Fourier Transform-Ion Mobility-Orbitrap Mass Spectrometer: A Next-Generation Instrument for Native Mass Spectrometry

Fe-S cluster biosynthesis and maturation: Mass spectrometry-based methods advancing the field

Iron‑sulfur (FeS) clusters are inorganic protein cofactors that perform essential functions in many physiological processes. Spectroscopic techniques have historically been used to elucidate details of FeS cluster type, their assembly and transfer, and changes in redox and ligand binding properties. Structural probes of protein topology, complex formation, and conformational dynamics are also necessary to fully understand these FeS protein systems. Recent developments in mass spectrometry (MS) instrumentation and methods provide new tools to investigate FeS cluster and structural properties. With the unique advantage of sampling all species in a mixture, MS-based methods can be utilized as a powerful complementary approach to probe native dynamic heterogeneity, interrogate protein folding and unfolding equilibria, and provide extensive insight into protein binding partners within an entire proteome. Here, we highlight key advances in FeS protein studies made possible by MS methodology and contribute an outlook for its role in the field.

Development of a Modular, Open-Source, Reduced-Pressure, Drift Tube Ion Mobility Spectrometer

Toward the goal of minimizing construction costs while maintaining high performance, a new, reduced-pressure, drift tube ion mobility system is coupled with an ion trap mass analyzer through a custom ion shuttle. The availability of reduced-pressure ion mobility systems remains limited due to comparatively expensive commercial options and limited shared design features in the open literature. This report details the complete design and benchmarking characteristics of a reduced-pressure ion mobility system. The system is constructed from FR4 PCB electrodes and encased in a PTFE vacuum enclosure with custom torque-tightened couplers to utilize standard KF40 bulkheads. The PTFE enclosure directly minimizes the overall system expenses, and the implementation of threaded brass inserts allows for facile attachments to the vacuum enclosure without damaging the thermoplastic housing. Front and rear ion funnels maximize ion transmission and help mitigate the effects of radial ion diffusion. A custom planar ion shuttle transports ions from the exit of the rear ion funnel into the ion optics of an ion trap mass analyzer. The planar ion shuttle can couple the IM system to any contemporary Thermo Scientific ion trap mass analyzer. Signal stability and ion intensity remain unchanging following the implementation of the planar ion shuttle when compared to the original stacked ring ion guide. The constructed IM system showed resolving powers up to 85 for various small molecules and proteins using the Fourier transform from a ∼1 m drift tube. Recorded mobilities derived from first principles agree with published literature results with an average error of 1.1% and an average error toward literature values using single field calibration of <1.3%.

Nonlinear Frequency Modulation for Fourier Transform Ion Mobility Mass Spectrometry Improves Experimental Efficiency

Through optimization of terminal frequencies and effective sampling rates, we have developed nonlinear sawtooth-shaped frequency sweeps for efficient Fourier transform ion mobility mass spectrometry (FT-IM-MS) experiments. This is in contrast to conventional FT-IM-MS experiments where ion gates are modulated according to a linear frequency sweep. Linear frequency sweeps are effective but can be hindered by the amount of useful signal obtained using a single sweep over a large frequency range imposed by ion gating inefficiencies, particularly small ion packets, and gate depletion. These negative factors are direct consequences of the inherently low gate pulse widths of high-frequency ion gating events, placing an upper bound on FT-IM-MS performance. Here, we report alternative ion modulation strategies. Sawtooth frequency sweeps may be constructed for the purpose of either extending high-SNR transients or conducting efficient signal-averaging experiments for low-SNR transients. The data obtained using this approach show high-SNR signals for a set of low-mass tetraalkylammonium salts (<1000 m/z) where resolving powers in excess of 500 are achieved. Data for low-SNR obtained for multimeric protein complexes streptavidin (53 kDa) and GroEL (800 kDa) also reveal large increases in the signal-to-noise ratio for reconstructed arrival time distributions.

Digital Quadrupole Isolation and Electron Capture Dissociation on an Extended Mass Range Q-TOF Provides Sequence and Structure Information on Proteins and Protein Complexes

Electron capture dissociation (ECD) is now a well-established method for sequencing peptides and performing top-down analysis on proteins of less than 30 kDa, and there is growing interest in using this approach for studies of larger proteins and protein complexes. Although much progress on ECD has been made over the past few decades, establishing methods for obtaining informative spectra still poses a significant challenge. Here we describe how digital quadrupole (DigiQ) ion isolation can be used for the mass selection of single charge states of proteins and protein complexes prior to undergoing ECD and/or charge reduction. First, we demonstrate that the DigiQ can isolate single charge states of monomeric proteins such as ubiquitin (8.6 kDa) and charge states of large protein complexes such as pyruvate kinase (234 kDa) using a hybrid quadrupole-TOF-MS (Agilent extended m/z range 6545XT). Next, we demonstrate that fragment ions resulting from ECD can be utilized to provide information about the sequence and structure of the cytochrome c/heme complex and the ubiquitin monomer. Lastly, an especially interesting result for DigiQ isolation and electron capture (EC) was noted; namely, the 16+ charge state of the streptavidin/biotin complex reveals different electron capture patterns for the biotinylated proteoforms of streptavidin. This result is consistent with previous reports that apo streptavidin exists in multiple conformations and that biotin binding shifts the conformational dynamics of the complex (Quintyn, R. Chem. Biol. 2015, 22 (55), 583-592).

Integration of Trapped Ion Mobility Spectrometry and Ultraviolet Photodissociation in a Quadrupolar Ion Trap Mass Spectrometer

There is a growing demand for lower-cost, benchtop analytical instruments with complementary separation capabilities for the screening and characterization of biological samples. In this study, we report on the custom integration of trapped ion mobility spectrometry and ultraviolet photodissociation capabilities in a commercial Paul quadrupolar ion trap multistage mass spectrometer (TIMS-QIT-MSn UVPD platform). A gated TIMS operation allowed for the accumulation of ion mobility separated ion in the QIT, followed by a mass analysis (MS1 scan) or m/z isolation, followed by selected collision induced dissociation (CID) or ultraviolet photodissociation (UVPD) and a mass analysis (MS2 scan). The analytical potential of this platform for the analysis of complex and labile biological samples is illustrated for the case of positional isomers with varying PTM location of the histone H4 tryptic peptide 4-17 singly and doubly acetylated and the histone H3.1 tail (1-50) singly trimethylated. For all cases, a baseline ion mobility precursor molecular ion preseparation was obtained. The tandem CID and UVPD MS2 allowed for effective sequence confirmation as well as the identification of reporter fragment ions associated with the PTM location; a higher sequence coverage was obtained using UVPD when compared to CID. Different from previous IMS-MS implementation, the novel TIMS-QIT-MSn UVPD platform offers a lower-cost alternative for the structural characterization of biological molecules that can be widely disseminated in clinical laboratories.

