A review of the application of sourdough technology to wheat breads

Characterization of Lactic Acid Bacteria and Yeast from Grains as Starter Cultures for Gluten-Free Sourdough

With the increasing number of people affected by gluten consumption-related diseases, adhering to a gluten-free (GF) diet is the most effective preventive measure. Herein, we aimed to isolate and characterize the functional properties of autochthonous lactic acid bacteria (LAB) and yeast from various GF sourdoughs to determine their suitability in starter cultures for sourdough preparation. Three LAB, Weissella confusa BAQ2, Lactobacillus brevis AQ2, Leuconostoc citreum YC2, and Saccharomyces cerevisiae BW1, were identified. The isolated LAB exhibited greater TTA, faster acidification rates, and higher acid tolerance than commercial LAB. W. confusa BAQ2 exhibited the highest EPS production, W. confusa BAQ2 and L. brevis AQ2 showed high maltose utilization, and S. cerevisiae BW1 exhibited the highest CO2 production rate. Accordingly, all four microbial strains were mixed for the starter culture. The sourdough prepared with starter cultures exhibited differences in gas production depending on fermentation time, which influenced the volume of GF bread dough. GF bread prepared with fermented sourdough exhibited a 16% higher specific volume and enhanced crumb firmness and elasticity than that prepared using non-fermented sourdough. Thus, autochthonous LAB strains isolated from various GF sourdoughs can be used together to improve the quality of sourdough bread, demonstrating their potential for use in starter cultures for GF sourdough production.

Optimization of fermentation conditions in Barbari bread based on mixed whole flour (barley and sprouted wheat) and sourdough

The purpose of this study was to use a mixture of whole wheat-barley flour mixture in the preparation of traditional Iranian bread (Barbari) in the optimum condition of fermentation to benefit from all available nutrients. In this study, bread parameters such as specific volume, porosity, textural characteristics, zinc, iron, phytic acid and organoleptic properties were investigated. In this research, different percentages of sourdough (15-30%) and fermentation time (30 - 120 min) were applied. Results showed that the phytic acid content significantly decreased (p < 0.05) (0.23 - 0.14) by increasing sourdough and fermentation time, which result in increasing in zinc (17.49 - 22.89%) and iron (36.44 - 45.32%) content. Both the sourdough content and fermentation time parameters had a significant effect (p < 0.05) on the better porosity (9.05 - 13.50%) and overall acceptability of bread (2.15 - 3.85). The hardness, gumminess, chewiness, porosity, phytic acid and overall acceptance parameters were used to optimize the fermentation conditions of Barbari bread by response surface methodology using a central composite design. Optimal conditions for the production of Barbari bread were 29.53% sourdough and 120 min fermentation time. Under optimal conditions, the overall acceptance, hardness, porosity, chewability, gumminess and phytic acid were 3.84, 60.81 N, 14.09%, 302.01 N/mm, 41.37 N and 0.15%, respectively.

Comparison Study of Nontreated and Fermented Wheat Varieties 'Ada', 'Sarta', and New Breed Blue and Purple Wheat Lines Wholemeal Flour

The aim of this study was to analyze and compare the acidity, microbiological, and chromaticity parameters; fatty acid (FA) and volatile compound (VC) profiles; and biogenic amine (BA), macro- and microelement, and mycotoxin concentrations in nontreated ‘Ada’, ‘Sarta’, and new breed blue (DS8472-5) and purple (DS8526-2) wheat lines wholemeal (WW) with those fermented with lactic acid bacteria (LAB) possessing antimicrobial/antifungal properties, isolated from spontaneous sourdough: Pediococcus acidilactici-LUHS29, Liquorilactobacillus uvarum-LUHS245, Lactiplantibacillus plantarum-LUHS122). All the fermented WW showed >8.0 log10 CFU/g of LAB count, and the type of LAB was a significant factor in the WW acidity parameters. Phenylethylamine was the predominant BA in WW, and the wheat variety (WV), the type of LAB, and their interaction were significant factors on the BA formation. Despite the fact that some differences in trace element concentrations in WW were obtained, in most of the cases fermentation was not a significant factor in their content. The main FAs in WW were palmitic acid, all-cis,trans-octadecenoic acid, and linoleic acid. Fermented WW showed a more diverse VC profile; however, the influence of fermentation on deoxynivalenol in WW was varied. Finally, further studies are needed to indicate the technological parameters that would be the most effective for each WV, including the lowest BA formation and mycotoxin degradation.

