Partitioning of peptides and recombinant protein-peptide fusions in thermoseparating aqueous two-phase systems: effect of peptide primary structure

Thermoseparating aqueous two-phase systems: Recent trends and mechanisms

Having the benefits of being environmentally friendly, providing a mild environment for bioseparation, and scalability, aqueous two-phase systems (ATPSs) have increasingly caught the attention of industry and researchers for their application in the isolation and recovery of bioproducts. The limitations of conventional ATPSs give rise to the development of temperature-induced ATPSs that have distinctive thermoseparating properties and easy recyclability. This review starts with a brief introduction to thermoseparating ATPSs, including its history, unique characteristics and advantages, and lastly, key factors that influence partitioning. The underlying mechanism of temperature-induced ATPSs is covered together with a summary of recent applications. Thermoseparating ATPSs have been proven as a solution to the demand for economically favorable and environmentally friendly industrial-scale bioextraction and purification techniques.

Aqueous two-phase extraction for protein recovery from corn extracts

Corn has been used as an expression host for several recombinant proteins with potential for large-scale production. Cost-effective downstream initial recovery, separation and concentration remain a challenge. Aqueous two-phase (ATP) partitioning has been used to recover and concentrate proteins from fermentation broths and offers advantages for integration of those steps with biomass removal. To examine the applicability of ATP partitioning to recombinant protein purification from corn endosperm and germ, ATP system parameters including poly(ethylene glycol) (PEG) molecular weight (MW), phase-forming salt, tie line length (TLL), and pH were manipulated to control partitioning of extracted native proteins from each fraction. Moderate PEG MW, reduction of phase ratio, and added NaCl effected complete recovery of the hydrophobic model protein lysozyme in the top phase with ca. 5x enrichment and illustrates a favorable match of recombinant protein characteristics, expression host, and separation method. Furthermore, integration of protein extraction with the partitioning reduced the load of contaminating host proteins relative to the more traditional separate steps of extraction followed by partitioning. Performance of the integrated partitioning was hindered by endosperm solids loading, whereas for germ, which has ca. 35x higher aqueous soluble protein, the limit was protein solubility. For more hydrophilic model proteins (the model being cytochrome c), effective separation required further reduction of PEG MW to effect more partitioning of host proteins to the top phase and enrichment of the model protein in the lower phase. The combination of PEG MW of 1450 with 8.5 wt.% NaCl addition (Na(2)SO(4) as the phase-forming salt) provided for complete recovery of cytochrome c in the lower phase with enrichment of 9x (germ) and 5x (endosperm). As a result of lower-phase recovery, the advantage of simultaneous removal of solids is lost. The lower solubility of native endosperm proteins results in higher purity for the same enrichment.

Hydrophobic peptide tags as tools in bioseparation

Hydrophobic interactions are highly selective, and differences in surface hydrophobicities between proteins can be used as an efficient handle to facilitate protein isolation. Aromatic amino acid residues are of particular importance for molecular recognition because they have a key role in several biological functions. The hydrophobicity of a protein can easily be altered with minor genetic modifications, such as site-directed mutagenesis or fusions of hydrophobic peptide tags. An important advantage of hydrophobic peptide tags over traditional affinity tags is the possibility of exploring simple and inexpensive bioseparation materials. Recent results demonstrate the potential of hydrophobic interaction chromatography and aqueous two-phase systems as tools to study relative hydrophobicities of recombinant proteins with only minor alterations. This review focuses on hydrophobic peptide tags as fusion partners, which can be used as important tools in bioseparation.

Pilot-scale extraction of an intracellular recombinant cutinase from E. coli cell homogenate using a thermoseparating aqueous two-phase system

A thermoseparating aqueous two-phase system for extraction of a recombinant cutinase fusion protein from Escherichia coli homogenate has been scaled up to pilot scale. The target protein ZZ-cutinase-(WP)(4) was produced in a fed batch process at 500 l to a concentration of 12% of the total protein and at a cell concentration of 19.7 g l(-1). After harvest and high-pressure homogenisation a first extraction step was performed in an EO(50)PO(50) (50% (w/w) ethylene oxide and 50% (w/w) propylene oxide) thermopolymer/amylopectin rich Waxy barley starch system. The (WP)(4) tag was used for enhanced target protein partitioning to the EO(50)PO(50) phase while the cell debris was collected in the starch phase. A second extraction step followed where the recovered EO(50)PO(50) phase from the first step was supplemented with a non-ionic detergent (C(12-18)EO(5)) and heated to the cloud point (CP) temperature (45 degrees C). One polymer-rich liquid phase and one almost pure aqueous phase were formed. The target protein could be obtained in a water phase after the thermal phase separation at a total recovery over the extraction steps of 71% and a purification factor of 2.5. We were able to demonstrate that a disk-stack centrifugal separator could be adapted for rapid separation of both primary and thermoseparated phase systems.

