Treatment results of high-dose-rate remote afterloading brachytherapy for cervical cancer and retrospective comparison of two regimens

Working title: high dose rate intra-cavitary brachytherapy with cobalt 60 source for locally advanced cervical cancer: the Zimbabwean experience

BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE

Cervical cancer is the fourth commonest cancer in women in the world with the highest regional incidence and mortality seen in Southern, Eastern and Western Africa. It is the commonest cause of cancer morbidity and mortality among Zimbabwean women. Most patients present with locally advanced disease that is no longer amenable to surgery. Definitive concurrent chemoradiation (CCRT), which is the use of external beam radiotherapy (EBRT) and weekly cisplatin, includes use of intracavitary brachytherapy, as the standard treatment. In the setting of this study, cobalt-60 (Co⁶⁰)-based high dose rate brachytherapy (HDR-BT) has been in use since 2013. This study sought to review practices pertaining to use of brachytherapy in Zimbabwe, including timing with external beam radiotherapy, adverse effects and patient outcomes.

METHODS

A retrospective analysis of data from records of patients with histologically confirmed cervical cancer treated with HDR-BT at the main radiotherapy centre in Zimbabwe from January 2013 to December 2014 was done. Outcome measures were local control, overall survival as well as gastro-intestinal and genito-urinary toxicity.

RESULTS

A total of 226 patients were treated with HDR-BT during the study period, with a 97% treatment completion rate. All patients received between 45-50Gy of pelvic EBRT. Seventy-four percent received concurrent platinum-based chemotherapy. In 52% of the patients, HDR-BT was started when they were still receiving EBRT. The commonest fractionation schedule used was the 7Gy × 3 fractions, once a week (87%). Clinical complete tumour response was achieved in 75% at 6 weeks post treatment, 23% had partial response. Follow-up rates at 1 year and 2 years were 40 and 19% respectively. Disease free survival at 1 year and 2 years was 94 and 95% respectively. Vaginal stenosis was the commonest toxicity recorded, high incidence noted with increasing age. Four patients developed vesico-vaginal fistulae and two patients had rectovaginal fistulae.

CONCLUSION

One hundred and seventeen patients patients started HDR-BT during EBRT course, with a treatment completion rate of 97%. The overall treatment duration was within 56 days in the majority of patients. Early local tumour control was similar for all the HDR-BT fractionation regimes used in the study, with a high rate (75%) of complete clinical response at 6 weeks post-treatment. Prospective studies to evaluate early and long-term outcomes of HDR-BT in our setting are recommended.

Comparison of clinical outcome between computed tomography-based image-guided brachytherapy and two-dimensional-based brachytherapy for cervical cancer

This study aimed to analyze the clinical results of radiotherapy for cervical cancer using two-dimensional (2D) intracavitary brachytherapy (ICBT) and computed tomography (CT)-based image-guided brachytherapy (IGBT) at our institution. Patients with stage IB–IVA cervical cancer who received ICBT between April 2008 and April 2014 were included in this study. In total 58 patients were assessed. The first 38 patients received ICBT with the 2D treatment plan (the 2D group), and the remaining 20 patients received CT-based IGBT (the IGBT group). The dose of point A tended to be lower in the IGBT group (mean value, 60.6 Gy vs. 62.5 Gy; p = .07), though the minimum dose to the 90% (D90) of the clinical target volume (CTV) was equivalent in both groups (mean value, 66.0 Gy vs. 66.2 Gy; p = .91). The rectum minimum dose to 2 cc (D2cc) was significantly lower in the IGBT group than in the 2D group (mean value, 61.2 Gy vs. 69.1 Gy; p = .001). With a median follow-up time of 60 months, the 5-year local control rates (LCRs) of the IGBT group and 2D group were 100% and 83%, respectively (p = .12). The 5-year incidence of rectal complications in the IGBT group and the 2D group were 11% and 29%, respectively (p = .26). Our study showed favorable LCR and preferred incidence of rectal complications in patients treated with CT-based IGBT.

•

The difference of the treatment results between 2D and 3D brachytherapy was analyzed.

•

The rectum D2cc was significantly lower in the IGBT group compared with the 2D group.

•

Local control rates tended to be better in the IGBT group than in the 2D group.

•

The incidence of rectal complications tended to be lower in the IGBT group.

Aurora-A affects radiosenstivity in cervical squamous cell carcinoma and predicts poor prognosis

BACKGROUND

Definitive radiation therapy (RT) (with or without cisplatin-based chemotherapy) is one of the most effective treatments for cervical squamous cell carcinoma (CSCC), but efficacy is limited due to resistance. In the present study, we investigated the relationship between the expression of Aurora kinase A (Aurora-A, AURKA)and response to RT in patients with CSCC.

METHODS

The expression of Aurora-A in biopsy specimens of untreated primary tumors in 129 Uyghur patients with CSCC was investigated immunohistochemically. Primary treatment in these patients was definitive radical RT, which consisted of pelvic RT plus brachytherapy (total point A dose:70-85 Gy) (with or without cisplatin-based chemotherapy). The prognostic value of tumoral Aurora-A expression and patients' clinical outcomes were evaluated.

RESULTS

Aurora-A expression was significantly associated with lymph node metastasis (P<0.001), large tumor size (P<0.001), low hemoglobin (Hb) level (P=0.011) and recurrence (P<0.001), but not other clinicopathological factors. Definitive RT was unfavorable in patients with high Aurora-A expression (P < 0.001). In 129 enrolled patients, lymph node metastasis, large tumor size, low Hb level, and AURKA overexpression were prognostic factors for both recurrent free survival (RFS) and overall survival (OS) in univariate analysis. However, only high AURKA expression was an adverse independent risk factor for both RFS (hazard ratio, 3.953; 95% CI, 1.473-10.638; P = 0.006) and OS (hazard ratio 9.091; 95%CI 2.597-32.258; P<0.001) in multivariate analyses.

CONCLUSIONS

Aurora-A may serve as a predictive biomarker of radiation response and a therapeutic target to reverse radiation therapy resistance.

Dosimetric comparison and observation of three-dimensional conformal radiotherapy for recurrent nasopharyngeal carcinoma

The aim of the study was to investigate the effect of three-dimensional conformal radiation therapy (3D-CRT) on nasopharyngeal carcinoma (NPC) and the incidence of complications. Between May 2010 and June 2012, 141 patients diagnosed with local recurrence of NPC due to cranial base lesions or cranial nerve symptoms, confirmed by pathology biopsy and/or by CT/MRI, were included in the present study. In accordance with the principle of randomized control, the patients were divided into three groups and treated with three different doses of 3D-CRT. The planned radiotherapy doses of 3D-CRT were 58/1.8–2 Gy, 62/1.8–2 Gy and 68/1.8–2 Gy, respectively. The survival rate, disease-free survival (DFS) rate and local control rate of the three groups of patients were compared as well as the adverse reactions observed after radiotherapy. The prognoses of NPC patients were analyzed by univariate and multivariate analyses. The follow-up rate of the study was 100%. The 5-year overall survival, DFS, and locoregional recurrence-free survival rates were: 43.2 vs. 64.53 vs. 75%, 29.13 vs. 42.82 vs. 39.7% and 30.76 vs. 44.19 vs. 45.4%, respectively. In addition, 62/1.8–2 Gy was similar in treatment effects to 68/1.8–2 Gy, but 68/1.8–2 Gy showed more adverse reactions than 62/1.8–2 Gy. Thus, 62/1.8–2 Gy can be used as a safe and effective dose for 3D-CRT treatment of NPC. Univariate and multivariate analyses showed that age may be the main prognostic factor of patients with NPC. In conclusion, 3D-CRT with a dose of 62/1.8–2 Gy is a safe, effective and tolerable treatment for NPC patients with good clinical value.

American Brachytherapy Task Group Report: A pooled analysis of clinical outcomes for high-dose-rate brachytherapy for cervical cancer

PURPOSE

Advanced imaging used in combination with brachytherapy (BT) has revolutionized the treatment of patients with cervical cancer. We present a comprehensive review of the literature for definitive radiation with high-dose-rate (HDR) BT. In addition, we investigate potential outcome improvement with image-based brachytherapy (IBBT) compared to studies using traditional Point A dosing. This review extensively investigates acute and late toxicities.

METHODS AND MATERIALS

This study reviews the literature from 2000 to 2015 with an emphasis on modern approaches including concurrent chemotherapy (chemoRT), radiation, and HDR BT and IBBT. Descriptive statistics and pelvic control (PC), disease-free survival (DFS), and overall survival (OS) outcomes were calculated using weighted means to report pooled analysis of outcomes.

