Role of humoral immune reactions as target for antirejection therapy in recipients of a spousal-donor kidney graft

On a Long and Winding Road: Alloantibodies in Organ Transplantation

Today we know that both the humoral and the cellular arm of the immune system are engaged in severe immunological challenges. A close interaction between B and T cells can be observed in most "natural" challenges, including infections, malignancies, and autoimmune diseases. The importance and power of humoral immunity are impressively demonstrated by the current coronavirus disease 2019 pandemic. Organ transplant rejection is a normal immune response to a completely "artificial" challenge. It took a long time before the multifaceted action of different immunological forces was recognized and a unified, generally accepted opinion could be formed. Here, we address prominent paradigms and paradigm shifts in the field of transplantation immunology. We identify several instances in which the transplant community missed a timely paradigm shift because essential, available knowledge was ignored. Moreover, we discuss key findings that critically contributed to our understanding of transplant immunology but sometimes developed with delay and in a roundabout way, as was the case with antibody-mediated rejection-a main focus of this article. These include the discovery of the molecular principles of histocompatibility, the recognition of the microcirculation as a key interface of immune damage, the refinement of alloantibody detection, the description of C4d as a footmark of endothelium-bound antibody, and last but not least, the developments in biopsy-based diagnostics beyond conventional morphology, which only now give us a glimpse of the enormous complexity and pathogenetic diversity of rejection.

Outcome of Husband-to-Wife Kidney Transplantation With Mutual Children: Single Center Experience Using T Cell-Depleting Induction and Review of the Literature

Few data on husband-to-wife transplantations with mutual children (H2W) exist in the current era. We investigated the outcome of H2W transplantations (n = 25) treated with T cell-depleting induction compared to women with prior pregnancies also receiving their first HLA-mismatched kidney transplant, but from a different donor source: (i) other living donor (n = 52) and (ii) deceased donor (n = 120). Seventy-four percent of the women had ≥2 pregnancies; median follow-up time was 5 years. Death-censored allograft survival was significantly lower in the H2W group compared to the other two groups (p = 0.03). Three of four graft losses in the H2W group were due to rejection. 5-year patient survival in the H2W group was high and similar compared to the other living donor group (100 vs. 98%; p = 0.28). The incidence of (sub)clinical antibody-mediated rejection was higher in the H2W group (36 vs. 20 vs. 18%) (p = 0.10). The frequency of infections was similar among the three groups. No immunological parameter was predictive for rejection or graft loss in H2W transplantations. In conclusion, H2W transplantation is a valuable option, but associated with a higher risk for allograft loss due to rejection despite T cell-depleting induction. Further research is required for better risk prediction on an individual patient level.

Outcomes of Living-Donor Kidney Transplantation in Female Recipients with Possible Pregnancy-Related Pre-Sensitization According to Donor Relationship

BACKGROUND Given that pregnancy is an immune-sensitizing event, female kidney transplant recipients who receive allografts from their offspring or husbands may have a higher risk of rejection and graft failure due to pre-sensitization acquired during pregnancy or childbirth. We investigated the association between donor relatedness (i.e., offspring, husband, unrelated) and graft survival among female living-donor kidney transplant (LDKT) recipients with pregnancy histories. MATERIAL AND METHODS From January 2009 to January 2018, a total of 2060 LDKTs were performed at Asan Medical Center, Seoul, Korea. After excluding HLA-incompatible transplantation, re-transplantation, and those without a clear history of childbirth, 390 female recipients were included and categorized into group I (offspring-to-mother, n=175), group II (husband-to-wife, n=159), and group III (unrelated, n=56). The primary endpoint was biopsy-proven acute rejection (BPAR) and graft survival. We also evaluated delayed graft function (DGF), death-censored graft failure, and mortality. RESULTS Group I had the lowest number of HLA mismatches (p<0.001), and group II had the highest number of ABO-incompatible transplantations (p=0.005). At 5 years after transplant, graft survival and death-censored graft survival did not significantly differ among the 3 groups (graft survival: 96.0% vs. 95.5% vs. 93.3%, p=0.685; death-censored graft survival: 98.3% vs. 97.5% vs. 100%, p=0.732). Five-year BPAR-free survival showed no significant differences among the 3 groups (88.6 vs. 88.7 vs. 88.6%, p=0.842). Group II had the highest rate of clinical rejection (p=0.103) and DGF (p=0.174), but the difference was not statistically significant. CONCLUSIONS Female LDKT recipients with possible pregnancy-related pre-sensitization who received grafts from offspring or husbands did not show significantly worse clinical outcomes than those who received grafts from unrelated donors.

The Role of Long-Lived Plasma Cells in Antibody-Mediated Rejection of Kidney Transplantation: An Update

Background

Antibody-mediated rejection (ABMR) following kidney transplant is closely associated with poor prognosis of the recipients. Long-lived plasma cells (LLPCs) produce alloantibodies as long as life time and play a crucial role in ABMR.

Summary

LLPCs generate from germinal centers and reside in survival niches in the bone marrow as well as the inflamed tissues. They are the main and long-term source of the antibodies. LLPCs mediate ABMR via the generation of preformed antibodies in sensitized patients and de novo antibodies after transplantation. They have been acknowledged as the leading causes of ABMR; however, LLPCs are insensitive to traditional immunosuppressive therapy that removes B cells. Strategies targeting LLPCs, such as antithymocyte globulin, proteasome inhibitors as well as monoclonal antibodies, are promising methods to persistently and thoroughly clear the entire PC pool.

