Strategies to Control or Mimic Growth Factor Activity for Bone, Cartilage, and Osteochondral Tissue Engineering

Harnessing Peptide-Based Hydrogels for Enhanced Cartilage Tissue Engineering

Cartilage tissue engineering remains a formidable challenge due to its complex, avascular structure and limited regenerative capacity. Traditional approaches, such as microfracture, autografts, and stem cell delivery, often fail to restore functional tissue adequately. Recently, there has been a surge in the exploration of new materials that mimic the extracellular microenvironment necessary to guide tissue regeneration. This review investigates the potential of peptide-based hydrogels as an innovative solution for cartilage regeneration. These hydrogels, formed via supramolecular self-assembly, exhibit excellent properties, including biocompatibility, ECM mimicry, and controlled biodegradation, making them highly suitable for cartilage tissue engineering. This review explains the structure of cartilage and the principles of supramolecular and peptide hydrogels. It also delves into their specific properties relevant to cartilage regeneration. Additionally, this review presents recent examples and a comparative analysis of various peptide-based hydrogels used for cartilage regeneration. The review also addresses the translational challenges of these materials, highlighting regulatory hurdles and the complexities of clinical application. This comprehensive investigation provides valuable insights for biomedical researchers, tissue engineers, and clinical professionals aiming to enhance cartilage repair methodologies.

Collagen patches releasing phosphatidylserine liposomes guide M1-to-M2 macrophage polarization and accelerate simultaneous bone and muscle healing

Bilateral communication between bones and muscles is essential for healing composite bone-muscle injuries from orthopedic surgeries and trauma. However, these injuries are often characterized by exaggerated inflammation, which can disrupt bone-muscle crosstalk, thereby seriously delaying the healing of either tissue. Existing approaches are largely effective at healing single tissues. However, simultaneous healing of multiple tissues remains challenging, with little research conducted to date. Here we introduce collagen patches that overcome this overlooked issue by harnessing the plasticity of macrophage phenotypes. Phosphatidylserine liposomes (PSLs) capable of shifting the macrophage phenotype from inflammatory M1 into anti-inflammatory/prohealing M2 were coated on collagen patches via a layer-by-layer method. Original collagen patches failed to improve tissue healing under inflammatory conditions coordinated by M1 macrophages. In contrast, PSL-coated collagen patches succeeded in accelerating bone and muscle healing by inducing a microenvironment dominated by M2 macrophages. In cell experiments, differentiation of preosteoblasts and myoblasts was completely inhibited by secretions of M1 macrophages but unaffected by those of M2 macrophages. RNA-seq analysis revealed that type I interferon and interleukin-6 signaling pathways were commonly upregulated in preosteoblasts and myoblasts upon stimulation with M1 macrophage secretions, thereby compromising their differentiation. This study demonstrates the benefit of PSL-mediated M1-to-M2 macrophage polarization for simultaneous bone and muscle healing, offering a potential strategy toward simultaneous regeneration of multiple tissues. STATEMENT OF SIGNIFICANCE: Existing approaches for tissue regeneration, which primarily utilize growth factors, have been largely effective at healing single tissues. However, simultaneous healing of multiple tissues remains challenging and has been little studied. Here we demonstrate that collagen patches releasing phosphatidylserine liposomes (PSLs) promote M1-to-M2 macrophage polarization and are effective for simultaneous healing of bone and muscle. Transcriptome analysis using next-generation sequencing reveals that differentiation of preosteoblasts and myoblasts is inhibited by the secretions of M1 macrophages but promoted by those of M2 macrophages, highlighting the importance of timely regulation of M1-to-M2 polarization in tissue regeneration. These findings provide new insight to tissue healing of multiple tissues.