RESULTS

Literature search yielded 16 prospective, 51 retrospective studies that reported survival outcomes, and 13 retrospective studies that focused on acute and late toxicity outcomes regardless of applicator type. There are 57 studies that report Point A dose specification with 33 having chemoRT, and 10 studies that use IBBT, 8 with chemoRT. Patients receiving radiation and chemoRT with HDR BT in the prospective studies, with >24 months followup, rates of PC were: for RT: 73%, SD: 11; CRT: 82%, SD: 8; DFS-RT: 55%, SD: 10; CRT: 65%, SD: 7; OS-RT: 66%, SD: 7; CRT: 70%, SD: 11. In the retrospective studies, the PC rates (weighted means) for the radiation and chemoradiation outcomes are 75% vs. 80%, and for DFS, the values were 55% vs. 63%, respectively. Comparing patients receiving chemoRT and IBBT to traditional Point A dose specification, there is a significant improvement in PC (p < 0.01) and DFS (p < 0.01) with IBBT. The range of genitourinary late toxicity reported for radiation was Grade 3: 1-6% and for chemoRT 2-20%. The range of late gastrointestinal toxicity for radiation was Grade 3: 4-11% and for chemoRT, 1-11%. For the late gynecologic toxicity, only 1 of the 16 prospective trials report a Grade 1-2 of 17% for radiation and 9% for chemoRT effects.

CONCLUSIONS

We present concise outcomes of PC, DFS, OS, and toxicity for cervical cancer patients treated with chemoradiation and HDR BT. Our data suggest an improvement in outcomes with the use of IBBT compared with traditional Point A dose prescriptions. In conclusion, HDR BT is a safe, effective modality when combined with IBBT.

External beam techniques to boost cervical cancer when brachytherapy is not an option-theories and applications

The management of locally advanced cervical cancer relies on brachytherapy (BT) as an integral part of the radiotherapy delivery armamentarium. Occasionally, intracavitary BT is neither possible nor available. In these circumstances, post-external beam radiotherapy (EBRT) interstitial brachytherapy and/or hysterectomy may represent viable options that must be adequately executed in a timely manner. However, if these options are not applicable due to patient related or facility related reasons, a formal contingency plan should be in place. Innovative EBRT techniques such as intensity modulated and stereotactic radiotherapy may be considered for patients unable to undergo brachytherapy. Relying on provocative arguments and recent data, this review explores the rationale for and limitations of non-brachytherapy substitutes in that setting aiming to establish a formal process for the optimal execution of this alternative plan.

Treatment outcomes of patients with FIGO Stage I/II uterine cervical cancer treated with definitive radiotherapy: a multi-institutional retrospective research study

The purpose of this study was to analyze the patterns of care and outcomes of patients with FIGO Stage I/II cervical cancer who underwent definitive radiotherapy (RT) at multiple Japanese institutions. The Japanese Radiation Oncology Study Group (JROSG) performed a questionnaire-based survey of their cervical cancer patients who were treated with definitive RT between January 2000 and December 2005. A total of 667 patients were entered in this study. Although half of the patients were considered suitable for definitive RT based on the clinical features of the tumor, about one-third of the patients were prescribed RT instead of surgery because of poor medical status. The RT schedule most frequently utilized was whole-pelvic field irradiation (WP) of 30 Gy/15 fractions followed by WP with midline block of 20 Gy/10 fractions, and high-dose-rate intracavitary brachytherapy (HDR-ICBT) of 24 Gy/4 fractions prescribed at point A. Chemotherapy was administered to 306 patients (46%). The most frequent regimen contained cisplatin (CDDP). The median follow-up time for all patients was 65 months (range, 2-135 months). The 5-year overall survival (OS), pelvic control (PC) and disease-free survival (DFS) rates for all patients were 78%, 90% and 69%, respectively. Tumor diameter and nodal status were significant prognostic indicators for OS, PC and DFS. Chemotherapy has potential for improving the OS and DFS of patients with bulky tumors, but not for non-bulky tumors. This study found that definitive RT for patients with Stage I/II cervical cancer achieved good survival outcomes.

Treatment interruption during concurrent chemoradiotherapy of uterine cervical cancer; analysis of factors and outcomes

BACKGROUND

To evaluate factors which effect treatment interruption during concurrent chemoradiotherapy (CCRT) and overall survival in patients with uterine cervical cancer stage IB2-IVA in Srinagarind Hospital.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Between January 2006 and December 2007, 107 patients with stage IB2-IVA as FIGO staging, 2000, were treated with CCRT in Srinagarind Hospital. Factors which caused treatment interruptions and impacted on overall survival were reviewed and analyzed.

RESULTS

Twenty of 107 patients had treatment interruption during CCRT in patients with uterine cervical cancer stage IB2-IVA in Srinagarind Hospital. The causes of treatment interruption were as follows: hematologic toxicity was found in 16 of 20 cases, 12 cases with grade 2 and 4 cases with grade 3; three of 20 cases had gastrointestinal toxicities, 1 case with grade 2 and 2 cases with grade 3; one case had grade 3 skin toxicity. The mean total treatment time of the uninterrupted and interrupted groups were significantly different (78.98 days vs 161.80 days, p <0.001). The patients who could tolerate ≥5 cycles of cisplatin administration had significantly higher mean white blood counts (WBC) (9,769 cells/ mm3 vs 7,141 cells/mm3, p=0.02). The mean initial hemoglobin (Hb) in the uninterrupted group was significantly higher than the interrupted group (11.5 mg% vs 10.3 mg%, p=0.03). Other factors including age, KPS, initial platelets, initial serum creatinine levels showed no statistical significance. The 3-year overall survival of the uninterrupted group was better than in the interrupted group (78.6% vs 55.0%, p=0.03).

CONCLUSIONS

The initial Hb and WBC levels were significantly correlated with treatment interruption during CCRT in patients with uterine cervical cancer. The 3-year overall survival of the uninterrupted group was significantly better than interrupted group. These factors may then be used indirectly to predict the outcomes of treatment.

Major causes of impractical brachytherapy in elderly patients with uterine cervical cancer

AIM

Incomplete brachytherapy is a major risk factor for recurrence. However, high-dose-rate intracavitary brachytherapy has not been assessed adequately in elderly patients with invasive cervical cancer. The present study investigated the clinical importance of intracavitary brachytherapy and risk factors of incomplete intracavitary brachytherapy in elderly patients with cervical cancer.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

Subjects were 76 patients aged 70-89 years old with invasive cervical cancer. All subjects were recruited between January 1997 and September 2010, and were planning to receive external beam radiation therapy followed by high-dose-rate intracavitary brachytherapy. Survival rates and the incidence of complications were compared between the 70s and 80s age groups. Risk factors for recurrence in elderly patients were evaluated using multivariate analysis, and risk factors for impractical intracavitary brachytherapy were also estimated.

RESULTS

No significant differences were observed in 3-year progression-free survival rates or the incidence of complications in the two age groups. Cox multivariate analysis showed that histology (non-squamous cell carcinoma), incomplete intracavitary brachytherapy, and lymph node swelling were significant prognostic factors for recurrence. Impractical application was the major reason for incomplete treatment. Multiple logistic regression analysis revealed that a previous history without vaginal births (P = 0.016) was an independent risk factor for the impractical application, independent of tumor diameter ≥ 4 cm (P = 0.007).

CONCLUSIONS

Incomplete intracavitary brachytherapy decreased the survival rates of elderly patients. Larger tumors and patients without a history of vaginal births were the two major causes of impractical intracavitary brachytherapy, which may be fatal, especially in elderly patients with bulky tumors.

High dose rate versus low dose rate intracavity brachytherapy for locally advanced uterine cervix cancer

BACKGROUND

This is an updated version of the original Cochrane review published in 2010 (Issue 7).Carcinoma of the uterine cervix is the second most common cancer and the third leading cause of cancer death among women. Radiotherapy has been used successfully to treat cervical cancer for nearly a century. The combination of external beam radiotherapy (EBRT) and intracavity brachytherapy (ICBT) has become a standard treatment for cervical cancer. Whether high dose rate (HDR) or low dose rate (LDR) brachytherapy improves outcomes in terms of local control rates, survival and complications for women with cervical cancer remains controversial.

OBJECTIVES

To assess the efficacy and safety of HDR versus LDR ICBT in combination with EBRT for women with uterine cervical cancer.