Key Message

LLPCs play an important role in ABMR by producing alloantibodies continually, and targeting LLPCs might be a novel and effective approach against ABMR.

Sex and gender disparities in the epidemiology and outcomes of chronic kidney disease

Improved understanding of sex and gender-specific differences in the aetiology, mechanisms and epidemiology of chronic kidney disease (CKD) could help nephrologists better address the needs of their patients. Population-based studies indicate that CKD epidemiology differs by sex, affecting more women than men, especially with regard to stage G3 CKD. The effects of longer life expectancy on the natural decline of glomerular filtration rate (GFR) with age, as well as potential overdiagnosis of CKD through the inappropriate use of GFR equations, might be in part responsible for the greater prevalence of CKD in women. Somewhat paradoxically, there seems to be a preponderance of men among patients starting renal replacement therapy (RRT); the protective effects of oestrogens in women and/or the damaging effects of testosterone, together with unhealthier lifestyles, might cause kidney function to decline faster in men than in women. Additionally, elderly women seem to be more inclined to choose conservative care instead of RRT. Dissimilarities between the sexes are also apparent in the outcomes of CKD. In patients with predialysis CKD, mortality is higher in men than women; however, this difference disappears for patients on RRT. Although access to living donor kidneys among men and women seems equal, women have reduced access to deceased donor transplantation. Lastly, health-related quality of life while on RRT is poorer in women than men, and women report a higher burden of symptoms. These findings provide insights into differences in the underlying pathophysiology of disease as well as societal factors that can be addressed to reduce disparities in access to care and outcomes for patients with CKD.

Sex and gender disparities in the epidemiology and outcomes of chronic kidney disease

Improved understanding of sex and gender-specific differences in the aetiology, mechanisms and epidemiology of chronic kidney disease (CKD) could help nephrologists better address the needs of their patients. Population-based studies indicate that CKD epidemiology differs by sex, affecting more women than men, especially with regard to stage G3 CKD. The effects of longer life expectancy on the natural decline of glomerular filtration rate (GFR) with age, as well as potential overdiagnosis of CKD through the inappropriate use of GFR equations, might be in part responsible for the greater prevalence of CKD in women. Somewhat paradoxically, there seems to be a preponderance of men among patients starting renal replacement therapy (RRT); the protective effects of oestrogens in women and/or the damaging effects of testosterone, together with unhealthier lifestyles, might cause kidney function to decline faster in men than in women. Additionally, elderly women seem to be more inclined to choose conservative care instead of RRT. Dissimilarities between the sexes are also apparent in the outcomes of CKD. In patients with predialysis CKD, mortality is higher in men than women; however, this difference disappears for patients on RRT. Although access to living donor kidneys among men and women seems equal, women have reduced access to deceased donor transplantation. Lastly, health-related quality of life while on RRT is poorer in women than men, and women report a higher burden of symptoms. These findings provide insights into differences in the underlying pathophysiology of disease as well as societal factors that can be addressed to reduce disparities in access to care and outcomes for patients with CKD.

Prevention and treatment of alloantibody-mediated kidney transplant rejection

Antibody-mediated rejection (AMR), which is commonly caused by preformed and/or de novo HLA alloantibodies, has evolved as a leading cause of early and late kidney allograft injury. In recent years, effective treatment strategies have been established to counteract the deleterious effects of humoral alloreactivity. One major therapeutic challenge is the barrier of a positive pretransplant lymphocytotoxic crossmatch. Several apheresis- and/or IVIG-based protocols have been shown to enable successful crossmatch conversion, including a strategy of peritransplant immunoadsorption for rapid crossmatch conversion immediately before deceased donor transplantation. While such protocols may increase transplant rates and allow for acceptable graft survival, at least in the short-term, it has become evident that, despite intense treatment, many patients still experience clinical or subclinical AMR. This reinforces the need for innovative strategies, such as complementary allocation programs to improve transplant outcomes. For acute AMR, various studies have suggested efficiency of plasmapheresis- or immunoadsorption-based protocols. There is, however, no established treatment for chronic AMR and the development of strategies to reverse or at least halt chronic active rejection remains a big challenge. Major improvements can be expected from studies evaluating innovative therapeutic concepts, such as proteasome inhibition or complement blocking agents.

Pre-kidney-transplant blood transfusions do not improve transplantation outcome: a Dutch national study

BACKGROUND

Female renal transplant candidates are prone to be sensitized by prior pregnancies, and undetected historical sensitization might decrease transplantation outcome. Hypothesis of our study was that pre-transplant blood transfusions (PTFs) can elucidate historical sensitization and that the avoidance of the associated antigens can improve transplantation outcome.

METHODS

Data from all female non-immunized renal transplant candidates who received a random PTF (rPTF) (n = 620), matched PTF (mPTF) (one HLA-A and B and one HLA-DR match) (n = 86) or donor-specific blood transfusion (DST) (n = 100) between 1996 and 2006 were collected. Complement-dependent cytoxicity was used to detect anti-HLA antibodies. Sensitization and transplantation outcomes after a PTF were analyzed. Non-immunized female renal transplant recipients who did not receive a PTF were used as the control group.

