Reaction pathways in transcript elongation

CBR antimicrobials alter coupling between the bridge helix and the β subunit in RNA polymerase

Bacterial RNA polymerase (RNAP) is a validated target for antibacterial drugs. CBR703 series antimicrobials allosterically inhibit transcription by binding to a conserved α helix (β' bridge helix, BH) that interconnects the two largest RNAP subunits. Here we show that disruption of the BH-β subunit contacts by amino-acid substitutions invariably results in accelerated catalysis, slowed-down forward translocation and insensitivity to regulatory pauses. CBR703 partially reverses these effects in CBR-resistant RNAPs while inhibiting catalysis and promoting pausing in CBR-sensitive RNAPs. The differential response of variant RNAPs to CBR703 suggests that the inhibitor binds in a cavity walled by the BH, the β' F-loop and the β fork loop. Collectively, our data are consistent with a model in which the β subunit fine tunes RNAP elongation activities by altering the BH conformation, whereas CBRs deregulate transcription by increasing coupling between the BH and the β subunit.

Mechanistically consistent reduced models of synthetic gene networks

Designing genetic networks with desired functionalities requires an accurate mathematical framework that accounts for the essential mechanistic details of the system. Here, we formulate a time-delay model of protein translation and mRNA degradation by systematically reducing a detailed mechanistic model that explicitly accounts for the ribosomal dynamics and the cleaving of mRNA by endonucleases. We exploit various technical and conceptual advantages that our time-delay model offers over the mechanistic model to probe the behavior of a self-repressing gene over wide regions of parameter space. We show that a heuristic time-delay model of protein synthesis of a commonly used form yields a notably different prediction for the parameter region where sustained oscillations occur. This suggests that such heuristics can lead to erroneous results. The functional forms that arise from our systematic reduction can be used for every system that involves transcription and translation and they could replace the commonly used heuristic time-delay models for these processes. The results from our analysis have important implications for the design of synthetic gene networks and stress that such design must be guided by a combination of heuristic models and mechanistic models that include all relevant details of the process.

On the move

Single-molecule experiments have shed new light on the mechanisms responsible for the movement of RNA polymerase along DNA during transcription.

Complete dissection of transcription elongation reveals slow translocation of RNA polymerase II in a linear ratchet mechanism

During transcription elongation, RNA polymerase has been assumed to attain equilibrium between pre- and post-translocated states rapidly relative to the subsequent catalysis. Under this assumption, recent single-molecule studies proposed a branched Brownian ratchet mechanism that necessitates a putative secondary nucleotide binding site on the enzyme. By challenging individual yeast RNA polymerase II with a nucleosomal barrier, we separately measured the forward and reverse translocation rates. Surprisingly, we found that the forward translocation rate is comparable to the catalysis rate. This finding reveals a linear, non-branched ratchet mechanism for the nucleotide addition cycle in which translocation is one of the rate-limiting steps. We further determined all the major on- and off-pathway kinetic parameters in the elongation cycle. The resulting translocation energy landscape shows that the off-pathway states are favored thermodynamically but not kinetically over the on-pathway states, conferring the enzyme its propensity to pause and furnishing the physical basis for transcriptional regulation. DOI:http://dx.doi.org/10.7554/eLife.00971.001.

Suppression of in vivo Rho-dependent transcription termination defects: evidence for kinetically controlled steps

The conventional model of Rho-dependent transcription termination in bacteria requires RNA-dependent translocase activity of the termination factor Rho as well as many kinetically controlled steps to execute efficient RNA release from the transcription elongation complex (EC). The involvement of the kinetically controlled steps, such as RNA binding, translocation and RNA release from the EC, means that this termination process must be kinetically coupled to the transcription elongation process. The existence of these steps in vivo has not previously been delineated in detail. Moreover, the requirement for translocase activity in Rho-dependent termination has recently been questioned by a radical view, wherein Rho binds to the elongating RNA polymerase (RNAP) prior to loading onto the mRNA. Using growth assays, microarray analyses and reporter-based transcription termination assays in vivo, we showed that slowing of the transcription elongation rate by using RNAP mutants (rpoB8 and rpoB3445) and growth of the strains in minimal medium suppressed the termination defects of five Rho mutants, three NusG mutants defective for Rho binding and the defects caused by two Rho inhibitors, Psu and bicyclomycin. These results established the existence of kinetically controlled steps in the in vivo Rho-dependent termination process and further reinforced the importance of 'kinetic coupling' between the two molecular motors, Rho and RNAP, and also argue strongly that the Rho translocation model is an accurate representation of the in vivo situation. Finally, these results indicated that one of the major roles of NusG in in vivo Rho-dependent termination is to enhance the speed of RNA release from the EC.

