High yield of endoreduplication induced by ICRF-193: a topoisomerase II catalytic inhibitor

Investigation of nuclear enzyme topoisomerase as a putative molecular target of monohaloacetonitrile disinfection by-products

Disinfection by-products occur widely as the unintended effect of water disinfection and are associated with toxicity and adverse human health effects. Yet the molecular mechanisms of their toxicity are not well understood. To investigate the molecular basis of hyperploidy induction by monohaloacetonitriles, the interaction of monohaloacetonitriles with topoisomerase II in Chinese hamster ovary cells was examined. We showed a concentration-dependent inhibition of DNA decatenation activity of topoisomerase under acellular conditions while in vitro monohaloacetonitrile treatment expressed mixed results. The working hypothesis, that topoisomerase II is a molecular target of monohaloacetonitriles, was only partially supported. Nevertheless, this research serves as a starting point toward molecular mechanisms of toxic action of monohaloacetonitriles.

The DNA topoisomerase II catalytic inhibitor merbarone is genotoxic and induces endoreduplication

In the last years a number of reports have shown that the so-called topoisomerase II (topo II) catalytic inhibitors are able to induce DNA and chromosome damage, an unexpected result taking into account that they do not stabilize topo II-DNA cleavable complexes, a feature of topo II poisons such as etoposide and amsacrine. Merbarone inhibits the catalytic activity of topo II by blocking DNA cleavage by the enzyme. While it was first reported that merbarone does not induce genotoxic effects in mammalian cells, this has been challenged by reports showing that the topo II inhibitor induces efficiently chromosome and DNA damage, and the question as to a possible behavior as a topo II poison has been put forward. Given these contradictory results, and the as yet incomplete knowledge of the molecular mechanism of action of merbarone, in the present study we have tried to further characterize the mechanism of action of merbarone on cell proliferation, cell cycle, as well as chromosome and DNA damage in cultured CHO cells. Merbarone was cytotoxic as well as genotoxic, inhibited topo II catalytic activity, and induced endoreduplication. We have also shown that merbarone-induced DNA damage depends upon ongoing DNA synthesis. Supporting this, inhibition of DNA synthesis causes reduction of DNA damage and increased cell survival.

The role of the DNA hypermethylating agent Budesonide in the decatenating activity of DNA topoisomerase II

Catenations between sister chromatids result from DNA replication and must be resolved to ensure proper chromatid segregation in mitosis. Functionally active Topoisomerase II (Topo II), through its mechanism of concerted breaking and rejoining of double stranded DNA, is required to carry out this fundamental process. In previous studies we have shown that modifications in DNA sequence by halogenated pyrimidines and by the demethylating agent 5-azacytidine leads to malfunction of Topo II that results in an increased yield of endorreduplicated cells as a result of segregation failure. In the present work we have evaluated the possible influence of the methylating agent Budesonide to modify the frequency of endoreduplicated cells in AA8 Chinese hamster cell population. Our results seem to indicate that when Budesonide was administered for two consecutive cell cycles did induce an increase in the yield of endoreduplicated cells, as previously observed for the hypomethylating agent 5-azaC. We have also examined the possible relationship between extensive hypermethylation induced by Budesonide in DNA and stabilization of cleavable complexes by m-AMSA. Taken as a whole, our results show that the degree of methylation in DNA correlates with the effectiveness of m-AMSA to stabilize the Topo II-DNA complexes and to induce DNA cleavage. These findings evidence for the first time the functional importance of DNA hyper- and hypomethylation changes as epigenetic factors able to modulate Topo II activity for proper chromosome segregation.

