Improved Anti-Biofouling Performance of Thin -Film Composite Forward-Osmosis Membranes Containing Passive and Active Moieties

Piezoceramic membrane with built-in ultrasound for reactive oxygen species generation and synergistic vibration anti-fouling

Piezoceramic membranes have emerged as a prominent solution for membrane fouling control. However, the prevalent use of toxic lead and limitations of vibration-based anti-fouling mechanism impede their wider adoption in water treatment. This study introduces a Mn/BaTiO3 piezoceramic membrane, demonstrating a promising in-situ anti-fouling efficacy and mechanism insights. When applied to an Alternating Current at a resonant frequency of 20 V, 265 kHz, the membrane achieves optimal vibration, effectively mitigating various foulants such as high-concentration oil (2500 ppm, including real industrial oil wastewater), bacteria and different charged inorganic colloidal particles, showing advantages over other reported piezoceramic membranes. Importantly, our findings suggest that the built-in ultrasonic vibration of piezoceramic membranes can generate reactive oxygen species. This offers profound insights into the distinct anti-fouling processes for organic and inorganic wastewater, supplementing and unifying the traditional singular vibrational anti-fouling mechanism of piezoceramic membranes, and potentially propelling the development of piezoelectric catalytic membranes.

Enhancing biofouling resistance in microfiltration membranes through capsaicin-derivative functionalization

The primary focal point in the fabrication of microfiltration membranes revolves around mitigating issues of low permeability stemming from the initial design as well as countering biofouling tendencies. This work aimed to address these issues by synthesizing an antibacterial capsaicin derivative (CD), which was then grafted to the poly(vinylidene fluoride-co-chlorotrifluoroethylene)-g-polymethacrylic acid (P(VDF-CTFE)-g-PMAA) matrix polymer, resulting in an antibacterial polymer (PD). Notably, both CD and PD demonstrated low cytotoxicities. Utilizing PD, a microfiltration membrane (MA) was successfully prepared through non-solvent-induced phase inversion. The pore sizes of the MA membrane were mainly concentrated at around 436 nm, while the pure water flux of MA reached an impressive value of 62 ± 0.17 Lm-2 h-1 at 0.01 MPa. MA exhibited remarkable efficacy in eradicating both Gram-negative (E. coli) and Gram-positive bacteria (Bacillus subtilis) from its surface. Compared with M1 prepared from P(VDF-CTFE), MA exhibited a lower flux decay rate (41.00% vs. 76.03%) and a higher flux recovery rate (84.95% vs. 46.54%) after three cycles. Overall, this research represents a significant step towards the development of a microfiltration membrane with inherent stable anti-biofouling capability to enhance filtration.

Recent advances in surface tailoring of thin film forward osmosis membranes: A review

The recent advancements in fabricating forward osmosis (FO) membranes have shown promising results in desalination and water treatment. Different methods have been applied to improve FO performance, such as using mixed or new draw solutions, enhancing the recovery of draw solutions, membrane modification, and developing FO-hybrid systems. However, reliable methods to address the current issues, including reverse salt flux, fouling, and antibacterial activities, are still in progress. In recent decades, surface modification has been applied to different membrane processes, including FO membranes. Introducing nanochannels, bioparticles, new monomers, and hydrophilic-based materials to the surface layer of FO membranes has significantly impacted their performance and efficiency and resulted in better control over fouling and concentration polarization (CP) in these membranes. This review critically investigates the recent developments in FO membrane processes and fabrication techniques for FO surface-layer modification. In addition, this study focuses on the latest materials and structures used for the surface modification of FO membranes. Finally, the current challenges, gaps, and suggestions for future studies in this field have been discussed in detail.

