Assessing the Potential of Folded Globular Polyproteins As Hydrogel Building Blocks

Competition between cross-linking and force-induced local conformational changes determines the structure and mechanics of labile protein networks

Folded protein hydrogels are emerging as promising new materials for medicine and healthcare applications. Folded globular proteins can be modelled as colloids which exhibit site specific cross-linking for controlled network formation. However, folded proteins have inherent mechanical stability and unfolded in response to an applied force. It is not yet understood how colloidal network theory maps onto folded protein hydrogels and whether it models the impact of protein unfolding on network properties. To address this, we study a hybrid system which contains folded proteins (patchy colloids) and unfolded proteins (biopolymers). We use a model protein, bovine serum albumin (BSA), to explore network architecture and mechanics in folded protein hydrogels. We alter both the photo-chemical cross-linking reaction rate and the mechanical properties of the protein building block, via illumination intensity and redox removal of robust intra-protein covalent bonds, respectively. This dual approach, in conjunction with rheological and structural techniques, allows us to show that while reaction rate can 'fine-tune' the mechanical and structural properties of protein hydrogels, it is the force-lability of the protein which has the greatest impact on network architecture and rigidity. To understand these results, we consider a colloidal model which successfully describes the behaviour of the folded protein hydrogels but cannot account for the behaviour observed in force-labile hydrogels containing unfolded protein. Alternative models are needed which combine the properties of colloids (folded proteins) and biopolymers (unfolded proteins) in cross-linked networks. This work provides important insights into the accessible design space of folded protein hydrogels without the need for complex and costly protein engineering, aiding the development of protein-based biomaterials.

Toward Tunable Protein-Driven Hydrogel Lens

Despite the significant progress in protein-based materials, creating a tunable protein-activated hydrogel lens remains an elusive goal. This study leverages the synergistic relationship between protein structural dynamics and polymer hydrogel engineering to introduce a highly transparent protein-polymer actuator. By incorporating bovine serum albumin into polyethyleneglycol diacrylate hydrogels, the authors achieved enhanced light transmittance and conferred actuating capabilities to the hydrogel. Taking advantage of these features, a bilayer protein-driven hydrogel lens that dynamically modifies its focal length in response to pH changes, mimicking the adaptability of the human lens, is fabricated. The lens demonstrates durability and reproducibility, highlighting its potential for repetitive applications. This integration of protein-diverse biochemistry, folding nanomechanics, and polymer engineering opens up new avenues for harnessing the wide range of proteins to potentially propel various fields such as diagnostics, lab-on-chip, and deep-tissue bio-optics, advancing the understanding of incorporating biomaterials in the optical field.

Building block aspect ratio controls assembly, architecture, and mechanics of synthetic and natural protein networks

Fibrous networks constructed from high aspect ratio protein building blocks are ubiquitous in nature. Despite this ubiquity, the functional advantage of such building blocks over globular proteins is not understood. To answer this question, we engineered hydrogel network building blocks with varying numbers of protein L domains to control the aspect ratio. The mechanical and structural properties of photochemically crosslinked protein L networks were then characterised using shear rheology and small angle neutron scattering. We show that aspect ratio is a crucial property that defines network architecture and mechanics, by shifting the formation from translationally diffusion dominated to rotationally diffusion dominated. Additionally, we demonstrate that a similar transition is observed in the model living system: fibrin blood clot networks. The functional advantages of this transition are increased mechanical strength and the rapid assembly of homogenous networks above a critical protein concentration, crucial for in vivo biological processes such as blood clotting. In addition, manipulating aspect ratio also provides a parameter in the design of future bio-mimetic and bio-inspired materials.

Diversity of viscoelastic properties of an engineered muscle-inspired protein hydrogel

Folded protein hydrogels are prime candidates as tuneable biomaterials but it is unclear to what extent their mechanical properties have mesoscopic, as opposed to molecular origins. To address this, we probe hydrogels inspired by the muscle protein titin and engineered to the polyprotein I27₅, using a multimodal rheology approach. Across multiple protocols, the hydrogels consistently exhibit power-law viscoelasticity in the linear viscoelastic regime with an exponent β = 0.03, suggesting a dense fractal meso-structure, with predicted fractal dimension d_f = 2.48. In the nonlinear viscoelastic regime, the hydrogel undergoes stiffening and energy dissipation, indicating simultaneous alignment and unfolding of the folded proteins on the nanoscale. Remarkably, this behaviour is highly reversible, as the value of β, d_f and the viscoelastic moduli return to their equilibrium value, even after multiple cycles of deformation. This highlights a previously unrevealed diversity of viscoelastic properties that originate on both at the nanoscale and the mesoscopic scale, providing powerful opportunities for engineering novel biomaterials.

