Access roads for RAG-ged terrains: control of T cell receptor gene rearrangement at multiple levels

The requirement for pre-TCR during thymic differentiation enforces a developmental pause that is essential for V-DJβ rearrangement

T cell development occurs in the thymus and is critically dependent on productive TCRβ rearrangement and pre-TCR expression in DN3 cells. The requirement for pre-TCR expression results in the arrest of thymocytes at the DN3 stage (β checkpoint), which is uniquely permissive for V-DJβ recombination; only cells expressing pre-TCR survive and develop beyond the DN3 stage. In addition, the requirement for TCRβ rearrangement and pre-TCR expression enforces suppression of TCRβ rearrangement on a second allele, allelic exclusion, thus ensuring that each T cell expresses only a single TCRβ product. However, it is not known whether pre-TCR expression is essential for allelic exclusion or alternatively if allelic exclusion is enforced by developmental changes that can occur in the absence of pre-TCR. We asked if thymocytes that were differentiated without pre-TCR expression, and therefore without pause at the β checkpoint, would suppress all V-DJβ rearrangement. We previously reported that premature CD28 signaling in murine CD4(-)CD8(-) (DN) thymocytes supports differentiation of CD4(+)CD8(+) (DP) cells in the absence of pre-TCR expression. The present study uses this model to define requirements for TCRβ rearrangement and allelic exclusion. We demonstrate that if cells exit the DN3 developmental stage before TCRβ rearrangement occurs, V-DJβ rearrangement never occurs, even in DP cells that are permissive for D-Jβ and TCRα rearrangement. These results demonstrate that pre-TCR expression is not essential for thymic differentiation to DP cells or for V-DJβ suppression. However, the requirement for pre-TCR signals and the exclusion of alternative stimuli such as CD28 enforce a developmental "pause" in early DN3 cells that is essential for productive TCRβ rearrangement to occur.

Cutting edge: Thymic NK cells develop independently from T cell precursors

Although NK cells in the mouse are thought to develop in the bone marrow, a small population of NK cells in the thymus has been shown to derive from a GATA3-dependent pathway. Characteristically, thymic NK cells express CD127 and few Ly49 molecules and lack CD11b. Because these NK cells develop in the thymus, the question of their relationship to the T cell lineage has been raised. Using several different mouse models, we find that unlike T cells, thymic NK cells are not the progeny of Rorc-expressing progenitors and do not express Rag2 or rearrange the TCRγ locus. We further demonstrate that thymic NK cells develop independently of the Notch signaling pathway, supporting the idea that thymic NK cells represent bona fide NK cells that can develop independently of all T cell precursors.

Lymphoid Differentiation Pathways Can Be Traced by TCR δ Rearrangements

TCR gene rearrangement generates diversity of T lymphocytes by V(D)J recombination. Ig genes are rearranged in B cells using the same enzyme machinery. TCRD (TCR delta) genes are frequently incompletely rearranged in B precursor leukemias and recently were found in a significant portion of physiological B lymphocytes. Incomplete TCRD rearrangements (V-D) thus serve as natural indicators of previous V(D)J recombinase activity. Functional V(D)J recombinase has recently been found in murine NK precursors. We tested whether physiological NK cells and other leukocyte subpopulations contained TCR rearrangements in humans. This would provide evidence that V(D)J recombinase was active in the ancestry cells and suggest common pathways among the positive cell types. TCRD were rearranged in 3.2-36% of NK cells but not in nonlymphoid leukocytes. The previously known phenomenon of TCRD transcription in NK cells is a possible mechanism that maintains the chromatin open at the TCRD locus. In comparison, TCRG rearrangements were frequent in T cells, low to negative in B and NK cells, and negative in nonlymphoid cells, suggesting a tighter control of TCRG. Levels of TCRD rearrangements were similar among the B lymphocyte subsets (B1-B2, naive-memory). In conclusion, human NK cells pass through a differentiation step with active V(D)J recombinase similar to T and B lymphocytes and unlike nonlymphoid leukocytes. This contradicts recent challenges to the concept of separate lymphoid and myeloid differentiation.

Multiple T-cell clones specific for the same foreign pMHC ligand can be generated from a single, ancestral TCR-VDJbeta precursor

Owing to ordered, stage-specific T-cell receptor (TCR) gene rearrangements and cell division during T-cell development, small cohorts of "half-sibling" T cells sharing an ancestral TCR VDJbeta rearrangement but expressing different TCR alpha-locus rearrangements may be selected into the mature T-cell repertoire. We wondered whether different alphabetaTCRs expressed by T cells from the same ancestral VDJbeta cohort might be capable of recognizing the same foreign peptide-major histocompatibility complex complex (pMHC). By a combined flow cytometric and single-cell polymerase chain reaction (PCR) approach to analyze TCRs selected by the previously defined foreign antigen, pCW3170-179/H-2Kd, we were able to identify cohorts of half-sibling antigen-specific CD8 T cells after their expansion in immunized mice. We amplified residual DJbeta rearrangements as clonal markers to confirm that the shared VDJbeta sequences represent ancestral rearrangements rather than identical but independent ones. An intriguing explanation of our findings would be that only a very limited repertoire of TCR alpha-chains is selected to pair with a given TCR beta-chain during T-cell development.