Antimicrobial Nanoparticles Mediated Prevention and Control of Membrane Biofouling in Water and Wastewater Treatment: Current Trends and Future Perspectives

Global water scarcity and water pollution necessitate wastewater reclamation for further use. As an alternative to conventional techniques, membrane technology is extensively used as an advanced method for water purification and wastewater treatment due to its selectivity, permeability, and efficient removal of pollutants. However, microbial biofouling is a major threat that deteriorates membrane performance and imparts operational challenges. It is a natural phenomenon caused by the undesirable colonization of microbes on membrane surfaces. The economic penalties associated with this menace are enormous. The traditional preventive measures are dominated by biocides, toxic chemicals, cleaners and antifouling surfaces, which are costly and often cause secondary pollution. Recent focus is thus being directed to promote inputs from nanotechnology to control and mitigate this major threat. Different anti-microbial nanomaterials can be effectively used to prevent the adhesion of microbes onto the membrane surfaces and eliminate microbial biofilms, to provide an economical and eco-friendly solution to biofouling. This review addresses the formation of microbial biofilms and biofouling in membrane operations. The potential of nanocomposite membranes in alleviating this problem and the challenges in commercialization are discussed. The antifouling mechanisms are also highlighted, which are not widely elucidated.

In situ surface modification of forward osmosis membrane by polydopamine/polyethyleneimine-silver nanoparticle for anti-fouling improvement in municipal wastewater treatment

In this work, we demonstrate the surface functionalization of cellulose triacetate membrane with co-deposition of polydopamine (PDA)/polyethyleneimine (PEI) and silver nanoparticles (AgNPs) for antifouling property in municipal wastewater treatment. PDA/PEI was first coated on the membrane surface by single-step co-deposition, while AgNPs were formed in situ through catechol groups of PDA immobilizing silver ions and subsequently reducing. The successful surface modification was verified by different membrane characterization techniques. The modified PDA/PEI-nAg CTA membrane exhibits enhanced hydrophilicity and improved antiadhesion and antimicrobial activity. Furthermore, the functional layer had an indistinctive effect on the membrane transport parameters. In addition, dynamic forward osmosis (FO) fouling experiment with raw municipal wastewater as feed solution indicated that the PDA/PEI-nAg CTA membrane exhibited notably lower water flux decrease compared to the nascent CTA membrane. The results of confocal laser scanning microscopy (CLSM) showed that PDA/PEI-nAg CTA membranes effectively reduced the adsorption of organic foulants (proteins and polysaccharides) and inhibited the formation and development of the fouling layer. The membrane surface modification of the CTA membrane with PDA/PEI and AgNPs efficiently mitigated membrane fouling in municipal wastewater treatment.

Maintaining Antibacterial Activity against Biofouling Using a Quaternary Ammonium Membrane Coupling with Electrorepulsion

Antibacterial modification is a chemical-free method to mitigate biofouling, but surface accumulation of bacteria shields antibacterial groups and presents a significant challenge in persistently preventing membrane biofouling. Herein, a great synergistic effect of electrorepulsion and quaternary ammonium (QA) inactivation on maintaining antibacterial activity against biofouling has been investigated using an electrically conductive QA membrane (eQAM), which was fabricated by polymerization of pyrrole with QA compounds. The electrokinetic force between negatively charged Escherichia coli and cathodic eQAM prevented E. coli cells from reaching the membrane surface. More importantly, cathodic eQAM accelerated the detachment of cells from the eQAM surface, particularly for dead cells whose adhesion capacity was impaired by inactivation. The number of dead cells on the eQAM surface was declined by 81.2% while the number of live cells only decreased by 49.9%. Characterization of bacteria accumulation onto the membrane surface using an electrochemical quartz crystal microbalance revealed that the electrorepulsion accounted for the cell detachment rather than inactivation. In addition, QA inactivation mainly contributed to minimizing the cell adhesion capacity. Consequently, the membrane fouling was significantly declined, and the final normalized water flux was promoted higher than 20% with the synergistic effect of electrorepulsion and QA inactivation. This work provides a unique long-lasting strategy to mitigate membrane biofouling.

Induced mazEF-mediated programmed cell death contributes to antibiofouling properties of quaternary ammonium compounds modified membranes

