Predictive assays of radiation response in patients with head and neck squamous cell carcinoma: a review of the Institute Gustave Roussy experience

Towards Data Driven RT Prescription: Integrating Genomics into RT Clinical Practice

The genomic era has significantly changed the practice of clinical oncology. The use of genomic-based molecular diagnostics including prognostic genomic signatures and new-generation sequencing has become routine for clinical decisions regarding cytotoxic chemotherapy, targeted agents and immunotherapy. In contrast, clinical decisions regarding radiation therapy (RT) remain uninformed about the genomic heterogeneity of tumors. In this review, we discuss the clinical opportunity to utilize genomics to optimize RT dose. Although from the technical perspective, RT has been moving towards a data-driven approach, RT prescription dose is still based on a one-size-fits all approach, with most RT dose based on cancer diagnosis and stage. This approach is in direct conflict with the realization that tumors are biologically heterogeneous, and that cancer is not a single disease. Here, we discuss how genomics can be integrated into RT prescription dose, the clinical potential for this approach and how genomic-optimization of RT dose could lead to new understanding of the clinical benefit of RT.

Radiation oncology in the era of precision medicine

Technological advances and clinical research over the past few decades have given radiation oncologists the capability to personalize treatments for accurate delivery of radiation dose based on clinical parameters and anatomical information. Eradication of gross and microscopic tumours with preservation of health-related quality of life can be achieved in many patients. Two major strategies, acting synergistically, will enable further widening of the therapeutic window of radiation oncology in the era of precision medicine: technology-driven improvement of treatment conformity, including advanced image guidance and particle therapy, and novel biological concepts for personalized treatment, including biomarker-guided prescription, combined treatment modalities and adaptation of treatment during its course.

[Radiomics: Definition and clinical development]

The ultimate goal in radiation oncology is to offer a personalized treatment to all patients indicated for radiotherapy. Radiomics is a tool that reinforces a deep analysis of tumors at the molecular aspect taking into account intrinsic susceptibility in a long-term follow-up. Radiomics allow qualitative and quantitative performance analyses with high throughput extraction of numeric radiologic data to obtain predictive or prognostic information from patients treated for cancer. A second approach is to define biological or constitutional that could change the practice. This technique included normal tissue individual susceptibility but also potential response of tumors under ionizing radiation treatment. These "omics" are biological and technical techniques leading to simultaneous novel identification and exploration a set of genes, lipids, proteins.

Feasibility of Primary Tumor Culture Models and Preclinical Prediction Assays for Head and Neck Cancer: A Narrative Review

Primary human tumor culture models allow for individualized drug sensitivity testing and are therefore a promising technique to achieve personalized treatment for cancer patients. This would especially be of interest for patients with advanced stage head and neck cancer. They are extensively treated with surgery, usually in combination with high-dose cisplatin chemoradiation. However, adding cisplatin to radiotherapy is associated with an increase in severe acute toxicity, while conferring only a minor overall survival benefit. Hence, there is a strong need for a preclinical model to identify patients that will respond to the intended treatment regimen and to test novel drugs. One of such models is the technique of culturing primary human tumor tissue. This review discusses the feasibility and success rate of existing primary head and neck tumor culturing techniques and their corresponding chemo- and radiosensitivity assays. A comprehensive literature search was performed and success factors for culturing in vitro are debated, together with the actual value of these models as preclinical prediction assay for individual patients. With this review, we aim to fill a gap in the understanding of primary culture models from head and neck tumors, with potential importance for other tumor types as well.

Effective Biomarkers and Radiation Treatment in Head and Neck Cancer

CONTEXT

Radiation is a key arm in the multidisciplinary treatment of patients with head and neck squamous cell carcinoma. During the past 2 decades, significant changes in the way radiation therapy is planned and delivered have improved efficacy and decreased toxicity. Refined approaches in the application of radiation and chemoradiation have led to organ-sparing treatment regimens for laryngeal and pharyngeal cancers and have improved local and regional control rates in the postoperative, adjuvant setting. The molecular and genetic determinants of tumor cell response to radiation have been studied, and several potential biomarkers are emerging that could further improve application and efficacy of radiation treatment in head and neck squamous cell carcinoma.

OBJECTIVE

To discuss the current understanding of potential biomarkers related to radiation response in head and neck squamous cell carcinoma.

DATA SOURCES

Existing published literature.

CONCLUSIONS

Several potential biomarkers are actively being studied as predictors and targets to improve the use and efficacy of radiation therapy to treat head and neck squamous cell carcinoma. Several promising candidates have been defined, and new markers are on the horizon.

Discovery of the cancer stem cell related determinants of radioresistance

Tumors are known to be heterogeneous containing a dynamic mixture of phenotypically and functionally different tumor cells. The two concepts attempting to explain the origin of intratumor heterogeneity are the cancer stem cell hypothesis and the clonal evolution model. The stochastic model argues that tumors are biologically homogenous and all cancer cells within the tumor have equal ability to propagate the tumor growth depending on continuing mutations and selective pressure. By contrast, the stem cells model suggests that cancer heterogeneity is due to the hierarchy that originates from a small population of cancer stem cells (CSCs) which are biologically distinct from the bulk tumor and possesses self-renewal, tumorigenic and multilineage potential. Although these two hypotheses have been discussed for a long time as mutually exclusive explanations of tumor heterogeneity, they are easily reconciled serving as a driving force of cancer evolution and diversity. Recent discovery of the cancer cell plasticity and heterogeneity makes the CSC population a moving target that could be hard to track and eradicate. Understanding the signaling mechanisms regulating CSCs during the course of cancer treatment can be indispensable for the optimization of current treatment strategies.

Assessment of predictive molecular variables in feline oral squamous cell carcinoma treated with stereotactic radiation therapy

This study evaluated molecular characteristics that are potentially prognostic in cats with oral squamous cell carcinoma (SCC) that underwent stereotactic radiation therapy (SRT). Survival time (ST) and progression-free interval (PFI) were correlated with mitotic index, histopathological grades, Ki67 and epidermal growth factor receptor expressions, tumour microvascular density (MVD), and tumour oxygen tension (pO(2)). Median ST and PFI were 106 and 87 days, respectively (n = 20). Overall response rate was 38.5% with rapid improvement of clinical symptoms in many cases. Patients with higher MVD or more keratinized SCC had significantly shorter ST or PFI than patients with lower MVD or less keratinized SCC (P = 0.041 and 0.049, respectively). Females had significantly longer PFI and ST than males (P ≤ 0.016). Acute toxicities were minimal. However, treatment-related complications such as fractured mandible impacted quality of life. In conclusion, SRT alone should be considered as a palliative treatment. MVD and degree of keratinization may be useful prognostic markers.