SEARCH METHODS

We searched the Cochrane Gynaecological Cancer Group Specialised Register and the Cochrane Central Register of Controlled Trials (CENTRAL) (The Cochrane Library 2014, Issue 1), MEDLINE (1966 to March 2014), EMBASE (1974 to March 2014), and the Chinese Biomedical Literature Database (CBM) (1978 to March 2014) for relevant original, published trials.

SELECTION CRITERIA

Randomised controlled trials (RCTs) and quasi-RCTs that compared HDR with LDR ICBT, combined with EBRT, for women with locally advanced uterine cervical cancer.

DATA COLLECTION AND ANALYSIS

Two authors independently extracted the data using standardised forms. Primary outcome measures included overall survival (OS), relapse-free survival (RFS) and pelvic control rate, while secondary outcomes included rates of recurrence and complications.

MAIN RESULTS

Four studies involving 1265 women met the inclusion criteria. In our meta-analysis to compare HDR and LDR ICBT, the pooled risk ratios (RRs) were 0.95 (95% confidence interval (CI) 0.79 to 1.15), 0.93 (95% CI 0.84 to 1.04) and 0.79 (95% CI 0.52 to 1.20) for 3-, 5- and 10-year overall survival rates respectively; and 0.95 (95% CI 0.84 to 1.07) and 1.02 (0.88 to 1.19) for 5- and 10-year disease-specific survival (DSS) rates respectively. The RR for RFS was 1.04 (95% CI 0.71 to 1.52) and 0.96 (95% CI 0.81 to 1.14) at 3- and 5- years. For local control rates the RR was 0.95 (95% CI 0.86 to 1.05) and 0.95 (95% CI 0.87 to 1.05) at 3- and 5- years; with a RR of 1.09 (95% CI 0.83 to 1.43) for locoregional recurrence, 0.79 (95% CI 0.40 to 1.53) for local and distant recurrence, 2.23 (95% CI 0.78 to 6.34) for para-aortic lymph node metastasis, and 0.99 (95% CI 0.72 to 1.35) for distance metastasis. For bladder, rectosigmoid and small bowel complications, the RR was 1.33 (95% CI 0.53 to 3.34), 1.00 (95% CI 0.52 to 1.91) and 3.37 (95% CI 1.06 to 10.72) respectively. These results indicated that there were no significant differences except for increased small bowel complications with HDRs (P = 0.04).

AUTHORS' CONCLUSIONS

Since the last version of this review, no new studies were identified for inclusion in this review to provide additional information. This review showed no significant differences between HDR and LDR ICBT when considering OS, DSS, RFS, local control rate, recurrence, metastasis and treatment related complications for women with cervical carcinoma. Due to some potential advantages of HDR ICBT (rigid immobilization, outpatient treatment, patient convenience, accuracy of source and applicator positioning, individualized treatment) we recommend the use of HDR ICBT for all clinical stages of cervix cancer. The overall risk of bias was high for the included studies as many of the items were either of high or unclear risk. The GRADE assessment of the quality of the evidence was low to moderate.

Combined External and Intracavitary Irradiation in Treatment of Advanced Cervical Carcinomas: Predictive Factors for Treatment Outcome and Early and Late Radiation Reactions

Objective

The objective of this study was to find out predictive factors of tumor control as well as acute and late radiation reactions in treatment of advanced cervical carcinomas.

Methods

In a series of 134 primary cervical carcinomas in International Federation of Gynecology and Obstetrics stages I to IV treated with combined external pelvic and intraluminal cervical-vaginal brachytherapy, predictive and prognostic factors were analyzed with regard to tumor control, recurrences, survival data, and adverse effects. Concomitant chemotherapy was given to 48 patients (35.8%). The external beam therapy was given with a 4-field technique (50–60 Gy) and brachytherapy was given with a high-dose rate (iridium-192) afterloading technique using a ring applicator set. A computed tomographically based 3-dimensional dose-planning system was used for the external beam therapy and for the brachytherapy planning. The mean age of the patients was 65 years. A total of 110 tumors were squamous cell carcinomas and 24 were adenocarcinomas or adenosquamous carcinomas. A total of 111 tumors were in International Federation of Gynecology and Obstetrics stages I to II; 23 tumors, in stages III to IV.

Results

The primary control rate of the complete series was 92.5%. Tumor size, the brachytherapy dose, the combined external and brachytherapy dose, as well as the number of days of interruption (delay) of irradiation were all significant predictive factors for local tumor control. Forty recurrences (30%) were recorded. Early radiation reactions were recorded in 67% (mostly grade 1) and were associated with the widths of the anterior-posterior and lateral pelvic fields. Serious late radiations reactions (grade 3–4) were noted in 11%.

Conclusions

The width of the lateral pelvic fields, left point A and B doses, dose to the rectal reference point, as well as asymmetry of the dose distribution were associated with late severe reactions. Prior abdominal and pelvic surgery was also a high-risk factor for late tissue reactions. Concomitant chemotherapy did not increase the risk for acute or late toxicity.

Variable impact of intracavitary brachytherapy fractionation schedule on biologically effective dose to organs at risk in patients with cervical cancer

PURPOSE

To determine the effect of intracavitary brachytherapy (ICBT) fractionation schedule on biologically effective dose to organs at risk.

METHODS AND MATERIALS

We reviewed records from 26 patients who had CT imaging during ICBT for International Federation of Gynecology and Obstetrics stage IB2-IVA cervical cancer. Using α/β=10, we calculated hypothetical nominal doses to achieve a biologically effective dose at 2 Gy per fraction (EQD2α/β=10) of 40 Gy to Point A for high-dose-rate ICBT with 1-15 fractions. Corresponding minimum EQD2α/β=3s to the maximally irradiated 2 cc of rectum, bladder, and sigmoid were calculated for each fractionation scheme and added to EQD2α/β=3 from external beam radiotherapy. Total EQD2α/β=3s were compared with American Brachytherapy Society suggested dose constraints (rectum/sigmoid, ≤75 Gy; bladder, ≤90 Gy).

RESULTS

Except for rectal EQD2α/β=3 in three patients, the rectal, bladder, and sigmoid EQD2α/β=3s decreased with increasing fractionation in all patients. Although the total rectal EQD2α/β=3s were less than the American Brachytherapy Society rectal dose constraint in all patients at all fractionation schedules, the total bladder EQD2α/β=3s routinely exceeded the bladder dose constraint, even at maximum fractionation. By contrast, increasing fractionation decreased the number of patients with doses exceeding the sigmoid dose constraint by 48%.

CONCLUSIONS

The relationship between ICBT fractionation schedule and relative EQD2α/β=3s to rectum, bladder, and sigmoid depends on individual anatomy. Fractionation optimization can improve therapeutic ratios by minimizing the risk or severity of toxic effects. For patients in whom many fractions optimize the therapeutic ratio, low-dose-rate or pulsed-dose-rate brachytherapy may be preferred.

Effect of brachytherapy technique and patient characteristics on cervical cancer implant dosimetry

Our purpose was to evaluate the relationship between brachytherapy technique and patient characteristics on dose to organs-at-risk (OARs) in patients undergoing high dose rate (HDR) brachytherapy for cervical cancer. From 1998 to 2008, 31 patients with cervical cancer with full dosimetric data were identified who received definitive external-beam radiation and HDR brachytherapy with tandem and ovoid applicators. Doses were recorded at point A, the International Commission on Radiation Units and Measurements (ICRU)-38 rectal point, the ICRU-38 bladder point, the vaginal surface, and the pelvic sidewall. Generalized estimating equations were used to determine the significance of changes in OAR to point A dose ratios with differences in brachytherapy technique or patient characteristics. Patients underwent a median of 5 brachytherapy procedures (range, 3 to 5), with a total of 179 procedures for 31 patients. For all brachytherapy treatments, the average ratios between the doses for the rectal, bladder, vaginal surface, and pelvic sidewall reference points to those at point A were 0.49, 0.59, 1.15, and 0.17, respectively. In general, decreased OAR dose was associated with a lower stage, younger age, increased ovoid size, increased tandem length, and earlier implant number. Increased tandem curvature significantly increased bladder dose and decreased rectal dose. Intravenous anesthesia usage was not correlated with improved dosimetry. This study allowed identification of patient and procedure characteristics influencing OAR dosing. Although the advent of 3-dimensional (3D) image-guided brachytherapy will bring new advances in treatment optimization, the actual technique involved at the time of the brachytherapy implant procedure will remain important.

