Proton Relay in Iron Porphyrins for Hydrogen Evolution Reaction

Proton Relays in Molecular Catalysis for Hydrogen Evolution and Oxidation: Lessons From the Mimicry of Hydrogenases and Electrochemical Kinetic Analyses

The active sites of metalloenzymes involved in small molecules activation often contain pendant bases that act as proton relay promoting proton-coupled electron-transfer processes. Here we focus on hydrogenases and on the reactions they catalyze, i. e. the hydrogen evolution and oxidation reactions. After a short description of these enzymes, we review some of the various biomimetic and bioinspired molecular systems that contain proton relays. We then provide the formal electrochemical framework required to decipher the key role of such proton relay to enhance catalysis in a single direction and discuss the few systems active for H2 evolution for which quantitative kinetic data are available. We finally highlight key parameters required to reach bidirectional catalysis (both hydrogen evolution and hydrogen oxidation catalyzed) and then transition to reversible catalysis (both reactions catalyzed in a narrow potential range) as well as illustrate these features on few systems from the literature.

Metal-Free Electrocatalytic Alkaline Water Splitting by Porous Macrocyclic Proton Sponges

Macrocycles are unique as they encapsulate and transfer guest molecules or ions and facilitate catalytic processes. Although metalated macrocycles are pivotal in electrocatalytic processes, using metal-free analogs has been rare. Following the strategy of Kanbara et al., we synthesized an azacalixarene macrocycle-N, N', N''-tris(p-aminophenyl)azacalix[3](2,6)pyridine (CalixNH2). The macrocycle encapsulates a proton in its cavity, maintaining the protonation even in highly alkaline media. Notably, it retains almost 50 % protonated form in 1 M KOH (~pH 14)-acting as a proton sponge. As hydrogen evolution is complex in alkaline media owing to sluggish water dissociation, we implemented the proton sponge (CalixNH2) in an alkaline hydrogen evolution reaction. Conjugated Porous polymers, TpCalix and DhaCalix, have been synthesized from the triamine-CalixNH2. The most efficient catalyst, TpCalix, has shown excellent performance in alkaline HER and OER in 1 M KOH (~pH 14), with low overpotentials of only 112(±2) and 290(±2) mV at 10 mA cm-2, respectively, and durable up to 24 hours. A full-cell reaction using TpCalix in both the cathode and anode exhibited a low full-cell voltage of 1.73 V and was stable for 12 hours. DFT calculations verified the tripyridinic core, which acts as the principal site for proton abstraction and binding.

Corrolato(oxo)antimony(V) Dimer with Hydrogen-Bond Donor Groups in Secondary Coordination Sphere as a Catalyst for Hydrogen Evolution Reaction

The focus is on developing alternative molecular catalysts using main-group elements and implementing strategic improvements for sustainable hydrogen production. For this purpose, a FB corrole with a (2-(2-((4-methylphenyl)sulfonamido)ethoxy)phenyl) group inserted into the meso position (C-10) of the corrole, along with its high-valent (corrolato)(oxo)antimony(V) dimer, was synthesized. In the crystal structure analysis of the FB corrole and the (corrolato)(oxo)antimony(V) dimer complex, it was noted that the sulfonamido group in the ligand periphery sits atop the corrole ring. The electrochemical hydrogen evolution reaction (HER) of the (corrolato)(oxo)antimony(V) dimer was studied and compared with a previously reported (corrolato)(oxo)antimony(V) complex, which lacks hydrogen-bond donor groups in the secondary coordination sphere. The newly designed molecules, featuring hydrogen-bond donor groups in the secondary coordination sphere, demonstrated clear superiority in the electrochemical HER. Controlled potential electrolysis was employed to evaluate the charge accumulation associated with hydrogen generation in a homogeneous three-electrode system in the presence of 50 mM TFA. The produced hydrogen exhibits a Faradaic efficiency of approximately 80.96%, a turnover frequency (TOF) of 0.44 h-1, and a production rate of 52.83 μL h-1, highlighting the effective catalytic activity of the (corrolato)(oxo)antimony(V) dimer in hydrogen evolution.

