Stronger Hydration of Eu(III) Impedes Its Competition against Am(III) in Binding with N-donor Extractants

Computational Comparative Study of the Binding of Americium with N-Donor Ligands

The accessibility of multiple valence states of americium (Am) inspired redox-based protocols aimed at efficient separation of trivalent Am (Am3+) from trivalent lanthanides (Ln3+) alternative to the traditional liquid-liquid extraction. This requires an extensive understanding of the coordination chemistry of Am in its various accessible valence states in the aqueous phase. In this work, by means of DFT calculations, the coordination of AmIII-VI with five typical N-donor ligands, i.e., terpyridine (tpy), bispyrazinylpyridine (dpp), bistriazinylpyridine (BTP), bistriazinyl bipyridine (BTBP), and bistrazinyl phenanthroline (BTPhen), was studied in terms of energy and topological analysis. The results show that the exchange of aqua ligands of hydrated ions by N-donor ligands is an entropy-driven process and enthalpically unfavorable. Topological analysis suggests a distinct mechanism of BTP to modulate the redox potential of Am(III) in that BTP can assist the relay of the leaving electron of AmIII, while the other N-donor ligands can detain the oxidation of Am by offering their electron instead. This comparative study enriches our understanding of the coordination chemistry of high-valent Am with N-donor ligands and recommends the ligand design toward the modulation of redox potentials of hydrated Am(III) ions.

Next-Generation 3,3'-AlkoxyBTPs as Complexants for Minor Actinide Separation from Lanthanides: A Comprehensive Separations, Spectroscopic, and DFT Study

Progress toward the closure of the nuclear fuel cycle can be achieved if satisfactory separation strategies for the chemoselective speciation of the trivalent actinides from the lanthanides are realized in a nonproliferative manner. Since Kolarik's initial report on the utility of bis-1,2,4-triazinyl-2,6-pyridines (BTPs) in 1999, a perfect complexant-based, liquid-liquid separation system has yet to be realized. In this report, a comprehensive performance assessment for the separation of 241Am3+ from 154Eu3+ as a model system for spent nuclear fuel using hydrocarbon-actuated alkoxy-BTP complexants is described. These newly discovered complexants realize gains that contemporary aryl-substituted BTPs have yet to achieve, specifically: long-term stability in highly concentrated nitric acid solutions relevant to the low pH of unprocessed spent nuclear fuel, high DAm over DEu in the economical, nonpolar diluent Exxal-8, and the demonstrated capacity to complete the separation cycle with high efficiency by depositing the chelated An3+ to the aqueous layer via decomplexation of the metal-ligand complex. These soft-N-donor BTPs are hypothesized to function as bipolar complexants, effectively traversing the organic/aqueous interface for effective chelation and bound metal/ligand complex solubility. Complexant design, separation assays, spectroscopic analysis, single-crystal X-ray crystallographic data, and DFT calculations are reported.

Theoretical investigations into the bonding and separation properties of non-rigid, partially rigid, and rigid ligands derived from Et-Tol-PTA with trivalent lanthanides and actinides

The separation of trivalent actinide elements from lanthanide elements represents one of the most formidable challenges within the context of nuclear waste partitioning and transmutation (P&T) processes. Consequently, we embarked on a systematic investigation aimed at elucidating the bonding properties and thermodynamic behavior of a N-ethyl-N-tolyl-2-amide-1,10-phenanthroline (Et-Tol-PTA) ligand in conjunction with trivalent actinide and lanthanide elements. This investigation involved the utilization of various density functional theory (DFT) methods and a comparative analysis between small-core pseudopotential basis sets and all-electron basis sets. It was found that well-performing results were achieved using the PBE0 functional in both bond length and thermodynamic energy calculations, with minimal impact being exerted by the basis set on the results. Furthermore, an exploration was carried out into the bonding and thermodynamic properties of trivalent actinides and lanthanides with ligands derived from Et-Tol-PTA, encompassing non-rigid (La), partially rigid (Lb, Lc), and rigid (Ld) ligands. Thermodynamically, advantages in the separation of Am(III)/Eu(III) were exhibited by Lb and Lc ligands, while excellent performance in the separation of Am(III)/Cm(III) was demonstrated by the La ligand. Analyses conducted using quantum theory of atoms in molecules (QTAIM), reduced density gradient (RDG), and natural bond orbital (NBO) methodologies revealed the presence of partial covalent character in the bonds between oxygen (O) and metal (M), as well as between nitrogen (N) and metal (M), with a higher degree of covalent character being observed in O-Am and N-Am bonds compared to O-Cm/Eu and N-Cm/Eu interactions.