Palliative treatment of advanced cervical cancer with radiotherapy and thai herbal medicine as supportive remedy - analysis of survival

BACKGROUND

To evaluate outcomes using a Thai herbal medicine, Vilac Plus (G716/45) with standard radiotherapy in comparison with historic controls from literature reports of the results of treatment in stage IIIB cervical cancer.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Between March 2003 and June 2005, thirty patients with advanced cervical cancer stage IIIB-IV who had a poor performance status were treated by palliative radiotherapy along with an adjuvant daily dose of 15-30 ml of Thai herbal tonic solution (Vilac Plus G716/45) administered orally three times after meals as an additional supportive therapy. The results were analyzed from the aspect of the overall survival rates with curves estimated by the Kaplan-Meier method.

RESULTS

The median follow -up time for stage IIIB was 4.2 years with a range of 7.9 months - 6.1 years. The overall 1, 3, and 5 year survival rates for stage IIIB were 88%, 60% and 52%.

CONCLUSIONS

The overall 5 year survival rate for stage IIIB with a poor performance status was 52% when compared with 34-54.8% for historic controls. The combined complementary palliative radiotherapy (CCPR) had low rates of radiation morbidity. It was a simple technique and feasible for developing countries. The pilot study was limited by the small number of patients and further research will be necessary to assess interrelated and confounding factors in treatment of cervical cancer patients.

Evaluation of the response of concurrent high dose rate intracavitary brachytherapy with external beam radiotherapy in management of early stage carcinoma cervix

OBJECTIVES

To evaluate local disease control and early complications of concomitant brachytherapy with external beam-radiotherapy in early stage carcinoma cervix.

METHODS

Fifty patients of early stage carcinoma cervix (FIGO-IB/IIA) were randomly divided into study group concomitant external beam irradiation (EBRT) and HDR-ICBT (intra-cavitary brachytherapy, xrt = 50 Gy/25 Fr, HDR 5.2 Gy*5 Fr) and the control group EBRT followed by HDR-ICBT (xrt = 50 Gy/25 Fr, HDR 7.5 Gy*3 Fr). Acute reactions and local disease response were compared between treatment and at 6-month follow up.

RESULTS

Median overall treatment times were 38 and 61 days in the study and the control groups, respectively. Acute skin reactions and diarrhea were more in the study but manageable. At the completion of the study, there were 80 and 68 % complete responses, 16 and 20 % partial responses, 0 and 8 % stable diseases in the study group and the control group, respectively.

CONCLUSIONS

Response was better in the study group but statistically insignificant. Larger number of patients and longer follow up are required to arrive at concrete conclusion.

The effects of two HDR brachytherapy schedules in locally advanced cervical cancer treated with concurrent chemoradiation: a study from Chiang Mai, Thailand

Efficacy of different schedules of HDR brachytherapy in concurrent chemoradiotherapy was evaluated. The study compared the effectiveness of the two HDR brachytherapy schedules which have the same Biological Effective Dose (BED) in locally advanced cervical carcinoma that was treated with concurrent chemoradiotherapy. Included in the study were 377 randomly selected patients with advanced carcinoma of the cervix uteri who were treated during the period 2004-2006. Patients were divided into Group I: 7.2 Gy × 3 fractions and Group II: 6 Gy × 4 fractions. With a median follow-up time of 35 months, local control, disease-free survival and overall survival rates were 80.8%, 63.4%, 98.8% in group I and 86.7%, 63.8%, 97.3% in group II, respectively. There was no statistical significance in terms of local control, disease-free survival, overall survival and complication rates between the two treatment schedules which could be observed. Seven patients in group I developed acute grade 2-4 GI toxicities and two patients in group II. In GU toxicities, there were three patients in group I and three patients in group II who developed grade 2-4 toxicities. In late toxicity, no patient developed grade 3-4 GU toxicities in group I while two patients developed grade 3-4 GU toxicities in group II. In GI toxicities, there were five and six patients in group I and group II, respectively, who developed grade 3-4 severity. Both HDR schedules seem to be safe and effective for the treatment of locally advanced cervical cancer.

Hypofractionated extracranial stereotactic radiotherapy boost for gynecologic tumors: a promising alternative to high-dose rate brachytherapy

The purpose of this study is to report toxicity and outcome results in patients with gynaecological tumours treated with a final boost using extra-cranial stereotactic radiotherapy (SRT) with a linac-based micro-multileaf collimator technique as an alternative to high-dose rate brachytherapy (HDR-BT). Since January 2002, 26 patients with either endometrial (n = 17) or cervical (n = 9) cancer were treated according to this protocol: 45-50.4 Gy external radiotherapy (RT) to the pelvic +/- para-aortic regions followed by a final SRT boost of 2 x 7 Gy to the vaginal vault (4-7 day interval between fractions). Median age was 62 years (37-74 range). Fifteen patients were diagnosed with adenocarcinoma, 7 with squamous-cell carcinoma, and 4 with sarcoma. FIGO stage I (n = 17), stage II (n = 7), and stage III (n = 2). Toxicity was scored according to RTOG/EORTC criteria. No severe (> grade-3) acute urinary or low-gastrointestinal (GI) toxicity was observed during treatment and up to 3 months after treatment completion. Moderate (grade < or = 3) acute urinary or low-GI toxicity was observed in 23% and 35% of patients, respectively. After a median follow-up of 47 months (4-77, range), late urinary, low-GI, and sexual > or = grade-2 (worst score) has been reported in 4%, 12% and 29.4% of patients, respectively. The 3-year loco-regional failure-free and overall survival rates were 96% and 95%, respectively. Preliminary results on feasibility, tolerance, and outcome with SRT are encouraging and may be considered a sound alternative to HDR-BT for gynecologic tumors.

High dose rate versus low dose rate intracavity brachytherapy for locally advanced uterine cervix cancer

BACKGROUND

Carcinoma of the uterine cervix is the second most common cancer and the third leading cause of cancer death among women. Radiotherapy has been used successfully to treat cervical cancer for nearly a century. The combination of external beam radiotherapy (EBRT) and intracavitary brachytherapy (ICBT) has become a standard treatment modality for cervical cancer. Depending on the difference in dose rate on 'Point A' (located 2 cm above the cervical os and 2 cm lateral to the central axis of the uterus), the ICBT is divided into three modalities: low dose rate (LDR), high dose rate (HDR) and medium dose rate (MDR). Despite the practical advantages of HDR, it is necessary to investigate further the efficacy and safety of HDR brachytherapy compared to LDR brachytherapy. Questions arise as to whether HDR or LDR brachytherapy improves results for patients with cervical cancer in terms of local control rates, survival and complications related to treatment.

OBJECTIVES

To assess the efficacy and safety of HDR- versus LDR-ICBT for patients with uterine cervical cancer.

SEARCH STRATEGY

We searched the Cochrane Gynaecological Cancer Group Specialised Register and the Cochrane Central Register of Controlled Trials (CENTRAL) (The Cochrane Library 2009, Issue 4), MEDLINE (1966 to November 2009), EMBASE (1974 to November 2009), Chinese Biomedical Literature Database (CBM) (1978 to November 2009) for relevant original, published trials.

SELECTION CRITERIA

Randomised controlled trials (RCTs) and quasi-RCTs that compared HDR- with LDR-ICBT, combined with EBRT, for patients with locally advanced uterine cervical cancer.

DATA COLLECTION AND ANALYSIS

Two authors independently extracted the data using standardised forms. Primary outcome measures included overall survival (OS), relapse-free survival (RFS) and pelvic control rate, while secondary outcomes included rates of recurrence and complications.

MAIN RESULTS

Four studies involving 1265 patients met the inclusion criteria. In our meta-analysis to compare HDR and LDR, the pooled RRs were 0.95 (95% CI 0.79 to 1.15), 0.93 (95% CI 0.84 to 1.04) and 0.79 (95% CI 0.52 to 1.20) for 3-, 5- and 10-year overall survival rates; and 0.95 (95% CI 0.84 to 1.07) and 1.02 (0.88 to 1.19) for 5- and 10-year disease-specific survival (DSS) rates. The RR for RFS was 1.04 (95% CI 0.71 to 1.52) and 0.96 (95% CI 0.81 to 1.14) at three and five years. For local control rates the RR was 0.95 (95% CI 0.86 to 1.05) and 0.95 (95% CI 0.87 to 1.05) at three and five years; with a RR of 1.09 (95% CI 0.83 to 1.43) for locoregional recurrence, 0.79 (95% CI 0.40 to 1.53) for local and distance recurrence, 2.23 (95% CI 0.78 to 6.34) for para-aortic lymph node metastasis and 0.99 (95% CI 0.72 to 1.35) for distance metastasis. For bladder, rectosigmoid and small bowel complications, the RR was 1.33 (95% CI 0.53 to 3.34), 1.00 (95% CI 0.52 to 1.91) and 3.37 (95% CI 1.06 to 10.72), respectively. These results indicate that there were no significant differences except for increased small bowel complications with HDR (P = 0.04).

