Conformal episcleral plaque therapy

A practical method of estimating medium-heterogeneity corrected dose without a Monte Carlo calculation in ocular brachytherapy using 125I COMS plaques

PURPOSE

To provide a practical method of estimating medium-heterogeneity corrected dose without a Monte Carlo (MC) calculation in ocular brachytherapy using 125I Collaborative Ocular Melanoma Study (COMS) plaques.

METHODS AND MATERIALS

Using egs_brachy, MC simulations (1) under task group-43 assumptions with fully loaded seed configurations in water (HOMO) and (2) with effects of plaque backing, insert and inter-seed interactions (HETERO) were performed for seven 125I COMS plaques (10 mm-22 mm in diameter), and homogeneous dose (DHOMO) and heterogeneous dose (DHETERO) for central-axis and off-axis points were determined. For DHOMO, 85 Gy was normalized to a depth of 5 mm. Central-axis heterogeneity correction factors (HCFs) from a depth of 0 mm (inner sclera) to 22 mm (opposite retina) were derived from a ratio of DHETERO to DHOMO. Off-axis HCFs for optic disc/macula and lens as a function of distance from optic disc/macula (DT/MT) for various basal dimensions of tumor (BD/BM) were derived from DHETERO/DHOMO.

RESULTS

Central-axis HCF varied with a dose reduction of 10.3-19.8% by heterogeneity. Off-axis HCF for optic disc/macula varied significantly depending on DT/MT and BD/BM with a dose reduction of 11.3-38.3%. Off-axis HCF for lens had a dependence on MT and BM with its variation of 11.0-19.0%. A clinical example of using HCFs to estimate DHETERO was presented.

CONCLUSIONS

The practical method of using depth-dependent central-axis HCF and DT/MT- and BD/BM-dependent off-axis HCF provided in this study will facilitate a heterogeneous dose estimate for 125I COMS plaques without MC calculations.

Transitioning from a COMS-based plaque brachytherapy program to using eye physics plaques and plaque simulator treatment planning system: A single institutional experience

The aim of this work is to describe the implementation and commissioning of a plaque brachytherapy program using Eye Physics eye plaques and Plaque Simulator treatment planning system based on the experience of one institution with an established COMS-based plaque program. Although commissioning recommendations are available in official task groups publications such as TG-129 and TG-221, we found that there was a lack of published experiences with the specific details of such a transition and the practical application of the commissioning guidelines. The specific issues addressed in this paper include discussing the lack of FDA approval of the Eye Physics plaques and Plaque Simulator treatment planning system, the commissioning of the plaques and treatment planning system including considerations of the heterogeneity corrected calculations, and the implementation of a second check using an FDA-approved treatment planning system. We have also discussed the use of rental plaques, the analysis of plans using dose histograms, and the development of a quality management program. By sharing our experiences with the commissioning of this program this document will assist other institutions with the same task and act as a supplement to the recommendations in the recently published TG-221.

Radio-luminescent imaging for rapid, high-resolution eye plaque loading verification

BACKGROUND

Eye plaque brachytherapy is currently an optimal therapy for intraocular cancers. Due to the lack of an effective and practical technique to measure the seed radioactivity distribution, current quality assurance (QA) practice according to the American Association of Physicists in Medicine TG129 only stipulates that the plaque assembly be visually inspected. Consequently, uniform seed activity is routinely adopted to avoid possible loading mistakes of differential seed loading. However, modulated dose delivery, which represents a general trend in radiotherapy to provide more personalized treatment for a given tumor and patient, requires differential activities in the loaded seeds.

PURPOSE

In this study, a fast and low-cost radio-luminescent imaging and dose calculating system to verify the seed activity distribution for differential loading was developed.

METHODS

A proof-of-concept system consisting of a thin scintillator sheet coupled to a camera/lens system was constructed. A seed-loaded plaque can be placed directly on the scintillator surface with the radioactive seeds facing the scintillator. The camera system collects the radioluminescent signal generated by the scintillator on its opposite side. The predicted dose distribution in the scintillator's sensitive layer was calculated using a Monte Carlo simulation with the planned plaque loading pattern of I-125 seeds. Quantitative comparisons of the distribution of relative measured signal intensity and that of the relative predicted dose in the sensitive layer were performed by gamma analysis, similar to intensity-modulated radiation therapy QA.

RESULTS

Data analyses showed high gamma (3%/0.3 mm, global, 20% threshold) passing rates for correct seed loadings and low passing rates with distinguished high gamma value area for incorrect loadings, indicating that possible errors may be detected. The measurement and analysis only required a few extra minutes, significantly shorter than the time to assay the extra verification seeds the physicist already must perform as recommended by TG129.

CONCLUSIONS

Radio-luminescent QA can be used to facilitate and assure the implementation of intensity-modulated, customized plaque loading.

Individualized dosimetry in Ru-106 ophthalmic brachytherapy based on MRI-derived ocular anatomical parameters

PURPOSE

To estimate ocular geometry-related inaccuracies of the dosimetric plan in Ru-106 ophthalmic brachytherapy.

METHODS AND MATERIALS

Thirty patients with intraocular lesions were treated with brachytherapy using a Ru-106 plaque-shell of inner radius of 12 mm. Magnetic resonance imaging was employed to determine the external scleral radius at tumor site and the tumor margins. A mathematical model was developed to determine the distance between the external sclera and the internal surface of the plaque associated with the tangential application of the plaque on the treated eye. Differences in delivered dose to the tumor apex, sclera and tumor margins as derived by considering the default eye-globe of standard size (external sclera radius = 12 mm) against the individual-specific eye globe were determined.

RESULTS

The radius of external sclera at the tumor site was found to range between 10.90 and 13.05 mm for the patient cohort studied. When the patient specific eye-globe/tumor geometry is not taken into account, the delivered dose was found to be overestimated by 8.1% ± 4.1% (max = 15.3%) at tumor apex, by 1.5% ± 2.8% (max = 5.7%) at anterior tumor margin, by 16.6% ± 7.5% (max = 36.4%) at posterior tumor margin and 8.1% ± 3.8% (max = 13.2%) at central sclera of eyes with lower than the default radius. The corresponding dose overestimations for eyes with higher than the default radius was 13.5% ± 4.3% (max = 22.3%), 1.5% ± 2.8% (max = 5.7%), 12.6% ± 4.5% (max = 20.0%), and 15.1% ± 5.0% (max = 24.4%).

CONCLUSIONS

The proposed patient-specific approach for Ru-106 brachytherapy treatment planning may improve dosimetric accuracy. Individualized treatment planning dosimetry may prevent undertreatment of intraocular tumors especially for highly myopic or hyperopic eyes.

Recent advancements in the management of retinoblastoma and uveal melanoma

Retinoblastoma in children and uveal melanoma in adults can pose a serious threat to both vision and life. For many decades, enucleation was often the only option to treat these intraocular malignancies. For retinoblastoma, intra-arterial chemotherapy is often utilized as the primary treatment at advanced academic centers and has dramatically improved local tumor control and eye salvage rates. For uveal melanoma, both plaque brachytherapy and proton beam irradiation have served as widely utilized therapies with a local failure rate of approximately 1–10%, depending on the series. Major recent advancements have allowed for a better understanding of the genomics of uveal melanoma and the impact of certain mutations on metastatic susceptibility. Gene expression profile stratifies uveal melanomas into two classes: low-risk (class 1) and high-risk (class 2). A loss-of-function mutation of BAP1 is associated with a class 2 gene expression profile and therefore confers worse prognosis due to elevated risk of metastasis. On the other hand, gain-of-function mutations of EIF1AX and SF3B1 correspond to a gene expression profile of class 1A and class 1B and confer a better prognosis. Preferentially expressed antigen in melanoma (PRAME) is an antigen that increases metastatic susceptibility when expressed in uveal melanoma cells. In addition to plaque brachytherapy and proton beam irradiation, both of which have demonstrated superb clinical outcomes, scientists are actively investigating newer therapeutic modalities as either primary therapy or adjuvant treatment, including a novel nanoparticle therapy and immunotherapy.

