MR UROGRAPHY

The diagnostic value of magnetic resonance urography for detecting ureteric obstruction: a systematic review and meta-analysis

OBJECTIVE

To evaluate the diagnostic accuracy of magnetic resonance urography (MRU) and determine its value for detecting ureteric obstruction.

METHODS

The electronic databases, including PubMed, Embase and the Cochrane library, were systematically searched for studies published throughout September 2018. The summary of sensitivity, specificity, positive likelihood ratio (PLR), negative likelihood ratio (NLR), diagnostic odds ratio (DOR) and receiver operating characteristic (ROC) curves was assessed to evaluate the diagnostic accuracy of MRU. Subgroup analyses were conducted based on the mean age of the included patients (adults or children).

RESULTS

Eight studies with a total of 594 patients were included. The summary of the sensitivity and specificity of MRU for diagnosing ureteric obstruction was 0.94 and 0.87, respectively. Furthermore, the pooled PLR and NLR were 7.33 and 0.07, respectively. The DOR of MRU for detecting ureteric obstruction was 95.12. In addition, the summary of the area under the ROC of MRU was 0.96. Finally, the specificity, PLR and area under the ROC of MRU for diagnosing ureteric obstruction in adults were higher than children, while the sensitivity of MRU in adults was lower than children.

CONCLUSIONS

These findings suggested a relatively high diagnostic value of MRU for detecting ureteric obstruction. Moreover, the diagnostic accuracy of MRU in adults was higher than in children. KEY MESSAGE Magnetic resonance urography (MRU) in detecting ureteric obstruction has relatively better sensitivity, specificity, PLR, NLR, DOR and AUC. The diagnostic value, including specificity, PLR and AUC of MRU in adults, was higher than in children, while the sensitivity of MRU in adults was lower than in children.

MRI for diagnosis of post-renal transplant complications: current state-of-the-art and future perspectives

Kidney transplantation has developed into a widespread procedure to treat end stage renal failure, with transplantation results improving over the years. Postoperative complications have decreased over the past decades, but are still an important cause of morbidity and mortality. Early accurate diagnosis and treatment is the key to prevent renal allograft impairment or even graft loss. Ideally, a diagnostic tool should be able to detect post-transplant renal dysfunction, differentiate between the different causes and monitor renal function during and after therapeutic interventions. Non-invasive imaging modalities for diagnostic purposes show promising results. Magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) techniques have a number of advantages, such as the lack of ionizing radiation and the possibility to obtain relevant tissue information without contrast, reducing the risk of contrast-induced nephrotoxicity. However, most techniques still lack the specificity to distinguish different types of parenchymal diseases. Despite some promising outcomes, MRI is still barely used in the post-transplantation diagnostic process. The aim of this review is to survey the current literature on the relevance and clinical applicability of diagnostic MRI modalities for the detection of various types of complications after kidney transplantation.

The role of static magnetic resonance urography in the evaluation of obstructive uropathy

OBJECTIVE

To assess the diagnostic accuracy of static magnetic resonance urography (MRU) in hydronephrosis and to compare parameters of hydronephrosis in MRU with intravenous urography (IVU).

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Sixty-nine patients were included in this study of which 55 patients with a total of 63 hydronephrotic units underwent both IVU and MRU. MRU was performed on a 1.5 T scanner using heavily T2-weighted sequences. The level, grade, and cause of obstruction on each modality were interpreted by 2 radiologists. These were compared with the final diagnosis based on other appropriate modalities including imaging, intraoperative and histopathologic diagnosis.

RESULTS

The sensitivity and specificity MRU in detecting hydronephrosis were 95% and 100%, respectively. In determining the level of obstruction, the strength of agreement between IVU and MRU using kappa statistics was κ = 0.66, which corresponds to a good level of agreement. The Spearman correlation coefficient for the grade of hydronephrosis on MRU and IVU was 0.92 (95% confidence interval 0.86-0.95), with a P value of < .0001. The correct diagnosis was made in 89.2% of the cases by IVU and in 93.8% of the cases by MRU.

CONCLUSION

Along with a high sensitivity and specificity in detecting the presence, level, and grade of hydronephrosis, MRU without contrast also shows a good agreement with IVU. Static MRU can reliably replace IVU when the latter is contraindicated or technically difficult.