Functionalized antibiofouling membranes have attracted increasing attention in water and wastewater treatment. Among them, contact-killing antibiofouling membranes deliver a long-lasting effect with no leaching or release, thus providing distinctive advantages. However, the antibiofouling mechanism especially in the vicinity of the membrane surface remains unclear. Herein, we demonstrate that mazEF-mediated programmed cell death (PCD) is critical for the antibiofouling behaviors of quaternary ammonium compounds modified membranes (QM). The viability of wild type Escherichia coli (WT E. coli) upon exposure to QM for 1 h was decreased dramatically (31.5 ± 1.4% of the control). In contrast, the bacterial activity of E. coli with the knockout of mazEF gene (KO E. coli) largely remained (85.8 ± 5.2%). Through addition of quorum sensing factor, i.e., extracellular death factor (EDF), the antibacterial activity was significantly enhanced in a dilute culture, indicating that the density-dependent bacterial communication played an important role in the mazEF-mediated PCD system in biofouling control. Long-term study further showed that QM exhibited a better antibiofouling performance to treat feedwater containing WT E. coli, especially when EDF was dosed. Results of this study suggested that the bacteria on the membrane surface subject to contact killing could modulate the population growth in the vicinity via quorum-sensing mazEF-mediated PCD, paving a way to develop efficient antibiofouling materials based on contact-killing scenarios.

A passive-active combined strategy for ultrafiltration membrane fouling control in continuous oily wastewater purification

Membrane-based technology has been confirmed as an effective way to treat emulsified oily wastewater, however, membrane fouling is still one of practical challenges in long-term operation. Herein, a novel passive-active combined strategy was proposed to control membrane fouling in continuous oily wastewater purification, where the δ-MnO₂ decoration layer helped to reduce the total fouling ratio (passive strategy for fouling mitigation) and the catalytic cleaning effectively removed the irreversible oil fouling (active strategy for fouling removal). The functional membrane was prepared via in-situ modification, referred to as δ-MnO₂@TA-PES. The morphology, crystalline phase, chemical structure and surface properties of the membranes were systematically characterized. Compared with PES, the δ-MnO₂@TA-PES possessed superhydrophilicity, enhanced electronegativity and narrowed pore size. The δ-MnO₂@TA-PES achieved high water permeation flux of 723.9 L·m ^- 2·h ^- 1·bar^-1, excellent oil rejection with separation efficiency above 98.5% for various emulsions, and durable anti-oil-fouling performance with FRR_b of 98.0%. Notably, the oil cake layer fouling on δ-MnO₂@TA-PES was greatly alleviated owing to its enhanced surface properties. In addition, δ-MnO₂@TA-PES showed high cleaning efficiency in the peroxymonosulfate (PMS) cleaning process, where the radical and nonradical pathways occurred simultaneously. And the active substances generated in the nonradical process (especially ¹O₂) were considered as the main contributor to the reduction of irreversible fouling. Overall, the novel strategy of fouling control ensured the efficient operation of ultrafiltration membranes for the continuous oily wastewater purification.

Purifying water with silver nanoparticles (AgNPs)-incorporated membranes: Recent advancements and critical challenges

In the face of the growing global water crisis, membrane technology is a promising means of purifying water and wastewater. Silver nanoparticles (AgNPs) have been widely used to improve membrane performance, for antibiofouling, and to aid in photocatalytic degradation, thermal response, and electro-conductivity. However, several critical issues such as short antimicrobial periods, trade-off effects and silver inactivation seriously restrict the engineering application of AgNPs-incorporated membranes. In addition, there is controversy around the use of AgNPs given the toxic preparation process and environmental/biological risks. Hence, it is of great significance to summarize and analyze the recent developments and critical challenges in the use of AgNPs-incorporated membranes in water and wastewater treatment, and to propose potential solutions. We reviewed the different properties and functions of AgNPs and their corresponding applications in AgNPs-incorporated membranes. Recently, multifunctional, novel AgNP-incorporated membranes combined with other functional materials have been developed with high-performance. We further clarified the synergistic mechanisms between AgNPs and these novel nanomaterials and/or polymers, and elucidated their functions and roles in membrane separation. Finally, the critical challenges of AgNPs-incorporated membranes and the proposed solutions were outlined: i) Prolonging the antimicrobial cycle through long-term and controlled AgNPs release; ii) Overcoming the trade-off effect and organic fouling of the AgNPs-incorporated membranes; iii) Preparation of sustainable AgNPs-incorporated membranes; iv) Addressing biotoxicity induced by AgNPs; and v) Deactivation of AgNPs-incorporated membrane. Overall, this review provides a comprehensive discussion of the advancements and challenges of AgNPs-incorporated membranes and guides the development of more robust, multi-functional and sustainable AgNPs-incorporated membranes.

