The relationship between the transfer systems of some bacterial plasmids

Rate of segregation due to plasmid incompatibility

We calculated the rates of segregation due to plasmid incompatibility under several simple models. A common feature of all the models that we considered is that incompatibility is caused by the inability of the segregation mechanism to distinguish between two incompatible plasmids.

We measured the rate of segregation due to incompatibility of a pair of ColE1 derivatives under two conditions: (1) One plasmid was introduced into cells carrying the other by conjugation. (2) Cells carrying both plasmids were maintained by selection and then selection was released.

Interpretation of the results was made more difficult by effects of the Plasmids on the host cell's growth rate. These experiments gave results in agreement with the predictions of a random pool replication model. Published results were also in reasonable agreement with this model.

Characterization and nucleotide sequence of the oriT-traM-finP region of the IncFVII plasmid pSU233

By hybridizing the IncFVII haemolytic plasmid pSU233 with a probe containing the origin of transfer of the IncFII plasmid R1, we isolated a 1.9 kb BglII fragment containing at least the origin of transfer (oriT), and the genes traM and finP. Functional complementation analysis of deletion derivatives was used to map the origin of transfer. We also determined the nucleotide sequence of traM and finP. Comparison with similar regions of several plasmids, also belonging to the Rep-FIIA family, revelaed that pSU233 resembles the F plasmid by very close. The homology is not evenly distributed along this region, but clustered into homologous regions (TraZb-oriT, TraMb-oriT and traM separated by non-homologous regions (TraYb-oriT, finP). This organization resembles that reported for the replication region and also suggests evolution by exchange of modules. In addition, the nucleotide sequence of finP is different from those previously described for other IncF plasmids and constitutes a new allele, which we have denominated allele VI.

Revised genetic map of the distal end of the F transfer operon: implications for DNA helicase I, nicking at oriT, and conjugal DNA transport

The DNA transfer stage of conjugation requires the products of the F sex factor genes traMYDIZ and the cis-acting site oriT. Previous interpretation of genetic and protein analyses suggested that traD, traI, and traZ mapped as contiguous genes at the distal end of the transfer operon and saturated this portion of the F transfer region (which ends with an IS3 element). Using antibodies prepared against the purified TraD and TraI proteins, we analyzed the products encoded by a collection of chimeric plasmids constructed with various segments of traDIZ DNA. We found the traI gene to be located 1 kilobase to the right of the position suggested on previous maps. This creates an unsaturated space between traD and traI where unidentified tra genes may be located and leaves insufficient space between traI and IS3 for coding the 94-kilodalton protein previously thought to be the product of traZ. We found that the 94-kilodalton protein arose from a translational restart and corresponds to the carboxy terminus of traI; we named it TraI*. The precise physical location of the traZ gene and the identity of its product are unknown. The oriT nicking activity known as TraZ may stem from unassigned regions between traD and traI and between traI and IS3, but a more interesting possibility is that it is actually a function of traI. On our revised map, the position of a previously detected RNA polymerase-binding site corresponds to a site at the amino terminus of traI rather than a location 1 kilobase into the coding region of the gene. Furthermore, the physical and genetic comparison of the F traD and traI genes with those of the closely related F-like conjugative plasmids R1 and R100 is greatly simplified. The translational organization we found for traI, together with its identity as the structural gene for DNA helicase I, suggests a possible functional link to several other genes from which translational restart polypeptides are expressed. These include the primases of the conjugative plasmids ColI and R16, the primase-helicase of bacteriophage T7, and the cisA product (nickase) of phage phi X174.

Structure and nucleotide sequence of the region encoding the mobilization proteins of plasmid CloDF13

Mobilization of the non-conjugative plasmid CloDF13 requires both gene products of a conjugative plasmid and CloDF13-encoded information. About 30% of the CloDF13 genome is involved in plasmid transfer. The CloDF13 mobilization region comprises sequences acting in cis (bom, basis of mobilization) as well as protein-coding sequences (mob). Here we present the nucleotide sequence of the genes encoding the CloDF13 mobilization proteins. We confirmed the previous genetic data that the plasmid CloDF13 encodes two proteins involved in plasmid mobilization. The information for these proteins, designated B and C having Mrs of 57,890 and 15,870, respectively, is located within one operon directed by a promoter at 94% of the CloDF13 genome. The gene encoding the smaller protein is located distally within this operon. Transcription proceeds counter-clockwise and is terminated beyond gene C, although it can not be excluded that attenuation of the transcript occurs in the intergenic region. The role of the CloDF13 mobilization proteins in plasmid transfer will be discussed.