The origins of time-delay in template biopolymerization processes

Time-delays are common in many physical and biological systems and they give rise to complex dynamic phenomena. The elementary processes involved in template biopolymerization, such as mRNA and protein synthesis, introduce significant time delays. However, there is not currently a systematic mapping between the individual mechanistic parameters and the time delays in these networks. We present here the development of mathematical, time-delay models for protein translation, based on PDE models, which in turn are derived through systematic approximations of first-principles mechanistic models. Theoretical analysis suggests that the key features that determine the time-delays and the agreement between the time-delay and the mechanistic models are ribosome density and distribution, i.e., the number of ribosomes on the mRNA chain relative to their maximum and their distribution along the mRNA chain. Based on analytical considerations and on computational studies, we show that the steady-state and dynamic responses of the time-delay models are in excellent agreement with the detailed mechanistic models, under physiological conditions that correspond to uniform ribosome distribution and for ribosome density up to 70%. The methodology presented here can be used for the development of reduced time-delay models of mRNA synthesis and large genetic networks. The good agreement between the time-delay and the mechanistic models will allow us to use the reduced model and advanced computational methods from nonlinear dynamics in order to perform studies that are not practical using the large-scale mechanistic models.

Monitoring RNA transcription in real time by using surface plasmon resonance

The decision to elongate or terminate the RNA chain at specific DNA template positions during transcription is kinetically regulated, but the methods used to measure the rates of these processes have not been sufficiently quantitative to permit detailed mechanistic analysis of the steps involved. Here, we use surface plasmon resonance (SPR) technology to monitor RNA transcription by Escherichia coli RNA polymerase (RNAP) in solution and in real time. We show that binding of RNAP to immobilized DNA templates to form active initiation or elongation complexes can be resolved and monitored by this method, and that changes during transcription that involve the gain or loss of bound mass, including the release of the sigma factor during the initiation-elongation transition, the synthesis of the RNA transcript, and the release of core RNAP and nascent RNA at intrinsic terminators, can all be observed. The SPR method also permits the discrimination of released termination products from paused and other intermediate complexes at terminators. We have used this approach to show that the rate constant for transcript release at intrinsic terminators tR2 and tR' is approximately 2-3 s(-1) and that the extent of release at these terminators is consistent with known termination efficiencies. Simulation techniques have been used to fit the measured parameters to a simple kinetic model of transcription and the implications of these results for transcriptional regulation are discussed.

A Central Role of the RNA Polymerase Trigger Loop in Active-Site Rearrangement during Transcriptional Pausing

Transcriptional pausing by RNA polymerase is an underlying event in the regulation of transcript elongation, yet the physical changes in the transcribing complex that create the initially paused conformation remain poorly understood. We report that this nonbacktracked elemental pause results from an active-site rearrangement whose signature includes a trigger-loop conformation positioned near the RNA 3' nucleotide and a conformation of betaDloopII that allows fraying of the RNA 3' nucleotide away from the DNA template. During nucleotide addition, trigger-loop movements or folding appears to assist NTP-stimulated translocation and to be crucial for catalysis. At a pause, the trigger loop directly contributes to the paused conformation, apparently by restriction of its movement or folding, whereas a previously postulated unfolding of the bridge helix does not. This trigger-loop-centric model can explain many properties of transcriptional pausing.

Mechanochemical kinetics of transcription elongation

The mechanochemical kinetics of transcription elongation was examined with a combination of theoretical and experimental approaches. The predictive power of a sequence-dependent thermal ratchet model for transcription elongation was tested by establishing model parameters based solely on measurements under chemical perturbations and then directly predicting responses under mechanical perturbations without additional model parameters. Agreement between predicted and measured force-velocity curves provides strong support for a simple mechanochemical coupling mechanism.

Single-molecule approaches reveal the idiosyncrasies of RNA polymerases

Recently developed single-molecule techniques have provided new insights into the function of one of the most complex and highly regulated processes in the cell--the transcription of the DNA template into RNA. This review discusses methods and results from this emerging field, and it puts them in perspective of existing biochemical and structural data.