Structural and mechanical properties of folded protein hydrogels with embedded microbubbles

Globular folded proteins are powerful building blocks to create biomaterials with mechanical robustness and inherent biological functionality. Here we explore their potential as advanced drug delivery scaffolds, by embedding microbubbles (MBs) within a photo-activated, chemically cross-linked bovine serum albumin (BSA) protein network. Using a combination of circular dichroism (CD), rheology, small angle neutron scattering (SANS) and microscopy we determine the nanoscale and mesoscale structure and mechanics of this novel multi-composite system. Optical and confocal microscopy confirms the presence of MBs within the protein hydrogel, their reduced diffusion and their effective rupture using ultrasound, a requirement for burst drug release. CD confirms that the inclusion of MBs does not impact the proportion of folded proteins within the cross-linked protein network. Rheological characterisation demonstrates that the mechanics of the BSA hydrogels is reduced in the presence of MBs. Furthermore, SANS reveals that embedding MBs in the protein hydrogel network results in a smaller number of clusters that are larger in size (∼16.6% reduction in number of clusters, 17.4% increase in cluster size). Taken together, we show that MBs can be successfully embedded within a folded protein network and ruptured upon application of ultrasound. The fundamental insight into the impact of embedded MBs in protein scaffolds at the nanoscale and mesoscale is important in the development of future platforms for targeted and controlled drug delivery applications.

Mechanical Properties of Protein-Based Hydrogels Derived from Binary Protein Mixtures-A Feasibility Study

Hydrogels based on natural polymers such as proteins are considered biocompatible and, therefore, represent an interesting class of materials for application in the field of biomedicine and high-performance materials. However, there is a lack of understanding of the proteins which are able to form hydrogel networks by photoinduced dityrosine crosslinking as well as a profound knowledge of the formed network itself and the mechanisms which are responsible for the resulting mechanical properties of such protein-based hydrogels. In this study, casein, bovine serum albumin, α-amylase, and a hydrophobic elastin-like protein were used to prepare binary protein mixtures with defined concentration ratios. After polymerization, the mechanical properties of the resulting homopolymeric and copolymeric hydrogels were determined using rheological methods depending on the protein shares used. In additional uniaxial compression tests, the fracture strain was shown to be independent of the protein shares, while hydrogel toughness and compressive strength were increased for protein-based hydrogels containing casein.

Acetic Acid Enables Precise Tailoring of the Mechanical Behavior of Protein-Based Hydrogels

Engineering viscoelastic and biocompatible materials with tailored mechanical and microstructure properties capable of mimicking the biological stiffness (<17 kPa) or serving as bioimplants will bring protein-based hydrogels to the forefront in the biomaterials field. Here, we introduce a method that uses different concentrations of acetic acid (AA) to control the covalent tyrosine-tyrosine cross-linking interactions at the nanoscale level during protein-based hydrogel synthesis and manipulates their mechanical and microstructure properties without affecting protein concentration and (un)folding nanomechanics. We demonstrated this approach by adding AA as a precursor to the preparation buffer of a photoactivated protein-based hydrogel mixture. This strategy allowed us to synthesize hydrogels made from bovine serum albumin (BSA) and eight repeats protein L structure, with a fine-tailored wide range of stiffness (2-35 kPa). Together with protein engineering technologies, this method will open new routes in developing and investigating tunable protein-based hydrogels and extend their application toward new horizons.