Quantifying and Controlling the Proteolytic Degradation of Cell Adhesion Peptides

Peptides are widely used within biomaterials to improve cell adhesion, incorporate bioactive ligands, and enable cell-mediated degradation of the matrix. While many of the peptides incorporated into biomaterials are intended to be present throughout the life of the material, their stability is not typically quantified during culture. In this work, we designed a series of peptide libraries containing four different N-terminal peptide functionalizations and three C-terminal functionalizations to better understand how simple modifications can be used to reduce the nonspecific degradation of peptides. We tested these libraries with three cell types commonly used in biomaterials research, including mesenchymal stem/stromal cells (hMSCs), endothelial cells, and macrophages, and quantified how these cell types nonspecifically degraded peptides as a function of terminal amino acid and chemistry. We found that peptides in solution which contained N-terminal amines were almost entirely degraded by 48 h, irrespective of the terminal amino acid, and that degradation occurred even at high peptide concentrations. Peptides with C-terminal carboxylic acids also had significant degradation when cultured with the cells. We found that simple modifications to the termini could significantly reduce or completely abolish nonspecific degradation when soluble peptides were added to cells cultured on tissue culture plastic or within hydrogel matrices, and that functionalizations which mimicked peptide conjugations to hydrogel matrices significantly slowed nonspecific degradation. We also found that there were minimal differences in peptide degradation across cell donors and that sequences mimicking different peptides commonly used to functionalize biomaterials all had significant nonspecific degradation. Finally, we saw that there was a positive trend between RGD stability and hMSC spreading within hydrogels, indicating that improving the stability of peptides within biomaterial matrices may improve the performance of engineered matrices.

Supramolecular Motion Enables Chondrogenic Bioactivity of a Cyclic Peptide Mimetic of Transforming Growth Factor-β1

Transforming growth factor (TGF)-β1 is a multifunctional protein that is essential in many cellular processes that include fibrosis, inflammation, chondrogenesis, and cartilage repair. In particular, cartilage repair is important to avoid physical disability since this tissue does not have the inherent capacity to regenerate beyond full development. We report here on supramolecular coassemblies of two peptide amphiphile molecules, one containing a TGF-β1 mimetic peptide, and another which is one of two constitutional isomers lacking bioactivity. Using human articular chondrocytes, we investigated the bioactivity of the supramolecular copolymers of each isomer displaying either the previously reported linear form of the mimetic peptide or a novel cyclic analogue. Based on fluorescence depolarization and 1H NMR spin-lattice relaxation times, we found that coassemblies containing the cyclic compound and the most dynamic isomer exhibited the highest intracellular TGF-β1 signaling and gene expression of cartilage extracellular matrix components. We conclude that control of supramolecular motion is emerging as an important factor in the binding of synthetic molecules to receptors that can be tuned through chemical structure.

An Acellular, Self-Healed Trilayer Cryogel for Osteochondral Regeneration in Rabbits

Osteochondral regeneration remains formidable challenges despite significant advances in microsurgery. Herein, an acellular trilayer cryogel (TC) with injectability, tunable pore sizes (80-200 µm), and appropriate compressive modulus (10.8 kPa) is manufactured from self-healable hydrogel under different gelling times through Schiff reaction between chitosan and difunctionalized polyurethane (DFPU). Bioactive molecules (Y27632 and dexamethasone) are respectively loaded in the top and bottom layers to form the Y27632/dexamethasone-loaded trilayer cryogel (Y/DEX-TC). Mesenchymal stem cells (MSCs) seeded in Y/DEX-TC proliferated ≈350% in vitro and underwent chondrogenesis or osteogenesis in response to the respective release of Y or DEX in 14 days. Acupuncture is administered to animals in an attempt to modulate the innate regulatory system and mobilize endogenous MSCs for osteochondral defect regeneration. In vivo rabbit experiments using Y/DEX-TC combined with acupuncture successfully regulate SDF-1 and TGF-β1 levels, which possibly cause MSC migration toward Y/DEX-TC. The synergistic effect of cryogel and acupuncture on immunomodulation is verified with a ≈7.3-fold enhancement of the M2-/M1-macrophage population ratio by treatment of Y/DEX-TC combining acupuncture, significantly greater than ≈1.5-fold increase by acupuncture or ≈2.2-fold increase by Y/DEX-TC alone. This novel strategy using acellular drug-loaded cryogel and accessible acupuncture shows promise in treating osteochondral defects of joint damage.

