Vertigo in Childhood

Differentiation of peripheral and non-peripheral etiologies in children with vertigo/dizziness: The video-head impulse test and suppression head impulse paradigm

OBJECTIVES

To identify the etiology of vertigo/dizziness and determine the effectiveness of the video-head impulse test (vHIT) and the suppression head impulse paradigm (SHIMP) tests in distinguishing between peripheral and non-peripheral etiologies in children who presented to the otolaryngology department with complaints of vertigo/dizziness.

METHODS

The vHIT and SHIMP tests were applied to the children. The vestibulo-ocular reflex (VOR) gain and saccade parameters were compared.

RESULTS

In 27 children presenting with vertigo/dizziness, the most common etiological factor was inner ear malformation (IEM) (n = 6/27, 22.2%), followed by cochlear implant surgery (11.1%) and migraine (11.1%). Vestibular hypofunction was indicated by the vHIT results at a rate of 60% (9/15 children) and SHIMP results at 73.3% (11/15 children) among the children with a peripheral etiology, while these rates were 8.3% (1/12 children) and 25% (3/12 children), respectively, in the non-peripheral etiology group. SHIMP-VOR and vHIT-VOR gain values had a moderate positive correlation (p = 0.01, r = 0.349). While there were overt/covert saccades in the vHIT, anti-compensatory saccade (ACSs) were not observed in the SHIMP test (p = 0.041). The rates of abnormal vHIT-VOR gain (p = 0.001), over/covert saccades (p = 0.019), abnormal vHIT response (p = 0.014), ACSs (p = 0.001), and abnormal SHIMP response (p = 0.035) were significantly higher in the peripheral etiology group.

CONCLUSIONS

IEM was the most common etiological cause, and the rate of vestibular hypofunction was higher in these children with peripheral vertigo. vHIT and SHIMP are effective and useful vestibular tests for distinguishing peripheral etiology from non-peripheral etiology in the pediatric population with vertigo/dizziness. These tests can be used together or alone, but the first choice should be the SHIMP test, considering its short application time (approximately 4-5 min) and simplicity.

Spinning Through History: Evolution of the Concept of Vestibular Migraine

Vestibular migraine represents a growing public health problem, imposing enormous societal burdens in the form of patient suffering, loss of productivity, and direct healthcare costs. This raises the question of how we developed our ideas about vestibular migraine and how these ideas shape how we treat it. This review walks through the history of how our conceptualization of migraine and vestibular symptoms evolved, starting with clinical observations in ancient times, inclusion under the umbrella of Meniere's disease, and then separation from Meniere's disease with its own identity. Tradition, clinical observations, and diagnostic criteria developed by professional societies have played prominent roles in building our current concept of vestibular migraine. A review of the ideas that have shaped our current conception of vestibular migraine may help us to see which ones have stood the test of time and which ones should continue to evolve. As in other disciplines, we study history in medicine to be inspired, warned, and sometimes, to be freed.

(Doctor…My child keeps falling over) unexpected MRI findings in children with history of frequent falls and dizziness: a case series

Frequent falls and dizziness are common complaints in children. These symptoms can be caused by wide range of underlying pathologies including peripheral vestibular deficits, cardiac disease, central lesions, motor skills delay and psychogenic disorders. We report three paediatric cases who presented with complaints of repeated falls and imbalance. MRI scan revealed underlying brain lesions (frontal lobe arteriovenous malformation, exophytic brain stem glioma and cerebellomedullary angle arachnoid cyst with cerebellar tonsillar ectopia). By reporting these cases, we would like to emphasise the importance of a thorough assessment of children with similar symptoms by detailed clinical history, physical examination and maintaining low threshold for investigations, including radiological imaging. Taking in consideration, the wide range of differential diagnosis, the challenge of obtaining detailed history and difficulty of performing reliable physical examination in this age group. Management of underlying disorders can be medical, surgical or just observational.