Implementation of an Open-Source Multiplexing Ion Gate Control for High Kinetic Energy Ion Mobility Spectrometry (HiKE-IMS)

With ion mobility spectrometry increasingly used in mass spectrometry to enhance separation by increasing orthogonality, low ion throughput is a challenge for the drift-tube ion mobility experiment. The High Kinetic Energy Ion Mobility Spectrometer (HiKE-IMS) is no exception and routinely uses duty cycles of less than 0.1%. Multiplexing techniques such as Fourier transform and Hadamard transform represent two of the most common approaches used in the literature to improve ion throughput for the IMS experiment; these techniques promise increased duty cycles of up to 50% and an increased signal-to-noise ratio (SNR). With no instrument modifications required, we present the implementation of Hadamard Transform on the HiKE-IMS using a low cost, high-speed (600 MHz), open source microcontroller, a Teensy 4.1. Compared to signal average mode, 7- to 10-bit pseudorandom binary sequences resulted in increased analyte signal by over a factor of 3. However, the maximum SNR gain of 10 did not approach the theoretical 2n-1 gain largely due to capacitive coupling of the ion gate modulation with the Faraday plate used as a detector. Even when utilizing an inverse Hadamard technique, capacitive coupling was not completely eliminated. Regardless, the benefits of multiplexing IMS coupled to mass spectrometers are well documented throughout literature, and this first effort serves as a proof of concept for multiplexing HiKE-IMS. Finally, the highly flexible Teensy used in this effort can be used to multiplex other devices or can be used for Fourier transform instead of Hadamard transform.

Low-cost Arduino controlled dual-polarity high voltage power supply

Ion Mobility Spectrometry (IMS) provides low ppbv detection limits for gas-phase or aqueous analytes. These instruments rely an electric field to produce ion motion. This electric field is typically 200-600 V/cm with a 15 cm cell, requiring an HV source of 6-10 kV. In this work, we present a low-cost alternative for supplying this high voltage. Inexpensive, commercially available 0-20 kV HV modules are mapped to an analog 0-5 V input signal, controlled using an Arduino microcontroller and digital analog converter. Dual polarities are selectable through a front-panel switch and ramps potentials between settings to avoid damage to attached devices.

Improving Ion Mobility Mass Spectrometry of Proteins through Tristate Gating and Optimization of Multiplexing Parameters

Coupling drift tube ion mobility (IM) to Fourier transform mass spectrometry (FT-MS) affords the opportunity for gas-phase separation of ions based on size and conformation with high-resolution mass analysis. However, combining IM and FT-MS is challenging because ions exit the drift tube on a much faster time scale than the rate of mass analysis. Fourier transform (FT) and Hadamard transform multiplexing methods have been implemented to overcome the duty-cycle mismatch, offering new avenues for obtaining high-resolution, high-mass-accuracy analysis of mobility-selected ions. The gating methods used to integrate the drift tube with the FT mass analyzer discriminate against the transmission of large, low-mobility ions owing to the well-known gate depletion effect. Tristate gating strategies have been shown to increase ion transmission for drift tube IM-FT-MS systems through implementation of dual ion gating, controlling the quantity and timing of ions through the drift tube to reduce losses of slow-moving ions. Here we present an optimized set of multiplexing parameters for tristate gating ion mobility of several proteins on an Orbitrap mass spectrometer and further report parameters for increased ion transmission and mobility resolution as well as decreased experimental times from 15 min down to 30 s. On average, peak intensities in the arrival time distributions (ATDs) for ubiquitin increased 2.1× on average, while those of myoglobin increased by 1.5× with a resolving power increase on average of 11%.

Gas-Phase Unfolding of Protein Complexes Distinguishes Conformational Isomers

Proteins can adopt different conformational states that are important for their biological function and, in some cases, can be responsible for their dysfunction. The essential roles that proteins play in biological systems make distinguishing the structural differences between these conformational states both fundamentally and practically important. Here, we demonstrate that collision-induced unfolding (CIU), in combination with ion mobility-mass spectrometry (IM-MS) measurements, distinguish subtly different conformational states for protein complexes. Using the open and closed states of the β-lactoglobulin (βLG) dimer as a model, we show that these two conformational isomers unfold during collisional activation to generate distinct states that are readily separated by IM-MS. Extensive molecular modeling of the CIU process reproduces the distinct unfolding intermediates and identifies the molecular details that explain why the two conformational states unfold in distinct ways. Strikingly, the open conformational state forms new electrostatic interactions upon collisional heating, while the closed state does not. These newly formed electrostatic interactions involve residues on the loop differentially positioned in the two βLG conformational isomers, highlighting that gas-phase unfolding pathways reflect aspects of solution structure. This combination of experiment and theory provides a path forward for distinguishing subtly different conformational isomers for protein complexes via gas-phase unfolding experiments. Our results also have implications for understanding how protein complexes dissociate in the gas phase, indicating that current models need to be refined to explain protein complex dissociation.

Seeing the complete picture: proteins in top-down mass spectrometry

Top-down protein mass spectrometry can provide unique insights into protein sequence and structure, including precise proteoform identification and study of protein–ligand and protein–protein interactions. In contrast with the commonly applied bottom-up approach, top-down approaches do not include digestion of the protein of interest into small peptides, but instead rely on the ionization and subsequent fragmentation of intact proteins. As such, it is fundamentally the only way to fully characterize the composition of a proteoform. Here, we provide an overview of how a top-down protein mass spectrometry experiment is performed and point out recent applications from the literature to the reader. While some parts of the top-down workflow are broadly applicable, different research questions are best addressed with specific experimental designs. The most important divide is between studies that prioritize sequence information (i.e., proteoform identification) versus structural information (e.g., conformational studies, or mapping protein–protein or protein–ligand interactions). Another important consideration is whether to work under native or denaturing solution conditions, and the overall complexity of the sample also needs to be taken into account, as it determines whether (chromatographic) separation is required prior to MS analysis. In this review, we aim to provide enough information to support both newcomers and more experienced readers in the decision process of how to answer a potential research question most efficiently and to provide an overview of the methods that exist to answer these questions.