Tryptophan-tagged cutinase studied by steady state fluorescence for understanding of tag interactions in aqueous two-phase systems

Genetic engineering has been used to construct fusion proteins of Fusarium solani pisi cutinase and tryptophan-based tags, expressed in Saccharomyces cerevisiae, to increase the partitioning in aqueous two-phase systems. The separation systems were composed of thermoseparating polymers (random copolymers of ethylene oxide and propylene oxide, EOPO) and detergents (C(12)EO(n)). In this study, the fluorescence behaviour of the peptide-tagged protein, free peptide tag and tryptophan was investigated. The tryptophan-tagged proteins, cutinase-(WP)(4) and cutinase-TGGSGG-(WP)(4), showed emission spectra similar to the free peptides and tryptophan, indicating solvent exposure of the tag. The influence of polymers and detergents on the fluorescence of tagged proteins was examined. When peptides and tagged proteins were exposed to polymer, a slight blue shift of the emission maximum was observed. Larger blue shifts of the emission maximum were observed when C(12)EO(n) detergents were utilised. The results correlate with aqueous two-phase partitioning where addition of C(12)EO(n) detergents results in more extreme partitioning compared to systems containing only polymers. Dynamic light scattering (DLS) measurements of the EOPO copolymers were carried out, showing that the polymers did not aggregate at concentrations used in aqueous two-phase systems. Quenching of fluorescence with iodide for both proteins and peptide tags was studied. Plots according to the Stern-Volmer equation resulted in a linear fit, indicating exposed tryptophan residues for both free peptides and fusion proteins. The quenching constants were similar for both tagged protein and free peptide tag. The fluorescence results indicated that the tryptophan residues in the tag were exposed to the solvent and could interact with detergents and polymers in the two-phase systems.

Partitioning of peptide-tagged proteins in aqueous two-phase systems using hydrophobically modified micelle-forming thermoseparating polymer

Genetic engineering has been used to construct hydrophobically modified fusion proteins of cutinase from Fusarium solani pisi and tryptophan-containing peptides. The aim was to enhance the partitioning of the tagged protein in a novel aqueous two-phase system formed by only one water-soluble polymer. The system was based on a hydrophobically modified random copolymer of ethylene oxide (EO) and propylene oxide (PO) units, HM-EOPO, with myristyl groups (C(14)H(29)) at both ends. The HM-EOPO polymer is strongly self-associating and has a lower critical solution temperature (cloud point) at 12 degrees C in water. At temperatures above the cloud point a two-phase system is formed with a water top phase and a polymer-enriched bottom phase. By adding a few percent of hydroxypropyl starch polymer, Reppal PES 200, to the system, it is possible to change the densities of the phases so the HM-EOPO-enriched phase becomes the top phase and Reppal-enriched phase is the bottom phase. Tryptophan-based peptides strongly preferred the HM-EOPO rich phase. The partitioning was increased with increasing length of the peptides. Full effect of the tag as calculated from peptide partitioning data was not found in the protein partitioning. When a short spacer was introduced between the protein and the tag the partitioning was increased, indicating a better exposure to the hydrophobic core of the polymer micelle. By adding a hydrophilic spacer between the protein and trp-tag, it was possible to increase the partitioning of cutinase 10 times compared to wild-type cutinase partitioning. By lowering the pH of the system and addition of NaCl, the partitioning of tagged protein was further increased towards the HM-EOPO phase. After isolating the HM-EOPO phase, the temperature was increased and the protein was back-extracted from the HM-EOPO phase to a fresh water phase.

