Current Practices in LC-MS Untargeted Metabolomics: A Scoping Review on the Use of Pooled Quality Control Samples

Online Comprehensive Two-Dimensional Liquid Chromatography/Quadrupole Time-of-Flight Mass Spectrometry-Based Metabolic Profiling and Comparison Enabling the Characterization of 1146 Ginsenosides and More Explicit Differentiation of Ginseng

This work was designed for the in-depth characterization and holistic comparison of up to 12 ginseng varieties, which can benefit the development of functional foods and ensure their authenticity in the food industry. An online comprehensive two-dimensional liquid chromatography/quadrupole time-of-flight mass spectrometry (2D-LC/QTOF-MS) approach was established by configurating the XCharge C18 and HSS Cyano columns. Under the optimal conditions, we characterized a total of 1146 ginsenosides (including 876 potentially new compounds) from 12 ginseng varieties by reference to an in-house library of 573 known ginsenosides and 70 reference compounds. The online 2D-LC/QTOF-MS-based untargeted metabolomics workflows were developed, by which 126 potential ginsenoside markers were unveiled and utilized to establish the key identification points for each ginseng species. Compared with the conventional liquid chromatography/mass spectrometry metabolomics, our multidimensional chromatography approach performed better in discriminating multiple ginseng varieties. This work demonstrates a potent and practical methodology to identify easily confused functional plants.

Integration analysis of transcriptome and metabolome revealed the potential mechanism of spermatogenesis in Tibetan sheep (Ovis aries) at extreme high altitude

Testis has an indispensable function in male reproduction of domestic animals. Numerous genes and metabolites were related to testicular development and spermatogenesis. However, little is known about the biological regulation pathways associated with fecundity in male Tibetan sheep. In this study, Testes were collected from Huoba Tibetan sheep (HB, 4614 m) and Gangba Tibetan sheep (GB, 4401 m) at extreme high altitude, and Alpine Merino sheep (AM, 2500 m, control group) at medium-high altitude, investigating the genes and metabolites levels of them. The histological analysis of testicular tissue using hematoxylin-eosin (HE) staining was performed for Tibetan sheep and Alpine Merino sheep, and the testes of them were analyzed by transcriptomics and metabolomics to explore the potential mechanism of testicular development and spermatogenesis. The statistical results showed that the cross-sectional area of testicular seminiferous tubules, diameter of seminiferous tubules, and spermatogenic epithelium thickness were significantly smaller in HB and GB than in AM (P < 0.05). Overall, 5648 differentially expressed genes (DEGs) and 336 differential metabolites (DMs) were identified in three sheep breeds, which were significantly enriched in spermatogenesis and other related pathways. According to integrated metabolomic and transcriptomic analysis, glycolysis/gluconeogenesis, AMPK signaling pathway, and TCA cycle, were predicted to have dramatic effects on the spermatogenesis of Tibetan sheep. Several genes (including Wnt2, Rab3a, Sox9, Hspa8, and Slc38a2) and metabolites (including L-histidinol, Glucose, Fumaric acid, Malic acid, and Galactose) were significantly enriched in pathways related to testicular development and spermatogenesis, and might affect the reproduction of Tibetan sheep by regulating the acrosome reaction, meiotic gene expression, and the production of sex hormones. Our results provide further understanding of the key genes and metabolites involved in testicular development and spermatogenesis in Tibetan sheep.

Advances in mass spectrometry for metabolomics: Strategies, challenges, and innovations in disease biomarker discovery

Mass spectrometry (MS) plays a crucial role in metabolomics, especially in the discovery of disease biomarkers. This review outlines strategies for identifying metabolites, emphasizing precise and detailed use of MS techniques. It explores various methods for quantification, discusses challenges encountered, and examines recent breakthroughs in biomarker discovery. In the field of diagnostics, MS has revolutionized approaches by enabling a deeper understanding of tissue-specific metabolic changes associated with disease. The reliability of results is ensured through robust experimental design and stringent system suitability criteria. In the past, data quality, standardization, and reproducibility were often overlooked despite their significant impact on MS-based metabolomics. Progress in this field heavily depends on continuous training and education. The review also highlights the emergence of innovative MS technologies and methodologies. MS has the potential to transform our understanding of metabolic landscapes, which is crucial for disease biomarker discovery. This article serves as an invaluable resource for researchers in metabolomics, presenting fresh perspectives and advancements that propels the field forward.