Considerations for Generating Frequency Modulation Waveforms for Fourier Transform-Ion Mobility Experiments

By casting the information regarding an ion population's mobility in the frequency domain, the coupling of time-dispersive ion mobility techniques is now imminently compatible with slower mass analyzers such as ion traps. Recent reports have detailed the continued progress toward maximizing the efficiency of the Fourier transform ion mobility-mass spectrometry (FT-IM-MS) experiments, but few reports have outlined the intersection between the practical considerations of implementation against the theoretical limits imposed by traditional signal processing techniques. One of the important concerns for Fourier-based multiplexing experiments is avoiding signal aliasing as a product of undersampled signals that may occur during data acquisition. In addition to traditional considerations such as detector sampling frequency, the limitations (i.e., maximum measurable drift time) imposed by experimental mass scan duration and the frequency sweep used for ion gate modulation must also be assessed. This work aims to connect the fundamental underpinnings of FT-IM-MS experiments and the associated experimental parameters that are encountered when coupling the comparatively fast separations in the mobility domain with the slower m/z scanning common for ion-trap mass analyzers. In addition to stating the relevant theory that applies to the FT-IM-MS experiment, this report highlights how aliased signals will manifest post Fourier transform in reconstructed arrival time distributions and calculated mobilities.

Structural mass spectrometry of membrane proteins

The analysis of proteins and protein complexes by mass spectrometry (MS) has come a long way since the invention of electrospray ionization (ESI) in the mid 80s. Originally used to characterize small soluble polypeptide chains, MS has progressively evolved over the past 3 decades towards the analysis of samples of ever increasing heterogeneity and complexity, while the instruments have become more and more sensitive and resolutive. The proofs of concepts and first examples of most structural MS methods appeared in the early 90s. However, their application to membrane proteins, key targets in the biopharma industry, is more recent. Nowadays, a wealth of information can be gathered from such MS-based methods, on all aspects of membrane protein structure: sequencing (and more precisely proteoform characterization), but also stoichiometry, non-covalent ligand binding (metals, drug, lipids, carbohydrates), conformations, dynamics and distance restraints for modelling. In this review, we present the concept and some historical and more recent applications on membrane proteins, for the major structural MS methods.

Surface Activity of Amines Provides Evidence for the Combined ESI Mechanism of Charge Reduction for Protein Complexes

Charge reduction reactions are important for native mass spectrometry (nMS) because lower charge states help retain native-like conformations and preserve noncovalent interactions of protein complexes. While mechanisms of charge reduction reactions are not well understood, they are generally achieved through the addition of small molecules, such as polyamines, to traditional nMS buffers. Here, we present new evidence that surface-active, charge reducing reagents carry away excess charge from the droplet after being emitted due to Coulombic repulsion, thereby reducing the overall charge of the droplet. Furthermore, these processes are directly linked to two mechanisms for electrospray ionization, specifically the charge residue and ion evaporation models (CRM and IEM). Selected protein complexes were analyzed in solutions containing ammonium acetate and selected trialkylamines or diaminoalkanes of increasing alkyl chain lengths. Results show that amines with higher surface activity have increased propensities for promoting charge reduction of the protein ions. The electrospray ionization (ESI) emitter potential was also found to be a major contributing parameter to the prevalence of charge reduction; higher emitter potentials consistently coincided with lower average charge states among all protein complexes analyzed. These results offer experimental evidence for the mechanism of charge reduction in ESI and also provide insight into the final stages of the ESI and their impact on biological ions.

Exploring the Conformations and Binding Location of HMGA2·DNA Complexes Using Ion Mobility Spectrometry and 193 nm Ultraviolet Photodissociation Mass Spectrometry

Although it is widely accepted that protein function is largely dependent on its structure, intrinsically disordered proteins (IDPs) lack defined structure but are essential in proper cellular processes. Mammalian high mobility group proteins (HMGA) are one such example of IDPs that perform a number of crucial nuclear activities and have been highly studied due to their involvement in the proliferation of a variety of disease and cancers. Traditional structural characterization methods have had limited success in understanding HMGA proteins and their ability to coordinate to DNA. Ion mobility spectrometry and mass spectrometry provide insights into the diversity and heterogeneity of structures adopted by IDPs and are employed here to interrogate HMGA2 in its unbound states and bound to two DNA hairpins. The broad distribution of collision cross sections observed for the apo-protein are restricted when HMGA2 is bound to DNA, suggesting that increased protein organization is promoted in the holo-form. Ultraviolet photodissociation was utilized to probe the changes in structures for the compact and elongated structures of HMGA2 by analyzing backbone cleavage propensities and solvent accessibility based on charge-site analysis, which revealed a spectrum of conformational possibilities. Namely, preferential binding of the DNA hairpins with the second of three AT-hooks of HMGA2 is suggested based on the suppression of backbone fragmentation and distribution of DNA-containing protein fragments.

Separation and Collision Cross Section Measurements of Protein Complexes Afforded by a Modular Drift Tube Coupled to an Orbitrap Mass Spectrometer

New developments in analytical technologies and biophysical methods have advanced the characterization of increasingly complex biomolecular assemblies using native mass spectrometry (MS). Ion mobility methods, in particular, have enabled a new dimension of structural information and analysis of proteins, allowing separation of conformations and providing size and shape insights based on collision cross sections (CCSs). Based on the concepts of absorption-mode Fourier transform (aFT) multiplexing ion mobility spectrometry (IMS), here, a modular drift tube design proves capable of separating native-like proteins up to 148 kDa with resolution up to 45. Coupled with high-resolution Orbitrap MS, binding of small ligands and cofactors can be resolved in the mass domain and correlated to changes in structural heterogeneity observed in the ion-neutral CCS distributions. We also demonstrate the ability to rapidly determine accurate CCSs for proteins with 1-min aFT-IMS-MS sweeps without the need for calibrants or correction factors.