Quantifying Subclinical and Longitudinal Microvascular Changes Following Episcleral Plaque Brachytherapy Using Spectral Domain-Optical Coherence Tomography Angiography

PURPOSE

To assess longitudinal microvascular changes in eyes treated with I-125 episcleral plaque brachytherapy (EPB).

METHODS

High resolution OCT angiograms of the central 3×3mm macula were obtained from I-125 episcleral plaque brachytherapy treated and untreated fellow eyes of 61 patients. Capillary density (vessel skeleton density, VSD) and caliber (vessel diameter index, VDI) were quantified using previously validated semi-automated algorithms. Nonperfusion was also quantified as flow impairment regions (FIR). Exams from treated and fellow eyes obtained pre-treatment and at 6-month, 1-year, and 2-year intervals were compared using generalized estimating equation linear models. Dosimetry maps were used to evaluate spatial correlation between radiation dose and microvascular metrics.

RESULTS

At 6 months, treated eyes had significantly lower VSD (0.145 ± 0.003 vs 0.155 ± 0.002; p = 0.009) and higher FIR (2.01 ± 0.199 vs 1.46 ± 0.104; p = 0.010) compared to fellow eyes. There was a significant decrease in VSD and a corresponding increase in FIR even for treated eyes without clinically identifiable retinopathy at 6 months. VDI was significantly higher in treated eyes than in fellow eyes at 2 years (2.92 ± 0.025 vs 2.84 ± 0.018; p < 0.001). When our cohort was categorized into low dose radiation (<15Gy) and high dose radiation (>45Gy) to the fovea, there were significant differences in VSD and FIR between groups.

CONCLUSIONS

OCTA can be used to quantify and monitor EPB induced retinopathy, and can detect vascular abnormalities even in the absence of clinically observable retinopathy. OCTA may therefore be useful in investigating treatment interventions that aim to delay EPB-induced radiation retinopathy.

AAPM recommendations on medical physics practices for ocular plaque brachytherapy: Report of task group 221

The American Association of Physicists in Medicine (AAPM) formed Task Group 221 (TG-221) to discuss a generalized commissioning process, quality management considerations, and clinical physics practice standards for ocular plaque brachytherapy. The purpose of this report is also, in part, to aid the clinician to implement recommendations of the AAPM TG-129 report, which placed emphasis on dosimetric considerations for ocular brachytherapy applicators used in the Collaborative Ocular Melanoma Study (COMS). This report is intended to assist medical physicists in establishing a new ocular brachytherapy program and, for existing programs, in reviewing and updating clinical practices. The report scope includes photon- and beta-emitting sources and source:applicator combinations. Dosimetric studies for photon and beta sources are reviewed to summarize the salient issues and provide references for additional study. The components of an ocular plaque brachytherapy quality management program are discussed, including radiation safety considerations, source calibration methodology, applicator commissioning, imaging quality assurance tests for treatment planning, treatment planning strategies, and treatment planning system commissioning. Finally, specific guidelines for commissioning an ocular plaque brachytherapy program, clinical physics practice standards in ocular plaque brachytherapy, and other areas reflecting the need for specialized treatment planning systems, measurement phantoms, and detectors (among other topics) to support the clinical practice of ocular brachytherapy are presented. Expected future advances and developments for ocular brachytherapy are discussed.

Monte Carlo dosimetry modeling of focused kV x-ray radiotherapy of eye diseases with potential nanoparticle dose enhancement

PURPOSE

Eye plaque brachytherapy is the most common approach for intraocular cancer treatment. It is, however, invasive and subject to large setup uncertainty due to the surgical operation. We propose a novel-focused kV x-ray technique with potential nanoparticle (NP) enhancement and evaluate its application in treating choroidal melanoma and iris melanoma by Monte Carlo (MC) dosimetry modeling.

METHODS

A polycapillary x-ray lens was used to focus 45 kVp x rays to achieve pinpoint accuracy of dose delivery to small tumors near critical structures. In addition to allowing for beam focusing, the use of kV x rays takes advantage of the strong photoelectric absorption of metallic NPs in that energy regime and hence strong radiosensitization. We constructed an MC simulation program that takes into account the x-ray optic modeling and used GEANT4 for dosimetric calculation. Extensive phantom measurements using a prototype-focused x-ray system were carried out. The MC simulation of simple geometry phantom irradiation was first compared to measurements to verify the x-ray optic lens modeling in conjunction with the Geant4 dosimetric calculation. To simulate tumor treatment, a geometric eye model and two tumor models were constructed. Dose distributions of the simulated treatments were then calculated. NP radiosensitization was also simulated for two concentrations of 2 nm gold NP (AuNP) uniformly distributed in the tumor.

RESULTS

The MC-simulated full width at half maximum (FWHM) and central-axis depth dose of the focused kV x-ray beam match those measured on EBT3 films within ~10% around the depth of focus of the beam. Dose distributions of the simulated ocular tumor treatments show that focused x-ray beams can concentrate the high-dose region in or close to the tumor plus margin. For the simulated posterior choroidal tumor treatment, with sufficient tumor coverage, the doses to the optic disc and fovea are substantially reduced with focused x-ray therapy compared to eye plaque treatment (3.8 vs 39.8 Gy and 11.1 vs 53.8 Gy, respectively). The eye plaque treatment was calculated using an Eye Physics plaque with I-125 seeds under TG43 assumption. For the energy spectrum used in this study, the average simulated dose enhancement ratios (DERs) are roughly 2.1 and 1.1 for 1.0% and 0.1% AuNP mass concentration in the tumor, respectively.

CONCLUSION

Compared to eye plaque brachytherapy, the proposed focused kV x-ray technique is noninvasive and shows great advantage in sparing healthy critical organs without sacrificing the tumor control. The NP radiation dose enhancement is considerable at our proposed kV range even with a low NP concentration in the tumor, providing better critical structure protection and more flexibility for treatment planning.

Outcomes of choroidal melanomas treated with eye physics plaques: A 25-year review

PURPOSE

To review long-term outcomes of the University of Southern California Plaque Simulator (PS) software and Eye Physics (EP) plaques. We hypothesize that the PS/EP system delivers lower doses to critical ocular structures, resulting in lower rates of radiation toxicity and favorable visual outcomes compared to Collaborative Ocular Melanoma Study plaques, while maintaining adequate local tumor control.

METHODS AND MATERIALS

Retrospective review of 133 patients treated for choroidal melanoma with ¹²⁵I brachytherapy, using PS software and EP plaques, from 1990 through 2015. A dose of 85 Gy at a rate of 0.6 Gy/h was prescribed to the tumor apex (with a typical margin of 2 mm) over 7 days. Primary outcomes were local tumor recurrence, globe salvage, and metastasis. Secondary outcomes were changes in visual acuity and radiation complications.

RESULTS

With median followup of 42 months, 5-year Kaplan-Meier estimated rates for tumor control, globe salvage, and metastatic-free survival were 98.3%, 96.4%, and 88.2%, respectively. Median doses to the macula and optic nerve were 39.9 Gy and 30.0 Gy, respectively. Forty-three percent of patients developed radiation retinopathy, and 20% developed optic neuropathy; 39% lost ≥6 Snellen lines of vision.