A molecular assay of tumor radiosensitivity: a roadmap towards biology-based personalized radiation therapy

The last two decades have seen technological developments that have led to more accurate delivery of radiation therapy (RT), which has resulted in clinical gains in many solid tumors. However, a fundamental question and perhaps the next major hurdle is whether biological strategies can be developed to further enhance the effectiveness and efficiency of RT. This article addresses the development of a novel genomics-based molecular assay to predict tumor radiosensitivity, and proposes that this assay may prove pivotal in the development of biologically guided RT.

The HYP-RT hypoxic tumour radiotherapy algorithm and accelerated repopulation dose per fraction study

The HYP-RT model simulates hypoxic tumour growth for head and neck cancer as well as radiotherapy and the effects of accelerated repopulation and reoxygenation. This report outlines algorithm design, parameterisation and the impact of accelerated repopulation on the increase in dose/fraction needed to control the extra cell propagation during accelerated repopulation. Cell kill probabilities are based on Linear Quadratic theory, with oxygenation levels and proliferative capacity influencing cell death. Hypoxia is modelled through oxygen level allocation based on pO₂ histograms. Accelerated repopulation is modelled by increasing the stem cell symmetrical division probability, while the process of reoxygenation utilises randomised pO₂ increments to the cell population after each treatment fraction. Propagation of 10⁸ tumour cells requires 5–30 minutes. Controlling the extra cell growth induced by accelerated repopulation requires a dose/fraction increase of 0.5–1.0 Gy, in agreement with published reports. The average reoxygenation pO₂ increment of 3 mmHg per fraction results in full tumour reoxygenation after shrinkage to approximately 1 mm. HYP-RT is a computationally efficient model simulating tumour growth and radiotherapy, incorporating accelerated repopulation and reoxygenation. It may be used to explore cell kill outcomes during radiotherapy while varying key radiobiological and tumour specific parameters, such as the degree of hypoxia.

The chemopreventive and clinically used agent curcumin sensitizes HPV (-) but not HPV (+) HNSCC to ionizing radiation, in vitro and in a mouse orthotopic model

Radiation therapy (RT) plays a critical role in the local-regional control of head and neck squamous cell carcinoma (HNSCC). However, the efficacy of RT in treating HNSCC is limited by severe normal tissue toxicity, predominantly mucositis. One pharmacological approach for increasing the clinical response to RT is the use of radiation response modifiers that preferentially sensitize tumor cells. Previously we demonstrated that curcumin, a natural plant polyphenol, increased the radiation sensitivity of HNSCC cells and that the observed sensitization was dependent on curcumin-mediated inhibition of thioredoxin reductase 1 (TxnRd1) a key cytosolic regulator of redox-dependent signaling. Here, we examined curcumin-induced radiation sensitization in HNSCC cell lines with differing HPV status and expressing different levels of TxnRd1, in vitro. The intrinsic radiation resistance of the HPV (-) cell lines was significantly higher than the HPV (+) cell lines used in our study. Notably, all of the HPV (-) cell lines expressed high levels of TxnRd1 and exhibited higher intrinsic resistance to RT. While curcumin was effective at increasing the radiation response of the resistant HPV (-) cell lines it had no effect on the HPV (+) cells. Based on these findings we employed an orthotopic, HPV (-) HNSCC tumor model in athymic nude mice to examine the effect of combining curcumin with fractionated RT, in vivo. The combination of curcumin feeding and fractionated RT had a significant effect on tumor doubling time and overall animal survival. We therefore propose that curcumin and RT should be considered as a first line treatment of HPV (-) HNSCC.

The role of PET imaging in overcoming radiobiological challenges in the treatment of advanced head and neck cancer

PURPOSE

Despite the large variety of treatment methods available for the management of advanced head and neck carcinomas, these tumours remain highly challenging due to their aggressiveness and complex anatomical location. Among the treatment challenges associated with head and neck cancers, hypoxia and tumour repopulation during treatment are, most likely, the main reason for locoregional treatment failure. Whilst the number of techniques and predictive assays designed to assess the oxygenation status or the proliferative ability of tumours is rather large, they all come with drawbacks which limit their implementation as routine clinical procedures. Latest developments in the field of nuclear medicine have opened the road to new possibilities in functional imaging, thus overcoming some of the confines imposed by the more conventional techniques.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

The current paper presents the role of PET imaging as a quantitative evaluation tool for hypoxia status and proliferative ability of advanced head and neck tumours. Traditional as well as novel radioisotopes with high affinity towards hypoxia and proliferative tumour activity are presented and their pre-clinical/clinical results analysed.

RESULTS

While the number of clinical studies which aimed to validate novel radiotracers for head and neck cancer is limited, a number of results show promising correlation between uptake/marker activity and treatment outcome.

CONCLUSION

There is need for further studies and well designed clinical trials to obtain more conclusive results.

Molecular biology: the key to personalised treatment in radiation oncology?

We know considerably more about what makes cells and tissues resistant or sensitive to radiation than we did 20 years ago. Novel techniques in molecular biology have made a major contribution to our understanding at the level of signalling pathways. Before the "New Biology" era, radioresponsiveness was defined in terms of physiological parameters designated as the five Rs. These are: repair, repopulation, reassortment, reoxygenation and radiosensitivity. Of these, only the role of hypoxia proved to be a robust predictive and prognostic marker, but radiotherapy regimens were nonetheless modified in terms of dose per fraction, fraction size and overall time, in ways that persist in clinical practice today. The first molecular techniques were applied to radiobiology about two decades ago and soon revealed the existence of genes/proteins that respond to and influence the cellular outcome of irradiation. The subsequent development of screening techniques using microarray technology has since revealed that a very large number of genes fall into this category. We can now obtain an adequately robust molecular signature, predicting for a radioresponsive phenotype using gene expression and proteomic approaches. In parallel with these developments, functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI) and positron emission tomography (PET) can now detect specific biological molecules such as haemoglobin and glucose, so revealing a 3D map of tumour blood flow and metabolism. The key to personalised radiotherapy will be to extend this capability to the proteins of the molecular signature that determine radiosensitivity.