Polydopamine-modified konjac glucomannan scaffold with sustained release of vascular endothelial growth factor to promote angiogenesis

The fabrication of scaffolds capable of the sustained release of the vascular endothelial growth factor (VEGF) to promote angiogenesis for a long time remains a challenge in tissue engineering. Here, we report a facile approach for effectively fabricating a bioactive scaffold that gradually releases VEGF to promote angiogenesis. The scaffold was fabricated by coating polydopamine (PDA) on a konjac glucomannan (KGM) scaffold, followed by the surface immobilization of VEGF with PDA. The resulting VEGF-PDA/KGM scaffold, with a porous and interconnected microstructure (392 μm pore size with 84.80 porosity), combined the features of long-term biodegradability (10 weeks with 51 % degradation rate), excellent biocompatibility, and sustained VEGF release for up to 21 days. The bioactive VEGF-PDA/KGM scaffold exhibited multiple angiogenic activities over time, as confirmed by in vivo and in vitro experiments. For example, the scaffold significantly promoted the attachment and proliferation of human umbilical vein endothelial cells and the formation of vascular tubes in vitro. Moreover, the in vivo results demonstrated the formation and maturation of blood vessels after subcutaneous implantation in rats for four weeks. This promising strategy is a feasible approach for producing bioactive materials that can induce angiogenesis in vivo. These findings provide a new avenue for designing and fabricating biocompatible and long-term biodegradable scaffolds for sustained VEGF release to facilitate angiogenesis.

Essential elements for spatiotemporal delivery of growth factors within bio-scaffolds: A comprehensive strategy for enhanced tissue regeneration

The precise delivery of growth factors (GFs) in regenerative medicine is crucial for effective tissue regeneration and wound repair. However, challenges in achieving controlled release, such as limited half-life, potential overdosing risks, and delivery control complexities, currently hinder their clinical implementation. Despite the plethora of studies endeavoring to accomplish effective loading and gradual release of GFs through diverse delivery methods, the nuanced control of spatial and temporal delivery still needs to be elucidated. In response to this pressing clinical imperative, our review predominantly focuses on explaining the prevalent strategies employed for spatiotemporal delivery of GFs over the past five years. This review will systematically summarize critical aspects of spatiotemporal GFs delivery, including judicious bio-scaffold selection, innovative loading techniques, optimization of GFs activity retention, and stimulating responsive release mechanisms. It aims to identify the persisting challenges in spatiotemporal GFs delivery strategies and offer an insightful outlook on their future development. The ultimate objective is to provide an invaluable reference for advancing regenerative medicine and tissue engineering applications.

Neuro-bone tissue engineering: emerging mechanisms, potential strategies, and current challenges

The skeleton is a highly innervated organ in which nerve fibers interact with various skeletal cells. Peripheral nerve endings release neurogenic factors and sense skeletal signals, which mediate bone metabolism and skeletal pain. In recent years, bone tissue engineering has increasingly focused on the effects of the nervous system on bone regeneration. Simultaneous regeneration of bone and nerves through the use of materials or by the enhancement of endogenous neurogenic repair signals has been proven to promote functional bone regeneration. Additionally, emerging information on the mechanisms of skeletal interoception and the central nervous system regulation of bone homeostasis provide an opportunity for advancing biomaterials. However, comprehensive reviews of this topic are lacking. Therefore, this review provides an overview of the relationship between nerves and bone regeneration, focusing on tissue engineering applications. We discuss novel regulatory mechanisms and explore innovative approaches based on nerve-bone interactions for bone regeneration. Finally, the challenges and future prospects of this field are briefly discussed.