RESULTS

In 165 patients, anti-HLA antibodies (IgG) were detected after the PTF. Both historical and primary sensitizations were found. A DST induced donor-specific anti-HLA antibodies in 25% of the DST recipients. Our policy did not improve transplantation outcome in recipients of a kidney from a deceased donor (n = 368) or in recipients of a living donor [DST (n = 49) and mPTF (n = 66)].

CONCLUSIONS

A PTF did elucidate historical sensitization but induce primary sensitization as well. No beneficial effect of PTFs on transplantation outcome was found, and PTFs with the intention to detect historical sensitization are therefore not suggested.

Antibody-mediated rejection: treatment alternatives and outcomes

Over the past 10 years, thanks to the development of sensitive methods of antibody detection and markers of antibody injury such as C4d staining, the role of anti-human leukocyte antigen (HLA) and non-HLA alloantibodies as effectors of acute and chronic immune allograft injury has been revisited. Antibody-mediated rejection (AMR) defines all allograft rejection caused by antibodies directed against donor-specific HLA molecules, blood group antigen (ABO)-isoagglutinins, or endothelial cell antigens. Antibody-mediated rejection can be a recalcitrant process, resistant to therapy and carries an ominous prognosis to the graft. In concordance with these views, treatment protocols for AMR use permutations of a multiple-prong approach that include (1) the suppression of the T-cell dependent antibody response, (2) the removal of donor reactive antibody, (3) the blockade of the residual alloantibody, and (4) the depletion of naive and memory B-cells. Although all published protocols report a variable rate of success, a major weakness of all current protocols is the lack of effective anti-plasma cell agents. In comparison to acute AMR, the treatment for chronic AMR (CAMR) is not well characterized. Although in acute AMR large titers of pre-existent alloantibodies result in massive activation of the complement system and lytic injury of the graft endothelium, thereby requiring aggressive and fast removal of the offending agents, in CAMR, complement activation results in sublytic endothelial cell injury and activation. Although this type of injury results in chronic graft failure, its slow progression likely renders it amenable of suppression by heightening of maintenance immunosuppression and anti-idiotypic blockade of the circulating alloantibody without the need of plasma exchange. In this review, we will discuss the rationale behind the design of treatment protocols for acute AMR and CAMR as well as their reported results and complications.

Offspring-to-mother and husband-to-wife renal transplantation: a single-center experience

BACKGROUND

It has been demonstrated that graft survival rates of offspring-to-mother and husband-to-wife renal transplants are equivalent to those of other living donors. Although the vast majority of these transplants proceed without incident, hyperacute rejection can result from an anamnestic reaction subsequent to the in utero exposure of the mother to human leukocyte antigen (HLA) of the fetus with sensitization developing during the pregnancy.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

Among 1350 renal transplants performed at our center, 12 corresponded to offspring-to-mother (G1) and 9 were husband-to-wife transplantations (G2). All recipients were multiparous (2 to 5 children). We compared these patients with other multiparous women (n = 150) who received grafts from living unrelated donors (G3).

RESULTS

Two subjects in G1 (16.6%), two in G2 (22.2%), and none in G3 developed hyperacute rejection, which led to graft loss. One, 3-, and 5-year patient and graft survival rates were different between the remaining patients.

CONCLUSIONS

Our limited experience suggested that, for some women, pregnancy is in fact a sensitizing event. A pretransplantation cross-match testing negative result was by no means an absolute guarantee that an adverse anamnestic immunological event would not occur.

C4d in pediatric renal allograft biopsies: a marker for negative outcome in steroid-resistant rejection

Recently, deposition of C4d, reflecting complement activation via the classical pathway, has been established as marker of antibody-mediated rejection. As C4d can be detected in paraffin sections, it allows for retrospective analysis in populations with low case loads, such as in pediatric transplantation. In this study we re-evaluated consecutive renal transplant biopsies obtained since 1990 in 36 children (18 boys, 18 girls) who had received their allograft (nine living, 27 cadaveric) at an age of 10.12+/-4.4 yr. Clinical indications for biopsy were 16 acute steroid resistant rejections (ASRs), 11 chronic rejections and nine other diagnoses. Overall, C4d deposition was found in nine cases (25%), eight of them with diagnosed ASR. Six out of these eight allografts were lost during 36 months of clinical follow-up, a significantly higher rate than in C4d-negative biopsies (p<0.05). C4d status therefore turned out to be an excellent predictor for inferior graft survival following ASR. None of the other histopathologic markers were sensitive for humoral rejections. In conclusion, the high prevalence of C4d-positive staining in ASR demonstrates the importance of the humoral part of the immune system in pediatric transplantation. The worse outcome of C4d-positive rejections despite massive immunosuppressive therapy clearly indicates the need for innovative therapies in this high-risk population.

Immunosuppression and immune monitoring after renal transplantation

Monitoring of immunosuppression therapy in renal transplant recipients is essential for good patient and graft survival. Monitoring includes frequent laboratory assays of serum immunosuppression levels, patient visits to assess and treat side effects, and vigilance for medication interactions. We review the various immunosuppression medications commonly used in renal transplantation, including usual dosing and side effects. Monitoring assays are discussed, as well as the frequency of monitoring and patient visits. Finally, we discuss several common clinical scenarios that often require adjustment of immunosuppression medications or regimens.

