Engineering Nanodisc Scaffold Proteins for Native Mass Spectrometry

The structure, self-assembly and dynamics of lipid nanodiscs revealed by computational approaches

Nanodisc technology is increasingly being used in structural, biochemical and biophysical studies of membrane proteins. The computational approaches have revealed many important features of nanodisc assembly, structures and dynamics. Therefore, we reviewed the application of computational approaches, especially molecular modeling and molecular dyncamics (MD) simulations, to characterize nanodiscs, including the structural models, assembly and disassembly, protocols for modeling, structural properties and dynamics, and protein-lipid interactions in nanodiscs. More amazing computational studies about nanodiscs are looked forward to in the future.

SIMULTANEOUS NATIVE MASS SPECTROMETRY ANALYSIS OF SINGLE AND DOUBLE MUTANTS TO PROBE LIPID BINDING TO MEMBRANE PROTEINS

Lipids are critical modulators of membrane protein structure and function. However, it is challenging to investigate the thermodynamics of protein-lipid interactions because lipids can simultaneously bind membrane proteins at different sites with different specificities. Here, we developed a native mass spectrometry (MS) approach using single and double mutants to measure the relative energetic contributions of specific residues on Aquaporin Z (AqpZ) toward cardiolipin (CL) binding. We first mutated potential lipid-binding residues on AqpZ, and mixed mutant and wild-type proteins together with CL. By using native MS to simultaneously resolve lipid binding to the mutant and wild-type proteins in a single spectrum, we directly determined the relative affinities of CL binding, thereby revealing the relative Gibbs free energy change for lipid binding caused by the mutation. Comparing different mutants revealed that the W14 contributes to the tightest CL binding site, with R224 contributing to a lower affinity site. Using double mutant cycling, we investigated the synergy between W14 and R224 sites on CL binding. Overall, this novel native MS approach provides unique insights into lipid binding to specific sites on membrane proteins.

Online Buffer Exchange Enables Automated Membrane Protein Analysis by Native Mass Spectrometry

Membrane proteins represent the majority of clinical drug targets and are actively involved in a range of cellular processes. However, the complexity of membrane mimetics for membrane protein solubilization poses challenges for native mass spectrometry (MS) analyses. The most common approach for native MS analyses of membrane proteins remains offline buffer exchange into native MS-compatible buffers prior to manual sample loading into static nano-ESI emitters. This laborious process requires relatively high sample consumption and optimization for the individual proteins. Here, we developed online buffer exchange coupled to native mass spectrometry (OBE-nMS) for analyzing membrane proteins in different membrane mimetics, including detergent micelles and nanodiscs. Detergent screening for OBE-nMS reveals that mobile phases containing ammonium acetate with lauryl-dimethylamine oxide are most universal for characterizing both bacterial and mammalian membrane proteins in detergent. Membrane proteins in nanodiscs simply require ammonium acetate as the mobile phase. To preserve the intact nanodiscs, a novel switching electrospray approach was used to capture the high-flow separation on the column with a low-flow injection to MS. Rapid OBE-nMS completes each membrane protein measurement within minutes and thus enables higher-throughput assessment of membrane protein integrity prior to its structural elucidation.

A Research Journey: Over a Decade of Denaturing and Native-MS Analyses of Hydrophobic and Membrane Proteins in Amgen Therapeutic Discovery

Membrane proteins and associated complexes currently comprise the majority of therapeutic targets and remain among the most challenging classes of proteins for analytical characterization. Through long-term strategic collaborations forged between industrial and academic research groups, there has been tremendous progress in advancing membrane protein mass spectrometry (MS) analytical methods and their concomitant application to Amgen therapeutic project progression. Herein, I will describe a detailed and personal account of how electrospray ionization (ESI) native mass spectrometry (nMS), ion mobility-MS (IM-MS), reversed phase liquid chromatographic mass spectrometry (RPLC-MS), high-throughput solid phase extraction mass spectrometry, and matrix-assisted laser desorption ionization mass spectrometry methods were developed, optimized, and validated within Amgen Research, and importantly, how these analytical methods were applied for membrane and hydrophobic protein analyses and ultimately therapeutic project support and progression. Additionally, I will discuss all the highly important and productive collaborative efforts, both internal Amgen and external academic, which were key in generating the samples, methods, and associated data described herein. I will also describe some early and previously unpublished nano-ESI (nESI) native-MS data from Amgen Research and the highly productive University of California Los Angeles (UCLA) collaboration. I will also present previously unpublished examples of real-life Amgen biotherapeutic membrane protein projects that were supported by all the MS (and IM) analytical techniques described herein. I will start by describing the initial nESI nMS experiments performed at Amgen in 2011 on empty nanodisc molecules, using a quadrupole time-of-flight MS, and how these experiments progressed on to the 15 Tesla Fourier transform ion cyclotron resonance MS at UCLA. Then described are monomeric and multimeric membrane protein data acquired in both nESI nMS and tandem-MS modes, using multiple methods of ion activation, resulting in dramatic spectral simplification. Also described is how we investigated the far less established and less published subject, that is denaturing RPLC-MS analysis of membrane proteins, and how we developed a highly robust and reproducible RPLC-MS method capable of effective separation of membrane proteins differing in only the presence or absence of an N-terminal post translational modification. Also described is the evolution of the aforementioned RPLC-MS method into a high-throughput solid phase extraction MS method. Finally, I will give my opinion on key developments and how the area of nMS of membrane proteins needs to evolve to a state where it can be applied within the biopharmaceutical research environment for routine therapeutic project support.

