Middle-Down Analysis of Monoclonal Antibodies with Electron Transfer Dissociation Orbitrap Fourier Transform Mass Spectrometry

Top-down proteomics

Proteoforms, which arise from post-translational modifications, genetic polymorphisms and RNA splice variants, play a pivotal role as drivers in biology. Understanding proteoforms is essential to unravel the intricacies of biological systems and bridge the gap between genotypes and phenotypes. By analysing whole proteins without digestion, top-down proteomics (TDP) provides a holistic view of the proteome and can decipher protein function, uncover disease mechanisms and advance precision medicine. This Primer explores TDP, including the underlying principles, recent advances and an outlook on the future. The experimental section discusses instrumentation, sample preparation, intact protein separation, tandem mass spectrometry techniques and data collection. The results section looks at how to decipher raw data, visualize intact protein spectra and unravel data analysis. Additionally, proteoform identification, characterization and quantification are summarized, alongside approaches for statistical analysis. Various applications are described, including the human proteoform project and biomedical, biopharmaceutical and clinical sciences. These are complemented by discussions on measurement reproducibility, limitations and a forward-looking perspective that outlines areas where the field can advance, including potential future applications.

Panda-UV Unlocks Deeper Protein Characterization with Internal Fragments in Ultraviolet Photodissociation Mass Spectrometry

Ultraviolet photodissociation (UVPD) mass spectrometry unlocks insights into the protein structure and sequence through fragmentation patterns. While N- and C-terminal fragments are traditionally relied upon, this work highlights the critical role of internal fragments in achieving near-complete sequencing of protein. Previous limitations of internal fragment utilization, owing to their abundance and potential for random matching, are addressed here with the development of Panda-UV, a novel software tool combining spectral calibration, and Pearson correlation coefficient scoring for confident fragment assignment. Panda-UV showcases its power through comprehensive benchmarks on three model proteins. The inclusion of internal fragments boosts identified fragment numbers by 26% and enhances average protein sequence coverage to a remarkable 93% for intact proteins, unlocking the hidden region of the largest protein carbonic anhydrase II in model proteins. Notably, an average of 65% of internal fragments can be identified in multiple replicates, demonstrating the high confidence of the fragments Panda-UV provided. Finally, the sequence coverages of mAb subunits can be increased up to 86% and the complementary determining regions (CDRs) are nearly completely sequenced in a single experiment. The source codes of Panda-UV are available at https://github.com/PHOENIXcenter/Panda-UV.

CE-MS/MS and CE-timsTOF to separate and characterize intramolecular disulfide bridges of monoclonal antibody subunits and their application for the assessment of subunit reduction protocols

Characterization at the subunit level enables detailed mass spectrometric characterization of posttranslational modifications (PTMs) of monoclonal antibodies (mAbs). The implemented reduction often leaves the intramolecular disulfide bridges intact. Here, we present a capillary electrophoretic (CE) method based on a neutral-coated capillary for the separation of immunoglobulin G-degrading enzyme of Streptococcus pyogenes (IdeS) digested and reduced mAb subunits followed by mass spectrometry (MS), MS/MS identification, and trapped ion mobility mass spectrometry (timsTOF). Our CE approach enables the separation of (i) different subunit moieties, (ii) various reduction states, and (iii) positional isomers of these partly reduced subunit moieties. The location of the remaining disulfide bridges can be determined by middle-down electron transfer higher energy collisional dissociation (EThcD) experiments. All these CE-separated variants show differences in ion mobility in the timsTOF measurements. Applying the presented CE-MS/MS method, reduction parameters such as the use of chaotropic salts were studied. For the investigated antibodies, urea improved the subunit reduction significantly, whereas guanidine hydrochloride (GuHCl) leads to multiple signals of the same subunit in the CE separation. The presented CE-MS method is a powerful tool for the disulfide-variant characterization of mAbs on the subunit level. It enables understanding disulfide bridge reduction processes in antibodies and potentially other proteins.

Internal Fragments Enhance Middle-Down Mass Spectrometry Structural Characterization of Monoclonal Antibodies and Antibody-Drug Conjugates

Monoclonal antibodies (mAbs) and antibody-drug conjugates (ADCs) are important large biotherapeutics (∼150 kDa) and high structural complexity that require extensive sequence and structure characterization. Middle-down mass spectrometry (MD-MS) is an emerging technique that sequences and maps subunits larger than those released by trypsinolysis. It avoids potentially introducing artifactual modifications that may occur in bottom-up MS while achieving higher sequence coverage compared to top-down MS. However, returning complete sequence information by MD-MS is still challenging. Here, we show that assigning internal fragments in direct infusion MD-MS of a mAb and an ADC substantially improves their structural characterization. For MD-MS of the reduced NIST mAb, including internal fragments recovers nearly 100% of the sequence by accessing the middle sequence region that is inaccessible by terminal fragments. The identification of important glycosylations can also be improved after the inclusion of internal fragments. For the reduced lysine-linked IgG1-DM1 ADC, we show that considering internal fragments increases the DM1 conjugation sites coverage to 80%, comparable to the reported 83% coverage achieved by peptide mapping on the same ADC (Luo et al. Anal. Chem. 2016, 88, 695-702). This study expands our work on the application of internal fragment assignments in top-down MS of mAbs and ADCs and can be extended to other heterogeneous therapeutic molecules such as multispecifics and fusion proteins for more widespread applications.

GeLC-FAIMS-MS workflow for in-depth middle-down proteomics

Middle-down proteomics (MDP) is an analytical approach in which protein samples are digested with proteases such as Glu-C to generate large peptides (>3 kDa) that are analyzed by mass spectrometry (MS). This method is useful for characterizing high-molecular-weight proteins that are difficult to detect by top-down proteomics (TDP), in which intact proteins are analyzed by MS. In this study, we applied GeLC-FAIMS-MS, a multidimensional separation workflow that combines gel-based prefractionation with LC-FAIMS MS, for deep MDP. Middle-down peptides generated by optimized limited Glu-C digestion conditions were first size-fractionated by polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis, followed by C4 reversed-phase liquid chromatography separation and additional ion mobility fractionation, resulting in a significant increase in peptide length detectable by MS. In addition to global analysis, the GeLC-FAIMS-MS concept can also be applied to targeted MDP, where only proteins in the desired molecular weight range are gel-fractionated and their Glu-C digestion products are analyzed, as demonstrated by targeted analysis of integrins in exosomes. In-depth MDP achieved by global and targeted GeLC-FAIMS-MS supports the exploration of proteoform information not covered by conventional TDP by increasing the number of detectable protein groups or post-translational modifications (PTMs) and improving the sequence coverage.