Rad9A is required for G2 decatenation checkpoint and to prevent endoreduplication in response to topoisomerase II inhibition

The Rad9A checkpoint protein interacts with and is required for proper localization of topoisomerase II-binding protein 1 (TopBP1) in response to DNA damage. Topoisomerase II (Topo II), another binding partner of TopBP1, decatenates sister chromatids that become intertwined during replication. Inhibition of Topo II by ICRF-193 (meso-4,4'-(3,2-butanediyl)-bis-(2,6-piperazinedione)), a catalytic inhibitor that does not induce DNA double-strand breaks, causes a mitotic delay known as the G(2) decatenation checkpoint. Here, we demonstrate that this checkpoint, dependent on ATR and BRCA1, also requires Rad9A. Analysis of different Rad9A phosphorylation mutants suggests that these modifications are required to prevent endoreduplication and to maintain decatenation checkpoint arrest. Furthermore, Rad9A Ser(272) is phosphorylated in response to Topo II inhibition. ICRF-193 treatment also causes phosphorylation of an effector kinase downstream of Rad9A in the DNA damage checkpoint pathway, Chk2, at Thr(68). Both of these sites are major targets of phosphorylation by the ATM kinase, although it has previously been shown that ATM is not required for the decatenation checkpoint. Examination of ataxia telangectasia (A-T) cells demonstrates that ATR does not compensate for ATM loss, suggesting that phosphorylation of Rad9A and Chk2 by ATM plays an additional role in response to Topo II inhibition than checkpoint function alone. Finally, we have shown that murine embryonic stem cells deficient for Rad9A have higher levels of catenated mitotic spreads than wild-type counterparts. Together, these results emphasize the importance of Rad9A in preserving genomic integrity in the presence of catenated chromosomes and all types of DNA aberrations.

The benzene metabolite, hydroquinone and etoposide both induce endoreduplication in human lymphoblastoid TK6 cells

Both occupational exposure to the leukemogen benzene and in vitro exposure to its metabolite hydroquinone (HQ) lead to the induction of numerical and structural chromosome changes. Several studies have shown that HQ can form DNA adducts, disrupt microtubule assembly and inhibit DNA topoisomerase II (topo II) activity. As these are potential mechanisms underlying endoreduplication (END), a phenomenon that involves DNA amplification without corresponding cell division, we hypothesized that HQ could cause END. We measured END in the human lymphoblastoid cell line, TK6, treated with HQ (0-20 microM) and etoposide (0-0.2 microM) for 48 h. Etoposide was used as a positive control as it is a topo II poison and established human leukemogen that has previously been shown to induce END in Chinese hamster ovary cells. Both HQ and etoposide significantly induced END in a dose-dependent manner (P(trend) < 0.0001 and P(trend) = 0.0003, respectively). Since END may underlie the acquisition of high chromosome numbers by tumour cells, it may play a role in inducing genomic instability and subsequent carcinogenesis from HQ and etoposide. In order to further explore the cytogenetic effects of HQ and etoposide, we also examined specific structural changes. HQ did not induce translocations of chromosome 11 [t(11;?)] but significantly induced translocations of chromosome 21 [t(21;?)] and structural chromosome aberrations (SCA) (P(trend) = 0.0415 and P(trend) < 0.0001, respectively). Etoposide potently induced all these structural changes (P(trend) < 0.0001). The lack of an effect of HQ on t(11;?) and the reduced ability of HQ to induce t(21;?) and SCA, compared with etoposide, further suggests that HQ acts primarily as a topo II catalytic inhibitor rather than as a topo II poison in intact human cells.

The high rate of endoreduplication in the repair deficient CHO mutant EM9 parallels a reduced level of methylated deoxycytidine in DNA

It has been recently proposed that hypomethylation of DNA induced by 5-azacytidine (5-azaC) leads to reduced chromatid decatenation that ends up in endoreduplication, most likely due to a failure in topo II function [S. Mateos, I. Domínguez, N. Pastor, G. Cantero, F. Cortés, The DNA demethylating 5-azaC induces endoreduplication in cultured Chinese hamster cells, Mutat. Res. 578 (2005) 33-42]. The Chinese hamster mutant cell line EM9 has a high spontaneous frequency of endoreduplication as compared to its parental line AA8. In order to see if this is related to the degree of DNA methylation, we have investigated the basal levels of both endpoints in AA8 and EM9, as well as the effect of extensive 5-azaC-induced demethylation on the production of endoreduplication. Based on the correlation between the levels of DNA methylation and indices of endoreduplication we propose that genomic DNA hypomethylation in EM9 cell line is probably an important factor that bears significance in relation to the high basal level of endoreduplication observed in this cell line.