What's the defect? Using mass defects to study oligomerization of membrane proteins and peptides in nanodiscs with native mass spectrometry

Many membrane proteins form functional complexes that are either homo- or hetero-oligomeric. However, it is challenging to characterize membrane protein oligomerization in intact lipid bilayers, especially for polydisperse mixtures. Native mass spectrometry of membrane proteins and peptides inserted in lipid nanodiscs provides a unique method to study the oligomeric state distribution and lipid preferences of oligomeric assemblies. To interpret these complex spectra, we developed novel data analysis methods using macromolecular mass defect analysis. Here, we provide an overview of how mass defect analysis can be used to study oligomerization in nanodiscs, discuss potential limitations in interpretation, and explore strategies to resolve these ambiguities. Finally, we review recent work applying this technique to studying formation of antimicrobial peptide, amyloid protein, and viroporin complexes with lipid membranes.

Do Nanodisc Assembly Conditions Affect Natural Lipid Uptake?

Lipids play critical roles in modulating membrane protein structure, interactions, and activity. Nanodiscs provide a tunable membrane mimetic that can model these endogenous protein-lipid interactions in a nanoscale lipid bilayer. However, most studies of membrane proteins with nanodiscs use simple synthetic lipids that lack the headgroup and fatty acyl diversity of natural extracts. Prior research has successfully used natural lipid extracts in nanodiscs that more accurately mimic natural environments, but it is not clear how nanodisc assembly may bias the incorporated lipid profiles. Here, we applied lipidomics to investigate how nanodisc assembly conditions affect the profile of natural lipids in nanodiscs. Specifically, we tested the effects of assembly temperature, nanodisc size, and lipidome extract complexity. Globally, our analysis demonstrates that the lipids profiles are largely unaffected by nanodisc assembly conditions. However, a few notable changes emerged within individual lipids and lipid classes, such as a differential incorporation of cardiolipin and phosphatidylglycerol lipids from the E. coli polar lipid extract at different temperatures. Conversely, some classes of brain lipids were affected by nanodisc size at higher temperatures. Collectively, these data enable the application of nanodiscs to study protein-lipid interactions in complex lipid environments.

Expanding Orbitrap Collision Cross-Section Measurements to Native Protein Applications Through Kinetic Energy and Signal Decay Analysis

The measurement of collision cross sections (CCS, σ) offers supplemental information about sizes and conformations of ions beyond mass analysis alone. We have previously shown that CCSs can be determined directly from the time-domain transient decay of ions in an Orbitrap mass analyzer as ions oscillate around the central electrode and collide with neutral gas, thus removing them from the ion packet. Herein, we develop the modified hard collision model, thus deviating from the prior FT-MS hard sphere model, to determine CCSs as a function of center-of-mass collision energy in the Orbitrap analyzer. With this model, we aim to increase the upper mass limit of CCS measurement for native-like proteins, characterized by low charge states and presumed to be in more compact conformations. We also combine CCS measurements with collision induced unfolding and tandem mass spectrometry experiments to monitor protein unfolding and disassembly of protein complexes and measure CCSs of ejected monomers from protein complexes.

Investigating Daptomycin-Membrane Interactions Using Native MS and Fast Photochemical Oxidation of Peptides in Nanodiscs

Daptomycin is a cyclic lipopeptide antibiotic that targets the lipid membrane of Gram-positive bacteria. Membrane fluidity and charge can affect daptomycin activity, but its mechanisms are poorly understood because it is challenging to study daptomycin interactions within lipid bilayers. Here, we combined native mass spectrometry (MS) and fast photochemical oxidation of peptides (FPOP) to study daptomycin-membrane interactions with different lipid bilayer nanodiscs. Native MS suggests that daptomycin incorporates randomly and does not prefer any specific oligomeric states when integrated into bilayers. FPOP reveals significant protection in most bilayer environments. Combining the native MS and FPOP results, we observed that stronger membrane interactions are formed with more rigid membranes, and pore formation may occur in more fluid membranes to expose daptomycin to FPOP oxidation. Electrophysiology measurements further supported the observation of polydisperse pore complexes from the MS data. Together, these results demonstrate the complementarity of native MS, FPOP, and membrane conductance experiments to shed light on how antibiotic peptides interact with and within lipid membranes.