A global perspective on the status of clinical metabolomics in laboratory medicine - a survey by the IFCC metabolomics working group

OBJECTIVES

Metabolomics aims for comprehensive characterization and measurement of small molecule metabolites (<1700 Da) in complex biological matrices. This study sought to assess the current understanding and usage of metabolomics in laboratory medicine globally and evaluate the perception of its promise and future implementation.

METHODS

A survey was conducted by the IFCC metabolomics working group that queried 400 professionals from 79 countries. Participants provided insights into their experience levels, knowledge, and usage of metabolomics approaches, along with detailing the applications and methodologies employed.

RESULTS

Findings revealed a varying level of experience among respondents, with varying degrees of familiarity and utilization of metabolomics techniques. Targeted approaches dominated the field, particularly liquid chromatography coupled to a triple quadrupole mass spectrometer, with untargeted methods also receiving significant usage. Applications spanned clinical research, epidemiological studies, clinical diagnostics, patient monitoring, and prognostics across various medical domains, including metabolic diseases, endocrinology, oncology, cardiometabolic risk, neurodegeneration and clinical toxicology.

CONCLUSIONS

Despite optimism for the future of clinical metabolomics, challenges such as technical complexity, standardization issues, and financial constraints remain significant hurdles. The study underscores the promising yet intricate landscape of metabolomics in clinical practice, emphasizing the need for continued efforts to overcome barriers and realize its full potential in patient care and precision medicine.

Validation of two LCHRMS methods for large-scale untargeted metabolomics of serum samples: Strategy to establish method fitness-for-purpose

Untargeted metabolomics by LCHRMS is a powerful tool to enhance our knowledge of pathophysiological processes. Whereas validation of a bioanalytical method is customary in most analytical chemistry fields, it is rarely performed for untargeted metabolomics. This study aimed to establish and validate an analytical platform for a long-term, clinical metabolomics study. Sample preparation was performed with an automated liquid handler and four analytical methods were developed and evaluated. The validation study spanned three batches with twelve runs using individual serum samples and various quality control samples. Data was acquired with untargeted acquisition and only metabolites identified at level 1 were evaluated. Validation parameters were set to evaluate key performance metrics relevant for the intended application: reproducibility, repeatability, stability, and identification selectivity, emphasizing dataset intrinsic variance. Concordance of semi-quantitative results between methods was evaluated to identify potential bias. Spearman rank correlation coefficients (rs) were calculated from individual serum samples. Of the four methods tested, two were selected for validation. A total of 47 and 55 metabolites (RPLC-ESI+- and HILIC-ESI--HRMS, respectively) met specified validation criteria. Quality assurance involved system suitability testing, sample release, run release, and batch release. The median repeatability and within-run reproducibility as coefficient of variation% for metabolites that passed validation on RPLC-ESI+- and HILIC-ESI--HRMS were 4.5 and 4.6, and 1.5 and 3.8, respectively. Metabolites that passed validation on RPLC-ESI+-HRMS had a median D-ratio of 1.91, and 89 % showed good signal intensity after ten-fold dilution. The corresponding numbers for metabolites with the HILIC-ESI--HRMS method was 1.45 and 45 %, respectively. The rs median ({range}) for metabolites that passed validation on RPLC-ESI+- was 0.93 (N = 9 {0.69-0.98}) and on HILIC-ESI--HRMS was 0.93 (N = 22 {0.55-1.00}). The validated methods proved fit-for-purpose and the laboratory thus demonstrated its capability to produce reliable results for a large-scale, untargeted metabolomics study. This validation not only bolsters the reliability of the assays but also significantly enhances the impact and credibility of the hypotheses generated from the studies. Therefore, this validation study serves as a benchmark in the documentation of untargeted metabolomics, potentially guiding future endeavors in the field.