Improved partitioning in aqueous two-phase system of tyrosine-tagged recombinant lactate dehydrogenase

The partitioning of Bacillus stearothermophilus lactate dehydrogenase (LDH) in an aqueous two-phase system was studied. Particularly, the influence of tyrosine tags on the partitioning was evaluated. The hydrophobic effect, caused by the addition of tyrosine residues, was determined in a system based on dextran and the thermoseparating ethylene oxide-propylene oxide random copolymer (EO30PO70). Five different LDH variants were constructed with N-terminal tags containing tyrosines (Y3 and Y6), tyrosines and prolines (Y3P2 and Y6P2), and only prolines (P2). LDH fused with tags containing tyrosines increased the partitioning coefficient, and the more tyrosines added to the protein, the larger improvement in partitioning. When prolines were added between the tyrosine-rich tag and the protein, a further increased partitioning was obtained. The enhanced partitioning was attributed to the rigid structure of the proline, which in turn led to an increase in the exposure of the tag to the surroundings. The best tyrosine tag, Y6P2, increased the partition coefficient four times and additionally, a higher thermostability was observed.

Primary recovery of a genetically engineered Trichoderma reesei endoglucanase I (Cel 7B) fusion protein in cloud point extraction systems

Here we present data to demonstrate how partitioning of a hydrophilic enzyme can be directed to the hydrophobic detergent-enriched phase of an aqueous two-phase system by addition of short stretches of amino acid residues to the protein molecule. The target enzyme was the industrially important endoglucanase I, EGI (endo-1,4-beta-D-glucan-4-glucanohydrolase, EC 3.2.1.4, Cel7B) of Trichoderma reesei. We investigated the partitioning of three EGI variants containing various C-terminal peptide extensions including Trp-Pro motifs of different lengths and localizations. Additionally, a recently developed system composed of the thermoseparating copolymer HM-EOPO was utilized to study the effects of fusion tags. The addition of peptides containing tryptohan residues enhanced the partitioning of EGI to the HM-EOPO-rich phase. The system composed of a nonionic detergent (Agrimul NRE1205) resulted in the highest partition coefficient (K = 31) and yield (90%) with the construct EGI(core-P5)(WP)(4) containing (Trp-Pro)(4) after a short linker stretch. A recombinant strain of T. reesei Rut-C30 for large-scale production was constructed in which the fusion protein EGI(core-P5)(WP)(4) was expressed from the strong promoter of the cellulase gene cbh1. The fusion protein was successfully expressed and secreted from the fungus during shake-flask cultivations. Cultivation in a 28-L bioreactor however, revealed that the fusion protein is sensitive to proteases. Consequently, only low production levels were obtained in large-scale production trials.

The surface exposed amino acid residues of monomeric proteins determine the partitioning in aqueous two-phase systems

It is of great interest and importance how different amino acid residues contribute to and affect the properties of a protein surface. Partitioning in aqueous two-phase systems has the potential to be used as a rapid and simple method for studying the surface properties of proteins. The influence on partitioning of the surface exposed amino acid residues of eight structurally determined monomeric proteins has been studied. The proteins were characterized in terms of surface exposed residues with a computer program, Graphical Representation and Analysis of Surface Properties (GRASP), and partitioned in two EO30PO70-dextran aqueous two-phase systems, only differing in polymer concentrations (system I: 6.8% EO30PO70, 7.1% dextran; system II: 9% EO30PO70, 9% dextran). We show for the first time that the partitioning behaviour of different monomeric proteins can be described by the differences in surface exposed amino acid residues. The contribution to the partition coefficient of the residues was found to be best characterized by peptide partitioning in the aqueous two-phase system. Compared to hydrophobicity scales available in the literature, each amino acid contribution is characterized by the slope given by the graph of log K against peptide chain length, for peptides of different length containing only one kind of residue. It was also shown that each amino acid contribution is relative to the total protein surface and the other residues on the surface. Surface hydrophobicity calculations realized for systems I and II gave respectively correlation coefficients of 0.961 and 0.949 for the linear relation between log K and calculated hydrophobicity values. To study the effect on the partition coefficient of different amino acids, they were grouped into classes according to common characteristics: the presence of an aromatic group, a long aliphatic chain or the presence of charge. Using these groups it was possible to confirm that aromatic residues have the strongest effect on the partition coefficient, giving preference to the upper EO30PO70 phase of the system; on the other hand the presence of charged amino acids on the protein surface enhances the partition of the protein to the lower dextran phase. It is also important to note that the sensitivity of the EO30PO70-dextran system for the surface exposed residues was increased by increasing the polymer concentrations. The partition coefficient of a monomeric protein can thus be predicted from its surface exposed amino acid residues and the system can also be used to characterize protein surfaces of monomeric proteins in general.

