Spontaneous hypoglycaemia in the presence of both anti-insulin antibody and anti-insulin receptor antibody

Levels of anti-insulin antibodies in diabetic retinopathy patients: an observational cross-sectional study

Aim: This study evaluated the levels of anti-insulin antibodies (AIAs) and the influence of some antidiabetic medications on AIA in diabetes mellitus (DM) patients with retinopathy. Patient & methods: An observational cross-sectional study. Results: A lower titer of AIA IgG was observed in the diabetic retinopathy (DR) and DM-only study categories compared with the control group [DR = 86 (5-560), DM-only = 50 (5-500), versus control = 200 (7-565); p = 0.017]. Taking nifedipine and metformin were negatively correlated (r = -0.32, p = 0.04) with the levels of AIA IgE in the DR group. Conclusion: A decreased titer of circulating AIAs was observed in the DR study category, suggesting that AIA may not contribute to the pathogenesis of DR.

Clopidogrel as a Distinctive Cause of Insulin Autoimmune Syndrome: A Systematic Case Review

The sulfhydryl group of clopidogrel metabolite could induce insulin autoimmune syndrome (IAS) with hypoglycemia as the major symptom. For patients with cardiovascular disease taking clopidogrel for vascular protection, this adverse event hypoglycemia increases the risk of cardiovascular events. However, discontinuing clopidogrel leaves patients without appropriate antiplatelet therapy. Treating IAS with glucocorticoids is also risky for these patients' primary cardiovascular diseases. Early recognition and appropriate treatment of clopidogrel-induced IAS (CIAS) would be beneficial for patients. This research aimed to discover the clinical features and investigate optimal therapeutic management of CIAS. We systematically searched for cases of CIAS in PubMed and Embase and performed data mining in Food and Drug Administration Adverse Event Reporting System (FAERS). In the CIAS series, clinical features were summarized and compared to 287 IAS cases, including demographic information, HLA alleles, onset, and symptoms. The therapeutic effect of glucocorticoids was compared between the receiving group and the not-receiving group. The possibilities of common antiplatelet drugs to induce hypoglycemia/IAS were investigated with chemical structure and FAERS reports. A CIAS series of 51 patients was established. CIAS had an onset age of 74.8±8.6 years old, 92.2% male, and a balanced proportion of East Asians and non-East Asians. Confusion occurred more frequently in CIAS than in IAS from various causes, while the other symptoms and hypoglycemia types were similar. The recovery time was approximately the same whether using glucocorticoids/immunotherapy in CIAS or not. Among common antiplatelet drugs, ticagrelor and rivaroxaban were unlikely to induce hypoglycemia/IAS. Clopidogrel is a distinctive cause of IAS featuring an elderly male presenting confusion as the symptom of hypoglycemia. Glucocorticoids/immunotherapy might not be necessary for the long-term recovery of CIAS. To balance the risks of hypoglycemia and cardiovascular events, substituting clopidogrel with ticagrelor and rivaroxaban might be considered.

Anti-Insulin Receptor Antibodies in the Pathology and Therapy of Diabetes Mellitus

Diabetes mellitus (DM) is recognized as the most common and the world's fastest-growing chronic disease with severe complications leading to increased mortality. Many strategies exist for the management of DM and its control, including treatment with insulin and insulin analogs, oral hypoglycemic therapy such as insulin secretion stimulators and insulin sensitizers, and diet and physical training. Over the years, many types of drugs and molecules with an interesting pharmacological diversity have been developed and proposed for their anti-diabetic potential. Such molecules target diverse key receptors, enzymes, and regulatory/signaling proteins known to be directly or indirectly involved in the pathophysiology of DM. Among them, insulin receptor (IR) is undoubtedly the target of choice for its central role in insulin-mediated glucose homeostasis and its utilization by the major insulin-sensitive tissues such as skeletal muscles, adipose tissue, and the liver. In this review, we focus on the implication of antibodies targeting IR in the pathology of DM as well as the recent advances in the development of IR antibodies as promising anti-diabetic drugs. The challenge still entails development of more powerful, highly selective, and safer anti-diabetic drugs.