AUTHORS' CONCLUSIONS

This review showed no significant differences between HDR- and LDR-ICBT when considering OS, DSS, RFS, local control rate, recurrence, metastasis and treatment related complications for women with cervical carcinoma. Due to some potential advantages of HDR-ICBT (rigid immobilization, outpatient treatment, patient convenience, accuracy of source and applicator positioning, individualized treatment) we recommend the use of HDR-ICBT for all clinical stages of cervix cancer.

Effectiveness of two different HDR brachytherapy regimens with the same BED value in cervical cancer

PURPOSE

To analyze the effectiveness of biologically effective dose (BED) in two different regimens of HDR brachytherapy keeping the same total BED to point A and to compare the relationship of overall treatment time in terms of local control and bladder and rectal complications.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

The study included two groups comprising a total of 90 cervical cancer patients who underwent external beam radiotherapy (EBRT) followed by HDR intracavitary brachytherapy (ICBT). EBRT treatment was delivered by a Co-60 teletherapy unit to a prescribed dose of 45 Gy with 1.8 Gy per fraction in 25 fractions over a period of five weeks. Parallel opposed anterior-posterior (AP/PA) fields with no central shielding were used, followed by the HDR ICBT dose, to point A, of either two fractions of 9.5 Gy with a gap of 10 days, or three fractions of 7.5 Gy with a gap of 7 days between the fractions. Gemcitabine (dose of 150 mg/m²) was given weekly to all the patients as a radiosensitizer. The calculate BED₃ to point A was almost the same in both groups to keep the same late complication rates. The doses, and BED₁₀ and BED₃, were calculated at different bladder and rectal point as well as at the lymphatic trapezoid points. During and after treatment patients were evaluated for local control and complications for 24 months.

RESULTS AND CONCLUSIONS

Doses and BEDs at different bladder, rectal and lymphatic trapezoid points, local control, and complications in both HDR ICBT groups did not have statistically significant differences (p > 0.05). Both HDR ICBT schedules are well tolerable and equally effective.

Late effects after radiotherapy for locally advanced cervical cancer: comparison of two brachytherapy schedules and effect of dose delivered weekly

PURPOSE

To compare the severe late effects (Grade 3 or greater) for two groups of cervical cancer patients treated with the same external beam radiotherapy and two high-dose-rate intracavitary brachytherapy regimens and to investigate the influence of the dose delivered each week.

METHODS AND MATERIALS

For 120 patients, intracavitary brachytherapy was delivered with 33.6 Gy in eight fractions to Point A (HD group), and for 119, intracavitary brachytherapy was delivered with 29.4 Gy in seven fractions to Point A (LD group). The cumulative incidence of severe gastrointestinal and genitourinary late effects were calculated for both dose groups using Kaplan-Meier survival analysis. This method was also used to explore whether the number of weeks with different dose levels could predict the cumulative incidence of late effects.

RESULTS

The actuarial rate of developing severe gastrointestinal morbidity at 7 years was 10.7% and 8.3% for HD and LD groups, respectively. The rate for genitourinary morbidity was 6.6% for the HD group and 5.0% for the LD group, respectively. No significant difference was found between the two groups. The analyses showed that a marginally significant increase occurred in severe gastrointestinal complications as the number of weeks with a physical dose >20 Gy increased in the HD group (p = .047).

CONCLUSION

To establish dose-response relationships for late complications, three-dimensional imaging and dose-volume histogram parameters are needed. We found some indications that 20 Gy/wk is an upper tolerance level when the dose to the International Commission on Radiation Units and Measurements rectum point is 81 Gy(alpha/beta=3) (isoeffective [equivalent] dose of 2-Gy fractions). However, additional investigations using three-dimensional data are needed.

Prognostic nomogram for overall survival in stage IIB-IVA cervical cancer patients treated with concurrent chemoradiotherapy

OBJECTIVE

On the basis of outcome data from concurrent chemoradiotherapy (CCRT) for locally advanced cervical squamous cell carcinoma, the authors developed a nomogram for predicting survival outcome.

STUDY DESIGN

Two hundred fifty-one eligible patients with International Federation of Gynecology and Obstetrics stage IIB-IVA squamous cell carcinoma of the uterine cervix who underwent CCRT were included for the construction of the nomogram. Predictor variables included age, serum squamous cell carcinoma antigen, tumor size, parametrium invasion, hydronephrosis, bladder/rectum invasion, and lymph node metastases. Internal validation of the nomogram was performed.

RESULTS

A nomogram for predicting the 5 year overall survival for these patients was constructed on the basis of a Cox regression model from 7 parameters. The concordance index was 0.69.

CONCLUSION

This nomogram is a predictive tool, upon external validation, that can be used to counsel patients in predicting outcomes. The discriminatory ability of the nomogram indicates that this population should not be considered homogeneous with respect to risk of death.

Late Rectal Complications Evaluated by Computed Tomography–Based Dose Calculations in Patients With Cervical Carcinoma Undergoing High-Dose-Rate Brachytherapy

PURPOSE

To investigate the efficacy of dose calculations at the computed tomography (CT)-based rectal point (CTRP) as a predictive factor for late rectal complications in patients with cervical carcinoma who were treated with a combination of high-dose-rate intracavitary brachytherapy and external beam radiotherapy.

METHODS AND MATERIALS

Ninety-two patients with uterine cervical carcinoma undergoing definitive radiotherapy alone were retrospectively analyzed. The median follow-up time for all patients was 32 months (range, 13-60 months). The cumulative biologically effective dose (BED) was calculated at the rectal reference point as defined by the International Commission on Radiation Units and Measurements Report 38 (BED(RP)) and at the CTRP (BED(CTRP)). Late rectal complications were recorded according to the Radiation Therapy Oncology Group grading system.

RESULTS

The late rectal complications were distributed as follows: Grade 0, 68 patients (74%); Grade 1, 20 patients (22%); Grade 2, 4 patients (4%). Univariate analysis showed that BED(RP), BED(CTRP), RP dose/point A dose ratio, and CTRP dose/point A dose ratio were significantly correlated with late rectal complications (p < 0.05). On multivariate analysis, patients with a rectal BED(CTRP) >/=140 Gy(3) presented with significantly greater frequency of rectal complications (p = 0.031).

CONCLUSIONS

The present results suggest that BED(CTRP) is a useful predictive factor for late rectal complications.

Vesicovaginal fistula formation in patients with Stage IVA cervical carcinoma

OBJECTIVES

To evaluate the rate of vesicovaginal fistula formation and mortality in women with Stage IVA cervical carcinoma.

METHODS

Data were abstracted from the clinical records of women diagnosed with Stage IVA cervical cancer at the time of examination under anesthesia, cystoscopy, and proctoscopy (EUA/C/P) at a single institution from 1994 to 2004. Demographic and treatment characteristics were compared using either Fisher's exact test or Student's t-test, as appropriate. Survival was calculated using the Kaplan-Meier method.

RESULTS

Twenty-three patients were diagnosed with Stage IVA cervical cancer. All were diagnosed with extension of disease into the bladder; one patient had rectal involvement as well. Concurrent chemotherapy and radiation was used in 60.8%, while 30.4% received radiation alone and 8.7% elected no treatment. Fifty-six percent of the patients were smokers. Eleven patients (47.8%) developed a fistula at a median time of 2.9 months from cancer diagnosis. Fistula formation was significantly increased among smokers as compared to non-smokers (73 vs 27%; p=0.03). Two patients (8.7%) are alive without evidence of disease at a median follow-up of 19 months. The disease-specific survival is 23.1 months. Patients who developed a vesicovaginal fistula had a median survival of 11.2 months after fistula formation.

CONCLUSIONS

High rates of vesicovaginal fistula formation can be expected when treating women with extension of cervical cancer into the bladder, particularly among women who smoke. The routine use of EUA/C/P at the time of initial diagnosis aids in counseling women about the likelihood of this complication. Novel strategies for managing vesicovaginal fistulae after chemoradiation are needed.

Concurrent weekly cisplatin plus external beam radiotherapy and high-dose rate brachytherapy for advanced cervical cancer: A control cohort comparison with radiation alone on treatment outcome and complications

PURPOSE

To test, though a control-cohort study, the hypothesis that concurrent chemoradiotherapy (CCRT) using weekly cisplatin, plus high-dose rate intracavitary brachytherapy (HDRICB) is superior to radiation (RT) alone in patients with advanced cervical cancer.