Measurement of reoxygenation during fractionated radiotherapy in head and neck squamous cell carcinoma xenografts

Hypoxic tissues lack adequate oxygenation and it has been long established that tumours commonly exhibit hypoxia and that hypoxia is a factor contributing towards resistance to radiotherapy. To develop computer models and make predictions about the affects of tumour hypoxia on treatment outcome, quantitative tumour oxygenation and reoxygenation data from in vivo systems is required. The aim of this study was to investigate the timing and degree of reoxygenation during radiotherapy in a human head and neck squamous cell carcinoma xenograft mouse model (FaDu). Mice were immobilised using a novel restraining system and exposed unanaesthetised in 3 or 5 Gy fractions, up to a maximum of 40 Gy. Partial pressures of oxygen (pO2) measurements were recorded at six time points throughout the 2 week course of radiotherapy, using a fibre optic system. Tumours receiving 0-30 Gy did not exhibit an increase in pO2. However, the mean pO2 after 2 weeks of accelerated fractionated radiotherapy (40 Gy) was significantly increased (P<0.01) compared to the mean pO2 of tumours not receiving the full schedule (0-30 Gy). These results lead to the conclusion of an average reoxygenation onset time of 2 weeks in this group of xenografts. A relatively large range of pO2 values measured at each dose point in the study indicate a large inter-tumour variation in oxygenation among the tumours. Data from this experimental work will be used to define the range of reoxygenation onset times implemented in a Monte Carlo computer model, simulating hypoxic head and neck cancer growth and radiotherapy.

Comparison of predicted and clinical response to radiotherapy: a radiobiology modelling study

INTRODUCTION

A model to predict clinical outcome after radiation therapy would be a valuable aid in the effort of developing more tailored treatment regimes for different patients. In this work we evaluate the clinical utility of a model that incorporates the following individually measured radiobiology parameters: intrinsic radiosensitivity, proliferation and number of clonogenic cells. The hypothesis underlying the study was that the incorporation of individually measured tumour parameters in a model would increase its reliability in predicting treatment outcome compared with the use of average population derived data.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

Forty-six patients with head and neck tumours were analyzed, the majority of whom received both external beam radiotherapy and brachytherapy. Eighteen patients received external beam treatment alone and statistical analyses were carried out on this subgroup.

RESULTS

Four of the 18 patients had a >95% calculated probability of cure and none developed a local recurrence resulting in a negative predictive value of 100% (compared with 67% for population-derived data). The sensitivity of the model in predicting local recurrence was 75% (compared with 38% for population-derived data). Using a model that incorporated individually measured radiobiology data, there was a statistically significant difference in local control levels for patients with >95% and <5% predicted probability of local control (chi(2), p = 0.04).

DISCUSSION

This study suggests, therefore, that incorporation of measured biological data within a radiobiological model improves its ability to predict radiation therapy outcome compared with the use of population-derived data.

Predicting response to clinical radiotherapy: past, present, and future directions

BACKGROUND

Personalized radiation therapy holds the promise that the diagnosis, prevention, and treatment of cancer will be based on individual assessment of risk. Although advances in personalized radiation therapy have been achieved, the biological parameters that define individual radiosensitivity remain unclear.

METHODS

This review focuses on discussing the field of radiosensitivity predictive assays, a technology central to the concept of personalized medicine in radiation oncology. Two novel approaches, DNA end-binding complexes and gene expression classifiers, show promise in solving some of the logistic problems associated with previous assays.

RESULTS

Current data suggest that predicting clinical response to radiotherapy is possible. The delivery of this promise depends on the ability to define the variables that define response to clinical radiotherapy. A successful predictive assay is key to the development of personalized treatment strategies in radiation oncology.

CONCLUSIONS

Novel technologies need to be developed that will improve our understanding of the biological variables that define clinical tumor response and will lead to the development of a clinically useful assay.

Hypoxia positron emission tomography imaging with 18f-fluoromisonidazole

The importance of hypoxia in disease pathogenesis and prognosis is gathering increasing clinical significance and having a greater impact on patient management and outcome. Previous efforts to evaluate hypoxia have included the invasive assessment of hypoxia with immunohistologic and histographic oxygen probes. The emergence of new radiotracers has allowed noninvasive assessment of hypoxia, with the most extensively investigated and validated positron emission tomography radiotracer of hypoxia to date being (18)F-fluoromisonodazole ((18)F-FMISO). This review discusses the relevance and biology of hypoxia in cells and organ systems, and reviews the laboratory and clinical applications of (18)F-FMISO in oncology and noncancer disease states.

Clinical and biological factors affecting response to radiotherapy in patients with head and neck cancer: a review

OBJECTIVE

The main aim of this article was to review the clinical and biological factors that have been shown to influence the response of the head and neck squamous cell carcinoma (HNSCC) to primary radiotherapy and briefly discuss how some of these factors could be exploited to improve outcome.

DESIGN

Medline based search covering 1982-2006 to identify the HNSCC literature where the effect of clinical and biological factors on locoregional control and overall survival were investigated.

RESULTS

Clinical factors are routinely used in management decisions. Nevertheless, identically staged tumours receiving the same treatment may have different outcomes. Biological factors such as hypoxia, proliferation and radio-sensitivity play an important role in radiation response. However, these are not currently used in practise because tests that are clinically reliable and feasible are not available.

CONCLUSION

High-quality translational research will allow us to develop biological tests that can be used in routine clinical practise to tailor individual treatment, with the ability to improve patient outcome further by modifying the underlying tumour biology.

Cell kinetics

Cell kinetic concepts have pervaded radiation therapy since the early part of the 20th century and have been instrumental in the development of modern radiotherapy. In this review, the fundamental radiobiological concepts that have been developed based on cell kinetic knowledge will be revisited and discussed in the context of contemporary radiation therapy. This will include how the proliferation characteristics, variation in sensitivity during the cell cycle and the extent of radiation-induced cell cycle delay translate into a variable time for the expression of damage, how cell kinetics interacts with hypoxia and how the response to fractionated radiation schedules is influenced by cell kinetics in terms of repair, redistribution, reoxygenation and repopulation. The promise of combining radiation with new biologically targeted agents and the potential of non-invasive positron emission tomography imaging of proliferation are areas where cell kinetics will continue to influence radiotherapy practice.

Comparison between pimonidazole binding, oxygen electrode measurements, and expression of endogenous hypoxia markers in cancer of the uterine cervix

BACKGROUND

Although tumor hypoxia has been associated with a more aggressive phenotype and lower cure rate, there is no consensus as to the method best suited for routine measurement. Binding of the chemical hypoxia marker, pimonidazole, and expression of the endogenous hypoxia markers HIF-1alpha and CAIX were compared for their ability to detect hypoxia in tumor biopsies from 67 patients with advanced carcinoma of the cervix.

