Rett syndrome--a review and discussion of syndrome delineation and syndrome definition

Clinical and biological progress over 50 years in Rett syndrome

In the 50 years since Andreas Rett first described the syndrome that came to bear his name, and is now known to be caused by a mutation in the methyl-CpG-binding protein 2 (MECP2) gene, a compelling blend of astute clinical observations and clinical and laboratory research has substantially enhanced our understanding of this rare disorder. Here, we document the contributions of the early pioneers in Rett syndrome (RTT) research, and describe the evolution of knowledge in terms of diagnostic criteria, clinical variation, and the interplay with other Rett-related disorders. We provide a synthesis of what is known about the neurobiology of MeCP2, considering the lessons learned from both cell and animal models, and how they might inform future clinical trials. With a focus on the core criteria, we examine the relationships between genotype and clinical severity. We review current knowledge about the many comorbidities that occur in RTT, and how genotype may modify their presentation. We also acknowledge the important drivers that are accelerating this research programme, including the roles of research infrastructure, international collaboration and advocacy groups. Finally, we highlight the major milestones since 1966, and what they mean for the day-to-day lives of individuals with RTT and their families.

Phenotype Differentiation of FOXG1 and MECP2 Disorders: A New Method for Characterization of Developmental Encephalopathies

OBJECTIVE

To differentiate developmental encephalopathies by creating a novel quantitative phenotyping tool.

STUDY DESIGN

We created the Developmental Encephalopathy Inventory (DEI) to differentiate disorders with complex multisystem neurodevelopmental symptoms. We then used the DEI to study the phenotype features of 20 subjects with FOXG1 disorder and 11 subjects with MECP2 disorder.

RESULTS

The DEI identified core domains of fine motor and expressive language that were severely impaired in both disorders. Individuals with FOXG1 disorder were overall more severely impaired. Subjects with FOXG1 disorder were less able to walk, had worse fine motor skills, more disability in receptive language and reciprocity, and had more disordered sleep than did subjects with MECP2 disorder (P <.05). Covariance, cluster, and principal component analysis confirmed a relationship between impaired awareness, reciprocity, and language in both disorders. In addition, abnormal ambulation was a first principal component for FOXG1 but not for MECP2 disorder, suggesting that impaired ambulation is a strong differentiating factor clinically between the 2 disorders.

CONCLUSIONS

We have developed a novel quantitative developmental assessment tool for developmental encephalopathies and propose this tool as a method to identify and illustrate core common and differential domains of disability in these complex disorders. These findings demonstrate clear phenotype differences between FOXG1 and MECP2 disorders.

Rett Syndrome Turns 50: Themes From a Chronicle: Medical Perspectives and the Human Face of Rett Syndrome

BACKGROUND

Fifty years ago Andreas Rett first described in great detail what came to be known as "Rett syndrome." Understanding girls and women with this syndrome and their families helped in many ways to revolutionize modern neurodevelopmental medicine. For some people the identification of the genetic underpinning of the syndrome and the ongoing biological research into this condition represented the peak of the scientific accomplishments in Rett syndrome. For others, it was developments in clinical research methodologies that were especially important. Above all, the patient- and family-oriented empathetic and collaborative approach to care by professionals collaborating with families has led to immense achievements, both scientific and humanistic.

AIM

The aim of this narrative was to describe the medical and personal life story of a young woman with Rett syndrome and to offer a history that highlights developments in the unraveling of this condition from its initial recognition to our current understanding.

CONCLUSION

We believe that much can be learned from the humanistic style of care provision combined with the best possible level of assisted autonomy and life enjoyment of the young woman with Rett syndrome. In addition, the approach to collaborative research by dedicated and often charitable leaders in the field can teach us many important lessons about the ethics of clinical and health services research.

Atypical presentations and specific genotypes are associated with a delay in diagnosis in females with Rett syndrome

There is often delay between onset of Rett syndrome symptoms and its diagnosis, possibly related to symptom presentation or socio-demographic factors. We hypothesized that girls with an atypical presentation or whose family had a lower socio-economic status would receive a later diagnosis. Female subjects with a confirmed diagnosis of Rett syndrome were sourced from the Australian Rett Syndrome and InterRett Databases. Variables analyzed included timing and development of symptoms; MECP2 mutation type; parental occupation and education; maternal age and birth order. Residential location and socio-economic status were also analyzed for the Australian cases. Linear regression was used to determine relationships between these factors and age at diagnosis. A total of 909 cases were included. An older age of diagnosis was associated with later loss of hand function and speech, later onset of hand stereotypies and the presence of the p.R133C or p.R294X MECP2 mutation. Socio-economic factors did not predict age of diagnosis for Australian families. For families participating in the InterRett database, a younger age of diagnosis was associated with higher levels of parental education or occupation. A clinical picture consistent with the classic presentation of Rett syndrome is associated with an earlier diagnosis. Clinicians need to be alerted to the variable presentation of Rett syndrome including the milder phenotypes of cases with the p.R133C or p.R294X mutation. Educational resources to assist this understanding including guidance on when to request genetic testing could be useful to streamline the process of diagnosis in Rett syndrome.