CONCLUSIONS

The PS/EP system is designed to improve the accuracy and conformality of the radiation dose, creating a steep dose gradient outside the melanoma to decrease radiation to surrounding ocular structures. We report favorable rates of local tumor control, globe salvage, metastases, and radiation complications when compared to the Collaborative Ocular Melanoma Study and other studies. Overall, the PS/EP system results in excellent tumor control and appears to optimize long-term visual and radiation-related outcomes after brachytherapy.

Recent advancements in the management of retinoblastoma and uveal melanoma

Retinoblastoma and uveal melanoma are the most common intraocular malignancies observed in pediatric and adult populations, respectively. For retinoblastoma, intra-arterial chemotherapy has dramatically improved treatment outcomes and eye salvage rates compared with traditional salvage rates of systemic chemotherapy and external beam radiation therapy. Intravitreal injections of chemotherapy have also demonstrated excellent efficacy for vitreous seeds. Uveal melanoma, on the other hand, is treated predominantly with iodine-125 plaque brachytherapy or with proton beam therapy. Major strides in uveal melanoma genomics have been made since the early 2000s, allowing ocular oncologists to better understand the metastatic risks of the tumor on the basis of specific genetic signatures. Loss-of-function mutations of the BAP1 gene are associated with the highest metastatic risk, whereas gain-of-function mutations of SF3B1 and EIF1AX often confer a better prognosis. Expression of a cancer-testis antigen called PRAME (preferentially expressed antigen in melanoma) has been shown to increase metastatic risks in both low-risk and high-risk melanomas. New therapeutic approaches, including molecular therapies and nanoparticle phototherapy, are currently being investigated as alternative treatment modalities for uveal melanoma.

Initial evaluation of Advanced Collapsed cone Engine dose calculations in water medium for I-125 seeds and COMS eye plaques

PURPOSE

To investigate the dose calculation accuracy in water medium of the Advanced Collapsed cone Engine (ACE) for three sizes of COMS eye plaques loaded with low-energy I-125 seeds.

METHODS

A model of the Oncura 6711 I-125 seed was created for use with ACE in Oncentra^® Brachy (OcB) using primary-scatter separated (PSS) point dose kernel and Task Group (TG) 43 datasets. COMS eye plaque models of diameters 12, 16, and 20 mm were introduced into the OcB applicator library based on 3D CAD drawings of the plaques and Silastic inserts. To perform TG-186 level 1 commissioning, treatment plans were created in OcB for a single source in water and for each COMS plaque in water for two scenarios: with only one centrally loaded seed, or with all seed positions loaded. ACE dose calculations were performed in high accuracy mode with a 0.5 × 0.5 × 0.5 mm³ calculation grid. The resulting dose data were evaluated against Monte Carlo (MC) calculated doses obtained with MCNP6, using both local and global percent differences.

RESULTS

ACE doses around the source for the single seed in water agreed with MC doses on average within < 5% inside a 6 × 6 × 6 cm³ region, and within < 1.5% inside a 2 × 2 × 2 cm³ region. The PSS data were generated at a higher resolution within 2 cm from the source, resulting in this improved agreement closer to the source due to fewer approximations in the ACE dose calculation. Average differences in both investigated plaque loading patterns in front of the plaques and on the plaque central axes were ≤ 2.5%, though larger differences (up to 12%) were found near the plaque lip.

CONCLUSIONS

Overall, good agreement was found between ACE and MC dose calculations for a single I-125 seed and in front of the COMS plaques in water. More complex scenarios need to be investigated to determine how well ACE handles heterogeneous patient materials.

Early outcomes of uveal melanoma treated with intraoperative ultrasound guided brachytherapy using custom built plaques

PURPOSE

To report early outcomes of patients with uveal melanoma treated with Eye Physics iodine-125 episcleral plaque therapy using modern biopsy techniques and intraoperative ultrasound guidance at our institution.

METHODS AND MATERIALS

A retrospective chart review was conducted for 48 consecutive patients with uveal melanoma who were treated with Eye Physics plaque brachytherapy performed by 1 ocular oncologist. All patients underwent intraoperative ultrasound for image guidance of plaque placement. A dose of 85 Gy was prescribed to the apical height of the tumor or 5 mm from the inner sclera, whichever was greater. Forty-five patients underwent biopsy. Visual acuity, complication data, and recurrence rates were recorded.

RESULTS

Median age at presentation was 63.0 years (range, 19-86 years). Median follow-up was 21.6 months. Median tumor apical height was 3.3 mm (range, 1.8-11.5 mm). Median dose at apex for tumor height >5 mm was 85.0 Gy and 142.5 Gy for tumor height ≤5 mm. Mean percent decrease in tumor height from baseline at 12, 24, and 36 months was 39.6%, 51.8%, and 53.8%, respectively. At 24 months, 19/23 (82.6%) patients maintained vision within 3 lines of baseline visual acuity. Twelve patients developed radiation retinopathy, 6 of whom were treated with anti-vascular endothelial growth factor therapy in the context of a clinical trial. No patients to date have local failure. Three patients are alive with confirmed hepatic metastases.

CONCLUSIONS

We reported 0% early local failure rate and steady reduction in tumor height in 48 patients with uveal melanoma, ranging from small to large size, who were treated with Eye Physics iodine-125 episcleral plaque therapy using intraoperative ultrasound guidance. This promising result emphasizes the importance of image guided brachytherapy with intraoperative ultrasound at the time of plaque placement.

Use of the Toric Surgical Marker to Aid in Intraoperative Plaque Placement for the USC Eye Physics Plaques to Treat Uveal Melanoma: A New Surgical Technique

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVE

To describe a new surgical technique for intraoperative placement of Eye Physics (EP) plaques for uveal melanoma using a toric marker.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

A toric marker is designed for cataract surgery to align the axis of astigmatism; its use was modified in this protocol to mark the axis of suture coordinates as calculated by Plaque Simulator (PS) software.

RESULTS

The toric marker can be used to localize suture coordinates, in degrees, during intraoperative plaque placement. Linear marking using the toric marker decreases potential inaccuracies associated with the surgeon estimating 'clock-hours' by dot placement.

CONCLUSION

Use of the toric marker aided surgical placement of EP plaques. The EP planning protocol is now designed to display the suture coordinates either by clock-hours or degrees, per surgeon preference. Future research is necessary to determine whether routine use of the toric marker improves operative efficiency. [Ophthalmic Surg Lasers Imaging Retina. 2015;46:866-870.].

Outcomes of medium choroidal melanomas treated with ruthenium brachytherapy guided by three-dimensional pretreatment modeling

PURPOSE

The Collaborative Ocular Melanoma Study (COMS) established iodine-125 (I-125) plaque brachytherapy for eye preserving treatment of medium-sized choroidal melanomas in the United States. Eye Physics I-125 plaque treatment modeled with Plaque Simulator (PS) software yields similar results to COMS. Herein, we report results from a series of 15 patients treated with ruthenium-106 (Ru-106) plaque brachytherapy using PS pretreatment modeling for plaque localization and dosimetry.

METHODS AND MATERIALS

Fifteen patients with medium-sized choroidal melanomas (2.84-5.5 mm in apical height and a basal diameter of 7.8-12.6 mm) treated with ruthenium brachytherapy from 2003 to 2005 were evaluated retrospectively. Baseline and followup data were evaluated for tumor height, best corrected visual acuity, radiation retinopathy, radiation optic neuropathy, postradiation cataract formation, diplopia, and ptosis. Tumor response for both Ru-106 and I-125 plaques planned using the same PS pretreatment modeling was evaluated and compared.

RESULTS

Isotope-specific radiation profiles were compared, and rates of local treatment failure (0%), optic neuropathy (6.7%), retinopathy (20%), and cataracts (33%) were evaluated. Five year-treated tumor heights were approximately 0.61 ± 0.29 (I-125, n = 16) and 0.53 ± 0.17 (Ru-106, n = 6) of their heights at diagnosis.