Improving the quality of traditional Iranian bread by using sourdough and optimizing the fermentation conditions

The aim of this study was to improve the quality and nutritional value of Barbari bread using sourdough and whole wheat-barley flour. To optimize the fermentation condition, the effect of sourdough content (15–30%), temperature (30–45 °C), and time (30–120 min) of fermentation on Barbari bread characteristics (specific volume, porosity, textural characteristics, phytic acid and sensory properties) were investigated. The optimal conditions obtained by the model for the production of Barbari bread were found 30.00% sourdough, 39.39 °C temperature, and 55.81 min fermentation time. Under optimal condition, the overall acceptance, hardness, gumminess, chewability, volume, porosity, and phytic acid were 3.63, 38.58 N, 24.61 N, 193.50 N/mm, 1.69%, 17.71%, and 0.151%, respectively, which was consistent with experimental data. The phytic acid content significantly decreased by increasing sourdough and fermentation time, which resulted in the highest content of zinc and iron content.

Phenotypic and genotypic characterisation of Lactobacillus and yeast isolates from a traditional New Zealand Māori potato starter culture

Parāroa Rēwena is a traditional Māori sourdough produced by fermentation using a potato starter culture. The microbial composition of the starter culture is not well characterised, despite the long history of this product. The morphological, physiological, biochemical and genetic tests were conducted to characterise 26 lactic acid bacteria (LAB) and 15 yeast isolates from a Parāroa Rēwena potato starter culture. The results of sugar fermentation tests, API 50 CHL tests, and API ID 32 C tests suggest the presence of four different LAB phenotypes and five different yeast phenotypes. 16S rRNA and 26S rRNA sequencing identified the LAB as Lacticaseibacillus paracasei and the yeast isolates as Saccharomyces cerevisiae, respectively. Multilocus sequence typing (MLST) of the L. paracasei isolates indicated that they had identical genotypes at the MLST loci, to L. paracasei subsp. paracasei IBB 3423 or L. paracasei subsp. paracasei F19. This study provides new insights into the microbial composition of the traditional sourdough Parāroa Rēwena starter culture.

•

16S sequencing, Multilocus sequencing typing for LAB in the potato starter culture.

•

26S sequencing for yeast in the starter culture.

•

Lacticaseibacillus paracasei subsp. paracasei IBB3423.

•

Lacticaseibacillus paracasei subsp. paracasei F19.

•

Saccharomycescerevisiae.

Extraction, purification and characterisation of exopolysaccharides produced by newly isolated lactic acid bacteria strains and the examination of their influence on resistant starch formation

Exopolysaccharides (EPS) were produced by four newly isolated lactic acid bacteria strains, then further extracted, separated and characterised under standardised conditions. Using a sucrose carbon source, these LAB strains belonging to Weissella confusa/cibaria produced EPS with a dextran high molecular weight fraction. The obtained yields of EPS ranged from 3.2 g/L to 47.1 g/L and outstandingly high yields were obtained using Weissella confusa/cibaria 3MI3 isolated from spontaneous spelt sourdough. After purification the influence of EPS-dextran of molar mass 3,244,000 g/mol on resistant starch formation in wheat starch pastes and pasted samples after temperature-cycled storage was examined. Size exclusion chromatography with post-column derivatisation revealed that a 1.5% share of EPS dextran limited formation of high molar mass resistant starch in starch pastes during storage. This work provides new insight on hindering resistant starch formation by using EPS, which could be efficiently produced in sourdough, thus improving the properties of sourdough bread.

