Concomitant early appearance of anti-ribonucleoprotein and anti-nucleosome antibodies in lupus prone mice

Exposure to Gold Induces Autoantibodies against Nuclear Antigens in A.TL Mice

To demonstrate causation or/and assess pathogenic mechanisms of environment-induced autoimmunity, various animal models that mimic the characteristics of the human autoimmune diseases need to be developed. Experimental studies in mice reveal the genetic factors that contribute to autoimmune diseases. Here, the immune response of two mouse strains congenic for non-H-2 genes, A.TL (H-2tl) and A.SW (H-2s), was evaluated after 15 weeks' exposure to gold aurothiomalate (AuTM). AuTM-treated A.TL mice showed anti-nuclear antibodies (ANA) with homogenous and/or fine speckled staining patterns and serum autoantibodies to ds-DNA, chromatin, histones, and ribonucleoproteins (RNP). Female A.TL mice showed a stronger immune response than males, as well as an increase of B cells in their spleen after 15 weeks of gold exposure. A.SW exposed for AuTM showed the induction of anti-nucleolar antibodies (ANoA) with a clumpy staining pattern, as well as an increase in splenic B and T cells. The serum autoantibodies levels in A.SW mice were limited compared to those of A.TL mice. Overall, A.TL presents a stronger immune response after gold exposure than A.SW. The immune response developed in A.TL presents similarities with the clinical manifestations in human autoimmune diseases. Thus, gold-exposed A.TL could constitute a potential experimental mouse model for the study of autoimmunity.

The mechanisms and applications of T cell vaccination for autoimmune diseases: a comprehensive review

Autoimmune diseases (ADs) are a spectrum of diseases originating from loss of immunologic self-tolerance and T cell abnormal autoreactivity, causing organ damage and death. However, the pathogenic mechanism of ADs remains unclear. The current treatments of ADs include nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs (NSAIDS), antimalarials, corticosteroids, immunosuppressive drugs, and biological therapies. With the need to prevent side effects resulting from current treatments and acquire better clinical remission, developing a novel pharmaceutical treatment is extremely urgent. The concept of T cell vaccination (TCV) has been raised as the finding that immunization with attenuated autoreactive T cells is capable of inducing T cell-dependent inhibition of autoimmune responses. TCV may act as an approach to control unwanted adaptive immune response through eliminating the autoreactive T cells. Over the past decades, the effect of TCV has been justified in several animal models of autoimmune diseases including experimental autoimmune encephalomyelitis (EAE), murine autoimmune diabetes in nonobese diabetic (NOD) mice, collagen-induced arthritis (CIA), and so on. Meanwhile, clinical trials of TCV have confirmed the safety and efficacy in corresponding autoimmune diseases ranging from multiple sclerosis (MS) to systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE). This review aims to summarize the ongoing experimental and clinical trials and elucidate possible molecule mechanisms of TCV.

The spectrum of anti-chromatin/nucleosome autoantibodies: independent and interdependent biomarkers of disease

Autoantibodies directed to chromatin components date back to the discovery of the LE cell and the LE cell phenomenon circa 1950, and subsequent evidence that major components of that reaction were chromatin components and histones in particular. Over time, immunoassays ranging from ELISA and line immunoassays to more modern bead-based assays incorporated histone and DNA mixtures, purified histones, and purified nucleosomes leading to a more thorough understanding of the genesis and pathogenetic relationships of antibodies to chromatin components in systemic lupus erythematosus and other autoimmune conditions. More recently, interest has focussed on other components of chromatin such as high mobility group (HMG) proteins both as targets of B cell responses and pro-inflammatory mediators. This review will focus on immunoassays that utilize chromatin components, their clinical relationships, and newer evidence implicating HMG proteins and DNA neutrophil extracellular traps (NETs) as important players in systemic autoimmune rheumatic diseases.