Robust In Situ Fouling Control toward Thin-Film Composite Reverse Osmosis Membrane via One-Step Deposition of a Ternary Homogeneous Metal-Organic Hybrid Layer

Membrane fouling is one of the persistent headaches for water desalination because of the significant detriment to membrane performance and operating cost control. It is a great challenge to overcome such crisis in a facile and robust manner. This work was dedicated to customizing an antifouling thin-film composite (TFC) reverse osmosis (RO) membrane with a polydopamine (PDA)/β-alanine (βAla)/Cu²⁺ ternary homogeneous metal-organic hybrid coating. The metal ions were evenly distributed in a continuous organic network via polydentate coordination. The incorporation of βAla enabled a substantial promotion of the Cu²⁺ loading capacity on the membrane surface. The involved one-step codeposition protocol made the surface engineering practically accessible. The deposition time was optimized to afford an uncompromising permselectivity of the membrane. This novel trinity was a smart blend of anti-adhesive and bactericidal factors, and each component in the all-in-one layer performed its own function. The hydrophilic PDA/βAla phase induced weak deposition propensity of organic foulant and bacteria onto the modified membrane, as elucidated by water flux variation, foulants adhesion profile, and interfacial interaction energy. Meanwhile, the Cu²⁺-loaded surface strongly inactivated the attached bacteria to further alleviate biofouling. Excellent sustainability and stability implied the reliable performance of such trinity-coated membrane in practical service. Given the simplicity and robustness, this work opened a promising avenue for in situ fouling control of TFC RO membranes during water desalination.

Corn Stalk-Derived Carbon Quantum Dots with Abundant Amino Groups as a Selective-Layer Modifier for Enhancing Chlorine Resistance of Membranes

Low permeability and chlorine resistance of normal thin-film composite (TFC) membranes restrict their practical applications in many fields. This study reports the preparation of a high chlorine-resistant TFC membrane for forward osmosis (FO) by incorporating corn stalk-derived N-doped carbon quantum dots (N-CQDs) into the selective polyamide (PA) layer to construct a polydopamine (PDA) sub-layer (PTFC_CQD). Membrane modification is characterized by surface morphology, hydrophilicity, Zeta potential, and roughness. Results show that TFC_CQD (without PDA pretreatment) and PTFC_CQD membranes possess greater negative surface charges and thinner layer-thickness (less than 68 nm). With N-CQDs and PDA pretreatment, the surface roughness of the PTFC_CQD membrane decreases significantly with the co-existence of microsized balls and flocs with a dense porous structure. With the variation of concentration and type of draw solution, the PTFC_CQD membrane exhibits an excellent permeability with low J_{(reverse salt flux)}/J_{(water flux)} values (0.1-0.25) due to the enhancement of surface hydrophilicity and the shortening of permeable paths. With 16,000 ppm·h chlorination, reverse salt flux of the PTFC_CQD membrane (8.4 g m^-2 h^-1) is far lower than those of TFC_CQD (136.2 g m^-2 h^-1), PTFC (127.6 g m^-2 h^-1), and TFC (132 g m^-2 h^-1) membranes in FO processes. The decline of salt rejection of the PTFC_CQD membrane is only 8.2%, and the normalized salt rejection maintains 0.918 in the RO system (16,000 ppm·h chlorination). Super salt rejection is ascribed to the existence of abundant N-H bonds (N-CQDs), which are preferentially chlorinated by free chlorine to reduce the corrosion of the PA layer. The structure of the PA layer is stable during chlorination also due to the existence of various active groups grafted on the surface. This study may pave a new direction for the preparation of durable biomass-derivative (N-CQD)-modified membranes to satisfy much more possible applications.

Application of Zwitterions in Forward Osmosis: A Short Review

Forward osmosis (FO) is an important desalination method to produce potable water. It was also used to treat different wastewater streams, including industrial as well as municipal wastewater. Though FO is environmentally benign, energy intensive, and highly efficient; it still suffers from four types of fouling namely: organic fouling, inorganic scaling, biofouling and colloidal fouling or a combination of these types of fouling. Membrane fouling may require simple shear force and physical cleaning for sufficient recovery of membrane performance. Severe fouling may need chemical cleaning, especially when a slimy biofilm or severe microbial colony is formed. Modification of FO membrane through introducing zwitterionic moieties on the membrane surface has been proven to enhance antifouling property. In addition, it could also significantly improve the separation efficiency and longevity of the membrane. Zwitterion moieties can also incorporate in draw solution as electrolytes in FO process. It could be in a form of a monomer or a polymer. Hence, this review comprehensively discussed several methods of inclusion of zwitterionic moieties in FO membrane. These methods include atom transfer radical polymerization (ATRP); second interfacial polymerization (SIP); coating and in situ formation. Furthermore, an attempt was made to understand the mechanism of improvement in FO performance by zwitterionic moieties. Finally, the future prospective of the application of zwitterions in FO has been discussed.