Investigating the Lipid Selectivity of Membrane Proteins in Heterogeneous Nanodiscs

The structure and function of membrane proteins can be significantly impacted by the surrounding lipid environment, but membrane protein-lipid interactions in lipid bilayers are often difficult to study due to their transient and polydisperse nature. Here, we used two native mass spectrometry (MS) approaches to investigate how the Escherichia coli ammonium transporter trimer (AmtB) and aquaporin Z (AqpZ) selectively remodel their local lipid environment in heterogeneous lipoprotein nanodiscs. First, we used gas-phase ejection to isolate the membrane protein with bound lipids from heterogeneous nanodiscs with different combinations of lipids. Second, we used solution-phase detergent extraction as an orthogonal approach to study membrane protein remodeling of lipids in the nanodisc with native MS. Our results showed that Triton X-100 and lauryldimethylamine oxide retain lipid selectivity that agrees with gas-phase ejection, but C8E4 distorts some preferential lipid interactions. Both approaches reveal that AmtB has a few selective binding sites for phosphatidylcholine (PC) lipids, is selective for binding phosphatidylglycerols (PG) overall, and is nonselective for phosphatidylethanolamines (PE). In contrast, AqpZ prefers either PC or PG over PE and prefers PC over PG. Overall, these experiments provide a picture of how membrane proteins bind different lipid head groups in the context of mixed lipid bilayers.

Lipids and EGCG Affect α-Synuclein Association and Disruption of Nanodiscs

Lipid membranes have recently been implicated in protein misfolding and disease etiology, including for α-synuclein and Parkinson's disease. However, studying the intersection of protein complex formation, membrane interactions, and bilayer disruption simultaneously is challenging. In particular, the efficacies of small molecule inhibitors for toxic protein aggregation are not well understood. Here, we used native mass spectrometry in combination with lipid nanodiscs to study α-synuclein-membrane interactions. α-Synuclein did not interact with zwitterionic 1,2-dimyristoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphocholine lipids but interacted strongly with anionic 1,2-dimyristoyl-sn-glycero-3-phospho(1'-rac-glycerol) lipids, eventually leading to membrane disruption. Unsaturated 1-palmitoyl-2-oleoyl-sn-glycero-3-phospho(1'-rac-glycerol) (POPG) lipid nanodiscs were also prone to bilayer disruption, releasing α-synuclein:POPG complexes. Interestingly, the fibril inhibitor, (-)-epigallocatechin gallate (EGCG), prevented membrane disruption but did not prevent the incorporation of α-synuclein into nanodisc complexes. Thus, although EGCG inhibits fibrillization, it does not inhibit α-synuclein from associating with the membrane.

Approaches to Heterogeneity in Native Mass Spectrometry

Native mass spectrometry (MS) is aimed at preserving and determining the native structure, composition, and stoichiometry of biomolecules and their complexes from solution after they are transferred into the gas phase. Major improvements in native MS instrumentation and experimental methods over the past few decades have led to a concomitant increase in the complexity and heterogeneity of samples that can be analyzed, including protein-ligand complexes, protein complexes with multiple coexisting stoichiometries, and membrane protein-lipid assemblies. Heterogeneous features of these biomolecular samples can be important for understanding structure and function. However, sample heterogeneity can make assignment of ion mass, charge, composition, and structure very challenging due to the overlap of tens or even hundreds of peaks in the mass spectrum. In this review, we cover data analysis, experimental, and instrumental advances and strategies aimed at solving this problem, with an in-depth discussion of theoretical and practical aspects of the use of available deconvolution algorithms and tools. We also reflect upon current challenges and provide a view of the future of this exciting field.

Surface-induced Dissociation Mass Spectrometry as a Structural Biology Tool

Native mass spectrometry (nMS) is evolving into a workhorse for structural biology. The plethora of online and offline preparation, separation, and purification methods as well as numerous ionization techniques combined with powerful new hybrid ion mobility and mass spectrometry systems has illustrated the great potential of nMS for structural biology. Fundamental to the progression of nMS has been the development of novel activation methods for dissociating proteins and protein complexes to deduce primary, secondary, tertiary, and quaternary structure through the combined use of multiple MS/MS technologies. This review highlights the key features and advantages of surface collisions (surface-induced dissociation, SID) for probing the connectivity of subunits within protein and nucleoprotein complexes and, in particular, for solving protein structure in conjunction with complementary techniques such as cryo-EM and computational modeling. Several case studies highlight the significant role SID, and more generally nMS, will play in structural elucidation of biological assemblies in the future as the technology becomes more widely adopted. Cases are presented where SID agrees with solved crystal or cryoEM structures or provides connectivity maps that are otherwise inaccessible by "gold standard" structural biology techniques.