Accelerated rejection following offspring-to-mother and husband-to-wife transplants

It has been demonstrated that graft survival rates of offspring-to-mother and husband-to-wife renal transplants are equivalent to those of other living donors. Although the vast majority of these transplants proceed without incident, we have encountered several instances of delayed accelerated rejections that are not predicted by a positive cross-match. The accelerated rejection can result from an anamnestic reaction subsequent to the in utero exposure of the mother to human leukocyte antigen (HLA) antigens of the fetus with sensitization developing during the pregnancy.

Plasmapheresis in C4d-positive Acute Humoral Rejection Following Kidney Transplantation: A Review of 4 Cases

Acute and chronic rejection after kidney transplantation has long been exclusively attributed to cellular and vascular mechanisms. Modern immunosuppressive therapy, therefore, addresses the cellular immune system. Rising experiences in kidney transplantation in the last few decades have revealed that some types of rejection are refractory to the conventional immunosuppressive treatment. Humoral rejection. which has previously been reported as a crucial factor in hyperacute rejection, is now suspected to play also an important role in acute and chronic rejection. Acute humoral rejection (AHR) is characterized by immunohistochemical detection of C4d deposits in peritubular capillaries. As shown for other antibody-mediated diseases, such as some autoimmune diseases, plasmapheresis has been suggested to be an efficient therapeutic approach in AHR. We present four patients with C4d-positive AHR in the early phase after kidney transplantation. In three of the four patients, humoral graft rejection was successfully treated by plasmapheresis. Graft function was significantly improved with a stable long-term outcome. One patient lost the graft. Although the number of patients with C4d-positive AHR treated by plasmapheresis is limited, plasma exchange appears to be an efficient and powerful therapeutic approach to control humoral rejection.

The role of B cells and alloantibody in the host response to human organ allografts

Some human organ transplants deteriorate slowly over a period of years, often developing characteristic syndromes: transplant glomerulopathy (TG) in kidneys, bronchiolitis obliterans in lungs, and coronary artery disease in hearts. In the past, we attributed late graft deterioration to "chronic rejection", a distinct but mysterious immunologic process different from conventional rejection. However, it is likely that much of chronic rejection is explained by conventional T-cell-mediated rejection (TMR), antibody-mediated rejection (AMR), and other insults. Recently, criteria have emerged to now permit us to diagnose AMR in kidney transplants, particularly C4d deposition in peritubular capillaries and circulating antibody against donor human leukocyte antigens (HLA). Some cases with AMR develop TG, although the relationship of TG to AMR is complex. Thus, a specific diagnosis of AMR in kidney can now be made, based on graft damage, C4d deposition, and donor-specific alloantibodies. Criteria for AMR in other organs must be defined. Not all late rejections are AMR; some deteriorating organs probably have smoldering TMR. The diagnosis of late ongoing AMR raises the possibility of treatment to suppress the alloantibody, but efficacy of the available treatments requires further study.

Evidence that humoral allograft rejection in lung transplant patients is not histocompatibility antigen-related

We have recently recognized humoral rejection (HR) in lung allograft recipients and its association with acute and chronic graft dysfunction. We have shown that C4d, a stable marker of classic complement activation, is deposited in lung allografts, correlating with clinical rejection and parenchymal injury. The antigenic target may be endothelium in the setting of recurrent acute rejection while varying components of the bronchial wall may be important in chronic graft dysfunction. We sought to establish whether there is a role for antibodies with histocompatibility antigen specificity in the lung humoral allograft phenomenon. Flow cytometric and ELISA assays to assess donor-specific antigens were conducted on sera from 25 lung transplant recipients who had experienced one or more episodes of clinical rejection; in addition, the serum samples were tested for evidence of antiendothelial cell antibody activity. Morphologically, each case had biopsies showing septal capillary injury with significant deposits of immunoreactants with microvascular localization and positive indirect immunofluorescent antiendothelial cell antibody assay. Panel-reactive antibody testing showed absence of MHC Class I/II alloantibodies; ELISA based crossmatch detecting donor-specific MHC Class I/II specific antibodies was negative. HR can occur in the absence of antibodies with HLA specificity; antigenic targets may be of endothelial cell origin.

C3D deposition in peritubular capillaries indicates a variant of acute renal allograft rejection characterized by a worse clinical outcome

BACKGROUND

C4d deposition in peritubular capillaries (PTCs) is a sign of humoral renal allograft rejection and an independent predictor of graft survival. Few investigators have focused on the meaning of capillary C3 deposition in rejecting grafts. Because C3 production can result from both classic and alternative pathway activation of the complement cascade, it is not clear whether C3 deposition indicates a distinct entity of acute rejection (AR) or merely represents a separate form of C4d-positive AR.

METHODS

We examined the deposition of C3d in the PTCs of recipients with AR in the first year posttransplantation (n=30). Clinical outcome variables and histology were compared with C3d-negative control patients (n=82).

