Three-dimensional echocardiography: the influence of number of component images on accuracy of left ventricular volume quantitation

Valid and Reproducible Quantitative Assessment of Cardiac Volumes by Echocardiography in Patients with Valvular Heart Diseases-Possible or Wishful Thinking?

The analysis of left ventricular function is predominantly based on left ventricular volume assessment. Especially in valvular heart diseases, the quantitative assessment of total and effective stroke volumes as well as regurgitant volumes is necessary for a quantitative approach to determine regurgitant volumes and regurgitant fraction. In the literature, there is an ongoing discussion about differences between cardiac volumes estimated by echocardiography and cardiac magnetic resonance tomography. This viewpoint focuses on the feasibility to assess comparable cardiac volumes with both modalities. The former underestimation of cardiac volumes determined by 2D and 3D echocardiography is presumably explained by methodological and technical limitations. Thus, this viewpoint aims to stimulate an urgent and critical rethinking of the echocardiographic assessment of patients with valvular heart diseases, especially valvular regurgitations, because the actual integrative approach might be too error prone to be continued in this form. It should be replaced or supplemented by a definitive quantitative approach. Valid quantitative assessment by echocardiography is feasible once echocardiography and data analysis are performed with methodological and technical considerations in mind. Unfortunately, implementation of this approach cannot generally be considered for real-world conditions.

Agreement between cardiac outputs by four-dimensional echocardiography and thermodilution method is poor

OBJECTIVE

The objective of the study was to determine the agreement of cardiac output (CO) measured by four-dimensional echocardiography (4D echo) to simultaneously obtain CO from pulmonary artery catheter (PAC) using thermodilution technique.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Sixty-three comparable readings from 27 patients scheduled for elective coronary artery bypass were included. All echocardiographic measurements were obtained by one experienced echocardiographer. All echo images were analyzed independently and blinded from PAC-obtained measurements. Analysis was primarily done by Bland and Altman plot. The collected data were further controlled for interobserver bias and image quality.

RESULTS

Differences in CO measurements increased with higher CO, hence values were logarithmically transformed. On the logaritmic scale, the 4D echo underestimated CO by 0.37 l/min compared with PAC, indicating that PAC measurements were 1.45 times higher than the 4D echo (95% confidence interval 1.32-1.52) and limits of agreement 0.97-2.14). The interobserver bias of 4D echo measurement analysis was 0.29 l/min (95% confidence interval 0.16-0.42) and limits of agreement -0.8-1.38). No difference was seen in image quality between comparisons with good agreement compared with comparisons with poor agreement.

CONCLUSION

The agreement between COs by 4D echo and standard PAC thermodilution technique was poor. 4D echo underestimates CO as compared with PAC. This is most likely caused by the analysis software or low frame rate inherent to the technique.

Relative importance of errors in left ventricular quantitation by two-dimensional echocardiography: insights from three-dimensional echocardiography and cardiac magnetic resonance imaging

BACKGROUND

The accuracy of left ventricular (LV) volumes and ejection fraction (EF) on two-dimensional echocardiography (2DE) is limited by image position (IP), geometric assumption (GA), and boundary tracing (BT) errors.

METHODS

Real-time three-dimensional echocardiography (RT3DE) and cardiac magnetic resonance imaging (CMR) were used to determine the relative contribution of each error source in normal controls (n = 35) and patients with myocardial infarctions (MIs) (n = 34). LV volumes and EFs were calculated using (1) apical biplane disk summation on 2DE (IP + GA + BT errors), (2) biplane disk summation on RT3DE (GA + BT errors), (3) 4-multiplane to 8-multiplane surface approximation on RT3DE (GA + BT errors), (4) voxel-based surface approximation on RT3DE (BT error alone) and (5) CMR. By comparing each method with CMR, the absolute and relative contributions of each error source were determined.

RESULTS

IP error predominated in LV volume quantification on 2DE in normal controls, whereas GA error predominated in patients with MIs. Underestimation of volumes on 2DE was overcome by increasing the number of imaging planes on RT3DE. Although 4 equidistant image planes were acceptable, the best results were achieved with voxel-based RT3DE. For EF estimation, IP error predominated in normal controls, whereas BT error predominated in patients with MIs. Nevertheless, one third of the EF estimation error in patients with MIs was due to a combination of IP and GA errors, both of which may be addressed using RT3DE.