METHODS

Two biopsies were taken one day after administration of pimonidazole and were analyzed for pimonidazole binding using flow cytometry or immunohistochemistry. CAIX and HIF-1alpha expression and degree of colocalization were measured in sequential antibody-stained sections. Patient subsets were examined for tumor oxygen tension using an Eppendorf electrode, S phase DNA content, or change in HIF-1alpha expression over the course of treatment.

RESULTS

Approximately 6% of the tumor area stained positive for pimonidazole, HIF-1alpha, or CAIX. The CAIX positive fraction correlated with the pimonidazole positive fraction (r = 0.60). Weaker but significant correlations were observed between pimonidazole and HIF-1alpha (r = 0.31) and CAIX and HIF-1alpha (r = 0.41). Taking the extent of marker colocalization into consideration increased the confidence that all markers were identifying hypoxic regions. Over 65% of stained areas showed a high degree of colocalization with the other markers. Oxygen microelectrode measurements and S phase fraction were not correlated with the hypoxic fraction measured using the three hypoxia markers. HIF-1alpha levels tended to decrease with time after the start of therapy.

CONCLUSIONS

Endogenous hypoxia marker binding shows reasonable agreement, in extent and location, with binding of pimonidazole. CAIX staining pattern is a better match to the pimonidazole staining pattern than is HIF-1alpha, and high CAIX expression in the absence (or low levels) of HIF-1alpha may indicate a different biology.

Altered fractionation and combined radio-chemotherapy approaches: pioneering new opportunities in head and neck oncology

Squamous cell carcinoma of the head and neck (HNSCC) are increasingly treated by multimodality approaches combining surgery, radiotherapy and chemotherapy. Randomised controlled trials have demonstrated major improvements in loco-regional tumour control from altered fractionation radiotherapy, accelerated fractionation and hyperfractionation, as compared with conventional fractionation. This experience is summarised, and the limit as to how far these modifications can be taken is discussed. It is emphasised that radiation fractionation will need to be optimised separately in multimodality strategies. Combined chemotherapy and radiotherapy has also been shown in phase III trials to produce an improved survival and an improved disease control. Chemotherapy may be given as neoadjuvant, concurrent or adjuvant treatment and the biological rationales for each of these, and the data supporting them, are reviewed. Although, large meta-analyses have shown concurrent chemoradiation to be the most effective, there is still a strong rationale for trying to develop neoadjuvant and adjuvant schedules. New, more active drugs may be important in this context. As therapy is becoming more intense, a careful recording and reporting of treatment-related morbidity is a crucial element in estimating the therapeutic gain from competing therapeutic management strategies. Development of non-cytostatic drugs and individualization of therapy using molecular prognostic markers are exciting areas of research with a great potential for improving therapy in the next decade and these are briefly discussed. Finally, a number of avenues for further research are identified.

[Probabilities of controlling tumors and complications (TCP/NTCP) after radiotherapy: methodologic, physical, and biological aspects]

Radiotherapy is aimed at getting the best possible therapeutic ratio (tumor local control versus morbidity). Physicists and radiation oncologists have to evaluate explicitly or implicitly the probability of induced complications to normal surrounding tissues. This is based on published data and clinician's experience. Quantitative methods have been introduced with different models in order to predict the impact of partial or global irradiation on a normal organ. These models correspond to the Tumor Control Probability (TCP) and Normal Tissue Complication Probability (NTCP). These biological models may be useful to evaluate the quality of a treatment planning or for the optimization process. The methodologies used and the clinical data are developed and discussed.

Accelerated hyperfractionation (AHF) compared to conventional fractionation (CF) in the postoperative radiotherapy of locally advanced head and neck cancer: influence of proliferation

Based on the assumption that an accelerated proliferation process prevails in tumour cell residues after surgery, the possibility that treatment acceleration would offer a therapeutic advantage in postoperative radiotherapy of locally advanced head and neck cancer was investigated. The value of T(pot) in predicting the treatment outcome and in selecting patients for accelerated fractionation was tested. Seventy patients with (T2/N1-N2) or (T3-4/any N) squamous cell carcinoma of the oral cavity, larynx and hypopharynx who underwent radical surgery, were randomized to either (a) accelerated hyperfractionation: 46.2 Gy per 12 days, 1.4 Gy per fraction, three fractions per day with 6 h interfraction interval, treating 6 days per week or (b) Conventional fractionation: 60 Gy per 6 weeks, 2 Gy per fraction, treating 5 days per week. The 3-year locoregional control rate was significantly better in the accelerated hyperfractionation (88 +/- 4%) than in the CF (57+/- 9%) group, P=0.01 (and this was confirmed by multivariate analysis), but the difference in survival (60 +/- 10% vs 46 +/- 9%) was not significant (P=0.29). The favourable influence of a short treatment time was further substantiated by demonstrating the importance of the gap between surgery and radiotherapy and the overall treatment time between surgery and end of radiotherapy. Early mucositis progressed more rapidly and was more severe in the accelerated hyperfractionation group; reflecting a faster rate of dose accumulation. Xerostomia was experienced by all patients with a tendency to be more severe after accelerated hyperfractionation. Fibrosis and oedema also tended to be more frequent after accelerated hyperfractionation and probably represent consequential reactions. T(pot) showed a correlation with disease-free survival in a univariate analysis but did not prove to be an independent factor. Moreover, the use of the minimum and corrected P-values did not identify a significant cut-off. Compared to conventional fractionation, accelerated hyperfractionation did not seem to offer a survival advantage in fast tumours though a better local control rate was noted. This limits the use of T(pot) as a guide for selecting patients for accelerated hyperfractionation. For slowly growing tumours, tumour control and survival probabilities were not significantly different in the conventional fractionation and accelerated hyperfractionation groups. A rapid tumour growth was associated with a higher risk of distant metastases (P=0.01). In conclusion, tumour cell repopulation seems to be an important determinant of postoperative radiotherapy of locally advanced head and neck cancer despite lack of a definite association between T(pot) and treatment outcome. In fast growing tumours accelerated hyperfractionation provided an improved local control but without a survival advantage. To gain a full benefit from treatment acceleration, the surgery-radiotherapy gap and the overall treatment time should not exceed 6 and 10 weeks respectively.