Halogen substitution of DNA protects from poisoning of topoisomerase II that results in DNA double-strand breaks

DNA topoisomerase II (topo II), a fundamental nuclear enzyme, cleaves the double-stranded DNA molecule at preferred sequences within its recognition/binding sites. We have recently reported [F. Cortés, N. Pastor, S. Mateos, I. Domínguez, The nature of DNA plays a role in chromosome segregation: endoreduplication in halogen-substituted chromosomes, DNA Repair 2 (2003) 719-726] that when cells incorporate halogenated nucleosides analogues of thymidine into DNA, it interferes with normal chromosome segregation, as shown by an extraordinarily high yield of endoreduplication. The frequency of endoreduplicated cells paralleled the level of analogue substitution into DNA, lending support to the idea that thymidine analogue substitution into DNA is most likely responsible for the triggering of endoreduplication. Using the pulsed-field gel electrophoresis (PFGE) technique, we have now analyzed a possible protection provided by the incorporation of exogenous halogenated nucleosides against DNA breakage induced by the topo II poison m-AMSA. The result was that the different halogenated nucleosides were shown as able to protect DNA from double-strand breaks induced by m-AMSA depending such a protection upon the relative percent of incorporation of a given thymidine analogue into DNA. Our results clearly indicate that the presence of halogenated nucleosides in DNA diminishes the frequency of interaction of topo II with DNA and thus the frequency with which cleavage can occur.

Cell cycle-dependent DNA damage signaling induced by ICRF-193 involves ATM, ATR, CHK2, and BRCA1

Topoisomerase II is essential for cell proliferation and survival and has been a target of various anticancer drugs. ICRF-193 has long been used as a catalytic inhibitor to study the function of topoisomerase II. Here, we show that ICRF-193 treatment induces DNA damage signaling. Treatment with ICRF-193 induced G2 arrest and DNA damage signaling involving gamma-H2AX foci formation and CHK2 phosphorylation. DNA damage by ICRF-193 was further demonstrated by formation of the nuclear foci of 53BP1, NBS1, BRCA1, MDC1, and FANCD2 and increased comet tail moment. The DNA damage signaling induced by ICRF-193 was mediated by ATM and ATR and was restricted to cells in specific cell cycle stages such as S, G2, and mitosis including late and early G1 phases. Downstream signaling of ATM and ATR involved the phosphorylation of CHK2 and BRCA1. Altogether, our results demonstrate that ICRF-193 induces DNA damage signaling in a cell cycle-dependent manner and suggest that topoisomerase II might be essential for the progression of the cell cycle at several stages including DNA decondensation.

Genotoxicity and endoreduplication inducing activity of the food flavouring eugenol