Robust immobilization of anionic silver nanoparticles on cellulose filter paper toward a low-cost point-of-use water disinfection system with improved anti-biofouling properties

Silver nanoparticle (AgNP)-decorated cellulose filter paper (FP), a low-cost point-of-use (POU) water disinfection system, can supply affordable and safe drinking water for people in desperate need, especially in rural areas in developing countries. However, owing to the unstable immobilization of AgNPs, silver can leach into the treated drinking water from the FP and exceed the World Health Organization (WHO) drinking water limit (<100 μg L-1), which is a potential threat to both human health and the environment. In this work, in order to robustly immobilize anionic silver nanoparticles (GA@AgNPs), we facilely prepared lipoic acid-modified cellulose filter paper (LA-FP), in which GA@AgNPs were robustly immobilized onto filter paper (GA@AgNPs-LA-FP) by strong chelation via the disulfide bond of LA with the surface of the silver nanoparticles. GA@AgNPs-LA-FP exhibited both excellent bacterial anti-adhesion activity and strong bactericidal activity, which can synergistically mitigate biofouling by inhibiting biofilm formation on the paper surface. Moreover, employed as a gravity-driven bactericidal filter, the GA@AgNPs-LA-FP membrane treated 100 mL of river water within 10 min, and the resulting water quality met the WHO drinking water standards, indicating this material's practical application for POU water disinfection.

Membrane Biofouling Control by Surface Modification of Quaternary Ammonium Compound Using Atom-Transfer Radical-Polymerization Method with Silica Nanoparticle as Interlayer

A facile approach to fabricate antibiofouling membrane was developed by grafting quaternary ammonium compounds (QACs) onto polyvinylidene fluoride (PVDF) membrane via surface-initiated activators regenerated by electron transfer atom-transfer radical-polymerization (ARGET ATRP) method. During the modification process, a hydrophilic silica nanoparticle layer was also immobilized onto the membrane surface as an interlayer through silicification reaction for QAC grafting, which imparted the membrane with favorable surface properties (e.g., hydrophilic and negatively charged surface). The QAC-modified membrane (MQ) showed significantly improved hydrophilicity and permeability mainly due to the introduction of silica nanoparticles and exposure of hydrophilic quaternary ammonium groups instead of long alkyl chains. Furthermore, the coverage of QAC onto membrane surface enabled MQ membrane to have clear antibacterial effect, with an inhibition rate ~99.9% of Escherichia coli (Gram-negative) and Staphylococcus aureus (Gram-positive), respectively. According to the batch filtration test, MQ had better antibiofouling performance compared to the control membrane, which was ascribed to enhanced hydrophilicity and antibacterial activity. Furthermore, the MQ membrane also exhibited impressive stability of QAC upon suffering repeated fouling–cleaning tests. The modification protocols provide a new robust way to fabricate high-performance antibiofouling QAC-based membranes for wastewater treatment.

Membrane processes

This literature review provides a review for publications in 2018 and 2019 and includes information membrane processes findings for municipal and industrial applications. This review is a subsection of the annual Water Environment Federation literature review for Treatment Systems section. The following topics are covered in this literature review: industrial wastewater and membrane. Bioreactor (MBR) configuration, membrane fouling, design, reuse, nutrient removal, operation, anaerobic membrane systems, microconstituents removal, membrane technology advances, and modeling. Other sub-sections of the Treatment Systems section that might relate to this literature review include the following: Biological Fixed-Film Systems, Activated Sludge, and Other Aerobic Suspended Culture Processes, Anaerobic Processes, and Water Reclamation and Reuse. This publication might also have related information on membrane processes: Industrial Wastes, Hazardous Wastes, and Fate and Effects of Pollutants.