Imaging of the renal transplant: comparison of MRI with duplex sonography

Renal transplantation is an established treatment for patients with end-stage renal disease. Many causes of graft dysfunction are treatable, making prompt detection and diagnosis of complications essential. Sensitive, noninvasive imaging procedures, which do not use iodinated contrast media, are therefore highly desirable to evaluate graft function. Duplex sonography (US) has traditionally been the initial investigation of graft dysfunction. US offers many advantages, particularly during the postoperative period, when it can be performed portably regardless of renal function and can guide percutaneous procedures. However, US lacks specificity in assessing hydronephrosis, cannot differentiate parenchymal causes of dysfunction, and may have difficulty assessing transplant vessels. Recently comprehensive magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) protocols including MR urography, gadolinium-enhanced MR angiography, and MR renography have evolved as a "one-stop" diagnostic technique in the evaluation of the entire graft and peritransplant region. Multiplanar capabilities enable MRI to identify the site of urinary obstruction and assess renal vessels in their entirety. The evolving technique of MR renography may also differentiate parenchymal causes of dysfunction. By combining these three components into a single examination, further information may be obtained regarding the graft when compared with US and other conventional studies, with improved patient convenience, less morbidity, and a potential cost saving.

3D excretory MR urography: Improved image quality with intravenous saline and diuretic administration

PURPOSE

To assess the effect of diuretic administration on the image quality of excretory magnetic resonance urography (MRU) obtained following intravenous hydration, and to determine whether intravenous hydration alone is sufficient to produce diagnostic quality studies of nondilated upper tracts.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

A total of 22 patients with nondilated upper tracts were evaluated with contrast-enhanced MRU. All patients received 250 mL of saline intravenously immediately prior to the examination. A total of 11 patients received 10-20 mg furosemide in addition to saline. Imaging was performed with a three-dimensional (3D) and two-dimensional (2D) breathhold spoiled gradient-echo sequences. Excretory MRU images were acquired five minutes after the administration of 0.1 mmol/kg gadolinium and were independently reviewed by two radiologists, who were blinded to the MRU technique. Readers evaluated the calyces, renal pelvis, and ureters qualitatively for degree of opacification, distention, and artifacts on a four-point scale. Statistical analysis was performed using a permutation test.

RESULTS

There was no significant disagreement between the two readers (P=0.14). Furosemide resulted in significant improvement in calyceal and renal pelvis distention (P<0.005), and significant artifact reduction in all upper tract segments (P<0.001) compared to the effect of saline alone.

CONCLUSION

Intravenous furosemide significantly improves the image quality of excretory MRU studies obtained following intravenous hydration. Intravenous saline alone is insufficient to produce diagnostic quality studies of the non-dilated upper tracts.

Uso de la urografía por resonancia magnética en el estudio del aparato urinario frente a la urografía convencional

Conventional urography (IVU) is an essential examination for the assessment of urinary tract but it is not free of complications, such as adverse reactions to contrast agents used (vasovagal and anaphylactic reactions), neurotoxicity, nephrotoxicity, as well as the damage due to the ionizing irradiation applied to the patient. For this reason, alternative imaging techniques such as magnetic resonance (MR) urography or uro-resonance have been developed.

OBJECTIVE

We present a case study assessing the diagnostic accuracy, specificity and sensitivity of uro-resonance and IVU as a morphological and functional examination of the urinary tract: and a quality study of the urographic images obtained with MR versus IVU.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

150 patients have submited to a MR study, 63 of them with an IVU study already performed, acquiring high-intensity signals at T2 corresponding to abdominal and retroperitoneal fluid, initially using furosemide at low doses and, in a final study, administering gadolinium at a rate of 0.1 mg/Kg. The test was indicated in patients with antecedents of adverse reactions to iodine contrast, acute or chronic kidney failure, functional cancellation of the kidneys, pregnant patients and those in paediatric age. The capacity of diagnosis of urinary obstruction and the aetiology of this obstruction of both tests was studied, as well as the quality of the images obtained by the urographic study using MR.