Vertigo in childhood: a retrospective series of 100 children

OBJECTIVE

Evaluation and management of vertigo in children vary between institutions and medical specialties. The aim of this study is to describe the characteristics of vertigo in children presenting to a pediatric neurology referral center and to investigate the relationship between vertigo and migraine.

STUDY DESIGN

Patients <18 years old presenting with vertigo to Hacettepe University Ihsan Dogramaci Children's Hospital Neurology Unit between January 1996-January 2012 were included (n = 100). Data were obtained from patient files and phone interviews.

RESULTS

Mean age was 7.5 years. The most common etiological groups were benign paroxysmal vertigo of childhood (BPVC) (39%), psychogenic vertigo (21%), epileptic vertigo (15%), and migraine-associated vertigo (MAV) (11%). BPVC was the most common diagnosis in children ≤5 years of age while psychogenic vertigo prevailed in children >5 years. Staring episodes characterized epileptic vertigo patients (p = 0.021) while headache was more often described by MAV patients (p < 0.001). Vertigo attacks >5 min were uncommon in BPVC patients compared to others (p = 0.013). Twenty percent of BPVC patients contacted through phone interviews were experiencing migraine type headaches that started at a median age of 7.5 years. An algorithm for evaluation of children with vertigo was formed based on data obtained from this study and the literature. When this algorithm was applied to 100 cases of this series, 88 (88%) were correctly diagnosed.

CONCLUSION

While most vertigo cases in children can be diagnosed accurately by a detailed medical history, physical and neurological examination, a standard algorithm can help with the correct classification.

Vertigo in children and adolescents: characteristics and outcome

Objectives. To describe the characteristics and outcome of vertigo in a pediatric population. Patients. All children and adolescents presenting with vertigo to a tertiary otoneurology clinic between the years 2003–2010 were included in the study. Results. Thirty-seven patients with a mean age of 14 years were evaluated. The most common etiology was migraine-associated vertigo (MAV) followed by acute labyrinthitis/neuritis and psychogenic dizziness. Ten patients (27%) had pathological findings on the otoneurological examination. Abnormal findings were documented in sixteen of the twenty-three (70%) completed electronystagmography evaluations. Twenty patients (54%) were referred to treatment by other disciplines than otology/otoneurology. A follow-up questionnaire was filled by twenty six (70%) of the study participants. While all patients diagnosed with MAV had continuous symptoms, most other patients had complete resolution. Conclusions. Various etiologies of vertigo may present with similar symptoms and signs in the pediatric patient. Yet, variable clinical courses should be anticipated, depending on the specific etiology. This is the reason why treatment and follow up should be specifically tailored for each case according to the diagnosis. Close collaboration with other medical disciplines is often required to reach the correct diagnosis and treatment while avoiding unnecessary laboratory examinations.

Vertigo and balance problems in children--an epidemiologic study in Finland

OBJECTIVES

There is only scant data about the frequency and characteristics of vertigo in children. The aim of the study was to determine the prevalence and characteristics of vertigo and balance problems in children aged between 1 and 15 years.

METHOD

One thousand and fifty children aged from 1 to 15 years from one child welfare unit and three schools in Helsinki University Hospital District received a questionnaire acquiring about their dizzy symptoms.

RESULTS

Of 1050 eligible children, 938 (89%) or a caregiver completed a simple screening questionnaire, 8% had experienced vertigo and 23% of these it was so severe vertigo that it prevented their present activity. Reason for vertigo was unknown in one third of the children and 69% could name a provocative factor for their vertigo.

CONCLUSION

Balance problems are not rare in children and can limit their daily activities.