High-Resolution Native Mass Spectrometry

Native mass spectrometry (MS) involves the analysis and characterization of macromolecules, predominantly intact proteins and protein complexes, whereby as much as possible the native structural features of the analytes are retained. As such, native MS enables the study of secondary, tertiary, and even quaternary structure of proteins and other biomolecules. Native MS represents a relatively recent addition to the analytical toolbox of mass spectrometry and has over the past decade experienced immense growth, especially in enhancing sensitivity and resolving power but also in ease of use. With the advent of dedicated mass analyzers, sample preparation and separation approaches, targeted fragmentation techniques, and software solutions, the number of practitioners and novel applications has risen in both academia and industry. This review focuses on recent developments, particularly in high-resolution native MS, describing applications in the structural analysis of protein assemblies, proteoform profiling of─among others─biopharmaceuticals and plasma proteins, and quantitative and qualitative analysis of protein-ligand interactions, with the latter covering lipid, drug, and carbohydrate molecules, to name a few.

Lipid tails modulate antimicrobial peptide membrane incorporation and activity

Membrane disrupting antimicrobial peptides (AMPs) are often amphipathic peptides that interact directly with lipid bilayers. AMPs are generally thought to interact mostly with lipid head groups, but it is less clear how the lipid alkyl chain length and saturation modulate interactions with membranes. Here, we used native mass spectrometry to measure the stoichiometry of three different AMPs-LL-37, indolicidin, and magainin-2-in lipid nanodiscs. We also measured the activity of these AMPs in unilamellar vesicle leakage assays. We found that LL-37 formed specific hexamer complexes but with different intermediates and affinities that depended on the bilayer thickness. LL-37 was also most active in lipid bilayers containing longer, unsaturated lipids. In contrast, indolicidin incorporated to a higher degree into more fluid lipid bilayers but was more active with bilayers with thinner, less fluid lipids. Finally, magainin-2 incorporated to a higher degree into bilayers with longer, unsaturated alkyl chains and showed more activity in these same conditions. Together, these data show that higher amounts of peptide incorporation generally led to higher activity and that AMPs tend to incorporate more into longer unsaturated lipid bilayers. However, the activity of AMPs was not always directly related to amount of peptide incorporated.

Investigating Antimicrobial Peptide-Membrane Interactions Using Fast Photochemical Oxidation of Peptides in Nanodiscs

Antimicrobial peptides (AMPs) are an important part of the innate immune system and demonstrate promising applications in the fight against antibiotic-resistant infections due to their unique mechanism of targeting bacterial membranes. However, it is challenging to study the interactions of these peptides within lipid bilayers, making it difficult to understand their mechanisms of toxicity and selectivity. Here, we used fast photochemical oxidation of peptides, an irreversible footprinting technique that labels solvent accessible residues, and native charge detection-mass spectrometry to study AMP-lipid interactions with different lipid bilayer nanodiscs. We observed differences in the oxidation of two peptides, indolicidin and LL-37, in three distinct lipid environments, which reveal their affinity for lipid bilayers. Our findings suggest that indolicidin interacts with lipid head groups via a simple charge-driven mechanism, but LL-37 is more specific for Escherichia coli nanodiscs. These results provide complementary information on the potential modes of action and lipid selectivity of AMPs.

Mass spectrometry for multi-dimensional characterization of natural and synthetic materials at the nanoscale

Characterization of materials at the nanoscale plays a crucial role in in-depth understanding the nature and processes of the substances. Mass spectrometry (MS) has characterization capabilities for nanomaterials (NMs) and nanostructures by offering reliable multi-dimensional information consisting of accurate mass, isotopic, and molecular structural information. In the last decade, MS has emerged as a powerful nano-characterization technique. This review comprehensively summarizes the capabilities of MS in various aspects of nano-characterization that greatly enrich the toolbox of nano research. Compared with other characterization techniques, MS has unique capabilities for real-time monitoring and tracking reaction intermediates and by-products. Moreover, MS has shown application potential in some novel aspects, such as MS imaging of the biodistribution and fate of NMs in animals and humans, stable isotopic tracing of NMs, and risk assessment of NMs, which deserve update and integration into the current knowledge framework of nano-characterization.

Temperature- and composition-dependent conformational transitions of amphipathic peptide-phospholipid nanodiscs

Nanodiscs are discoidal particles in which a lipid bilayer is encircled by amphipathic molecules such as proteins, peptides, or synthetic polymers. The apolipoprotein-A-I-derived peptide 18A is known to form nanodiscs in the presence of phospholipids, but the detailed mechanism of the formation and deformation of these nanodiscs in response to changes in the surrounding environment is not well understood. Here, we investigated the temperature- and composition-dependent structural changes of 18A-phosphatidylcholine complexes using fluorescence spectroscopy, dynamic light scattering, circular dichroism, static ³¹P NMR, and electron microscopy. We found that the nanodiscs in fast isotropic rotational motion increased in size above the gel-to-liquid-crystalline phase transition temperature of the lipid bilayers, resulting in the formation of enlarged nanodiscs and a lamellar phase. The lamellar phase was found to be oriented along the magnetic field. Further increase in temperature induced the formation of lipid vesicles. These transformations were explained using a transition model based on the migration of the peptide from the rim of the nanodiscs to the liquid-crystalline bilayer phase. The study outcomes provide a basis for understanding the design principles of discoidal nanostructures for structural biology and nanomedicine applications.