Theoretical investigation on the ligands constructed from phenanthroline and five-membered N-heterocyclic rings for bonding and separation properties of Am(III) and Eu(III)

The ligands, derived from the combination of phenanthroline and various five-membered N-heterocyclic rings, were subject to a comprehensive investigation for their potential in the extraction and separation of actinides and lanthanides. This study employed DFT methods to thoroughly explore the properties of both phenanthroline (Ph) and the diverse five-membered N-heterocyclic rings (R1-R8). Additionally, tridentate ligands RlPh (l = 1-8) and tetradentate ligands RlPhRr (l, r = 1-8) were analyzed in detail, encompassing their electrostatic potential (ESP), protonation energy, coordination bonding with the metals Am(III) and Eu(III), and the thermodynamics of extraction separation for Am(III) and Eu(III). The findings highlight that the electrostatic potential (ESP) and binding capabilities of the five-membered N-heterocyclic ring units serve as effective predictors for the properties of intricate tridentate and tetradentate ligands, as well as their coordination bonding affinity with metals. The ligands' binding energy is closely associated with their ESP, and notably, the binding energy of tridentate and tetradentate ligands correlates well with the binding energies of their constituent structural units. The computational results reveal that the R2 unit, along with its corresponding tridentate ligand R2Ph and tetradentate ligands R2PhRr, exhibits the highest ESP, superior binding energies, and the strongest coordination bonding affinity with the metals. The theoretical calculations further identify several promising extractants for the effective separation of Am(III) and Eu(III). The tridentate ligands R1Ph, R7Ph, and R4Ph, and the tetradentate ligands R4PhR4, R6PhR6, R2PhR2, R1PhR5 and R3PhR6 were identified as having excellent separation performance for Am(III) and Eu(III). This study would provide insights for the design of extractants for the separation of Am(III) and Eu(III) by use of five-membered N-heterocyclic rings as structural units.

Experimental and Theoretical Investigation on the Extractive Mass Transfer of Eu3+ Ions Using Novel Amide Ligands in 1-Hexyl-3-methylimidazolium Bis(trifluoromethylsulfonyl)imide

Novel amide ligands in the ionic liquid (1-hexyl-3-methylimidazolium bis(trifluoromethylsulfonyl)imide) were utilized for the liquid-liquid biphasic mass transfer of Eu3+ ions from aqueous acidic waste solution. The cation exchange mechanism was found to be operative with the formation of [Eu(NO3)2L3]+ species (L = 4-chloro-N-(1-methyl-1H-pyrazol-3-yl)picolinamide). However, the presence of an inner-sphere water molecule was revealed by density functional theory (DFT) calculations. The viscosity-induced slower kinetics was evidenced during mass transfer, which was improved by increasing temperature. The process was exothermic in nature. The improvement in the kinetics of extractive mass transfer at higher temperatures is evinced by a reduction in the distribution ratio value. The spontaneity of the reaction was evidenced through the negative Gibbs free energy value, whereas the process enhances the entropy of the system, probably by releasing water molecules at least partially during complexation. The structures of bare ligands and complexes have been optimized by using DFT calculations. A high value of complexation energy, solvation energy, and associated enthalpy and free energy change reveal the efficacy in binding Eu with O and N donor atoms. In addition, natural population analysis, atoms-in-molecules analysis, and energy decomposition analysis have been employed to explore the nature of bonding existing in Eu-O and Eu-N bonds.

Recent Advances in the Study of Trivalent Lanthanides and Actinides by Phosphinic and Thiophosphinic Ligands in Condensed Phases

The separation of trivalent actinides and lanthanides is a key step in the sustainable development of nuclear energy, and it is currently mainly realized via liquid-liquid extraction techniques. The underlying mechanism is complicated and remains ambiguous, which hinders the further development of extraction. Herein, to better understand the mechanism of the extraction, the contributing factors for the extraction are discussed (specifically, the sulfur-donating ligand, Cyanex301) by combing molecular dynamics simulations and experiments. This work is expected to contribute to improve our systematic understanding on a molecular scale of the extraction of lanthanides and actinides, and to assist in the extensive studies on the design and optimization of novel ligands with improved performance.