Native Mass Spectrometry: Recent Progress and Remaining Challenges

Native mass spectrometry (nMS) has emerged as an important tool in studying the structure and function of macromolecules and their complexes in the gas phase. In this review, we cover recent advances in nMS and related techniques including sample preparation, instrumentation, activation methods, and data analysis software. These advances have enabled nMS-based techniques to address a variety of challenging questions in structural biology. The second half of this review highlights recent applications of these technologies and surveys the classes of complexes that can be studied with nMS. Complementarity of nMS to existing structural biology techniques and current challenges in nMS are also addressed.

Enhanced Ion Mobility Separation and Characterization of Isomeric Phosphatidylcholines Using Absorption Mode Fourier Transform Multiplexing and Ultraviolet Photodissociation Mass Spectrometry

The structural diversity of phospholipids plays a critical role in cellular membrane dynamics, energy storage, and cellular signaling. Despite its importance, the extent of this diversity has only recently come into focus, largely owing to advances in separation science and mass spectrometry methodology and instrumentation. Characterization of glycerophospholipid (GP) isomers differing only in their acyl chain configurations and locations of carbon-carbon double bonds (C═C) remains challenging due to the need for both effective separation of isomers and advanced tandem mass spectrometry (MS/MS) technologies capable of double-bond localization. Drift tube ion mobility spectrometry (DTIMS) coupled with MS can provide both fast separation and accurate determination of collision cross section (CCS) of molecules but typically lacks the resolving power needed to separate phospholipid isomers. Ultraviolet photodissociation (UVPD) can provide unambiguous double-bond localization but is challenging to implement on the timescales of modern commercial drift tube time-of-flight mass spectrometers. Here, we present a novel method for coupling DTIMS with a UVPD-enabled Orbitrap mass spectrometer using absorption mode Fourier transform multiplexing that affords simultaneous localization of double bonds and accurate CCS measurements even when isomers cannot be fully resolved in the mobility dimension. This method is demonstrated on two- and three-component mixtures and shown to provide CCS measurements that differ from those obtained by individual analysis of each component by less than 1%.

Synchronized Stepped Frequency Modulation for Multiplexed Ion Mobility Measurements

Implementation of frequency-encoded multiplexing for ion mobility spectrometry (e.g., Fourier transform ion mobility spectrometry (FT-IMS)) has facilitated the direct coupling of drift tube ion mobility instrumentation with ion-trap mass analyzers despite their duty cycle mismatch. Traditionally, FT-IMS experiments have been carried out to utilize continuous linear frequency sweeps that are independent of the scan rate of the ion-trap mass analyzer, thus creating a situation where multiple frequencies are swept over two sequential mass scans. This in turn creates a degree of ambiguity in which the ion current derived from a single modulation frequency cannot be assigned to a single data point in the frequency-modulated signal. In an effort to eliminate this ambiguity, this work describes a discrete stepwise function to modulate the ion gates of the IMS while synchronization between the generated frequencies and the scan rate of the linear ion trap is achieved. While the number of individual frequencies used in the stepped frequency sweeps is less than in continuous linear modulation experiments, there is no loss in performance and high levels of precision are maintained across differing combinations of terminal frequencies and scan lengths. Furthermore, the frequency-scan synchronization enables further data-processing techniques such as linear averaging of the frequency modulated signal to drastically improve signal-to-noise ratio for both high and low intensity analytes.

Recent technological developments for native mass spectrometry

Native mass spectrometry (MS), the analysis of proteins and protein complexes from solutions that stabilize native solution structures, is a rapidly expanding area. There is strong evidence supporting the retention of proteins' native folds in the absence of solvent under the experimental timescales of MS experiments. Therefore, instrumentation has been developed to use gas-phase native-like protein ions to exploit the speed, sensitivity, and selectivity of mass spectrometry approaches to solve emerging problems in structural biology. This article reviews some of the recent advances and applications in gas-phase instrumentation for structural proteomics.

Implementing Digital-Waveform Technology for Extended m/z Range Operation on a Native Dual-Quadrupole FT-IM-Orbitrap Mass Spectrometer

Here, we describe a digital-waveform dual-quadrupole mass spectrometer that enhances the performance of our drift tube FT-IMS high-resolution Orbitrap mass spectrometer (MS). The dual-quadrupole analyzer enhances the instrument capabilities for studies of large protein and protein complexes. The first quadrupole (q) provides a means for performing low-energy collisional activation of ions to reduce or eliminate noncovalent adducts, viz., salts, buffers, detergents, and/or endogenous ligands. The second quadrupole (Q) is used to mass-select ions of interest for further interrogation by ion mobility spectrometry and/or collision-induced dissociation (CID). Q is operated using digital-waveform technology (DWT) to improve the mass selection compared to that achieved using traditional sinusoidal waveforms at floated DC potentials (>500 V DC). DWT allows for increased precision of the waveform for a fraction of the cost of conventional RF drivers and with readily programmable operation and precision (Hoffman, N. M. . A comparison-based digital-waveform generator for high-resolution duty cycle. Review of Scientific Instruments 2018, 89, 084101).

Ion Mobility Spectrometry of Superheated Macromolecules at Electric Fields up to 500 Td

Since its inception in 1980s, differential or field asymmetric waveform ion mobility spectrometry (FAIMS) has been implemented at or near ambient gas pressure. We recently developed FAIMS at 15-30 Torr with mass spectrometry and utilized it to analyze amino acids, isomeric peptides, and protein conformers. The separations broadly mirrored those at atmospheric pressure, save for larger proteins that (as predicted) exhibited dipole alignment at ambient but not low pressure. Here we reduce the pressure down to 4.7 Torr, allowing normalized electric fields up to 543 Td-double the maximum in prior FAIMS or IMS studies of polyatomic ions. Despite the collisional heating to ∼1000 °C at the waveform peaks, the proteins of size from ubiquitin to albumin survived intact. The dissociation of macromolecules in FAIMS appears governed by the average ion temperature over the waveform cycle, unlike the isomerization controlled by the peak temperature. The global separation trends in this "superhot" regime extend those at moderately low pressures, with distinct conformers and no alignment as theorized. Although the scaling of the compensation voltage with the field fell below cubic at lower fields, the resolving power increased and the resolution of different proteins or charge states substantially improved.