Direct Comparison of the Hinge-Cleaving Proteases IgdE and BdpK for LC-MS-Based IgG1 Clonal Profiling

Human antibodies are heterogeneous molecules primarily due to clonal sequence variations. Analytical techniques to assess antibody levels quantitatively, such as ELISA, lack the power to resolve abundances at the clonal level. Recently, we introduced an LC-MS-based approach that can distinguish and quantify antibody clones using the mass and retention time of their corresponding Fab-fragments. We used specific hinge-cleaving protease IgdE (FabALACTICA) to release the Fab-fragments from the constant Fc region of the antibody. Here, we explore an alternative IgG1 hinge-cleaving protease, BdpK (FabDELLO), and compare it directly to IgdE for use in IgG1 repertoire profiling. We used IgdE and BdpK in parallel to digest all IgG1s from the same set of plasma samples. Both proteases cleave IgG1 specifically in the hinge, albeit via different mechanisms and at two distinct cleavage sites. Notwithstanding these differences, the Fab fragments generated by IgdE or BdpK produced highly similar clonal repertoires. However, IgdE required ∼16 h of incubation to digest plasma IgG1s, while BdpK required ∼2 h. We authenticated the similarity of the clones by top-down proteomics using electron transfer dissociation. We conclude that BdpK performs very well in digesting polyclonal plasma IgG1s and that neither BdpK nor IgdE displays detectable biases in cleaving IgG1s. We anticipate that BdpK may emerge as the preferred protease for IgG1 hinge-digestion because it offers a shorter digestion time compared to IgdE, an equally specific digestion site, and no bias against any IgG1 present in plasma.

Interpretation of Tandem Mass Spectrometry (MS-MS) Spectra for Peptide Analysis

The aim of this chapter is to give a short introduction to peptide analysis by mass spectrometry (MS) and interpretation of fragment mass spectra. Through examples and guidelines, we will demonstrate how to understand and validate search results and how to perform de novo sequencing based on the often very complex fragmentation pattern obtained by tandem mass spectrometry (also referred to as MSMS). The focus will be on simple rules for interpretation of MSMS spectra of tryptic as well as non-tryptic peptides.

Internal Fragment Ions from Higher Energy Collision Dissociation Enable the Glycoform-Resolved Asn325 Deamidation Assessment of Antibodies by Middle-Down Mass Spectrometry

A major challenge in proteoform characterization is to obtain information on coexisting post-translational modifications (PTMs), which is lost in traditional bottom-up analysis. Middle-down approaches of antibodies provide a good balance of resolution, site-specificity, and proteoform heterogeneity to characterize individual proteoforms at subunit level. Currently, most middle-down studies focus on terminal fragment ions, which may not cover or resolve PTMs in the center of the sequence or with minor mass shifts such as deamidation, often a critical quality attribute for antibody drugs. Antibody glycosylation at Asn 297 and deamidation at Asn 325 are two important PTMs impacting the interaction with Fc gamma receptors and hence effector functions such as antibody-dependent cellular cytotoxicity. Here, we established a new middle-down workflow that uses internal fragment ions for the qualitative and quantitative assessment of a functional relevant deamidation site, Asn 325, through higher energy collision dissociation fragmentation of individual antibody glycoforms upon quadrupole isolation. We identified a signature internal fragment ion to resolve and estimate the relative abundances of deamidation of individual glycoforms in complex mixtures. Our proof-of-concept work demonstrates the feasibility to identify and quantify Asn 325 deamidation at the glycoform-resolved subunit level using internal fragment ions, which greatly advances the capabilities to study PTM dynamics by middle-down analysis.

Mass spectrometry characterization of antibodies at the intact and subunit levels: from targeted to large-scale analysis

Antibodies are one of the most formidable molecular weapons available to our immune system. Their high specificity against a target (antigen) and capability of triggering different immune responses (e.g., complement system activation and antibody-dependent cell-mediated cytotoxicity) make them ideal drugs to fight many different human diseases. Currently, both monoclonal antibodies and more complex molecules based on the antibody scaffold are used as biologics. Naturally, such highly heterogeneous molecules require dedicated analytical methodologies for their accurate characterization. Mass spectrometry (MS) can define the presence and relative abundance of multiple features of antibodies, including critical quality attributes. The combination of small and large variations within a single molecule can only be determined by analyzing intact antibodies or their large (25 to 100 kDa) subunits. Hence, top-down (TD) and middle-down (MD) MS approaches have gained popularity over the last decade. In this Young Scientist Feature we discuss the evolution of TD and MD MS analysis of antibodies, including the new frontiers that go beyond biopharma applications. We will show how this field is now moving from the "quality control" analysis of a known, single antibody to the high-throughput investigation of complex antibody repertoires isolated from clinical samples, where the ultimate goal is represented by the complete gas-phase sequencing of antibody molecules without the need of any a priori knowledge.

Added Value of Internal Fragments for Top-Down Mass Spectrometry of Intact Monoclonal Antibodies and Antibody-Drug Conjugates

Monoclonal antibodies (mAbs) and antibody-drug conjugates (ADCs) are two of the most important therapeutic drug classes that require extensive characterization, whereas their large size and structural complexity make them challenging to characterize and demand the use of advanced analytical methods. Top-down mass spectrometry (TD-MS) is an emerging technique that minimizes sample preparation and preserves endogenous post-translational modifications (PTMs); however, TD-MS of large proteins suffers from low fragmentation efficiency, limiting the sequence and structure information that can be obtained. Here, we show that including the assignment of internal fragments in native TD-MS of an intact mAb and an ADC can improve their molecular characterization. For the NIST mAb, internal fragments can access the sequence region constrained by disulfide bonds to increase the TD-MS sequence coverage to over 75%. Important PTM information, including intrachain disulfide connectivity and N-glycosylation sites, can be revealed after including internal fragments. For a heterogeneous lysine-linked ADC, we show that assigning internal fragments improves the identification of drug conjugation sites to achieve a coverage of 58% of all putative conjugation sites. This proof-of-principle study demonstrates the potential value of including internal fragments in native TD-MS of intact mAbs and ADCs, and this analytical strategy can be extended to bottom-up and middle-down MS approaches to achieve even more comprehensive characterization of important therapeutic molecules.