Theoretical Study on the Coordination and Separation Capacity of Macrocyclic N-Donor Extractants for Am(III)/Eu(III)

Designing ligands that can effectively separate actinide An(III)/lanthanide Ln(III) in the solvent extraction process remains one of the key issues in the treatment of accumulated spent nuclear fuel. Nitrogen donor ligands are considered as promising extractants for the separation of An(III) and Ln(III) due to their environmental friendliness. Four new macrocyclic N-donor hexadentate extractants were designed and their coordination with Am(III) and Eu(III), as well as their extraction selectivity and separation performance for Am(III) and Eu(III), were investigated by scalar relativistic density functional theory. A variety of theoretical methods have been used to evaluate the properties of the four ligands and the coordination structures, bonding properties, and thermodynamic properties of the complexes formed by the four ligands with Am(III) and Eu(III). The results of various wavefunction analysis methods including NBO analysis, quantum theory of atoms in molecules (QTAIM) analysis, and so on show that Am(III) has a stronger coordination ability with the ligands than Eu(III) due to the Am 5f orbitals more involved in bonding with the ligands than the Eu 4f orbitals, and the bonding environment of the N-donor in the ligand has a significant effect on its coordination ability of the metal ions. Thermodynamic analysis of the solvent extraction process shows that all of the four N-containing macrocyclic ligands have good extraction selectivity and separation performance for Am(III) and Eu(III). This study provides theoretical support for designing potential nitrogen-containing macrocyclic extractants with excellent separation performance.

Synthesis and Application of a Novel Metal-Organic Frameworks-Based Ion-Imprinted Polymer for Effective Removal of Co(II) from Simulated Radioactive Wastewater

In this work, a novel metal-organic frameworks (MOFs)-based ion-imprinted polymer (MIIP) was prepared to remove Co(II) from simulated radioactive wastewater. The batch experiments indicated that the sorption was well described by the pseudo-second-order kinetic and Langmuir models, and it is monolayer chemisorption. The theoretical maximum sorption capacity was estimated to be 181.5 mg∙g^-1, which is by far the reported maximum value of Co(II) sorption by the imprinted materials. The MIIP presented an excellent selectivity for Co(II) in the presence of common monovalent and divalent metal ions, and the selectivity coefficients were 44.31, 33.19, 10.84, 27.71, 9.45, 16.25, and 7.60 to Li(I), K(I), Mg(II), Ca(II), Mn(II), Ba(II), and Cd(II), respectively. The sorption mechanism was explored by X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy (XPS) technology and density functional theory (DFT) calculations, suggesting that Co(II) was adsorbed by the MIIP via the chelation of 4-vinylpyridine (VP) ligands with Co(II), which was a spontaneous process, and the optimal coordination ratio of VP to Co(II) was 6. This work suggested that the MIIP has a high sorption capacity and excellent selectivity for Co(II), which is of great significance for the selective separation of Co-60 from radioactive wastewater.

Chelation Behaviors of 3,4,3-LI(1,2-HOPO) with Lanthanides and Actinides Implicated by Molecular Dynamics Simulations

The hydroxypyridinone ligand 3,4,3-LI(1,2-HOPO) (denoted as t-HOPO) is a potential chelator agent for decorporation of in vivo actinides (An), while its coordination modes with actinides and the dynamics of the complexes (An(t-HOPO)) in aqueous phase remain unclear. Here, we report molecular dynamics simulations of the complexes with key actinides (Am³⁺, Cm³⁺, Th⁴⁺, U⁴⁺, Np⁴⁺, Pu⁴⁺) to study their coordination and dynamic behaviors. For comparison, the complexation of the ligand with a ferric ion and key lanthanides (Sm³⁺, Eu³⁺, Gd³⁺) was also studied. The simulations show that the nature of metal ions determines the properties of the complexes. The t-HOPO in the Fe^III(t-HOPO)^1- complex ion formed a compact and rigid cage to encapsulate the ferric ion, which was hexa-coordinated. Ln³⁺/An³⁺ cations were ennea-coordinated with eight ligating oxygen atoms from t-HOPO and one from an aqua ligand, and An⁴⁺ cations were deca-coordinated with a second aqua ligand. The t-HOPO shows strong affinity for metal ions (stronger for An⁴⁺ than Ln³⁺/An³⁺) benefited from its high denticity and its flexible backbone. Meanwhile, the complexes displayed different dynamic flexibilities, with the An^IV(t-HOPO) complexes more significant than the others, and in the An^IV(t-HOPO) complexes, the fluctuation of the t-HOPO ligand was highly correlated with that of the eight ligating O atoms. This is attributed to the more compact conformation of the ligand, which raises backbone tension, and the competition of the aqua ligand against the t-HOPO ligand in coordinating with the tetravalent actinides. This work enriches our understanding on the structures and conformational dynamics of the complexes of actinides with t-HOPO and is expected to benefit the design of HOPO analogues for actinide sequestering.