A simplified diagnostic approach to dizziness in children

The objective of the study was to validate the effectiveness of a questionnaire and computer-assisted algorithm in diagnosing children with dizziness or vertigo. Dizziness and vertigo are common complaints in children, causing an extensive, often unnecessary evaluation. A pediatric "dizziness questionnaire" was designed and a computer-assisted algorithm was developed to facilitate the diagnostic task. A retrospective medical record review was conducted on all children presenting to the clinic for dizziness or vertigo throughout a 2-year period. The information was used by one investigator to complete the questionnaire and by the other, the algorithm. The two diagnoses thus obtained were compared by the third investigator to the medical record diagnosis. Sixty-two records were reviewed. The final diagnoses were migraine (39%), benign paroxysmal vertigo (15%), vestibular neuronitis (14%), and anxiety (13%). In 57 patients (92%), the questionnaire-derived diagnosis was identical to the medical record diagnosis. In 52 patients (84%), the algorithm-derived diagnosis matched the medical record diagnosis. The questionnaire and computer-assisted algorithm are reliable diagnostic screening tools for children with dizziness or vertigo. When these tools combined provide a clear-cut diagnosis, no further evaluation is necessary.

Various causes and clinical characteristics in vertigo in children with normal eardrums

OBJECTIVE

The differential diagnosis of vertigo in children is extensive. Otitis media and middle ear effusion could be the most common causes of vertigo in children, but there are some problems in detecting the other causes for vertigo because they are one of most frequent diseases of childhood. The purpose of this study is to review the clinical characteristics and both the audiological and vestibular findings of vertigo in children with normal eardrums, who do not show otitis media or middle ear effusion, and to assist in making a differential diagnosis of vertigo.

METHODS

The fifty five children (< 16 years old) with vertigo, who visited the Department of Otolaryngology, Ajou University Hospital, Suwon, South Korea between January 1995 and December 2001 were selected for this study. These excluded the patients with abnormal eardrums/tympanograms or those that did not perform questionnaires, audiological, or vestibular evaluations. They were retrospectively analyzed for clinical symptoms, vestibular functions, and differential diagnosis.

RESULTS

The most common causes for vertigo in children were migraine in 17 (30.9%) and benign paroxysmal vertigo of childhood (BPVC) in 14 (25.5%). Other less frequent causes included four cases of trauma, two cases each of Meniere's disease, delayed endolymphatic hydrops, benign positional vertigo, and one case only for cerebellopontine angle tumor, seizure, acute vestibular neuritis, juvenile rheumatoid arthritis, leaving ten cases (18.2%) as unclassified. Abnormal findings were noted in 13 (23.6%) in pure tone audiogram, 3 (5.5%) in positioning test, 6 (10.9%) in bithermal caloric test, and 36 (65.5%) in rotation chair test.

CONCLUSIONS

The vertigo in children with normal eardrums, who did not show otitis media or middle ear effusion, was most commonly caused by migraine and BPVC. These findings have shown to be very different from those with adult vertigo. The evaluation of vertigo in children requires a questionnaire for extensive and complete history taking, audiograms and vestibular function tests. And in selected cases, electroencephalography, hematological evaluation, imaging of the brain or temporal bone should be performed.

Ménière's disease and delayed endolymphatic hydrops in children

In order to study the characteristics of pediatric patients (< or = 15 years at onset) with endolymphatic hydrops disorders, we selected 5 patients with Ménière's disease (MD) and 3 patients with delayed endolymphatic hydrops (DEH) from 7418 patients who had visited the Neurotological Clinic of the Toyama Medical and Pharmaceutical University Hospital between 1979 and 1999. Clinical features were characterized as follows: (i) pediatric MD patients were rare, comprising approximately 1.5% of all the 337 MD patients in the sample; (ii) a fluctuating hearing loss, strong positive response in glycerol test, high SP/AP amplitude ratio in electrocochleography and moderate positive response in furosemide vestibulo-ocular reflex test were recorded; (iii) in 2 of the 5 pediatric MD patients, vertiginous attacks had persisted for a long period and they had undergone surgical procedures (sac operation and vestibular neurectomy); and (iv) the ipsilateral type of DEH was observed in 2/3 children, and contralateral DEH in 1/3.