CONCLUSIONS

The relative contribution of each source of LV quantitation error on 2DE was defined and quantified. Each source of error differed depending on patient characteristics and LV geometry.

Three-dimensional echocardiographic analysis of left ventricular function during hemodialysis

BACKGROUND

The effects of hemodialysis (HD) on left ventricular (LV) function have been studied by various echocardiographic techniques (M-mode, 2D echocardiography). These studies are hampered by a low accuracy of measurements because of geometric assumptions regarding LV shape. Three-dimensional echocardiography (3DE) overcomes this limitation.

METHODS

We tested the feasibility of 3DE assessment of LV function during HD. Conventional biplane Simpson rule (BSR) and single plane area length method (SPM) for LV function analysis were used as a reference.

RESULTS

12 HD patients were studied and in 10 (83%) a total of 80 3D datasets were acquired. In 3 patients, one dataset (4%) was of insufficient quality and excluded from analysis. Correlation between SPM, BSR and 3DE for calculation of end-diastolic (EDV, r = 0.89 and r = 0.92, respectively), end-systolic volume (ESV, r = 0.92 and r = 0.93, respectively) and for ejection fraction (EF, r = 0.90 and r = 0.88, respectively) was moderate. Limits-of-agreement results for EDV and ESV were poor with confidence intervals larger than 30 ml. Both 2DE methods underestimated end-diastolic and end-systolic volume, while overestimating ejection fraction.

CONCLUSION

3DE is feasible for image acquisition during HD, which opens the possibility for accurate and reproducible measurement of LV function during HD. This may improve the assessment of the acute effect of HD on LV performance, and guide therapeutic strategies aimed at preventing intradialytic hypotension.

Real-time three-dimensional echocardiography: a pilot feasibility study in an Italian cardiologic center

BACKGROUND

The majority of studies demonstrating the diagnostic potential of three-dimensional (3-D) echocardiography have been conducted on selected series of patients in research laboratories.

AIM

To investigate the feasibility and usefulness of real-time 3-D transthoracic echocardiography in daily routine practice.

METHODS

Two hundred consecutive patients underwent standard two-dimensional (2-D) transthoracic echocardiography (TTE) and real-time (RT) 3-D TTE with a commercially available ultrasound system (Sonos 7500 LIVE 3D, Philips Medical Systems). The quality of 3-D acquisitions and post-processed images was graded as: bad, satisfactory, good and demo. In each case, the results of 3-D TTE were compared with 2-D images to disclose additional qualitative information provided by 3-D examination. An additional qualitative information score was given for each cardiac structure.

RESULTS

The mean time of the 3-D examination was 11+/-4 min. The mean time of 2-D transthoracic studies in our laboratory is 25 min and the total time in this series was therefore approximately 36 min. The mean number of acquisitions in our series was 11.5 per patient. The quality was evaluated as bad/insufficient in 7.0%, satisfactory/sufficient in 29.6%, good in 40.2% and demo in 23.2% of all datasets and reconstructions. The structures with greater additional qualitative information scores comprise the anterior and posterior mitralic leaflets, antero-lateral and postero-medial papillary muscles and leaflets of tricuspid valve. The intra- and interobserver reproducibility of quality grading was good and there are few interobserver discrepancies, which were resolved by two physicians, experienced in 3-D echocardiography, not involved in the study.

CONCLUSIONS

RT 3-D TTE may be used in clinical settings with high feasibility rate and may provide additional, clinically quite relevant qualitative information. This technique may expand the abilities of non-invasive cardiology and open new doors for the evaluation of cardiac disease.

Rapid and Accurate Measurement of Left Ventricular Function with a New Second-Harmonic Fast-Rotating Transducer and Semi-Automated Border Detection