Quantifying the Influence of Covalent Metal-Ligand Bonding on Differing Reactivity of Trivalent Uranium and Lanthanide Complexes

Qualitative differences in the reactivity of trivalent lanthanide and actinide complexes have long been attributed to differences in covalent metal-ligand bonding, but there are few examples where thermodynamic aspects of this relationship have been quantified, especially with U³⁺ and in the absence of competing variables. Here we report a series of dimeric phosphinodiboranate complexes with trivalent f-metals that show how shorter-than-expected U-B distances indicative of increased covalency give rise to measurable differences in solution deoligomerization reactivity when compared to isostructural complexes with similarly sized lanthanides. These results, which are in excellent agreement with supporting DFT and QTAIM calculations, afford rare experimental evidence concerning the measured effect of variations in metal-ligand covalency on the reactivity of trivalent uranium and lanthanide complexes.

Biphasic Behaviors of Nd3+ Bound with Cyanex272, Cyanex301, and Cyanex302: A Molecular Dynamics Simulation Study

By means of molecular dynamics simulations, this work addresses the conformational flexibility and migration of trivalent neodymium (Nd³⁺) coordinated with three or six titled (thio)phosphinic ligands and shows that the fluxionality of the complexes enables them to adapt to the solvent environment during the migration. Cyanex272 forms a more compact complex than the other two types of ligands and screens more significantly the interaction between the water solvent and the metal ion in the complex, which weakens the detainment of the aqueous environment. This results in faster motion of the Nd(C272)₃ complex both in its translation and rotation than the other complexes when migrating to the organic phase and wins over the other two ligands in transporting the metal ions from the aqueous phase to the organic phase. Depending on the solvent environment, these complexes may take two types of conformations to balance the forces from the environment benefited from their fluxionality. The migration of the M:L = 1:6 complexes, Nd[H(C272)₂]₃ and Nd[H(C301)₂]₃, was also investigated. The rich presence of the alkyl groups in the complexes screens the influence of the aqueous environment and benefits the transportation of metal ions to the interface. This work is expected to contribute to the community of inorganic chemistry interested in the coordination chemistry of metal ions and their behaviors in the condensed phase.

Theoretical Insights into the Selective Separation of Am(III)/Eu(III) Using Hydrophilic Triazolyl-Based Ligands

Designing ligands with efficient actinide (An(III))/lanthanide (Ln(III)) separation performance is still one of the key issues for the disposal of accumulated radioactive waste and the recovery of minor actinides. Recently, the hydrophilic ligands as promising extractants in the innovative Selective ActiNide Extraction (i-SANEX) process show excellent selectivity for Am(III) over Eu(III), such as hydroxylated-based ligands. In this work, we investigated the selective back-extraction toward Am(III) over Eu(III) with three hydrophilic hydroxylated triazolyl-based ligands (the skeleton of pyridine L^a, bipyridine L^b, and phenanthroline L^c) using scalar-relativistic density functional theory. The properties of three hydrophilic hydroxylated ligands and the coordination structures, bonding nature, and thermodynamic properties of the Am(III) and Eu(III) complexes with three ligands have been evaluated using multiple theoretical methods. The results of molecular orbitals (MOs), quantum theory of atoms in molecules (QTAIMs), and natural bond orbital (NBO) reveal that Am-N bonds possess more covalent character compared to Eu-N bonds. The thermodynamic results indicate that the complexing ability of L^b and L^c with metal ions is almost the same, which is stronger than that of L^a. However, L^a has the best Am(III)/Eu(III) selectivity among three ligands, which is attributed to the largest difference in covalency between Am-N_trzl and Eu-N_trzl bonds in ML^a(NO₃)₃. This work provides an in-depth understanding of the preferential selectivity of the hydrophilic hydroxylated ligands with An(III) over Ln(III) and also provides theoretical support for designing potential hydrophilic ligands with excellent separation performance of Am(III)/Eu(III).