RESULTS

High resolution images were obtained of all the upper urinary tracts using MR, especially in the renal pelvis, without artefacts caused by peristalsis or intestinal fluid interposition. In 83.3% of cases, examinations revealed urological pathology. The diagnostic accuracy of the involvement cause of the urinary tract was 83.3%, with a sensitivity of 89.6%, a specificity of 69.2%. a positive predictive value of 86.6% and a negative predictive value of 75%.

CONCLUSION

MR urography is a high sensitive technique for the study of urinary tract, used as an alternative to conventional urography particularly in cases of the contraindication of ionizing radiation or allergy to the contrast agent, as well as in patients with renal failure, and offers a wider morphological and functional study, with a high image quality, able to displace conventional examinations in the short or medium term.

[Functional and morphological MR imaging of the upper urinary tract in the pediatric age group]

MR imaging is being increasingly used for the diagnosis of congenital urinary tract obstruction. The following conditions have to be fulfilled to provide an MR urography technique which is useful for the pediatric age group: (1) the combination of morphology and function, (2) a high-resolution morphological image, (3) a morphological image independent of kidney function, (4) reliable determination of split renal function and (5) of urinary excretion. This is best accomplished with a combination of a T1-weighted fast GE sequence post-contrast and a heavily T2-weighted 3D IR-TSE sequence. Selected sequence parameters are important for optimization as well as for a correct functional assessment. Then MR urography is superior to the conventional methods of excretory urography, ultrasound, and scintigraphy in the morphological depiction of the urinary tract even of complex malformations as well as in a detailed functional assessment. In particular, this method is useful in the situation of complicated duplex kidneys, dystopic kidneys, unclear morphology, or discrepant former results and perioperative assessment. The main advantages are avoiding radiation and obtaining a simultaneous functional-morphological diagnosis.

Magnetic resonance voiding cystography in the diagnosis of vesicoureteral reflux: comparative study with voiding cystourethrography

PURPOSE

To evaluate the feasibility of magnetic resonance voiding cystography (MRVC) compared with voiding cystourethrography (VCUG) for detecting and grading vesicoureteral reflux (VUR).

MATERIALS AND METHODS

MRVC was performed upon 20 children referred for investigation of reflux. Either coronal T1-weighted spin-echo (SE) or gradient-echo (GE) (fast multiplanar spoiled gradient-echo (FMPSPGR) or turbo fast low-angle-shot (FLASH)) images were obtained before and after transurethral administration of gadolinium solution, and immediately after voiding. The findings of MRVC were compared with those of VCUG and technetium-99m ((99m)Tc) dimercaptosuccinic acid (DMSA) single-photon emission computed tomography (SPECT) performed within 6 months of MRVC.

RESULTS

VUR was detected in 23 ureterorenal units (16 VURs by both methods, 5 VURs by VCUG, and 2 VURs by MRVC). With VCUG as the standard of reference, the sensitivity of MRVC was 76.2%; the specificity, 90.0%; the positive predictive value, 88.9%; and the negative predictive value, 78.3%. There was concordance between two methods regarding the grade of reflux in all 16 ureterorenal units with VUR detected by both methods. Of 40 kidneys, MRVC detected findings of renal damage or reflux nephropathy in 13 kidneys, and (99m)Tc DMSA renal SPECT detected findings of reflux nephropathy in 17 kidneys.

CONCLUSION

Although MRVC is shown to have less sensitivity for VUR than VCUG, MRVC may represent a method of choice offering a safer nonradiation test that can additionally evaluate the kidneys for changes related to reflux nephropathy.

DIAGNOSIS OF URETERAL OBSTRUCTION IN PATIENTS WITH COMPROMISED RENAL FUNCTION: THE ROLE OF NONINVASIVE IMAGING MODALITIES

We compared the role of noncontrast computerized tomography (NCCT), magnetic resonance urography (MRU), and combined abdominal radiography (KUB) and ultrasonography (US) in the diagnosis of the cause of ureteral obstruction in patients with compromised renal function.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

The study included 149 patients, of whom 110 had bilateral obstruction and 39 had obstruction of a solitary kidney. Therefore, the total number of renal units was 259. All patients had renal impairment with serum creatinine greater than 2.5 mg/dl. Besides conventional KUB and US all patients underwent NCCT and MRU. The gold standard for diagnosis of the cause of obstruction included retrograde or antegrade ureterogram, ureteroscopy and/or open surgery. The sensitivity, specificity and overall accuracy of NCCT, MRU, and combined KUB and US in the diagnosis of ureteral obstruction were calculated in comparison with the gold standard.