A multiparameter optimization in middle-down analysis of monoclonal antibodies by LC-MS/MS

In antibody-based drug research, a complete characterization of antibody proteoforms covering both the amino acid sequence and all posttranslational modifications remains a major concern. The usual mass spectrometry-based approach to achieve this goal is bottom-up proteomics, which relies on the digestion of antibodies but does not allow the diversity of proteoforms to be assessed. Middle-down and top-down approaches have recently emerged as attractive alternatives but are not yet mastered and thus used in routine by many analytical chemistry laboratories. The work described here aims at providing guidelines to achieve the best sequence coverage for the fragmentation of intact light and heavy chains generated from a simple reduction of intact antibodies using Orbitrap mass spectrometry. Three parameters were found crucial to this aim: the use of an electron-based activation technique, the multiplex selection of precursor ions of different charge states, and the combination of replicates.

[Antibody proteomics]

Antibodies represent an essential component of humoral immunity; therefore their study is important for molecular biology and medicine. The unique property of antibodies to specifically recognize and bind a certain molecular target (an antigen) determines their widespread application in treatment and diagnostics of diseases, as well as in laboratory and biotechnological practices. High specificity and affinity of antibodies is determined by the presence of primary structure variable regions, which are not encoded in the human genome and are unique for each antibody-producing B cell clone. Hence, there is little or no information about amino acid sequences of the variable regions in the databases. This differs identification of antibody primary structure from most of the proteomic studies because it requires either B cell genome sequencing or de novo amino acid sequencing of the antibody. The present review demonstrates some examples of proteomic and proteogenomic approaches and the methodological arsenal that proteomics can offer for studying antibodies, in particular, for identification of primary structure, evaluation of posttranslational modifications and application of bioinformatics tools for their decoding.

Characterization of the Time-Domain Isotopic Beat Patterns of Monoclonal Antibodies in Fourier Transform Mass Spectrometry

The time-domain transients in the Fourier transform mass spectrometry (FTMS) analysis of monoclonal antibodies (mAbs) are known to exhibit characteristic isotopic beat patterns. These patterns are defined by the isotopic distributions of all gaseous mAb ions present in the FTMS mass analyzer, originating from single or multiple charge states, and from single or multiple proteoforms. For an isolated charge state of a single proteoform, the mAb isotopic beat pattern resembles narrow splashes of signal amplitude (beats), spaced periodically in the time-domain transient, with broad (often exceeding 1 s) "valleys" between them. Here, we reinforce the importance of isotopic beat patterns for the accurate interpretation and presentation of FTMS data in the analysis of mAbs and other large biopolymers. An updated, mAb-grade version of the transient-mediated FTMS data simulation and visualization tool, FTMS Simulator is introduced and benchmarked. We then apply this tool to evaluate the charge-state dependent characteristics of isotopic beats in mAbs analyses with modern models of Orbitrap and ion cyclotron resonance (ICR) FTMS instruments, including detection of higher-order harmonics. We demonstrate the impact of the isotopic beat patterns on the analytical characteristics of the resulting mass spectra of individual and overlapping mAb proteoforms. The results reported here detail highly nonlinear dependences of resolution and signal-to-noise ratio on the time-domain transient period, absorption or magnitude mode spectra representation, and apodization functions. The provided description and the demonstrated ability to routinely conduct accurate simulations of FTMS data for large biopolymers should aid the end-users of Orbitrap and ICR FTMS instruments in the analysis of mAbs and other biopolymers, including viruses.

Fourier-transform ion cyclotron resonance mass spectrometry for characterizing proteoforms

Proteoforms contribute functional diversity to the proteome and aberrant proteoforms levels have been implicated in biological dysfunction and disease. Fourier-transform ion cyclotron resonance mass spectrometry (FT-ICR MS), with its ultrahigh mass-resolving power, mass accuracy, and versatile tandem MS capabilities, has empowered top-down, middle-down, and native MS-based approaches for characterizing proteoforms and their complexes in biological systems. Herein, we review the features which make FT-ICR MS uniquely suited for measuring proteoform mass with ultrahigh resolution and mass accuracy; obtaining in-depth proteoform sequence coverage with expansive tandem MS capabilities; and unambiguously identifying and localizing post-translational and noncovalent modifications. We highlight examples from our body of work in which we have quantified and comprehensively characterized proteoforms from cardiac and skeletal muscle to better understand conditions such as chronic heart failure, acute myocardial infarction, and sarcopenia. Structural characterization of monoclonal antibodies and their proteoforms by FT-ICR MS and emerging applications, such as native top-down FT-ICR MS and high-throughput top-down FT-ICR MS-based proteomics at 21 T, are also covered. Historically, the information gleaned from FT-ICR MS analyses have helped provide biological insights. We predict FT-ICR MS will continue to enable the study of proteoforms of increasing size from increasingly complex endogenous mixtures and facilitate the benchmarking of sensitive and specific assays for clinical diagnostics. © 2020 John Wiley & Sons Ltd. Mass Spec Rev.

A perspective toward mass spectrometry-based de novo sequencing of endogenous antibodies

A key step in therapeutic and endogenous humoral antibody characterization is identifying the amino acid sequence. So far, this task has been mainly tackled through sequencing of B-cell receptor (BCR) repertoires at the nucleotide level. Mass spectrometry (MS) has emerged as an alternative tool for obtaining sequence information directly at the – most relevant – protein level. Although several MS methods are now well established, analysis of recombinant and endogenous antibodies comes with a specific set of challenges, requiring approaches beyond the conventional proteomics workflows. Here, we review the challenges in MS-based sequencing of both recombinant as well as endogenous humoral antibodies and outline state-of-the-art methods attempting to overcome these obstacles. We highlight recent examples and discuss remaining challenges. We foresee a great future for these approaches making de novo antibody sequencing and discovery by MS-based techniques feasible, even for complex clinical samples from endogenous sources such as serum and other liquid biopsies.