Measurement of left ventricular (LV) volume and function are the most common clinical referral questions to the echocardiography laboratory. A fast, practical, and accurate method would offer important advantages to obtain this important information. To validate a new practical method for rapid measurement of LV volume and function. We developed a continuous fast-rotating transducer, with second-harmonic capabilities, for three-dimensional echocardiography (3DE). Fifteen cardiac patients underwent both 3DE and magnetic resonance imaging (reference method) on the same day. 3DE image acquisition was performed during a 10-second breath-hold with a frame rate of 100 frames/sec and a rotational speed of 6 rotations/sec. The individual images were postprocessed with Matlab software using multibeat data fusion. Subsequently, with these images, 12 datasets per cardiac cycle were reconstructed, each comprising seven equidistant cross-sectional images for analysis in the new TomTec 4DLV analysis software, which uses a semi-automated border detection (ABD) algorithm. The ABD requires an average analysis time of 15 minutes per patient. A strong correlation was found between LV end-diastolic volume (r = 0.99; y = 0.95x - 1.14 ml; SEE = 6.5 ml), LV end-systolic volume (r = 0.96; y = 0.89x + 7.91 ml; SEE = 7.0 ml), and LV ejection fraction (r = 0.93; y = 0.69x + 13.36; SEE = 2.4%). Inter- and intraobserver agreement for all measurements was good. The fast-rotating transducer with new ABD software is a dedicated tool for rapid and accurate analysis of LV volume and function.

Three-Dimensional Echocardiography: Rational Mode of Component Images for Left Ventricular Volume Quantitation

Three-dimensional echocardiography (3DE) improves the accuracy of left ventricle (LV) volumetry compared with the two-dimensional echocardiography (2DE) approach because geometric assumptions in the algorithms may be eliminated. The relationship between accuracy of mode (short- versus long-axis planimetry) and the number of component images versus time required for analysis remains to be determined. Sixteen latex models simulating heterogeneously distorted (aneurysmatic) human LVs (56-303 ml; mean 182+/-82 ml) were scanned from an 'apical' position (simultaneous 2DE and 3DE). For 3DE volumetry, the slice thickness was varied for the short (C-scan) and long axes (B-scan) in 5-mm steps between 1 and 25 mm. The mean differences (true-echocardiographic volumes) were 16.5+/-44.3 ml in the 2DE approach (95% confidence intervals -27.8 to +60.8) and 0.6+/-4.0 ml (short axis; 95% confidence intervals -3.4 to +4.6) as well as 2.1+/-9.9 ml (long axis; 95% confidence intervals -7.8 to +12.0) in the 3DE approach (in both cases, the slice thickness was 1 mm). Above a slice thickness of 15 mm, the 95% confidence intervals increased steeply; in the short versus long axes, these were -6.5 to +8.5 versus -7.0 to +10.6 at 15 mm and -10.1 to +15.7 versus -11.3 to +10.9 at 20 mm. The intra-observer variance differed significantly (p<0.001) only above 15 mm (short axis). Time required for analysis derived by measuring short-axis slice thicknesses of 1, 15, and 25 mm was 58+/-16, 7+/-2 and 3+/-1 min, respectively. The most rational component image analysis for 3DE volumetry in the in vitro model uses short-axis slices with a thickness of 15 mm.

Freehand Three-Dimensional Echocardiography with Rotational Scanning for Measurements of Left Ventricular Volume and Ejection Fraction in Patients with Coronary Artery Disease

BACKGROUND

Measurement of left ventricular (LV) volumes and ejection fraction (EF) is important in managing patients with coronary artery disease (CAD). Introduction of free-hand three-dimensional echocardiography (3DE) system which is equipped with small magnetic tracking system and average rotational geometry for LV volumes may provide easy and accurate quantification of LV systolic function in CAD patients.

PURPOSE

To evaluate the feasibility and accuracy of LV volumes and EF measurement by free-hand 3DE with rotational geometry in patients with CAD.

METHODS AND RESULTS

The study subjects consisted of consecutive 25 patients with CAD who were scheduled for quantitative gated single-photon emission computed tomography (QGS). LV end-diastolic volume (EDV), end-systolic volume (ESV), and EF were determined by conventional two-dimensional echocardiography (2DE), 3DE, and QGS. Three-dimensional echocardiography data acquisition and analysis were possible in 22 of 25 subjects (feasibility 88%). In this 3DE system, image acquisition time was 2 minutes, and 5 minutes were needed for off-line analysis of LV volumes and EF. Correlations and the limits of agreement between 3DE and QGS (r = 0.97, 0.0 +/- 9.1 ml for EDV, r = 0.99, 0.0 +/- 5.0 ml for ESV, and r = 0.97, 0.5 +/- 3.3% for EF, respectively) were superior to those between 2DE and QGS (r = 0.85, 12.6 +/- 26.8 ml for EDV, r = 0.85, 9.7 +/- 26.1 ml for ESV, and r = 0.90, -1.3 +/- 6.9% for EF, respectively). Inter- and intra-observer variabilities of 3DE were smaller than that of 2DE (5% vs 10%, 5% vs 10% for EDV, 6% vs 13%, 5% vs 9% for ESV, and 4% vs 11%, 4% vs 6% for EF, respectively).