Autoantibodies in systemic lupus erythematosus

Systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE) is a multifactorial disorder with multigenic inheritance and various environmental factors implicated in its aetiopathogenesis. Despite the multiple mechanisms involved in the aetiology of SLE being elusive, recent studies have made progress in our understanding of the pathogenic mechanisms via abnormal regulation of cell-mediated and humoral immunity that lead to tissue damage. The heterogeneity of the clinical manifestations probably reflects the complexity of the disease pathogenesis itself. The immune system in SLE is characterised by a complex interplay between overactive B cells, abnormally activated T cells and antigen-presenting cells. This interplay leads to the production of an array of inflammatory cytokines, apoptotic cells, diverse autoantibodies and immune complexes that in turn activate effector cells and the complement system, leading to tissue injury and damage which are the hallmarks of the clinical manifestations. SLE patients have dysregulation of inflammatory cytokines, chemokines and immune response-related genes, as well as of the genes involved in apoptosis, signal transduction and the cell cycle.

Trichloroethylene alters central and peripheral immune function in autoimmune-prone MRL(+/+) mice following continuous developmental and early life exposure

Trichloroethylene (TCE) is a widespread environmental toxicant known to promote CD4(+) T-lymphocyte activation, IFNgamma production, and autoimmunity in adult MRL(+/+) mice. Because developing tissues may be more sensitive to toxicant exposure, it was hypothesized that continuous TCE exposure beginning at conception might induce even more pronounced CD4(+) T-lymphocyte effects and exacerbate the development of autoimmunity in MRL(+/+) mice. In the current study, MRL(+/+) mice were exposed to occupationally-relevant doses of TCE from conception until adulthood (i.e., 7-8 wk-of-age). The CD4(+) T-lymphocyte effects in the thymus and periphery were evaluated, as well as serum antibody levels. TCE exposure altered the number of thymocyte subsets, and reduced the capacity of the most immature CD4-/CD8- thymocytes to undergo apoptosis in vitro. In the periphery, T-lymphocyte IFN(gamma) production was monitored in the blood prior to sacrifice by intracellular cytokine staining and flow cytometry. TCE induced a dose-dependent increase in T-lymphocyte IFN(gamma) as early as 4-5-week-of-age. However, these effects were transient, and not observed in splenic T-lymphocytes in 7-8-week-old mice. In contrast, the serum levels of anti-histone autoantibodies and total IgG(2a) were significantly elevated in the TCE-exposed offspring. The data illustrated that occupationally-relevant doses of TCE administered throughout development until adulthood affected central and peripheral immune function in association with early signs of autoimmunity. Future studies will address the possibility that early-life exposure to TCE may alter some aspect of self tolerance in the thymus, leading to autoimmune disease later in life.

Autoantibodies against complement C1q specifically target C1q bound on early apoptotic cells

Autoantibodies against complement C1q (anti-C1q) are frequently found in patients with systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE). They strongly correlate with the occurrence of severe lupus nephritis, suggesting a pathogenic role in SLE. Because anti-C1q are known to recognize a neoepitope on bound C1q, but not on fluid-phase C1q, the aim of this study was to clarify the origin of anti-C1q by determining the mechanism that renders C1q antigenic. We investigated anti-C1q from serum and purified total IgG of patients with SLE and hypocomplementemic urticarial vasculitis as well as two monoclonal human anti-C1q Fab from a SLE patient generated by phage display. Binding characteristics, such as their ability to recognize C1q bound on different classes of Igs, on immune complexes, and on cells undergoing apoptosis, were analyzed. Interestingly, anti-C1q did not bind to C1q bound on Igs or immune complexes. Neither did we observe specific binding of anti-C1q to C1q bound on late apoptotic/necrotic cells when compared with binding in the absence of C1q. However, as shown by FACS analysis and confocal microscopy, anti-C1q specifically targeted C1q bound on early apoptotic cells. Anti-C1q were found to specifically target C1q bound on cells undergoing apoptosis. Our observations suggest that early apoptotic cells are a major target of the autoimmune response in SLE and provide a direct link between human SLE, apoptosis, and C1q.