Searching for the Culprit: When Diabetic Ketoacidosis Presents With Insulin Autoantibodies

Objective

The main objective was to describe and review a unique case that presented with diabetic ketoacidosis, positive insulin autoantibodies (IAAbs, which are found in Hirata disease and are usually present with hypoglycemia), and laboratory findings characteristic of type B insulin resistance syndrome (TBIRS) and systemic lupus erythematosus. Confirmation of TBIRS was obtained in Germany as immunoassay for insulin receptor antibodies (IRAbs) is not available in the United States.

Methods

A literature review on TBIRS and cases that present with IAAbs and IRAbs simultaneously was conducted.

Results

We found 6 cases presenting with hypoglycemia, both antibodies, and treatment attempts with various management approaches that were different from the proposed National Institutes of Health (NIH) protocol for TBIRS. Our case is distinct because of the demographic background, presentation with diabetic ketoacidosis, comparatively lower insulin requirement, and no significant hypoglycemic episodes in the third phase.

Conclusion

We propose that access to IRAb immunoassays may be important for diagnosing milder cases of TBIRS, while IAAbs may provide prognostic and therapeutic insights. Despite completely different presentation from other TBIRS patients reviewed, we observed that the proposed NIH protocol consisting of dexamethasone, rituximab, and cyclophosphamide was successfully employed in our patient. Thus, we propose that our case and the findings regarding antibody testing and the NIH treatment regimen may assist clinicians with earlier recognition and effective management of milder cases of TBIRS.

Association of Higher Circulating Insulin Antibody with Increased Mean Amplitude Glycemic Excursion in Patients with Type 2 Diabetes Mellitus: A Cross-Sectional, Retrospective Case-Control Study

Insulin antibody (IA) may potentially affect a patient's glycemic control due to its variability in both binding and/or releasing insulin. However, the association between IA titer and daily glycemic variability (GV) is still unknown. We thus performed this cross-sectional, retrospective case-control study to assess the relationship between IA titer and mean amplitude glycemic excursion (MAGE) in type 2 diabetes mellitus (T2DM) patients using a continuous glucose monitoring (CGM) system. We recruited 100 eligible patients (IA > 5%, IA positive) and divided them into two groups-a low (L) group and a high (H) group-based on their IA titer. The control (C) group consisted of 47 patients (IA ≤ 5%, IA negative) matched for age, BMI, gender, and glycosylated hemoglobin A1c (HbA1c). The CGM determined the GV of enrolled patients. The primary outcome was the relationship between the IA titer and the MAGE, and the secondary outcome was the differences of GV among the three groups. We found that patients in the H group had higher levels of blood glucose fluctuation parameters than those in the L and C groups. The Ln(IA) was positively correlated with Ln(MAGE) even after adjusting for age, gender, BMI, HbA1c, and fasting and postprandial C-peptide(r = 0.423, p < 0.001). Multiple linear stepwise regression analysis revealed that Ln(IA) was an independent factor of Ln(MAGE) (beta = 0.405, p < 0.001). In conclusion, the higher circulating IA titer was associated with increased MAGE in T2DM patients, indicating that those patients with elevated IA titer should receive GV assessment and individualized treatment.

The insulin autoimmune syndrome (IAS) as a cause of hypoglycaemia: an update on the pathophysiology, biochemical investigations and diagnosis

Insulin autoimmune syndrome (IAS) is considered to be very rare in Caucasians. Understanding its pathophysiology is paramount in (a) appreciating its potential impact on analyses of pancreatic hormones and (b) explaining its highly variable clinical manifestations in non-diabetic, non-acutely ill patients with indeterminate hypoglycaemia. The underlying aetiology of IAS is the presence of variable affinity/avidity endogenous insulin antibodies in significant amounts. The two types of insulin antibodies namely antibodies which bind insulin and/or proinsulin(s) and receptor antibodies (insulin mimetic) will be discussed. Their biochemical and immunological roles in causing hypoglycaemia will be highlighted. Clinical manifestations of IAS can vary from mild and transient to spontaneous, severe and protracted hypoglycaemia necessitating in extreme cases plasmapheresis for glycaemic control. Antibodies of IAS can interfere in pancreatic immunoassay tests causing erroneous and potentially misleading results. Thorough testing for endogenous insulin antibodies must be considered in the investigations of non-diabetic, non-acutely ill patients with indeterminate and/or unexplained hypoglycaemia.