Free-Radical Membrane Protein Footprinting by Photolysis of Perfluoroisopropyl Iodide Partitioned to Detergent Micelle by Sonication

A free-radical footprinting approach is described for integral membrane protein (IMP) that extends, significantly, the "fast photochemical oxidation of proteins" (FPOP) platform. This new approach exploits highly hydrophobic perfluoroisopropyl iodide (PFIPI) together with tip sonication to ensure efficient transport into the micelle interior, allowing laser dissociation and footprinting of the transmembrane domains. In contrast to water soluble footprinters, PFIPI footprints both the hydrophobic intramembrane and the hydrophilic extramembrane domains of the IMP vitamin K epoxide reductase (VKOR). The footprinting is fast, giving high coverage for Tyr (100 %) and Trp. The incorporation of the reagent with sonication does not significantly affect VKOR's enzymatic function, and tyrosine iodination does not compromise protease digestion and the subsequent analysis. The locations for the modifications are largely consistent with the corresponding solvent accessibilities, recommending this approach for future membrane protein footprinting.

Suzuki Coupling of Protected Aryl Diazonium Ions: Expanding the Knowledge of Triazabutadiene Compatible Reactions

Aryl diazonium ions are important in synthesis and chemical biology, and the acid-labile triazabutadiene can protect this handle for future use. We report a Suzuki coupling strategy that is compatible with the triazabutadiene scaffold, expanding the scope of synthetically available triazabutadienes. Shown herein, the triazabutadiene scaffold remains intact and reactive after coupling, as demonstrated by releasing the aryl diazonium ion to label a tyrosine-rich model protein.

Native Mass Spectrometry Reveals the Simultaneous Binding of Lipids and Zinc to Rhodopsin

Rhodopsin, a prototypical G-protein-coupled receptor, is responsible for scoptic vision at low-light levels. Although rhodopsin's photoactivation cascade is well understood, it remains unclear how lipid and zinc binding to the receptor are coupled. Using native mass spectrometry, we developed a novel data analysis strategy to deconvolve zinc and lipid bound to the proteoforms of rhodopsin and investigated the allosteric interaction between lipids and zinc binding. We discovered that phosphatidylcholine bound to rhodopsin with a greater affinity than phosphatidylserine or phosphatidylethanolamine, and that binding of all lipids was influenced by zinc but with different effects. In contrast, zinc binding was relatively unperturbed by lipids. Overall, these data reveal that lipid binding can be strongly and differentially influenced by metal ions.

Copper-Free Click Enabled Triazabutadiene for Bioorthogonal Protein Functionalization

Aryl diazonium ions have long been used in bioconjugation due to their reactivity toward electron-rich aryl residues, such as tyrosine. However, their utility in biological systems has been restricted due to the requirement of harsh conditions for their generation in situ, as well as limited hydrolytic stability. Previous work describing a scaffold known as triazabutadiene (TBD) has shown the ability to protect aryl diazonium ions allowing for increased synthetic utility, as well as triggered release under biologically relevant conditions. Herein, we describe the synthesis and application of a novel TBD, capable of installation of a cyclooctyne on protein surfaces for later use of copper-free click reactions involving functional azides. The probe shows efficient protein labeling across a wide pH range that can be accomplished in a convenient and timely manner. Orthogonality of the cyclooctyne modification was showcased by labeling a model protein in the presence of hen egg proteins, using an azide-containing fluorophore. We further confirmed that the azobenzene modification can be cleaved using sodium dithionite treatment.

Nanodiscs and Mass Spectrometry: Making Membranes Fly

Cells are surrounded by a protective lipid bilayer membrane, and membrane proteins in the bilayer control the flow of chemicals, information, and energy across this barrier. Many therapeutics target membrane proteins, and some directly target the lipid membrane itself. However, interactions within biological membranes are challenging to study due to their heterogeneity and insolubility. Mass spectrometry (MS) has become a powerful technique for studying membrane proteins, especially how membrane proteins interact with their surrounding lipid environment. Although detergent micelles are the most common membrane mimetic, nanodiscs are emerging as a promising platform for MS. Nanodiscs, nanoscale lipid bilayers encircled by two scaffold proteins, provide a controllable lipid bilayer for solubilizing membrane proteins. This Young Scientist Perspective focuses on native MS of intact nanodiscs and highlights the unique experiments enabled by making membranes fly, including studying membrane protein-lipid interactions and exploring the specificity of fragile transmembrane peptide complexes. It will also explore current challenges and future perspectives for interfacing nanodiscs with MS.