Nucleotide sequences of the R1-19 plasmid transfer genes traM, finP, traJ, and traY and the traYZ promoter

The complete nucleotide sequences of the R1 drd-19 (R1-19) plasmid transfer genes traM, finP, traJ, and traY and the region encoding the traYZ promoter were determined. The traM protein from R1-19 was similar to the 127-amino-acid traM product from the conjugative plasmid F; only 28 residues were not identical. finP, a negative regulatory element of the traJ gene, contained a 12-base-pair inverted repeat identical to that found in the F plasmid, but differed in the 7 base pairs found between the repeats. The traJ gene and the traYZ promoter (the site of transcriptional stimulation by the traJ product) were completely different from the equivalent sequences in plasmid F. Galactokinase fusion studies of the traYZ promoter indicated that the R1-19 and F plasmids have analogous but not homologous traYZ promoter strengths and regulation. The traY protein from R1-19 was 44 residues shorter than the traY product from plasmid F, but there was some homology within the C-terminal halves of the traY gene products. The predicted translational start codon for the traY gene is GUG.

Specificities of IncF plasmid conjugation genes

The conjugation regions of IncF plasmids are closely related in that they share extensive DNA homology, and that they specify related pili. Variations between individual conjugation gene products of different IncF plasmids have, however, been noted. We have extended these observations by carrying out a systematic survey of twelve such plasmids, to examine the numbers and the groupings of the plasmid-specific alleles of several genes required for conjugation and its control.

Using vector plasmids carrying cloned origins of transfer (oriT), four different specificities were recognized, and these were correlated with the specificities of the genes with products that may act at this site (traM, traYandtraZ). ThetraYgene is the first gene of the major transfer operon, and is therefore located close to the site at which thetraJprotein acts to induce expression of the operon: correspondingly, correlation was observed between theoriT/traMYZandtraJspecificities in most of the plasmids. In turn,traJis negatively regulated by thefinOandfinPproducts acting in concert: thefinOproduct was relatively non-specific, but sixfinPalleles were identified, again with specificities correlated with those oftraJ. Our explanation for this unexpectedly large number offinPalleles derives from the concept that thefinPproduct is an RNA molecule rather than a protein. Although the conjugative pili encoded by IncF plasmids are closely related, they confer different efficiencies of plating of the various F-specific bacteriophages. We distinguished four groups on this basis, presumably resulting from differences in the primary amino-acid sequences of the pilin proteins. These groups could be related to the surface exclusion system specificities, consistent with the hypothesis that surface exclusion acts at least in part by preventing interaction between the pilus and the recipient cell surface.

From these data, information about the evolutionary relationships between the twelve IncF plasmids can be deduced.

Characterization and sequence analysis of pilin from F-like plasmids

Conjugative pili are expressed by derepressed plasmids and initiate cell-to-cell contact during bacterial conjugation. They are also the site of attachment for pilus-specific phages (f1, f2, and QB). In this study, the number of pili per cell and their ability to retract in the presence of cyanide was estimated for 13 derepressed plasmids. Selected pilus types were further characterized for reactivity with anti-F and anti-ColB2 pilus antisera as well as two F pilus-specific monoclonal antibodies, one of which is specific for a sequence common to most F-like pilin types (JEL92) and one which is specific for the amino terminus of F pilin (JEL93). The pilin genes from eight of these plasmids were cloned and sequenced, and the results were compared with information on F, ColB2, and pED208 pilin. Six pilus groups were defined: I, was F-like [F, pED202(R386), ColV2-K94, and ColVBtrp]; IIA was ColB2-like in sequence but had a lowered sensitivity to f1 phage due to its decreased ability for pilus retraction [pED236(ColB2) and pED203(ColB4)]; IIB was ColB2-like but retained f1 sensitivity [pED200(R124) and pED207(R538-1)]; III contained R1-19, which had a ColB2-like amino terminus but had an additional lysine residue at its carboxy terminus which may affect its phage sensitivity pattern and its antigenicity; IV was R100-1-like [R100-1 and presumably pED241(R136) and pED204(R6)] which had a unique amino-terminal sequence combined with a carboxy terminus similar to that of F. pED208(Folac) formed group V, which was multipiliated and exhibited poor pilus retraction although it retained full sensitivity to f1 phage. The pED208 pilin gene could not be cloned at this time since it shared no homology with the pilin gene of the F plasmid.