CONCLUSIONS

This patient subset had background characteristics very similar to those of the COMS and patients treated at our institution with I-125 plaques. Treatment response was equivalent although radiation complications occurred slightly less frequently in the Ru-106 group compared with those treated with I-125. Image-guided three-dimensional pretreatment modeling for plaque localization and dosimetry seems to work equally as well for Ru as for I-125 plaques and justifies more extensive investigation.

Monte Carlo dosimetry for 103Pd, 125I, and 131Cs ocular brachytherapy with various plaque models using an eye phantom

PURPOSE

To investigate dosimetry for ocular brachytherapy for a range of eye plaque models containing(103)Pd, (125)I, or (131)Cs seeds with model-based dose calculations.

METHODS

Five representative plaque models are developed based on a literature review and are compared to the standardized COMS plaque, including plaques consisting of a stainless steel backing and acrylic insert, and gold alloy backings with: short collimating lips and acrylic insert, no lips and silicone polymer insert, no lips and a thin acrylic layer, and individual collimating slots for each seed within the backing and no insert. Monte Carlo simulations are performed using the EGSnrc user-code BrachyDose for single and multiple seed configurations for the plaques in water and within an eye model (including nonwater media). Simulations under TG-43 assumptions are also performed, i.e., with the same seed configurations in water, neglecting interseed and plaque effects. Maximum and average doses to ocular structures as well as isodose contours are compared for simulations of each radionuclide within the plaque models.

RESULTS

The presence of the plaque affects the dose distribution substantially along the plaque axis for both single seed and multiseed simulations of each plaque design in water. Of all the plaque models, the COMS plaque generally has the largest effect on the dose distribution in water along the plaque axis. Differences between doses for single and multiple seed configurations vary between plaque models and radionuclides. Collimation is most substantial for the plaque with individual collimating slots. For plaques in the full eye model, average dose in the tumor region differs from those for the TG-43 simulations by up to 10% for(125)I and (131)Cs, and up to 17% for (103)Pd, and in the lens region by up to 29% for (125)I, 34% for (103)Pd, and 28% for (131)Cs. For the same prescription dose to the tumor apex, the lowest doses to critical ocular structures are generally delivered with plaques containing (103)Pd seeds.

CONCLUSIONS

The combined effects of ocular and plaque media on dose are significant and vary with plaque model and radionuclide, suggesting the importance of model-based dose calculations employing accurate ocular and plaque media and geometries for eye plaque brachytherapy.

Monte Carlo dosimetry of the eye plaque design used at the St. Erik Eye Hospital for (125)I brachytherapy

PURPOSE

At St. Erik Eye Hospital in Stockholm, Sweden, ocular tumors of apical height above 6 mm are treated with brachytherapy, using iodine-125 seeds attached to a gold alloy plaque while the treatment planning is performed assuming homogeneous water surroundings. The aim of this work was to investigate the dose-modifying effects of the plaque and the seed fixating silicone rubber glue.

METHODS AND MATERIALS

The impact of the gold plaque and silicone rubber glue was studied with the Monte Carlo N-particle transport code, version 5.

RESULTS

For the 2 cm most proximal to the plaque surface along the plaque's central axis, the eyeball received 104.6-93.0% of the dose in all-water conditions.

CONCLUSIONS

The 0.3 mm thick layer of silicone rubber glue, used for seed fixation, attenuates photons little enough to allow characteristic X-rays from the gold alloy plaque to reach the eyeball. Close to the plaque, the dose rates were higher with the plaque and glue present, than in homogeneous water conditions. This is in contrast to what has been reported for more commonly used eye plaques, demonstrating the importance of investigating the dosimetry of individual treatment systems.

Treatment of primary intraocular melanoma

The treatment of intraocular melanoma has evolved recently. Enucleation has been superseded largely by brachytherapy, proton beam radiotherapy, stereotactic irradiation, trans-scleral local resection, transretinal resection and diode laser phototherapy. Many patients develop metastatic disease, which usually involves the liver and occurs hematogenously. Disseminated disease rarely responds to therapy, and is usually fatal within 1 year of the onset of symptoms. Uveal melanomas develop characteristic chromosomal abnormalities, such as loss of chromosome 3. This is associated with a reduction in the 5-year survival from approximately 95% to less than 50%.

The retina dose-area histogram: a metric for quantitatively comparing rival eye plaque treatment options

PURPOSE

Episcleral plaques have a history of over a half century in the delivery of radiation therapy to intraocular tumors such as choroidal melanoma. Although the tumor control rate is high, vision-impairing complications subsequent to treatment remain an issue. Notable, late complications are radiation retinopathy and maculopathy. The obvious way to reduce the risk of radiation damage to the retina is to conform the prescribed isodose surface to the tumor base and to reduce the dose delivered to the surrounding healthy retina, especially the macula. Using a fusion of fundus photography, ultrasound and CT images, tumor size, shape and location within the eye can be accurately simulated as part of the radiation planning process. In this work an adaptation of the dose-volume histogram (DVH), the retina dose-area histogram (RDAH) is introduced as a metric to help compare rival plaque designs and conformal treatment planning options with the goal of reducing radiation retinopathy.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

The RDAH is calculated by transforming a digitized fundus-photo collage of the tumor into a rasterized polar map of the retinal surface known as a retinal diagram (RD). The perimeter of the tumor base is digitized on the RD and its area computed. Area and radiation dose are calculated for every pixel in the RD.

RESULTS

The areal resolution of the RDAH is a function of the pixel resolution of the raster image used to display the RD and the number of polygon edges used to digitize the perimeter of the tumor base. A practical demonstration is presented.

CONCLUSIONS

The RDAH provides a quantitative metric by which episcleral plaque treatment plan options may be evaluated and compared in order to confirm adequate dosimetric coverage of the tumor and margin, and to help minimize dose to the macula and retina.

Keeping an eye on the ring: COMS plaque loading optimization for improved dose conformity and homogeneity

PURPOSE

To improve tumor dose conformity and homogeneity for COMS plaque brachytherapy by investigating the dosimetric effects of varying component source ring radionuclides and source strengths.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

The MCNP5 Monte Carlo (MC) radiation transport code was used to simulate plaque heterogeneity-corrected dose distributions for individually-activated source rings of 14, 16 and 18 mm diameter COMS plaques, populated with (103)Pd, (125)I and (131)Cs sources. Ellipsoidal tumors were contoured for each plaque size and MATLAB programming was developed to generate tumor dose distributions for all possible ring weighting and radionuclide permutations for a given plaque size and source strength resolution, assuming a 75 Gy apical prescription dose. These dose distributions were analyzed for conformity and homogeneity and compared to reference dose distributions from uniformly-loaded (125)I plaques. The most conformal and homogeneous dose distributions were reproduced within a reference eye environment to assess organ-at-risk (OAR) doses in the Pinnacle(3) treatment planning system (TPS). The gamma-index analysis method was used to quantitatively compare MC and TPS-generated dose distributions.

RESULTS

Concentrating > 97% of the total source strength in a single or pair of central (103)Pd seeds produced the most conformal dose distributions, with tumor basal doses a factor of 2-3 higher and OAR doses a factor of 2-3 lower than those of corresponding uniformly-loaded (125)I plaques. Concentrating 82-86% of the total source strength in peripherally-loaded (131)Cs seeds produced the most homogeneous dose distributions, with tumor basal doses 17-25% lower and OAR doses typically 20% higher than those of corresponding uniformly-loaded (125)I plaques. Gamma-index analysis found > 99% agreement between MC and TPS dose distributions.

CONCLUSIONS

A method was developed to select intra-plaque ring radionuclide compositions and source strengths to deliver more conformal and homogeneous tumor dose distributions than uniformly-loaded (125)I plaques. This method may support coordinated investigations of an appropriate clinical target for eye plaque brachytherapy.