Bioinspired Diiron Complex with Proton Shuttling and Redox-Active Ligand for Electrocatalytic Hydrogen Evolution

A μ-oxo diiron complex, featuring the pyridine-2,6-dicarboxamide-based thiazoline-derived redox-active ligand, H2L (H2L = N2,N6-bis(4,5-dihydrothiazol-2-yl)pyridine-2,6-dicarboxamide), was synthesized and thoroughly characterized. [FeIII-(μ-O)-FeIII] showed electrocatalytic hydrogen evolution reaction activity in the presence of different organic acids of varying pKa values in dimethylformamide. Through electrochemical analysis, we found that [FeIII-(μ-O)-FeIII] is a precatalyst that undergoes concerted two-electron reduction to generate an active catalyst. Fourier transform infrared spectrum of reduced species and density functional theory (DFT) investigation indicate that the active catalyst contains a bridged hydroxo unit which serves as a local proton source for the Fe(III) hydride intermediate to release H2. We propose that in this active catalyst, the thiazolinium moiety acts as a proton-transferring group. Additionally, under sufficiently strong acidic conditions, bridged oxygen gets protonated before two-electron reduction. In the presence of exogenous acids of varying strengths, it displays electro-assisted catalytic response at a distinct applied potential. Stepwise electron-transfer and protonation reactions on the metal center and the ligand were studied through DFT to understand the thermodynamically favorable pathways. An ECEC or EECC mechanism is proposed depending on the acid strength and applied potential.

Switchable molecular electrocatalysis

We demonstrate a switchable electrocatalysis mechanism modulated by hydrogen bonding interactions in ligand geometries. By manipulating these geometries, specific electrochemical processes at a single catalytic site can be selectively and precisely activated or deactivated. The α geometry enhances dioxygen electroreduction (ORR) while inhibiting protium redox processes, with the opposite effect seen in the β geometry. Intramolecular hydrogen bonding in the α geometry boosts electron density at the catalytic center, facilitating a shift of ORR to a 4-electron pathway. Conversely, the β geometry promotes a 2-electron ORR and facilitates electrocatalytic hydrogen evolution through an extensive proton charge assembly; offering a paradigm shift to conventional electrocatalytic principles. The expectations that ligand geometry induced electron density modulations in the catalytic metal centre would have a comparable impact on both ORR and HER has been questioned due to the contrasting reactivity exhibited by α-geometry and β-geometry molecules. This further emphasizes the complex and intriguing nature of the roles played by ligands in molecular electrocatalysis.

Redox Active Ligands for Catalyzing the Hydrogen Evolution Reaction

Boron subphthalocyanines with chloride and fluoride axial ligands and three antimony complexes chelated by corroles that differ in size and electron-richness were examined as electrocatalysts for reduction of protons to hydrogen. Experiment- and computation-based investigations revealed that all redox events are ligand-centered and that the meso-C of the corroles and the peripheral N atoms of the subphthalocyanines are the largely preferred proton-binding sites.

Long-range electrostatic effects from intramolecular Lewis acid binding influence the redox properties of cobalt-porphyrin complexes

A CoII-porphyrin complex (1) with an appended aza-crown ether for Lewis acid (LA) binding was synthesized and characterized. NMR spectroscopy and electrochemistry show that cationic group I and II LAs (i.e., Li+, Na+, K+, Ca2+, Sr2+, and Ba2+) bind to the aza-crown ether group of 1. The binding constant for Li+ is comparable to that observed for a free aza-crown ether. LA binding causes an anodic shift in the CoII/CoI couple of between 10 and 40 mV and also impacts the CoIII/CoII couple. The magnitude of the anodic shift of the CoII/CoI couple varies linearly with the strength of the LA as determined by the pKa of the corresponding metal-aqua complex, with dications giving larger shifts than monocations. The extent of the anodic shift of the CoII/CoI couple also increases as the ionic strength of the solution decreases. This is consistent with electric field effects being responsible for the changes in the redox properties of 1 upon LA binding and provides a novel method to tune the reduction potential. Density functional theory calculations indicate that the bound LA is 5.6 to 6.8 Å away from the CoII ion, demonstrating that long-range electrostatic effects, which do not involve changes to the primary coordination sphere, are responsible for the variations in redox chemistry. Compound 1 was investigated as a CO2 reduction electrocatalyst and shows high activity but rapid decomposition.