Functional and Healthy Features of Conventional and Non-Conventional Sourdoughs

Sourdough is a composite ecosystem largely characterized by yeasts and lactic acid bacteria which are the main players in the fermentation process. The specific strains involved are influenced by several factors including the chemical and enzyme composition of the flour and the sourdough production technology. For many decades the scientific community has explored the microbiological, biochemical, technological and nutritional potential of sourdoughs. Traditionally, sourdoughs have been used to improve the organoleptic properties, texture, digestibility, palatability, and safety of bread and other kinds of baked products. Recently, novel sourdough-based biotechnological applications have been proposed to meet the demand of consumers for healthier and more natural food and offer new inputs for the food industry. Many researchers have focused on the beneficial effects of specific enzymatic activities or compounds, such as exopolysaccharides, with both technological and functional roles. Additionally, many studies have explored the ability of sourdough lactic acid bacteria to produce antifungal compounds for use as bio-preservatives. This review provides an overview of the fundamental features of sourdoughs and their exploitation to develop high value-added products with beneficial microorganisms and/or their metabolites, which can positively impact human health.

Effects of different starter cultures on the quality characteristics and shelf-life of fermented rice cake

The effects of Makgeolli, dry yeast (DY), sourdough with dry yeast (SDDY) and sourdough with Makgeolli (SDMG) on the quality of fermented rice cakes (FRCs) stored at 23 °C for 3 days were determined. The acidity of SDDY and SDMG significantly increased with increasing fermentation time. The FRCs supplemented with sourdough had slightly higher moisture contents than others. The addition of DY and SDDY increased the specific volume of the FRC, in which its texture was softer. The addition of DY and sourdoughs significantly decreased the firming rate of crumb and improved the sensory qualities. The sourdoughs retarded amylopectin retrogradation, indicating their anti-staling effect on the FRC. Compared to the control, the shelf-lives of FRCs made with DY and SDDY were extended by 0.7 and 0.5 days based on the instrumental hardness, respectively. DY and SDDY effectively improved the appearance and texture of FRC and extended its shelf-life.

Comparison of the Functionality of Exopolysaccharides Produced by Sourdough Lactic Acid Bacteria in Bread and Steamed Bread

Exopolysaccharides (EPSs) produced by lactic acid bacteria improve the quality of bread; however, their functionality in steamed bread is unknown. This study aimed to compare the impact of EPS produced during sourdough fermentation on the quality of bread and steamed bread. Sourdoughs were fermented with EPS-producing Fructilactobacillus sanfranciscensis, Weissella cibaria, and Leuconostoc mesenteroides; Latilactobacillus sakei LS8 and chemically acidified sourdough were prepared as controls. EPS production generally enhanced the specific volume, improved the texture, and reduced the staling rate of bread. The effect of EPS on steamed bread quality was more pronounced when compared to its effect on bread quality. Remarkably, the beneficial effects of F. sanfranciscensis bread quality were largely independent of EPS formation and may relate to gluten modifications rather than EPS production. In conclusion, the direct comparison of sourdough and EPS functionality in steaming and baking provides novel insights for the optimization of commercial (steamed) bread production.

Exploitation of Lactic Acid Bacteria and Baker's Yeast as Single or Multiple Starter Cultures of Wheat Flour Dough Enriched with Soy Flour

Sourdough fermentation presents several advantageous effects in bread making, like improved nutritional quality and increased shelf life. Three types of experiments aimed to evaluate comparatively the efficiency of two Lactobacillus (Lb.) strains, Lb. plantarum ATCC 8014 and Lb. casei ATCC 393, to metabolize different white wheat flour and soybeans flour combinations to compare their efficiency, together with/without Saccharomyces cerevisiae on sourdough fermentation. For this purpose, the viability, pH, organic acids, and secondary metabolites production were investigated, together with the dynamic rheological properties of the sourdough. During sourdough fermentation, LAB presented higher growth, and the pH decreased significantly from above pH 6 at 0 h to values under 4 at 24 h for each experiment. Co-cultures of LAB and yeast produced a higher quantity of lactic acid than single cultures, especially in sourdough enriched with soy-flour. In general, sourdoughs displayed a stable, elastic-like behavior, and the incorporation of soy-flour conferred higher elasticity in comparison with sourdoughs without soy-flour. The higher elasticity of sourdoughs enriched with soy-flour can be attributed to the fact that through frozen storage, soy proteins have better water holding capacity. In conclusion, sourdough supplemented with 10% soy-flour had better rheological properties, increased lactic, acetic, and citric acid production.

The use of cyclic dipeptide producing LAB with potent anti-aflatoxigenic capability to improve techno-functional properties of clean-label bread

Purpose

The aim of the present study was to evaluate the antifungal activity, anti-aflatoxigenic capability, and technological functionality of the selected lactic acid bacteria (LAB) isolated from wheat sourdough.