RESULTS

C3d-positive patients demonstrated more frequent preexisting T-cell antibodies (57%) and more re-transplants (37%), and they received more blood transfusions (mean 10.3 units). C3d-positive patients experienced more frequent multiple AR episodes (57%) and delayed graft function (36.7%). All nine C3d-positive recipients screened for posttransplantation donor-specific human leukocyte antigen antibodies demonstrated positive results. Graft failure occurred in 23% of C3d-positive recipients (7.3% in the control group) (P=0.03). C3d-positive biopsies showed significantly less tubulitis (P=0.03), whereas congestive PTCs with intraluminal accumulation of polymorphonuclear leukocytes were conspicuous. Thrombi, fibrinoid necrosis, and acute tubular necrosis were not more pronounced. In 19% of rejection biopsies, C3d deposition in PTCs was present without C4d deposition. In the remaining biopsies, C3d and C4d deposition was found simultaneously.

CONCLUSIONS

The deposition of complement factor C3d in PTCs indicates a variant type of AR characterized by a worse clinical outcome.

Beneficial effect of plasmapheresis and intravenous immunoglobulin on renal allograft survival of patients with acute humoral rejection

BACKGROUND

Acute humoral rejection (AHR) has been associated with enhanced graft loss. Our study compared the renal allograft survival of patients with AHR treated with plasmapheresis (PP) and intravenous immunoglobulin (IVIG) with allograft survival in patients with acute cellular rejection (ACR).

METHODS

We retrospectively analyzed all kidney transplants performed at our institution between January 1999 and August 2001 (n=286). Recipients were classified into three groups according to biopsy reports: AHR, ACR, or no rejection. The ACR group was further divided into early and late rejection (<90 and >90 days posttransplant, respectively).

RESULTS

After a mean follow-up of 569+/-19 days, the incidence of AHR was 5.6% (n=16). Recipient presensitization, delayed graft function, early rejection, and higher creatinine at diagnosis were characteristic of AHR. Most AHR patients (14/16) were treated with PP and IVIG. One patient received only IVIG, whereas another received only PP. All AHR patients were given steroid pulses, but only four received antilymphocyte therapy because of concomitant severe ACR. The ACR group comprised 43 patients (15%). One patient with mild rejection received no therapy, 20 improved with steroids alone, and 22 required additional antilymphocyte therapy. One-year graft survival by Kaplan Meier analysis was 81% and 84% in the AHR and ACR groups, respectively (P=NS). Outcomes remained similar when AHR patients were compared with those with early ACR.

CONCLUSIONS

We conclude that AHR, when diagnosed early and treated aggressively with PP and IVIG, carries a short-term prognosis that is similar to ACR.

Tissue injury and repair in allografts: novel perspectives

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

Recent research achievements might considerably alter scientific concepts of pathways involved in tissue injury and repair.

RECENT FINDINGS

Accumulating evidence for an important role of alloantibodies in acute and chronic allograft rejection led to a renewed interest in humoral kidney transplant rejection. Studies reassessing the mechanisms of antibody- and complement-mediated injury now shed new light on the pathogenic mechanisms underlying acute or chronic graft dysfunction and injury. A closer look at humoral effector mechanisms revealed that endothelial cell activation and injury may play a key role in humoral rejection, and further uncovered an important interplay between humoral and cellular alloimmunity. Regeneration of cells after injury has been thought to rely on activation of local progenitor cells. Recent investigation indicates that regeneration of grafted solid organs is not exclusively based on self-renewal of tissues but obviously also involves repopulation of the graft by recipient cells, creating chimerism in the vasculature and other compartments. Besides reparative compensation of cell loss, chimerism of endothelial cells might also alter immunologic properties of the graft, thus favoring adaptation and graft survival. On the other hand, however, myofibroblasts mediating deleterious arterial intimal proliferation may also be of recipient origin. A possible source of graft-repopulating recipient cells are bone marrow-derived adult stem cells with the amazing capacity of differentiating into cell types of all three germ cell layers.

SUMMARY

Reliable diagnosis of humoral mechanisms in allograft rejection and identification of involved effector mechanisms should provide the basis for development and targeted application of specific anti-humoral treatment. Recently emerged new concepts of mechanisms underlying tissue regeneration might pave the way for entirely new therapeutic approaches in human disease.

A case of acute antidonor antibody-mediated humoral rejection after renal transplantation with specific consideration of serial graft biopsy histology