METHODS AND MATERIALS

A total of 171 patients with Stage IIB-III cervical cancer were enrolled in this study. Seventy patients were treated with CCRT and the results were compared with those of 101 patients who had been treated with RT using the same protocol at an early period. RT consisted of 45 Gy in 25 fractions to the whole pelvis, followed by a 12.6-Gy boost to the parametrium. Four courses of HDRICB using 6.0 Gy to Point A were performed. Chemotherapy consisted of weekly cisplatin at a dose of 40 mg/m(2) for 5-6 cycles.

RESULTS

The 4-year actuarial survival was 74% for the CCRT group and 68% for the RT group (p = 0.60). The 4-year pelvic relapse-free survival was 87% for the CCRT group and 85% for the RT group (p = 0.37). The 4-year distant metastases-free survival was 75% for the CCRT group and 76% for the RT group (p = 0.44). The cumulative incidence of gastrointestinal and genitourinary injuries of grade 3 or above was 14.3% for the CCRT group and 7.9% for the RT group (p = 0.19).

CONCLUSION

This study did not show a survival benefit of CCRT with weekly cisplatin and HDRICB for Stage II-III cervical cancer, nor did it demonstrate a significant increase of late complications when comparing with RT alone.

A pre-optimised dosimetry system using a rigid applicator for intracavitary treatment of cervical carcinoma

AIMS

Tumour control and complication risk have been major concerns in the treatment of cervical carcinoma. A review of dose distribution for intracavitary treatment of cervical carcinoma revealed that modification of the Manchester dosimetry system is necessary for cases of narrow-sized vagina. A revised dosimetry system was introduced in the present study, with the objective of optimising the dose coverage for the parametrium while minimising the bladder and rectum dosage by restricting the rectal dose so as not to exceed 75% of the brachytherapy prescription dose.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

A suitable-sized applicator was selected according to the patient's anatomy. The revised system is optimised based on the fixed geometry of the applicator. The system was therefore predefined and the distribution of the treatment dose already determined before application. The revised system was applied to 135 cases, involving 540 applications. The clinical outcome in terms of local tumour control and complication rates is reported. The differences between the revised system and the Manchester system in terms of dose coverage for the parametrium and the rectum dose were compared.

RESULTS

The results showed that higher rectal and parametrial dosages were obtained with the Manchester system as compared with the revised system. Our study showed that over 50% of our patients would have received a rectal dose close to 100% of the point A dose if the Manchester system was applied, whereas it was restricted to below 75% using the revised system. Using the revised system, the significance of the parametrial dosage coverage in relation to local control was assessed: the mean dose to the rectum and the bladder as a percentage of point A was 65.7 +/- 5% (range 50-85%) and 66.4 +/- 14% (range 29-116%), respectively. The 5-year actuarial local failure-free survival rates were 90, 92.9, 86.8, 100, 69.7 and 0% for stages IB, IIA, IIB, IIIA, IIIB and IV (P < 0.0001), respectively. The 3-year actuarial complication rates (grade 3/4) for proctitis and cystitis were 1.4 and 0.5%, respectively. The dosage coverage for the parametrium was found to be significant (P = 0.029) in relation to local control for early-stage disease.

CONCLUSIONS

The favourable local tumour control and low complication rates shown by our results indicate that the revised system presents an optimal dose distribution, particularly for the application of small ovoids, whereas morbidity was reduced to a lower level without compromising local control.

Radiotherapy and wound healing

Radiotherapy is an invaluable weapon when treating cancer. However, the deleterious effects of radiation, both immediate and long-term, may have a significant effect on local tissues. Problematic wound healing in radiation-damaged tissue constitutes a major problem that is frequently overlooked during the management of patients who require radiotherapy, or have had radiotherapy in the past. Poor wound healing may lead to chronic ulceration, pain, secondary infection and psychological distress and compromise the outcome of general or reconstructive surgery. We discuss the pathophysiology of poor wound healing following radiotherapy, specific problems for radiation-damaged tissue and potential treatments to improve wound healing of irradiated tissues.

Phase II study of the American Brachytherapy Society guidelines for the use of high-dose rate brachytherapy in the treatment of cervical carcinoma: is 45-50.4 Gy radiochemotherapy plus 31.8 Gy in six fractions high-dose rate brachytherapy tolerable?

In 2000, the American Brachytherapy Society (ABS) published incompletely evaluated guidelines for curative chemoradiation and high-dose rate (HDR) brachytherapy for cervical cancer: our aim was to assess guideline tolerability in an Asian population. From 2000, all stage I-IVA cervical carcinoma patients were treated following ABS guidelines. Early disease (FIGO stage I/II <4 cm) received 45 Gy whole-pelvis external-beam radiation (EBRT) at 1.8 Gy/fraction, while advanced-stage disease received 50.4 Gy: no central shielding was used. All patients were planned to receive chemotherapy during EBRT, cisplatin 40 mg/m(2) weekly. All patients received 31.8-Gy HDR brachytherapy (six fractions of 5.3 Gy/fraction) to point A via three-channel applicators. Radiotherapy was completed within 8 weeks. Toxicity scoring used Common Toxicity Criteria. Nineteen of 21 (90.4%) patients (8 early, 13 advanced stage) received planned radiation, and 85.7% received planned chemotherapy. Median follow-up was 24 months (range 9-50 months). Three-year overall survival (S) was 79.1% and disease-free survival (DFS) was 64.8%. S/DFS for early and advanced stage was 85.7%/85.7% and 73.3%/47.1%, respectively. Complete response (CR) was achieved by 85.7% of patients, partial response 14.3%. For those in CR, there were no local failures. Acute cystitis occurred in 23.8%, proctitis 4.8%, and gastroenteritis 47.6%. Late cystitis occurred in 9.5%, gastroenteritis 4.8%, and genitourinary fistula (in the presence of progressive disease) 4.8%. No grade 3/4 treatment-related toxicity occurred. The ABS guidelines were well tolerated and efficacious in our study, although longer follow-up is required. Further studies are warranted to validate safety and efficacy of the recommendations.

A single institutional experience with definitive radiotherapy for cervical cancer using both high- and low-dose-rate brachytherapy

OBJECTIVE

To evaluate outcomes in cervical cancer patients treated with high-dose-rate (HDRB) or low-dose-rate (LDRB) brachytherapy.

METHODS

A retrospective chart review compared control rates, survival, and complications in the two groups.

RESULTS

All patients received pelvic EBRT (45 Gy/5 weeks). 106 patients receiving LDRB were compared to 107 treated with HDRB. The median point A LDRB and HDRB dose was 42 Gy and 25 Gy/5, respectively. Tumor size and stage (I(B) 23% LDRB, 30% HDRB, II(A) 22% LDRB, 11% HDRB, II(B) 44% LDRB, 48% HDRB, III(B) 11% LDRB and HDRB) were similar, but more HDRB patients received chemosensitization (44% versus 6%). After adjusting for lymph node status with cox regression, no difference in 5-year survival (53% HDRB and 61% LDRB P = 0.088) or 5-year DFS (54% both groups, P = 0.089) was found between the two groups. Local recurrences occurred in 19% of the LDRB and 5% of the HDRB cohort. The time to LR was significantly longer in the HDRB group, and this persisted after adjusting for the increased used of chemotherapy in these patients. There was no significant difference in grade III or IV toxicity (6.6% LDRB and 3.7% HDRB).

CONCLUSIONS

This HDRB dose fractionation schedule yielded improved local control but similar survival compared to LDRB.

Current controversies in high-dose-rate versus low-dose-rate brachytherapy for cervical cancer

The use of brachytherapy in the treatment of cervical cancer has increased worldwide since its initial introduction over 100 years ago. However, certain aspects of the use of high-dose-rate (HDR) versus low-dose-rate (LDR) brachytherapy continue to be controversial, particularly the role of HDR in FIGO Stage III cervical cancer and the use of HDR with concurrent chemotherapy. This study represents a systematic literature review of prospective and retrospective series of patients with cervical carcinoma treated with external-beam radiation (EBRT) followed by either HDR or LDR radiation. The local control rates, survival rates, and treatment-related complications in patients with Stage III cervical cancer treated with HDR or LDR and those treated with concomitant chemotherapy are examined. Patients with Stage III cervical cancer treated with EBRT and brachytherapy have a local control rate of >50% in most series. Randomized prospective and retrospective studies show overall statistically equivalent local control, overall survival, and complication rates between HDR and LDR. However, LDR may be preferable for large, bulky tumors at the time of brachytherapy. Retrospective studies of HDR and concurrent chemotherapy are limited but have demonstrated toxicity rates similar to those with LDR. Selected patients with Stage III cervical carcinoma who have an adequate response to EBRT and concomitant chemotherapy may be treated with HDR brachytherapy. The existing literature shows no significant increase in complications in patients treated with HDR and concurrent chemotherapy; however, sufficient tumor shrinkage prior to HDR and careful monitoring of the dose to the normal tissues are imperative.