Eugenol (1-allyl-3-methoxy-4-hydroxybenzene; CAS No. 97-53-0), a compound extracted from clove oil and marjoram, is widely used as a food flavouring substance and is present in spices such as basil, cinnamon and nutmeg. It is also used in dentistry as an antiseptic and analgesic. Structural similarities with the class IIB IARC carcinogen safrole raises questions on its putative carcinogenicity. We evaluated the genotoxicity of eugenol in V79 cells using chromosomal aberrations (CAs), with and without rat liver biotransformation (S9). Eugenol induced CAs, with significant increases (3.5% aberrant cells) at 2500 microM, demonstrating cytotoxicity at higher doses. S9 increased the induction of CAs in a dose-dependent manner to 15% at 2500 microM, with a high frequency of chromatid exchanges. In particular, an increase of endoreduplicated cells was observed, from 0% at control levels to 2.3 and 5% at 2000 microM, without and with S9, respectively. Since endoreduplication has been linked to inhibition of topoisomerase II, the topoisomerase II inhibitor ICRF-193 was used as a control inducer of endoreduplication (0.1-0.5 microM), increasing the number of endoreduplicated cells from 0% (control) to 3.5% (0.5 microM). S9 did not influence endoreduplication by ICRF-193. Both eugenol and ICRF-193 were also assayed for inhibition of topoisomerase II, and both showed a dose-dependent inhibitory effect, with ICRF-193 being a more potent inhibitor. Our results confirm that eugenol is genotoxic and raises the possibility of it having topoisomerase II inhibiting activity.

Endoreduplication induced in cultured Chinese hamster cells by different anti-topoisomerase II chemicals

With the ultimate purpose of testing the hypothesis that, as shown in yeast mutants, any malfunction of DNA topoisomerase II might result in aberrant mitosis due to defective chromosome segregation, we have chosen three chemicals of different nature, recently reported to catalytically inhibit the enzyme. The endpoint selected to assess any negative effect on the ability of topoisomerase II to properly carry out decatenation of fully replicated chromosomes in the G2/M phase of the cell cycle was the presence of metaphases showing diplochromosomes as a result of endoreduplication, i.e. two successive rounds of DNA replication without intervening mitosis. The anti-topoisomerase drugs selected were the anthracycline antibiotic and antineoplastic agent aclarubicin, the respiratory venom sodium azide, and 9-aminoacridine, a chemical compound with planar topology capable of intercalation between DNA bases. Our results show that the three chemicals tested are able to induce endoreduplication to different degrees. These observations seem to lend support to the proposal that topoisomerase II plays a central role in chromosome segregation in mammalian cells.

The DNA demethylating 5-azaC induces endoreduplication in cultured Chinese hamster cells

We have investigated the possible influence of 5-azacytidine (5-azaC) substitution for cytidine into DNA on topoisomerase II (topo II) function in chromosome segregation. The endpoint chosen has been the induction of endoreduplicated cells at mitosis showing diplochromosomes. Experiments were performed in the presence and absence of the cytidine analogue to assess the degree of 5-azaC-induced DNA hypomethylation, using differential cutting by restriction endonucleases Hpa II and Msp I. Using the pulsed-field gel electrophoresis (PFGE) technique, we have also observed a protective effect provided by 5-azaC treatment against DNA breakage induced by the topo II poison m-AMSA. Concentrations of 5-azaC shown as able to induce extensive DNA hypomethylation and capable to protect DNA from double-strand breaks induced by m-AMSA were used for our cytogenetic experiments to analyze chromosome segregation. Our results seem to indicate that the presence of 5-azaC in DNA induces a dose-dependent increase in the yield of endoreduplicated cells that parallels the levels of hypomethylation observed.

Toward a comprehensive model for induced endoreduplication

Both the biological significance and the molecular mechanism of endoreduplication (END) have been debated for a long time by cytogeneticists and researchers into cell cycle enzymology and dynamics alike. Mainly due to the fact that a wide variety of agents have been reported as able to induce endoreduplication and the diversity of cell types where it has been described, until now no clear or unique mechanism of induction of this phenomenon, rare in animals but otherwise quite common in plants, has been proposed. DNA topoisomerase II (topo II), plays a major role in mitotic chromosome segregation after DNA replication. The classical topo II poisons act by stabilizing the enzyme in the so-called cleavable complex and result in DNA damage as well as END, while the true catalytic inhibitors, which are not cleavable-complex-stabilizers, do induce END without concomitant DNA and chromosome damage. Taking into account these observations on the induction of END by drugs that interfere with topo II, together with our recently obtained evidence that the nature of DNA plays an important role for chromosome segregation [Cortes, F., Pastor, N., Mateos, S., Dominguez, I., 2003. The nature of DNA plays a role in chromosome segregation: endoreduplication in halogen-substituted chromosomes. DNA Repair 2, 719-726.], a straightforward model is proposed in which the different mechanisms leading to induced END are considered.

