Recent developments in the encoding and deconvolution of combinatorial libraries

High-Throughput Synthesis of Diverse Compound Collections for Lead Discovery and Optimization

Small-molecule intervention of protein function is one central dogma of drug discovery. The generation of small-molecule libraries fuels the discovery pipeline at many stages and thereby resembles a key aspect of this endeavor. High-throughput synthesis is a major source for compound libraries utilized in academia and industry, seeking new chemical modulators of pharmacological targets. Here, we discuss the crucial factors of library design strategies from the perspective of synthetic chemistry, giving a brief historic background and a summary of current approaches. Simple measures of success of a high-throughput synthesis such as quantity or diversity have long been discarded and replaced by more integrated measures. Case studies are presented and put into context to highlight the cross-connectivity of the various stages of the drug discovery process.

Small-molecule discovery from DNA-encoded chemical libraries

Researchers seeking to improve the efficiency and cost effectiveness of the bioactive small-molecule discovery process have recently embraced selection-based approaches, which in principle offer much higher throughput and simpler infrastructure requirements compared with traditional small-molecule screening methods. Since selection methods benefit greatly from an information-encoding molecule that can be readily amplified and decoded, several academic and industrial groups have turned to DNA as the basis for library encoding and, in some cases, library synthesis. The resulting DNA-encoded synthetic small-molecule libraries, integrated with the high sensitivity of PCR and the recent development of ultra high-throughput DNA sequencing technology, can be evaluated very rapidly for binding or bond formation with a target of interest while consuming minimal quantities of material and requiring only modest investments of time and equipment. In this tutorial review we describe the development of two classes of approaches for encoding chemical structures and reactivity with DNA: DNA-recorded library synthesis, in which encoding and library synthesis take place separately, and DNA-directed library synthesis, in which DNA both encodes and templates library synthesis. We also describe in vitro selection methods used to evaluate DNA-encoded libraries and summarize successful applications of these approaches to the discovery of bioactive small molecules and novel chemical reactivity.

High Throughput Chemistry in Drug Discovery

This chapter outlines the evolution of high throughput chemistry from its origins in the genome revolution of the early 1990's to its current practice as an integral tool in drug discovery, via the concept of the large “universal library” to the practice of small targeted arrays for structure–activity relationship generation. The technologies developed as part of this evolution are also outlined including early ACT peptide synthesisers and other automated and non-automated devices for both solid-supported and solution-based approaches. Finally, the chapter outlines several case studies of the application of high throughput synthesis to drug discovery.

De novo sequencing of peptides on single resin beads by MALDI-FTICR tandem mass spectrometry

An efficient approach in combinatorial chemistry is the synthesis of one-bead-one-compound peptide libraries. In contrast to synthesis and functional screening, which is performed in a largely automated manner, structure determination has been frequently laborious and time-consuming. Here we report an approach for de novo sequencing of peptides on single beads by matrix-assisted laser desorption/ionization Fourier transform ion cyclotron resonance (MALDI-FTICR) tandem mass spectrometry, using a resin with a photolinker for solid-phase peptide synthesis. Upon sorting out single beads, an efficient sample preparation on the MALDI target was developed that enables fragmentation upon irradiation of the bead-matrix mixture with the ultraviolet (UV)-MALDI laser, with enhanced yield of sequence-specific fragment ions at increased laser energy. This approach is illustrated by sequence determinations of two peptides from a library with sequences varying in a single amino acid; the feasibility with tandem-MS procedures and fragment ion assignment was ascertained by sustained off-resonance irradiation/collision induced dissociation (SORI/CID) and infrared multiphoton dissociation (IRMPD) fragmentation.

A general method for designing combinatorial peptide libraries decodable by amino acid analysis

Herein we describe an algorithm for designing combinatorial peptide libraries for split-and-mix synthesis on solid support that are decodable by amino acid analysis (AAA) of the beads. AAA is a standard service analysis available in most biochemical laboratories, and it allows one to control the quality of the peptide on each bead, an important feature that is missing from most library decoding protocols. In the algorithm, each AA is assigned to two variable positions in the sequence grouped in a "unique pair". This arrangement limits sequence design because both the number of unique pairs U (setting the maximum number of variable AA) and the maximum number S of different AA per variable position depend on the peptide length N (U=N(N-1)/2), S=N-1). The method is therefore only suitable for focused libraries. An application example is shown for the selection of peptides with N-terminal proline or hydroxyproline catalyzing an aldol reaction from a combinatorial library of 65536 octapeptides. A simple enumeration program is available to help design combinatorial libraries decodable by amino acid analysis. The method applies to linear and cyclic peptides, can be used for nonnatural building blocks, including beta-amino acids, and should help to explore the vast chemistry of linear and cyclic peptide for catalysis and bioactivity.

