Improvement of pagetic bone lesions with risedronate treatment: a radiologic study

Diagnosis and treatment of Paget's disease of bone: position paper from the Italian Society of Osteoporosis, Mineral Metabolism and Skeletal Diseases (SIOMMMS)

INTRODUCTION

Paget's disease of bone is a focal skeletal disorder causing bone deformities and impairing bone quality. Despite the prevalence of asymptomatic cases is increasing, the progression of the disease can lead to invalidating complications that compromise the quality of life. Doubts on clinical and therapeutic management aspects exist, although beneficial effects of antiresorptive drugs, particularly bisphosphonates are known. However, limited information is available from randomized controlled trials on the prevention of disease complications so that somewhat contrasting positions about treatment indications between expert panels from the main scientific societies of metabolic bone diseases exist. This task force, composed by expert representatives appointed by the Italian Society of Osteoporosis, Mineral Metabolism and Skeletal Diseases and members of the Italian Association of Paget's disease of bone, felt the necessity for more specific and up to date indications for an early diagnosis and clinical management.

METHODS

Through selected key questions, we propose evidence-based recommendations for the diagnosis and treatment of the disease. In the lack of good evidence to support clear recommendations, available information from the literature together with expert opinion of the panel was used to provide suggestions for the clinical practice.

RESULTS AND CONCLUSION

Description of the evidence quality and support of the strength of the statements was provided on each of the selected key questions. The diagnosis of PDB should be mainly based on symptoms and the typical biochemical and radiological features. While treatment is mandatory to all the symptomatic cases at diagnosis, less evidence is available on treatment indications in asymptomatic as well as in previously treated patients in the presence of biochemical recurrence. However, given the safety and long-term efficacy of potent intravenous bisphosphonates such as zoledronate, a suggestion to treat most if not all cases at the time of diagnosis was released.

Drug treatment strategies for Paget's disease: relieving pain and preventing progression

INTRODUCTION

Paget's disease of bone (PDB) is a focal bone disorder caused by a marked dysregulation of osteoblasts and osteoclasts in basic multicellular units, leading to abnormal and disorganized deposition of collagen fibers (the so-called "woven bone"). Therefore, pagetic bones are increased in size, and at increased risk for bone pain, deformities, fractures, osteoarthritis, and, more rarely, neoplastic degeneration.

AREAS COVERED

In this review we revise the available information concerning the pharmacological treatment of PDB.

EXPERT OPINION

PDB progresses slowly within the affected skeletal sites and, if untreated, often leads to bone overgrowth, with bone pain, deformity and a likely increased risk of complications. Thus, the primary goal of treatment is the restoration of a normal bone turnover, in order to relieve bone pain or other symptoms and possibly prevent the complications. PDB long remained a poorly treatable disorder until the discovery of antiresorptive agents such as calcitonin first and bisphosphonates (BPs) later. With the recent development of potent intravenous BPs like zoledronate, allowing a better control of disease activity over the long term with a single infusion, has contributed to a marked improvement of the clinical management of this invalidating disorder.

Bisphosphonates in the management of Paget's disease

The first clinical use of bisphosphonates was in Paget's disease of bone (PDB) when disodium etidronate was found to be effective at suppressing metabolic activity of the disease. Subsequently, PDB became a testing ground for many bisphosphonates using changes in alkaline phosphatase (ALP) as the primary outcome measure in clinical trials. Bisphosphonates are now considered to be the treatment of choice for PDB since they are highly effective at suppressing the elevations in bone turnover that are characteristic of the disease. Short term studies have shown that treatment with alendronate and risedronate can promote formation of lamellar bone in affected sites and improve x-ray appearances in some patients. Bisphosphonates have also been shown to improve bone pain in PDB and within the bisphosphonates, zoledronic acid (ZA) is most likely to give a favourable pain response. Many patients with PDB do not have pain however, even when there is increased metabolic activity and more research is needed to find out why this is the case. The effects of bisphosphonates on complications of PDB such as deformity, pathological fractures and deafness have not been adequately studied since most clinical trials have been short term and have not collected information on these important outcomes. The PRISM and PRISM-EZ studies investigated the long-term effects of bisphosphonates in patients with established PDB using a treat-to-target approach and showed that intensive bisphosphonate therapy aimed at normalising ALP was no more effective than symptom directed treatment with bisphosphonates at preventing complications of PDB. The Zoledronate in the Prevention of Paget's Disease (ZiPP) trial, which is currently in progress, seeks to determine whether early intervention with this potent bisphosphonate might be effective in preventing disease progression. Should the ZiPP study yield positive results, genetic testing coupled to prophylactic bisphosphonate therapy might represent a new indication for these highly effective inhibitors of bone resorption in future years.