Promoter-distal region of the tra operon of F-like sex factor R100 in Escherichia coli K-12

The distal region of the tra (transfer) operon of F-like plasmid R100 was investigated, using small plasmids derived from R100, primarily the plasmid pSM6. The transposon Tn5 (which confers kanamycin resistance) was inserted at different positions into pSM6, and the transposition derivatives were tested for ability to complement defined tra mutants of the F sex factor. Thus, the tra genes traH, G, T, and D were localized on the plasmid R100. A restriction map of pSM6 was constructed, and the locations of the insertions were mapped, using restriction endonuclease digestion of the plasmid DNA and exploiting the fact that several restriction sites are localized in the inverted repeat regions of the transposon. The gene products of the genes traG, S, T, and D were identified by radioactive labeling of proteins synthesized in minicells carrying the various insertion plasmids followed by sodium dodecyl sulfate-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis. The presence of another transfer gene, traI, was inferred from these data. Another protein, the r2-A protein, was also identified, and its gene was mapped. On the basis of the data, a best-fit physical map of this region of the tra operon of R100 was constructed. The results confirmed that the general order and size of the distal transfer genes is as in the F sex factor, but showed that differences exist with respect to all of the gene products. The significance of these differences are discussed in the light of the genetic and physical homology (Manning et al., J. Bacteriol. 150:76-88) of the transfer regions.

Interactions between the F conjugal transfer system and CloDF13::Tna plasmids

It was confirmed that all the F transfer genes required for the formation of stable mating pairs, including traN and traG, are essential for transfer of the two small multicopy plasmids ColE1 and cloDF13, whereas the traM, traI and traZ genes that are required for F conjugal DNA metabolism, are not. Differences between ColE1 and CloDF13 were that the F traD gene was needed for transfer of ColE1 but not of CloDF13, and that R100-1 efficiently transferred CloDF13 but not ColE1. A copy number mutant of CloDF13 inhibited F transfer and reduced plaque formation by the F-specific RNA phage f2, but not by Q beta or by the single-strand DNA phage f1. This phenotype suggests that the inhibition system (FinC) acts on traD, mutations in which give a similar phenotype. Hybridisation experiments with lambda tra phage DNA showed that transcription of traD was not reduced, and FinC probably inhibits function of the traD product rather than its synthesis. FinC-insensitive Flac mutants were isolated and characterised. One was shown to have an uppromoter mutation resulting in increased transcription of traJ and hence of the traY leads to Z operon including traD: the raised level of the traD product presumably then counteracted FinC inhibition.

Plasmid control of recombination of E. coli K12

The recombination proficiency of three recipient strains of Escherichia coli K12 carrying different plasmids was investigated by conjugal mating with Hfr Cavalli. Some plasmids (e.g. R1drd 19, R6K) caused a marked reduction in the yield of recombinants formed in crosses with Hfr but did not reduce the ability of host strains to accept plasmid F104. The effect of plasmids on recombination was host-dependent. In Hfr crosses with AB1157 (R1-19) used as a recipient the linkage between selected and unselected proximal markers of the donor was sharply decreased. Plasmid R1-19 also decreased the yield of recombinants formed by recF, recL, and recB recC sbcA mutants, showed no effect on the recombination proficiency of recB recC sbcB mutant, and increased the recombination proficiency of recB, recB recC sbcB recF, and recB recC sbcB recL mutants. An ATP-dependent exonuclease activity was found in all tested recB recC mutants carrying plasmid R1-19, while this plasmid did not affect the activity of exonuclease I in strain AB1157 and its rec- derivatives. The same plasmid was also found to protect different rec- derivatives of the strain AB1157 against the lethal action of UV light. We suppose that a new ATP-dependent exonuclease determined by R1-19 plays a role in both repair and recombination of the host through the substitution of or competition with the exoV coded for by the genes recB and recC.