A 61-year-old-woman with end-stage renal disease caused by IgA nephropathy received living unrelated kidney transplantation from her husband in February 2001. Pre-transplant donor-specific T- and B-cell cross-match was negative. Immunosuppressive treatment consisted of tacrolimus (TAC), mycophenolate mofetil (MMF), methylprednisolone (MP) and antilymphocyte globulin (ALG). The kidney functioned immediately after kidney transplantation. On post-operative day 9, the level of serum creatinine (S-Cr) rose from 1.1 to 1.5 mg/dL. The allograft biopsy specimen taken on the day revealed moderate accumulations of polymorphonuclear leucocytes in peritubular capillaries (PTCs), dilatation of PTCs and transplant glomerulitis, moderate to severe. Immunofluorescent study of a frozen section of the allograft biopsy specimen showed a strong, diffusely distributed endothelial staining pattern in PTCs for the stable complement split product C4d. Post-transplant donor-specific T- and B-cell cross-matches performed on post-operative day 13 were positive. From the allograft biopsy and the positive post-transplant donor-specific T- and B-cell cross-matching, acute humoral rejection (AHR) associated with the development of antidonor antibodies (ADA) was diagnosed. Plasma exchange (PE) treatment was initiated on day 11. After a total of 13 treatments of PE, donor-specific T- and B-cell cross-matches became negative and the biopsy performed on day 72 revealed mild transplant glomerulopathy without accumulation of polymorphonuclear leucocytes in PTCs or a C4d staining pattern in PTCs of immunofluorescence. The allograft functioned well and the creatinine level was 1.1 mg/dL 7 months post-transplant. This was a case of AHR after renal transplantation associated with the development of ADA, which was triggered by spousal-donor antigens. The presence of widespread C4d deposition in PTCs in renal allograft biopsies played a role in the diagnosis of AHR and the diagnosis was confirmed by positive donor-specific T- and B-cell cross-matches at the time of rejection, which were negative at pre-transplantation. Several treatments of PE were effective for resolving AHR in this case and the effect of PE in the treatment of AHR could be assessed by the degree of peritubular capillaritis (PTCitis) and C4d deposits in PTCs.

Capillary deposition of complement split product C4d in renal allografts is associated with basement membrane injury in peritubular and glomerular capillaries: a contribution of humoral immunity to chronic allograft rejection

Endothelial deposition of the complement split product C4d is an established marker of antibody-mediated acute renal allograft rejection. A contribution of alloantibody-dependent immune reactions to chronic rejection is under discussion. In this study, the association of immunohistochemically detected endothelial C4d deposition in peritubular capillaries (PTC) with morphologic features of chronic renal allograft injury was investigated in a large study cohort. C4d deposits in PTC were detected in 73 (34%) of 213 late allograft biopsies performed in 213 patients more than 12 mo after transplantation (median, 4.9 yr) because of chronic allograft dysfunction. Endothelial C4d deposition was found to be associated with chronic transplant glomerulopathy (CG) (P < 0.0001), with basement membrane multilayering in PTC (P = 0.01), and with an accumulation of mononuclear inflammatory cells in PTC (P < 0,001). Furthermore, C4d deposits in PTC (in biopsies with normal glomerular morphology) were associated with development of CG in follow-up biopsies. Other morphologic features of chronic allograft nephropathy (with exception of tubular atrophy) were not associated with C4d deposits in PTC. Analyses of previous and follow-up biopsies revealed that C4d deposits may occur de novo and may also disappear at any time after transplantation. In conclusion, the data suggest that complement activation in renal microvasculature, indicating humoral alloreactivity, contributes to chronic rejection characterized by chronic transplant glomerulopathy and basement membrane multilayering in PTC.

Flow cytometric evaluation of pregnancy-induced anti-HLA immunization and blood transfusion-induced reactivation

BACKGROUND

Pregnancy-induced alloimmunization (PIA) may decrease to a level that becomes undetectable by complement-dependent cytotoxicity (CDC). Nevertheless, such alloimmunization may provoke acute rejections after kidney transplantation and lead to broad-spectrum immunizations after transfusion. Flow-cytometry (FC) was used to estimate the frequency of low-level PIA and to evaluate its influence on posttransfusion alloimmunization profiles.

METHODS

To evaluate the frequency of low-level PIA, the sera of 36 women, free of CDC-detectable anti-HLA IgG (CDC-IgG- negative), were cross-matched by FC against their husband's or offspring's lymphocytes and further analyzed with human leukocyte antigen (HLA) Ag-coated microbeads (Flow-PRA One-Lambda, Canoga Park, CA). To evaluate the influence of low-level alloimmunization on posttransfusion appearance of CDC-IgG, pretransfusion sera of a second cohort of 43 women, also CDC-IgG-negative and included in a transfusion protocol, were analyzed by Flow-PRA. Posttransfusion sera were analyzed for the development of cytotoxic IgG.

RESULTS

Ten of the first cohort of 36 (27.8%) CDC-IgG-negative women showed a positive FC cross-match against the husband or offspring lymphocytes. Flow-PRA analysis confirmed that 9 of 10 positive cross-matched sera contained anti-HLA IgG. Among the 43 transfused patients, 11 of 16 (68.7%) of the women who were CDC-IgG-positive after blood transfusion showed FC-detectable IgG before transfusion; although 2 of 27 (7.4%) of the patients who remained CDC-IgG-negative after transfusion showed FC-detectable IgG before transfusion (P <0.001).

CONCLUSION

Most of the de novo anti-HLA immunizations detected by CDC after transfusion in previously pregnant women can be detected by Flow-PRA before transfusion.

