Structural Dynamic Heterogeneity of Polyubiquitin Subunits Affects Phosphorylation Susceptibility

Cyclization of ubiquitin chains reinforces their recognition by ZNF216

Lys48-linked ubiquitin chains, regulating proteasomal protein degradation, are known to include cyclized forms. This cyclization hinders recognition by many downstream proteins by occluding the Ile44-centered patch. In contrast, the A20-like Znf domain of ZNF216 (a ubiquitin-binding protein, A20 Znf) is expected to bind to cyclic ubiquitin chains via constitutively solvent-exposed surfaces. However, the underlying interaction mechanism remains unclear. Here, our ITC and NMR experiments collectively showed that cyclization did not interfere with and even slightly enhance the molecular recognition of diubiquitin by A20 Znf. This effect is explained by the cyclization-induced repression of conformational dynamics in diubiquitin and an enlarged molecular interface in the complex. Thus, these results suggest that cyclic ubiquitin chains can be involved in regulation of ZNF216-dependent proteasomal protein degradation.

An integrated approach of NMR experiments and MD simulations visualizes structural dynamics of a cyclic multi-domain protein

Cyclization can stabilize the structure of proteins, as previously demonstrated in single-domain proteins. Although Lys48-linked polyubiquitin, a multi-domain protein, is also known to be cyclized in human cells, the structural effects of cyclization remain unclear. Here, we examined the impact of cyclization on the structural stability and dynamics of cyclic Lys48-linked diubiquitin (Ub2 ). As expected, cyclization increased the thermal stability of Ub2 and its resistance to proteolytic digestion, indicating that cyclization stabilized the structure of Ub2 . Furthermore, cyclization repressed the interdomain motion in Ub2 , but cyclic Ub2 still exhibited microsecond conformational exchange in NMR relaxation dispersion experiments. A series of long coarse-grained (CG) MD simulations visualized how cyclization slowed down the intrinsic nanosecond open-closed domain motion of Ub2 to microseconds. Thus, CG-MD analysis helped to explain the unexpected NMR relaxation results, thereby facilitating characterization of the structural stabilization of cyclic Ub2 .

Solution structure of the HOIL-1L NZF domain reveals a conformational switch regulating linear ubiquitin affinity

Attachment of polyubiquitin (poly-Ub) chains to proteins is a major posttranslational modification in eukaryotes. Linear ubiquitin chain assembly complex, consisting of HOIP (HOIL-1-interacting protein), HOIL-1L (heme-oxidized IRP2 Ub ligase 1), and SHARPIN (Shank-associated RH domain-interacting protein), specifically synthesizes "head-to-tail" poly-Ub chains, which are linked via the N-terminal methionine α-amino and C-terminal carboxylate of adjacent Ub units and are thus commonly called "linear" poly-Ub chains. Linear ubiquitin chain assembly complex-assembled linear poly-Ub chains play key roles in immune signaling and suppression of cell death and have been associated with immune diseases and cancer; HOIL-1L is one of the proteins known to selectively bind linear poly-Ub via its Npl4 zinc finger (NZF) domain. Although the structure of the bound form of the HOIL-1L NZF domain with linear di-Ub is known, several aspects of the recognition specificity remain unexplained. Here, we show using NMR and orthogonal biophysical methods, how the NZF domain evolves from a free to the specific linear di-Ub-bound state while rejecting other potential Ub species after weak initial binding. The solution structure of the free NZF domain revealed changes in conformational stability upon linear Ub binding, and interactions between the NZF core and tail revealed conserved electrostatic contacts, which were sensitive to charge modulation at a reported phosphorylation site: threonine-207. Phosphomimetic mutations reduced linear Ub affinity by weakening the integrity of the linear di-Ub-bound conformation. The described molecular determinants of linear di-Ub binding provide insight into the dynamic aspects of the Ub code and the NZF domain's role in full-length HOIL-1L.

Molecular recognition and deubiquitination of cyclic K48-linked ubiquitin chains by OTUB1

Conjugation of K48-linked ubiquitin chains to intracellular proteins mainly functions as a signal for proteasomal degradation. The conjugating enzyme E2-25K synthesizes not only canonical (noncyclic) but also cyclic K48-linked ubiquitin chains. Although the cyclic conformation is expected to repress molecular recognition by ubiquitin binding proteins due to restricting the flexibility of the ubiquitin subunits in a chain, multiple proteins are reported to associate with cyclic ubiquitin chains similar to noncyclic chains. However, the molecular mechanism of how cyclic ubiquitin chains are recognized remains unclear. Here we investigated the effect of cyclization on ubiquitin-chain cleavage and molecular recognition by a K48-linkage specific deubiquitinating enzyme OTUB1 for cyclic diubiquitin by NMR spectroscopic analyses. Compared to noncyclic diubiquitin, we observed slow but unambiguously detectable cleavage of cyclic diubiquitin to monoubiquitin by OTUB1. Intriguingly, upon ubiquitin chain cleavage, cyclic diubiquitin appeared to alter its "autoinhibited" conformation to an incompletely but partially accessible conformation, induced by interaction with OTUB1 via the ubiquitin-subunit specific recognition patches and adjacent surfaces. These data imply that cyclic ubiquitin chains may exist stably in cells in spite of the presence of deubiquitinating enzymes and that these chains can be recognized by intracellular proteins in a manner distinct from that of noncyclic ubiquitin chains.