Application of middle-down approach in quantitation and catabolite identification of protein by LC-high-resolution mass spectrometry

Aim: To further enhance the detection sensitivity and increase resolving power of top-down intact protein bioanalysis, middle-down approach was explored. Materials & methods: An monoclonal antibody (mAb) was used as a model protein to evaluate quantitative bioanalytical assay performance and a disulfide linked dimer protein was investigated for its pharmacokinetics properties and catabolism in vivo by middle-down approach. Results & Conclusion: For quantitation of the mAb, different subunits generated by middle-down approach provided different level of signal improvement in biological samples with Lc and half Fc giving five-times better sensitivity than intact mAb. For the dimer protein, middle-down analysis by reduction enabled effective differentiation of the unchanged protein and its oxidized form, and clearly elucidated their respective proteolytic catabolites.

Fast in-line bottom-up analysis of monoclonal antibodies: Toward an electrophoretic fingerprinting approach

For their characterization and quality control, monoclonal antibodies are frequently analyzed at the bottom-up level to generate specific fingerprints that can be used to tackle post-translational modifications or ensure production consistency between lots. To circumvent time-consuming and labor-intensive off-line sample preparation steps, the implementation of integrated methodologies from sample preparation to separation and detection is highly valuable. In this perspective, capillary zone electrophoresis appears as a choice technique since the capillary can subsequently be used as a vessel for sample preparation and electrophoretic discrimination/detection of the reaction products. Here, a fast in-line methodology for the routine quality control of mAbs at the bottom-up level is reported. Simultaneous denaturation and reduction (pretreatment step) were conducted with RapiGest® surfactant and dithiothreitol before in-line tryptic digestion. Reactant mixing was realized by transverse diffusion of laminar flow profile under controlled temperature. In-line digestion was carried out with a resistant trypsin to autolysis. The main parameters affecting the digestion efficiency (trypsin concentration and incubation conditions) were optimized to generate mAb electrophoretic profiles free from trypsin interferences. An acidic MS-compatible BGE was used to obtain high resolution separation of released peptides and in-line surfactant cleavage. The whole methodology was performed in less than two hours with good repeatability of migration times (RSD = 0.91%, n = 5) and corrected peak areas (RSD = 9.6%, n = 5). CE-fingerprints were successfully established for different mAbs and an antibody-drug conjugate.

Electron Transfer Dissociation Parameter Optimization Using Design of Experiments Increases Sequence Coverage of Monoclonal Antibodies

Middle-down analysis of monoclonal antibodies (mAbs) by tandem mass spectrometry (MS²) can provide detailed insight into their primary structure with minimal sample preparation. The middle-down approach uses an enzyme to cleave mAbs into Fc/2, LC, and Fd subunits that are then analyzed by reversed phase liquid chromatography tandem mass spectrometry (RPLC-MS²). As maximum sequence coverage is desired to obtain meaningful structural information at the subunit level, a host of dissociation methods have been developed, and sometimes combined, to bolster fragmentation and increase the number of identified fragments. Here, we present a design of experiments (DOE) approach to optimize MS² parameters, in particular those that may influence electron transfer dissociation (ETD) efficiency to increase the sequence coverage of antibody subunits. Applying this approach to the NIST monoclonal antibody standard (NISTmAb) using three RPLC-MS² runs resulted in high sequence coverages of 67%, 67%, and 52% for Fc/2, LC, and Fd subunits, respectively. In addition, we apply this DOE strategy to model the parameters required to maximize the number of fragments produced in "low", "medium", and "high" mass ranges, which ultimately resulted in even higher sequence coverages of NISTmAb subunits (75%, 78%, and 64% for Fc/2, LC, and Fd subunits, respectively). The DOE approach provides high sequence coverage percentages utilizing only one fragmentation method, ETD, and could be extended to other state-of-the-art techniques that combine multiple fragmentation mechanisms to increase coverage.

Integration of liquid chromatography mass spectrometry with a heavy peptide response curve accurately measures unprocessed C-terminal lysine during peptide mapping analysis of therapeutic antibodies in a single run

Therapeutic monoclonal and bispecific antibodies are susceptible to modification after protein biosynthesis. These post-translational modifications (PTMs) not only contribute to mass and charge heterogeneity, but they can also negatively impact the molecule's activity, half-life, and immunogenicity. Therefore, identification and quantification of PTMs are critical to ensure the safety and efficacy of an antibody therapeutic as well as demonstrate product consistency and process control. Unprocessed C-terminal lysine on the heavy chain (HC) is a prevalent modification that contributes to this charge heterogeneity in antibodies. Peptide mapping through liquid chromatography tandem mass spectrometry (LC-MS²) enjoys higher selectivity and sensitivity for measuring this PTM relative to global PTM methods, but differences in the ionization efficiencies of the unprocessed C-terminal K peptide and the truncated C-terminal K peptide result in its overestimation. Consequently, large discrepancies in this PTM's measured abundance may exist between different characterization assays used in regulatory filings, which can be further compounded by large variability when multiple mass spectrometers are used to quantify C-terminal K during a therapeutic's lifespan. In this study, we propose a simple new method to quantify unprocessed C-terminal K in antibodies in a single LC-MS² run that incorporates heavy isotopic standards for both the unprocessed and truncated C-terminal K peptide to build a response curve and correct for the disparity in ionization efficiency between these two different peptide sequences. The approach was evaluated across two different Orbitrap-based mass spectrometers using multiple monoclonal and bispecific therapeutic antibodies, resulting in accurate (<10% error, as determined with peptide standards) and precise C-terminal K quantification during peptide mapping analysis.

Multi-dimensional LC-MS: the next generation characterization of antibody-based therapeutics by unified online bottom-up, middle-up and intact approaches

This review presents an overview of current analytical trends in antibody characterization by multidimensional LC-MS approaches.