Ménière's disease in childhood

We report 3 rare cases of Ménière's disease in children. In Case 1 and 3, vertigo, hearing loss and tinnitus recovered soon after medical therapy. In Case 2, however, vertigo recurred and the hearing level on the right side markedly deteriorated. The equal-loudness contours on three-dimensional audiogram showed that right-sided aggravated hearing loss fluctuated for 4 years at middle-and low-frequencies despite medication. Finally intratympanic injection of gentamicin sulfate was performed. The patient has had no definitive spell of vertigo after gentamicin therapy. At our department, the incidence of Ménière's disease in pediatric patients with vertigo was 2.9%.

Dizziness in childhood

There is a scant literature regarding vestibular evaluation of children with complaints of dizziness or vertigo. Considerable time and effort are expended on the problem and prevention of hearing loss in children, yet we often ignore concurrent or subsequent vestibular disorders. This neglect could be due to several factors, perhaps the most common being the fact that vertiginous crises in childhood are often attributed to problems of behavior or incoordination. In this article, we offer an approach to the dizzy child based on presenting symptoms. We discuss features of the history, examination, and laboratory evaluation key to determining the cause of dizziness. Finally, we discuss management, which varies according to the diagnosis.

Is the vestibular system affected by middle ear effusion?

The association between middle ear effusion (MEE) and vestibular pathology is controversial. To investigate this point, 50 children with MEE scheduled for myringotomy and grommet, and 20 normal hearing children without MEE scheduled for adenotonsillectomy, underwent vestibular investigations by craniocorpography and rotatory chair, preoperatively and postoperatively. Most of the correlations, preoperative vs. postoperative, and study vs. control groups, were nonsignificant. Assuming that serous labyrinthitis is responsible for vestibular involvement in MEE, the lack of significant vestibular pathology in our study could probably be explained by the fact that no children with acute otitis media episodes or otalgia were included.

Dysequilibrium and otitis media with effusion: what is the association?

An association between non-suppurative otitis media (NSOM) and symptoms of dysequilibrium has been observed but not previously quantified in children (Gates, 1980; Busis, 1983; Blayney and Coleman, 1984). This study compared the incidence of balance related problems in 154 children with surgically proven glue ear and 51 children with normal ear function. Symptoms ranging from true vertigo to mild ataxia were discovered in 22 per cent of the children with NSOM but in none of those within the control group (p less than 0.001). Periods of dysequilibrium were associated with episodes of otalgia in 64 per cent of the children but were not increased in those with unilateral compared to those with bilateral effusions. Complete resolution of symptoms occurred in 85 per cent of children following the insertion of grommets. A history of balance disturbance should be actively sought in all children with otitis media with effusion, and when present, provides a strong indication for early operative intervention.

Meniere’s Disease in Childhood

The incidence of Meniere’s disease in childhood has been reported to range between 1% and 7% of all patients diagnosed with the disease. The classic triad of symptoms including tinnitus, fluctuating hearing loss, and vertigo presents specific problems in the school setting. This paper is a review of the literature including incidence, symptoms and diagnosis, eitology, treatment, and implications for management in the school environment. Description of an actual case study is also presented.

Vestibular neuronitis in childhood

Over a 14-year period commencing in 1973, we followed 177 children less than 12 years old suffering from vertigo and/or disequilibrium. In 35 of 177 patients, the vertigo-like condition was due to peripheral causes: 10 sudden deafness, six vestibular neuronitis, three benign paroxysmal positional vertigo and three Meniere's disease. In this paper, two cases of pediatric vestibular neuronitis will be reported in detail. All six patients with vestibular neuronitis were boys, and the affected sides were equally distributed in the group. The patients recovered within two to four weeks, a prognosis which is better than that observed in adults. With regard to directional nystagmus, the gaze was bilateral in five patients and vertical in two. They showed neuro-otologic findings that suggest not only unilateral dysfunction but also bilateral disorders or partial lesions on the central vestibular system. Consequently, in the hope that the study of vertigo in childhood may provide additional clues to the pathogenesis of the disease in adults, we would like to consider two cases of pediatric cases of vestibular neuronitis.