1,3,5-triazine-based mass spectral tagging of one-bead one-compound libraries

A triazine-based mass encoding strategy that accommodates cleavable linker, isotopic labeling, and diversity receptor moieties is reported. The resulting triazine-based tags, which are coupled to bifunctionalized TentaGel resin in a one-pot transformation, enable the construction of a 1-oxa-2,8-diazaspiro[4.5]dec-2-ene-7-carboxamide library and facilitate decoding by equalizing the ionization potential of the liberated tags in single bead MALDI-TOF experiments as well as balancing the reactivity of the starting tags in the resin coupling step. [reaction: see text].

OBOC small-molecule combinatorial library encoded by halogenated mass-tags

[reaction: see text] A bromine-/chlorine-containing mass-tag encoding strategy for a small-molecule OBOC combinatorial library is reported. The resulting MALDI FTMS isotope pattern of each tag clearly defines the component building blocks of each "hit" bead in an 1890-member demonstration library screened on-bead for binding against streptavidin via both enzyme-linked colorimetric and Quantum Dot/COPAS assays.

Cleavable Hydrophilic Linker for One-Bead-One-Compound Sequencing of Oligomer Libraries by Tandem Mass Spectrometry

We have developed a method for the rapid and unambiguous identification of sequences of hit compounds from one-bead-one-compound combinatorial libraries of peptide and peptoid ligands. The approach uses a cleavable linker that is hydrophilic to help reduce nonspecific binding to biological samples and allows for the attachment of a halogen tag, which greatly facilitates post-screening sequencing by tandem mass spectrometry (MS/MS). The linker is based on a tartaric acid unit, which, upon cleavage from resin, generates a C-terminal aldehyde. This aldehyde can then be derivatized with a bromine-containing amino-oxy compound that serves as an isotope tag for subsequent MS/MS analysis of y-ion fragments. We have applied this linker and method to the syntheses of a number of peptoids that vary in sequence and length and have also demonstrated single-bead sequencing of a peptoid pentamer. The linker is also shown to have very low levels of nonspecific binding to proteins.

Vibrational spectroscopic encoding of polystyrene-based resin beads: converting the encoding peaks into barcodes

A detailed approach is described for the vibrational spectroscopic encoding of polystyrene-based resin beads by converting the infrared absorption peaks suitable for encoding (encoding peaks) into barcodes. Based on combining the FT-IR measurements and the quantum-chemical computations, the vibrational characteristics of p-tert-butylstyrene monomer, polystyrene and poly(p-tert-butylstyrene) resin beads are analyzed, which are helpful for the selection of encoding peaks. The vibrational spectroscopic encoding of polystyrene-based resin beads could be obtained by converting the wavenumber, intensity and full width at half maximum (FWHM) of the encoding peaks into barcodes automatically through a computer program designed in our laboratory.

New approaches in identifying drugs to inactivate oncogene products

With an information explosion on the molecular mechanism of oncogenesis, the completion of the human genome sequence project, and the advances in genomic and proteomic methods, many therapeutic targets for various cancers have been identified. It is timely that a number of new drug development techniques have been developed in this last decade. Candidate drug targets can now be efficiently validated with RNA interference and transgenic animals studies. Combinatorial chemistry provides large numbers of chemical compounds for drug lead discovery and optimization. High throughput assays and high content cell-based assays, in conjunction with sophisticated robotics, are now available for screening large numbers of compounds. Based on X-ray crystallographic structure data, drug leads can be discovered through in silico screening of virtual libraries. By applying these various drug discovery techniques, it is anticipated that more potent and specific anti-cancer agents will be discovered within the next decade.