CONCLUSION

Three-dimensional echocardiography using magnetic tracking system and average rotational geometry offered a feasible and accurate method for quantification of LV volumes and EF in patients with CAD.

Usefulness of real-time three-dimensional echocardiography for reliable measurement of cardiac output in patients with ischemic or idiopathic dilated cardiomyopathy

The determination of stroke volume (SV) is a potentially important application of real-time 3-dimensional echocardiography (RT3DE). SV measurements by thermodilution were compared with values obtained using transthoracic RT3DE in a sequential cohort of patients who underwent assessment for potential cardiac transplantation. There was a strong correlation between echocardiographically derived SV and catheterization data (r = 0.95, n = 14). On average, RT3DE appeared to underestimate SV by 7.5 ml (SD = 5.8) or 17% (SD = 12%). A role for RT3DE in the measurement of SV in severe heart failure is suggested.

Accuracy of measurement of left ventricular volume and ejection fraction by new real-time three-dimensional echocardiography in patients with wall motion abnormalities secondary to myocardial infarction

Three-dimensional echocardiography is an ideal tool for the measurement of left ventricular (LV) volume because no geometric assumptions about LV shape are needed. The introduction of new real-time 3-dimensional echocardiography (RT3DE) has allowed rapid acquisition of a 3-dimensional dataset with good image quality. The purpose of this study was to examine the accuracy of RT3DE for the measurement of LV volume and ejection fraction in patients with wall motion abnormalities by using quantitative gated single-photon emission computed tomography (QGSPECT) as a reference standard. The study population consisted of 25 consecutive patients with wall motion abnormalities who underwent LV volume measurement by 2-dimensional echocardiography and by QGSPECT. LV volume and ejection fraction by RT3DE were measured offline by using the average rotation method. In 23 of 25 patients (92%), it was possible to measure 3-dimensional volume with RT3DE. RT3DE correlated well with QGSPECT in the measurement of end-diastolic volume and end-systolic volume (r = 0.97, mean difference 3.4 ml; r = 0.98, mean difference 2.0 ml, respectively), 2-dimensional echocardiography also correlated with QGSPECT but underestimated LV volume (r = 0.98, mean difference 21.1 ml; r = 0.98, mean difference 15.6 ml, respectively). Ejection fraction obtained by RT3DE had better agreement with that obtained by QGSPECT than that obtained by 2-dimensional echocardiography (r = 0.92, mean difference -0.2%; r = 0.89, mean difference -2.7%, respectively). RT3DE allows convenient and accurate estimation of LV volume and ejection fraction in patients with wall motion abnormalities.

Pointwise assessment of three-dimensional computer reconstruction of mitral leaflet surfaces from rotationally scanned echocardiograms in vitro

Three-dimensional transesophageal echocardiography offers promise for improved understanding of mitral leaflet pathology, but it has not been validated quantitatively, nor has the minimum number of imaging planes for satisfactory reconstruction been determined with a rotational scanning geometry. This study assessed its accuracy in vitro by comparing, on a 1 x 1-mm grid, the surfaces of mitral leaflets derived from 5-degree rotational ultrasonic scans with those derived from laser scans of casts of the atrial side of the leaflets. Overall, the ultrasonically derived surface had a mean absolute deviation of 0.65 +/- 0.12 mm from the laser-derived surface. Using only alternate imaging planes (10-degree increments) made no significant difference in the overall distribution of deviations (P =.56), although the distributions on some individual specimens differed markedly. We conclude that 5-degree rotational scanning in vitro can reconstruct the mitral valve leaflets with sufficient accuracy and detail to render clinically important features.