Type B insulin resistance syndrome

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

To review the epidemiology, pathophysiology, clinical features, and management of type B insulin resistance syndrome.

RECENT FINDINGS

Type B insulin resistance syndrome is a rare disorder caused by autoantibodies to the insulin receptor. This disorder is most frequently reported in middle-aged black women and is invariably associated with other autoimmune diseases. Typically, refractory transient hyperglycemia and extreme insulin resistance are the cardinal features, but hypoglycemia may also occur. Traditionally, the high reported mortality rate was typically attributed to the hypoglycemia. There is no well standardized treatment regimen. However, recent therapeutic advances with combination immunomodulatory therapy have led to significant reported improvements in hypoglycemia-associated mortality and durability of remission.

SUMMARY

We review the literature on the pathophysiology and clinical features of type B insulin resistance syndrome and highlight the complexities and recent advances in the management of this disorder.

Recurrent hypoglycemia from insulin autoimmune syndrome

Insulin autoimmune syndrome (IAS) is an uncommon cause of hyperinsulinemic hypoglycemia characterized by autoantibodies to endogenous insulin in individuals without previous exposure to exogenous insulin. IAS is the third leading cause of spontaneous hypoglycemia in Japan, and is increasingly being recognized worldwide in non-Asian populations. We report a case of IAS in a Caucasian woman with recurrent complaints of hypoglycemia, with laboratory findings of serum glucose 2.5 mmol/L (45 mg/dL), insulin 54,930 pmol/L (7,909 μIU/mL), connecting peptide (C-peptide) 4,104 pmol/L (12.4 ng/mL), and a corresponding insulin to C-peptide molar ratio of 13.4 during a spontaneous hypoglycemic event. Autoantibodies to insulin were markedly elevated at > 50 kU/L (> 50 U/mL). IAS should be considered in the differential diagnosis of hypoglycemia in non-diabetic individuals. Distinction from insulinoma is especially crucial to prevent unwarranted invasive procedures and surgical interventions in hypoglycemic patients.

Identifying and reducing potentially wrong immunoassay results even when plausible and "not-unreasonable"

The primary role of the clinical laboratory is to report accurate results for diagnosis of disease and management of illnesses. This goal has, to a large extent been achieved for routine biochemical tests, but not for immunoassays which remained susceptible to interference from endogenous immunoglobulin antibodies, causing false, and clinically misleading results. Clinicians regard all abnormal results including false ones as "pathological" necessitating further investigations, or concluding iniquitous diagnosis. Even more seriously, "false-negative" results may wrongly exclude pathology, thus denying patients' necessary treatment. Analytical error rate in immunoassays is relatively high, ranging from 0.4% to 4.0%. Because analytical interference from endogenous antibodies is confined to individuals' sera, it can be inconspicuous, pernicious, sporadic, and insidious because it cannot be detected by internal or external quality assessment procedures. An approach based on Bayesian reasoning can enhance the robustness of clinical validation in highlighting potentially erroneous immunoassay results. When this rational clinical/statistical approach is followed by analytical affirmative follow-up tests, it can help identifying inaccurate and clinically misleading immunoassay data even when they appear plausible and "not-unreasonable." This chapter is largely based on peer reviewed articles associated with and related to this approach. The first section underlines (without mathematical equations) the dominance and misuse of conventional statistics and the underuse of Bayesian paradigm and shows that laboratorians are intuitively (albeit unwittingly) practicing Bayesians. Secondly, because interference from endogenous antibodies is method's dependent (with numerous formats and different reagents), it is almost impossible to accurately assess its incidence in all differently formulated immunoassays and for each analytes/biomarkers. However, reiterating the basic concepts underpinning interference from endogenous antibodies can highlight why interference will remain analytically pernicious, sporadic, and an inveterate problem. The following section discuses various stratagems to reduce this source of inaccuracy in current immunoassay results including the role of Bayesian reasoning. Finally, the role of three commonly used follow-up affirmative tests and their interpretation in confirming analytical interference is discussed.