Management of Paget's disease of bone

Paget's disease is a progressive focal bone condition which can result in pain, low quality of life, deformity and other complications. Disease progression can be halted with potent bisphosphonates, resulting in improvement in both quality of life and pain, and normalisation of scintigraphy, plain radiographs and bone histology. Zoledronate has transformed the treatment of Paget's disease, producing sustained remissions in almost all patients. Thus, it is now possible to normalise bone cell activity and prevent disease progression at low cost, with one or two intravenous injections of zoledronate, greatly reducing follow-up costs. Patients with Paget's disease who are symptomatic or at risk of complications should have the opportunity to reap these therapeutic benefits. Potent bisphosphonates are highly effective in halting disease progression in Paget's disease, but guidelines disagree about treatment indications. The efficacy, safety and low cost of zoledronate recommend its use in any patient who is symptomatic or judged to be at risk of complications from Paget's disease.

Protective effect of glucosamine and risedronate (alone or in combination) against osteoarthritic changes in rat experimental model of immobilized knee

This study is aiming to investigate the protective effect of glucosamine, risedronate (alone or in combination) on articular cartilage in experimental model of immobilized rat knee. Twenty-five adult male albino rats were divided into five groups (five rats each): control group, immobilized group, glucosamine-treated group, risedronate-treated group, and group treated by a combination of glucosamine and risedronate. The articular cartilage was obtained for histological, immunohistochemical and morphometric studies. The immobilized group showed manifestations of osteoarthritis in the form of significant decrease of articular cartilage thickness with surface erosions, shrunken chondrocytes with pyknotic nuclei and marked manifested fall of chondrocyte number. There was manifested reduction of collagen contents of the articular cartilage using Masson trichrome stain. Safranin O–Fast Green revealed low proteoglycan contents. The collagen type II was also declined. The manikin score was 7.8. Risedronate improved this manifestation slightly more than glucosamine, but combination of booth drugs caused significant improvement of the damaged articular cartilage caused by immobilization. Oral administration of glucosamine and risedronate improved the degenerative changes of rat knee articular cartilage that follow immobilization. This improvement was more remarkable when both drugs were used in combination.

Recent advances in understanding and managing Paget's disease

Paget’s disease is a condition which continues to challenge and surprise. The dramatic fall in its incidence over the last three decades has been an enormous surprise, as is the capacity of a single infusion of the potent bisphosphonate, zoledronate, to produce biochemical remission in 90% of patients, remissions which usually persist for many years and raise the possibility of a cure in some patients. However, challenges in its management remain. The trials carried out in Paget’s disease have almost always had biochemical indices as their primary endpoints. From these studies, we also know that bone pain is relieved, quality of life improved, bone histology normalised, and radiological lesions healed. Thus, disease progression is halted. Studies have not been powered to assess whether clinically important endpoints such as fracture and the need for joint replacement surgery are diminished, although these complications are well established as part of the natural history of the condition. Since disease progression is prevented by potent bisphosphonates, it is likely that disease complications will also be prevented. Zoledronate also reduces the frequency of follow-up needed and therefore provides a very cost-effective intervention in those who have symptomatic disease or are at risk of complications.

Paget's Disease of Bone

Paget's disease of bone (PDB) is a chronic and focal bone disorder, characterized by increased osteoclast-mediated bone resorption and a subsequent compensatory increase in bone formation, resulting in a disorganized mosaic of woven and lamellar bone at one or more affected skeletal sites. As a result, bone pain, noticeable deformities, arthritis at adjacent joints, and fractures can occur. In a small proportion of cases neoplastic degeneration in osteosarcoma, or, less frequently, giant cell tumor has been also described at PDB sites. While recent epidemiological evidences clearly indicate a decrease in the prevalence and the severity of PDB, over the past 2 decades there have been consistent advances on the genetic mechanisms of disease. It is now clear that PDB is a genetically heterogeneous disorder, with mutations in at least two different genes (SQSTM1, ZNF687) and more common predisposing variants. As a counterpart to the genetic hypothesis, the focal nature of lesions, the decline in prevalence rates, and the incomplete penetrance of the disease among family members suggest that one or more environmental triggers may play a role in the pathophysiology of PDB. The exact nature of these triggers and how they might interact with the genetic factors are less understood, but recent experimental data from mice models suggest the implication of paramixoviral infections. The clinical management of PDB has also evolved considerably, with the development of potent aminobisphosphonates such as zoledronic acid which, given as a single intravenous infusion, now allows a long-term disease remission in the majority of patients.