Single-molecule analysis of RNA polymerase transcription

The kinetics and mechanisms of transcription are now being investigated by a repertoire of single-molecule techniques, including optical and magnetic tweezers, high-sensitivity fluorescence techniques, and atomic force microscopy. Single-molecule techniques complement traditional biochemical and crystallographic approaches, are capable of detecting the motions and dynamics of individual RNAP molecules and transcription complexes in real time, and make it possible to directly measure RNAP binding to and unwinding of template DNA, as well as RNAP translocation along the DNA during transcript synthesis.

Stochastic kinetics description of a simple transcription model

We study a stochastic model of transcription kinetics in order to characterize the distributions of transcriptional delay and of elongation rates. Transcriptional delay is the time which elapses between the binding of RNA polymerase to a promoter sequence and its dissociation from the DNA template strand with consequent release of the transcript. Transcription elongation is the process by which the RNA polymerase slides along the template strand. The model considers a DNA template strand with one promoter site and n nucleotide sites, and five types of reaction processes, which we think are key ones in transcription. The chemical master equation is a set of ordinary differential equations in 3(n) variables, where n is the number of bases in the template. This model is too huge to be handled if n is large. We manage to get a reduced Markov model which has only 2n independent variables and can well approximate the original dynamics. We obtain a number of analytical and numerical results for this model, including delay and transcript elongation rate distributions. Recent studies of single-RNA polymerase transcription by using optical-trapping techniques raise an issue of whether the elongation rates measured in a population are heterogeneous or not. Our model implies that in the cases studied, different RNA polymerase molecules move at different characteristic rates along the template strand. We also discuss the implications of this work for the mathematical modeling of genetic regulatory circuits.

Thinking quantitatively about transcriptional regulation

By thinking about the chemical and physical mechanisms that are involved in the stepwise elongation of RNA transcripts, we can begin to understand the way that these mechanisms are controlled within the cell to reflect the different requirements for transcription that are posed by various metabolic, developmental and disease states. Here, we focus on the mechanistic details of the single-nucleotide addition (or excision) cycle in the transcription process, as this is the level at which many regulatory mechanisms function and can be explained in quantitative terms.

Dynamics of molecular motors and polymer translocation with sequence heterogeneity

The effect of sequence heterogeneity on polynucleotide translocation across a pore and on simple models of molecular motors such as helicases, DNA polymerase/exonuclease, and RNA polymerase is studied in detail. Pore translocation of RNA or DNA is biased due to the different chemical environments on the two sides of the membrane, whereas the molecular motor motion is biased through a coupling to chemical energy. An externally applied force can oppose these biases. For both systems we solve lattice models exactly both with and without disorder. The models incorporate explicitly the coupling to the different chemical environments for polymer translocation and the coupling to the chemical energy (as well as nucleotide pairing energies) for molecular motors. Using the exact solutions and general arguments, we show that the heterogeneity leads to anomalous dynamics. Most notably, over a range of forces around the stall force (or stall tension for DNA polymerase/exonuclease systems) the displacement grows sublinearly as t(micro), with micro < 1. The range over which this behavior can be observed experimentally is estimated for several systems and argued to be detectable for appropriate forces and buffers. Similar sequence heterogeneity effects may arise in the packing of viral DNA.

Sequence-dependent kinetic model for transcription elongation by RNA polymerase

We present a kinetic model for the sequence-dependent motion of RNA polymerase (RNAP) during transcription elongation. For each NTP incorporation, RNAP has a net forward translocation of one base-pair along the DNA template. However, this process may involve the exploration of back-tracked and forward-tracked translocation modes. In our model, the kinetic rates for the reaction pathway, calculated based on the stabilities of the transcription elongation complex (TEC), necessarily lead to sequence-dependent NTP incorporation rates. Simulated RNAP elongation kinetics is in good agreement with data from transcription gels and single-molecule studies. The model provides a kinetic explanation for well-known back-tracked pauses at transcript positions with unstable TECs. It also predicts a new type of pause caused by an energetically unfavorable transition from pre to post-translocation modes.