Exploring the Multifarious Role of the Ligand in Electrocatalytic Hydrogen Evolution Reaction Pathways

In recent years, researchers have shifted their focus towards investigating the redox properties of ancillary ligand backbones for small-molecule activation. Several metal complexes have been reported for the electrocatalytic H2 evolution reaction (HER), providing valuable mechanistic insights. This process involves efficient coupling of electrons and protons. Redox-active ligands stipulate internal electron transfer and promote effective orbital overlap between metal and ligand, thereby, enabling efficient proton-coupled electron transfer reactions. Understanding such catalytic mechanisms requires thorough spectroscopic and computational analyses. Herein, we summarize recent examples of molecular electrocatalysts based on 3d transition metals that have significantly influenced mechanistic pathways, thus, emphasizing the multifaceted role of metal-ligand cooperativity.

Hydrogen evolution catalysis by a cobalt porphyrin peptide: A proposed role for porphyrin propionic acid groups

Cobalt microperoxidase-11 (CoMP11-Ac) is a cobalt porphyrin-peptide catalyst for hydrogen (H2) evolution from water. Herein, we assess electrocatalytic activity of CoMP11-Ac from pH 1.0-10.0. This catalyst remains intact and active under highly acidic conditions (pH 1.0) that are desirable for maximizing H2 evolution activity. Analysis of electrochemical data indicate that H2 evolution takes place by two pH-dependent mechanisms. At pH < 4.3, a proton transfer mechanism involving the propionic acid groups of the porphyrin is proposed, decreasing the catalytic overpotential by 280 mV.

Chitosan-Derived Nitrogen-Doped Carbon as a Support of Cobalt(II)-Phthalocyanine/Gold Nanoparticles for Photocatalytic Water Splitting

Water splitting is considered one of the worthy approaches to generate hydrogen as a green fuel with diverse applications. Promoting this reaction with the photocatalytic strategy enjoys a free source of solar energy, without the use of expensive instruments. In this research, gold nanoparticles and cobalt(II)-phthalocyanine were deposited on nitrogen-doped carbon, obtained from chitosan, to afford a photocatalytic water splitting at the rate of 792 mol molAu-1 h-1. Gold as the catalyst in contact with cobalt(II)-phthalocyanine as the sensitizer and nitrogen-doped carbon as the support/semiconductor provided a desired heterojunction for the photocatalytic purpose. The nanocomposite showed remarkable light harvesting in the region of visible light with a band gap of 2.01 eV. While a facile protocol to the synthesis of the mentioned photocatalyst by a simple thermal treatment of cobalt(II)-phthalocyanine and chitosan could be invaluable, this research pointed out the significance of cobalt(II)-phthalocyanine as the sensitizer in the gold photocatalytic transformations.

Proton transfer kinetics of transition metal hydride complexes and implications for fuel-forming reactions

Proton transfer reactions involving transition metal hydride complexes are prevalent in a number of catalytic fuel-forming reactions, where the proton transfer kinetics to or from the metal center can have significant impacts on the efficiency, selectivity, and stability associated with the catalytic cycle. This review correlates the often slow proton transfer rate constants of transition metal hydride complexes to their electronic and structural descriptors and provides perspective on how to exploit these parameters to control proton transfer kinetics to and from the metal center. A toolbox of techniques for experimental determination of proton transfer rate constants is discussed, and case studies where proton transfer rate constant determination informs fuel-forming reactions are highlighted. Opportunities for extending proton transfer kinetic measurements to additional systems are presented, and the importance of synergizing the thermodynamics and kinetics of proton transfer involving transition metal hydride complexes is emphasized.

Electrocatalytic hydrogen evolution with a copper porphyrin bearing meso-(o-carborane) substituents

A newly designed copper complex of 5,15-bis(pentafluorophenyl)-10,20-bis(o-carborane)porphyrin (1) was synthesized and tested for the electrocatalytic hydrogen evolution reaction (HER). In acetonitrile, 1 was much more efficient than Cu 5,15-bis(pentafluorophenyl)-10,20-diphenylporphyrin (2) for electrocatalytic HER by shifting the catalytic wave to the anodic direction by 190 mV. In aqueous media, 1 also outperformed 2 by achieving higher current densities under smaller overpotentials. This enhancement was attributed to the aromatic and the strong electron-withdrawing properties of o-carborane groups. This work is significant to address the crucial effects of meso-(o-carborane) substituents of metal porphyrins on boosting the electrocatalytic HER.