Changing mechanical properties of photopolymerized, dityrosine-crosslinked protein-based hydrogels

Hydrogels based on renewable resources are a promising class of materials for future applications in pharmaceutics, drug delivery and personalized medicine. Thus, optional adjustments of mechanical properties such as swelling behavior, elasticity and network strength are desired. In this context, hydrogels based on the biological raw materials bovine serum albumin and casein were prepared by dityrosine-crosslinking of their tyrosine residues through visible light-induced photopolymerization. Changing the tyrosine accessibility by urea addition before photopolymerization increased the storage modulus of the hydrogels by 650% while simultaneously being more elastic. Furthermore, contributions of the buffer system composition, variation of protein concentration and storage medium towards mechanical properties of the hydrogel such as storage moduli, elasticity, fracture strain, compressive strength and relative weight swelling ratio are discussed. It could be shown, that changes in precursor solution and storage medium characteristics are crucial parameters towards tuning the mechanical properties of protein-based hydrogels.

Solution and interfacial self-assembly of Bacillus subtilis bacterial lipoteichoic acid (LTA): nanoclustering, and effects of Ca2+ and temperature

Lipoteichoic acid (LTA) is a major structural and functional molecule in the Gram-positive bacteria membrane. Knowledge of LTA adsorption at interfaces and its solution self-assembly is crucial to understanding its role in bacterial adhesion and colonisation, infections and inflammations. Here, we report the self-assembly behaviour of LTA extracted from Bacillus subtilis, a Gram-positive bacterium, in an aqueous solution using cryogenic transmission electron microscopy (Cryo-TEM) and small-angle neutron scattering (SANS) and its adsorption behaviour at the solid-liquid interface using atomic force microscopy (AFM) imaging and quartz crystal microbalance with dissipation monitoring (QCM-D). The Cryo-TEM results indicated the formation of spherical LTA micelles that decreased in size on addition of calcium chloride (CaCl₂), attributed to charge neutralisation and possible formation of stable Ca²⁺-bridges between the phosphate groups on neighbouring LTA chains. Analysis of the SANS data from the polydisperse LTA aggregates in solution using the two Lorentzian model revealed the existence of two correlation lengths, which could respectively account for the presence of LTA micelle clusters and the local structure arising from LTA intra-molecular interactions. In the presence of CaCl₂, the decrease in the correlation lengths of the clusters indicated possible disruption of H-bonding by Ca²⁺, leading to poorer water-LTA interactions. At higher temperatures, the correlation length corresponding to the clusters increased, indicating a temperature assisted growth caused by the fluidization of micellar core and dehydration of the polar LTA chains. AFM imaging showed that adsorption of LTA aggregates at the SiO₂-water interface was significantly prompted by the addition of CaCl₂, also confirmed by QCM-D measurements. These unprecedented nanoscopic structural details on the morphology of LTA aggregates in solution and at the solid-liquid interface add to our fundamental understanding of its self-assembly behaviour hitherto underexplored.

What Is the Force-per-Molecule Inside a Biomaterial Having Randomly Oriented Units?

Both synthetic and natural protein-based materials are made of randomly oriented cross-linked molecules. Here we introduce a coarse-grained approach to estimate the average force-per-molecule for materials made from globular proteins. Our approach has three steps: placement of molecules inside a unit volume, cross-linking, and trimming to remove the protein domains that do not participate to the force response. Following this procedure, we estimate the number of active domains per cross-section area, that allows for a direct calculation of the force-per-domain. Among the variables considered, we found that concentration was the most sensitive parameter. We then synthesized protein hydrogels made from BSA and polyprotein L and measured the stresses that these materials can withstand. We found that forces-per-molecules of up to 17 pN per domain can be obtained experimentally using protein hydrogels. Our approach represents an important step toward understanding the scaling of tension in biomaterials.

Methacrylated Bovine Serum Albumin and Tannic Acid Composite Materials for Three-Dimensional Printing Tough and Mechanically Functional Parts

Nature uses proteins as building blocks to create three-dimensional (3D) structural components (like spiderwebs and tissue) that are recycled within a closed loop. Furthermore, it is difficult to replicate the mechanical properties of these 3D architectures within synthetic systems. In the absence of biological machinery, protein-based materials can be difficult to process and can have a limited range of mechanical properties. Herein, we present an additive manufacturing workflow to fabricate tough, protein-based composite hydrogels and bioplastics with a range of mechanical properties. Briefly, methacrylated bovine-serum-albumin-based aqueous resins were 3D-printed using a commercial vat photopolymerization system. The printed structures were then treated with tannic acid to introduce additional non-covalent interactions and form tough hydrogels. The hydrogel material could be sutured and withstand mechanical load, even after immersion in water for 24 h. Additionally, a denaturing thermal cure could be used to virtually eliminate rehydration of the material and form a bioplastic. To highlight the functionality of this material, a bioplastic screw was 3D-printed and driven into wood without damage to the screw. Moreover, the 3D-printed constructs enzymatically degraded up to 85% after 30 days in pepsin solution. Thus, these protein-based 3D-printed constructs show great potential for biomedical devices that degrade in situ.