The nature of DNA plays a role in chromosome segregation: endoreduplication in halogen-substituted chromosomes

AA8 Chinese hamster ovary cells were treated with halogenated nucleosides analogues of thymidine, namely CldU, 5-iodo-2'-deoxyuridine (IdU), and 5-bromo-2'-deoxyuridine (BrdU), following different experimental protocols. The purpose was to see whether incorporation of exogenous pyrimidine analogues into DNA could interfere with normal chromosome segregation. The endpoint chosen was endoreduplication, that arises after aberrant mitosis when daughter chromatids segregation fails. Treatment with any of the halogenated nucleosides for two consecutive cell cycles resulted in endoreduplication, with a highest yield for CldU, intermediate for IdU, and lowest for BrdU. The frequency of endoreduplicated cells paralleled in all cases the level of analogue substitution into DNA. Our results seem to support that thymidine analogue substitution into DNA is responsible for the triggering of endoreduplication. Besides, the lack of any effect on endoreduplication when CldU was present for only one S-period strongly suggest that it is the nature of template, and not nascent DNA, that plays a major role in chromosome segregation. Taking into account that topoisomerase II cleaves DNA at preferred sequences within its recognition/binding sites, the likely involvement of the enzyme is discussed.

Induction of endoreduplication by topoisomerase II catalytic inhibitors

The striking phenomenon of endoreduplication has long attracted attention from cytogeneticists and researchers into cell cycle enzymology and dynamics alike. Because of the variety of agents able to induce endoreduplication and the various cell types where it has been described, until now no clear or unique mechanism of induction of this phenomenon, rare in animals but otherwise quite common in plants, has been proposed. Recent years, however, have witnessed the unfolding of a number of essential physiological roles for DNA topoisomerase II, with special emphasis on its major role in mitotic chromosome segregation after DNA replication. In spite of the lack of mammalian mutants defective in topoisomerase II as compared with yeast, experiments with inhibitors of the enzyme have supported the hypothesis that this crucial untangling of daughter DNA molecules by passing an intact helix through a transient double-stranded break carried out by the enzyme, when it fails, leads to aberrant mitosis that results in endoreduplication, polyploidy and eventually cell death. Anticancer drugs that interfere with topoisomerase II can be classified into two groups. The classical poisons act by stabilizing the enzyme in the so-called cleavable complex and result in DNA damage, which represents a problem in the study of endoreduplication. The true catalytic inhibitors, which are not cleavable complex stabilizers, allow us to use doses efficient in the induction of endoreduplication while eliminating high levels of DNA and chromosome damage. This review will discuss the basic and applied aspects of this as yet scarcely explored field.

Roles of DNA topoisomerases in chromosome segregation and mitosis

DNA topoisomerases are highly specialized nuclear enzymes that perform topological changes in the DNA molecule in a very precise and unique fashion. Taking into account their fundamental roles in many events during DNA metabolism such as replication, transcription, recombination, condensation or segregation, it is no wonder that the last decade has witnessed an exponential interest on topoisomerases, mainly after the discovery of their potential role as targets in novel antitumor therapy. The difficulty of the lack of topoisomerase II mutants in higher eukaryotes has been partly overcome by the availability of drugs that act as either poisons or true catalytic inhibitors of the enzyme. These chemical tools have provided strong evidence that accurate performance of topoisomerase II is essential for chromosome segregation before anaphase, and this in turn constitutes a prerequisite for the development of normal mitosis. In the absence of cytokinesis, cells become polyploid or endoreduplicated.