Encoding Method for OBOC Small Molecule Libraries Using a Biphasic Approach for Ladder-Synthesis of Coding Tags

In the "one-bead one-compound" (OBOC) combinatorial library method, each compound bead displays only one compound entity. Hundreds of thousands to millions of compound beads can be synthesized rapidly and screened simultaneously. Positive compound beads are then isolated for structural analysis. To fully exploit the power of OBOC combinatorial small molecule libraries, a robust and high throughput encoding method is needed to decode the positive compound beads. In this paper, we report on the development of a novel encoding strategy that combines the concepts of ladder-synthesis and chemical encoding on bilayer beads. In these encoded libraries, small molecule compounds are displayed on the bead surface, and cleavable coding tags consisting of a series of truncated molecules reside in the bead interior. Such a library can be easily constructed using the biphasic approach (J. Am. Chem. Soc.2002, 124, 7678) to topologically segregate the functionalities of the beads during library synthesis. The ladder members and coding tags are then released for MALDI-TOF-MS analysis. To simplify the interpretation of the mass spectra, we purposely add bromine into the cleavable linker so that the cleavage products generate a characteristic isotope fingerprint. The chemical structure of library compounds can be determined by analyzing the mass differences between adjacent peaks on the mass spectra. This encoding strategy also provides valuable information on the quality of the testing compound on the surface of the bead. To validate this methodology, a model OBOC small molecule library with 12,288 members was synthesized on TentaGel beads and screened against streptavidin. The chemical structures of the compound on each positive bead were unambiguously identified.

A novel and rapid encoding method based on mass spectrometry for "one-bead-one-compound" small molecule combinatorial libraries

A novel and efficient encoding method based on mass spectrometry for "one-bead-one-compound" small molecule combinatorial libraries has been developed. The topologically segregated bifunctional resin beads with orthogonal protecting groups in the outer and inner regions are first prepared according to our previously published procedure. Prior to library synthesis, the inner core of each bead is derivatized with 3-4 different coding blocks on a cleavable linker. Each functional group on the scaffold is encoded by an individual coding block containing a functional group with the same chemical reactivity. During the library synthesis, the same chemical reactions take place on the scaffold (outer layer of the bead) and coding blocks (inner core of the bead) concurrently. After screening, the coding tags in the positive beads are released, followed by molecular mass determination using matrix-assisted laser desorption ionization Fourier transform mass spectrometry. The chemical structure of library compounds can be readily identified according to the molecular masses of the coding tags. The feasibility and efficiency of this approach were demonstrated by the synthesis and screening of a model small molecule library containing 84 672 member compounds, with a model receptor, streptavidin. Streptavidin binding ligands with structural similarity (17) were identified. The decoding results were clear and unambiguous.

High-throughput one-bead-one-compound approach to peptide-encoded combinatorial libraries: MALDI-MS analysis of single TentaGel beads

The identification of pharmacologically promising compounds (lead compounds) from combinatorial libraries is frequently limited by the throughput of the analytical technique employed. Fourier transform mass spectrometry (FTMS) offers high sensitivity, mass accuracy (m/Deltam > 500 000), and sequencing capabilities. A rapid and efficient method for high-throughput analysis of single beads from peptide-encoded combinatorial libraries with matrix-assisted laser desorption/ionization (MALDI) mass spectrometry is presented. Encoding peptides on single beads are identified and structurally characterized by MALDI time-of-flight (TOF) and ultrahigh-resolution MALDI Fourier transform ion cyclotron resonance (FT-ICR) mass spectrometry. A strategy of on-probe sample preparation is developed to minimize handling of the beads.

Combinatorial peptide library methods for immunobiology research

The field of combinatorial peptide chemistry has emerged as a powerful tool in the study of many biological systems. This review focuses on combinatorial peptide library methodology, which includes biological library methods, spatially addressable parallel library methods, library methods requiring deconvolution, the "one-bead one-compound" library method, and affinity chromatography selection method. These peptide libraries have successfully been employed to study a vast array of cell surface receptors, as well as have been useful in identifying protein kinase substrates and inhibitors. In recent immunobiological applications, peptide libraries have proven monumental in the definition of MHC anchor residues, in lymphocyte epitope mapping, and in the development of peptide vaccines. Peptides identified from such libraries, when presented in a chemical microarray format, may prove useful in immunodiagnostics. Combinatorial peptide libraries offer a high-throughput approach to study limitless biological targets. Peptides discovered from such studies may be therapeutically and diagnostically useful agents.