Risk stratification of patients with advanced squamous cell carcinoma of cervix treated by radiotherapy alone

PURPOSE

To identify prognostic factors for local and distant relapse and perform risk stratification for patients with advanced cervical cancer treated with radiotherapy (RT) alone.

METHODS AND MATERIALS

A total of 1031 patients with Stage IB-IVA squamous cell carcinoma of the cervix treated with full-course RT but without any chemotherapy were included for analysis. Of these, 311 patients with nonbulky Stage IB-IIA disease were designated the reference group and the other 720 patients were the study group. The associations of stage, squamous cell carcinoma antigen (SCC-ag) level, hemoglobin level, age, cell differentiation, and pelvic lymph node status with treatment failure were evaluated. The independent prognostic factors were identified by multivariate analysis. The study group was further stratified into subgroups using combinations of these risk factors.

RESULTS

In the study group, independent risk factors for local relapse were advanced stage and age <45 years. The 5-year local relapse-free survival rate was 86% for patients > or =45 years with bulky Stage IB-IIA or IIB disease, and was even greater, up to 90% if the SCC-ag level was <2. In contrast, it was 65% for patients with Stage IIIB who were <45 years old. The independent risk factors for distant failure were advanced stage, SCC-ag level >2, and positive pelvic lymph nodes. The 5-year distant relapse-free survival rate was 83% for patients with bulky Stage IB-IIA and IIB disease, SCC-ag level <2, and negative lymph nodes and 43% for patients with Stage III, SCC-ag level >2, and positive lymph nodes.

CONCLUSION

The risk of treatment failure in advanced-stage cervical cancer patients treated by RT alone can be more precisely predicted by risk stratification. A certain subgroup of patients had better control than the others. The benefit of treating these relatively low-risk patients with additional treatment such as concurrent chemotherapy should be further evaluated in prospective studies or meta-analyses.

Comparison of low and high dose rate brachytherapy in the treatment of uterine cervix cancer. Retrospective analysis of two sequential series

PURPOSE

This retrospective analysis aims to report on the comparative outcome of cervical cancer patients treated with low dose rate (LDR) and high dose rate (HDR) brachytherapy.

METHODS AND MATERIALS

From 1989 to 1995, 190 patients were treated with low dose rate (LDR) brachytherapy (LDR group) and from 1994 to 2001, 118 patients were treated with high dose rate (HDR) brachytherapy (HDR group). FIGO stage distribution for the LDR group was Stage I: 6.3%; Stage II: 57.4%; and Stage III: 36.3% and for the HDR group Stage I: 9.3%; Stage II: 43.2%; and Stage III: 47.4%. All patients were treated with telecobalt external-beam radiotherapy (EBR). Median doses of LDR brachytherapy at Point A were 40 Gy and 50 Gy for patients treated with 1 and 2 implants, respectively. All patients from the HDR group were treated with 24 Gy in 4 fractions of 6 Gy to Point A. Survival, disease-free survival, local control, and late complications at 5 years, were endpoints compared for both groups.

RESULTS

Median follow-up time for LDR and HDR groups was 70 months (range, 8-127 months) and 33 months (range, 4-117 months), respectively. For all stages combined, overall survival, disease-free survival, and local control at 5 years were better in the LDR group (69% vs. 55%, p = 0.007; 73% vs. 56%, p = 0.002; and 74% vs. 65%; p = 0.04, respectively). For clinical Stages I and II, no differences was seen in overall survival, disease-free survival, and local control at 5 years between the two groups. For clinical Stage III, overall survival and disease-free survival at 5 years were better in the LDR group than in the HDR group (46% vs. 36%, p = 0.04 and 49% vs. 37%, p = 0.03, respectively), and local control was marginally higher in the LDR group than in the HDR group (58% vs. 50%, p = 0.19). The 5-year probability of rectal complications was higher in the LDR group than in the HDR group (16% vs. 8%, p = 0.03) and 5-year probability of small bowel and urinary complications was not statistically different between the the LDR group and the HDR group (4.6% vs. 8.9%, p = 0.17 and 6% vs. 3%, p = 0.13, respectively).

CONCLUSIONS

This comparative series suggests similar outcome for Stages I and II patients treated with either HDR or LDR brachytherapy. Lower overall and disease-free survival and marginally lower local control were observed for Stage III patients treated with HDR brachytherapy. Less late rectal complications were observed in the HDR group patients. These findings were probably the result of the relatively low HDR brachytherapy dose delivered at Point A.

Long-term results of high-dose rate brachytherapy in cervix cancer using a small number of fractions

OBJECTIVES

To evaluate the long-term treatment outcome of patients with carcinoma of the cervix treated with high dose rate brachytherapy (HDRB) using a small number of fractions.

METHODS

Between 1984 and 1997, 282 patients with cervix cancer (stages IB to IVA) were treated with external beam radiotherapy to the whole pelvis (median dose of 45 Gy) and HDRB (median dose of 24 Gy at point A in 3 insertions given weekly). Endpoints assessed were survival, patterns of failure and complications. Multivariate analysis was performed to identify variables predictive for overall survival and local control. Variables investigated were stage, age, overall duration of treatment, HDRB scheduling and total dose to point A.

RESULTS

At a median follow-up of 86.3 months for patients at risk, the 5-, 10- and 15-year overall survival rates are 57%, 52% and 47%, respectively. On multivariate analysis, only stage and age correlated with improved survival. Treatment duration beyond 47 days was associated with poorer overall survival, although it did not reach statistical significance (P = 0.10). Brachytherapy scheduling and BED to point A had no impact on overall survival. Stage and age significantly correlated with pelvic disease control. Duration of therapy, scheduling of the brachytherapy and BED at point A were not individual predictors for overall local control. Overall, gastrointestinal and genitourinary actuarial complication rates were 15% and 8%, respectively.

CONCLUSIONS

In our experience, HDRB using 3 insertions is well tolerated and the results are comparable to HDRB using larger number of fractions and to low dose rate brachytherapy.

Long-term results of high-dose rate intracavitary brachytherapy for squamous cell carcinoma of the uterine cervix

BACKGROUND

The authors performed a long-term follow-up study to evaluate the efficacy and late toxicity of high-dose rate intracavitary brachytherapy (HDR-ICBT) for cervical carcinoma.

METHODS

From 1968 to 1986, 1148 patients with Stage IB to IVB squamous cell carcinoma of the cervix (staging was performed according to the International Federation of Gynecology and Obstetrics) were treated with a combination of external beam radiotherapy (EBRT) and HDR-ICBT. For patients with early-stage disease, 20 gray (Gy) of EBRT was delivered to the whole pelvis, followed by 24 Gy/4 fractions of HDR-ICBT and 30 Gy of central-shielding EBRT. For patients with advanced-stage disease, 20-40 Gy of whole pelvic EBRT was administered, followed by 24 Gy/4 fractions of ICBT and 30-10 Gy of central-shielding EBRT. The overall treatment time was approximately 6 weeks. Among survivors, the follow-up rate was 98% and the median follow-up duration was 22 years.

RESULTS

The 10-year pelvic tumor control rates were 93% for patients with Stage IB disease, 82% for patients with Stage II disease, and 75% for patients with Stage III disease. The 10-year overall and cause-specific survival rates were 74% and 89% for patients with Stage IB disease, 52% and 74% for patients with Stage II disease, and 42% and 59% for patients with Stage III disease, respectively. The 10-year actuarial rates of major complications were 4.4% in the rectosigmoid colon, 0.9% in the bladder, and 3.3% in the small intestines.

CONCLUSIONS

The results of the current study suggest that the combination of EBRT and HDR-ICBT according to the authors' protocol provided outcomes that were comparable to those of the conventional low-dose rate brachytherapy with acceptable rates of late complications in the treatment of cervical carcinoma.

Recurrent squamous cell carcinoma of cervix after definitive radiotherapy

PURPOSE

To study retrospectively the characteristics and survival of patients with recurrent squamous cell carcinoma (SCC) of the cervix after definitive radiotherapy (RT) and to identify subsets of patients who might benefit from aggressive salvage treatment.