Capillary C4d deposition in kidney allografts: a specific marker of alloantibody-dependent graft injury

Capillary deposition of the complement split product C4d has been discussed as a marker for antibody-mediated kidney allograft rejection. The relationship between C4d staining and posttransplant alloantibody detection remains to be thoroughly investigated, however. In this study, C4d staining in peritubular capillaries (PTC) and the incidence of alloantibody formation, as detected with sensitive techniques, were evaluated among a cohort of transplant recipients who had undergone biopsies and had not been selected for a specific histologic diagnosis. One hundred thirteen biopsies, obtained from 58 cadaveric kidney transplant recipients, were tested. Serum samples obtained at the time of biopsy were evaluated by flow cytometric crossmatch (FCXM) testing and FlowPRA (One Lambda, Inc., Canoga Park, CA) analysis of anti-HLA panel reactivity. Most biopsies with C4d deposits in PTC (C4d(PTC)(+), n = 21 of 24) were associated with positive posttransplant FCXM results (T and/or B cell FCXM) and/or > or =5% FlowPRA (anti-HLA class I and/or II) reactivity. Approximately 50% of the C4d(PTC)(-) biopsies were observed to be associated with donor-specific alloantibodies. Accordingly, high specificity (93%) but low sensitivity (31%) were calculated for capillary C4d staining (with FCXM testing as the standard method). For clinical evaluation, three patient groups were defined, i.e., a group of recipients with positive C4d staining in at least one allograft biopsy (C4d(PTC)(+), n = 16) and two C4d(PTC)(-) groups, which were discriminated on the basis of posttransplant FCXM results as C4d(PTC)(-)/FCXM(+) (n = 22) and C4d(PTC)(-)/FCXM(-) (n = 20) groups. Univariate analyses revealed significant differences between these groups with respect to serum creatinine levels at 12 mo [median, 2.83 mg/dl (interquartile range, 1.93 to 4.2 mg/dl) versus 1.78 mg/dl (1.47 to 2.24 mg/dl) versus 1.59 mg/dl (1.2 to 1.71 mg/dl), P < 0.001]. Of the five immunologic graft losses, four occurred in the C4d(PTC)(+) group and one occurred in the C4d(PTC)(-)/FCXM(+) group. In a multivariate analysis, C4d positivity was observed to have an independent predictive value for inferior 12-mo graft function (P = 0.02), whereas the observed moderate difference between C4d(PTC)(-)/FCXM(+) and C4d(PTC)(-)/FCXM(-) recipients did not achieve significance. In conclusion, these data demonstrate that positive C4d staining, which is an independent predictor of kidney graft dysfunction, represents a reliable specific marker for antibody-dependent graft injury.

Acute humoral renal allograft rejection

In kidney transplantation, it is well established that donor-specific antibodies can cause substantial graft injury. Hyperacute rejection, now virtually eliminated by routine pretransplant cytotoxic crossmatch testing, represents the prototype of humoral rejection. However, there is now increasing evidence that alloantibody-mediated immune reactions may also cause acute rejection. Acute humoral rejection, which is frequently associated with severe graft dysfunction and immunologic graft loss, represents a particular diagnostic and therapeutic challenge. Reliable detection of antibody-mediated graft injury is required to govern the application of antihumoral therapeutic strategies. This review focuses on new approaches in the diagnosis and treatment of acute humoral rejection. Special attention is given to a novel diagnostic marker, the complement split product C4d.

C4d deposition in acute rejection: an independent long-term prognostic factor

Peritubular capillary deposition of C4d has been demonstrated to be associated with both acute humoral and vascular rejection and increased graft loss. Whether it is an independent predictor of long-term graft survival rates is uncertain. The biopsies (n = 126) from all patients (n = 93) with a tissue diagnosis of acute rejection that were performed between July 1, 1995, and December 31, 1997, were classified according to Cooperative Clinical Trials in Transplantation (CCTT) criteria. Fresh frozen tissue was immunostained for C4d. There were 58 patients with CCTT type I (interstitial) rejection and 35 with CCTT type II (vascular) rejection. For 34 patients, at least one biopsy exhibited peritubular C4d deposition (C4d+ group). The C4d+ group had proportionately more female patients (P = 0.003), more patients with high (>30%) panel-reactive antibody levels (P = 0.024), more patients with resistance to conventional antirejection therapy (P = 0.010), and fewer patients with postrejection hypertension (P = 0.021) and exhibited a greater rate of graft loss (38 versus 7%, P = 0.001). Peritubular C4d deposition was associated with significantly lower graft survival rates in the CCTT type I rejection group (P = 0.003) and the CCTT type II rejection group (P = 0.003). Multivariate analyses demonstrated that peritubular C4d deposition (P = 0.0002), donor age (P = 0.0002), cold ischemic time (P = 0.0211), and HLA matches (P = 0.0460) were significant independent determinants of graft survival rates. Peritubular C4d deposition is a significant predictor of graft survival rates and is independent of histologic rejection type and a variety of clinical prognostic factors.

Detection of the complement degradation product C4d in renal allografts: diagnostic and therapeutic implications