Paget's Disease of Bone: A Review of Epidemiology, Pathophysiology and Management

Paget's disease of bone is a common disorder which may affect one or many bones. Although many patients are asymptomatic, a variety of symptoms and complications may occur. Fortunately, effective pharmacologic therapy, primarily with potent bisphosphonates, is now available to treat patients with complications or symptoms. This review of Paget's disease of bone will include epidemiology and pathophysiology, complications and clinical findings, indications for treatment, and the drugs currently available to treat this condition.

Emerging strategies and therapies for treatment of Paget's disease of bone

Paget's disease of bone (PDB) is a progressive monostotic or polyostotic metabolic bone disease characterized by focal abnormal bone remodeling, with increased bone resorption and excessive, disorganized, new bone formation. PDB rarely occurs before middle age, and it is the second most frequent metabolic bone disorder after osteoporosis, affecting up to 3% of adults over 55 years of age. One of the most striking and intriguing clinical features is the focal nature of the disorder, in that once the disease is established within a bone, there is only local spread within that bone and no systemic dissemination. Despite many years of intense research, the etiology of PDB has still to be conclusively determined. Based on a detailed review of genetic and viral factors incriminated in PDB, we propose a unifying hypothesis from which we can suggest emerging strategies and therapies. PDB results in weakened bone strength and abnormal bone architecture, leading to pain, deformity or, depending on the bone involved, fracture in the affected bone. The diagnostic assessment includes serum total alkaline phosphatase, total body bone scintigraphy, skull and enlarged view pelvis x-rays, and if needed, additional x-rays. The ideal therapeutic option would eliminate bone pain, normalize serum total alkaline phosphatase with prolonged remission, heal radiographic osteolytic lesions, restore normal lamellar bone, and prevent recurrence and complications. With the development of increasingly potent bisphosphonates, culminating in the introduction of a single intravenous infusion of zoledronic acid 5 mg, these goals of treatment are close to being achieved, together with long-term remission in almost all patients. Based on the recent pathophysiological findings, emerging strategies and therapies are reviewed: ie, pulse treatment with zoledronic acid; denosumab, a fully human monoclonal antibody directed against RANK ligand; tocilizumab, an interleukin-6 receptor inhibitor; odanacatib, a cathepsin K inhibitor; and proteasome and Dickkopf-1 inhibitors.

Risedronate decreases biochemical markers of cartilage degradation but does not decrease symptoms or slow radiographic progression in patients with medial compartment osteoarthritis of the knee: results of the two-year multinational knee osteoarthritis structural arthritis study

OBJECTIVE

Bisphosphonates have slowed the progression of osteoarthritis (OA) in animal models and have decreased pain in states of high bone turnover. The Knee OA Structural Arthritis (KOSTAR) study, which is the largest study to date investigating a potential structure-modifying OA drug, tested the efficacy of risedronate in providing symptom relief and slowing disease progression in patients with knee OA.

METHODS

The study group comprised 2,483 patients with medial compartment knee OA and 2-4 mm of joint space width (JSW), as determined using fluoroscopically positioned, semiflexed-view radiography. Patients were enrolled in 2 parallel 2-year studies in North America and the European Union. These studies evaluated the efficacy of risedronate at dosages of 5 mg/day, 15 mg/day, 35 mg/week (in Europe), and 50 mg/week (in North America) compared with placebo in reducing signs and symptoms, as measured by the Western Ontario and McMaster Universities Osteoarthritis (WOMAC) index and patient global assessment (PGA) scores, and in slowing radiographic progression.

RESULTS

A reduction of approximately 20% in signs and symptoms, as measured by WOMAC subscales and PGA scores, was observed in all groups, with no treatment effect of risedronate demonstrated. Risedronate did not significantly reduce radiographic progression as measured by decreased JSW or using a dichotomous definition of progression (joint space loss of >or=0.6 mm). Thirteen percent of patients receiving placebo demonstrated significant disease progression over 2 years. A dose-dependent reduction in the level of C-terminal crosslinking telopeptide of type II collagen, a cartilage degradation marker associated with progressive OA, was seen in patients who received risedronate. No increase in the number of adverse events was demonstrated for risedronate compared with placebo.