Accelerated macrophage apoptosis induces autoantibody formation and organ damage in systemic lupus erythematosus

Increased monocyte/macrophage (Mphi) apoptosis occurs in patients with systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE) and is mediated, at least in part, by an autoreactive CD4(+) T cell subset. Furthermore, autoreactive murine CD4(+) T cells that kill syngeneic Mphi in vitro induce a lupus-like disease in vivo. However, it is unclear whether increased Mphi apoptosis in SLE per se is sufficient to accelerate/promote autoimmunity. We have investigated whether increased Mphi apoptosis in vivo, induced by the administration of clodronate liposomes, can exacerbate the autoimmune phenotype in NZB x SWR (SNF(1)) lupus-prone mice, and induce autoantibody production in haplotype-matched BALB/c x DBA1 (DBF(1)) non-lupus-prone mice. Lupus-prone mice SNF(1) mice that were treated with clodronate liposomes, but not mice treated with vehicle, developed significant increases in autoantibodies to dsDNA, nucleosomes, and the idiotypically related family of nephritic Abs Id(LN)F(1), when compared with untreated SNF(1) mice. Furthermore, clodronate treatment hastened the onset of proteinuria and worsened SNF(1) lupus nephritis. When compared with vehicle-treated controls, clodronate-treated non-lupus-prone DBF(1) mice developed significantly higher levels of anti-nucleosome and Id(LN)F(1) Abs but did not develop lupus nephritis. We propose that Mphi apoptosis contributes to the pathogenesis of autoantibody formation and organ damage through both an increase in the apoptotic load and impairment in the clearance of apoptotic material. This study suggests that mechanisms that induce scavenger cell apoptosis, such as death induced by autoreactive cytotoxic T cells observed in SLE, could play a pathogenic role and contribute to the severity of the disease.

A murine model of mixed connective tissue disease induced with U1 small nuclear RNP autoantigen

OBJECTIVE

To test whether immunizing mice with autoantigens closely linked to mixed connective tissue disease (MCTD) could induce an MCTD-like clinical syndrome distinguishable from systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE).

METHODS

Transgenic and knockout C57BL/6-derived mice were immunized subcutaneously at age 8-12 weeks with U1-70-kd small nuclear RNP (70K) fusion protein along with either Freund's complete adjuvant (CFA) or U1 RNA. After 2 months, mice were killed and analyzed histologically and serologically.

RESULTS

Immunization of C57BL/6-derived mice transgenic for human HLA-DR4 with 70K and either CFA or U1 RNA led to anti-70K antibodies in 62% of mice (21 of 34), and diversified anti-RNP immune responses. MCTD-like lung disease also developed in 50% of immunized mice (17 of 34), and anti-70K antibodies were strongly correlated with lung disease. CFA and U1 RNA were comparably able to induce this syndrome. Mice deficient in Toll-like receptor 3 (TLR-3) also developed this same syndrome when immunized with 70K and CFA. However, TLR-3(-/-) mice failed to develop MCTD-like lung disease when treated with 70K and U1 RNA. Rather, TLR-3(-/-) mice immunized with 70K and U1 RNA developed an autoimmune syndrome characterized by glomerulonephritis typical of SLE.

CONCLUSION

Exposure to 70K in an appropriate context is sufficient to induce autoimmunity and target organ injury consistent with MCTD. This system represents a new model of autoimmune interstitial lung disease, and establishes a closer link between anti-70K immunity and MCTD-like lung disease. Of note, changes in innate immune signaling can cause the same trigger to lead to the development of SLE-like nephritis rather than MCTD-like lung disease.