Approaches to Heterogeneity in Native Mass Spectrometry

Native mass spectrometry (MS) is aimed at preserving and determining the native structure, composition, and stoichiometry of biomolecules and their complexes from solution after they are transferred into the gas phase. Major improvements in native MS instrumentation and experimental methods over the past few decades have led to a concomitant increase in the complexity and heterogeneity of samples that can be analyzed, including protein-ligand complexes, protein complexes with multiple coexisting stoichiometries, and membrane protein-lipid assemblies. Heterogeneous features of these biomolecular samples can be important for understanding structure and function. However, sample heterogeneity can make assignment of ion mass, charge, composition, and structure very challenging due to the overlap of tens or even hundreds of peaks in the mass spectrum. In this review, we cover data analysis, experimental, and instrumental advances and strategies aimed at solving this problem, with an in-depth discussion of theoretical and practical aspects of the use of available deconvolution algorithms and tools. We also reflect upon current challenges and provide a view of the future of this exciting field.

Separations of Carbohydrates with Noncovalent Shift Reagents by Frequency-Modulated Ion Mobility-Orbitrap Mass Spectrometry

An increased focus on characterizing the structural heterogeneity of carbohydrates has been driven by their many significant roles in extant life and potential roles in chemical evolution and the origin of life. In this work, multiplexed drift tube ion mobility-Orbitrap mass spectrometry methods were developed to analyze mixtures of disaccharides modified with noncovalent shift reagents. Since traditional coupling of atmospheric pressure drift tube ion mobility cells with Orbitrap mass analyzers suffers from low duty cycles (<0.1%), a frequency modulation scheme was applied to improve the signal-to-noise ratios (SNR). Several parameters such as the resolution setting and maximum injection time of the Orbitrap analyzer and the magnitude and duration of the frequency sweep were investigated for their impact on the sensitivity gains and resolution of disaccharide-shift reagent adducts. The sweep time and disaccharide concentration had a positive correlation with SNR. The magnitude of the frequency sweep had a negative correlation with SNR. However, increasing the frequency sweep improved the resolution of mixtures of disaccharide analytes. Application of frequency-modulated ion mobility-Orbitrap mass spectrometry to four noncovalently modified glucose dimers allowed for the differentiation of three out of these four analytes.

Protein-Small Molecule Interactions in Native Mass Spectrometry

Small molecule drug discovery has been propelled by the continual development of novel scientific methodologies to occasion therapeutic advances. Although established biophysical methods can be used to obtain information regarding the molecular mechanisms underlying drug action, these approaches are often inefficient, low throughput, and ineffective in the analysis of heterogeneous systems including dynamic oligomeric assemblies and proteins that have undergone extensive post-translational modification. Native mass spectrometry can be used to probe protein-small molecule interactions with unprecedented speed and sensitivity, providing unique insights into polydisperse biomolecular systems that are commonly encountered during the drug discovery process. In this review, we describe potential and proven applications of native MS in the study of interactions between small, drug-like molecules and proteins, including large multiprotein complexes and membrane proteins. Approaches to quantify the thermodynamic and kinetic properties of ligand binding are discussed, alongside a summary of gas-phase ion activation techniques that have been used to interrogate the structure of protein-small molecule complexes. We additionally highlight some of the key areas in modern drug design for which native mass spectrometry has elicited significant advances. Future developments and applications of native mass spectrometry in drug discovery workflows are identified, including potential pathways toward studying protein-small molecule interactions on a whole-proteome scale.

High-Resolution Native Mass Spectrometry

Native mass spectrometry (MS) involves the analysis and characterization of macromolecules, predominantly intact proteins and protein complexes, whereby as much as possible the native structural features of the analytes are retained. As such, native MS enables the study of secondary, tertiary, and even quaternary structure of proteins and other biomolecules. Native MS represents a relatively recent addition to the analytical toolbox of mass spectrometry and has over the past decade experienced immense growth, especially in enhancing sensitivity and resolving power but also in ease of use. With the advent of dedicated mass analyzers, sample preparation and separation approaches, targeted fragmentation techniques, and software solutions, the number of practitioners and novel applications has risen in both academia and industry. This review focuses on recent developments, particularly in high-resolution native MS, describing applications in the structural analysis of protein assemblies, proteoform profiling of—among others—biopharmaceuticals and plasma proteins, and quantitative and qualitative analysis of protein–ligand interactions, with the latter covering lipid, drug, and carbohydrate molecules, to name a few.

Absorption Mode Fourier Transform Ion Mobility Mass Spectrometry Multiplexing Combined with Half-Window Apodization Windows Improves Resolution and Shortens Acquisition Times

Fourier transform multiplexing enables the coupling of drift tube ion mobility to a wide array of mass spectrometers with improved ion utilization and duty cycles compared to dual-gate signal averaging methods. Traditionally, the data generated by this method is presented in the magnitude mode, but significant improvements in resolution and the signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) are expected if the data can be phase corrected and presented in the absorption mode. A method to simply and reliably determine and correct phase shifts in Fourier transform ion mobility mass spectrometry data using information readily available to any user is presented and evaluated for both small molecule and intact protein analyses with no modification to instrument hardware or experimental procedures. Additionally, the effects of apodization and zero padding are evaluated for both processing methods, and a strategy to use these techniques to reduce acquisition times is presented and evaluated. Resolution is improved by an average factor of 1.6, the SNR is improved by an average factor of 1.2, and acquisition times are reduced by up to 80% through the application of absorption mode processing combined with apodization and zero padding.

Variable-Temperature Electrospray Ionization for Temperature-Dependent Folding/Refolding Reactions of Proteins and Ligand Binding

Stabilities and structure(s) of proteins are directly coupled to their local environment or Gibbs free energy landscape as defined by solvent, temperature, pressure, and concentration. Solution pH, ionic strength, cofactors, chemical chaperones, and osmolytes perturb the chemical potential and induce further changes in structure, stability, and function. At present, no single analytical technique can monitor these effects in a single measurement. Mass spectrometry and ion mobility-mass spectrometry play increasingly essential roles in studies of proteins, protein complexes, and even membrane protein complexes; however, with few exceptions, the effects of the solution temperature on the stability and structure(s) of analytes have not been thoroughly investigated. Here, we describe a new variable-temperature electrospray ionization (vT-ESI) source that utilizes a thermoelectric chip to cool and heat the solution contained within the static ESI emitter. This design allows for solution temperatures to be varied from ∼5 to 98 °C with short equilibration times (<2 min) between precisely controlled temperature changes. The performance of the apparatus for vT-ESI-mass spectrometry and vT-ESI-ion mobility-mass spectrometry studies of cold- and heat-folding reactions is demonstrated using ubiquitin and frataxin. Instrument performance for studies on temperature-dependent ligand binding is shown using the chaperonin GroEL.