Covalent binding modes between BMP-2-derived peptides and graphene in 3D scaffolds determine their osteoinductivity and capacity for calvarial defect repair in vivo

Covalent introduction of bioactive molecules is one of main strategies to significantly enhance the biological activities of bone repair materials. In this study, three most-commonly used chemical groups were respectively introduced on graphene (GP), followed by covalent binding with bone morphogenetic protein-2 (BMP-2) -derived peptides, ensuring that the same molar mass of peptides was bound to different functionalized GP (f-GP). Then the same amount of composites composed of different f-GP and peptides were respectively compounded with poly (lactic-co-glycolic acid) to fabricate 3D scaffolds. In vivo study demonstrated that the scaffolds containing ammonized GP covalently bound with the peptides through amide binding could reach best efficiency of promoting ectopic bone regeneration and repairing calvarial defect probably because the most positive charges on the peptide chain and surface of the ammonized GP could absorb more specific proteins in vivo and have better interactions with them, thereby differentiating most inducible cells into osteogenic cells. Our results indicate that the performances of scaffolds containing covalently bound bioactive molecules can be controlled by the covalent binding mode, and that our prepared scaffold containing ammonized GP covalently bound with the BMP-2-derived peptides through amide binding possess inspiring potential applicable prospects for bone tissue regeneration and engineering.

Designed peptide amphiphiles as scaffolds for tissue engineering

Peptide amphiphiles (PAs) are peptide-based molecules that contain a peptide sequence as a head group covalently conjugated to a hydrophobic segment, such as lipid tails. They can self-assemble into well-ordered supramolecular nanostructures such as micelles, vesicles, twisted ribbons and nanofibers. In addition, the diversity of natural amino acids gives the possibility to produce PAs with different sequences. These properties along with their biocompatibility, biodegradability and a high resemblance to native extracellular matrix (ECM) have resulted in PAs being considered as ideal scaffold materials for tissue engineering (TE) applications. This review introduces the 20 natural canonical amino acids as building blocks followed by highlighting the three categories of PAs: amphiphilic peptides, lipidated peptide amphiphiles and supramolecular peptide amphiphile conjugates, as well as their design rules that dictate the peptide self-assembly process. Furthermore, 3D bio-fabrication strategies of PAs hydrogels are discussed and the recent advances of PA-based scaffolds in TE with the emphasis on bone, cartilage and neural tissue regeneration both in vitro and in vivo are considered. Finally, future prospects and challenges are discussed.

Biodegradable and Non-Biodegradable Biomaterials and Their Effect on Cell Differentiation

Biomaterials for tissue scaffolds are key components in modern tissue engineering and regenerative medicine. Targeted reconstructive therapies require a proper choice of biomaterial and an adequate choice of cells to be seeded on it. The introduction of stem cells, and the transdifferentiation procedures, into regenerative medicine opened a new era and created new challenges for modern biomaterials. They must not only fulfill the mechanical functions of a scaffold for implanted cells and represent the expected mechanical strength of the artificial tissue, but furthermore, they should also assure their survival and, if possible, affect their desired way of differentiation. This paper aims to review how modern biomaterials, including synthetic (i.e., polylactic acid, polyurethane, polyvinyl alcohol, polyethylene terephthalate, ceramics) and natural (i.e., silk fibroin, decellularized scaffolds), both non-biodegradable and biodegradable, could influence (tissue) stem cells fate, regulate and direct their differentiation into desired target somatic cells.