Investigations of the F conjugation gene traI:traI mutants and lambdatraI transducing phages

A series of traI point and deletion mutants of Flac, and a traM mutant, were characterised. Complementation tests with an amber Flac traI mutant confirmed their genotypes, and in addition all the traI mutants, but not the traM mutant, were complemented by pRS31 (PSC101 traDI) and EDlambda109 (lambdatraI). Judging from the efficiencies of plating of F-specific phages, none of the mutations affected pilus formation. The traI products of F and of the F-like plasmid R1 were interchangeable with each other but not with that of R100, while the traM product of F could not be replaced by those of R1 or of R100. Neither traI nor traM were needed for conjugal transfer of ColE1. Three lambda transducing phages carrying traI were isolated by in vivo or in vitro techniques, and characterised by genetic complementation tests, by analysis of the fragments produced by restriction endonucleases, and by measurement of heteroduplex molecules. The genetic structures together with the sizes and F coordinates, of the transfer regions carried by the phages were thereby determined. Comparison of the proteins synthesised in UV-irradiated cells by one of the lambdatraI phages with those made by a derivative carrying an amber traI mutation, allowed the traI product to be identified as a protein of molecular weight 174,000. In addition, the molecular weights of the traD (84,000), traS (18,000), and traT (25,000) products made by the lambdatraSTD1 phage EDlambda107 were measured. The possible roles of the traI and traM products in conjugation are discussed.

Molecular sizes and relationships of TOL plasmids in Pseudomonas

Plasmid deoxyribonucleic acid was isolated from thirteen Pseudomonas strains judged on genetic criteria to carry plasmids coding for the degradation of toluene and m- and p-xylenes (TOL plasmids). Most strains carried a single species, but two strains carried two size classes, and cells of a third strain contained plasmids ranging in size from 25 X 10(6) to 202 X 10(6) daltons. Some plasmids could be transformed into a Pseudomonas putida strain to yield Tol+ progeny. Plasmids from 5 of the 13 strains were indistinguishable on the basis of size and gel pattern of fragments after endonuclease digestion.

Effect of entry exclusion on mating aggregates and transconjugants

Mating aggregates during conjugation directed by an F-like R factor in Escherichia coli were measured as the number of Lac+-Lac- sectored colonies present in a mating mixture. There is a high degree of correlation between the concentration of transconjugants produced in a mating mixture and the concentration of mating aggregates observed at several different concentrations of donor and recipient cells. The mating aggregates are sex pilus specific as demonstrated by the ability of donor-specific ribonucleic acid phage MS-2 to decrease both mating aggregates and transconjugants in a mating mixture. During entry exclusion by either a derepressed or a repressed F-like R factor, isogenic to the superinfecting R factor except for a resistance determinant, the number of transconjugants was markedly reduced, but the number of mating aggregates was not decreased. Entry exclusion by F-Gal toward the donor HfrH resembled that of the F-like R factor in that there was a reduction in the number of recombinants but no significant decrease in mating aggregates. These results suggest that entry exclusion inhibits conjugation at a stage after the formation of mating aggregates.

Comparative study of R1-specific chromosomal transfer in Escherichia coli K-12 and salmonella typhimurium LT2

High-frequency transfer of the chromosomal trp region by R1 observed in Escherichia coli (Pearce and Meynell, 1968) also occurs in Salmonella typhimurium. The reaction is recA independent in both species. The origin of transfer lies within a segment of the chromosome that is inverted in S. typhimurium relative to E. coli, and thus transfer occurs in a different direction in the two species. The character of R1 that is responsible, known as Tfa+, may be lost without affecting other properties of the R factor such as its own transfer.