THE IMS PARADOX: A PERSPECTIVE ON STRUCTURAL ION MOBILITY-MASS SPECTROMETRY

Studies of large proteins, protein complexes, and membrane protein complexes pose new challenges, most notably the need for increased ion mobility (IM) and mass spectrometry (MS) resolution. This review covers evolutionary developments in IM-MS in the authors' and key collaborators' laboratories with specific focus on developments that enhance the utility of IM-MS for structural analysis. IM-MS measurements are performed on gas phase ions, thus "structural IM-MS" appears paradoxical-do gas phase ions retain their solution phase structure? There is growing evidence to support the notion that solution phase structure(s) can be retained by the gas phase ions. It should not go unnoticed that we use "structures" in this statement because an important feature of IM-MS is the ability to deal with conformationally heterogeneous systems, thus providing a direct measure of conformational entropy. The extension of this work to large proteins and protein complexes has motivated our development of Fourier-transform IM-MS instruments, a strategy first described by Hill and coworkers in 1985 (Anal Chem, 1985, 57, pp. 402-406) that has proved to be a game-changer in our quest to merge drift tube (DT) and ion mobility and the high mass resolution orbitrap MS instruments. DT-IMS is the only method that allows first-principles determinations of rotationally averaged collision cross sections (CSS), which is essential for studies of biomolecules where the conformational diversities of the molecule precludes the use of CCS calibration approaches. The Fourier transform-IM-orbitrap instrument described here also incorporates the full suite of native MS/IM-MS capabilities that are currently employed in the most advanced native MS/IM-MS instruments. © 2020 John Wiley & Sons Ltd. Mass Spec Rev.

Masked Multiplexed Separations to Enhance Duty Cycle for Structures for Lossless Ion Manipulations

The experimental paradigm of one ion packet release per spectrum severely hinders throughput in broadband ion mobility spectrometry (IMS) systems (e.g., drift tube and traveling wave systems). Ion trapping marginally mitigates this problem, but the duty cycle deficit is amplified when moving to high resolution, long pathlength systems. As a consequence, new multiplexing strategies that maximize throughput while preserving peak fidelity are essential for high-resolution IMS separations [e.g., structures for lossless ion manipulations (SLIMs) and multi-pass technologies]. Currently, broadly applicable deconvolution strategies for Hadamard-based ion multiplexing are limited to a narrow range of modulation sequences and do not fully maximize the ion signal generated during separation across an extended path length. Compared to prior Hadamard deconvolution errors that rely upon peak picking or discrete error classification, the masked deconvolution matrix technique exploits the knowledge that Hadamard transform artifacts are reflected about the central, primary signal [i.e., the true arrival time distribution (ATD)]. By randomly inducing mathematical artifacts, it is possible to identify spectral artifacts simply by their high degree of variability relative to the core ATD. It is important to note that the deweighting approach using the masked deconvolution matrix does not make any assumptions about the underlying transform and is applicable to any multiplexing strategy employing binary sequences. In addition to demonstrating a 100-fold increase in the total number of ions detected, the effective deconvolution of data from 5, 6, 7, and 8-bit pseudo-random sequences expands the utility and efficiency of the SLIM platform.

Development of Native MS Capabilities on an Extended Mass Range Q-TOF MS

Native mass spectrometry (nMS) is increasingly used for studies of large biomolecules (>100 kDa), especially proteins and protein complexes. The growth in this area can be attributed to advances in native electrospray ionization as well as instrumentation that is capable of accessing high mass-to-charge (m/z) regimes without significant losses in sensitivity and resolution. Here, we describe modifications to the ESI source of an Agilent 6545XT Q-TOF MS that is tailored for analysis of large biomolecules. The modified ESI source was evaluated using both soluble and membrane protein complexes ranging from ~127 to ~232 kDa and the ~801 kDa protein chaperone GroEL. The increased mass resolution of the instrument affords the ability to resolve small molecule adducts and analyze collision-induced dissociation products of the native complexes.

Metal- and Affinity-Specific Dual Labeling of Cysteine-Rich Proteins for Identification of Metal-Binding Sites

Here, using human metallothionein (MT2) as an example, we describe an improved strategy based on differential alkylation coupled to MS, assisted by zinc probe monitoring, for identification of cysteine-rich binding sites with nanomolar and picomolar metal affinity utilizing iodoacetamide (IAM) and N-ethylmaleimide reagents. We concluded that an SN2 reaction provided by IAM is more suitable to label free Cys residues, avoiding nonspecific metal dissociation. Afterward, metal-bound Cys can be easily labeled in a nucleophilic addition reaction after separation by reverse-phase C18 at acidic pH. Finally, we evaluated the efficiency of the method by mapping metal-binding sites of Zn7-xMT species using a bottom-up MS approach with respect to metal-to-protein affinity and element(al) resolution. The methodology presented might be applied not only for MT2 but to identify metal-binding sites in other Cys-containing proteins.

Selective regulation of human TRAAK channels by biologically active phospholipids

TRAAK is an ion channel from the two-pore domain potassium (K_2P) channel family with roles in maintaining the resting membrane potential and fast action potential conduction. Regulated by a wide range of physical and chemical stimuli, the affinity and selectivity of K_2P4.1 towards lipids remains poorly understood. Here we show the two isoforms of K_2P4.1 have distinct binding preferences for lipids dependent on acyl chain length and position on the glycerol backbone. Unexpectedly, the channel can also discriminate the fatty acid linkage at the sn-1 position. Of the 33 lipids interrogated using native mass spectrometry, phosphatidic acid (PA) had the lowest equilibrium dissociation constants for both isoforms of K_2P4.1. Liposome potassium flux assays with K_2P4.1 reconstituted in defined lipid environments show that those containing PA activate the channel in a dose-dependent fashion. Our results begin to define the molecular requirements for the specific binding of lipids to K_2P4.1.