Functionalized 3D-Printed ST2/Gelatin Methacryloyl/Polcaprolactone Scaffolds for Enhancing Bone Regeneration with Vascularization

Growth factors were often used to improve the bioactivity of biomaterials in order to fabricate biofunctionalized bone grafts for bone defect repair. However, supraphysiological concentrations of growth factors for improving bioactivity could lead to serious side effects, such as ectopic bone formation, radiculitis, swelling of soft tissue in the neck, etc. Therefore, safely and effectively applying growth factors in bone repair biomaterials comes to be an urgent problem that needs to be addressed. In this study, an appropriate concentration (50 ng/mL) of Wnt3a was used to pretreat the 3D-bioprinting gelatin methacryloyl(GelMA)/polycaprolactone(PCL) scaffold loaded with bone marrow stromal cell line ST2 for 24 h. This pretreatment promoted the cell proliferation, osteogenic differentiation, and mineralization of ST2 in the scaffold in vitro, and enhanced angiogenesis and osteogenesis after being implanted in critical-sized mouse calvarial defects. On the contrary, the inhibition of Wnt/β-catenin signaling in ST2 cells reduced the bone repair effect of this scaffold. These results suggested that ST2/GelMA/PCL scaffolds pretreated with an appropriate concentration of Wnt3a in culture medium could effectively enhance the osteogenic and angiogenic activity of bone repair biomaterials both in vitro and in vivo. Moreover, it would avoid the side effects caused by the supraphysiological concentrations of growth factors. This functionalized scaffold with osteogenic and angiogenic activity might be used as an outstanding bone substitute for bone regeneration and repair.

Progress of Platelet Derivatives for Cartilage Tissue Engineering

Articular cartilage has limited self-regeneration ability for lacking of blood vessels, nerves, and lymph that makes it a great challenge to repair defects of the tissue and restore motor functions of the injured or aging population. Platelet derivatives, such as platelet-rich plasma, have been proved effective, safe, and economical in musculoskeletal diseases for their autologous origin and rich in growth factors. The combination of platelet derivatives with biomaterials provides both mechanical support and localized sustained release of bioactive molecules in cartilage tissue engineering and low-cost efficient approaches of potential treatment. In this review, we first provide an overview of platelet derivatives and their application in clinical and experimental therapies, and then we further discuss the techniques of the addition of platelet derivatives and their influences on scaffold properties. Advances in cartilage tissue engineering with platelet derivatives as signal factors and structural components are also introduced before prospects and concerns in this research field. In short, platelet derivatives have broad application prospects as an economical and effective enhancement for tissue engineering–based articular cartilage repair.

Engineering Extracellular Microenvironment for Tissue Regeneration

The extracellular microenvironment is a highly dynamic network of biophysical and biochemical elements, which surrounds cells and transmits molecular signals. Extracellular microenvironment controls are of crucial importance for the ability to direct cell behavior and tissue regeneration. In this review, we focus on the different components of the extracellular microenvironment, such as extracellular matrix (ECM), extracellular vesicles (EVs) and growth factors (GFs), and introduce engineering approaches for these components, which can be used to achieve a higher degree of control over cellular activities and behaviors for tissue regeneration. Furthermore, we review the technologies established to engineer native-mimicking artificial components of the extracellular microenvironment for improved regenerative applications. This review presents a thorough analysis of the current research in extracellular microenvironment engineering and monitoring, which will facilitate the development of innovative tissue engineering strategies by utilizing different components of the extracellular microenvironment for regenerative medicine in the future.

Growth Factor Immobilization Strategies for Musculoskeletal Disorders

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

Tissue regenerative solutions for musculoskeletal disorders have become increasingly important with a growing aged population. Current growth factor treatments often require high dosages with the potential for off-target effects. Growth factor immobilization strategies offer approaches towards alleviating these concerns. This review summarizes current growth factor immobilization techniques (encapsulation, affinity interactions, and covalent binding) and the effects of immobilization on growth factor loading, release, and bioactivity.

RECENT FINDINGS

The breadth of immobilization techniques based on encapsulation, affinity, and covalent binding offer multiple methods to improve the therapeutic efficacy of growth factors by controlling bioactivity and release. Growth factor immobilization strategies have evolved to more complex systems with the capacity to load and release multiple growth factors with spatiotemporal control. The advancements in immobilization strategies allow for development of new, complex musculoskeletal tissue treatment strategies with improved spatiotemporal control of loading, release, and bioactivity.