Lectin and Liquid Chromatography-Based Methods for Immunoglobulin (G) Glycosylation Analysis

Immunoglobulin (Ig) glycosylation has been shown to dramatically affect its structure and effector functions. Ig glycosylation changes have been associated with different diseases and show a promising biomarker potential for diagnosis and prognosis of disease advancement. On the other hand, therapeutic biomolecules based on structural and functional features of Igs demand stringent quality control during the production process to ensure their safety and efficacy. Liquid chromatography (LC) and lectin-based methods are routinely used in Ig glycosylation analysis complementary to other analytical methods, e.g., mass spectrometry and capillary electrophoresis. This chapter covers analytical approaches based on LC and lectins used in low- and high-throughput N- and O-glycosylation analysis of Igs, with the focus on immunoglobulin G (IgG) applications. General principles and practical examples of the most often used LC methods for Ig purification are described, together with typical workflows for N- and O-glycan analysis on the level of free glycans, glycopeptides, subunits, or intact Igs. Lectin chromatography is a historical approach for the analysis of lectin-carbohydrate interactions and glycoprotein purification but is still being used as a valuable tool in Igs purification and glycan analysis. On the other hand, lectin microarrays have found their application in the rapid screening of glycan profiles on intact proteins.

Rapid structural discrimination of IgG antibodies by multicharge-state collision-induced unfolding

Immunoglobulin G (IgG) antibodies are an important class of biotherapeutics that target various diseases, such as cancers, neurodegenerative disorders, and autoimmune diseases, yet rapid discrimination of IgG antibodies remains a great challenge due to heterogeneity, flexibility, and large size. Herein, we demonstrate a simplified multicharge-state collision-induced unfolding (CIU) method for rapid differentiation of four IgG isotypes that differ in terms of the numbers and patterns of disulfide bonds, bypassing tedious single charge-state selection in advance. The results presented herein reveal that gas-phase unfolding behaviors have a strong dependence on charge states outside IgG surfaces; therefore, multicharge-state CIU analysis of IgG subtypes could offer a great opportunity to gain deeper insights into their gas-phase structural differentiation. The full discrimination of IgG antibody isoforms that possess different disulfide bond numbers and even subtle disulfide bonding patterns can be achieved based on their charge-dependent gas-phase unfolding behaviors and root-mean square deviation in CIU difference spectra. Taken together, the incorporation of all charge states observed in a native ion mobility-mass spectrometry (IM-MS) experiment to CIU analysis could make this strategy sensitive to more subtle structural discrepancies, facilitating the rapid discrimination and evaluation of innovative structurally similar biotherapeutic candidates with unexplored functions.

A simplified multicharge-state collision-induced unfolding (CIU) method was proposed for rapid differentiation of IgG isotypes that differ in terms of the numbers and patterns of disulfide bonds.

Glycoproteomics Technologies in Glycobiotechnology

Glycosylation is a key factor determining the pharmacological properties of biotherapeutics, including their stability, solubility, bioavailability, pharmacokinetics, and immunogenicity. As such, comprehensive information about glycosylation of biotherapeutics is critical to demonstrate similarity. Regulatory agencies also require extensive documentation of the comprehensive analyses of glycosylation-related critical quality attributes (CQAs) during the development, manufacturing, and release of biosimilars. Mass spectrometry has catalysed tremendous advancements in the characterisation of glycosylation CQAs of biotherapeutics. Here we provide a perspective overview on the MS-based technologies relevant for biotherapeutic product characterisation with an emphasis on the recent developments that allow determination of glycosylation features such as site of glycosylation, sialic acid linkage, glycan structure, and content.

Integrating Intact Mass Analysis and Middle-Down Mass Spectrometry Approaches to Effectively Characterize Trastuzumab and Adalimumab Structural Heterogeneity

Comprehensive characterization of therapeutic monoclonal antibody (mAb) structures is critical for drug development but remains challenging due to the inherent structural heterogeneity. In this study, an integrated strategy has been developed to characterize trastuzumab structural heterogeneity, which has prominent advantages in fast sample preparation with minimal artifacts, and complementary information obtained from intact mass and middle-down analyses. Our methods were all developed on an electron transfer dissociation (ETD)-enabled Q-TOF instrument. As a result, more than 13 structurally different proteoforms were easily identified and quantified through native and denatured intact mass analysis, which may result from the collective differences in glycosylation and C-terminal lysine clipping. Based on collision-induced dissociation and ETD-combined middle-down analysis, sequence coverage values of 28, 45, and 41% for trastuzumab Fc/2, Lc, and Fd subunits, respectively, were reached in a single LC run. The main glycan structure and relative abundance level were determined, and the glycosylation site was confirmed to be on the Fc fragment Asn 61. We finally integrated the native MS and middle-down results to have a more realistic detection of molecular weight, sequence variants, and glycosylation variants of trastuzumab. Applying the integrated strategy, we successfully completed the comprehensive characterization of adalimumab and found unexpected C-terminal lysine-modified variants (dataset identifier PXD021287). Overall, our integration strategy can be easily implemented for in-depth mAb structural heterogeneity characterization during pharmaceutical development and quality control.

Therapeutic Fc-fusion proteins: Current analytical strategies

Fc-Fusion proteins represent a successful class of biopharmaceutical products, with already 13 drugs approved in the European Union and United States as well as three biosimilar versions of etanercept. Fc-Fusion products combine tailored pharmacological properties of biological ligands, together with multiple functions of the fragment crystallizable domain of immunoglobulins. There is a great diversity in terms of possible biological ligands, including the extracellular domains of natural receptors, functionally active peptides, recombinant enzymes, and genetically engineered binding constructs acting as cytokine traps. Due to their highly diverse structures, the analytical characterization of Fc-Fusion proteins is far more complex than that of monoclonal antibodies and requires the use and development of additional product-specific methods over conventional generic/platform methods. This can be explained, for example, by the presence of numerous sialic acids, leading to high diversity in terms of isoelectric points and complex glycosylation profiles including multiple N- and O-linked glycosylation sites. In this review, we highlight the wide range of analytical strategies used to fully characterize Fc-fusion proteins. We also present case studies on the structural assessment of all commercially available Fc-fusion proteins, based on the features and critical quality attributes of their ligand-binding domains.