RESULTS

The definitive cause of ureteral obstruction was calculous in 146 and noncalculous in 113 renal units, including ureteral stricture in 65, bladder or ureter in 43, extraurinary collection in 3 and retroperitoneal fibrosis in 2. The site of stone impaction was identified by NCCT in all 146 renal units (100% sensitivity), by MRU in 101 (69.2% sensitivity), and by combined KUB and US in 115 (78.7% sensitivity) with a difference of significant value in favor of NCCT (p <0.001). Ureteral strictures were identified by NCCT in 18 of the 65 cases (28%) and by MRU in 54 of 65 (83%). Bladder and ureteral tumors causing ureteral obstruction could be diagnosed in approximately half of the patients by NCCT (22 of 43) and in all except 1 by MRU (42 of 43). NCCT and MRU could identify all extraurinary causes of obstruction. Overall of the 113 kidneys with noncalculous obstruction the cause could be identified by MRU in 101 (89% sensitivity), by NCCT in 45 (40% sensitivity), and by combined KUB and US in only 20 (18% sensitivity) with a difference of significant value in favor of MRU (p <0.001).

CONCLUSIONS

In patients with renal impairment due to ureteral obstruction NCCT has superior diagnostic accuracy for detecting calculous causes of obstruction but MRU is superior for identifying noncalculous lesions.

[Imaging of chronic and intermittent adult upper urinary tract obstruction]

State-of-the-art analysis of non invasive diagnostic imaging techniques to demonstrate upper urinary tract obstruction. Advances in imaging techniques are illustrated (sonography, CT scan, MRI). The imaging features of different presentations of chronic and intermittent obstruction are described with reference to current imaging modalities. New strategies for evaluation of chronic and intermittent upper urinary tract obstruction are proposed using ultrasonography as the first line examination. The role of MRI is illustrated. Causes of obstruction are classified based from the intraluminal, parietal or extrinsic location of the lesion.

Diagnosis of noncalcareous hydronephrosis: role of magnetic resonance urography and noncontrast computed tomography

OBJECTIVES

To evaluate the role of magnetic resonance urography (MRU) and noncontrast computed tomography (NCCT) in the diagnosis of noncalcareous hydronephrosis when excretory urography (intravenous urography) is either contraindicated or inconclusive.

METHODS

A total 108 consecutive patients with noncalcareous hydronephrosis were included in this study. In all patients, intravenous urography was either contraindicated or could not determine the diagnosis. In all patients, calculus obstruction was excluded by NCCT and all underwent heavily T2-weighted MRU. The final definitive diagnosis was established by retrograde or antegrade ureterography, endoscopy, or open surgery and was considered the reference standard for the diagnosis of obstruction. Normal kidneys in patients with unilateral obstruction were considered the reference standard for the absence of obstruction. The results of MRU were compared with those of NCCT regarding sensitivity, specificity, and overall accuracy.

RESULTS

Of the 108 patients, 5 had bilateral obstruction and the remaining 103 had unilateral obstruction. Of the latter group, 5 had a solitary kidney; therefore, the total number of renal units was 211 (113 obstructed and 98 normal units). Ureteral strictures were identified by NCCT in 15 (28%) of 54 and by MRU in 45 (83%) of 54 patients. Bladder, ureter, or prostate tumors causing ureteral obstruction could be diagnosed in one half of the 54 patients with such tumors by NCCT (27 of 54) and in all but 2 patients by MRU (52 of 54). Both NCCT and MRU could identify all extraurinary causes of obstruction. Overall, of the 113 kidneys with noncalculus obstruction, the cause could be identified by MRU in 102 (sensitivity of 90%) and by NCCT in 47 (sensitivity of 42%), a difference of statistically significant value in favor of MRU (P <0.001). The specificity of T2-weighted MRU and NCCT was 100% and 99%, respectively (not a statistically significant difference). The overall accuracy of T2-weighted MRU and NCCT was 95% and 68%, respectively (P <0.001).