Role of the cell surface in bacterial mating: requirement for intact mucopeptide in donors for the expression of surface exclusion in R+ strains of Escherichia coli

Two derivatives of the F-like R factor R1drd19 carrying mutually exclusive resistance determinants were used to study the role of the mucopeptide in the expression of conjugal functions. The use of metabolically active penicillin spheroplasts in R+ times R- matings had no effect on the ability of the cells to donate or accept a plasmid. However, in R+ times R+ matings it was found that surface exclusion was totally abolished if the donor, but not the recipient, was a spheroplast. This result implies that the traS gene, expressed by the excluding plasmid, is dependent for its action on an intact mucopeptide layer in the donor cell, and that this interaction is independent of the transfer ability of the excluding plasmid.

Behavior of a hybrid F' ts114 lac+, his+ factor (F42-400) in Klebsiella pneumoniae M5a1

Episome F' ts114 lac+, his+ (F42-400) was transferred from Salmonella typhimurium to Klebsiella pneumoniae. From the progeny, a strain of K. pneumoniae able to retransfer the episome was obtained. The His+ phenotype in this strain is temperature sensitive. Escherichia coli female-specific phages phiII, W31, and T3 were shown to plate on K. pneumoniae. From phiII we obtained two derivatives; phiIIK, which plates only on K. pneumoniae, and phiIIE, which plates only on E. coli. Growth of phages T3 and phiIIK was inhibited by F42-400 in K. pneumoniae. Growth in presence of acridine orange in a defined medium at 40 C resulted in a high level of curing. The frequency of His+ cells after growth in acridine orange at 40 C was 0.001%. An extensive search to detect chromosome mobilization by F42-400 in K. pneumoniae, under different experimental conditions, was negative. We cannot exclude the possibility that the low transfer efficiencies prevented our detection of chromosome mobilization. A search among temperature-resistant, acridine orange-curing-resistant, or galactose-resistant derivatives of the K. pneumoniae donor strain failed to reveal any chromosome transfer. Our failure to detect Hfr's may be a result of: (i) the peculiarity of episome F42-400, (ii) the peculiarity of K. pneumoniae chromosome, or (iii) low transfer efficiency. K. pneumoniae-modified F42-400 and phage 424 were restricted by E. Coli K-12. E. coli K-12-modified episome F42-400 and phage 424 were restricted by K. pneumoniae. E. coli C failed to restrict F42-400 modified with K. pneumoniae specificity. The ability of K. pneumoniae to accept F42-400 is less, by about a factor of 50, than that of E. coli C. As an explanation for the differences in the behavior of E. coli C and K. pneumoniae in ability to receive F42-400 it was suggested that recipient bacteria have specific sites for interaction with the F-pilus tip; these are present in E. Coli C, leading to high transfer efficiency, whereas they may not be present (or if present, are not accessible) in K. pneumoniae, leading to low transfer efficiency.

Isolation of a hybrid F' factor-carrying Escherichia coli lactose region and Salmonella typhimurium histidine region, F42-400 (F' ts114 lac+, his+): its partial characterization and behavior in Salmonella typhimurium

Episome F' ts114 lac+ (F42-114) was transferred into Salmonella typhimurium carrying an F'his+ (FS400) episome, and fused episome F' ts114 lac+, his+ (F42-400) was obtained. Episome F42-400 could be transferred to S. typhimurium, Escherichia coli and Klebsiella pneumoniae. Identification of the episome was based on: (i) temperature sensitivity of the Lac+ and His+ phenotypes; (ii) the fact that F- segregants, obtained after temperature curing or acridine orange curing, were simultaneously Lac- and His-; and (iii) linkage of lac+ with his+ in episomal transfers to E. coli and S. typhimurium. The frequency of episome transfer was influenced by the genotype of the donor. Plasmid LT2, prevalent in S. typhimurium LT2 strains, was suggested to be responsible for the low fertility of S. typhimurium donors. Episome F42-400 was capable of chromosome mobilization, and the extent of chromosome mobilization was not influenced by the presence or absence of the histidine region on the donor chromosome. Growth in a defined medium with acridine orange was able to cure F42-400. The frequency of curing was increased (the frequency of His+ cells was 0.0001%) if the cells were grown at 40 C in the presence of acridine orange. Selection for temperature-resistant Lac+, His+ derivatives in a strain without histidine deletion yielded Hfr strains. However, similar and stronger selections in strains without the chromosomal histidine region failed to yield Hfr strains. Our inability to obtain Hfr's in strains without the chromosomal histidine region was explained by assuming that the episome F42-400 has lost the F sites involved in integration into the S. typhimurium chromosome.