METHODS AND MATERIALS

Between 1990 and 1999, 1292 patients with Stage I-IVA SCC of the cervix underwent full-course RT. Of the 1292 patients, 375 (29%) had either local or distant failure and were included in this analysis. The 35 patients (2.7%) with both pelvic and distant relapse were excluded. In the 162 patients with local failure, 71 (44%) had persistent disease and 91 (56%) had a relapse after complete tumor regression. Of these 162 patients, 47 (29%) received salvage surgery. In the 213 patients with distant failure, 46 (22%) had isolated para-aortic lymph node (PALN) metastasis, and 35 (76%) of them were treated with concurrent chemoradiotherapy/RT. Patients with supraclavicular lymph node (SCLN) relapse usually underwent concurrent chemoradiotherapy. Palliative chemotherapy and/or RT were given by decision of the responsible attending physician.

RESULTS

The independent prognostic factors for local failure were advanced stage and young age (<45 years) and, for distant failure, were advanced stage, positive pelvic lymph nodes, and high serum SCC-antigen levels. The 5-year overall survival rate was 10% and 11%, respectively, for patients with local or distant failure. For local relapse, the 5-year overall survival rate was 29% vs. 3% (p = 0.0001) for patients with vs. without salvage surgery and 22% vs. 9% vs. 4% for patients with tumors confined to the cervix, tumors extending but not beyond the cervix and adjacent tissues, and tumor extending beyond adjacent tissues but contained within the pelvis (p = 0.005). The survival rates, either with or without salvage surgery, were nearly identical between patients with persistent disease and those with relapse after complete regression. The 3-year overall survival rate was 34%, 28%, and 5% (p = 0.001), respectively, for patients with PALN relapse alone, SCLN relapse with or without PALN relapse, and relapse other than PALN and SCLN. Of the patients with PALN relapse alone, 27% survived >5 years.

CONCLUSION

For recurrent SCC of the cervix after RT, patients with isolated PALN relapse salvaged by RT or combined chemoradiotherapy or those with cervical relapse salvaged by surgery can achieve long-term survival. Early detection of relapse with aggressive salvage treatment is important for achieving better outcome. Patients with persistent disease or relapse after complete remission had similar outcomes. Patients with SCLN relapse had a longer survival time than those with other metastases (except PALN), and palliative RT might be beneficial.

Clinical comparison of two linear-quadratic model-based isoeffect fractionation schemes of high-dose-rate intracavitary brachytherapy for cervical cancer

PURPOSE

Two linear-quadratic model-based isoeffect fractionation schemes of high-dose-rate intracavitary brachytherapy (HDR-IC) were used to treat cervical cancer in two consecutive periods. Patient outcomes and complications were analyzed and compared.

METHODS AND MATERIALS

Between November 1987 and December 1996, a total of 541 women diagnosed with cervical cancer were treated with curative-intent radiotherapy. Patients were categorized into two groups according to the two isoeffect schemes used. Group 1 consisted of 254 patients treated with external beam radiotherapy (EBRT) plus 7.2 Gy HDR-IC to Point A for three fractions in the first period. Group 2 consisted of 284 patients treated with EBRT plus 4.8 Gy HDR-IC for five fractions in the second period. The goal of the new scheme for the latter group was to deliver an isoeffect dose that maintained similar tumor control but reduced normal tissue complications. The calculated biologically effective dose (BED(10), assuming an alpha/beta ratio = 10) of EBRT plus HDR-IC for tumor and acute responding tissue in Groups 1 and 2 was 90 Gy(10) (52.8 + 37.2 Gy) and 88.6 Gy(10) (53.1 + 35.5 Gy), respectively. The corresponding BED(3) for late responding tissue (assuming an alpha/beta ratio = 3) in Groups 1 and 2 was 146.7 Gy(3) (73.3 + 73.4 Gy) and 134.4 Gy(3) (72 + 62.4 Gy), respectively. Patients were followed for 6.1-15.2 years (median, 9.8 years).

RESULTS

Overall, 66 patients (12.2%) developed pelvic recurrence. Of these, 53 patients had central recurrence. Of the 53 patients with central recurrence, 24 (9.4%) were in Group 1 and 29 (10.1%) in Group 2 (p = 0.722). The actuarial pelvic control rate for Groups 1 and 2 was 88.2% and 86.3% at 5 years and 87.3% and 85.5% at 10 years, respectively (p = 0.504). The actuarial overall survival rate for Groups 1 and 2 was 63.5% and 56.1% at 5 years and 47.8% and 49.3% at 10 years, respectively (p = 0.734). The actuarial proctitis rate for Groups 1 and 2 was 49.7% and 32.7% at 5 years and 50.5% and 32.7% at 10 years, respectively (p <0.001). Most of the decrease in the rate of proctitis was a result of a decrease in the incidence of low-grade proctitis (38% vs. 22%). The incidence of high-grade complications remained unchanged, 8% vs. 7%. The actuarial cystitis rate for Groups 1 and 2 was 14.3% vs. 11.4% at 5 years and 24.1% vs. 15% at 10 years, respectively (p = 0.134). Multivariate analysis revealed that the fractionation scheme (three fractions vs. five fractions) was a significant factor influencing the proctitis rate (p = 0.004, hazard ratio = 0.807; 95% confidence interval, 0.697-0.934), but not the local pelvic control rate, overall survival rate, or cystitis rate.

CONCLUSION

The treatment results of the two groups maintained similar outcomes, while the complications decreased. The linear-quadratic model correctly predicted this outcome. Biologically, the manipulation of the fraction size in our study suggested that the sensitivity of the late responding tissue to the fractional change from 7.2 Gy to 4.8 Gy in HDR-IC is high and detectable clinically. The success, however, had its limitations, and the improvement was confined to low-grade complications.

A prospective randomized study on two dose fractionation regimens of high-dose-rate brachytherapy for carcinoma of the uterine cervix: comparison of efficacies and toxicities between two regimens

To evaluate the toxicities and efficacies of two fractionation regimens of high-dose-rate brachytherapy in uterine cervical cancer, patients were stratified by stage Ib-IIa versus IIb-IVa, and randomly assigned to receive 3 Gy fractions (group A) or 5 Gy fractions (group B). External radiotherapy was performed using a 10 MV radiography with a daily 1.8 Gy up to 30.6 Gy to the whole pelvis, and then with a midline shield up to 45.0 Gy. Brachytherapy was performed with 3 Gy x 10 times or 5 Gy x 5 times, and this was followed by booster brachytherapy of a smaller fraction to the residual tumor. Between August 1999 to July 2000, 46 patients were eligible. Median follow-up period was 42 months (5-49). The range of age was 37-83 yr (median, 58). The three-year disease-specific survival rates of group A (n=23) and B (n=23) were 90.5%, 84.9%, respectively (p=0.64). The three-year pelvic control rates of group A and B were 90.0% and 90.9%, respectively (p=0.92). The incidences of late complications of the rectum or bladder of grade 2 or greater in groups A and B were 23.8% and 9.1%, respectively (p=0.24). Our study showed that the results of two regimens were comparable. Fractionation regimen using 5 Gy fractions seems to be safe and effective, and offers shorter treatment duration.

Is simulation necessary for each high-dose-rate tandem and ovoid insertion in carcinoma of the cervix?

PURPOSE

To evaluate the dose variation in high-dose-rate (HDR) intracavitary brachytherapy for cancer of the cervix when treatment planning is performed prior to each applicator insertion versus when the initial plan is used for each treatment.

METHODS AND MATERIALS

Fourteen patients with carcinoma of the cervix were treated with chemoradiotherapy followed by five intracavitary tandem and ovoid insertions of 600 cGy/fraction. We modified the actual plans to calculate the dose each dose point would have received using only the treatment plan created for the initial fraction.

RESULTS

An increase in the percent dose to the rectum, bladder, and vaginal surface of 5%, cGy (p = 0.038), 6% (p = 0.006), and 11%, respectively, were observed when the initial treatment plan was used versus using the optimized treatment plan for each insertion. The greatest single change resulted in a percent increase of 35%, 30%, and 45% to the rectum, bladder, and vaginal surface points, respectively.

CONCLUSIONS

Increased dose to at-risk structures occurred when individualized treatment planning was not performed. Since a significant increase in dose to the rectum (p = 0.038) and bladder (p = 0.006) was obtained without customized treatment planning, we continue to advocate individualized treatment planning in HDR tandem and ovoid insertions for the treatment of cervix cancer.