Measurement of left ventricular volumes by 3-dimensional echocardiography with tissue harmonic imaging: a comparison with magnetic resonance imaging

We hypothesized that tissue harmonic imaging (THI) in comparison with fundamental imaging (FI) would improve endocardial border detection, and therefore in combination with 3-dimensional echocardiography (3D echo), it would be a precise method for left ventricular (LV) volume measurement. Ten healthy subjects and 18 consecutive patients with dilated hearts underwent estimation of LV volumes by magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) and transthoracic 3D echo with THI and FI. In patients, the agreement between MRI and 3D echo was closer with THI in comparison with FI for assessment of LV volumes. Thus the mean +/- 2 SD of differences between MRI and 3D echo with THI versus FI, respectively, was -6.4 +/- 40.0 mL versus -17.4 +/- 57.6 mL (P <.01) for the end-diastolic volume (EDV), and 0.0 +/- 26.6 mL versus -8.1 +/- 35.6 mL (P <.01) for the end-systolic volume (ESV). In patients, THI in comparison with FI approximately halved observer variation on EDV and ESV. In healthy subjects, only ESV showed significantly reduced observer variation by THI. In conclusion, because THI demonstrated a clinically relevant reduction in observer variation and a closer agreement to the MRI technique in patients with dilated hearts, it should replace FI in LV volume measurements.

Accuracy of three-dimensional echocardiography with unrestricted selection of imaging planes for measurement of left ventricular volumes and ejection fraction

BACKGROUND

Accurate, reproducible, noninvasive determination of left ventricular (LV) volumes and ejection fraction (EF) is important for clinical assessment, risk stratification, selection of therapy, and serial monitoring of patients with cardiovascular disease. Three-dimensional echocardiography (3DE) approaches have demonstrated significantly greater accuracy than current clinical 2DE, but the clinical utility of 3DE has been limited because of the need for substantial modifications to scanning technique (eg, all image acquisition from a single acoustic window) or cumbersome additional hardware. We describe a novel 3DE system without these limitations and its application to patients.

METHODS AND RESULTS

Twenty-five patients were examined by 3DE, 2DE, and magnetic resonance imaging (MRI). The 3DE system used a magnetic scanhead tracking device, and volumes were computed with a novel deformable shell model. End-diastolic volumes and EF by MRI ranged from 96 to 375 mL and 18% to 73%, respectively. There was excellent correlation, without statistically significant differences, between MRI and 3DE for end-systolic volume (ESV) (r(2) = 0.99) and end-diastolic volume (EDV) (r(2) = 0.98), ventricular stroke volume (SV) (r(2) = 0.93), and EF (r(2) = 0.97), with standard error estimates less than 10 mL for volumes and 3% for EF. Conventional 2DE consistently underestimated volumes (EDV, P <.01; ESV, P <.01; SV, P <.05); correlations with MRI were r(2) = 0.91 for ESV, r(2) = 0.88 for EDV, r(2) = 0.62 for SV, and r(2) = 0.72 for EF. Standard error estimates ranged from 16 to 20 mL for ventricular volumes and 9% for EF. Interobserver variability was reduced 3-fold with use of 3DE.

CONCLUSIONS

The novel 3DE system allows unrestricted selection and combination of acoustic windows in a single examination, improves accuracy of estimates of LV volumes and EF 3-fold compared with 2DE, and is practical for routine clinical assessment of LV size and function in patients with a wide range of cardiac pathology.

Optimal rotational interval for 3-dimensional echocardiography data acquisition for rapid and accurate measurement of left ventricular function

BACKGROUND

Prolonged 3-dimensional echocardiography (3DE) acquisition time currently limits its routine use for calculating left ventricular volume (LVV) and ejection fraction (EF). Our goal was to reduce the acquisition time by defining the largest rotational acquisition interval that still allows 3DE reconstruction for accurate and reproducible LVV and EF calculation.

METHODS

Twenty-one subjects underwent magnetic resonance imaging and precordial 3DE with 2 degrees acquisition intervals. Images were processed to result in data sets containing images at 2 degrees, 4 degrees, 8 degrees, 16 degrees, 32 degrees, and 64 degrees intervals by excluding images in between. With use of the paraplane feature, 8 equidistant short-axis slices were generated from each data set. The suitability of these short-axis slices for manual endocardial tracing was scored visually by 4 independent experienced observers. The LVV and EF were calculated by using Simpson's rule from 3DE data sets with 2 degrees, 8 degrees, and 16 degrees intervals, and the results were compared with values obtained from magnetic resonance imaging. The probability of 3DE to detect LVV and EF differences was calculated.