Methods

The preselected LAB isolates were screened based on their antifungal activities and acidification capacities. Then, the antifungal compounds were identified using gas chromatography/mass spectrometry in the selected LAB culture filtrate obtained from its preparative thin-layer chromatography. The HPLC-based analysis was also used to investigate the anti-aflatoxigenic potentials of the selected LAB isolate. Finally, controlled sourdough (containing selected LAB isolate as starter culture) was used to produce loaf bread, and properties of the product were evaluated in terms of hardness, phytic acid content, overall acceptability, and surface moldiness.

Results

Molecular approaches led to the identification of Pediococcus pentosaceus as the selected LAB isolate. In vitro and in situ antifungal activities of the selected LAB against Aspergillus niger were verified. Antifungal metabolites of the LAB included fatty acid ester, hydroxylated fatty acid ester, an antimicrobial compound, and cyclic dipeptide. Potent anti-aflatoxigenic capabilities of the LAB isolate and cyclic dipeptide (which was identified in the antifungal fraction of the LAB) were also verified. To our best knowledge, the cyclic dipeptide detected in the present study has never been shown before to possess anti-aflatoxigenic effect. Furthermore, the results revealed that controlled sourdough improved the techno-functional properties of the produced loaf wheat bread.

Conclusion

Altogether, our findings indicate that the selected P. pentosaceus isolate exhibiting proper characteristics can be used as a bio-preservative and bio-improver in the processing of clean-label breads.

Response surface methodology for investigating the effects of sourdough fermentation conditions on Iranian cup bread properties

In this study, the dominant lactic acid bacteria present in whole wheat sourdough was isolated and identified as Lactobacillus plantarum by molecular methods, before being utilized as the starter culture in the processing of sourdough cup breads. Subsequently, the effects of sourdough fermentation time, ash content, and sugar content on bread quality attributes were investigated by response surface methodology. In terms of the independent variables, the best polynomial models were fitted for bread hardness, chewiness, specific volume, total color difference (TCD), porosity and overall acceptability (OAA). Based on statistical analysis (P < 0.05), the effect of fermentation time on hardness and TCD was significant; ash content influenced specific volume and TCD significantly. In comparison with other functions, the interaction between fermentation time and sugar content had a significant (P < 0.05) influence on bread OAA. Furthermore, a strong positive correlation was ascertained between sourdough total titratable acidity and most of the quality attributes of cup bread (especially hardness, specific volume and OAA). Accordingly, the control of sourdough fermentation conditions is influential on microbial activity and metabolites, which affect bread quality characteristics.

Effect of liquid sourdough technology on the pre-biotic, texture, and sensory properties of a crispy flatbread

The present study compared liquid sourdough technology with baker's yeast leavening when applied to the production of a semolina-based crispy flatbread. Following in vitro starch digestion, the results revealed the sourdough leavened flatbread to contain a lower percentage of rapidly digestible starch (16%), higher amounts of slowly digestible starch (27%) and inaccessible digestible starch (4.1%) compared with the baker's yeast leavened flatbread (20, 20, and 2.4%, respectively), making the former nutritionally healthier. The sourdough leavened bread was crispier, stiffer and more solid, as shown by texture analyses, although Raman spectroscopy revealed no differences in the crystallinity status of starch. The descriptive analyses show that the use of sourdough enhances the positive sensory traits, as rated by the consumer panel scores (6.08 vs. 5.56). In summary, the results indicate that the implementation of sourdough technology in the production of flat crispy breads could confer economic advantages to this product.

Isolation of lactic acid bacteria starters from Jeung-pyun for sourdough fermentation

Lactic acid bacteria (LAB) are key for the fermentation of sourdoughs to improve the quality and nutritive value of bread. The aim of this study was to isolate the LAB starter for sourdough fermentation from Jeung-pyun, a Korean traditional rice cake. Among the twenty two LAB screened, five isolates were selected based on exo-polysaccharide production. Among them, three isolates showed cell growth greater than 8.5 Log CFU/g, maximum increase in the volume of dough, and dextran concentration up to 0.16%. During the sourdough fermentation, pH and total titratable acidity (TTA) were changed, as the three isolates synthesized lactic acid and acetic acid with fermentation quotients less than 2.0. They were identified as Leuconostoc lactis EFEL005, Lactobacillus brevis EFEL004, and Le. citreum EFEL006. They displayed good fermentation properties (growth, dextran production, pH, and TTA) in dough and they are regarded as potential starters to be used in sourdough fermentation.