Investigating the lipid profile of Anopheles stephensi mosquitoes across developmental life stages

Holometabolous insects undergo a distinct transition in their development, tightly correlated with shifting feeding patterns from larval stages and some adult phases to non-feeding phases as pupae and during other adult phases. Furthermore, the intricate life cycle of mosquitoes involves a sequence of developmental stages influenced by aquatic and terrestrial factors, demanding precise energy resource orchestration. Lipids serve multifaceted roles, encompassing energy storage, membrane structure, and participation in signal transduction and molecular recognition processes. A significant gap in the current research landscape is the need for a comprehensive study exploring the lipid repertoire throughout the developmental stages of Anopheles stephensi mosquitoes. We undertook an analysis of the An. stephensi metabolome across all life stages. We hypothesized that An. stephensi mosquitoes will have unique lipid metabolite markers for each life stage. A specific extraction and LC-MS based lipidomic approach was used to test this hypothesis. Our findings demonstrated that our methods were successful, with lipids comprising 62.15 % of the analyzed metabolome. Additionally, phospholipids (PL), lysophospholipids (LPL), sphingomyelin (SM), and triglycerides (TG) were abundant and dynamic across all life stages. Interestingly, comparison between the L1 and L2 lipidome revealed a dominant pattern of specific TGs in decreased abundance between these two life stages. Lastly, 20-hydroxyecdysone (20E), was found to be present in similar abundance across all 4 larval stages. These data indicate that there may be lipid metabolome pathways serving unique roles during mosquito development that may be used to explore laboratory management of colonies, parasite resistance, and environmental adaptation.

Denoising Search doubles the number of metabolite and exposome annotations in human plasma using an Orbitrap Astral mass spectrometer

Chemical exposures may impact human metabolism and contribute to the etiology of neurodegenerative disorders like Alzheimer's Disease (AD). Identifying these small metabolites involves matching experimental spectra to reference spectra in databases. However, environmental chemicals or physiologically active metabolites are usually present at low concentrations in human specimens. The presence of noise ions can significantly degrade spectral quality, leading to false negatives and reduced identification rates. In response to this challenge, the Spectral Denoising algorithm removes both chemical and electronic noise. Spectral Denoising outperformed alternative methods in benchmarking studies on 240 tested metabolites. It improved high confident compound identifications at an average 35-fold lower concentrations than previously achievable. Spectral Denoising proved highly robust against varying levels of both chemical and electronic noise even with >150-fold higher intensity of noise ions than true fragment ions. For human plasma samples of AD patients that were analyzed on the Orbitrap Astral mass spectrometer, Denoising Search detected 2.3-fold more annotated compounds compared to the Exploris 240 Orbitrap instrument, including drug metabolites, household and industrial chemicals, and pesticides. This combination of advanced instrumentation with a superior denoising algorithm opens the door for precision medicine in exposome research.

Diagnostic Value of Menstrual Blood Lipidomics in Endometriosis: A Pilot Study

Endometriosis is a prevalent chronic inflammatory disease characterized by a considerable delay between initial symptoms and diagnosis through surgery. The pressing need for a timely, non-invasive diagnostic solution underscores the focus of current research efforts. This study examines the diagnostic potential of the menstrual blood lipidome. The lipid profile of 39 samples (23 women with endometriosis and 16 patients in a control group) was acquired using reverse-phase high-performance liquid chromatography-mass spectrometry with LipidMatch processing and identification. Profiles were normalized based on total ion counts. Significant differences in lipids were determined using the Mann-Whitney test. Lipids for the diagnostic model, based on logistic regression, were selected using a combination of variance importance projection filters and Akaike information criteria. Levels of ceramides, sphingomyelins, cardiolipins, triacylglycerols, acyl- and alkenyl-phosphatidylethanolamines, and alkenyl-phosphatidylcholines increased, while acyl- and alkyl-phosphatidylcholines decreased in cases of endometriosis. Plasmenylphosphatidylethanolamine PE P-16:0/18:1 and cardiolipin CL 16:0_18:0_22:5_22:6 serve as marker lipids in the diagnostic model, exhibiting a sensitivity of 81% and specificity of 85%. The diagnostic approach based on dried spots of menstrual blood holds promise as an alternative to traditional non-invasive methods for endometriosis screening.

PeakQC: A Software Tool for Omics-Agnostic Automated Quality Control of Mass Spectrometry Data

Mass spectrometry is broadly employed to study complex molecular mechanisms in various biological and environmental fields, enabling 'omics' research such as proteomics, metabolomics, and lipidomics. As study cohorts grow larger and more complex with dozens to hundreds of samples, the need for robust quality control (QC) measures through automated software tools becomes paramount to ensure the integrity, high quality, and validity of scientific conclusions from downstream analyses and minimize the waste of resources. Since existing QC tools are mostly dedicated to proteomics, automated solutions supporting metabolomics are needed. To address this need, we developed the software PeakQC, a tool for automated QC of MS data that is independent of omics molecular types (i.e., omics-agnostic). It allows automated extraction and inspection of peak metrics of precursor ions (e.g., errors in mass, retention time, arrival time) and supports various instrumentations and acquisition types, from infusion experiments or using liquid chromatography and/or ion mobility spectrometry front-end separations and with/without fragmentation spectra from data-dependent or independent acquisition analyses. Diagnostic plots for fragmentation spectra are also generated. Here, we describe and illustrate PeakQC's functionalities using different representative data sets, demonstrating its utility as a valuable tool for enhancing the quality and reliability of omics mass spectrometry analyses.