RESULTS

All patients were in sinus rhythm with a mean heart rate of 72 bpm (SD + or - 12). The LV short-axis images obtained with 16 degrees rotational scanning intervals allowed LV endocardial tracing in all subjects. Good correlation, close limits of agreement, and nonsignificant differences were found between values of LVV and EF calculated with 3DE at 2 degrees, 8 degrees, and 16 degrees rotational intervals and those obtained with magnetic resonance imaging. At steps of 16 degrees, 3DE had excellent correlation (r = 98, 99, and 99), close limits of agreement (+ or - 38, + or - 28.6, and + or - 4.8), and nonsignificant differences (P =.5,.8, and.2) with values obtained from magnetic resonance imaging for calculating end-diastolic LVV, end-systolic LVV, and EF, respectively. Three-dimensional echocardiography with use of 16 degrees rotational intervals could detect 15-mL differences in end-diastolic volume with a probability of 95%, 11-mL differences in end-systolic volume with a probability of 92%, and 0.02 differences in EF with a probability of 95%.

CONCLUSIONS

The 3DE data sets reconstructed with images selected at 16 degrees intervals from data sets obtained at 2 degrees precordial rotational acquisition intervals allowed the generation of LV short-axis images with adequate quality for endocardial border tracing. Therefore precordial acquisition at 16 degrees intervals would be sufficient for the reconstruction of 3DE data sets for LV function measurement. This would reduce the acquisition time while maintaining enough accuracy for clinical decision making and would thus make 3DE more practical as a routine method.

Influence of echocardiographic scan plane location and number on the accuracy of three-dimensional left ventricular volume and shape determination

Quantitative 3-dimensional (3-D) echocardiography provides accurate assessment of left ventricular (LV) volume, shape, and function, but depends on manual endocardial border tracing. This study determined the minimal number of borders that need to be traced to obtain an accurate analysis of not only the volume of the left ventricle but also its shape, using the integrated methods for quantitative 3-D echocardiography developed by our laboratory. Transthoracic 3-D echocardiographic studies were obtained in 9 normal subjects and 6 patients with heart disease by freehand scanning. The LV endocardium was manually traced in 17 +/- 5 imaging planes and reconstructed in 3 dimensions. The volume and shape of each reconstruction were compared with values measured from surfaces reconstructed from 8 subsets containing 2 to 7 borders; each subset was acquired from different combinations of spatially distributed parasternal and apical views. Accurate measurements were obtained from data sets having > or = 5 borders, regardless of whether the image planes were predominantly apical or parasternal views. In conclusion, the LV border should be traced in > or = 5 imaging planes to obtain accurate measurements of volume and shape. The piece-wise smooth reconstruction method and freehand scanning using a magnetic field tracing system allow the borders to be acquired from whatever combination of acoustic windows and views provides optimal image quality.

Evolving era of multidimensional medical imaging

Currently, computer-assisted imaging can visualize very fast or very slow nonvisible motion events. We can create measurable geometric representations of physiology, including transformation, blood flow velocity, perfusion, pressure, contractility, image features, electricity, metabolism, and a vast number of other constantly changing parameters. The greatest attribute is the ability to present physiologic phenomena as easily understood geometric images more suited to the human's four-dimensional comprehension of reality. The key research challenges are to discover new visual metaphors for representing information, understand the analysis tasks that they support, and associate relevant information to create new information.

Paraplane analysis from precordial three-dimensional echocardiographic data sets for rapid and accurate quantification of left ventricular volume and function: a comparison with magnetic resonance imaging

OBJECTIVES

Three-dimensional echocardiography (3DE) calculates left ventricular volumes (LVV) and ejection fraction (EF) without geometric assumptions, but prolonged analysis time limits its routine use. This study was designed to validate a modified 3DE method for rapid and accurate LVV and EF calculation compared with magnetic resonance imaging (MRI).

METHODS

Forty subjects included 15 normal volunteers (group A) and 25 patients with segmental wall motion abnormalities and global hypokinesis caused by ischemic heart disease (group B) who underwent 3DE with precordial rotational acquisition technique (2-degree interval with electrocardiographic and respiratory gating) and MRI at 0.5 T, electrocardiogram (ECG)-triggered multislice multiphase T1-weighted fast field echo. End-diastolic and end-systolic LVV and EF were calculated from both techniques with Simpson's rule by manual endocardial tracing of equidistant parallel left ventricular short-axis slices. Slicing from the 3DE data sets were done by both 2.9-mm slice thickness (method 3DE-A) and by 8 equidistant short-axis slices (method 3DE-B); for MRI analysis, 9-mm slice thickness was used.