Incorporating biologic measurements (SF(2), CFE) into a tumor control probability model increases their prognostic significance: a study in cervical carcinoma treated with radiation therapy

PURPOSE

To assess whether incorporation of measurements of surviving fraction at 2 Gy (SF(2)) and colony-forming efficiency (CFE) into a tumor control probability (tcp) model increases their prognostic significance.

METHODS AND MATERIALS

Measurements of SF(2) and CFE were available from a study on carcinoma of the cervix treated with radiation alone. These measurements, as well as tumor volume, dose, and treatment time, were incorporated into a Poisson tcp model (tcp(alpha,rho)). Regression analysis was performed to assess the prognostic power of tcp(alpha,rho) vs. the use of either tcp models with biologic parameters fixed to best-fit estimates (but incorporating individual dose, volume, and treatment time) or the use of SF(2) and CFE measurements alone.

RESULTS

In a univariate regression analysis of 44 patients, tcp(alpha,rho) was a better prognostic factor for both local control and survival (p < 0.001 and p = 0.049, respectively) than SF(2) alone (p = 0.009 for local control, p = 0.29 for survival) or CFE alone (p = 0.015 for local control, p = 0.38 for survival). In multivariate analysis, tcp(alpha,rho) emerged as the most important prognostic factor for local control (p < 0.001, relative risk of 2.81). After allowing for tcp(alpha,rho), CFE was still a significant independent prognostic factor for local control, whereas SF(2) was not. The sensitivities of tcp(alpha,rho) and SF(2) as predictive tests for local control were 87% and 65%, respectively. Specificities were 70% and 77%, respectively.

CONCLUSIONS

A Poisson tcp model incorporating individual SF(2), CFE, dose, tumor volume, and treatment time was found to be the best independent prognostic factor for local control and survival in cervical carcinoma patients.

TP53 mutation is related to poor prognosis after radiotherapy, but not surgery, in squamous cell carcinoma of the head and neck

BACKGROUND AND METHODS

TP53 gene-mutation and expression of p53 have been described to influence the radiosensitivity of tumour cells from head and neck carcinomas. The present study was performed to evaluate whether TP53 mutation may influence the clinical outcome of head and neck cancer patients treated with radiotherapy or surgery.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

DNA was extracted from formalin-fixed paraffin-embedded tissue sections from primary biopsies taken before radiotherapy. Gene mutations (in exons 5-9) were identified using denaturing gradient gel electrophoresis (DGGE) as the initial scanning procedure and characterized by sequencing. Patients were treated with primary radiotherapy or surgery alone. Treatment was given according to the DAHANCA schedules with 5 or 6 weekly fractions (2 Gy) of radiotherapy (66-68 Gy). Most patients were also treated with the hypoxic radiosensitizer Nimorazole. The results are reported as 5-year actuarial values, and differences estimated by log-rank analysis.

RESULTS

The present analysis is based on 114 patients with squamous cell carcinoma of the larynx, pharynx and oral cavity diagnosed between March 1992 and October 1996. Ninety patients received primary radiotherapy alone and 21 were treated with surgery. TP53 mutations were found in 45 patients (39%) and in patients receiving radiotherapy, TP53 mutation was highly associated with poor prognosis. Loco-regional control rates (5-year actuarial values) for TP53 mutation was 29 vs. 54% for TP53 wildtype (P < 0.01). For disease-free survival the corresponding values were 13 and 38% (P < 0.01), respectively. The correlations were not found to be related to specific subtypes of mutations (e.g. missense mutations affecting DNA-contact or Zn-binding regions) but rather to the presence of any mutation at all. In contrast, TP53 mutation did not influence the response to surgery.

CONCLUSIONS

A strong relationship was observed between TP53 mutation and poor prognosis (increased risk of loco-regional failure and death) in head and neck cancer patients given primary radiotherapy but not surgery.

Monte Carlo dose calculations and radiobiological modelling: analysis of the effect of the statistical noise of the dose distribution on the probability of tumour control

The aim of this work is to investigate the influence of the statistical fluctuations of Monte Carlo (MC) dose distributions on the dose volume histograms (DVHs) and radiobiological models, in particular the Poisson model for tumour control probability (tcp). The MC matrix is characterized by a mean dose in each scoring voxel, d, and a statistical error on the mean dose, sigma(d); whilst the quantities d and sigma(d) depend on many statistical and physical parameters, here we consider only their dependence on the phantom voxel size and the number of histories from the radiation source. Dose distributions from high-energy photon beams have been analysed. It has been found that the DVH broadens when increasing the statistical noise of the dose distribution, and the tcp calculation systematically underestimates the real tumour control value, defined here as the value of tumour control when the statistical error of the dose distribution tends to zero. When increasing the number of energy deposition events, either by increasing the voxel dimensions or increasing the number of histories from the source, the DVH broadening decreases and tcp converges to the 'correct' value. It is shown that the underestimation of the tcp due to the noise in the dose distribution depends on the degree of heterogeneity of the radiobiological parameters over the population; in particular this error decreases with increasing the biological heterogeneity, whereas it becomes significant in the hypothesis of a radiosensitivity assay for single patients, or for subgroups of patients. It has been found, for example, that when the voxel dimension is changed from a cube with sides of 0.5 cm to a cube with sides of 0.25 cm (with a fixed number of histories of 10(8) from the source), the systematic error in the tcp calculation is about 75% in the homogeneous hypothesis, and it decreases to a minimum value of about 15% in a case of high radiobiological heterogeneity. The possibility of using the error on the tcp to decide how many histories to run for a given voxel size is also discussed.

Blood hemoglobin level may affect radiosensitivity-preliminary results on acutely reacting normal tissues

PURPOSE

To evaluate the influence of blood hemoglobin concentration on the radiosensitivity of acutely reacting normal tissues.

METHODS AND MATERIALS

Weekly scores (EORTC/RTOG criteria) for acute reactions of skin and mucosa are available for 60 patients with cancer of the head and neck undergoing a standard conventional radiotherapy. The prognostic significance of blood hemoglobin levels on the development of acute reactions is studied by multivariate analysis (Cox Proportional Hazards Model). Further, the incidence and the time to development of these reactions is looked at in cohorts of patients with different mean blood hemoglobin concentrations during radiotherapy. Patients are therefore classified into a "severely anemic group" (hemoglobin < 11.0 g/100 mL), and into a cohort with a blood hemoglobin value equal or above 11.0 g/100 mL.