Severe hypoglycemia secondary to methimazole-induced insulin autoimmune syndrome in a 16 year old African-American male

Insulin autoimmune syndrome (IAS) or Hirata's disease is a rare disorder characterized by hypoglycemia secondary to insulin autoantibodies (IAb). Over 200 patients have been described from Japan with significantly less numbers being reported from outside the Orient. IAS is more common in patients older than 40 yr of age with reports in the pediatric age group being notably rarer. Exposure to sulfhydryl group containing medications is implicated in the pathogenesis of this syndrome. In this report, we describe a case of IAS in an African-American adolescent. A 16-yr-old healthy African-American male was diagnosed with Graves' disease and started on Methimazole. Four weeks later, he was found unconscious and hypoglycemic (blood sugar 1.5 mmol/L). Evaluation was negative for insulinoma. Insulin antibodies were positive. Oral glucose tolerance test revealed elevated free insulin concentrations with disproportionately elevated total insulin levels. The patient was started on prednisone, diazoxide, and propranolol for management of IAS and hyperthyroidism. Thyroid radio-ablation was subsequently undertaken. The doses of prednisone and diazoxide were tapered and these medications discontinued after 9 months. The insulin antibody levels decreased gradually and became undetectable in 6 months with resolution of the hypoglycemia.

High prevalence of both anti-insulin and anti-insulin receptor antibodies in Korean patients with insulin autoimmune syndrome

We performed a retrospective pooled analysis of 28 patients who had been diagnosed with insulin autoimmune syndrome and evaluated the prevalence of anti-insulin receptor antibodies. Dual positivity for anti-insulin and anti-insulin receptor antibodies was common (53.8%). However, these patients had a similar phenotype compared with insulin receptor antibody-negative patients.

Probabilistic Bayesian reasoning can help identifying potentially wrong immunoassays results in clinical practice: even when they appear ‘not-unreasonable’

Background

Immunoassays are susceptible to analytical interferences including from endogenous immunoglobulin antibodies at a rate of ∼0.4% to 4%. Hundreds of millions of immunoassay tests (>10 millions in the UK alone) are performed yearly worldwide for measurements of an array of large and small moieties such as proteins, hormones, tumour markers, rheumatoid factor, troponin, small peptides, steroids and drugs.

Methods

Interference in these tests can lead to false results which when suspected, or surmised, can be analytically confirmed in most cases. Suspecting false laboratory data in the first place is not difficult when results are gross and without clinical correlates. However, when false results are subtle and/or plausible, it can be difficult to suspect with adverse clinical sequelae. This problem can be ameliorated by using a probabilistic Bayesian reasoning to flag up potentially suspect results even when laboratory data appear “not-unreasonable”.

Results

Essentially, in disorders with low prevalence, the majority of positive results caused by analytical interference are likely to be false positives. On the other hand, when the disease prevalence is high, false negative results increase and become more significant. To illustrate the scope and utility of this approach, six different examples covering wide range of analytes are given, each highlighting specific aspect/nature of interference and suggested options to reduce it.

Conclusion

Bayesian reasoning would allow laboratorians and/or clinicians to extract information about potentially false results, thus seeking follow-up confirmatory tests prior to the initiation of more expensive/invasive procedures or concluding a potentially wrong diagnosis.

Autoimmune forms of hypoglycemia

Autoimmune syndromes are a rare cause of hypoglycemia characterized by elevated levels of insulin in the presence of either anti-insulin antibodies (insulin autoimmune syndrome) or anti-insulin receptor antibodies (type B insulin resistance). Insulin autoimmune syndrome is the third leading cause of hypoglycemia in Japan, but has rarely been described in the non-Asian population.In the current study, we report the clinical and biochemical characteristics and clinical course of 2 white patients with insulin autoimmune syndrome, and present a literature review of non-Asian patients reported with insulin autoimmune syndrome. Also, we describe the clinical and biochemical characteristics of patients reported in the literature with type B insulin resistance who manifested hypoglycemia. We compare the clinical and laboratory features of insulin autoimmune syndrome and type B insulin resistance with each other and with other forms of hyperinsulinemic hypoglycemia.Autoimmune forms of hypoglycemia are uncommon. However, they should be considered in any patient with hypoglycemia in the setting of unsuppressed insulin levels associated with anti-insulin or anti-insulin receptor antibodies. Making the correct diagnosis may spare a hypoglycemic patient from an unnecessary pancreatic surgical procedure.