Nanodiscs: A toolkit for membrane protein science

Membrane proteins are involved in numerous vital biological processes, including transport, signal transduction and the enzymes in a variety of metabolic pathways. Integral membrane proteins account for up to 30% of the human proteome and they make up more than half of all currently marketed therapeutic targets. Unfortunately, membrane proteins are inherently recalcitrant to study using the normal toolkit available to scientists, and one is most often left with the challenge of finding inhibitors, activators and specific antibodies using a denatured or detergent solubilized aggregate. The Nanodisc platform circumvents these challenges by providing a self-assembled system that renders typically insoluble, yet biologically and pharmacologically significant, targets such as receptors, transporters, enzymes, and viral antigens soluble in aqueous media in a native-like bilayer environment that maintain a target's functional activity. By providing a bilayer surface of defined composition and structure, Nanodiscs have found great utility in the study of cellular signaling complexes that assemble on a membrane surface. Nanodiscs provide a nanometer scale vehicle for the in vivo delivery of amphipathic drugs, therapeutic lipids, tethered nucleic acids, imaging agents and active protein complexes. This means for generating nanoscale lipid bilayers has spawned the successful use of numerous other polymer and peptide amphipathic systems. This review, in celebration of the Anfinsen Award, summarizes some recent results and provides an inroad into the current and historical literature.

Native mass spectrometry-A valuable tool in structural biology

Proteins and the complexes they form with their ligands are the players of cellular action. Their function is directly linked with their structure making the structural analysis of protein-ligand complexes essential. Classical techniques of structural biology include X-ray crystallography, nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy and recently distinguished cryo-electron microscopy. However, protein-ligand complexes are often dynamic and heterogeneous and consequently challenging for these techniques. Alternative approaches are therefore needed and gained importance during the last decades. One alternative is native mass spectrometry, which is the analysis of intact protein complexes in the gas phase. To achieve this, sample preparation and instrument conditions have to be optimised. Native mass spectrometry then reveals stoichiometry, protein interactions and topology of protein assemblies. Advanced techniques such as ion mobility and high-resolution mass spectrometry further add to the range of applications and deliver information on shape and microheterogeneity of the complexes. In this tutorial, we explain the basics of native mass spectrometry including sample requirements, instrument modifications and interpretation of native mass spectra. We further discuss the developments of native mass spectrometry and provide example spectra and applications.

Revealing the Specificity of a Range of Antimicrobial Peptides in Lipid Nanodiscs by Native Mass Spectrometry

Antimicrobial peptides (AMPs) interact directly with lipid membranes of pathogens and may have the potential to combat antibiotic resistance. Although many AMPs are thought to form toxic oligomeric pores, their interactions within lipid membranes are not well understood. Here, we used native mass spectrometry to measure the incorporation of a range of different AMPs in lipoprotein nanodiscs. We found that the truncation of human LL37 increases the lipid specificity but decreases the specificity of complex formation. We also saw that the reduction of disulfide bonds can have a dramatic effect on the ability of AMPs to interact with lipid bilayers. Finally, by examining a wider range of peptides we discovered that AMPs tend to interact specifically with anionic lipids but form nonspecific complexes with wide oligomeric state distributions. Overall, these data reveal that each AMP has unique behaviors but some common trends apply to many AMPs.

Measuring Remodeling of the Lipid Environment Surrounding Membrane Proteins with Lipid Exchange and Native Mass Spectrometry

Due to their crucial biochemical roles, membrane proteins are important drug targets. Although it is clear that lipids can influence membrane protein function, the chemistry of lipid binding remains difficult to study because protein-lipid interactions are polydisperse, competitive, and transient. Furthermore, detergents, which are often used to solubilize membrane proteins in micelles, may disrupt lipid interactions that occur in bilayers. Here, we present two new approaches to quantify protein-lipid interactions in bilayers and understand how membrane proteins remodel their surrounding lipid environment. First, we used mass spectrometry (MS) to measure the exchange of lipids between lipoprotein nanodiscs with and without an embedded membrane protein. Shifts in the lipid distribution toward the membrane protein nanodiscs revealed lipid binding, and titrations allowed measurement of the optimal lipid composition for the membrane protein. Second, we used native or nondenaturing MS to ionize membrane protein nanodiscs with heterogeneous lipids. Ejecting the membrane protein complex with bound lipids in the mass spectrometer revealed enrichment of specific lipids around the membrane protein. Both new approaches showed that the E. coli ammonium transporter AmtB prefers phosphatidylglycerol lipids overall but has a minor affinity for phosphatidylcholine lipids.