THE USE OF MASS SPECTROMETRY TO STUDY ZN-METALLOPROTEASE-SUBSTRATE INTERACTIONS

Zinc metalloproteases (ZnMPs) participate in diverse biological reactions, encompassing the synthesis and degradation of all the major metabolites in living organisms. In particular, ZnMPs have been recognized to play a very important role in controlling the concentration level of several peptides and/or proteins whose homeostasis has to be finely regulated for the correct physiology of cells. Dyshomeostasis of aggregation-prone proteins causes pathological conditions and the development of several different diseases. For this reason, in recent years, many analytical approaches have been applied for studying the interaction between ZnMPs and their substrates and how environmental factors can affect enzyme activities. In this scenario, mass spectrometric methods occupy a very important role in elucidating different aspects of ZnMPs-substrates interaction. These range from identification of cleavage sites to quantitation of kinetic parameters. In this work, an overview of all the main achievements regarding the application of mass spectrometric methods to investigating ZnMPs-substrates interactions is presented. A general experimental protocol is also described which may prove useful to the study of similar interactions. © 2020 John Wiley & Sons Ltd. Mass Spec Rev.

First-Principles Collision Cross Section Measurements of Large Proteins and Protein Complexes

Rotationally averaged collision cross section (CCS) values for a series of proteins and protein complexes ranging in size from 8.6 to 810 kDa are reported. The CCSs were obtained using a native electrospray ionization drift tube ion mobility-Orbitrap mass spectrometer specifically designed to enhance sensitivity while having high-resolution ion mobility and mass capabilities. Periodic focusing (PF)-drift tube (DT)-ion mobility (IM) provides first-principles determination of the CCS of large biomolecules that can then be used as CCS calibrants. The experimental, first-principles CCS values are compared to previously reported experimentally determined and computationally calculated CCS using projected superposition approximation (PSA), the Ion Mobility Projection Approximation Calculation Tool (IMPACT), and Collidoscope. Experimental CCS values are generally in agreement with previously reported CCSs, with values falling within ∼5.5%. In addition, an ion mobility resolution (CCS centroid divided by CCS fwhm) of ∼60 is obtained for pyruvate kinase (MW ∼ 233 kDa); however, ion mobility resolution for bovine serum albumin (MW ∼ 68 kDa) is less than ∼20, which arises from sample impurities and underscores the importance of sample quality. The high resolution afforded by the ion mobility-Orbitrap mass analyzer provides new opportunities to understand the intricate details of protein complexes such as the impact of post-translational modifications (PTMs), stoichiometry, and conformational changes induced by ligand binding.

Discovery of Potent Charge-Reducing Molecules for Native Ion Mobility Mass Spectrometry Studies

There is growing interest in the characterization of protein complexes and their interactions with ligands using native ion mobility mass spectrometry. A particular challenge, especially for membrane proteins, is preserving noncovalent interactions and maintaining native-like structures. Different approaches have been developed to minimize activation of protein complexes by manipulating charge on protein complexes in solution and the gas-phase. Here, we report the utility of polyamines that have exceptionally high charge-reducing potencies with some molecules requiring 5-fold less than trimethylamine oxide to elicit the same effect. The charge-reducing molecules do not adduct to membrane protein complexes and are also compatible with ion-mobility mass spectrometry, paving the way for improved methods of charge reduction.

Molecular Mechanism of ISC Iron-Sulfur Cluster Biogenesis Revealed by High-Resolution Native Mass Spectrometry

Iron-sulfur (Fe-S) clusters are ubiquitous protein cofactors that are required for many important biological processes including oxidative respiration, nitrogen fixation, and photosynthesis. Biosynthetic pathways assemble Fe-S clusters with different iron-to-sulfur stoichiometries and distribute these clusters to appropriate apoproteins. In the ISC pathway, the pyridoxal 5'-phosphate-dependent cysteine desulfurase enzyme IscS provides sulfur to the scaffold protein IscU, which templates the Fe-S cluster assembly. Despite their functional importance, mechanistic details for cluster synthesis have remained elusive. Recent advances in native mass spectrometry (MS) have allowed proteins to be preserved in native-like structures and support applications in the investigation of protein structure, dynamics, ligand interactions, and the identification of protein-associated intermediates. Here, we prepared samples under anaerobic conditions and then applied native MS to investigate the molecular mechanism for Fe-S cluster synthesis. This approach was validated by the high agreement between native MS and traditional visible circular dichroism spectroscopic assays. Time-dependent native MS experiments revealed potential iron- and sulfur-based intermediates that decay as the [2Fe-2S] cluster signal developed. Additional experiments establish that (i) Zn(II) binding stabilizes IscU and protects the cysteine residues from oxidation, weakens the interactions between IscU and IscS, and inhibits Fe-S cluster biosynthesis; and (ii) Fe(II) ions bind to the IscU active site cysteine residues and another lower affinity binding site and promote the intermolecular sulfur transfer reaction from IscS to IscU. Overall, these results support an iron-first model for Fe-S cluster synthesis and highlight the power of native MS in defining protein-associated intermediates and elucidating mechanistic details of enzymatic processes.

Native IM-Orbitrap MS: Resolving What Was Hidden

Native ion mobility-mass spectrometry (IM-MS) is an emerging biophysical approach to probe the intricate details of protein structure and function. The instrument design enables measurements of accurate first-principle determinations of rotationally-averaged ion-neutral collision cross sections coupled with high-mass, high-resolution mass measurement capabilities of Orbitrap MS. The inherent duty-cycle mismatch between drift tube IM and Orbitrap MS is alleviated by operating the drift tube in a frequency modulated mode while continuously acquiring mass spectra with the Orbitrap MS. Fourier transform of the resulting time-domain signal, i.e., ion abundances as a function of the modulation frequency, yields a frequency domain spectrum that is then converted (s-1 to s) to IM drift time. This multiplexed approach allows for a duty-cycle of 25% compared to <1% for traditional "pulse-and-wait" IM-ToF-MS. Improvements in mobility and mass resolution of the IM-Orbitrap allows for accurate analysis of intact protein complexes and the possibility of capturing protein dynamics.