Application of the Hydrophilic Interaction Liquid Chromatography (HILIC-MS) Novel Protocol to Study the Metabolic Heterogeneity of Glioblastoma Cells

Glioblastoma is a highly malignant brain tumor consisting of a heterogeneous cellular population. The transformed metabolism of glioblastoma cells supports their growth and division on the background of their milieu. One might hypothesize that the transformed metabolism of a primary glioblastoma could be well adapted to limitations in the variety and number of substrates imported into the brain parenchyma and present it their microenvironment. Additionally, the phenotypic heterogeneity of cancer cells could promote the variations among their metabolic capabilities regarding the utilization of available substrates and release of metabolic intermediates. With the aim to identify the putative metabolic footprint of different types of glioblastoma cells, we exploited the possibility for separation of polar and ionic molecules present in culture media or cell lysates by hydrophilic interaction liquid chromatography (HILIC). The mass spectrometry (MS) was then used to identify and quantify the eluted compounds. The introduced method allows the detection and quantification of more than 150 polar and ionic metabolites in a single run, which may be present either in culture media or cell lysates and provide data for polaromic studies within metabolomics. The method was applied to analyze the culture media and cell lysates derived from two types of glioblastoma cells, T98G and U118. The analysis revealed that even both types of glioblastoma cells share several common metabolic aspects, and they also exhibit differences in their metabolic capability. This finding agrees with the hypothesis about metabolic heterogeneity of glioblastoma cells. Furthermore, the combination of both analytical methods, HILIC-MS, provides a valuable tool for metabolomic studies based on the simultaneous identification and quantification of a wide range of polar and ionic metabolites-polaromics.

Comprehensive analysis of phospholipid in milk and their biological roles as nutrients and biomarkers

Phospholipids (PL) have garnered significant attention due to their physiological activities. Milk and other dairy products are important dietary sources for humans and have been extensively used to analyze the presence of PL by various analytical techniques. In this paper, the analysis techniques of PL were reviewed with the eight trigrams of phospholipidomics and a comprehensive fingerprint of 1295 PLs covering 8 subclasses in milk and other dairy products, especially. Technology is the primary productive force. Based on phospholipidomics technology, we further review the relationship between the composition of PL and factors that may be involved in processing and experimental operation, and emphasized the significance of the biological role played by PL in dietary supplements and biomarkers (production, processing and clinical research), and providing the future research directions.

Establishing a framework for best practices for quality assurance and quality control in untargeted metabolomics

BACKGROUND

Quality assurance (QA) and quality control (QC) practices are key tenets that facilitate study and data quality across all applications of untargeted metabolomics. These important practices will strengthen this field and accelerate its success. The Best Practices Working Group (WG) within the Metabolomics Quality Assurance and Quality Control Consortium (mQACC) focuses on community use of QA/QC practices and protocols and aims to identify, catalogue, harmonize, and disseminate current best practices in untargeted metabolomics through community-driven activities.

AIM OF REVIEW

A present goal of the Best Practices WG is to develop a working strategy, or roadmap, that guides the actions of practitioners and progress in the field. The framework in which mQACC operates promotes the harmonization and dissemination of current best QA/QC practice guidance and encourages widespread adoption of these essential QA/QC activities for liquid chromatography-mass spectrometry.

KEY SCIENTIFIC CONCEPTS OF REVIEW

Community engagement and QA/QC information gathering activities have been occurring through conference workshops, virtual and in-person interactive forum discussions, and community surveys. Seven principal QC stages prioritized by internal discussions of the Best Practices WG have received participant input, feedback and discussion. We outline these stages, each involving a multitude of activities, as the framework for identifying QA/QC best practices. The ultimate planned product of these endeavors is a "living guidance" document of current QA/QC best practices for untargeted metabolomics that will grow and change with the evolution of the field.