Five control systems preventing transfer of Escherichia coli K-12 sex factor F

The transfer inhibition systems of 28 Fin+ plasmids have been characterized, using Flac mutants insensitive to inhibition by R100 or R62. All F-like plasmids (except R455) and one N group plasmid determined systems analogous to that of R100; this is designated the FinOP system. None of these plasmids could supply a FinP component of the transfer inhibitor able to replace that of F itself. In addition to the FinOP and R62 transfer inhibition systems described previously, new systems were encoded by the F-like plasmid R455, the I-like plasmid JR66a, and the group X plasmid R485. Besides inhibiting F transfer, JR66a also inhibited F pilus formation and surface exclusion, whereas R485 inhibited only pilus formation and R455 inhibited neither. All three R factors inhibited transfer of J-independent Flac elements, indicating that they act directly on one or more genes (or products) of the transfer operon, rather than directly via traJ. The tral products and transfer origin sequences of two Fin+ F-like plasmids, ColB2 and R124, appear to have similar specificities to those of F itself.

Plasmid specificity of the origin of transfer of sex factor F

The ability of F-like plasmids to promote transfer from the F origin of transfer was determined. Chromosome transfer was measured from plasmid derivatives of RecA(-) Hfr deletion strains which had lost all the F transfer genes but which in some cases retained, and in others had also lost, the origin sequence. ColV2 and ColVBtrp could initiate transfer from the F origin, but R100-1, R1-19, and R538-1 drd could not. These results can be correlated with the plasmid specificity of the traI components of the different plasmid transfer systems, supporting the hypothesis that the origin of transfer is the site of action of the traI product. Most F-like plasmids, including R1-19 and R538-1 drd, could transfer ColE1, consistent with previous findings that the (plasmid-specific) traI product is not necessary for ColE1 transfer by Flac; ColE1 transfer may be initiated by a ColE1-or host-determined product. R100-1 and R136fin(-) could not transfer ColE1 efficiently, apparently because of differences residing in their pilus-forming genes.

Interactions between the surface exclusion systems of some F-like plasmids

Four surface exclusion systems have been identified amongst a group of F-like plasmids inE. coli: SfxI(F), SfxII(ColV2 and R538-1fin−), SfxIII(ColVBtrpand R1-19) and SfxIV(R100-1 and R136fin−). None of these systems was expressed in stationary phase cells or, except for ColVBtrp, duringfin+transfer inhibition, showing that the surface exclusion gene(s) is usually co-controlled with the transfer genes.

Recipient cells carrying two plasmids specifying different surface exclusion systems did not always express both of these: the overall pattern suggested that the four systems and/or their sites of action are related. There was no surface exclusion between donor cells carrying two plasmids determining different surface exclusion systems and recipient cells carrying a plasmid determining either one of these. Our hypothesis to explain this and other results is that surface exclusion prevents interaction between the tip of the pilus on the donor cell and a receptor site on the recipient cell surface. Pili (probably mixed) with two types of tips would be present on cells carrying two different plasmids, the one unresponsive to the single surface exclusion system of the recipient cells allowing transfer of both plasmids.

Mapping loci for surface exclusion and incompatibility on the F factor of Escherichia coli K-12

A series of Hfr deletion strains carrying deletions extending different distances into the integrated F factor have been used to map loci for surface exclusion (traS) and for incompatibility (inc) on the Escherichia coli K-12 sex factor F. traS mapped between traG and traD. It forms a part of the large operon, including all the known transfer genes except traJ, and is co-controlled with these. The product of traS is not required for formation of the F pilus. inc mapped between the phi(R) (11) locus and the origin of transfer; it is therefore one of the earliest loci transferred during conjugation.

Surface exclusion by ColV-K94

Measurement of ColEl transfer by ColV2, inE. coliK12, showed that ColV2 specifies a surface exclusion system. This system is different from those specified by Flac, and by ColVBtrpand Rl-19. Like these other two systems, the ColV2 surface exclusion system is subject to inhibition by the appropriate transfer inhibitor, and is not expressed in stationary phase cells.