RESULTS

Normal tissue scoring and monitoring of blood hemoglobin levels allows for a detailed analysis of possible correlations. A decrease in the mean blood hemoglobin value of 1 g/100 mL predicts a reduced risk to develop a skin reaction of Grade 2 or 3 (RR = 0.9; p = 0.08; RR = 0.8; p = 0.26, respectively) or a mucosa reaction of Grade 3 (RR = 0.8; p = 0.16), independent from the radiation dose, the treatment time and from previous surgery within the radiation volume (multivariate analysis). Likewise, patients with severe anemia develop grade 3 mucositis or dermatitis less often (0%; 13%) as compared to those with blood hemoglobin concentrations equal or above 11.0 g/100 mL (21%; 19%). Skin and mucosa reactions further tend to occur later in the course of radiation. The observations are not statistically significant and possible reasons will be discussed.

CONCLUSIONS

A decreased blood hemoglobin concentration may-perhaps by an impaired tissue oxygenation-reduce the radiosensitivity of normal tissue such as skin and mucosa. However, the data is preliminary and needs further confirmation.

Genome-wide screening for radiation response factors in head and neck cancer

INTRODUCTION

Radiation therapy is an integral part of the treatment of head and neck cancer. Factors predicting radiation response are ill defined. The aim of this study was to identify genetic aberrations associated with radiation response in cell lines derived from head and neck squamous cell carcinomas (HNSCC) using comparative genomic hybridization (CGH) for genome-wide screening.

METHODS

Five cell lines derived from HNSCC were subjected to a single course of radiation (400 cGy) in parallel with a similarly handled, untreated control. Cellular response to radiation was determined on posttreatment days 1, 2, 3, 4, and 5 using a cell viability assay (MTT assay). Radiation response was defined as 35% or greater decrease in cell survival relative to control. Tumor doubling time was determined by cell counts performed at day 0 and 1 for each cell line. All experiments were done in quadruplicate. CGH analysis was performed by differentially labeling DNA from tumor and normal tissue with fluorescent agents. The labeled DNAs were simultaneously hybridized to normal metaphase chromosomes. Image analysis for fluorescence intensity along the entire length of each metaphase chromosome allowed generation of a color ratio, which was used to detect copy number changes.

RESULTS

Radioresistance was identified in two of five cell lines. The tumor doubling time was not a predictor of radiation response. CGH identified a complex pattern of aberrations, with gain of 3q common to all cell lines. The number of genetic aberration was higher in radiation-sensitive cell lines than in radiation-resistant ones. No recurrent aberrations were unique to the radiation-resistant cell lines. Recurrent gains at 7p and 17q and losses at 5q, 7q, and 18q were unique to the radiation-sensitive cell lines.

CONCLUSIONS

The number of aberrations identified by CGH analysis may be a predictor of radiation response. A large study of primary tumors is warranted to confirm this association and identify specific genetic aberrations associated with radiation response.

Tumor radiosensitivity (SF2) is a prognostic factor for local control in head and neck cancers

PURPOSE

To evaluate prospectively the prognostic value of SF2 for local control and survival in patients undergoing radiation therapy for head and neck cancers.

METHODS AND MATERIALS

Following informed consent tumor specimens were obtained from 156 patients with primary carcinomas of the head and neck region. The specimens were assessed for the ability to grow in vitro (colony forming efficiency, CFE) and inherent radiosensitivity measured as the surviving fraction at 2 Gy (SF2) using a soft-agar clonogenic assay. Patients were treated mainly with neoadjuvant chemotherapy plus radiation therapy usually as a combination of accelerated external beam and interstitial radiotherapy. The probabilities of local control and survival were analyzed by univariate, bivariate and Cox multivariate analyses.

RESULTS

Successful growth was achieved in 110/156 specimens and SF2 values were obtained from 99/156. Eighty four out of these patients underwent radical treatment. The median SF2 value for the 84 tumors was 0.40. At a mean follow-up time of 25 months (range 7-65) the median SF2 value of tumors from 14 patients who developed local recurrence was 0.53, which was significantly higher than the median of 0.38 for tumors from 70 patients without local recurrence (p = 0.015). Tumor SF2 was a significant prognostic factor for local control (p = 0.036), but not for overall survival (p = 0.20). Tumor SF2 was an independent prognostic factor for local control within bivariate and Cox multivariate analyses.

CONCLUSIONS

This study has shown that tumor radiosensitivity measured as SF2 is a significant prognostic factor for local control in head and neck cancers.

Interrelationship of proliferation and hypoxia in carcinoma of the cervix

PURPOSE

In human cervix cancer treated with radiotherapy, we have previously shown from separate groups of patients that tumor hypoxia and proliferation rate as measured by bromodeoxyuridine (BrdU) labeling index (LI) are important determinants of clinical outcome. We now examine the relationship of these two pre-treatment predictive assays in 43 patients studied prospectively from 1994-98 where both tests were performed for each patient.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

Newly diagnosed patients with carcinoma of the cervix were examined under anesthesia for staging purposes. Patients were given BrdU (200 mg) by intravenous route prior to the procedure. Tumor oxygenation was measured with the Eppendorf pO2 histograph. Biopsy of tumor was then performed and the BrdU LI was obtained by flow cytometry. The degree of tumor hypoxia for each tumor was expressed as median pO2 values, and as the percentage of pO2 readings <5 mm Hg (HP5).

RESULTS

The median age was 53 years (range 23-79 years). There were 32 squamous, and 11 non-squamous carcinomas. FIGO stages were: IB and IIA, 8; IIB, 17; IIIB, 18; with a median tumor size of 6 cm (range 2-10 cm). The patients received uniform treatment with radical radiation therapy. There were 22 diploid and 21 aneuploid tumors. The median LI, pO2, and HP5 were 8.0%, 5.4 mm Hg, and 46.8%, respectively. Tests for linear associations showed no significant correlation between median pO2 vs. LI (r = 0.078, p = 0.62), and HP5 vs. LI (r = -0.14, p = 0.38).

CONCLUSIONS

The clinical outcome in this group of patients is immature, but these results suggest that tumor hypoxia and proliferation measurements are independent and potentially complementary predictive assays in cervix carcinoma. Further investigations are required to examine the distribution of proliferating tumor cells and its relationship with hypoxic tumor cells in tissue sections with the use of immunohistological techniques and image analysis systems.