CONCLUSION

Although risedronate (compared with placebo) did not improve signs or symptoms of OA, nor did it alter progression of OA, a reduction in the level of a marker of cartilage degradation was observed. A sustained clinically relevant improvement in signs and symptoms was observed in all treatment and placebo groups.

Prescription-event monitoring study on 13,164 patients prescribed risedronate in primary care in England

Risedronate sodium is indicated in postmenopausal women for the prevention and treatment of osteoporosis and for the treatment of Paget's disease. Our aim was to evaluate the safety of risedronate in a large cohort of patients prescribed risedronate by general practitioners (GPs) in England, soon after it was marketed. An observational cohort study was conducted using the technique of prescription-event monitoring (PEM). Exposure data were obtained from dispensed National Health Service prescriptions issued between September 2000 and June 2002. Outcome data were collected by sending questionnaires to prescribing GPs requesting them to report any events that had occurred since starting risedronate, demographic details, indication, start and stop dates, reasons for stopping, suspected adverse drug reactions (ADRs) and causes of death. Event rates calculated as incidence densities (IDs) separately, for Paget's disease group and all other patients (osteoporosis group) were ranked and the difference between IDs in month 1 and months 2-6 calculated. The osteoporosis cohort comprised 13,180 patients (10,934 [83.0%] female); median ages for female and male patients were 73 and 69 years, respectively. The most frequently reported event in the first month of treatment was dyspepsia, being also amongst the most frequently reported reasons for stopping risedronate and suspected ADR. Adverse events assessed as possibly or probably related to risedronate included, six of facial edema and one each of Stevens-Johnson syndrome, swollen tongue, palpitation and episcleritis. Risedronate was fairly well tolerated. Adverse events affecting skin, eye, cardiovascular and immunological systems were identified. Prescribing doctors should be aware of these and monitor their patients accordingly.

High-dose risedronate treatment partially preserves cancellous bone mass and microarchitecture during long-term disuse

Disuse induces rapid and severe bone loss in larger mammals as a result of greatly elevated osteoclastic resorption. In this study, we tested whether risedronate (RIS), a potent inhibitor of osteoclastic activity, would effectively prevent cancellous bone loss in female beagles (5-7 years old, N = 28) subjected to single forelimb immobilization (IM) for 12 months. Age-matched, non-IM dogs served as controls (Con). Half the animals from each group received RIS 1 mg/kg p.o. daily (Con + RIS, IM + RIS). Remaining dogs received sterile water (Con, IM). Histomorphometry showed that IM caused a dramatic reduction in cancellous bone mass (-71%) of distal 2nd metacarpals, characterized by marked decreases in trabecular width (-51%) and number (-41%), and 4-fold increases in the indices of bone resorption (eroded surface, osteoclast number, and surface). Bone formation indices (calcein-labeled surface, osteoid surface, and bone formation rate) were also significantly higher in IM than in controls. Activation frequency in IM increased about 4-fold beyond control level. RIS treatment reduced, but did not abolish cancellous bone loss due to immobilization. IM animals treated with RIS lost nearly 50% of cancellous bone mass, while trabecular width and number were reduced by 31% and 25%, respectively. In both RIS-treated control and IM animals, overall bone formation parameters (mineralized bone surface fraction and bone formation rate) remained roughly at intact control levels; however, mineral apposition rate relative to intact control was reduced 40% in RIS-treated control and 86% in RIS-treated IM animals. These results indicate that high-dose RIS treatment might suppress osteoblastic function, especially under long-term disuse. Interestingly, bone resorption parameters in RIS-treated IM animals reached levels even higher than in vehicle-treated IM animals; values for eroded surface, osteoclast number, and surface were 84%, 53%, and 83% above vehicle-treated IM values, respectively. Our data indicate that risedronate treatment is partially effective in preventing cancellous bone loss during long-term disuse. Moreover, our results suggest that bisphosphonates can impair the ability of mature osteoclasts to resorb bone, but cannot overcome the strong stimulus for osteoclast recruitment caused by long-term disuse.