Cloning and characterization of a Weissella confusa dextransucrase and its application in high fibre baking

Wheat bran offers health benefits as a baking ingredient, but is detrimental to bread textural quality. Dextran production by microbial fermentation improves sourdough bread volume and freshness, but extensive acid production during fermentation may negate this effect. Enzymatic production of dextran in wheat bran was tested to determine if dextran-containing bran could be used in baking without disrupting bread texture. The Weissella confusa VTT E-90392 dextransucrase gene was sequenced and His-tagged dextransucrase Wc392-rDSR was produced in Lactococcus lactis. Purified enzyme was characterized using ¹⁴C-sucrose radioisotope and reducing value-based assays, the former yielding K_m and V_max values of 14.7 mM and 8.2 μmol/(mg∙min), respectively, at the pH optimum of 5.4. The structure and size of in vitro dextran product was similar to dextran produced in vivo. Dextran (8.1% dry weight) was produced in wheat bran in 6 h using Wc392-rDSR. Bran with and without dextran was used in wheat baking at 20% supplementation level. Dextran presence improved bread softness and neutralized bran-induced volume loss, clearly demonstrating the potential of using dextransucrases in bran bioprocessing for use in baking.

Production of wheat bread without preservatives using sourdough starters

In order for the beneficial effects of sourdough application in breadmaking to take place a proper selection of lactic acid bacteria species and strains, an appropriate technology and effective control of the purity and activity of the selected cultures. Four symbiotic starters for sourdough for the production of bread were developed and probated in a production laboratory using the selected strains Lactobacillus brevis LBRZ7, L. buchneri LBRZ6, L. plantarum X2, L. paracasei RN5, L. sanfranciscensis R and L. fermentum LBRH10 and the probiotic strain Propionibacterium freudenreichii ssp. shermanii NBIMCC 327. The starter sourdoughs that include Propionibacterium freudenreichii ssp. shermanii NBIMCC 327 had greater antimicrobial activity against saprophytic microorganisms: Bacillus subtilis, B. mesentericus, Aspergillus niger, Penicillium sp. and Rhizopus sp., but none of them inhibited the growth of bakery yeasts Saccharomyces cerevisiae. It was established that in order to prevent bacterial spoilage 10% of the selected starter sourdoughs had to be added in the breadmaking process, while for prevention of mold spoilage the necessary amount of starter sourdough had to be between 15% and 20%.The application of the developed starters for the production of wheat bread guarantees longer shelf life and no adverse alterations in the features of the final bread.

Significance of microbial symbiotic coexistence in traditional fermentation

Symbiosis has long been a central theme in microbiology. There have been many studies on the symbioses between microorganisms and higher organisms such as plants and animals. There also have been some studies on the symbiosis or coexistence of microorganisms, such as yeasts, lactic acid bacteria (LAB), acetic acid bacteria (AAB) and koji molds, in traditional fermentation (brewing). These microorganisms are considered to interact and cooperate with each other in various natural environments, such as dropped cereal crops or ripe fruits. Human beings have taken advantage of these microbial interactions for producing various fermented foods.

Physico-chemical and functional properties of spray-dried sourdough in breadmaking

In present study, spray-dried sourdough was produced using a pilot scale spray dryer and the physico-chemical and microbial characteristics of the obtained sourdough powder were investigated. The application of the spray-dried sourdough at different levels (3%, 6%, 9% and 15%) in breadmaking was also evaluated. Bulk density, wettability and suspensibility of the sourdough powder were 0.6 g/cm3, 98 s and 29%, respectively. The most of the powder particles were in a range of 106–250 µm. The spray-dried sourdough had a moisture content and ash content of 3.72% and 1.9% (db), respectively. The pH and total titratable acidity of the sourdough powder were 3.26 and 59 (mL of 0.1 N NaOH/10 g powder), respectively. Spray drying reduced lactic acid bacteria population of the sourdough to 2 × 105 CFU/g compared to the initial value of 109 CFU/g. Iranian traditional flat bread (Sangak) made with different levels of the sourdough powder had significantly ( p < 0.05) lower pH and higher total titratable acidity compared to those of the control. The results of sensory evaluation showed that Sangak breads containing 15% sourdough powder were slightly darker and sourer than the other breads. Incorporation of spray-dried sourdough delayed bread staling, as judged by sensory panel. The results suggest that spray-dried sourdough at the level of 9% can be successfully used for Sangak breadmaking, leading to bread with an improved flavor and delayed staling.