Toll-like receptor 9 controls anti-DNA autoantibody production in murine lupus

Systemic autoimmune disease in humans and mice is characterized by loss of immunologic tolerance to a restricted set of self-nuclear antigens. Autoantigens, such as double-stranded (ds) DNA and the RNA-containing Smith antigen (Sm), may be selectively targeted in systemic lupus erythematosus because of their ability to activate a putative common receptor. Toll-like receptor 9 (TLR9), a receptor for CpG DNA, has been implicated in the activation of autoreactive B cells in vitro, but its role in promoting autoantibody production and disease in vivo has not been determined. We show that in TLR9-deficient lupus-prone mice, the generation of anti-dsDNA and antichromatin autoantibodies is specifically inhibited. Other autoantibodies, such as anti-Sm, are maintained and even increased in TLR9-deficient mice. In contrast, ablation of TLR3, a receptor for dsRNA, did not inhibit the formation of autoantibodies to either RNA- or DNA-containing antigens. Surprisingly, we found that despite the lack of anti-dsDNA autoantibodies in TLR9-deficient mice, there was no effect on the development of clinical autoimmune disease or nephritis. These results demonstrate a specific requirement for TLR9 in autoantibody formation in vivo and indicate a critical role for innate immune activation in autoimmunity.

Autoantibodies in the Pathogenesis of Mixed Connective Tissue Disease

Antibodies to U1-RNP are part of the clinical definition of mixed connective tissue disease (MCTD). These antibodies and other well-defined antibodies tend to arise together in affected patients. Although still speculative, hypotheses that link U1-RNP antibodies to the development of autoimmunity in MCTD and that associate U1-RNP antibodies with mechanisms of tissue injury in MCTD have emerged and are being tested. Salient features of these hypotheses include: (1) an antigen-driven response that is due to impaired clearance of potentially immunogenic self-antigens, (2) inadequate B- and T-cell tolerance to RNP autoantigens, and (3) immunogenic properties of the RNA component of targeted ribonucleoproteins. Further studies are needed to establish whether anti-RNP antibodies have prognostic importance that is relevant to practicing clinicians.

The Relevance of Autoantigen Source and Cutoff Definition in Antichromatin (Nucleosome) Antibody Immunoassays

In the last few years, several reports have shown that chromatin (nucleosome) represents the main autoantigen-immunogen in systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE) and that specific antibodies are an important marker of the disease. To verify the clinical sensitivity and specificity of antinucleosome autoantibodies (ANuAs), we evaluated three ELISA immunoassay methods using different autoantigen preparations: Quanta Lite Chromatin, Medizym Anti-nucleo, and Nucleosome IgG Elisa. We compared the results with those obtained using two ELISA assays for determining anti-native DNA (anti-nDNA) antibodies: Axis-Shield and EliA dsDNA. We tested sera from 321 patients: 101 with SLE and 220 controls-48 with infectious diseases; 73 with autoimmune rheumatic disease (20 with rheumatoid arthritis, 30 with systemic sclerosis, and 23 with primary Sjögren's syndrome), and 99 healthy subjects. Using the manufacturer-recommended cutoff, the sensitivity for the three kits was 69%, 78%, and 74%, and specificity was 100%, 94.6%, and 95.0%, respectively. Using the cutoff corresponding to 95% specificity, the sensitivity of the methods for the ANuA assay was 86%, 77%, and 74%-higher than obtained with the two ELISA methods for anti-nDNA (65% and 64%). This study demonstrates that (1) the commercial reagents employed in clinical laboratories for ANuA detection show good sensitivity and high specificity; (2) ANuAs are more sensitive than anti-nDNA antibodies for diagnosing SLE; and (3) different solid-phase antigen preparations and methods used to define cutoff levels may affect a test's clinical performance.

Prevalence of autoantibodies against structure specific recognition protein 1 in systemic lupus erythematosus

Antibodies (Abs) against the structure specific recognition protein 1 (SSRP1) were reported in a small systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE) series but not in other systemic autoimmune diseases. The aim of the study was to confirm the selective presence of anti-SSRP1 Abs in a larger SLE series and to evaluate their relationship with disease activity and other immune markers. Anti-SSRP1 Abs were investigated by a 'home made' ELISA in: 120 SLE, 65 rheumatoid arthritis (RA), 51 systemic sclerosis (SSc), 23 Churg-Strauss syndrome (CSS) and 40 idiopathic autoimmune urticaria (IAU) patients and 190 healthy controls. Sera from MRL lpr/lpr and Balb-c mice were also tested. Anti-SSRP1 Abs were detected in 43 SLE (35.8%), nine SSc (17.6%), eight RA (12.3%), six IAU (15%), three CSS (13%) patients and five healthy controls (2.6%). Antibody prevalence and titers were significantly higher in SLE patients than in sera from both normal and disease controls. Anti-SSRP1 Ab activity was also detected in sera from MRL lpr/lpr but not Balb-c mice. The antibodies did not correlate with the disease activity evaluated as the ECLAM index score and were more prevalent in patients without renal involvement. No correlation was found with other serum autoantibodies. Our results confirm that anti-SSRP1 Abs are associated with but not specific for the lupus disease.