A Universal Score for Deconvolution of Intact Protein and Native Electrospray Mass Spectra

The growing use of intact protein mass analysis, top-down proteomics, and native mass spectrometry have created a need for improved data analysis pipelines for deconvolution of electrospray (ESI) mass spectra containing multiple charge states and potentially without isotopic resolution. Although there are multiple deconvolution algorithms, there is no consensus for how to judge the quality of the deconvolution, and many scoring schemes are not published. Here, an intuitive universal score (UniScore) for ESI deconvolution is presented. The UniScore is the weighted average of deconvolution scores (DScores) for each peak multiplied by the R² of the fit to the data. Each DScore is composed of separate components to score (1) the uniqueness and fit of the deconvolution to the data, (2) the consistency of the peak shape across different charge states, (3) the smoothness of the charge state distribution, and (4) symmetry and separation of the peak. Example scores are provided for a range of experimental and simulated data. By providing a means of judging the quality of the overall deconvolution as well as individual mass peaks, the UniScore scheme provides a foundation for standardizing ESI data analysis of larger molecules and enabling the use of ESI deconvolution in automated data analysis pipelines.

Mass spectrometry of membrane protein complexes

Membrane proteins are key players in the cell. Due to their hydrophobic nature they require solubilising agents such as detergents or membrane mimetics during purification and, consequently, are challenging targets in structural biology. In addition, their natural lipid environment is crucial for their structure and function further hampering their analysis. Alternative approaches are therefore required when the analysis by conventional techniques proves difficult. In this review, we highlight the broad application of mass spectrometry (MS) for the characterisation of membrane proteins and their interactions with lipids. We show that MS unambiguously identifies the protein and lipid components of membrane protein complexes, unravels their three-dimensional arrangements and further provides clues of protein-lipid interactions.

Enhanced Characterization of Membrane Protein Complexes by Ultraviolet Photodissociation Mass Spectrometry

Development of chemical chaperones to solubilize membrane protein complexes in aqueous solutions has allowed for gas-phase analysis of their native-like assemblies, including rapid evaluation of stability and interacting partners. Characterization of protein primary sequence, however, has thus far been limited. Ultraviolet photodissociation (UVPD) generates a multitude of sequence ions for the E. coli ammonia channel (AmtB), provides improved localization of a possible post-translational modification of aquaporin Z (AqpZ), and surpasses previous reports of sequence coverage for mechanosensitive channel of large conductance (MscL). Variations in UVPD sequence ion abundance have been shown to correspond to structural changes induced upon some perturbation. Preliminary results are reported here for elucidating increased rigidity or flexibility of MscL when bound to various phospholipids.

Imidazole Derivatives Improve Charge Reduction and Stabilization for Native Mass Spectrometry

Noncovalent interactions between biomolecules are critical to their activity. Native mass spectrometry (MS) has enabled characterization of these interactions by preserving noncovalent assemblies for mass analysis, including protein-ligand and protein-protein complexes for a wide range of soluble and membrane proteins. Recent advances in native MS of lipoprotein nanodiscs have also allowed characterization of antimicrobial peptides and membrane proteins embedded in intact lipid bilayers. However, conventional native electrospray ionization (ESI) can disrupt labile interactions. To stabilize macromolecular complexes for native MS, charge reducing reagents can be added to the solution prior to ESI, such as triethylamine, trimethylamine oxide, and imidazole. Lowering the charge acquired during ESI reduces Coulombic repulsion that leads to dissociation, and charge reduction reagents may also lower the internal energy of the ions through evaporative cooling. Here, we tested a range of imidazole derivatives to discover improved charge reducing reagents and to determine how their chemical properties influence charge reduction efficacy. We measured their effects on a soluble protein complex, a membrane protein complex in detergent, and lipoprotein nanodiscs with and without embedded peptides, and used computational chemistry to understand the observed charge-reduction behavior. Together, our data revealed that hydrophobic substituents at the 2 position on imidazole can significantly improve both charge reduction and gas-phase stability over existing reagents. These new imidazole derivatives will be immediately beneficial for a range of native MS applications and provide chemical principles to guide development of novel charge reducing reagents.

Eliminating Artifacts in Electrospray Deconvolution with a SoftMax Function

UniDec provides a rapid and robust approach to deconvolving electrospray mass spectra into their corresponding mass and charge components. However, the UniDec algorithm can produce artifacts depending on the quality and complexity of the data. Here, a SoftMax function is applied to the charge state distribution of each data point, which pushes the algorithm towards assigning each data point to one primary charge state. As shown for several data sets of increasing complexity, the SoftMax function significantly reduces deconvolution artifacts, even for data with overlapping charge states.