Interlaboratory Study for Characterizing Monoclonal Antibodies by Top-Down and Middle-Down Mass Spectrometry

The Consortium for Top-Down Proteomics (www.topdownproteomics.org) launched the present study to assess the current state of top-down mass spectrometry (TD MS) and middle-down mass spectrometry (MD MS) for characterizing monoclonal antibody (mAb) primary structures, including their modifications. To meet the needs of the rapidly growing therapeutic antibody market, it is important to develop analytical strategies to characterize the heterogeneity of a therapeutic product's primary structure accurately and reproducibly. The major objective of the present study is to determine whether current TD/MD MS technologies and protocols can add value to the more commonly employed bottom-up (BU) approaches with regard to confirming protein integrity, sequencing variable domains, avoiding artifacts, and revealing modifications and their locations. We also aim to gather information on the common TD/MD MS methods and practices in the field. A panel of three mAbs was selected and centrally provided to 20 laboratories worldwide for the analysis: Sigma mAb standard (SiLuLite), NIST mAb standard, and the therapeutic mAb Herceptin (trastuzumab). Various MS instrument platforms and ion dissociation techniques were employed. The present study confirms that TD/MD MS tools are available in laboratories worldwide and provide complementary information to the BU approach that can be crucial for comprehensive mAb characterization. The current limitations, as well as possible solutions to overcome them, are also outlined. A primary limitation revealed by the results of the present study is that the expert knowledge in both experiment and data analysis is indispensable to practice TD/MD MS.

Sequencing a Bispecific Antibody by Controlling Chain Concentration Effects When Using an Immobilized Nonspecific Protease

Complete sequence coverage of monospecific antibodies was previously achieved using immobilized aspergillopepsin I in a single LC-MS/MS analysis. Bispecific antibodies are asymmetrical compared to their monospecific antibody counterparts, resulting in a decrease in the concentration of individual subunits. Four standard proteins were used to characterize the effect of a decrease in concentration when using this immobilized enzyme reactor. Low concentration samples resulted in the elimination of large peptide products due to a greater number of enzymatic cleavages. A competitive inhibitor rich in arginine residues reduced the number of enzymatic cleavages to the protein and retained large molecular weight products. The digestion of a bispecific antibody with competitive inhibition of aspergillopepsin I maintained large peptide products better suited for sequence reconstruction, resulting in complete sequence coverage from a single LC-MS/MS analysis.

Top-Down Characterization of an Intact Monoclonal Antibody Using Activated Ion Electron Transfer Dissociation

Monoclonal antibodies (mAbs) are important therapeutic glycoproteins, but their large size and structural complexity make them difficult to rapidly characterize. Top-down mass spectrometry (MS) has the potential to overcome challenges of other common approaches by minimizing sample preparation and preserving endogenous modifications. However, comprehensive mAb characterization requires generation of many, well-resolved fragments and remains challenging. While ETD retains modifications and cleaves disulfide bonds-making it attractive for mAb characterization-it can be less effective for precursors having high m/z values. Activated ion electron transfer dissociation (AI-ETD) uses concurrent infrared photoactivation to promote product ion generation and has proven effective in increasing sequence coverage of intact proteins. Here, we present the first application of AI-ETD to mAb sequencing. For the standard NIST mAb, we observe a high degree of complementarity between fragments generated using standard ETD with a short reaction time and AI-ETD with a long reaction time. Most importantly, AI-ETD reveals disulfide-bound regions that have been intractable, thus far, for sequencing with top-down MS. We conclude AI-ETD has the potential to rapidly and comprehensively analyze intact mAbs.

Complementary Methods for de Novo Monoclonal Antibody Sequencing to Achieve Complete Sequence Coverage

Mass spectrometry is a powerful tool for de novo sequencing of novel proteins. Recent efforts in this area have mainly focused on liquid chromatography coupled with tandem mass spectrometry (LC-MS/MS). Here, we present an alternative method, capillary electrophoresis tandem mass spectrometry (CE-MS/MS), for sequencing novel monoclonal antibodies. Using less than 200 ng in total of tryptic digest sample in a triplicated measurement, CE-MS/MS with pH-mediated focusing successfully sequenced mAb infliximab with 100% sequence coverage and 100% accuracy for the light chain and 96% coverage and 93% accuracy for the heavy chain. It was also demonstrated that CE-MS/MS gives comparable results, and in some cases, even better results, as compared to LC-MS/MS when used as a standalone technique. A combined workflow using both CE-MS/MS and LC-MS/MS was also used to sequence a novel antibody, anti-CD-176, resulting in the first proposed sequence for this mAb.

Trace-Level Persistent Organic Pollutant Analysis with Gas-Chromatography Orbitrap Mass Spectrometry-Enhanced Performance by Complementary Acquisition and Processing of Time-Domain Data

The range of commercial techniques for high-resolution gas-chromatography-mass spectrometry (GC-MS) has been recently extended with the introduction of GC Orbitrap Fourier transform mass spectrometry (FTMS). We report on progress with quantitation performance in the analysis of persistent organic pollutants (POP), by averaging of time-domain signals (transients), from a number of GC-FTMS experiment replicates. Compared to a standard GC-FTMS measurement (a single GC-FTMS experiment replicate, mass spectra representation in reduced profile mode), for the 10 GC-FTMS technical replicates of ultratrace POP analysis, sensitivity improvement of up to 1 order of magnitude is demonstrated. The accumulation method was implemented with an external high-performance data acquisition system and dedicated data processing software to acquire the time-domain data for each GC-FTMS replicate and to average the acquired GC-FTMS data sets. Concomitantly, the increased flexibility in ion signal detection allowed the attainment of ultrahigh-mass resolution (UHR), approaching R = 700 000 at m/z = 200.