Activation and attenuation of apoptosis of CD4+ T cells following in vivo exposure to two common environmental toxicants, trichloroacetaldehyde hydrate and trichloroacetic acid

Exposure to occupationally relevant concentrations of the environmental pollutant, trichloroethylene (TCE), in the drinking water of autoimmune-prone MRL+/+ mice has been shown to promote the generation of lupus and autoimmune hepatitis in association with the activation of Interferon-gamma (IFN-gamma)-producing CD4+ T cells. Since blocking TCE metabolism suppressed the TCE-induced alteration in immune function, the present study was initiated to determine whether the major metabolites of TCE, trichloroacetaldehyde hydrate (TCAH) and trichloroacetic acid (TCA) could also mediate these immunoregulatory affects in vivo. TCAH and TCA were administered to the drinking water of MRL+/+ mice for 4 weeks. CD4+ T cells from TCAH and TCA-treated MRL+/+ mice, unlike CD4+ T cells from control mice, demonstrated functional and phenotypic signs of activation, as evidenced by increased IFN-gamma production in association with the increased percentage of CD62L(lo) CD4+ T cells. Interestingly, it was also found that the CD4+ T cells from the TCAH and TCA-treated mice showed a decreased susceptibility to the activation-induced cell death (AICD) form of apoptosis following re-stimulation in vitro. By demonstrating that TCAH and TCA can activate CD4+ T cells and inhibit their apoptosis following in vivo exposure represents a mechanism by which environmental toxicants may induce or accelerate the development of autoimmune disease.

Nucleosomes in the pathogenesis of systemic lupus erythematosus

Systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE) is characterized by the development of a large array of autoantibodies that primarily are directed against the whole chromatin (antinucleosome) and its individual components, dsDNA and histones. Apoptotic defects and impaired removal of apoptotic cells could contribute to an overload of autoantigens (and in particular of nucleosomes) in circulation or in target tissues that could become available to initiate an autoimmune response. In susceptible individuals, this can lead to autoantibody-mediated tissue damage. In addition to intrinsic or secondary apoptosis/apoptotic cell removal defects, certain apoptotic stimuli (eg, UV, viruses) could lead to posttranscriptional modifications that generate autoantigen cryptic fragments for which cells of the immune system have not been tolerized. Besides their role as a major immunogen in lupus, nucleosomes participate in antibody-mediated renal pathogenicity and act as a bridging molecule that recognizes heparin sulfate/collagen V components of the glomerular basement membrane. New tools that were developed to detect antinucleosome antibodies in the serum of patients (by ELISA) have shown the specificity and the high sensitivity of antinucleosome antibody reactivity in SLE. In particular, antinucleosome could be a useful marker of patients who have SLE and lack anti-dsDNA antibodies, a prognosis marker for imminent relapse, and a diagnosis marker of lupus nephritis.

Requirement of dying cells and environmental adjuvants for the induction of autoimmunity

OBJECTIVE

Cells commonly die without eliciting autoimmunity. However, dying cells are a potential initiating stimulus for systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE). Our goal was to verify whether immune adjuvants influence the autoimmunity induction that ensues following in vivo injection of dying cells.

METHODS

Mice were immunized with apoptotic thymocytes in the presence of artificial moieties, such as Freund's incomplete adjuvant (IFA), or natural adjuvants, such as dendritic cells (DCs). Renal involvement and the development of autoantibodies were monitored.