Maladie de Paget, prise en charge thérapeutique

Bisphosphonates, potent anti-osteoclastic agents, are nowadays the first-line therapy for Paget's disease of bone. Solid evidence about efficacy and the risk/benefit ratio favor tiludronate and risedronate for oral administration and pamidronate for intravenous administration. Treatment is always intermittent, with the frequency of therapeutic sequences depending on the specific drug and the quality and duration of response. Treatment response is assessed by the extent of the reduction of biochemical markers of bone turnover, especially plasma total alkaline phosphatase. The goal of the treatment is to induce full remission, that is, normal levels of alkaline phosphatase. Bisphosphonates should be used in all patients with bone involvement that might create long-term articular (arthropathy) or neurologic (compression) complications. This aggressive strategy is the most likely to provide effective prevention of complications in the long term.

Long-term disuse osteoporosis seems less sensitive to bisphosphonate treatment than other osteoporosis

We sought to determine whether risedronate can preserve cortical bone mass and mechanical properties during long-term disuse in dogs, assessed by histomorphometry and biomechanics on metacarpal diaphyses. Risedronate slowed cortical thinning and partially preserved mechanical properties, but it was unable to suppress bone loss to the degree seen in other osteoporoses.

INTRODUCTION

Disuse induces dramatic bone loss resulting from greatly elevated osteoclastic resorption. Targeting osteoclasts with antiresorptive agents, such as bisphosphonates, should be an effective countermeasure for preventing disuse osteoporosis.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Single forelimbs from beagles (5-7 years old, n = 28) were immobilized (IM) for 12 months. Age-matched, non-IM dogs served as controls. One-half the animals received either risedronate (RIS, 1 mg/kg) or vehicle daily. Histomorphometry was performed on second metacarpal mid-diaphyses. Cortical mechanical properties were determined by testing third metacarpal diaphyses in four-point bending.

RESULTS

IM caused marked reduction in cortical area (-42%) and cortical thinning (-40%) through endocortical resorption, extensive intracortical tunneling, and periosteal resorption; both bone resorption and formation were significantly elevated over control levels on all envelopes. IM also decreased maximum load and stiffness by approximately 80% compared with controls. RIS reduced both periosteal bone loss and marrow cavity expansion; however, cortical area remained significantly lower in RIS-treated IM animals than in untreated non-IM controls (-16%). RIS also increased resorption indices in all envelopes compared with nontreated IM, indicating that RIS suppressed osteoclast activity but not osteoclast recruitment. RIS did not affect bone formation. RIS treatment conserved some whole bone mechanical properties, but they were still significantly lower than in controls. There were no significant differences in tissue level material properties among the groups.

CONCLUSION

RIS treatment reduces cortical bone loss at periosteal and endocortical surfaces caused by long-term immobilization, thus partially conserving tissue mechanical properties. This modest effect contrasts with more dramatic actions of the bisphosphonate in other osteoporoses. Our results suggest that risedronate impairs osteoclastic function but cannot completely overcome the intense stimulus for osteoclast recruitment during prolonged disuse.

Paget's disease of bone

Paget's disease of bone is characterized by an anarchic bone remodelling, associated with morphological and functional abnormalities of osteoclasts. Its prevalence and incidence rates decreased gradually over the past two decades; the reason for this remains unclear. The aetiology of the disease is still obscure, the paramyxoviral theory being very controversial. Recent advances in understanding of the disease come from genetic studies, with the identification of specific mutations in the p62-sequestosome gene, which could be involved in pathogenetic mechanisms leading to increased osteoclast activity. The disease affects one or several bone pieces, leading to bone pain, deformities, characteristic imaging features, and increased markers of bone remodelling. The long-lasting disease activity leads to complications, including arthropathies, neurological compressions, fissures or fractures and, rarely, osteosarcomatous transformation of a pagetic lesion. Potent bisphosphonates have proven their efficacy in reducing symptoms and disease activity. They are currently used as the first-line treatment with the goal of normalizing bone remodelling and, hopefully, preventing late complications.