Automated mass spectrometric sequence determination of cyclic peptide library members

Cyclic peptides have come under scrutiny as potential antimicrobial therapeutic agents. Combinatorial split-and-pool synthesis of cyclic peptides can afford single compound per well libraries for antimicrobial screening, new lead identification, and construction of quantitative structure-activity relationships (QSAR). Here, we report a new sequencing protocol for rapid identification of the members of a cyclic peptide library based on automated computer analysis of mass spectra, obviating the need for library encoding/decoding strategies. Furthermore, the software readily integrates with common spreadsheet and database packages to facilitate data visualization and archiving. The utility of the new MS-sequencing approach is demonstrated using sonic spray ionization ion trap MS and MS/MS spectrometry on a single compound per bead cyclic peptide library and validated with individually synthesized pure cyclic D,L-alpha-peptides.

A novel peptide-based encoding system for "one-bead one-compound" peptidomimetic and small molecule combinatorial libraries

The "one-bead one-compound" (OBOC) combinatorial library method is highly efficient, especially when used with well-established on-bead binding or functional assays. Literally, millions of compounds can be screened concurrently within 1 to 2 days. However, structure determination of peptidomimetic and small molecule compounds on one single bead is not trivial. A novel, highly efficient, and robust peptide-based encoding system has been developed for OBOC peptidomimetic and small molecule combinatorial libraries. In this system, topologically segregated bifunctional beads, which are made by a simple biphasic solvent strategy, are employed for the preparation and screening of an OBOC combinatorial peptidomimetic and small molecule libraries. Testing molecules are on the outer layer, and the coding tags in the interior of the bead do not interfere with screening. The coding tag is a peptide containing a large number of unnatural alpha-amino acids derived from different building blocks used for generating the peptidomimetic or small molecule. By coupling common building blocks simultaneously to the scaffold of the testing compound and to the side chains of the alpha-amino acids on the coding peptide, extra synthetic steps are eliminated and the amount of undesirable side products is minimized. Positive bead decoding is easy and straightforward as there is no need for cleavage and retrieval of the coding tag, and positive beads can be sequenced directly with Edman degradation. To demonstrate the efficiency and simplicity of our encoding system, an encoded 158 400-member model peptidomimetic library has been generated and screened for ligands that bind to streptavidin. Potent and novel ligands with clear motifs have been identified.

Diversity-oriented synthesis of biaryl-containing medium rings using a one bead/one stock solution platform

Diversity-oriented synthesis of structurally complex and diverse small molecules can be used as the first step in a process to explore cellular and organismal pathways. The success of this process is likely going to be dependent on advances in the synthesis of small molecules having natural product-like structures in an efficient and stereoselective manner. The development, scope, and mechanism of the oxidation of organocuprates was investigated and exploited in the atropdiastereoselective synthesis of biaryl-containing medium rings (9-, 10-, and 11-membered rings). The methodology was performed on high-capacity, large polystyrene beads by metalating aryl bromides with i-PrBu(2)MgLi, followed by transmetalating with CuCN x 2LiBr and then oxidizing with 1,3-dinitrobenzene, and was used in a diversity-oriented synthesis of biaryl-containing medium rings (library total theoretical maximum 1412 members). The high capacity beads were arrayed into 384-well plates and, using a process optimized during the development of a one bead/one stock solution technology platform, converted into arrays of stock solutions, with each stock solution containing largely one compound. These stock solutions were used in numerous phenotypic and protein-binding assays. The process described outlines a pathway that we feel will contribute to a comprehensive and systematic chemical approach to exploring biology (chemical genetics).

Combinatorial libraries and biological discovery

Combinatorial chemistry has become a popular tool for the preparation of collections of compounds that can be used to find inhibitors and substrates for different protein targets. It has evolved to provide small molecule libraries, which, with the concomittant use of affinity chromatography, gene expression profiling and complementation, can be used to identify compounds and their protein targets in biological systems, including the neurological system.

Solutions for library encoding to create collections of discrete compounds

The ability to design, produce, analyze, and manage high quality combinatorial libraries depends on the encoding strategy applied. Several recent advances in encoding technology have extended the range of library design parameters. Enhancements of established techniques have made them more robust and versatile, while additional new and creative encoding concepts have been introduced. With better options now available, combinatorial chemists can more easily select an encoding technique to match resources, library design, and compound management criteria.