Translocation of Escherichia coli RNA polymerase against a protein roadblock in vivo highlights a passive sliding mechanism for transcript elongation

Current models for transcription elongation infer that RNA polymerase (RNAP) moves along the template by a passive sliding mechanism that takes advantage of random lateral oscillations in which single basepair sliding movements interconvert the elongation complex between pre- and post-translocated states. Such passive translocational equilibrium was tested in vivo by a systematic change in the templated NTP that is to be incorporated by RNAP, which is temporarily roadblocked by the lac repressor. Our results show that, under these conditions that hinder the forward movement of the polymerase, the elongation complex is able to extend its RNA chain one nucleotide further when the incoming NTP is a kinetically favoured substrate (i.e. low K(m)). The addition of an extra nucleotide destabilizes the repressor-operator roadblock leading to an increase in transcriptional readthrough. Similar results are obtained when the incoming NTPs are less kinetically favoured substrates (i.e. high K(m)s) by specifically increasing their intracellular concentrations. Altogether, these in vivo data are consistent with a passive sliding model in which RNAP forward translocation is favoured by NTP binding. They also suggest that fluctuations in the intracellular NTP pools may play a key role in gene regulation at the transcript elongation level.

Functional dissection of RNA polymerase III termination using a peptide nucleic acid as a transcriptional roadblock

We have shown previously that a T(10) peptide nucleic acid (PNA) bound to the transcriptional terminator of a Saccharomyces cerevisiae tDNA(Ile)(TAT) gene arrests elongating yeast RNA polymerase (pol) III at a position that precedes by 20 bp the upstream end of the PNA roadblock (Dieci, G., Corradini, R., Sforza, S., Marchelli, R., and Ottonello, S. (2001) J. Biol. Chem. 276, 5720-5725). Here, a PNA-binding cassette was placed at various distances downstream of a functional tDNA(Ile) transcriptional terminator (T(6)) that is not bound by the T(10) PNA, and the effect of the PNA roadblock on RNA 3'-end formation, transcript release, and transcription reinitiation was examined. With a PNA roadblock placed as close as 5 bp downstream of the T(6) terminator, pol III could still reach the termination site and complete pre-tRNA synthesis, implying that the catalytic site-to-front edge (C-F) distance of the polymerase can shorten by >10 bp upon recognition of the terminator element. In addition, transcripts synthesized by a PNA-roadblocked terminating pol III were found to be released from transcription complexes. Interestingly, however, the same roadblock dramatically reduced the rate of transcription reinitiation. Also, when placed 5 bp downstream of a mutationally inactivated terminator element (T(3)GT(2)), the PNA roadblock restored transcription termination, thus indicating that the inactivated terminator is compromised in its ability to cause pol III pausing, but can still induce C-F distance shortening and transcript release. The latter two activities were found to be further impaired in variants of the inactivated terminator bearing fewer than three consecutive T residues (T(2)G(2)T(2) and TG(2)TGT). The data indicate that RNA polymerase pausing, C-F distance shortening, and transcript release are functionally distinguishable features of the termination process and point to the RNA release propensity of pol III as a major determinant of its remarkably high termination efficiency.

Macromolecular complexes that unwind nucleic acids

In this essay, we consider helicases, defined as enzymes that use the free energies of binding and hydrolysis of ATP to drive the unwinding of double-stranded nucleic acids, and ask how they function within, and are "coupled" to, the macromolecular machines of gene expression. To illustrate the principles of the integration of helicases into such machines, we consider the macromolecular complexes that direct and control DNA replication and DNA-dependent RNA transcription, and use these systems to illustrate how machines centered around coupled polymerase-helicase systems can be regulated by small changes in the interactions of their functional components.

Diversity in the rates of transcript elongation by single RNA polymerase molecules

Single-molecule measurements of the activities of a variety of enzymes show that rates of catalysis may vary markedly between different molecules in putatively homogeneous enzyme preparations. We measured the rate at which purified Escherichia coli RNA polymerase moves along a approximately 2650-bp DNA during transcript elongation in vitro at 0.5 mm nucleoside triphosphates. Individual molecules of a specifically biotinated RNA polymerase derivative were tagged with 199-nm diameter avidin-coated polystyrene beads; enzyme movement along a surface-linked DNA molecule was monitored by observing changes in bead Brownian motion by light microscopy. The DNA was derived from a naturally occurring transcription unit and was selected for the absence of regulatory sequences that induce lengthy pausing or termination of transcription. With rare exceptions, individual enzyme molecules moved at a constant velocity throughout the transcription reaction; the distribution of velocities across a population of 140 molecules was unimodal and was well fit by a Gaussian. However, the width of the Gaussian, sigma = 6.7 bp/s, was considerably larger than the precision of the velocity measurement (1 bp/s). The observations show that different transcription complexes have differences in catalytic rate (and thus differences in structure) that persist for thousands of catalytic turnovers. These differences may provide a parsimonious explanation for the complex transcription kinetics observed in bulk solution.