A functional analysis of the spacer of V(D)J recombination signal sequences

During lymphocyte development, V(D)J recombination assembles antigen receptor genes from component V, D, and J gene segments. These gene segments are flanked by a recombination signal sequence (RSS), which serves as the binding site for the recombination machinery. The murine Jbeta2.6 gene segment is a recombinationally inactive pseudogene, but examination of its RSS reveals no obvious reason for its failure to recombine. Mutagenesis of the Jbeta2.6 RSS demonstrates that the sequences of the heptamer, nonamer, and spacer are all important. Strikingly, changes solely in the spacer sequence can result in dramatic differences in the level of recombination. The subsequent analysis of a library of more than 4,000 spacer variants revealed that spacer residues of particular functional importance are correlated with their degree of conservation. Biochemical assays indicate distinct cooperation between the spacer and heptamer/nonamer along each step of the reaction pathway. The results suggest that the spacer serves not only to ensure the appropriate distance between the heptamer and nonamer but also regulates RSS activity by providing additional RAG:RSS interaction surfaces. We conclude that while RSSs are defined by a "digital" requirement for absolutely conserved nucleotides, the quality of RSS function is determined in an "analog" manner by numerous complex interactions between the RAG proteins and the less-well conserved nucleotides in the heptamer, the nonamer, and, importantly, the spacer. Those modulatory effects are accurately predicted by a new computational algorithm for "RSS information content." The interplay between such binary and multiplicative modes of interactions provides a general model for analyzing protein-DNA interactions in various biological systems.

DNA-Rag Protein Interactions in the Control of Selective D Gene Utilization in the TCRβ Locus

Ordered assembly of Ag receptor genes by VDJ recombination is a key determinant of successful lymphocyte differentiation and function. Control of gene rearrangement has been traditionally viewed as a result of complex reorganization of the nucleochromatin mediated by several nuclear factors. Selective recombination of the variable (V) genes to the diversity (D), but not joining (J), gene segments within the TCRbeta locus has been shown to be controlled by recombination signal (RS) sequences that flank the gene segments. Through ex vivo and in vitro recombination assays, we demonstrate that the Rag proteins can discriminate between the RS of the D and J genes and enforce selective D gene incorporation into the TCRbeta variable domain in the absence of other nuclear factors or chromatin structure. DNA binding studies indicate that discrimination is not simply caused by higher affinity binding of the Rag proteins to the isolated 12RS of the D as opposed to the J genes. Furthermore, we also demonstrate that the 12RS within the TCRbeta locus is functionally inferior to the consensus 12RS. We propose that selective gene segment usage is controlled at the level of differential assembly and/or stability of synaptic RS complexes, and that evolutionary "deterioration" of the RS motifs may have been important to allow the VDJ recombinase to exert autonomous control over gene segment use during gene rearrangement.

T cell receptor gene rearrangement lineage analysis reveals clues for the origin of highly restricted antigen-specific repertoires

Due to ordered, stage-specific T cell receptor (TCR)-beta and -alpha locus gene rearrangements and cell division during T cell development, a given, ancestral TCR-beta locus VDJ rearrangement might be selected into the mature T cell repertoire as a small cohort of "half-sibling" progeny expressing identical TCR-beta chains paired with different TCR-alpha chains. The low frequency of such a cohort relative to the total alphabeta TCR repertoire precludes their direct identification and characterization in normal mice. We considered it possible that positive selection constraints might limit the diversity of TCR-alpha chains selected to pair with beta chains encoded by an ancestral VDJ-beta rearrangement. If so, half-sibling T cells expressing structurally similar, but different TCR-alpha chains might recognize the same foreign antigen. By single cell polymerase chain reaction analysis of antigen-specific TCRs selected during a model anti-tumor response, we were able to identify clusters of T cells sharing identical VDJ-beta rearrangements but expressing different TCR-alpha chains. The amplification of residual DJ-beta rearrangements as clonal markers allowed us to track T cells expressing different TCR-alpha chains back to a common ancestral VDJ-beta rearrangement. Thus, the diversity of TCR-alpha's selected as partners for a given VDJ-beta rearrangement into the mature TCR repertoire may indeed be very limited.