Dosimetry of (125)I and (103)Pd COMS eye plaques for intraocular tumors: report of Task Group 129 by the AAPM and ABS

Dosimetry of eye plaques for ocular tumors presents unique challenges in brachytherapy. The challenges in accurate dosimetry are in part related to the steep dose gradient in the tumor and critical structures that are within millimeters of radioactive sources. In most clinical applications, calculations of dose distributions around eye plaques assume a homogenous water medium and full scatter conditions. Recent Monte Carlo (MC)-based eye-plaque dosimetry simulations have demonstrated that the perturbation effects of heterogeneous materials in eye plaques, including the gold-alloy backing and Silastic insert, can be calculated with reasonable accuracy. Even additional levels of complexity introduced through the use of gold foil "seed-guides" and custom-designed plaques can be calculated accurately using modern MC techniques. Simulations accounting for the aforementioned complexities indicate dose discrepancies exceeding a factor of ten to selected critical structures compared to conventional dose calculations. Task Group 129 was formed to review the literature; re-examine the current dosimetry calculation formalism; and make recommendations for eye-plaque dosimetry, including evaluation of brachytherapy source dosimetry parameters and heterogeneity correction factors. A literature review identified modern assessments of dose calculations for Collaborative Ocular Melanoma Study (COMS) design plaques, including MC analyses and an intercomparison of treatment planning systems (TPS) detailing differences between homogeneous and heterogeneous plaque calculations using the American Association of Physicists in Medicine (AAPM) TG-43U1 brachytherapy dosimetry formalism and MC techniques. This review identified that a commonly used prescription dose of 85 Gy at 5 mm depth in homogeneous medium delivers about 75 Gy and 69 Gy at the same 5 mm depth for specific (125)I and (103)Pd sources, respectively, when accounting for COMS plaque heterogeneities. Thus, the adoption of heterogeneous dose calculation methods in clinical practice would result in dose differences >10% and warrant a careful evaluation of the corresponding changes in prescription doses. Doses to normal ocular structures vary with choice of radionuclide, plaque location, and prescription depth, such that further dosimetric evaluations of the adoption of MC-based dosimetry methods are needed. The AAPM and American Brachytherapy Society (ABS) recommend that clinical medical physicists should make concurrent estimates of heterogeneity-corrected delivered dose using the information in this report's tables to prepare for brachytherapy TPS that can account for material heterogeneities and for a transition to heterogeneity-corrected prescriptive goals. It is recommended that brachytherapy TPS vendors include material heterogeneity corrections in their systems and take steps to integrate planned plaque localization and image guidance. In the interim, before the availability of commercial MC-based brachytherapy TPS, it is recommended that clinical medical physicists use the line-source approximation in homogeneous water medium and the 2D AAPM TG-43U1 dosimetry formalism and brachytherapy source dosimetry parameter datasets for treatment planning calculations. Furthermore, this report includes quality management program recommendations for eye-plaque brachytherapy.

Comparison of 16 mm OSU-Nag and COMS eye plaques

OSU-NAG eye plaques use fewer sources than COMS-plaques of comparable size, and do not employ a Silastic seed carrier insert. Monte Carlo modeling was used to calculate 3D dose distributions for a 16 mm OSU-NAG eye plaque and a 16 mm COMS eye plaque loaded with either Iodine-125 or Cesium-131 brachytherapy sources. The OSU-NAG eye plaque was loaded with eight sources forming two squares, whereas the COMS eye plaque was loaded with thirteen sources approximating three isocentric circles. A spherical eyeball 24.6 mm in diameter and an ellipsoid-like tumor 6 mm in height and 12 mm in the major and minor axes were used to evaluate the doses delivered. To establish a fair comparison, a water seed carrier was used instead of the Silastic seed carrier designed for the traditional COMS eye plaque. Calculations were performed on the dose distributions along the eye plaque axis and the DVHs of the tumor, as well as the 3D distribution. Our results indicated that, to achieve a prescription dose of 85 Gy at 6 mm from the inner sclera edge for a six-day treatment, the OSU-NAG eye plaque will need 6.16 U/source and 6.82U/source for 125I and 131Cs, respectively. The COMS eye plaque will require 4.02 U/source and 4.43 U/source for the same source types. The dose profiles of the two types of eye plaques on their central axes are within 9% difference for all applicable distances. The OSU-NAG plaque delivers about 10% and 12% more dose than the COMS for 125I and 131Cs sources, respectively, at the inner sclera edge, but 6% and 3% less dose at the opposite retina. The DVHs of the tumor for two types of plaques were within 6% difference. In conclusion, the dosimetric quality of the OSU-NAG eye plaque used in eye plaque brachytherapy is comparable to the COMS eye plaque.

Ultrastructural Alterations in Extraocular Muscles Following Iodine-125 Brachytherapy for Uveal Melanoma

PURPOSE

This study investigated the ultrastructural changes in extraocular muscles under which radioactive plaques had been placed for the treatment of uveal melanoma.

METHODS

At the time of plaque removal, biopsies were taken from four horizontal recti that had been left in situ over plaques and from one lateral rectus muscle that had been disinserted before brachytherapy. Normal lateral recti from enucleated eyes were used as controls. Iodine-125 seeds were used with a mean total activity of 54.04 mCi, remaining for an average of 149.62 hours over the sclera.

RESULTS

Muscles that had been left in situ over the radioactive plaques demonstrated a focal decrease in muscular tissue and increased fibroblasts and collagen. Electron microscopy showed increased collagen, loss of sarcoplasmic reticulum and swollen mitochondria. The disinserted muscle in the plaque group appeared unaffected.

CONCLUSIONS

Despite the theoretical shielding properties of plaques, leaving an extraocular muscle over the plaque may lead to several non-specific ultrastructural changes.

Posterior uveal melanoma treated with I-125 brachytherapy or primary enucleation

PURPOSE

To study the incidence, clinical findings, and tumour characteristics of posterior uveal melanoma in Western Norway, and to report the results of a consistent treatment strategy (I-125 brachytherapy or primary enucleation) over a 13-year period.

METHODS

The clinical records of all patients with posterior uveal melanoma referred between January 1993 and December 2005 were reviewed. Clinical data, radiation parameters, visual outcome, and mortality were analysed in a dedicated database.

RESULTS

The study included 111 consecutive patients. The annual age-adjusted incidence (per million population) of posterior uveal melanoma was 8.5 for women and 8.9 for men. Fifty-six patients underwent I-125 brachytherapy, 52 were enucleated, and three received no treatment. The median follow-up time was 36 months (mean, 52 months; range, 2 months to 13 years). In the brachytherapy group, two eyes were enucleated owing to tumour recurrence and two because of neovascular glaucoma. A visual acuity of 0.1 or better, present in 87% of the patients before brachytherapy, was retained in 40% after a median follow-up of 61 months. After brachytherapy, the 5- and 10-year melanoma-specific mortality rates were 13.4 and 23.8%, respectively. The corresponding mortality rates for patients treated with primary enucleation were 49.5 and 49.5%.

CONCLUSION

After brachytherapy, many patients lost useful vision due to radiation-induced complications. The probability of retaining the eye was high and only two patients experienced recurrent tumour growth. The mortality rates compare well with published series, and the differences in tumour size explain the difference in mortality between the two treatment groups.

Finger's "slotted" eye plaque for radiation therapy: treatment of juxtapapillary and circumpapillary intraocular tumours

AIM

To create "slotted eye plaques" for the treatment of juxtapapillary and circumpapillary intraocular tumours.