A ready-to-use antifungal starter culture improves the shelf life of packaged bread

Fungal spoilage is the main cause of economic loss in the baking industry. In this study, we developed a ready-to-use biopreserver (slurry [SL]) for nonsliced packed bread by using selected antifungal lactic acid bacteria (LAB) and low-cost ingredients that are compatible with the food matrix. Four LAB strains (Lactobacillus brevis CRL 772, L. brevis CRL 796, L. plantarum CRL 778, and L. reuteri CRL 1100) tested in bread preservation were able to inhibit Penicillium sp. growth and lengthen shelf life twofold with respect to breads prepared using only Saccharomyces cerevisiae (2 days shelf life). The best biopreservation effect (5 days shelf life) was obtained with 40% antifungal slurry SL778 containing L. plantarum CRL 778; this was as effective as 0.2% calcium propionate (PCa). The antifungal effect of SL778 was related to the synthesis of acetic and phenyllactic acid as well as lactic acid, which was produced at a high concentration (31.2 mmol/kg) and lowered the pH of the dough, favoring the undissociated fraction of the organic acids. The combination of the starter SL778 with 0.4% PCa extended the shelf life of packaged bread to 24 days, 2.6-fold longer than breads prepared with only 0.4% PCa.

Biodiversity of exopolysaccharides produced from sucrose by sourdough lactic acid bacteria

The distribution and diversity of natural exopolysaccharides (EPS) produced from sucrose by thirty heterofermentative lactic acid bacteria strains from French traditional sourdoughs was investigated. The EPS production was found to be related to glucansucrase and fructansucrase extracellular activities. Depending on the strain, soluble and/or cell-associated glycansucrases were secreted. Structural characterization of the polymers by 1H and 13C NMR spectroscopy analysis further demonstrated a high diversity of EPS structures. Notably, we detected strains that synthesize glucans showing amazing variations in the amount of alpha-(1-->2), alpha-(1-->3) and alpha-(1-->6) linkages. The representation of Leuconostoc strains which produce putative alternan polymers and alpha-(1-->2) branched polymers was particularly high. The existence of glucan- and fructansucrase encoding genes was also confirmed by PCR detection. Sourdough was thus demonstrated to be a very attractive biotope for the isolation of lactic acid bacteria producing novel polymers which could find interesting applications such as texturing agent or prebiotics.

Sourdough and cereal fermentation in a nutritional perspective

Use of sourdough is of expanding interest for improvement of flavour, structure and stability of baked goods. Cereal fermentations also show significant potential in improvement and design of the nutritional quality and health effects of foods and ingredients. In addition to improving the sensory quality of whole grain, fibre-rich or gluten-free products, sourdough can also actively retard starch digestibility leading to low glycemic responses, modulate levels and bioaccessibility of bioactive compounds, and improve mineral bioavailability. Cereal fermentation may produce non-digestible polysaccharides, or modify accessibility of the grain fibre complex to gut microbiota. It has also been suggested that degradation of gluten may render bread better suitable for celiac persons. The changes in cereal matrix potentially leading to improved nutritional quality are numerous. They include acid production, suggested to retard starch digestibility, and to adjust pH to a range which favours the action of certain endogenous enzymes, thus changing the bioavailability pattern of minerals and phytochemicals. This is especially beneficial in products rich in bran to deliver minerals and potentially protective compounds in the blood circulation. The action of enzymes during fermentation also causes hydrolysis and solubilisation of grain macromolecules, such as proteins and cell wall polysaccharides. This changes product texture, which may affect nutrient and non-nutrient absorption. New bioactive compounds, such as prebiotic oligosaccharides or other metabolites, may also be formed in cereal fermentations.