Cutinase-peptide fusions in thermoseparating aqueous two-phase systems. Prediction of partitioning and enhanced tag efficiency by detergent addition

It is of increasing importance to develop efficient purification methods for recombinant proteins where the number of steps can be minimised. The aim has been to establish a method for predicting the partitioning of the wild-type target protein in an aqueous two-phase system, and with this as basis, develop fusion tags and optimise the phase system for enhanced partitioning of the target protein. The surface of the lipolytic enzyme cutinase from Fusarium solani pisi was investigated with a computer program, Graphical Representation and Analysis of Surface Properties (GRASP). The accessible surface areas for the different amino acid residues were used together with peptide partitioning data to calculate the partition coefficient for the protein. The separation system was composed of a thermoseparating random copolymer of ethylene oxide and propylene oxide. Breox PAG 50A 1000, as top phase forming polymer and a hydroxypropyl starch polymer, Reppal PES 200, as bottom phase polymer. The calculated partition coefficient for the wild-type protein (K= 1.0) agreed reasonably well with the experimentally determined value (K=0.85). Genetic engineering was used to construct fusion proteins expressed in Saccharomyces cerevisiae based on cutinase and peptide tags containing tryptophan, to enhance the partitioning in aqueous two-phase systems. The partitioning of the cutinase constructs could qualitatively be predicted from peptide partitioning data, i.e. the trends in partitioning could be predicted. A spacer peptide introduced between protein and tag increased the partitioning of the protein towards the ethylene oxide-propylene oxide (EOPO) copolymer top phase. The aqueous two-phase system was modified by addition of detergent to increase the partitioning of the cutinase variants towards the EOPO copolymer phase. Triton and a series of C12En detergents selectively increased the partitioning of cutinase constructs with (WP)4-based tags up to 14 times compared to wild-type cutinase. The protein partition could almost quantitatively be predicted from the peptide partition data.

Functional selection of phage displayed peptides for facilitated design of fusion tags improving aqueous two-phase partitioning of recombinant proteins

Aqueous two-phase systems allow for the unequal distribution of proteins and other molecules in water-rich solutions containing phase separating polymers or surfactants. One approach to improve the partitioning properties of recombinant proteins is to produce the proteins as fused to certain peptide tags. However, the rational design of such tags has proven difficult since it involves a compromise between multivariate parameters such as partitioning properties, solvent accessibility and production/secretion efficiency. In this work, a novel approach for the identification of suitable peptide tag extensions has been investigated. Using the principles of selection, rather than design, peptide sequences contributing to an improved partitioning have been identified using phage display technology. A 40 million member phagemid library of random nona-peptides, displayed as fusion to the major coat protein pVIII of the filamentous phage M13, was employed in the selection of top-phase partitioning phage particles in a PEG/sodium phosphate system. After multiple cycles of selection by partitioning, peptides with high frequencies of both tyrosine and proline residues were found to be over represented in selected clones. The identified peptide sequences, or derivatives thereof, were subsequently individually analyzed for their partitioning behavior as displayed on phage, as free synthetic peptides and as genetically fused to a recombinant model target protein. The results showed that novel peptide sequences capable of enhancing top-phase partitioning without interfering with protein production and secretion indeed could be identified for the aqueous two-phase system investigated.

Genetic engineering of the Trichoderma reesei endoglucanase I (Cel7B) for enhanced partitioning in aqueous two-phase systems containing thermoseparating ethylene oxide--propylene oxide copolymers