A Case Study to Identify the Drug Conjugation Site of a Site-Specific Antibody-Drug-Conjugate Using Middle-Down Mass Spectrometry

Middle-down mass spectrometry (MD MS) has emerged as a promising alternative to classical bottom-up approaches for protein characterization. Middle-level experiments after enzymatic digestion are routinely used for subunit analysis of monoclonal antibody (mAb)-related compounds, providing information on drug load distribution and average drug-to-antibody ratio (DAR). However, peptide mapping is still the gold standard for primary amino acid sequence assessment, post-translational modifications (PTM), and drug conjugation identification and localization. However, peptide mapping strategies can be challenging when dealing with more complex and heterogeneous mAb formats, like antibody-drug conjugates (ADCs). We report here, for the first time, MD MS analysis of a third-generation site-specific DAR4 ADC using different fragmentation techniques, including higher-energy collisional- (HCD), electron-transfer (ETD) dissociation and 213 nm ultraviolet photodissociation (UVPD). UVPD used as a standalone technique for ADC subunit analysis afforded, within the same liquid chromatography-MS/MS run, enhanced performance in terms of primary sequence coverage compared to HCD- or ETD-based MD approaches, and generated substantially more MS/MS fragments containing either drug conjugation or glycosylation site information, leading to confident drug/glycosylation site identification. In addition, our results highlight the complementarity of ETD and UVPD for both primary sequence validation and drug conjugation/glycosylation site assessment. Altogether, our results highlight the potential of UVPD for ADC MD MS analysis for drug conjugation/glycosylation site assessment, and indicate that MD MS strategies can improve structural characterization of empowered next-generation mAb-based formats, especially for PTMs and drug conjugation sites validation.

Direct measurement of light and heavy antibody chains using ion mobility and middle-down mass spectrometry

The analysis of monoclonal antibodies (mAbs) by a middle-down mass spectrometry (MS) approach is a growing field that attracts the attention of many researchers and biopharmaceutical companies. Usually, liquid fractionation techniques are used to separate mAbs polypeptides chains before MS analysis. Gas-phase fractionation techniques such as high-field asymmetric waveform ion mobility spectrometry (FAIMS) can replace liquid-based separations and reduce both analysis time and cost. Here, we present a rapid FAIMS tandem MS method capable of characterizing the polypeptide sequence of mAbs light and heavy chains in an unprecedented, easy, and fast fashion. This new method uses commercially available instruments and takes ~24 min, which is 40-60% faster than regular liquid chromatography-MS/MS analysis, to acquire fragmentation data using different dissociation methods.

Optimal Collision Energies and Bioinformatics Tools for Efficient Bottom-up Sequence Validation of Monoclonal Antibodies

Rigorous validation of amino acid sequence is fundamental in the characterization of original and biosimilar protein biopharmaceuticals. Widely accepted workflows are based on bottom-up mass spectrometry, and they often require multiple techniques and significant manual work. Here, we demonstrate that optimization of a set of tandem mass spectroscopy (MS/MS) collision energies and automated combination of all available information in the measurements can increase the sequence validated by one technique close to the inherent limits. We created a software (called "Serac") that consumes results of the Mascot database search engine and identifies the amino acids validated by bottom-up MS/MS experiments using the most rigorous, industrially acceptable definition of sequence coverage (we term this "confirmed sequence coverage"). The software can combine spectra at the level of amino acids or fragment ions to exploit complementarity, provides full transparency to justify validation, and reduces manual effort. With its help, we investigated collision energy dependence of confirmed sequence coverage of individual peptides and full proteins on trypsin-digested monoclonal antibody samples (rituximab and trastuzumab). We found the energy dependence to be modest, but we demonstrated the benefit of using spectra taken at multiple energies. We describe a workflow based on 2-3 LC-MS/MS runs, carefully selected collision energies, and a fragment ion level combination, which yields ∼85% confirmed sequence coverage, 25%-30% above that from a basic proteomics protocol. Further increase can mainly be expected from alternative digestion enzymes or fragmentation techniques, which can be seamlessly integrated to the processing, thereby allowing effortless validation of full sequences.

Middle-Down Multi-Attribute Analysis of Antibody-Drug Conjugates with Electron Transfer Dissociation

Antibody-drug conjugates (ADCs) are designed to combine the target specificity of monoclonal antibodies and potent cytotoxin drugs to achieve better therapeutic outcomes. Comprehensive evaluation of the quality attributes of ADCs is critical for drug development but remains challenging due to heterogeneity of the construct. Currently, peptide mapping with reversed-phase liquid chromatography (RPLC) coupled to mass spectrometry (MS) is the predominant approach to characterize ADCs. However, it is suboptimal for sequence characterization and quantification of ADCs because it lacks a comprehensive view of coexisting variants and suffers from varying ionization effects of drug-conjugated peptides compared to unconjugated counterparts. Here, we present the first middle-down RPLC-MS analysis of both cysteine (Adcetris; BV) and lysine (Kadcyla; T-DM1) conjugated ADCs at the subunit level (∼25 kDa) with electron transfer dissociation (ETD). We successfully achieved high-resolution separation of subunit isomers arising from different drug conjugation and subsequently localized the conjugation sites. Moreover, we obtained a comprehensive overview of the microvariants associated with each subunits and characterized them such as oxidized variants with different sites. Furthermore, we observed relatively high levels of conjugation near complementarity-determining regions (CDRs) from the heavy chain but no drug conjugation near CDRs of light chain (Lc) from lysine conjugated T-DM1. Based on the extracted ion chromatograms, we accurately measured average drug to antibody ratio (DAR) values and relative occupancy of drug-conjugated subunits. Overall, the middle-down MS approach enables the evaluation of multiple quality attributes including DAR, positional isomers, conjugation sites, occupancy, and microvariants, which potentially opens up a new avenue to characterize ADCs.

Specific and high-resolution identification of monoclonal antibody fragments detected by capillary electrophoresis-sodium dodecyl sulfate using reversed-phase HPLC with top-down mass spectrometry analysis

In recent years, capillary electrophoresis-sodium dodecyl sulfate (cSDS) has been widely used for high resolution separation and quantification of the fragments and aggregates of monoclonal antibodies (mAbs) to ensure the quality of mAb therapeutics. However, identification of the low-molecular-weight (LMW) and high-molecular-weight (HMW) species detected in cSDS electropherograms has been based primarily on the approximate MWs calculated from standard curves using known MW standards and correlations with fragments and aggregates identified by other methods. It is not easy to collect sufficient amounts of H/LMW species from cSDS for analysis by orthogonal methods and the direct coupling of cSDS with mass spectrometry (MS) is very difficult due to interference from SDS. In this study, we describe the precise identification of H/LMW species detected by cSDS using reversed-phase high performance liquid chromatography (RP-HPLC) coupled with top-down tandem MS analysis. The H/LMW species were first identified by on-line RP-HPLC MS analysis and the RP-HPLC fractions were then analyzed by cSDS to connect the identified H/LMW species with the peaks in the cSDS electropherogram. With this method, 58 unique H/LMW species were identified from an immunoglobulin G1 (IgG1) mAb. The identified fragments ranged from 10 kDa single chain fragments to 130 kDa triple chain fragments, including some with post-translational modifications. This is the first study to clearly identify the antibody fragments, including the exact clipping sites, observed in cSDS electropherograms. The methodology and results presented here should be applicable to most other IgG1 mAbs.