Intratumoral pO2-measurements as predictive assay in the treatment of carcinoma of the uterine cervix

BACKGROUND

Several studies have shown that pretreatment oxygenation status of cervical tumors measured with a polarographic oxygen electrode could be a predictive factor for radiation response and survival. The purpose of this study was to evaluate the impact of intratumoral pO2 levels and hypoxic fractions on local control and disease free survival employing a standardized measuring procedure under routine conditions.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Between April 1994 and December 1997 pO2 measurements were performed prior to radiotherapy with an Eppendorf histograph in 51 evaluable patients with primary cervical carcinoma. All patients were treated with curative intent by combined external beam therapy (median total dose 49.6 Gy) and 3-6 applications of high dose rate- (7 Gy/fr. at point 'A') or pulse dose rate brachytherapy (20-25 h pulses, 1 Gy/pulse at point 'A'). Oxygenation data are given as median pO2 of pooled readings and percentage of readings below 5 mm Hg (HF 5).

RESULTS

Median pO2 values ranged from 0 to 60 mm Hg (median 10). HF5 ranged from 0 to 95% (median 22%). Median follow-up was 26 months (range 9-54 months). Actuarial overall and disease-free survival rates (OS/DFS) at 3 years were 53%/50%. Comparing patients with median pO2 < or = 10 mm Hg (n = 26) to patients with higher median pO2 levels (n = 25) calculated DFS was 34 and 69%, respectively (P < 0.02). Corresponding data for local control were 47 and 84% (P = 0.053). Comparing patients with HF5 below and above the median calculated DFS was 36 and 66%, respectively (P < 0.02). Patients who had median pO2 < 10 mm Hg and HF5 > 20% had the worst prognosis (3-year DFS: 28%). Besides oxygenation status, stage and initial hemoglobin concentration were statistically significant for treatment outcome.

CONCLUSIONS

This study confirms earlier data that the presence of hypoxia is associated with poor local control and survival in patients with carcinoma of the uterine cervix. Polarographic pO2 measurements are feasible under routine conditions and can be regarded as a reproducible predictive assay.

Surfing prognostic factors in head and neck cancer at the millennium

The ability to reliably predict cancer outcome could tailor therapy to the aggressiveness of the tumour to achieve the best results in terms of loco-regional control, overall survival and quality of life. Retrospective and prospective clinical trials involving large series of patients have validated some predictive clinical and pathological factors, whereas the utility of many other prognostic factors has not been established. This has led to some confusion in clinical practice. In order to clarify the significance, role and cost of these prognostic factors we carried out a Medline search of all papers published between 1993 and 1998 concerning the reliability and cost of markers with prognostic significance, in head and neck squamous cell carcinoma, and assessed the results according to a number of criteria relating to reliability and cost. Regarding reliability we classified prognostic factors into: (1) those with a proven significance based on the fact that they were unanimously reported as having an independent statistical correlation with outcome and prognosis; and (2) those for which results were not unanimous, and which significance is still controversial. Cost analysis showed a substantial difference between validated tests which are of low cost and experimental tests which are expensive. Based on these data regarding both the reliability and cost of each prognostic factor, we propose guidelines for their use in clinical practice in the year 2000.

The lack of correlation between proliferation (Ki-67, PCNA, LI, Tpot), p53 expression and radiosensitivity for head and neck cancers

A study was made of the relationship between measurements of radiosensitivity versus proliferation and p53 status in head and neck cancers. Inherent tumour radiosensitivity was assessed as surviving fraction at 2 Gy (SF2) using a clonogenic soft agar assay (n = 77). The results were compared to data on proliferation obtained by both flow cytometry (labelling index (LI), the potential doubling time (Tpot) n = 55) and immunohistochemistry (Ki-67 and PCNA; n = 68), together with immunohistochemical p53 expression (n = 68). There were no overall significant differences in the median values of the various parameters analysed for the different sites within the head and neck region, disease stages, grades of tumour differentiation or nodal states. A subgroup analysis showed that oropharyngeal (n = 22) versus oral cavity (n = 35) tumours were more radiosensitive (P = 0.056) and had a higher Ki-67 index (P = 0.001). Node-positive tumours had higher LI (P = 0.021) and a trend towards lower Tpot (P = 0.067) values than node-negative ones. No correlations were seen between SF2 and any of the parameters studied. The long-standing dogma of an increased radiosensitivity of rapidly proliferating cells in contrast to slowly proliferating cells was not confirmed. The study shows that parallel measurements of different biological markers can be obtained for a large number of patients with head and neck cancers. The independence of the various parameters studied suggests that there may be potential for their combined use as prognostic factors for the outcome of radiotherapy.

Cell kinetics and repopulation parameters of irradiated xenograft tumours in SCID mice: comparison of two dose-fractionation regimens

The extent and mechanism(s) of repopulation were assessed in SiHa (human cervical squamous cell carcinoma) xenografts in SCID mice for two fractionated irradiation regimens. Mice in one arm of the study received 50 Gy in 20 fractions over 23 days with a 14 day split between 10 fraction, 5 day courses. The other tumours were treated with 50 Gy in 20 fractions over 10 consecutive days. Cell kinetics and tumour regrowth parameters were monitored during and after treatment by measuring tumour volume and analysing cellular DNA content and proliferation parameters with flow cytometry. Repopulation occurred rapidly, beginning during irradiation and largely attributable to an increased growth fraction and decreased potential doubling time, apparently triggered by increased cell loss. Cell cycle time, in contrast, remained relatively constant throughout. Extrapolation of these results to humans suggests that treatment times should be minimised whenever possible, since regrowth rates exceeded those predicted from pretreatment Tpot measurements.

In vitro radiosensitivity of tumour cells and fibroblasts derived from head and neck carcinomas: mutual relationship and correlation with clinical data

The aim was to characterize the variation in the cellular in vitro radiosensitivities in squamous cell carcinomas of the head and neck, and to test for a possible correlation between different measures of radiosensitivity and the clinical and histopathological data. Cellular in vitro radiosensitivities were assessed in tumour biopsies from 71 patients using the modified Courtenay-Mills soft agar clonogenic assay combined with an immunocytochemical analysis. Radiosensitivity was quantified as the surviving fraction after a radiation dose of 2 Gy irrespective of cell type (overall SF2), or based on identification of cell type (tumour cell SF2, fibroblast SF2). Sixty-three biopsies were from primary tumours, and eight were from recurrences. Overall plating efficiency ranged from 0.005 to 1.60% with a median of 0.052%. The majority of the colonies obtained from the biopsies were fibroblast marker-positive; the proportion of tumour marker-positive colonies ranged from 1 to 88% with a median of 15%. The median overall SF2 was 0.47 (range 0.24-0.96), the median tumour cell SF2 was 0.50 (range 0.11-1.0) and the median fibroblast SF2 was 0.49 (range 0.24-1.0). Comparing data from independent experiments, the overall SF2 was significantly correlated with the SF2 of fibroblasts (2P = 0.006) but not with the tumour cell SF2. The tumour cell and fibroblast radiosensitivities measured in the same individuals were not correlated (r= 0.06, 95% CI [-0.19, 0.30]):This finding seems to preclude a strong correlation between the radiosensitivity of tumour cells and fibroblasts. Concerning the clinical characteristics, neither of the measures of tumour radiosensitivity was correlated with T- and N-category, stage, tumour size, sex and age. However, the tumour cell radiosensitivity decreased with increasing grade of histopathological differentiation (2P = 0.012). The same tendency was found in two independent analyses of the same patient material. This correlation was not significant in case of the overall SF2 or the fibroblast SF2.