Intermediate Structural Hierarchy in Biological Networks Modulates the Fractal Dimension and Force Distribution of Percolating Clusters

Globular protein hydrogels are an emerging class of materials with the potential for rational design, and a generalized understanding of how their network properties emerge from the structure and dynamics of the building block is a key challenge. Here we computationally investigate the effect of intermediate (polymeric) nanoscale structure on the formation of protein hydrogels. We show that changes in both the cross-link topology and flexibility of the polymeric building block lead to changes in the force transmission around the system and provide insight into the dynamic network formation processes. The preassembled intermediate structure provides a novel structural coordinate for the hierarchical modulation of macroscopic network properties, as well as furthering our understanding of the general dynamics of network formation.

Control of Nanoscale In Situ Protein Unfolding Defines Network Architecture and Mechanics of Protein Hydrogels

Hierarchical assemblies of proteins exhibit a wide-range of material properties that are exploited both in nature and by artificially by humankind. However, little is understood about the importance of protein unfolding on the network assembly, severely limiting opportunities to utilize this nanoscale transition in the development of biomimetic and bioinspired materials. Here we control the force lability of a single protein building block, bovine serum albumin (BSA), and demonstrate that protein unfolding plays a critical role in defining the architecture and mechanics of a photochemically cross-linked native protein network. The internal nanoscale structure of BSA contains "molecular reinforcement" in the form of 17 covalent disulphide "nanostaples", preventing force-induced unfolding. Upon addition of reducing agents, these nanostaples are broken rendering the protein force labile. Employing a combination of circular dichroism (CD) spectroscopy, small-angle scattering (SAS), rheology, and modeling, we show that stapled protein forms reasonably homogeneous networks of cross-linked fractal-like clusters connected by an intercluster region of folded protein. Conversely, in situ protein unfolding results in more heterogeneous networks of denser fractal-like clusters connected by an intercluster region populated by unfolded protein. In addition, gelation-induced protein unfolding and cross-linking in the intercluster region changes the hydrogel mechanics, as measured by a 3-fold enhancement of the storage modulus, an increase in both the loss ratio and energy dissipation, and markedly different relaxation behavior. By controlling the protein's ability to unfold through nanoscale (un)stapling, we demonstrate the importance of in situ unfolding in defining both network architecture and mechanics, providing insight into fundamental hierarchical mechanics and a route to tune biomaterials for future applications.

Protein Hydrogels: The Swiss Army Knife for Enhanced Mechanical and Bioactive Properties of Biomaterials

Biomaterials are dynamic tools with many applications: from the primitive use of bone and wood in the replacement of lost limbs and body parts, to the refined involvement of smart and responsive biomaterials in modern medicine and biomedical sciences. Hydrogels constitute a subtype of biomaterials built from water-swollen polymer networks. Their large water content and soft mechanical properties are highly similar to most biological tissues, making them ideal for tissue engineering and biomedical applications. The mechanical properties of hydrogels and their modulation have attracted a lot of attention from the field of mechanobiology. Protein-based hydrogels are becoming increasingly attractive due to their endless design options and array of functionalities, as well as their responsiveness to stimuli. Furthermore, just like the extracellular matrix, they are inherently viscoelastic in part due to mechanical unfolding/refolding transitions of folded protein domains. This review summarizes different natural and engineered protein hydrogels focusing on different strategies followed to modulate their mechanical properties. Applications of mechanically tunable protein-based hydrogels in drug delivery, tissue engineering and mechanobiology are discussed.