Multiple states of stalled T7 RNA polymerase at DNA lesions generated by platinum anticancer agents

Transcription inhibition by DNA adducts of cisplatin is considered to be one of the major routes by which this anticancer drug kills cancer cells. Stalled RNA polymerases at platinum-DNA lesions evoke various cellular responses such as nucleotide excision repair, polymerase degradation, and apoptosis. T7 RNA polymerase and site-specifically platinated DNA templates immobilized on a solid support were used to study stalled transcription elongation complexes. In vitro transcription studies were performed in both a promoter-dependent and -independent manner. An elongation complex is strongly blocked by cisplatin 1,2-intrastrand d(GpG) and 1,3-intrastrand d(GpTpG) cross-links located on the template strand. Polymerase action is inhibited at multiple sites in the vicinity of the platinum lesion, the nature of which can be altered by the choice and concentration of NTPs. The [(1R,2R-diaminocyclohexane)Pt]2+ DNA adducts formed by oxaliplatin, which carries a stereochemically more demanding spectator ligand than the ammine groups in cisplatin, also strongly block the polymerase with measurable differences compared with cis-[(NH3)2Pt]2+ lesions. Elongation complexes stopped at sites of platinum damage were isolated and characterized. The stalled polymerase can be dissociated from the DNA by subsequent polymerases initiated from the same template. We also discovered that a polymerase stalled at the platinum-DNA lesion can resume transcription after the platinum adduct is chemically removed from the template.

Function and assembly of the bacteriophage T4 DNA replication complex: interactions of the T4 polymerase with various model DNA constructs

Complexes formed between DNA polymerase and genomic DNA at the replication fork are key elements of the replication machinery. We used sedimentation velocity, fluorescence anisotropy, and surface plasmon resonance to measure the binding interactions between bacteriophage T4 DNA polymerase (gp43) and various model DNA constructs. These results provide quantitative insight into how this replication polymerase performs template-directed 5' --> 3' DNA synthesis and how this function is coordinated with the activities of the other proteins of the replication complex. We find that short (single- and double-stranded) DNA molecules bind a single gp43 polymerase in a nonspecific (overlap) binding mode with moderate affinity (Kd approximately 150 nm) and a binding site size of approximately 10 nucleotides for single-stranded DNA and approximately 13 bp for double-stranded DNA. In contrast, gp43 binds in a site-specific (nonoverlap) mode and significantly more tightly (Kd approximately 5 nm) to DNA constructs carrying a primer-template junction, with the polymerase covering approximately 5 nucleotides downstream and approximately 6-7 bp upstream of the 3'-primer terminus. The rate of this specific binding interaction is close to diffusion-controlled. The affinity of gp43 for the primer-template junction is modulated specifically by dNTP substrates, with the next "correct" dNTP strengthening the interaction and an incorrect dNTP weakening the observed binding. These results are discussed in terms of the individual steps of the polymerase-catalyzed single nucleotide addition cycle and the replication complex assembly process. We suggest that changes in the kinetics and thermodynamics of these steps by auxiliary replication proteins constitute a basic mechanism for protein coupling within the replication complex.

Active Escherichia coli transcription elongation complexes are functionally homogeneous

The elongation phase of RNA transcription represents a major target for the regulation of gene expression. Two general classes of models have been proposed to define the dynamic properties of transcription complexes in the elongation phase. Stable heterogeneity models posit that the ensemble of active elongation-competent complexes consists of multiple distinct and stable forms that are specified early in the transcription cycle and isomerize to other forms slowly. In contrast, equilibrium or rapid interconversion models require that active elongation complexes interconvert rapidly on the time-scale of single nucleotide addition. Measurements of transcription termination efficiency (TE) can be used to distinguish between these models, because stable heterogeneity models predict that the termination-resistant fraction of an elongation complex population should be enriched after transcription through an upstream terminator, leading to a decreased TE at downstream terminators. In contrast, rapid interconversion models require that the population of active (elongation-competent) complexes equilibrate after transcription through each terminator and, therefore, that the value of TE observed at identical upstream and downstream terminators should be the same. We have constructed transcription templates containing multiple identical terminators and found no significant changes in TE with terminator position along the template. Various other forms of upstream treatment of elongation complex populations also were used to attempt to fractionate the complexes into functionally different forms. None of these treatments changed the apparent TE at downstream terminators. These results are consistent with a rapid interconversion model of transcript elongation. The consequences of these results for the regulation of gene expression are discussed.