Core-shell bioprinting as a strategy to apply differentiation factors in a spatially defined manner inside osteochondral tissue substitutes

One of the key challenges in osteochondral tissue engineering is to define specified zones with varying material properties, cell types and biochemical factors supporting locally adjusted differentiation into the osteogenic and chondrogenic lineage, respectively. Herein, extrusion-based core-shell bioprinting is introduced as a potent tool allowing a spatially defined delivery of cell types and differentiation factors TGF-β3 and BMP-2 in separated compartments of hydrogel strands, and, therefore, a local supply of matching factors for chondrocytes and osteoblasts. Ink development was based on blends of alginate and methylcellulose, in combination with varying concentrations of the nanoclay Laponite whose high affinity binding capacity for various molecules was exploited. Release kinetics of model molecules was successfully tuned by Laponite addition. Core-shell bioprinting was proven to generate well-oriented compartments within one strand as monitored by optical coherence tomography in a non-invasive manner. Chondrocytes and osteoblasts were applied each in the shell while the respective differentiation factors (TGF-β3, BMP-2) were provided by a Laponite-supported core serving as central factor depot within the strand, allowing directed differentiation of cells in close contact to the core. Experiments with bi-zonal constructs, comprising an osteogenic and a chondrogenic zone, revealed that the local delivery of the factors from the core reduces effects of these factors on the cells in the other scaffold zone. These observations prove the general suitability of the suggested system for co-differentiation of different cell types within a zonal construct.

Enhanced efficacy of transforming growth factor-β1 loaded an injectable cross-linked thiolated chitosan and carboxymethyl cellulose-based hydrogels for cartilage tissue engineering

Growth factors (GFs) are soluble proteins extracellular that control a wide range of cellular processes as well as tissue regeneration. While transforming growth factor beta-1 (TGF-β1) promotes chondrogenesis, its medical use is restricted by its potential protein instability, which necessitates high doses of the protein, which can result in adverse side effects such as inefficient cartilage formation. In this work, we have developed a novel hydrogel composite based on the polymer, cross-linked thiolated chitosan; TCS and carboxymethyl cellulose; CMC (TCS/CMC) hydrogel system was utilized as injectable TGF-β1 carriers for cartilage tissue engineering applications. Rheological measurements showed that the elastic modulus of TCS/CMC hydrogels with an optimized CMC concentration could reach around 2.5 kPa or higher than their respective viscous modulus, indicating that they behaved like strong hydrogels. Crosslinking significantly alters the overall network distribution, surface morphology, pore size, porosity, gelation time, swelling ratio, water content, and in vitro degradation of the TCS/CMC hydrogels. TCS/CMC hydrogels maintain more than 90% of their weight and retain their original form after 21 days. TGF-β1 released marginally from TCS/CMC hydrogels as incubation time increased, up to 21 days, with around 18.6 ± 0.9% of the drug stored inside the TCS/CMC hydrogels. On day 21, BMSC treated with TGF-β1 in medium or TGF-β1-loaded TCS/CMC hydrogels grew faster than the other groups. For in vivo cartilage repair, full-thickness cartilage defects were induced on rat knees for 8 weeks. The optimal ability of this novel TGF-β1-loaded TCS/CMC hydrogel system was further demonstrated by histological analysis, resulting in a novel therapeutic strategy for repairing articular cartilage defects.Research HighlightsAn in situ forming and injectable thiolated chitosan and carboxymethyl cellulose hydrogel was fabricated for cartilage tissue engineering.TCS/CMC displays suitable gelation time with high swelling ratio, tunable mechanical properties and highly porous.TGF-β1-loaded-TCS/CMC hydrogels showed maximum drug release activity.TGF-β1-loaded-TCS/CMC hydrogels had good biocompatibility to articular chondrocytes.An injectable TCS/CMC/TGF-β1 hydrogel is a promising material system for cartilage tissue engineering.