In Situ Ag-MOF Growth on Pre-Grafted Zwitterions Imparts Outstanding Antifouling Properties to Forward Osmosis Membranes

In this study, a polyamide forward osmosis membrane was functionalized with zwitterions followed by the in situ growth of metal-organic frameworks with silver as a metal core (Ag-MOFs) to improve its antibacterial and antifouling activity. First, 3-bromopropionic acid was grafted onto the membrane surface after its activation with N,N-diethylethylenediamine. Then, the in situ growth of Ag-MOFs was achieved by a simple membrane immersion sequentially in a silver nitrate solution and in a ligand solution (2-methylimidazole), exploiting the underlying zwitterions as binding sites for the metal. The successful membrane functionalization and the enhanced surface wettability were verified through an array of characterization techniques. When evaluated in forward osmosis tests, the modified membranes exhibited high performance and improved permeability compared to pristine membranes. Static antibacterial experiments, evaluated by confocal microscopy and colony-forming unit plate count, resulted in a 77% increase in the bacterial inhibition rate due to the activity of the Ag-MOFs. Microscopy micrographs of the Escherichia coli bacteria suggested the deterioration of the biological cells. The antifouling properties of the functionalized membranes translated into a significantly lower flux decline in forward osmosis filtrations. These modified surfaces displayed negligible depletion of silver ions over 30 days, confirming the stable immobilization of Ag-MOFs on their surface.

Anti-oil-fouling hydrophobic-superoleophobic composite membranes for robust membrane distillation performance

As a promising thermally driven separation process, membrane distillation (MD) is capable of treating challenging wastewaters. However, the traditional hydrophobic membranes are vulnerable to fouling by non-polar contaminants owing to the strong hydrophobic-hydrophobic interactions. To address this problem, we developed novel anti-oil-fouling MD membranes in this study. The composite membranes with asymmetric wettability were fabricated through electrospinning polyacrylonitrile (PAN) fibrous coating on a hydrophobic polytetrafluoroethylene (PTFE) membrane, followed by hydrolyzing the PAN coating with ethylenediamine (EDA) and NaOH, respectively. These two composite membranes exhibited excellent underwater superoleophobicity, with the underwater oil contact angle >150°, which can be attributed to the fibrous and re-entrant surface structure and the optimized surface hydrophilicity of the electrospun coating. During MD process using saline and oily emulsion as feed, the composite membranes presented robust anti-oil-fouling performance, indicating by stable permeate flux and salt rejection. A novel oil-droplet adhesion force probe was introduced to quasi-quantitatively elucidate oil-membrane interaction and evaluate membrane fouling propensity, the force spectroscopy indicated that the fabricated composite membranes had fairly less attractive to crude oil compared with the PTFE membrane. Our research results suggest that the novel composite membranes with asymmetric wettability were competent to serve as an anti-oil-fouling MD membrane for desalinating challenging saline and oily wastewaters.

Zwitterion-Ag Complexes That Simultaneously Enhance Biofouling Resistance and Silver Binding Capability of Thin Film Composite Membranes

Biofouling can be overcome with zwitterion grafts and antimicrobial, metallic nanoparticles. However, the mechanism underpinning this effective approach remains unclear. To elucidate the role of each component in this system while maximizing membrane antifouling and antimicrobial properties, here we performed a comparative study to investigate the impact of zwitterion type and their interactions with Ag of various states. Two different zwitterions (SO₃^--based and COO^--based) were employed to modify polyamide (PA) thin film composite (TFC) membranes, and the metallized and mineralized membranes were developed via in situ formation of silver (Ag) nanoparticles and deposition of silver chloride (AgCl) particles on the zwitterion-modified TFC membranes. The presence of zwitterions was key to enhance Ag content, resulting in significantly improved antimicrobial and antifouling properties without compromising the nanofiltration separation performance. COO^--based zwitterions were found more favorable toward Ag metallization and mineralization compared to SO₃^--based zwitterions. The underlying mechanisms underpinning this discovery were further revealed using density functional theory (DFT) to reveal Gibbs free energy of the binding between zwitterions and Ag⁺ ions. This fundamental knowledge is crucial for designing next-generation antibiofouling strategies.