METHODS

Eye plaques were altered such that 8 mm-wide slots (variable length) were created to accommodate the orbital portion of the optic nerve. Thus, as the nerve entered the slot, the plaque's posterior margin extended beyond the optic disc. Radioactive seeds were affixed around the slot, surrounding the juxtapapillary and posterior tumour margins.

RESULTS

As proof of principle, three patients with choroidal melanomas that encircled or were in contact with the optic disc (considered untreatable with a notched eye plaque) were considered to be initial candidates for slotted-plaque radiotherapy. Preoperative three-dimensional C-scan imaging of their optic nerve sheath diameters insured that they would fit in the slotted plaque. Intraoperative ultrasound imaging was used to confirm proper plaque placement. Radiation dosimetry modelling showed that all tumour tissue received a minimum of 85 Gy (despite the gap created by the slot). With relatively short-term follow-up, there has been no evidence of ocular ischaemia, tumour growth or complications attributable to the use of slotted-plaque radiation therapy.

CONCLUSION

Slotted plaques accommodate the retrobulbar optic nerve into the device and thereby shift the treatment zone to improve coverage of both juxtapapillary and circumpapillary intraocular tumours.

Novel low-kVp beamlet system for choroidal melanoma

Background

Treatment of choroidal melanoma with radiation often involves placement of customized brachytherapy eye-plaques. However, the dosimetric properties inherent in source-based radiotherapy preclude facile dose optimization to critical ocular structures. Consequently, we have constructed a novel system for utilizing small beam low-energy radiation delivery, the Beamlet Low-kVp X-ray, or "BLOKX" system. This technique relies on an isocentric rotational approach to deliver dose to target volumes within the eye, while potentially sparing normal structures.

Methods

Monte Carlo N-Particle (MCNP) transport code version 5.0(14) was used to simulate photon interaction with normal and tumor tissues within modeled right eye phantoms. Five modeled dome-shaped tumors with a diameter and apical height of 8 mm and 6 mm, respectively, were simulated distinct positions with respect to the macula iteratively. A single fixed 9 × 9 mm² beamlet, and a comparison COMS protocol plaque containing eight I-125 seeds (apparent activity of 8 mCi) placed on the scleral surface of the eye adjacent to the tumor, were utilized to determine dosimetric parameters at tumor and adjacent tissues. After MCNP simulation, comparison of dose distribution at each of the 5 tumor positions for each modality (BLOKX vs. eye-plaque) was performed.

Results

Tumor-base doses ranged from 87.1–102.8 Gy for the BLOKX procedure, and from 335.3–338.6 Gy for the eye-plaque procedure. A reduction of dose of at least 69% to tumor base was noted when using the BLOKX. The BLOKX technique showed a significant reduction of dose, 89.8%, to the macula compared to the episcleral plaque. A minimum 71.0 % decrease in dose to the optic nerve occurred when the BLOKX was used.

Conclusion

The BLOKX technique allows more favorable dose distribution in comparison to standard COMS brachytherapy, as simulated using a Monte Carlo iterative mathematical modeling. Future series to determine clinical utility of such an approach are warranted.

Design and dosimetric considerations of a modified COMS plaque: The reusable “seed-guide” insert

The Collaborative Ocular Melanoma Study (COMS) developed a standardized set of eye plaques that consist of a 0.5 mm thick bowl-like gold alloy backing with a cylindrical collimating lip. A Silastic seed carrier into which 125I seeds are loaded was designed to fit within the backing. The carrier provides a standardized seed pattern and functions to offset the seeds by 1.0 mm from the concave (front) surface of the carrier. These Silastic carriers have been found to be difficult to load, preclude flash sterilization, and are a source of dosimetric uncertainty because the effective atomic number of Silastic is significantly higher than that of water. The main dosimetric effect of the Silastic carrier is a dose-reduction (compared to homogeneous water) of approximately 10%-15% for 125I radiation. The dose reduction is expected to be even greater for 103Pd radiation. In an attempt to improve upon, yet retain as much of the familiar COMS design as possible, we have developed a thin "seed-guide" insert made of gold alloy. This new insert has cutouts which match the seed pattern of the Silastic carrier, but allows the seeds to be glued directly to the inner surface of the gold backing using either dental acrylic or a cyanoacrylate adhesive. When glued directly to the gold backing the seeds are offset a few tenths of a millimeter further away from the scleral surface compared to using the Silastic carrier. From a dosimetric perspective, the space formerly occupied by the Silastic carrier is now assumed to be water equivalent. Water equivalency is a desirable attribute for this space because it eliminates the dosimetric uncertainties related to the atomic composition of Silastic and thereby facilitates the use of either 125I and/or 103Pd seeds. The caveat is that a new source of dosimetric uncertainty would be introduced were an air bubble to become trapped in this space during or after the surgical insertion. The presence of air in this space is modeled and the dosimetric impact discussed. Another unintended consequence of water equivalency is that some fluorescent x rays emitted from the gold backing can now reach the eye. These very low energy x rays were virtually eliminated by absorption in Silastic. When loaded with 125I seeds the modified plaque appears to produce dose distributions that are almost the same as those of the original COMS plaque and the maximum dosimetric uncertainty introduced by an air bubble is about 2%. Dose distributions calculated for a modified plaque loaded with 103Pd seeds show that dose to healthy ocular structures distal to the tumor apex can be reduced compared to 125I. Clearly, it is faster and easier to glue seeds into the reusable gold seed-guide insert than it is to load the COMS-Silastic carrier.

Improved treatment planning for COMS eye plaques

PURPOSE

A recent reanalysis of the Collaborative Ocular Melanoma Study (COMS) medium tumor trial concluded that incorporating factors to account for anisotropy, line source approximation, the gold plaque, and attenuation in the Silastic seed carrier into the dose calculations resulted in a significant and consistent reduction of calculated doses to structures of interest within the eye. The authors concluded that future eye plaque dosimetry should be "performed using the most up-to-date parameters available." The reason these factors are important is attributable to the low energy (125)I radiation (approximately 28 keV) that is primarily absorbed by the photoelectric process. Photoelectric absorption is quite dependent on the atomic composition of the absorbing material. Being 40% silicon by weight, the effective atomic number of Silastic is significantly greater than that of water. Although the AAPM TG43 brachytherapy formalism inherently addresses the issues of source anisotropy and geometry, its parameter that accounts for scatter and attenuation, the radial dose function g(r), assumes that the source is immersed in infinite homogeneous water. In this work, factors are proposed for (125)I that correct for attenuation in the Silastic carrier and scatter deficits resulting from the gold plaque and nearby air. The implications of using (103)Pd seeds in COMS plaques are also discussed.

METHODS AND MATERIALS

An existing TG43-based ophthalmic plaque planning system was modified to incorporate additional scatter and attenuation correction factors that better account for the path length of primary radiation in the Silastic seed carrier and the distance between the dose calculation point and the eye-air interface.

RESULTS

Compared with homogeneous water, the dose-modifying effects of the Silastic and gold are greatest near the plaque surface and immediately adjacent to the plaque, while being least near the center of the eye. The calculated dose distribution surrounding a single (125)I seed centered in a COMS 20 mm plaque was found to be consistent with previously published examples that used thermoluminescent dosimetry measurements and Monte Carlo methods. For fully loaded 12 and 20 mm plaques, calculated dose to critical ocular structures ranged from 16%-50% less than would have been reported using the standard COMS dose calculation protocol.

CONCLUSIONS

Treatment planning for COMS eye plaques that accurately accounts for the presence of the gold, Silastic and extraocular air is both possible and practical.