3D-Printed Bioplastics with Shape-Memory Behavior Based on Native Bovine Serum Albumin

Bio-based plastics that can supplant petroleum-derived materials are necessary to meet the future demands of sustainability in the life cycle of plastic materials. While there are significant efforts to develop protein-based plastic materials for commercial use, their application is limited by poor processability and limitations in mechanical performance. Here, we present a bovine serum albumin (BSA)-based resin for stereolithographic apparatus (SLA) 3D printing that affords bioplastic objects with shape-memory behavior. We demonstrate that the native conformation of these globular proteins is largely retained in the 3D-printed constructs and that each protein molecule possesses a "stored length" that could be revealed during mechanical deformation (extension or compression) of the 3D bioplastic objects. While the plastically deformed objects could retain this state for an indefinite period of time, heating the object or submerging in water allowed it to return to its original 3D-printed shape.

Single molecule protein stabilisation translates to macromolecular mechanics of a protein network

Folded globular proteins are attractive building blocks for biopolymer-based materials, as their mechanically resistant structures carry out diverse biological functionality. While much is now understood about the mechanical response of single folded proteins, a major challenge is to understand and predictably control how single protein mechanics translates to the collective response of a network of connected folded proteins. Here, by utilising the binding of maltose to hydrogels constructed from photo-chemically cross-linked maltose binding protein (MBP), we investigate the effects of protein stabilisation at the molecular level on the macroscopic mechanical and structural properties of a protein-based hydrogel. Rheological measurements show an enhancement in the mechanical strength and energy dissipation of MBP hydrogels in the presence of maltose. Circular dichroism spectroscopy and differential scanning calorimetry measurements show that MBP remains both folded and functional in situ. By coupling these mechanical measurements with mesoscopic structural information obtained by small angle scattering, we propose an occupation model in which higher proportions of stabilised, ligand occupied, protein building blocks translate their increased stability to the macroscopic properties of the hydrogel network. This provides powerful opportunities to exploit environmentally responsive folded protein-based biomaterials for many broad applications.

100th Anniversary of Macromolecular Science Viewpoint: Synthetic Protein Hydrogels

Our bodies are composed of soft tissues made of various proteins. In contrast, most hydrogels designed for biological applications are made of synthetic polymers. Recently, it is increasingly recognized that genetically synthesized proteins can be tailored as building blocks of hydrogels with biological, chemical, and mechanical properties similar to native soft tissues. In this Viewpoint, we summarize recent progress in synthetic protein hydrogels. We compare the structural and mechanical properties of different protein building blocks. We discuss various biocompatible cross-linking strategies based on covalent chemical reactions and noncovalent physical interactions. We introduce how stimulus-responsive conformational changes or intermolecular interactions at the molecular level can be used to engineer responsive hydrogels. We highlight that hydrogel network structures are as important as the protein sequences for the properties and functions of protein hydrogels and should be carefully designed. Despite great progress and potentials of synthetic protein hydrogels, there are still quite a few unsettled challenges and unexploited opportunities, providing abundant room for future investigation and development, particularly as this field is quickly expanding beyond its initial stage. We discuss a number of possible directions, including optimizing protein production and reducing cost, engineering anisotropic hydrogels to better mimic native tissues, rationally designing hydrogel mechanical properties, investigating interplays of hydrogels and residing cells for 3D cell culture and organoid construction, and evaluating long-term cytotoxicity and immune response.

High-Strength Albumin Hydrogels With Hybrid Cross-Linking

Natural protein-based hydrogels possess excellent biocompatibility; however, most of them are weak or brittle. In the present work, high strength hybrid dual-crosslinking BSA gels (BSA DC gels), which have both chemical cross-linking and physical cross-linking, were fabricated by a facile photoreaction-heating process. BSA DC gels showed high transparency (light transmittance of ~90%) and high strength. At optimal conditions, BSA DC gel exhibited high compressive strength (σc,f) of 37.81 ± 2.61 MPa and tensile strength (σt,f) of 0.62 ± 0.078 MPa, showing it to be much stronger than physically cross-linked BSA gel (BSA PC gel) and chemically cross-linked BSA gel (BSA CC gel). More importantly, BSA DC gel displayed non-swelling properties while maintaining high strength in DI water, pH = 3.0, and pH = 10.0. Moreover, BSA DC gel also demonstrated large hysteresis, rapid self-recovery, and excellent fatigue resistance properties. It is believed that our BSA DC gel can potentially be applied in biomedical fields.