Forced Degradation Testing as Complementary Tool for Biosimilarity Assessment

Oxidation of monoclonal antibodies (mAbs) can impact their efficacy and may therefore represent critical quality attributes (CQA) that require evaluation. To complement classical CQA, bevacizumab and infliximab were subjected to oxidative stress by H₂O₂ for 24, 48, or 72 h to probe their oxidation susceptibility. For investigation, a middle-up approach was used utilizing liquid chromatography hyphenated with mass spectrometry (LC-QTOF-MS). In both mAbs, the Fc/2 subunit was completely oxidized. Additional oxidations were found in the light chain (LC) and in the Fd’ subunit of infliximab, but not in bevacizumab. By direct comparison of methionine positions, the oxidized residues in infliximab were assigned to M55 in LC and M18 in Fd’. The forced oxidation approach was further exploited for comparison of respective biosimilar products. Both for bevacizumab and infliximab, comparison of posttranslational modification profiles demonstrated high similarity of the unstressed reference product (RP) and the biosimilar (BS). However, for bevacizumab, comparison after forced oxidation revealed a higher susceptibility of the BS compared to the RP. It may thus be considered a useful tool for biopharmaceutical engineering, biosimilarity assessment, as well as for quality control of protein drugs.

Top or Middle? Up or Down? Toward a Standard Lexicon for Protein Top-Down and Allied Mass Spectrometry Approaches

In recent years, there has been increasing interest in top-down mass spectrometry (TDMS) approaches for protein analysis, driven both by technological advancements and efforts such as those by the multinational Consortium for Top-Down Proteomics (CTDP). Today, diverse sample preparation and ionization methods are employed to facilitate TDMS analysis of denatured and native proteins and their complexes. The goals of these studies vary, ranging from protein and proteoform identification, to determination of the binding site of a (non)covalently-bound ligand, and in some cases even with the aim to study the higher order structure of proteins and complexes. Currently, however, no widely accepted terminology exists to precisely and unambiguously distinguish between the different types of TDMS experiments that can be performed. Instead, ad hoc developed terminology is often used, which potentially complicates communication of top-down and allied methods and their results. In this communication, we consider the different types of top-down (or top-down-related) MS experiments that have been performed and reported, and define distinct categories based on the protocol used and type(s) of information that can be obtained. We also consider the different possible conventions for distinguishing between middle- and top-down MS, based on both sample preparation and precursor ion mass. We believe that the proposed framework presented here will prove helpful for researchers to communicate about TDMS and will be an important step toward harmonizing and standardizing this growing field. Graphical Abstract.

TCellXTalk facilitates the detection of co-modified peptides for the study of protein post-translational modification cross-talk in T cells

MOTIVATION

Protein function is regulated by post-translational modifications (PTMs) that may act individually or interact with others in a phenomenon termed PTM cross-talk. Multiple databases have been dedicated to PTMs, including recent initiatives oriented towards the in silico prediction of PTM interactions. The study of PTM cross-talk ultimately requires experimental evidence about whether certain PTMs coexist in a single protein molecule. However, available resources do not assist researchers in the experimental detection of co-modified peptides.

RESULTS

Herein, we present TCellXTalk, a comprehensive database of phosphorylation, ubiquitination and acetylation sites in human T cells that supports the experimental detection of co-modified peptides using targeted or directed mass spectrometry. We demonstrate the efficacy of TCellXTalk and the strategy presented here in a proof of concept experiment that enabled the identification and quantification of 15 co-modified (phosphorylated and ubiquitinated) peptides from CD3 proteins of the T-cell receptor complex. To our knowledge, these are the first co-modified peptide sequences described in this widely studied cell type. Furthermore, quantitative data showed distinct dynamics for co-modified peptides upon T cell activation, demonstrating differential regulation of co-occurring PTMs in this biological context. Overall, TCellXTalk facilitates the experimental detection of co-modified peptides in human T cells and puts forward a novel and generic strategy for the study of PTM cross-talk.

AVAILABILITY AND IMPLEMENTATION

TCellXTalk is available at https://www.tcellxtalk.org. Source Code is available at https://bitbucket.org/lp-csic-uab/tcellxtalk.

SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION

Supplementary data are available at Bioinformatics online.

Structural Analysis of Monoclonal Antibodies by Ultrahigh Resolution MALDI In-Source Decay FT-ICR Mass Spectrometry

The emergence of complex protein therapeutics in general and monoclonal antibodies (mAbs) in particular have stimulated analytical chemists to develop new methods and strategies for their structural characterization. Mass spectrometry plays a key role in providing information on the primary amino acid sequence, post-translational modifications, and other structure characteristics that must be monitored during the manufacturing process and subsequent quality control assessment. In this study, we present a novel method that allows structural characterization of mAbs based on MALDI in-source decay (ISD) fragmentation, coupled with Fourier transform ion cyclotron resonance (FT-ICR) MS. The method benefits from higher resolution of absorption mode FT mass spectra, compared to magnitude mode, which enables simultaneous identification of ISD fragments from both the heavy and light chains with a higher confidence in a wide mass range up to m/z 13 500. This method was applied to two standard mAbs, namely NIST mAb and trastuzumab, in preparation for method application in an interlaboratory study on mAbs structural analysis coordinated by the Consortium for Top-Down Proteomics. Extensive sequence coverage was obtained from the middle-down analysis (IdeS- and GingisKHAN-digested mAbs) that complemented the top-down analysis of intact mAbs. In addition, MALDI FT-ICR MS of IdeS-digested mAbs allowed isotopic-level profiling of proteoforms with regard to heavy chain N-glycosylation.