesion is a serious complication after trauma or surgery. Because adhesion formation is essentially a fibrogenetic process, a series of growth factors are assumed to be involved in its development. If this is true, it may be possible that inhibition of the growth factor activity suppresses adhesion formation. The current study was conducted to verify this hypothesis on fibroblast growth factor-2 using an intraarticular adhesion model in the rabbit knee. Forty Japanese White rabbits were used. They were divided randomly into five groups of eight animals, and in three of them, activity of endogenous fibroblast growth factor-2 was suppressed locally by a neutralizing antibody. The remaining two groups served as controls, and formation of adhesions was evaluated 4 weeks after surgery. The results showed that the administration of the antibody reduced the extent of adhesions macroscopically, whereas histologic observation and collagen content measurement suggested the adhesion tissue was not affected significantly. Corresponding to the macroscopic findings, contraction of the knee was improved in the antibody groups. The findings showed that suppression of fibroblast growth factor-2 activity reduces adhesions. It is expected that control of the cytokine activity may become a novel method for reducing adhesions.

In vitro effects of epidermal growth factor or insulin-like growth factor on tenoblast migration on absorbable suture material

OBJECTIVE

To determine the effects of epidermal growth factor (EGF) or insulin-like growth factor (IGF) on tenoblast migration on absorbable suture material using an in vitro model.

STUDY DESIGN

An in vitro evaluation of tenoblast migration.

ANIMAL OR SAMPLE POPULATION

Segments of the long digital flexor tendon were obtained from Cobb chickens (9-11 weeks old) immediately after the birds were euthanatized.

METHODS

Tissue culture explants of tendons containing absorbable suture material were treated with either EGF or IGF. Tenoblast migration was assessed daily using an inverted microscope equipped with bright field and phase optics. Tenoblast migration was assessed according to the following criteria: time of first cell appearance, percent of explant interfaces producing cells, migration distance, and terminal migration index at 120 and 168 hours.

RESULTS

EGF had a stimulatory effect on tenoblast migration for cells originating from the endotenon interfaces. No significant effect was noted on migration distance for cells originating from epitenon interfaces. A stimulatory effect on the percentage of interfaces producing cells and a significant decrease in time of first cell appearance were also observed after EGF treatment. IGF-stimulated cell migration distance for epitenon interfaces but this stimulatory effect did not occur at a higher concentration. IGF was inhibitory to percent of epitenon and endotenon interfaces producing cells but decreased time of first cell appearance at low concentration.

CONCLUSIONS

Using an in vitro model, EGF had a stimulatory effect on tenoblast migration. IGF was stimulatory at low concentration levels but inhibitory at a higher concentration. Increased migration distance was observed for endotenon interfaces after EGF treatment and for epitenon interfaces after IGF treatment.

CLINICAL RELEVANCE

EGF or IGF might enhance tendon repair if they could be delivered to the repair site. Incorporation of EGF or IGF into suture material would allow slow release and prolonged exposure of migrating tenoblasts to growth factors.

Flexor tendon repair in a rabbit model using a "core" of extensor retinaculum with synovial membrane. An experimental study

In this histological and biomechanical study in two groups of rabbits, a piece of the extensor retinaculum with its synovial membrane was inserted as a biological "core" into a hole at the centre of both stumps of a severed tendon, which was repaired with interrupted sutures. In the other group, the tendon was sutured without a "core". In the "core" group, proliferation and migration of fibroblasts from both tendon surfaces and the "core" surface toward the deep layer of the suture site was seen 2 weeks after operation. New collagen fibres, aligned parallel to the long axis of the tendon, could also be seen 4 weeks after operation, and healing was more advanced than in the coreless model. The maximum force to produce a gap in the "core" tendon was 82% greater than in the coreless tendon 4 weeks after operation.

Treatment of flexor tendon injuries: surgeons' perspective

Medical researchers continue to explore the flexor tendon's response to injury and repair. In recent years, hand surgery and therapy publications have focused on the biomechanics of suture techniques and the benefits of early postoperative motion on surgically repaired flexor tendons. Laboratory and clinical studies have shown that stronger suture techniques can withstand the strain of immediate active motion without a significant risk of tendon rupture or gap formation. Newly proposed therapy techniques and anatomic studies defining the effects of wrist and digital position on tendon excursion share the goals of achieving early motion and reducing restrictive adhesions. Clinical studies have evaluated the various imaging modalities used to diagnose postoperative adhesions. Other clinical surveys have detailed the use of pedicled autograft and allograft tendons in staged reconstruction. Histologic and immunologic researchers have concentrated on cellular activation patterns following tendon injury and the effects of pharmacologic agents, such as hyaluronan and aprotinin, on tendon healing and adhesion formation.

Decrease in adhesion formation by a single application of 5-fluorouracil after flexor tendon injury

Using an animal model, the effect of a single intraoperative application of 5-fluorouracil on digital flexor tendon adhesions was assessed. After a standard partial division of the tendon and immobilization with a stitch, the synovial sheath in 30 rabbit tendons was treated with 5-fluorouracil solution (50 mg/ml)-soaked sponge pledgets for 5 minutes. Buffered saline was substituted for 5-fluorouracil in 30 control tendons. The tendons were harvested 1 week postoperatively, and histologic sections were assessed with a light microscope. There was a significant reduction in synovial sheath thickening (p < 0.001), cell counts (p < 0.001) and proportional length of adhesions (p < 0.001) in the treated tendons. The reduction in synovial reaction and adhesion formation using this "one touch" technique presents a novel strategy for the management of the clinical problem of postoperative adhesions complicating tendon injury and repair.

Differential cellular response within the rabbit tendon unit following tendon injury

The cellular changes in the epitenon, endotenon and synovial sheath were investigated in a rabbit model after a partial transverse laceration was made on the plantar aspect of the flexor digitorum profundus proximal to the synovial sheath (which was not injured). Fibroblasts, macrophages and mast cells within the epitenon, endotenon and synovial sheath were counted on electron micrographs. The epitenon and uninjured synovial sheath became engorged with fibroblasts and macrophages following injury. The number of synovial fibroblasts showed the greatest increase during the first week after injury. In comparison, the endotenon exhibited a delay in cellular response with initial apoptosis, as judged by positive P53 staining. However, hypercellular activity was seen within the endotenon at 12 weeks postoperatively.