Chemical unfolding of protein domains induces shape change in programmed protein hydrogels

Programmable behavior combined with tailored stiffness and tunable biomechanical response are key requirements for developing successful materials. However, these properties are still an elusive goal for protein-based biomaterials. Here, we use protein-polymer interactions to manipulate the stiffness of protein-based hydrogels made from bovine serum albumin (BSA) by using polyelectrolytes such as polyethyleneimine (PEI) and poly-L-lysine (PLL) at various concentrations. This approach confers protein-hydrogels with tunable wide-range stiffness, from ~10-64 kPa, without affecting the protein mechanics and nanostructure. We use the 6-fold increase in stiffness induced by PEI to program BSA hydrogels in various shapes. By utilizing the characteristic protein unfolding we can induce reversible shape-memory behavior of these composite materials using chemical denaturing solutions. The approach demonstrated here, based on protein engineering and polymer reinforcing, may enable the development and investigation of smart biomaterials and extend protein hydrogel capabilities beyond their conventional applications.

The hierarchical emergence of worm-like chain behaviour from globular domain polymer chains

Biological organisms make use of hierarchically organised structures to modulate mechanical behaviour across multiple lengthscales, allowing microscopic objects to generate macroscopic effects. Within these structural hierarchies, the resultant physical behaviour of the entire system is determined not only by the intrinsic mechanical properties of constituent subunits, but also by their organisation in three-dimensional space. When these subunits are polyproteins, colloidal chains or other globular domain polymers, the Kratky-Porod model is often assumed for the individual subunits. Hence, it is implicitly asserted that the polymeric object has an intrinsic parameter, the persistence length, that defines its flexibility. However, the persistence lengths extracted from experiment vary, and are often relatively small. Through a series of simulations on polymer chains formed of globular subunits, we show that the persistence length itself is a hierarchical structural property, related not only to the intrinsic mechanical properties of the underlying monomeric subunits, but emerging due to the organisation of inhomogenous geometry along the polymer contour.

Hierarchically structured phase separated biopolymer hydrogels create tailorable delayed burst release during gastrointestinal digestion

The on demand delivery of novel peptide actives, traditional pharmaceuticals, nutrients and/or vitamins is a ever present challenge due to the digestive and metabolic degradation of the active and the delivery vehicle. Biodegradable biopolymer hydrogels have long held promise as candidates for creating tailored release profiles due to the ability to control gel porosity. The present study describes the creation of novel hierarchical biopolymer hydrogels for the controlled release of lipids/lipophilic actives pharmaceutical ingredients (APIs), and mathematically describes the mechanisms that affect the timing of release. The creation of phase separated protein/polysaccharide core (6.6 wt% gelatin, 40 wt% Oil in water emulsion) shell structures (7 g/L xanthan with 70-140 g/L β-lactoglobulin) altered enzyme mass transport processes. This core shell structure enabled the creation of a tailorable burst release of API during gastrointestinal digestion where there is a delay in the onset of release, without affecting the kinetics of release. The timing of the delay could be readily programmed (with release of between 60 and 240 min) by controlling either the thickness or protein concentration (between 70 g/L and 140 g/L β-lactoglobulin) of the outer mixed biopolymer hydrogel shell (7 g/L xanthan with 70-140 g/L β-lactoglobulin). Enzyme diffusion measurements demonstrated that surface erosion was the main degradation mechanism. A kinetic model was created to describe the delayed burst release behaviour of APIs encapsulated within the core, and successfully predicted the influence of shell thickness and shell protein density on the timing of gastro-intestinal release (in vitro). Our work highlights the creation of a novel family of core-shell hydrogel oral dosage forms capable of programmable delivery of lipids/lipophilic APIs. These findings could have considerable implications for the delivery of peptides, poorly soluble drugs, or the programmed delivery of lipids within the gastrointestinal tract.

Modeling Protein-Based Hydrogels under Force

Hydrogels made from structured polyprotein domains combine the properties of cross-linked polymers with the unfolding phase transition. The use of protein hydrogels as an ensemble approach to study the physics of domain unfolding is limited by the lack of scaling tools and by the complexity of the system. Here we propose a model to describe the biomechanical response of protein hydrogels based on the unfolding and extension of protein domains under force. Our model considers the contributions of the network dynamics of the molecules inside the gels, which have random cross-linking points and random topology. This model reproduces reported macroscopic viscoelastic effects and constitutes an important step toward using rheometry on protein hydrogels to scale down to the average mechanical response of protein molecules.