From the archives of the AFIP. Radiologic spectrum of Paget disease of bone and its complications with pathologic correlation

Paget disease of bone is a common disorder affecting approximately 3%-4% of the population over 40 years of age. The pathologic abnormality in Paget disease is excessive and abnormal remodeling of bone. Three pathologic phases have been described: the lytic phase (incipient-active), in which osteoclasts predominate; the mixed phase (active), in which osteoblasts cause repair superimposed on the resorption; and the blastic phase (late-inactive) in which osteoblasts predominate. Radiographic appearance of Paget disease reflects these pathologic changes and is often characteristic. Initially, there is osteolysis, particularly affecting the skull (osteoporosis circumscripta) and subchondral long bones, with subsequent development of trabecular and cortical thickening and enlargement of bone in the mixed phase of the disease. Finally, areas of sclerosis may develop in the blastic phase. Frequent sites of involvement include the skull (25%-65% of cases), spine (30%-75%), pelvis (30%-75%), and proximal long bones (25%-30%). Bone scintigraphy typically demonstrates marked increased uptake of radionuclide in all phases of Paget disease. Computed tomography and magnetic resonance imaging often show changes similar to those seen radiographically in noncomplicated Paget disease with maintenance of yellow marrow. Complications of Paget disease include the effects of osseous weakening (deformity and fracture), arthritis, neurologic symptoms, and neoplastic involvement. Sarcomatous transformation is the most feared complication, occurring in approximately 1% of cases, and is seen on images as focal bone destruction extending through the cortex with an associated soft-tissue mass. Recognition of the radiologic spectrum of the appearances of Paget disease usually allows prospective diagnosis and differentiation of its associated complications, which helps guide therapy and improve patient management.

Review of risedronate in the treatment of osteoporosis

Risedronate (Actonel, Procter & Gamble and Aventis) is a novel, orally administered pyridinyl bisphosphonate. Preclinical studies have shown that risedronate is a potent inhibitor of osteoclasts. Risedronate inhibited bone resorption and increased bone density in the spine and hip. Prospective, randomised, placebo-controlled trials (RCTs) in patients with postmenopausal osteoporosis (PMO) have demonstrated that risedronate decreased the risk of vertebral fractures by up to 49% and of non-vertebral fractures by up to 39% over 3 years in postmenopausal women with one or more prevalent vertebral fractures. This reduction of the risk for vertebral fractures was significant from the first year of treatment (risk reduction up to 65%). Risedronate was the first bisphosphonate to be studied in a large RCT with prevention of hip fracture as the primary end point. In this study, risedronate reduced the risk of hip fracture by 40% in elderly women with low hip bone density and one clinical risk factor for hip fracture and by 60% in women with low bone density and a prevalent vertebral fracture at baseline. Risedronate was also effective in the prevention and treatment of bone loss in glucocorticoid-induced osteoporosis (GIO), with a positive effect on vertebral fractures within the first year. Risedronate was well-tolerated with a safety profile comparable to placebo in all clinical studies. Patients with a previous or current history of upper GI illness or who were taking NSAIDs or aspirin were not excluded from these studies. Importantly, the upper GI safety profile of risedronate was shown to be similar to that of placebo in endoscopic studies. There was no evidence of acute-phase reactions or primary mineralisation defects. The most appropriate dose of risedronate was 5 mg/day.

Consensus statement on the modern therapy of Paget's disease of bone from a Western Osteoporosis Alliance symposium. Biannual Foothills Meeting on Osteoporosis, Calgary, Alberta, Canada, September 9-10, 2000

BACKGROUND

Bisphosphonate therapy remains the most effective way of controlling Paget's disease of bone (PD). Along with salmon calcitonin, etidronate has been the mainstay of therapy for approximately 20 years. However, the advent of newer bisphosphonates with different molecular actions on osteoclasts warrants a reevaluation of optimal treatment.

OBJECTIVE

At a symposium of the Western Osteoporosis Alliance, physicians with experience in the management of PD met to review currently available information and generate this consensus statement as a guideline for clinicians and a source of information for health care payers.

METHODS

All available randomized, double-blind, controlled studies that compared the efficacy of newer bisphosphonates with that of etidronate in the treatment of PD were identified through a search of MEDLINE using the terms Paget's disease, bisphosphonates, pamidronate, etidronate, alendronate, risedronate, tiludronate, clodronate, calcitonin, and salmon calcitonin. Because no such studies have been conducted for pamidronate, clodronate, or calcitonin, these drugs were not included in the analysis.

CONCLUSIONS

The consensus of the symposium was that etidronate has little place in the modern management of PD. Newer bisphosphonates such as alendronate and risedronate provide significant therapeutic advantages over etidronate, both in the extent of reduction in bone-specific alkaline phosphatase (BSAP) and/or total serum alkaline phosphatase (SAP) and in the duration of remission, as measured by normalization of BSAP/SAP. In the absence of a direct comparison between alendronate and risedronate in the treatment of PD, physician choice is likely to be based on personal experience, relative cost, and differences in dosing.