CONCLUSIONS

In patients with ureteral obstruction in whom intravenous urography is not helpful and after NCCT has excluded stone disease, heavily T2-weighted MRU is a sensitive and specific method in the identification of the cause of obstruction.

Evaluation of renal growth by magnetic resonance imaging and computerized tomography volumes

PURPOSE

Magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) and computerized tomography (CT) are commonly used to image complex medical conditions but limited data have been reported concerning normal renal volumetric measurement with these imaging techniques. We examined whether normative renal growth curves could be constructed from data derived from these imaging modalities, and from these curves assessed normal and abnormal renal development.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Patients who had undergone prior renal MRI or CT were identified. Total renal volume and renal cortical fraction (CF, cortical/total volume) were calculated, and growth curves were derived. To examine the curve utility for abnormal growth assessment, renal ultrasonography of children with reflux nephropathy was examined, and MRI and radionuclide scans were compared.

RESULTS

A total of 60 patients 2 months to 39 years old who underwent MRI were included in the growth curve. The CF of the 120 kidneys was 75.8 +/- 4.3% and independent of sex and age. In 19 patients with vesicoureteral reflux 13 kidneys had cortical scarring, and the CF was decreased (p <0.001, 63.65 +/- 5.72%), indicating disproportionate cortical loss. No difference between CF for normal and vesicoureteral reflux unscarred kidneys was found. Differential renal function on radionuclide study correlated highly with MRI renal volume (r = 0.91). CT was performed in 70 children 1 to 15 years old (mean age 7.9) volume correlated with age and renal length, and the left kidney was larger than right kidney on MRI and CT.

CONCLUSIONS

Normative renal growth curves can be constructed from CT and MRI derived renal volumes. Cortical fraction is consistent, and sex and age independent. In reflux nephropathy the CF is reduced and renal differential function on nuclear scan correlates with MRI derived differential volume. This concept may be useful for predicting abnormal renal growth and differential function.

MR urography in evaluation of acute flank pain: T2-weighted sequences and gadolinium-enhanced three-dimensional FLASH compared with urography. Fast low-angle shot

OBJECTIVE

The aim of this study was to compare the usefulness of breath-hold heavily T2-weighted sequences with gadolinium-enhanced three-dimensional fast low-angle shot (3D FLASH) MR urography in the evaluation of patients with acute flank pain.

SUBJECTS AND METHODS

Forty consecutive patients with symptoms of acute flank pain underwent MR urography followed immediately by excretory urography. Heavily T2-weighted (combined thin-slice half-Fourier acquisition single-shot turbo spin-echo [HASTE] and thick-slab single-shot turbo spin-echo) and 3D FLASH sequences were evaluated separately and independently by two experienced radiologists for the presence, cause, level, and degree of obstruction. Interobserver agreement was calculated using the kappa statistic. Excretory urography and the final clinical diagnosis were used as reference.

RESULTS

Twenty-six patients were found to have unilateral obstruction caused by ureteral stones. Both MR urography methods were excellent for detecting obstruction. In the detection of stones 3D FLASH was superior, with a sensitivity of 96.2% and 100% and specificity of 100% and 100% for observers A and B, respectively, compared with a sensitivity of 57.7% and 53.8% and a specificity of 100% and 100%, respectively, for T2-weighted sequences. The best degree of obstruction was seen with 3D FLASH, and the interobserver agreement was excellent for stone detection (kappa = 0.97).

CONCLUSION

T2-weighted sequences alone are not sufficient for examining patients with acute flank pain. However, the combined use of both T2-weighted and 3D FLASH sequences will ensure better confidence in the evaluation of acute suspected renal colic. MR urography can replace conventional excretory urography when the latter is contraindicated or undesirable.

MR virtual endoscopy of the upper urinary tract

OBJECTIVE

We investigated the feasibility of applying surface-rendered virtual endoscopy to the visualization of the upper urinary tract by processing unenhanced MR urography data sets.

SUBJECTS AND METHODS

Twenty-six patients, having neoplastic lesions (n = 9), calculi (n = 8), pelviureteric junction stenoses (n = 4), postoperative fibrotic strictures (n = 3), and extrinsic compressions of the ureter (n = 2), underwent unenhanced MR urography. Virtual endoscopy of the upper urinary tract was obtained using a thresholding technique and surface-rendering MR urography data sets.