Facile Improvement of Negative Ion Mode Electrospray Ionization Using Capillary Vibrating Sharp-Edge Spray Ionization

Electrospray ionization (ESI) is often affected by corona discharge when spraying 100% aqueous solutions as the voltage that induces discharge can be well below the onset voltage of ESI. As a result, it is especially challenging to perform native mass spectrometry in negative ion mode where 100% aqueous solution is preferred. Here we report a simple instrumentation method to improve the performance of ESI in negative ion mode based on capillary vibrating sharp-edge spray ionization. By attaching a fused silica capillary emitter to a vibrating glass slide, improved signal quality is achieved for various analytes in aqueous solutions over applying ESI alone. Compared to commercial ESI sources using nebulization gas to reduce discharge, 10-100-fold enhancement in signal intensity and 3-10-fold improvement in S/N are achieved for various kinds of molecules including DNA, peptides, proteins, and oligosaccharides. Finally, the new method demonstrates utility for native mass spectrometry analysis of proteins and G-quadruplex DNA. The present method is expected to have great potential to be adopted by the scientific community because of its improved analytical performance, simplicity, and low cost.

Increased ion throughput using tristate ion-gate multiplexing

For time dispersive ion mobility experiments detail control over the mechanism of ion beam modulation is necessary to establish optimum performance as this parameter greatly influences the temporal width of the ion beam arriving at the detector. When sampling continuous ion sources the temporal sampling or the incoming ion beam is often achieved by the electronic modulation of a grid or electric field. Not surprisingly, the rate at which a given ion population traverses this gating region is directly proportional to an ion's population and the applied electric field. This scenario establishes conditions where discrimination of the incoming ion beam may occur when the ion gate modulation rate is minimized. Recent developments in the mechanical construction of ion gates and their subsequent operation suggest that the mobility discrimination during ion gating may be minimized, however, it is remains unclear how this behavior will translate to ion beam multiplexing approaches. In this present work, we compare the performance levels of the tri-state ion shutter (3S-IS) to the two-state ion shutter (2S-IS) using a series of Fourier transform ion mobility mass spectrometry (FT-IMMS) experiments. The performance of the two different shutter operating principles were evaluated using ion multiplexing using tetraalkylammonium salts (TXA ions; T5-T8, T10, T12) bradykinin, and a set of reversed sequence isomeric pentapeptides using a variety of different ion gate frequency sweeps. Noticeable increases in ion throughput were observed for the 3S-IS with 95% and 45% increases in ion counts for the T5 and T12 ions respectively compared to the 2S-IS. Similarly, a 27% and 55% increase in ion counts was observed for the [M + 2H]2+ and [M + H]+ ions of bradykinin, respectively. In addition, a 10% increase in resolving power was also observed for the 3S-IS compared to the 2S-IS. Overall, utilization of the 3S-IS effectively minimizes both discrimination of slower ions and the impact of gate depletion effect common to traditional ion gating techniques.

Ion Mobility Spectrometry: Fundamental Concepts, Instrumentation, Applications, and the Road Ahead

Ion mobility spectrometry (IMS) is a rapid separation technique that has experienced exponential growth as a field of study. Interfacing IMS with mass spectrometry (IMS-MS) provides additional analytical power as complementary separations from each technique enable multidimensional characterization of detected analytes. IMS separations occur on a millisecond timescale, and therefore can be readily nested into traditional GC and LC/MS workflows. However, the continual development of novel IMS methods has generated some level of confusion regarding the advantages and disadvantages of each. In this critical insight, we aim to clarify some common misconceptions for new users in the community pertaining to the fundamental concepts of the various IMS instrumental platforms (i.e., DTIMS, TWIMS, TIMS, FAIMS, and DMA), while addressing the strengths and shortcomings associated with each. Common IMS-MS applications are also discussed in this review, such as separating isomeric species, performing signal filtering for MS, and incorporating collision cross-section (CCS) values into both targeted and untargeted omics-based workflows as additional ion descriptors for chemical annotation. Although many challenges must be addressed by the IMS community before mobility information is collected in a routine fashion, the future is bright with possibilities.

Atmospheric Pressure Ultraviolet Laser Desorption and Ionization from Liquid Samples for Native Mass Spectrometry

Understanding protein structure is vital for evaluating protein interactions with drugs, proteins, and other ligands. Native mass spectrometry (MS) is proving to be invaluable for this purpose, enabling analysis of "native-like" samples that mimic physiological conditions. Native MS is usually performed by electrospray ionization (ESI) with its soft ionization processes and the generation of multiply charged ions proving favorable for conformation retention and high mass analysis, respectively. There is scope to expand the currently available toolset, specifically to other soft ionization techniques such as soft laser desorption, for applications in areas like high-throughput screening and MS imaging. In this Letter, observations made from native MS experiments using an ultraviolet (UV) laser-based ion source operating at atmospheric pressure are described. The ion source is capable of producing predominately multiply charged ions similar to ESI. Proteins and protein complexes were analyzed from a native-like sample droplet to investigate the technique. Ion mobility-mass spectrometry (IM-MS) measurements showed that folded protein conformations were detected for ions with low charge states. This observation indicates the source is suitable for native MS analysis and should be further developed for higher mass analysis in the future.

Integration of High-Resolution Mass Spectrometry with Cryogenic Ion Vibrational Spectroscopy

We describe an instrumental configuration for the structural characterization of fragment ions generated by collisional dissociation of peptide ions in the typical MS2 scheme widely used for peptide sequencing. Structures are determined by comparing the vibrational band patterns displayed by cryogenically cooled ions with calculated spectra for candidate structural isomers. These spectra were obtained in a linear action mode by photodissociation of weakly bound D2 molecules. This is accomplished by interfacing a Thermo Fisher Scientific Orbitrap Velos Pro to a cryogenic, triple focusing time-of-flight photofragmentation mass spectrometer (the Yale TOF spectrometer). The interface involves replacement of the Orbitrap's higher-energy collisional dissociation cell with a voltage-gated aperture that maintains the commercial instrument's standard capabilities while enabling bidirectional transfer of ions between the high-resolution FT analyzer and external ion sources. The performance of this hybrid instrument is demonstrated by its application to the a1, y1 and z1 fragment ions generated by CID of a prototypical dipeptide precursor, protonated L-phenylalanyl-L-tyrosine (H+-Phe-Tyr-OH or FY-H+). The structure of the unusual z1 ion, nominally formed after NH3 is ejected from the protonated tyrosine (y1) product, is identified as the cyclopropane-based product is tentatively identified as a cyclopropane-based product.