Expanding the Types of Lipids Amenable to Native Mass Spectrometry of Lipoprotein Complexes

Native mass spectrometry (MS) has become an important tool for the analysis of membrane proteins. Although detergent micelles are the most commonly used method for solubilizing membrane proteins for native MS, nanoscale lipoprotein complexes such as nanodiscs are emerging as a promising complementary approach because they solubilize membrane proteins in a lipid bilayer environment. However, prior native MS studies of intact nanodiscs have employed only a limited set of phospholipids that are similar in mass. Here, we extend the range of lipids that are amenable to native MS of nanodiscs by combining lipids with masses that are simple integer multiples of each other. Although these lipid combinations create complex distributions, overlap between resonant peak series allows interpretation of nanodisc spectra containing glycolipids, sterols, and cardiolipin. We also investigate the gas-phase stability of nanodiscs with these new lipids towards collisional activation. We observe that negative ionization mode or charge reduction stabilizes nanodiscs and is essential to preserving labile lipids such as sterols. These new approaches to native MS of nanodiscs will enable future studies of membrane proteins embedded in model membranes that more accurately mimic natural bilayers. Graphical Abstract.

Native Mass Spectrometry of Antimicrobial Peptides in Lipid Nanodiscs Elucidates Complex Assembly

Antimicrobial peptides (AMPs) are generally cationic and amphipathic peptides that show potential applications to combat the growing threat of antibiotic resistant infections. AMPs are known to interact with bacterial membranes, but their mechanisms of toxicity and selectivity are poorly understood, in part because it is challenging to characterize AMP oligomeric complexes within lipid bilayers. Here, we used native mass spectrometry to measure the stoichiometry of AMPs inserted into lipoprotein nanodiscs with different lipid components. Titrations of increasing peptide concentration and collisional activation experiments reveal that AMPs can exhibit a range of behaviors from nonspecific incorporation into the nanodisc to formation of specific complexes. This new approach to characterizing formation of AMP complexes within lipid membranes will provide unique insights into AMP mechanisms.

Structural mass spectrometry comes of age: new insight into protein structure, function and interactions

Mass spectrometry (MS) provides an impressive array of information about the structure, function and interactions of proteins. In recent years, many new developments have been in the field of native MS and these exemplify a new coming of age of this field. In this mini review, we connect the latest methodological and instrumental developments in native MS to the new insights these have enabled. We highlight the prominence of an increasingly common strategy of using hybrid approaches, where multiple MS-based techniques are used in combination, and integrative approaches, where MS is used alongside other techniques such as ion-mobility spectrometry. We also review how the emergence of a native top-down approach, which combines native MS with top-down proteomics into a single experiment, is the pièce de résistance of structural mass spectrometry's coming of age. Finally, we outline key developments that have enabled membrane protein native MS to shift from being extremely challenging to routine, and how this technique is uncovering inaccessible details of membrane protein–lipid interactions.

Chemical Additives Enable Native Mass Spectrometry Measurement of Membrane Protein Oligomeric State within Intact Nanodiscs

Membrane proteins play critical biochemical roles but remain challenging to study. Recently, native or nondenaturing mass spectrometry (MS) has made great strides in characterizing membrane protein interactions. However, conventional native MS relies on detergent micelles, which may disrupt natural interactions. Lipoprotein nanodiscs provide a platform to present membrane proteins for native MS within a lipid bilayer environment, but previous native MS of membrane proteins in nanodiscs has been limited by the intermediate stability of nanodiscs. It is difficult to eject membrane proteins from nanodiscs for native MS but also difficult to retain intact nanodisc complexes with membrane proteins inside. Here, we employed chemical reagents that modulate the charge acquired during electrospray ionization (ESI). By modulating ESI conditions, we could either eject the membrane protein complex with few bound lipids or capture the intact membrane protein nanodisc complex-allowing measurement of the membrane protein oligomeric state within an intact lipid bilayer environment. The dramatic differences in the stability of nanodiscs under different ESI conditions opens new applications for native MS of nanodiscs.

Rapid LC-MS Method for Accurate Molecular Weight Determination of Membrane and Hydrophobic Proteins

Therapeutic target characterization involves many components, including accurate molecular weight (MW) determination. Knowledge of the accurate MW allows one to detect the presence of post-translational modifications, proteolytic cleavages, and importantly, if the correct construct has been generated and purified. Denaturing liquid chromatography-mass spectrometry (LC-MS) can be an attractive method for obtaining this information. However, membrane protein LC-MS methodology has remained relatively under-explored and under-incorporated in comparison to methods for soluble proteins. Here, systematic investigation of multiple gradients and column chemistries has led to the development of a 5 min denaturing LC-MS method for acquiring membrane protein accurate MW measurements. Conditions were interrogated with membrane proteins, such as GPCRs and ion channels, as well as bispecific antibody constructs of variable sizes with the aim to provide the community with rapid LC-MS methods necessary to obtain chromatographic and accurate MW measurements in a medium- to high-throughput manner. The 5 min method detailed has successfully produced MW measurements for hydrophobic proteins with a wide MW range (17.5 to 105.3 kDa) and provided evidence that some constructs indeed contain unexpected modifications or sequence clipping. This rapid LC-MS method is also capable of baseline separating formylated and nonformylated aquaporinZ membrane protein.