RESULTS

Analysis time required for manual endocardial tracing of end-diastolic and end-systolic short-axis slices was 10 minutes for the 3DE-B method compared with 40 minutes by the 3DE-A method. For all 40 subjects the mean +/- SD of end-diastolic LVV (mL) were 181 +/- 76, 179 +/- 73, and 182 +/- 76; for end-systolic LVV (mL), 120 +/- 76, 120 +/- 75, and 122 +/- 77; and for EF (%), 39 +/- 18, 38 +/- 18, and 38 +/- 18 for MRI, 3DE-A, and 3DE-B methods, respectively. The differences between 3DE-A and 3DE-B with MRI for calculating end-diastolic and end-systolic LVV and EF were not significant for the whole group of subjects as well as for the subgroups. The 3DE-B method had excellent correlation and close limits of agreement with MRI for calculating end-diastolic and end-systolic LVV and EF: r = 0.98 (-1.3 +/- 26.6), 0.99 (-1.6 +/- 21. 2), and 0.99 (0.2 +/- 5.2), respectively. The correlation between 3DE-A and MRI were r = 0.97, 0.98, and 0.98, and the limits of agreement were -1.4 +/- 36, -0.6 +/- 26, and 0.6 +/- 8 for calculating end-diastolic and end-systolic LVV and EF, respectively. In addition, excellent correlation and close limits of agreement between 3DE-A and 3DE-B with MRI for LVV and EF calculation was also found for the subgroups. Intraobserver and interobserver variability (SEE) of MRI for calculating end-diastolic and end-systolic LVV and EF were 6.3, 4.7, and 2.1; and 13.6, 11.5, and 4.7; respectively, whereas that for 3DE-B were 3.1, 4.4, and 2.2; and 6.2, 3.8, and 3. 6; respectively. Comparable observer variability was also found for the A and B subgroups.

CONCLUSIONS

The 3DE-A and 3DE-B methods have excellent correlation and close limits of agreement with MRI for calculating LVV and EF in both normal subjects and cardiac patients. The 3DE-B method by paraplane analysis with 8 equidistant short-axis slices has observer variability similar to MRI and reduces the 3DE analysis time to 10 minutes, therefore offering a rapid, reproducible, and accurate method for LVV and EF calculation.

Relation between the number of image planes and the accuracy of three-dimensional echocardiography for measuring left ventricular volumes and ejection fraction

The relation between accuracy of 3-dimensional echocardiography (3DE) in determining left ventricular end-diastolic volume, end-systolic volume, and ejection fraction (compared with magnetic resonance imaging) and the number of component planes used for 3DE ventricular reconstruction was evaluated in 41 adult subjects with normal (n = 24) and abnormal (n = 17) left ventricles. Accuracy and confidence of 3DE gradually increased with use of additional component planes, so that > or = 10 planes from both parasternal and apical windows provided 3DE reconstructions that accurately predict magnetic resonance imaging-measured left ventricular volumes and ejection fraction with confidence.

Estimation of the right ventricular volume and ejection fraction by transthoracic three-dimensional echocardiography. A validation study using magnetic resonance imaging

AIMS

To validate the use of three-dimensional transthoracic echocardiography compared with the magnetic resonance imaging for determination of right ventricular volume and ejection fraction.

METHODS AND RESULTS

We recorded transthoracic echocardiographic images starting from the apical four-chamber view in which the RV is clearly visualized in 15 healthy volunteers. The scanning plane of the RV was obtained by the rotational scanning technique in 2 degree angular increments for three-dimensional reconstruction. The RV volumes in end-diastole and end-systole were calculated using a Tomtec three-dimensional reconstruction computer. We also assessed the RV by cine magnetic resonance imaging using the Siemens Magnetom Impact Expert (1.0 T). Cine gradient echo images were obtained in the short axis of the RV. The RV volume at each phase was calculated by Simpson's method. We also calculated the RV ejection fraction. The RV volumes in end-diastole and end-systole were 111 +/- 22 ml and 52 +/- 13 ml, respectively as determined by three-dimensional echo, and 115 +/- 18 ml and 55 +/- 14 ml determined by MRI. The right ventricular volumes at end-diastole and end-systole determined by three-dimensional echo were correlated with the volumes determined by MRI (r = 0.94 and 0.97, respectively, p < 0.001). The RV ejection fraction determined by three dimensional echo was also correlated with the ejection fraction determined by MRI (r = 0.90, p < 0.01).