Dosimetric study of the 15mm ROPES eye plaque

The main aim of this paper is to make a study of dose-rate distributions obtained around the 15 mm, radiation oncology physics and engineering services, Australia (ROPES) eye plaque loaded with 125I model 6711 radioactive seeds. In this study, we have carried out a comparison of the dose-rate distributions obtained by the algorithm used by the Plaque Simulator (PS) (BEBIG GmbH, Berlin, Germany) treatment planning system with those obtained by means of the Monte Carlo method for the ROPES eye plaque. A simple method to obtain the dose-rate distributions in a treatment planning system via the superposition of the dose-rate distributions of a seed placed in the eye plaque has been developed. The method uses eye plaque located in a simplified geometry of the head anatomy and distributions obtained by means of the Monte Carlo code GEANT4. The favorable results obtained in the development of this method suggest that it could be implemented on a treatment planning system to improve dose-rate calculations. We have also found that the dose-rate falls sharply along the eye and that outside the eye the dose-rate is very low. Furthermore, the lack of backscatter photons from the air located outside the eye-head phantom produces a dose reduction negligible for distances from the eye-plaque r<1 cm but reaches up to 20% near the air-eye interface. Results showed that the treatment planning system lacks accuracy around the border of the eye (in the sclera and the surrounding area) due to the simplicity of the algorithm used. The BEBIG treatment planning system uses a global attenuation factor that takes into account the effect of the eye plaque seed carrier and the lack of backscatter photons caused by the metallic cover, which in the case of a ROPES eye plaque has a default value of T= 1 (no correction). In the present study, a global attenuation factor T=0.96 and an air-interface correction factor which improve on treatment planning system calculations were obtained.

Episcleral plaque 125I radiotherapy with episcleral LCF hyperthermia: a prospective randomized trial

PURPOSE

The purpose of this study was to search for an optimal radiation dose in the treatment of patients with uveal melanoma using 125I episcleral plaque radiotherapy (EPRT) and episcleral hyperthermia (HT).

METHODS AND MATERIALS

From 1991-1998, 35 patients with uveal melanoma were enrolled in a phase II prospective randomized trial of 125I EPRT combined with episcleral HT. Two groups were closely matched for pre-treatment patient and tumor characteristics. Group 1: N = 16, and Group 2: N = 19. The median dose to the tumor apex for Group 1 was 80.0 Gy and 60.8 Gy for Group 2. Episcleral HT was given once for 45 min immediately prior to EPRT with a median temperature of 44 degrees C for both groups. The median follow-up was 5.5 years for Group 1 and 5.3 years for Group 2.

RESULTS

The median tumor height decreased 1.7 mm for patients of both groups. The 5- and 8-year probability of local recurrence was 33% for Group 1, and 25% for Group 2, p = 0.73. The 5-year probability of DFS was 54% for Group 1 and 67% for Group 2, p = 0.51. The 5- and 8-year overall survival was 68% and 34%, respectively, for Group 1, and 83% and 50%, respectively, for Group 2, p = 0.60. The rate of distant metastasis at 5- and 8-years for Group 1 was 29% and 62%, respectively, and 17% and 17%, respectively, for Group 2, p = 0.18. The incidence of enucleation was 4 (25%) in Group 1 vs. 4 (22%) in Group 2. The incidence of late complications was similar in either treatment group. The ambulatory visual acuity (> 5/200) at last follow-up was slightly better in Group 2 (80%) than Group 1 (64%).

CONCLUSIONS

Treatment outcomes were similar despite a 25% difference in radiation dose. In view of these findings and in an attempt to reduce the incidence of late treatment toxicity a still lower radiation dose in combination with HT needs to be studied. The reported outcomes need to be evaluated with caution due to the small number of patients in this study.

The design and the dosimetry of bi-nuclide radioactive ophthalmic applicators

A novel type of applicator for the treatment of intra-ocular tumors has been developed, based on the two radionuclides 106Ru/106Rh and 125I. The dose distribution of this ophthalmic plaque combines advantageous features of both radionuclides and can be optimally adapted to a tumor thickness in the range 6.5-9 mm, a size which is beyond the dosimetric limitations of the 106Ru/106Rh plaque therapy. Compared with 125I plaques a bi-nuclide plaque allows to maintain the tumor dosage while the dose in the irradiated volume outside of the target volume is significantly reduced. Consequently, radiosensitive structures within the eye can be spared more effectively. Dedicated methods have been developed for the dosimetry of this plaque. These methods are based on our own extensive dosimetric investigations with plastic scintillators. The precondition was the availability, developed in recent years, of a more accurate determination of the absolute dose rate to water of beta- and low energy emitters.

Transscleral resection versus iodine brachytherapy for choroidal malignant melanomas 6 millimeters or more in thickness

OBJECTIVE

To assess differences in treatment outcome after transscleral resection (TSR) and iodine brachytherapy (IBT) of choroidal melanomas too thick for ruthenium brachytherapy.

DESIGN

Matched case-control study.

SETTING

Two national ocular oncology services.

PARTICIPANTS

Forty-nine pairs of patients with choroidal melanoma 6 mm thick or more (range = 6-14), treated within 3 years of each other by either TSR or IBT, and retrospectively matched by age, visual acuity at diagnosis, largest basal tumor diameter, and posterior extension of the tumor.

INTERVENTION

Iodine brachytherapy in Finland or TSR in United Kingdom. Prospectively collected time-to-event data were compared with parametric Weibull regression, adjusting for matching.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES

Tumor control, complications, and visual acuity.

RESULTS

Risk of local recurrence after IBT was smaller than that after TSR (hazard ratio [HR] = 0.02, 95% confidence interval [CI] = 0.01-0.11, P<0.001, Weibull regression adjusted for matching), but the 8-year all-cause and melanoma-specific (HR = 0.81, 95% CI = 0.30-2.22, P = 0.69) survivals did not differ. The risks of cataract (HR = 2.05, 95% CI = 1.08-3.89, P = 0.029), maculopathy (HR = 2.28, 95% CI = 0.96-5.43, P = 0.062), and vitreous hemorrhage (HR = 2.30, 95% CI = 0.95-5.57, P = 0.064) were higher after IBT. Rubeosis, neovascular glaucoma, and optic neuropathy developed only after IBT. Risk of retinal detachment, exudative after IBT and rhegmatogenous after TSR (HR = 0.84, 95% CI = 0.40-1.75, P = 0.63), and risk of losing 20/60 vision (HR = 1.37, 95% CI 0.76-2.45, P = 0.29) were comparable between the groups, but risk of losing 20/200 vision was higher after IBT (HR = 2.38, 95% CI = 1.48-3.83, P<0.001). No overall difference in quality of life was found.

CONCLUSIONS

This study suggests that TSR preserves 20/200 vision better than IBT and avoids some of its major complications, but increases the risk of local recurrence. About 350 patients would need to be randomized to prove that TRS preserves 20/60 vision better than IBT.

A reanalysis of the Collaborative Ocular Melanoma Study Medium Tumor Trial eye plaque dosimetry

PURPOSE

To recalculate the radiation doses delivered to structures of interest within the eye, i.e., the lens, tumor apex, 5-mm point, optic disk, and macula for patients treated with eye plaque radiotherapy on the Collaborative Ocular Melanoma Study (COMS) Medium Tumor Trial, using updated dosimetric data.

METHODS AND MATERIALS

Using the Plaque Simulator planning system, doses were recalculated for a sampling of COMS patients for each plaque size. Dosimetry parameters incorporated into the recalculation were line source approximation, a 90% Silastic transmission factor, and a 0% gold transmission factor. Generic solutions were generated from the dose recalculations for each plaque size and structures of interest combination. Doses for the remainder of the patient population were recalculated using the generic solutions and compared with the originally reported COMS doses.

RESULTS

Doses to all structures of interest were reduced 7%-21%, depending on the plaque size and structure combination. The reduction in dose for the macula, optic disc, lens, tumor apex, and 5-mm point was on average 10%, 18%, 8%, 11%, and 12%, respectively. The closer the macula and optic disk were to the plaque rim, the greater the dose reduction. Incorporation of the Silastic transmission factor accounted for a large part of the dose reduction.