RESULTS

Apoptotic cells failed to induce clinical disease or to sustain production of autoantibodies in (NZB x NZW)F(1) mice. In contrast, autoimmunity developed in the presence of IFA or DCs. The characteristics of the adjuvant influenced the array of autoantibodies, the kinetics of their development, and the severity of the disease. DCs were required for induction of anti-beta(2)-glycoprotein I IgG. Adjuvants alone did not elicit disease.

CONCLUSION

A "two-hit" signal composed of autoantigens and adjuvants initiates systemic autoimmunity. Moreover, environmental signals at the site of clearance of dead cells shape the features and the severity of the autoimmune disease. Strategies aimed at preventing the accumulation of dying cells and at modulating endogenous adjuvants may be beneficial for the treatment of SLE.

Antinucleosome antibodies in SLE: a two-year follow-up study of 101 patients

We prospectively analyzed the diagnostic sensitivity and specificity as well as the clinical relevance of antinucleosome antibodies in SLE. One hundred and one consecutive SLE patients were followed for 3 years. Three serial serum samples from each patient were tested for antinucleosome antibodies by ELISA (optimum cut-off value 10 U/ml), and for anti-dsDNA antibody (by ELISA and IIF on Crithidia luciliae), and anti-dsDNA avidity (by Scatchard plot analysis). Sera from 100 healthy individuals (HI), 35 patients with systemic sclerosis (SSc), 30 with primary Sjögren's syndrome (SS), 20 with rheumatoid arthritis (RA) and 48 with infectious diseases (ID), were assayed as controls. SLE activity and damage were evaluated using the ECLAM score and the SLICC/ACR index. At baseline, antinucleosome antibodies were found in 87 patients with SLE (86.1%), in 8 patients with SSc (22.8%), in 2 HI (2%), and in 1 ID (2.1%). The sensitivity and specificity of antinucleosome testing for SLE were 86.1% and 95.3%, respectively. The prevalence of antinucleosome antibodies in SLE was significantly higher than that of anti-dsDNA antibodies, with a correlation between them. No relevant relationship was found between antinucleosome antibodies and disease features, including renal involvement, disease activity, and disease damage. During follow-up, no significant variation was observed in antinucleosome level, nor in anti-dsDNA antibody level or avidity. We conclude that antinucleosome antibodies are commonly found in SLE. Low antibody levels can be detected in SSc, whereas medium/high levels are highly specific for SLE. Their clinical relevance during the disease course and utility for monitoring the individual patient seem to be poor.

Accumulation of plasma nucleosomes upon treatment with anti-tumour necrosis factor-alpha antibodies

OBJECTIVE

Patients undergoing anti-tumour necrosis factor-alpha (TNF-alpha) treatment often develop autoantibodies. Apoptotic cell antigens are a potential initiating stimulus for autoantibodies. Our goal was to verify whether anti-cytokine therapy causes the release of nucleosomes, a major autoantigen generated during cell death.

DESIGN

Laboratory research study with comparison group.

SETTING

Clinical Immunology Unit and Lab, H San Raffaele University Hospital, Italy.

SUBJECTS

Eleven healthy controls and 87 rheumatic patients were studied, including 51 with rheumatoid arthritis (RA) and 33 patients with systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE).

INTERVENTIONS

Vein blood samples were taken via the antecubital vein. Blood was retrieved from 11 patients before and after injection of anti-TNF-alpha humanized antibodies. Nucleosomes were measured with an enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay. Cell death induced by anti-TNF-alpha antibodies and by the soluble cytokine was assessed in vitro.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES

Nucleosome level by treatment.

RESULTS

Enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay effectively detected nucleosomes either released by dying cells in vitro or circulating in the plasma. SLE but not RA patients had circulating nucleosomes at the steady state. Eight of 11 patients had significantly higher levels of plasma nucleosomes after infliximab. Minute amounts of TNF-alpha enabled infliximab to induce cell death in vitro.

CONCLUSIONS

The accumulation of nucleosomes possibly fosters the development of autoantibodies in subjects with appropriate genetic backgrounds.