CONCLUSIONS

Three-dimensional transthoracic echocardiography provided reliable calculations of the right ventricular volume and ejection fraction.

A simplified, practical echocardiographic approach for 3-dimensional surfacing and quantitation of the left ventricle: clinical application in patients with abnormally shaped hearts

The goal of this study was to validate the quantitative accuracy of a system for 3-dimensional (3D) echocardiographic reconstruction of the left ventricle to assess its volume and function in human beings by using 3 apical views as a simplified technique to promote practical clinical application. End-diastolic and end-systolic volumes (EDV, ESV) and ejection fraction (EF) were obtained by 3D echocardiography in 50 patients with dilated or geometrically distorted left ventricles and compared with values from magnetic resonance imaging (20 consecutive patients), angiography (22 consecutive patients), and radionuclide imaging (8 consecutive patients). Three-dimensional results were also compared with 2-dimensional (2D) echocardiographic estimates. Three-dimensional left ventricular reconstruction provided values that correlated and agreed well with pooled data from the other techniques for EDV (y = 0.93x + 9.1, r = 0.95, standard error of the estimate [SEE] = 15.2 mL, mean difference = -0.5 +/- 15.4 mL), ESV (y = 0.94x + 4.3, r = 0. 96, SEE = 11.4 mL, mean difference = 0.4 +/- 11.5 mL), and EF (y = 0. 90x + 4.1, r = 0.92, SEE = 6.2%, mean difference = -0.9 +/- 6.4%) (all mean differences not significant versus 0), with greater errors by 2D echocardiography. Intraobserver and interobserver variabilities of 3D echocardiography were less than 6% for EDV, ESV, and EF. The overall time for image acquisition and 3D reconstruction was 5 to 8 minutes. Although this 3D method uses only a small number of apical views, it accurately calculates EDV, ESV, and EF in patients with dilated and asymmetric left ventricles and is more accurate than 2D echocardiography. The flexible surface fit used to combine the 3 views provides a convenient visual output as well as quantitation. This simple and rapid 3D method has the potential to facilitate routine clinical applications that assess left ventricular function and changes that occur with remodeling.

Three-Dimensional Echocardiography: Precision and Accuracy of Left Ventricular Volume Measurement Using Rotational Geometry with Variable Numbers of Slice Resolution

We developed a new, rapid (6 seconds) acquisition technique allowing collection of approximately six through nine apical rotational tomograms for three-dimensional (3-D) echocardiography. To justify an appropriate sampling density for precise and accurate measurement of chamber volumes in left ventricles with complicated shape, we designed a validation study in vitro using six canine heart specimens with irregular, asymmetric left ventricles with known volumes (28.5 to 104.3 ml; mean, 71.2 ml). The number of equally spaced slices were incrementally deleted from the original high resolution scans (48 slices) to 2 slices in 3-D reconstruction. We created subgroups of 48- and 36-, 24- and 16-, 12- and 8-, 6- and 4-, and 3- and 2-component slices to compare left ventricular (LV) volumes measured in 3-D images with different slice resolution with the reference standard measured in the specimen. The accuracy and precision of LV volume were relatively constant in the subgroup of 4- and 6- through 36- and 48-component slices. When the subgroup with 6- and 4-component slices was used, the correlation was r = 0.991, P < 0.0001, root-mean-square percent error of 5.0%, bias of 0.5 +/- 3.7 ml, and interobserver variability of 5.0%. With the reduction in component slices equal or less than three, the accuracy decreased significantly (root-mean-square percent error = 8.1% and bias = -2.0 +/- 5.7 ml) compared with higher slice resolutions. This study demonstrated that 3-D echocardiography using apical rotational techniques can accurately quantify LV volume in the canine heart specimens with irregular shapes with as few as 4-6 axial slices. The rapid 3-D acquisition technique is therefore anticipated to yield precise and accurate LV volumetry.