RESULTS

Virtual endoscopy of the renal pelvis and calices was feasible in all cases on the side of the urinary obstruction. Virtual endoscopy of the ureter was obtained for a diameter of at least larger than 5 mm. The nondilated side could be partially explored in 11 cases (43%). The mean virtual endoscopy threshold required for the visualization of the urinary tract was 157.36-159.94. The mean time for virtual endoscopy was 13.8 min. Endoluminal masses were found in three (12%) of 26 cases on the renal pelvis (corresponding to neoplastic lesions), and occlusions, in 23 (88%) of 26 on the pelviureteric junction and ureter (neoplastic lesions and other abnormalities).

CONCLUSION

Virtual endoscopy of MR urography data sets is feasible in patients with urinary tract dilatation. Virtual endoscopy displays the renal pelvis, calices, and ureter and, moreover, can show endoluminal changes caused by abnormalities.

Magnetic resonance urography enhanced by gadolinium and diuretics: a comparison with conventional urography in diagnosing the cause of ureteric obstruction

OBJECTIVE

To compare the ability of magnetic resonance urography (MRU), enhanced using gadolinium and frusemide diuresis, and conventional intravenous urography (IVU) to diagnose the cause of ureteric obstruction.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

The study included 82 patients in whom IVU showed or suggested obstruction and who also underwent MRU. The images from both methods were interpreted by various investigators independently; two evaluated the IVU and two others the MRU, the latter being unaware of the diagnosis after IVU. If the diagnosis remained unclear, further investigations (e.g. computed tomography, retrograde pyelography or ureteroscopy) were conducted.

RESULTS

The diagnoses were ureteric calculi in 72 patients, ureteric tumours in eight and extra-ureteric tumours in two. In those with urolithiasis, the diagnosis was correct with IVU in 49 patients and with MRU in 64. The diagnosis in this group was incorrect with MRU in only two patients. The main reason for the failure of IVU was absent contrast medium excretion. Three of eight patients with ureteric tumours were correctly diagnosed by IVU but in three patients the diagnosis was incorrect. MRU correctly diagnosed seven of the eight patients in this group, with no false diagnosis.

CONCLUSION

IVU is currently likely to remain the standard procedure for imaging the upper urinary tract, but this study shows the potential of MRU when enhanced with gadolinium and frusemide. MRU may be helpful if there is a dilated system with no excretory function, in pregnant women, in children and in those with contrast medium allergy.

Renal surgery in the new millennium

In the not too distant future, the minimally invasive renal surgeon will be able to practice an operation on a difficult case on a three-dimensional virtual reality simulator, providing all attributes of the real procedure. The patient's imaging studies will be imported into the simulator to better mimic particular anatomy. When confident enough of his or her skills, the surgeon will start operating on the patient using the same virtual reality simulator/telepresence surgery console system, which will permit the live surgery to be conducted by robots hundreds of miles away. The robots will manipulate miniature endoscopes or control minimally or noninvasive ablative technologies. Endoscopic/laparoscopic footage of the surgical procedure will be stored digitally in optical disks to be used later in telementoring of a surgery resident. All this and more will be possible in the not so distant third millennium.

State-of-the-art magnetic resonance imaging of the kidneys and upper urinary tract

State-of-the-art magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) is an excellent examination in several clinical contexts of interest to endourologists. First, it offers a one-stop imaging examination of prospective renal donors, obviating the need for arteriography and conventional excretory urography. Second, it reliably depicts urinary tract obstruction and can usually distinguish acute from chronic obstruction, although it is not as sensitive as helical CT in detecting small, nonobstructing stones. Third, it is an excellent examination for characterizing renal masses, especially complex cystic masses, and for surgical planning. Because MRI does not use ionizing radiation and because gadolinium contrast agents are essentially non-nephrotoxic, MRI is especially useful in children, women of childbearing age, and patients with renal insufficiency or renal allografts. Future developments will likely include MR "fluoroscopy," which will provide real-time imaging guidance for interventional procedures in the urinary tract.