The immunohistochemical detection of the complement degradation product C4d, a component of the classical complement pathway, offers a new and currently poorly defined tool in the evaluation of renal allograft biopsies. Our retrospective study aims at determining the diagnostic and clinical significance of C4d accumulation in kidney transplants, employing immunofluorescence microscopy. We analyzed 398 diagnostic allograft biopsies (n = 265 patients with 1 to 5 biopsies obtained 7 to 7165 d posttransplantation [tx]) and correlated the detection of C4d with 18 histologic changes, panel-reactive antibody titers, response to treatment, and outcome. One hundred twenty-five native kidney and baseline tx biopsies served as controls. Linear deposition of C4d along peritubular capillaries was only found in a subgroup (30%) of allografts post-tx, mainly during the early time-course (median, 38 d post-tx; range, 7 to 5646 d). There was no significant association with infections. C4d staining could change from negative to positive and vice versa within days to weeks. The accumulation of C4d was most tightly linked to a morphologic subtype of rejection, transplant glomerulitis (P < 0.0001). In addition, tubular MHC class II expression was correlated with C4d deposition (P < 0.0001). Both features are signs of "acute active rejection." In comparison with C4d-negative controls, 43% of C4d-positive patients showed increased (>10%) panel-reactive antibody titers (versus 19% in the negative group; P = 0.001). C4d positivity was frequently associated with higher serum creatinine levels at time of biopsy (compared with C4d-negative group; P < 0.01). More C4d-positive patients were treated with polyclonal antithymocyte globulins (ATG) or monoclonal anti-CD3 antibodies (OKT3) (P < 0.0001). Outcome did not significantly differ between C4d-positive and C4d-negative groups. In conclusion, the detection of C4d identifies a humoral alloresponse in a subgroup of kidney transplants, which is often associated with signs of cellular rejection, i.e. tx glomerulitis. Allograft dysfunction in C4d-positive rejection episodes is often more pronounced. We provide first evidence that C4d-positive rejection might benefit from intensive therapy, potentially preventing the previously reported high graft failure rate. In addition, we show that a subgroup of C4d-positive cases may not require any immediate therapeutic intervention. The presence of C4d is clinically relevant and should be reported in the histologic diagnosis.

C4d-positive acute humoral renal allograft rejection: effective treatment by immunoadsorption

There is increasing evidence for an important pathogenetic role of alloantibodies in acute renal allograft rejection. Acute humoral rejection (AHR) has been reported to be associated with a poor transplant survival. Although treatment modalities for cellular rejection are fairly well established, the optimal treatment for AHR remains undefined. Ten of 352 kidney allograft recipients transplanted at the authors' institution between November 1998 and September 2000 were diagnosed as having AHR, supported by severe graft dysfunction, C4d deposits in peritubular capillaries (PTC), and accumulation of granulocytes in PTC. AHR was diagnosed 18.9 +/- 17.5 d posttransplantation. All patients were subjected to immunoadsorption (IA) with protein A (median number of treatment sessions, 9; range, 3 to 17). Seven recipients with additional signs of cellular rejection (according to the Banff classification) received also antithymocyte globulin. In nine of ten patients, AHR was associated with an increase in panel reactive antibody reactivity. A pathogenetic role of alloantibodies was further supported by a positive posttransplant cytotoxic crossmatch in all tested recipients (n = 4). In nine of ten recipients, renal function recovered after initiation of anti-humoral therapy. One patient lost his graft shortly after initiation of specific therapy. Another recipient with partial reversal of AHR returned to dialysis 8 mo after transplantation. Mean serum creatinine in functioning grafts was 2.2 +/- 1.2 mg/dl after the last IA session (n = 9) and 1.5 +/- 0.5 mg/dl after a follow-up of 14.2 +/- 7.1 mo (n = 8). In conclusion, this study suggests that AHR, characterized by severe graft dysfunction, C4d staining, and peritubular granulocytes, can be effectively treated by timely IA. In the majority of patients, IA treatment can restore excellent graft function over a prolonged time period.

Endothelial C4d deposition is associated with inferior kidney allograft outcome independently of cellular rejection

BACKGROUND

Capillary deposition of complement split product C4d has been suggested to be a valuable marker for humoral rejection. In this retrospective study we evaluated the clinical impact of C4d deposition in renal allografts with special emphasis on associations between C4d staining patterns and histological features of acute rejection.

METHODS

One hundred and two allograft biopsies obtained from 61 kidney transplants (1-532 days after transplantation; median 14 days) were examined by immunohistochemistry on routine paraffin sections using a novel anti-C4d polyclonal antibody (C4dpAb).

RESULTS

Fourty-two of 102 biopsies showed endothelial C4d deposits in peritubular capillaries (PTC). Histopathological analysis revealed a significantly lower frequency of positive C4d staining in biopsies with rather than in those without acute cellular rejection defined by the Banff grading schema (P<0.01). For clinical evaluation, patients were classified according to C4d staining in allografts (C4d(PTC) positive in at least one biopsy, n=31 vs C4d(PTC) negative in all biopsies, n=30). C4d(PTC) positive patients had significantly higher serum creatinine levels than C4d negative patients. Even in the absence of morphological evidence for rejection, differences in serum creatinine levels between C4d(PTC) positive and negative recipients were significant (6 months: 2.01+/-0.75 vs 1.41+/-0.27 mg/dl; 12 months: 1.95+/-0.60 vs 1.36+/- 0.34 mg/dl; 18 months: 1.98+/-0.50 vs 1.47+/-0.31 mg/dl; P<0.05). All patients with rejection resistant to conventional therapy (n=4) were in the C4d(PTC) positive subgroup. All recipients with panel reactive antibodies (PRA) >50% (n=8) were C4d(PTC) positive.

CONCLUSIONS

Our data indicate that endothelial C4d deposition is associated with inferior graft outcome. We provide evidence that this immunohistochemical finding and its clinical impact are not associated with morphological signs of cellular rejection.