Trisomy 21 and Rett syndrome: a double burden

Rett syndrome is a severe neurodevelopmental disorder generally affecting girls. Affected individuals are apparently normal at birth but later pass through a period of regression with loss of hand and communication skills and the development of hand stereotypies and dyspraxia. Mutations in the methyl-CpG binding protein 2 (MECP2) gene, have now been found to cause Rett syndrome in up to 80% of classical cases. We report a girl with Down syndrome, one of three children with birth defects in a family of five. From the age of 18 months she developed symptomatology considered by her primary physician to be very characteristic of Rett syndrome. However, this remained a clinical diagnosis till the age of 12 years. Laboratory confirmation of the dual diagnosis, which includes a R168X mutation in the MECP2 gene in addition to trisomy 21, has now been possible. The presence of one neurological or developmental disorder does not necessarily preclude a diagnosis of Rett syndrome.

Describing the phenotype in Rett syndrome using a population database

BACKGROUND

Mutations in the MECP2 gene have been recently identified as the cause of Rett syndrome, prompting research into genotype-phenotype relations. However, despite these genetic advances there has been little descriptive epidemiology of the full range of phenotypes.

AIMS

To describe the variation in phenotype in Rett syndrome using four different scales, by means of a population database.

METHODS

Using multiple sources of ascertainment including the Australian Paediatric Surveillance Unit, the development of an Australian cohort of Rett syndrome cases born since 1976 has provided the first genetically characterised population based study of Rett syndrome. Follow up questionnaires were administered in 2000 to families and used to provide responses for items in four different severity scales.

RESULTS

A total of 199 verified cases of Rett syndrome were reported between January 1993 and July 2000; 152 families provided information for the follow up study. The mean score using the Kerr scale was 22.9 (SD 4.8) and ranged from 20.5 in those under 7 years to 24.2 in those over 17 years. The mean Percy score was 24.9 (SD 6.6) and also increased with age group from 23.0 to 26.9. The mean Pineda score was 16.3 (SD 4.5) and did not differ by age group. The mean WeeFIM was 29.0 (SD 11.9), indicating extreme dependence, and ranged from 18 to 75.

CONCLUSION

We have expanded on the descriptive epidemiology of Rett syndrome and shown different patterns according to the severity scale selected. Although all affected children are severely functionally dependent, it is still possible to identify some variation in ability, even in children with identified MECP2 mutations.

Clinical manifestations and stages of Rett syndrome

The presentation and clinical diagnosis of Rett syndrome at various ages and stages are reviewed. In addition to the classical form, variability in phenotype between different atypical Rett forms is given. Obligatory, supportive, and differential diagnostic criteria are summarized. Long-term follow-up findings in ageing Rett women are addressed.

Importance of Rett syndrome in child neurology

The syndrome of brain atrophy in girls described by Andreas Rett in 1966 [Rett, Wien Klin Wochenschr, 1966;116:723-726] was brought to the attention of the English-speaking world by Hagberg et al. in 1983 [Hagberg et al., Ann Neurol, 1983;14:471-479]. Four clinical stages after the age of 6 months were described in classical cases of Rett syndrome (RS), namely early onset stagnation at 6 months to 1(1/2) years, the rapid destructive stage at 1-3 years, the pseudo-stationary stage from pre-school to school years, and the late motor deterioration stage at 15-30 or more years. The rapid destructive stage causes profound dementia with loss of speech and hand skills, stereotypic movements, ataxia, apraxia, irregular breathing with hyperventilation while awake, and frequently seizures. Most cases are isolated in their families, apart from identical twins. However, linkage studies in rare familial cases suggested a critical region at Xq28. In 1999 American investigators found several mutations in the X-linked gene MECP2 encoding Methyl-CpG-binding protein 2 in a proportion of Rett patients. The protein MeCP2 can bind methylated DNA and when mutated may interfere with transcriptional silencing of other genes and result in abnormal chromatin assembly. Many different mutations of the protein are being studied in humans and in mice. Neuropathological studies have shown decreased brain growth and decreased size of individual neurons, with thinned dendrites in some cortical layers, and abnormalities in substantia nigra, suggestive of deficient synaptogenic development, probably starting before birth. Electrophysiology demonstrates progressively abnormal electroencephalograms (EEG) in the first three stages of the syndrome, with some subsequent improvement and occurrence of pseudoseizures. Neurometabolic factors are discussed in detail, particularly reduced levels of dopamine, serotonin, noradrenaline and choline acetyltransferase (ChAT) in brain, also estimation of nerve growth factors, endorphin, substance P, glutamate and other amino acids and their receptor levels. Autonomic dysfunction is described, particularly reduced vagal and overactive sympathetic activity. Neuro-imaging may be required for further investigation, as shown in the differential diagnosis.