CONCLUSIONS

Incorporating anisotropy, line source approximation, and Silastic and gold shield attenuation into dose recalculations resulted in a significant and consistent reduction of doses to structures of interest within the eyes.

The American Brachytherapy Society recommendations for brachytherapy of uveal melanomas

PURPOSE

This article presents the American Brachytherapy Society (ABS) guidelines for the use of brachytherapy for patients with choroidal melanomas.

METHODS

Members of the ABS with expertise in choroidal melanoma formulated brachytherapy guidelines based upon their clinical experience and a review of the literature. The Board of Directors of the ABS approved the final report.

RESULTS

Episcleral plaque brachytherapy is a complex procedure and should only be undertaken in specialized medical centers with expertise in this sophisticated treatment program. Recommendations were made for patient selection, techniques, dose rates, and dosages. Most patients with very small uveal melanomas (<2.5 mm height and <10 mm in largest basal dimension) should be observed for tumor growth before treatment. Patients with a clinical diagnosis of medium-sized choroidal melanoma (between 2.5 and 10 mm in height and <16 mm basal diameter) are candidates for episcleral plaques if the patient is otherwise healthy and without metastatic disease. A histopathologic verification is not required. Small melanomas may be candidates if there is documented growth; some patients with large melanomas (>10 mm height or >16 mm basal diameter) may also be candidates. Patients with large tumors or with tumors at peripapillary and macular locations have a poorer visual outcome and lower local control that must be taken into account in the patient decision-making process. Patients with gross extrascleral extension, ring melanoma, and tumor involvement of more than half of the ciliary body are not suitable for plaque therapy. For plaque fabrication, the ophthalmologist must provide the tumor size (including basal diameters and tumor height) and a detailed fundus diagram. The ABS recommends a minimum tumor (125)I dose of 85 Gy at a dose rate of 0.60-1.05 Gy/h using AAPM TG-43 formalism for the calculation of dose. NRC or state licensing guidelines regarding procedures for handling of radioisotopes must be followed.

CONCLUSIONS

Brachytherapy represents an effective means of treating patients with choroidal melanomas. Guidelines are established for the use of brachytherapy in the treatment of choroidal melanomas. Practitioners and cooperative groups are encouraged to use these guidelines to formulate their treatment and dose reporting policies. These guidelines will be modified as further clinical results become available.

A patch source model for treatment planning of ruthenium ophthalmic applicators

Beta-ray emitting Ru-106/Rh-106 ophthalmic applicators have been used for close to 4 decades in the treatment of choroidal melanoma. The form factor of these applicators is a spherically concave silver bowl with an inner radius of curvature between 12 and 14 mm, and a total shell thickness of 1 mm. The radioactive nuclide is deposited in a layer 0.1 mm below the concave surface of the applicator. Calculation of dose distributions for clinical treatment planning purposes is complicated by the concave nature of the distributed source, the asymmetric shape of the active region of some applicators, imperfections in the manufacturing process which can result in an inhomogeneous distribution of activity across the active surface, and absorption and scatter in the 0.1 mm layer of silver which seals and protects the radioactive layer. A semi-empirical method of calculating dose distributions for these applicators is described which is fundamentally compatible with treatment planning systems that use the AAPM TG43 brachytherapy formalism. Dose to water is estimated by summing a "patch source" dose function over a discrete number of overlapping patches uniformly distributed over the active surface of the applicator. The patch source dose function differs conceptually from a point source dose function in that it is intended to represent the macroscopic behavior of a small, disk-like region of the applicator. The patch source dose function includes an anisotropy term to account for angular variation in absorption and scatter as particles traverse the 0.1 mm silver window. It geometrically models the nearfield of a patch with properties akin to both a small disk and infinite plane, and models the farfield as if the patch were a point. This allows a manageable number of discrete patches (300 to 1000) to provide accuracy appropriate for clinical treatment planning. This approach has the advantages of using familiar concepts and data structures, it is computationally quick, and it readily adapts to asymmetric applicator shapes and inhomogeneities in the radionuclide distribution. A method for optimizing the patch source dose function parameters is presented, and the dosimetric calculations are compared with published Monte Carlo calculations and measurements.

Modeling volume effects of experimental brachytherapy in the rat rectum: uncovering the limitations of a radiobiologic concept

PURPOSE

To analyze the significance of volume effects in experimental brachytherapy, based on modeling normal tissue complication probability.

METHODS AND MATERIALS

Experimental brachytherapy in the rat rectum was based on an eight-step 2.5-mm step size source configuration for 192Ir, afterloaded into an unshielded polystyrene applicator. Volume effects were studied using a half-circumferential lead-shielded applicator and a shorter (two-step) source configuration. The main end point was rectal stenosis.

RESULTS

Rectal stenosis was always caused by a radiation ulcer. With the shielded configuration, single-dose ED50 (50% incidence of rectal stenosis) increased from 23 Gy to 36.5 Gy. Single-dose ED50 for the short configuration was 77.9 Gy. The data showed a reasonable fit to a three-parameter version of the biophysical model described by Jackson et al. (1995). This model assumes that organs consist of a large number of radiobiologically independent subunits and that radiation causes a complication if the fraction of the organ damaged is greater than its functional reserve. The fraction of the organ damaged is calculated summing over fractions of the organ damaged at each dose level. The calculated mean functional reserve (nu50) of the rat rectum, assuming a cumulative functional reserve distribution in the group of experimental rats, was 0.53.

CONCLUSIONS

The volume effect observed within small brachytherapy volumes agreed well with clinical experience of large tolerance doses in contact X-ray therapy. However, the nu50 value was comparable to the high functional reserve value reported for liver. Experimental volume effects probably reflect repair processes originating in the areas adjacent to small radiation fields of brachytherapy more than the radiobiologic characteristics of the cells in the irradiated volume.

Dosimetric verification of a dedicated 3D treatment planning system for episcleral plaque therapy

PURPOSE

Episcleral plaque therapy (EPT) is applied in the management of some malignant ocular tumors. A customized configuration of typically 4 to 20 radioactive seeds is fixed in a gold plaque, and the plaque is sutured to the scleral surface corresponding to the basis of the intraocular tumor, allowing for a localized radiation dose delivery to the tumor. Minimum target doses as high as 100 Gy are directed at malignant tumor sites close to critical normal tissues (e.g., optic disc and macula). Precise dosimetry is therefore fundamental for judging both the risk for normal tissue toxicity and tumor dose prescription. This paper describes the dosimetric verification of a commercially available dedicated treatment planning system (TPS) for EPT when realistic multiple-seed configurations are applied.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

The TPS Bebig Plaque Simulator is used to plan EPT at our institution. Relative dose distributions in a water phantom, including central axis depth dose and off-axis dose profiles for three different plaques, the University of Southern California (USC) #9 and the Collaborative Ocular Melanoma Study (COMS) 12-mm and 20-mm plaques, were measured with a diode detector. Each plaque was arranged with realistic multiple 125I seed configurations. The measured dose distributions were compared to the corresponding dose profiles calculated with the TPS. All measurements were corrected for the angular sensitivity variation of the diode.

RESULTS

Single-seed dose distributions measured with our dosimetry setup agreed with previously published data within 3%. For the three multiple-seed plaque configurations, the measured and calculated dose distributions were in good agreement. For the central axis depth doses, the agreement was within 4%, whereas deviations up to 11% were observed in single points far off-axis.

CONCLUSIONS

The Bebig Plaque Simulator is a reliable TPS for calculating relative dose distributions around realistic multiple 125I seed configurations in EPT.