Endoglucanases (endo-1,4-beta-D-glucan-4-glucanohydrolase, EC 3.2.1.4) are industrially important enzymes. In this study endoglucanase I (EGI or Cel7B) of the filamentous fungi Trichoderma reesei has been genetically engineered to investigate the influence of tryptophan rich peptide extensions (tags) on partitioning in an aqueous two-phase model system. EGI is a two-domain enzyme and is composed of a N-terminal catalytic domain and a C-terminal cellulose binding domain, separated by a linker. The aim was to find an optimal tag and fusion position, which further could be utilised for large scale extractions. Peptide tags of different length and composition were attached at various localisations of EGI. The fusion proteins were expressed from T. reesei with the use of the gpdA promoter from Aspergillus nidulans. Variations in secreted levels between the engineered proteins were obtained. The partitioning of EGI in an aqueous two-phase system composed of a thermoseparating ethylene oxide-propylene oxide random copolymer (EO(50)PO(50)) and dextran, could be significantly improved by relatively minor genetic engineering. The (Trp-Pro)(4) tag added after a short stretch of the linker, containing five proline residues, gave in the highest partition coefficient of 12.8. The yield in the top phase was 94%. The specific activity was 83% of the specific activity of unmodified EGI on soluble substrate. The efficiency of a tag fused to a protein is shown by the tag efficiency factor (TEF). A hypothetical TEF of 1.0 would indicate full tag exposure and optimal contribution to the protein partitioning by the fused tag. The location of the fusion point after the sequence of five proline residues in the linker of EGI is the most beneficial in two-phase separation. The highest TEF (0.97) was obtained with the (Trp-Pro)(2) tag at this position, indicating full exposure and intactness of the tag. However, the peptide tag composed of (Trp-Pro)(4) improved the partition properties the most but had lower TEF in comparison to (Trp-Pro)(2).

Genetically engineered peptide fusions for improved protein partitioning in aqueous two-phase systems. Effect of fusion localization on endoglucanase I of Trichoderma reesei

Genetic engineering has been used for fusion of the peptide tag, Trp-Pro-Trp-Pro, on a protein to study the effect on partitioning in aqueous two-phase systems. As target protein for the fusions the cellulase, endoglucanase I (endo-1,4-beta-Dglucan-4-glucanohydrolase, EC 3.2.1.4, EGI, Cel7B) of Trichoderma reesei was used. For the first time a glycosylated two-domain enzyme has been utilized for addition of peptide tags to change partitioning in aqueous two-phase systems. The aim was to find an optimal fusion localization for EGI. The peptide was (1) attached to the C-terminus end of the cellulose binding domain (CBD), (2) inserted in the glycosylated linker region, (3) added after a truncated form of EGI lacking the CBD and a small part of the linker. The different constructs were expressed in the filamentous fungus T. reesei under the gpdA promoter from Aspergillus nidulans. The expression levels were between 60 and 100 mg/l. The partitioning behavior of the fusion proteins was studied in an aqueous two-phase model system composed of the thermoseparating ethylene oxide (EO)-propylene oxide (PO) random copolymer EO-PO (50:50) (EO50PO50) and dextran. The Trp-Pro-Trp-Pro tag was found to direct the fusion protein to the top EO50PO50 phase. The partition coefficient of a fusion protein can be predicted with an empirical correlation based on independent contributions from partitioning of unmodified protein and peptide tag in this model system. The fusion position at the end of the CBD, with the spacer Pro-Gly, was shown to be optimal with respect to partitioning and tag efficiency factor (TEF) was 0.87, where a fully exposed tag would have a TEF of 1.0. Hence, this position can further be utilized for fusion with longer tags. For the other constructs the TEF was only 0.43 and 0.10, for the tag fused to the truncated EGI and in the linker region of the full length EGI, respectively.

Substitutions of surface amino acid residues of cutinase probed by aqueous two-phase partitioning

The surface properties of a protein are often crucial for recognition and interaction with other molecules. Important functional residues can be identified by mutational analysis. There is a need for rapid methods to study protein surfaces and surface changes due to mutations. Partitioning in aqueous two-phase systems has the potential to be used in this respect since protein partitioning depends on the surface properties of the protein. The influence of surface-exposed amino acid residues in protein partitioning has been studied with cutinase variants, which differed in one or several amino acid residues as a result of site-directed mutagenesis. The solvent accessibility of the mutated residues was determined with a computer program, Graphical Representation and Analysis of Surface Properties. The aqueous two-phase system was composed of dextran and a random copolymer of ethylene oxide and propylene oxide. It was shown, for the first time, to what extent surface-exposed amino acid residues influence the partition coefficient in an aqueous two-phase system. The effect on partitioning could be described only taking into account solvent accessibility and type of residue substitution. The results demonstrate that the system can be used to detect conformational changes in mutant proteins since the expected effect on partitioning due to a mutation can be calculated. The aqueous two-phase system used here does indeed provide a rapid and convenient method to study protein surfaces and slight surface changes due to mutations.