The value of pretreatment cell kinetic parameters as predictors for radiotherapy outcome in head and neck cancer: a multicenter analysis

PURPOSE

The aim of this study was to assess the potential of pre-treatment cell kinetic parameters to predict outcome in head and neck cancer patients treated by conventional radiotherapy.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Data from 11 different centers were pooled. Inclusion criteria were such that the patients received radiotherapy alone, and that the radiotherapy was given in an overall time of at least 6 weeks with a dose of at least 60 Gy. All patients received a tracer dose of either iododeoxyuridine (IdUrd) or bromodeoxyuridine (BrdUrd) intravenously prior to treatment and a tumor biopsy was taken several hours later. The cell kinetic parameters labeling index (LI), DNA synthesis time (Ts) and potential doubling time (Tpot) were subsequently calculated from flow cytometry data, obtained on the biopsies using antibodies against I/BrdUrd incorporated into DNA. Each center carried out their own flow cytometry analysis.

RESULTS

From the 11 centers, a total of 476 patients conforming to the inclusion criteria were analyzed. Median values for overall time and total dose were 49 days and 69 Gy, respectively. Fifty one percent of patients had local recurrences and 53% patients had died, the majority from their disease. Median follow-up was 20 months; being 30 months for surviving patients. Multivariate analysis revealed that T-stage, maximum tumor diameter, differentiation grade, N-stage, tumor localization and overall time correlated with locoregional control, in decreasing order of significance. For the cell kinetic parameters, univariate analysis showed that only LI was significantly associated with local control (P=0.02), with higher values correlating with a worse outcome. Ts showed some evidence that patients with longer values did worse, but this was not significant (P=0.06). Tpot showed no trend (P=0.8). When assessing survival in a univariate analysis, neither LI nor Tpot associated with outcome (P=0.4, 0.4, respectively). Surprisingly, Ts did correlate with survival, with longer values being worse (P=0.02). In the multivariate analysis of local control, LI lost its significance (P=0.16).

CONCLUSIONS

The only pretreatment kinetic parameter for which some evidence was found for an association with local control (the best end-point for testing the present hypothesis) was LI, not Tpot, and this evidence disappeared in a multivariate analysis. It therefore appears that pretreatment cell kinetic measurements carried out using flow cytometry, only provide a relatively weak predictor of outcome after radiotherapy in head and neck cancer.

Relationship between tumour cell in vitro radiosensitivity and clinical outcome after curative radiotherapy for squamous cell carcinoma of the head and neck

BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE

Clinically, it is recognized that individual tumours respond differently to radiation treatment. Variation in tumour cell radiosensitivity is believed to be an important underlying factor. In the current study, cellular in vitro radiosensitivity was estimated as the fraction of surviving cells after a radiation dose of 2 Gy (SF2) and related to clinical outcome after curative radiotherapy.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

Thirty-eight patients with squamous cell carcinoma of the head and neck were treated with curative radiotherapy alone. Pre-treatment biopsies were disaggregated to form a single-cell suspension and cells were cultured in the modified Courtenay-Mills soft agar clonogenic assay. Directly from this assay and with no respect to cell type, overall SF2 was assessed. By collecting the obtained colonies on a preparation slide using a colony-filter technique, and with immunocytochemical staining, it was possible to measure the surviving fraction of tumour cells selectively as tumour cell SF2.

RESULTS

Experimentally, a broad inter-tumour variation was found for both tumour cell SF2 and overall SF2. Using weighted linear regression, it was demonstrated that tumour cell SF2 and overall SF2 were two independent measures of tumour radiosensitivity. In general, the measures of tumour radiosensitivity were independent of patient sex and age, T- and N-category, disease stage, tumour size and plating efficiency. Among the 38 patients grouped in loco-regional failures and patients with loco-regional control, respectively, sex, age, total radiation dose, overall treatment time and tumour grade were equally distributed. Advanced stage, lymph node involvement and tumour size correlated statistically significantly with poor loco-regional control. Neither tumour cell SF2, overall SF2, nor plating efficiency predicted loco-regional tumour control probability. In a multivariate analysis with respect to the risk of loco-regional tumour failure, only disease stage yielded independent prognostic significance. This significance suggests that this patient sample was representative for the patient population with head and neck cancer.

CONCLUSION

In 38 patients with squamous cell carcinoma of the head and neck, the estimated tumour radiosensitivities were not statistically related to clinical outcome after curative radiotherapy alone.

[Tumor and individual radiosensitivity. An introduction]

This text is intended to introduce the following articles, which correspond to the lectures given at the "Radiosensitivity" session of the 1998 SFRO Meeting. We first underline the somewhat disappointing results obtained so far for evaluating tumoral radiosensitivity. However, a few new tests could bring some hope in a not-too distant future. We then focus on individual radiosensitivity. We first list the syndromes or diseases associated with a known hyperradiosensitivity. We then concentrate on the radiosensitivity tests that are available in 1998, some of them being already used in a few centers in specific situations. However, the "optimal" test is still to be identified. After a brief chapter on the possible modulations of radiosensitivity, we conclude with a few recommendations to the clinician.

[Tumor radiosensitivity tests: state of assays in 1998]

Various assays measuring tumor radiosensitivity were developed in the early eighties. These assays were based on cell cultures derived from tumor biopsies. In most studies there was no correlation between measured radiosensitivity and treatment outcome. New assays using new techniques (such as measurement of radiation-induced apoptosis, or fluorescence in situ hybridization) have been developed recently. Preliminary results are encouraging, but correlation with treatment outcome is expected to be difficult to demonstrate as multivarious clinical and biological parameters are involved in loco-regional control.