Juvenile Menière's disease

The authors report their experience in the diagnosis and treatment of Menière's disease in childhood. They believe it to be essential to carry out a complete battery of audio-vestibular tests, with particular reference to dehydration procedures, which in this age group are considered to be more significant for a correct diagnosis than in adults. After stressing the importance of eliminating other forms of disease which manifest themselves with vertigo, the authors conclude by asserting the efficacy of medical treatment with diuretics and they support the surgical procedure of endolymphatic-mastoid drainage as a valid means of contending with the hydrops.

Dizziness in childhood

Dizziness in childhood is not an infrequent symptom. Accurate history taking and close co-operation between otologist, paediatrician and neurologist are necessary in the approach to the dizzy child. Most cases of childhood dizziness settle in time and investigations should be carefully selected; those with severe and persistent dizziness or ataxia should be thoroughly investigated including: EEG, ENG, calorics and CT scan. The conditions causing dizziness in children are discussed and are illustrated with case histories from our series of 27 children. Dizziness of unknown aetiology, serous otitis media and benign paroxysmal vertigo were the most common diagnostic labels applied to our patients. Treatment is rarely necessary but dimenhydrinate or a labyrinthine sedative in those with troublesome vertigo, or the adjustment of the medical regime in those epileptics on phenytoin, may be beneficial. Surgical intervention is only required in those with an operable lesion.

Meniere's disease in infants

We described 3 patients who, from early infancy, evidenced attacks of vomiting associated with fluctuating hearing loss, culminating in bilateral severe sensorineural hearing loss. The patients suffered from Meniere's disease, according to all clinical yardsticks. The patients described by us were at first diagnosed and treated for gastroenteritis or meningitis. Meniere's disease was not suspected. We want to point out that Meniere's disease, though usually presenting itself at middle age, may well start in childhood as well as in infancy, and should be suspected whenever vomiting, without diarrhea, is associated with some hearing loss at any age--no matter how young the patient is. It is also possible that some sensorineural hearing losses in late childhood or adulthood are in effect the end result of burnt-out Meniere's disease--as our second case presented himself.

Ménière's disease in children

Approximately 3% of all patients with Meniere's disease are in the pediatric age group. These children require extensive evaluation. A history of physical or acoustic trauma should be sought and an allergic work-up should be obtained. A search for metabolic disturbances and identification of inflammatory disorders is also necessary. If a treatable etiology is identified, specific therapy should be directed toward its control. If, after careful evaluation, the etiology remains obscure, non-specific therapy should be instituted in an effort to alleviate the symptomatology of Meniere's disease. Surgical decompression of the endolymphatic sac and drainage into the mastoid cavity results in relieving the symptoms, particularly vertigo, and appears to be efficacious in patients who have failed diligent attempts at medical therapy.

Clinical findings and diagnostic problems in sensorineural low frequency hearing loss

The otological and audiological findings in 39 patients with sensorineural low frequency hearing loss are reported. This type of perceptive hearing loss is difficult to distinguish from the true conductive hearing losses due to the air conduction audiogram shape and the invalidity of bone conduction determinations showing a false "air-bone gap". This may lead to surgical treatment of a perceptive hearing loss, as reported in the four case histories. By various audiological tests, contradictory information may be obtained. In our material, Bing's test and absent acoustic reflexes indicated a conductive disorder in 25% of the ears. The final differentiation may require cochleography. The hearing loss may be diagnosed as Meniere's disease. In our material only 17% complained of tinnitus and no patients had vertigo. Consequently, we find sensorineural low frequency hearing loss to differ from Meniere's disease. Our material comprises different etiological types of perceptive low frequency hearing loss. On type was inherited as an autosomal dominant trait, another type due to cochlear malformation probably also inherited, and a third group showing diverse audiological results. When the diagnosis is established, the patients may be treated successfully by specially constructed hearing aids.