Metacarpophalangeal pattern profile and bone age in Rett syndrome: further radiological clues to the diagnosis

Hand radiographs of 100 girls representing 73% of the known Australian population of girls with Rett syndrome, age 20 years or less, were available for this study. Control radiographs were matched for age, sex, and laterality. Bone age was assessed against standard radiographs in Greulich and Pyle [1959: Radiographic Atlas of Skeletal Development of the Hands and Wrist, 2nd ed.]. A metacarpophalangeal pattern (MCPP) profile comparing the relative lengths of the hand bones with mean population norms by age was produced by converting the length of each of the 19 metacarpal and phalangeal bones into a Z score. In girls less than 15 years old, bone age was more advanced in Rett syndrome than in age-matched control girls (left hand P = 0.03, right hand 0.004), but was most advanced in the younger group and normalized with age. In Rett syndrome, the mean Z score for the 19 metacarpal and phalangeal bones was 1.0 in children under 5 years, -0.27 in those aged 5-11 years, and -1.7 in those aged 12 years and over. This variation between age groups was much greater than in the controls. The dips in the MCPP profile occurred at MC2 and D1, and the peaks at M5, P5, and M4. An MCPP profile may provide an additional aid to diagnosis in cases of Rett syndrome where all the criteria are not met, but in children under age 5 years, advanced bone age may be more helpful as a marker.

Diagnosis of Rett syndrome: can a radiograph help?

Rett syndrome (RS), a neurodevelopmental disorder almost exclusively affecting girls, is associated with severe intellectual and motor disability. In the absence of biological markers, diagnosis is determined by a set of clinical criteria. In a previous study in Scotland, shortening of the fourth metatarsal was reported clinically in 20% of classical RS cases aged 5 years or older. The Australian Rett Syndrome Study database has facilitated a population-based radiological study of the hands and feet of girls with RS. Straight radiographs of hands and feet were available from 94 cases, representing 70.1% of the known RS population in Australia. Control radiographs were matched for age, sex, and laterality. Relative shortening of the fourth metacarpal/metatarsal was assessed using the sign method. A short ulna (negative ulna variance) was defined as the distal articular surface of the ulna being at least 5mm proximal to the distal articular surface of the radius. A positive metacarpal sign was twice as common in verified cases of RS than in controls in the right but not the left hand. A short ulna was more common in subjects with RS than in controls. A short fourth metatarsal was also more common among subjects with RS. More than half (56.6%) the girls with RS over the age of 4 years had a negative ulnar variance in either wrist or a metatarsal sign in either foot. These findings will assist with the diagnosis of RS and may help direct research towards the location of the molecular defect.

Skeletal abnormalities in Rett syndrome: increasing evidence for dysmorphogenetic defects

The presence of metatarsal and metacarpal abnormalities in some individuals has raised the possibility that Rett syndrome is, in fact, a multiple congenital abnormalities/mental retardation (MCA/MR) syndrome. We have conducted radiological examination of 17 cases of Rett syndrome in Western Australia. Short fourth and/or fifth metatarsals were identified in 65% of cases and short fourth and/or fifth metacarpals in 57%. Metatarsal (P = 0.045) and metacarpal (P = 0.006) shortness were significantly more common in girls 14 years or older. Negative ulnar variance (found in 79% of cases) appeared to be independent of age. Reduced bone density in the hands was found in 86% of cases. A nationwide study using the Australian Rett Syndrome Database is planned to follow up these findings and compare them with findings from a control group. The confirmation of these abnormalities in a high proportion of cases may provide morphologic markers to assist in the diagnosis of Rett syndrome and perhaps provide a further avenue of research into the pathogenesis of this disorder.

Neuropathology of Rett syndrome: case report with neuronal and mitochondrial abnormalities in the brain

Neuronal changes in the brain of a Rett syndrome patient were examined in a frontal lobe biopsy performed at age 3 years and in the postmortem brain at age 15 years. In the brain biopsy, frontal cortex contained numerous scattered pyramidal neurons with cytoplasmic vacuolation and increased cytoplasmic density, with no neuronophagia or inflammation detected; electron microscopy showed these neurons to have large, lucent-appearing mitochondria, very abundant ribosomal content, and some lipofuscin granules. Postmortem brain 12 years later showed scattered neurons in frontal cortex, substantia nigra, and cerebellar folia, with increased electron density of the cytoplasm, stacks of ribosomal endoplasmic reticulum, and large amounts of disorganized membranous material, including autophagic-type organelles. Mitochondria of these neurons contained electron-dense, finely granular matrix inclusions; in the substantia nigra, some spherical mitochondrial inclusions completely filled the matrix space. Golgi preparations of (autopsy) frontal cortex and cerebellar folia showed truncation and thickening of dendrites and a degenerate appearance of cortical pyramidal neurons, similar to changes found in aged brain. Synaptophysin immunohistochemistry indicated that the density of synapses was not greatly altered compared to controls in frontal cortex and cerebellum. The patient also had a second genetic defect, severe combined immunodeficiency with thymic aplasia, which may be X-linked.

Rett syndrome: a review of current knowledge

Rett syndrome was first described in 1966 by Andreas Rett. To date, this syndrome has been reported only to afflict females. The disorder is characterized by a progressive loss of cognitive and motor skills as well as the development of stereotypic hand movements, occurring after an apparently normal 6 to 18 months of development. Although Rett syndrome is thought to afflict as many as 10,000 girls in the United States, fewer than 1,200 have been identified thus far. A lack of awareness of this disorder is thought to play a critical role in the failure to differentially diagnose this syndrome. The present article presents a review of our current knowledge concerning this disorder. Information is provided related to the clinical manifestations, etiology, prevalence, pathogenesis, and treatment of the Rett syndrome.

Is classical Rett syndrome ever present in males?

This paper is a case history which describes a male child who meets most of the Trevathan and Naidu criteria for the Rett syndrome (RS). If RS is possible in males, this has implications for genetic and metabolic research regarding the etiology of the syndrome, particularly studies related to the X chromosome. Further case studies need to be published and independently evaluated.

Research on Rett syndrome: strategy and preliminary results

The research strategy presented here involves four assumptions: (1) Rett syndrome exists; (2) a single cause will eventually be found to account for the majority of cases presently assigned to this disease category; (3) it is genetically determined; and (4) it represents a neurodegenerative disorder that can be defined by quantitative studies of nervous system structure and function. The strategy proposed here involves the comprehensive study of 100 patients with the classic Rett syndrome phenotype. Studies include the (1) search for a diagnostic marker; (2) high-resolution cytogenetic banding techniques, (3) quantitative morphologic studies of postmortem brain tissue as well as neurochemical analyses including autoradiographic techniques, radioimmunoassays, and in situ hybridization; and (4) positron emission tomography studies of cerebral glucose metabolism and neurotransmitters.

Practical and theoretical considerations concerning the genetics of the Rett syndrome

The Rett syndrome is exclusively found in girls. Considerable interest has been focused on a possible genetic background. The evidence for such an etiology is not conclusive and the findings in support of such a hypothesis are given. The few twin data and family data together with the chromosomal investigation indicate an X-linked inheritance. The recurrence risk in a family with one Rett girl is about 0.3%. Prenatal diagnosis is not recommended for the time being, as the only diagnosis, possible is prenatal sexing and most girls are healthy as the recurrence risk is low.

Rett syndrome: epidemiology and nosology--progress in knowledge 1986--a conference communication

Recent progress from pooled clinical experience is reviewed. The approximate number of documented cases of Rett syndrome (RS) as of October 1986 was 1,100. Three sister pairs, 3 monozygotic twin pairs (both twin girls affected), 3 dizygotic twin pairs (one twin girl affected) are known. Genetics are discussed based on these and other known occurrences. Early seizure-onset variants have been reported in a dozen cases representing various countries. Approximately 20 incomplete RS related cases, also termed "formes frustes," are documented as of October 1986. An actual Swedish series of 66 classical RS, 4 "formes frustes," 2 early seizure-onset variants and 9 other clinically near related atypical cases is summarized. A suggested late stage IV spinal cord impairment is discussed, as well as the whole adult multifacetted complex neurological pattern. Gastrointestinal pathology is discussed with reference to possible generalized neuropeptide disturbances.