Investigation of Iron(III) Tetraphenylporphyrin as a Redox Flow Battery Anolyte: Unexpected Side Reactivity with the Electrolyte

Redox flow batteries (RFBs) present an opportunity to bridge the gap between the intermittent availability of green energy sources and the need for on-demand grid level energy storage. While aqueous vanadium-based redox flow batteries have been commercialized, they are limited by the constraints of using water as an electrochemical solvent. Nonaqueous redox flow battery systems can be used to produce high voltage batteries due to the larger electrochemical window in nonaqueous solvents and the ability to tune the redox properties of active materials through functionalization. Iron porphyrins, a class of organometallic macrocycles, have been the subject of many studies for their photocatalytic and electrocatalytic properties in nonaqueous solvents. Often, iron porphyrins can undergo multiple redox events making them interesting candidates for use as anolytes in asymmetrical redox flow batteries or as both catholyte and anolyte in symmetrical redox flow battery systems. Here the electrochemical properties of Fe(III)TPP species relevant to redox flow battery electrolytes are investigated including solubility, electrochemical properties, and charge/discharge cycling. Commonly used support electrolyte salts can have reactivities that are often overlooked beyond their conductivity properties in nonaqueous solvents. Parasitic reactions with the cations of common support electrolytes are highlighted herein, which underscore the careful balance required to fully assess the potential of novel RFB electrolytes.

Substituent Effect on Ligand-Centered Electrocatalytic Hydrogen Evolution of Phosphorus Corroles

There have been few reports on the substituent effect of main-group-element corrole complexes as ligand-centered homogeneous electrocatalysts for the hydrogen evolution reaction (HER). The key to comprehend the catalytic mechanism and develop efficient catalysts is the elucidation of the effects of electronic structure on the performance of energy-related small molecules. In this work, the "push-pull" electronic effect of the substituents on electrocatalytic HER of phosphorus corroles was investigated by using 5,10,15-tris(phenyl) corrole phosphorus (1P), 10-pentafluorophenyl-5,15-bis(phenyl) corrole phosphorus (2P), 10-phenyl-5,15-bis(pentafluorophenyl) corrole phosphorus (3P), 5,10,15-tris(pentafluorophenyl) corrole phosphorus (4P) complexes bearing hydroxyl axial ligands and different numbers of fluorine atoms on the meso-aryl substituents. The results revealed that the catalytic HER activity of phosphorus corroles decreased with the increasing of fluorine atom numbers, it follows in the order 1P>2P>3P>4P. Density functional theory (DFT) calculations show that the corrole 1P has the lowest free energy barrier in catalytic HER.

Enzymatic and Bioinspired Systems for Hydrogen Production

The extraordinary potential of hydrogen as a clean and sustainable fuel has sparked the interest of the scientific community to find environmentally friendly methods for its production. Biological catalysts are the most attractive solution, as they usually operate under mild conditions and do not produce carbon-containing byproducts. Hydrogenases promote reversible proton reduction to hydrogen in a variety of anoxic bacteria and algae, displaying unparallel catalytic performances. Attempts to use these sophisticated enzymes in scalable hydrogen production have been hampered by limitations associated with their production and stability. Inspired by nature, significant efforts have been made in the development of artificial systems able to promote the hydrogen evolution reaction, via either electrochemical or light-driven catalysis. Starting from small-molecule coordination compounds, peptide- and protein-based architectures have been constructed around the catalytic center with the aim of reproducing hydrogenase function into robust, efficient, and cost-effective catalysts. In this review, we first provide an overview of the structural and functional properties of hydrogenases, along with their integration in devices for hydrogen and energy production. Then, we describe the most recent advances in the development of homogeneous hydrogen evolution catalysts envisioned to mimic hydrogenases.

Investigation of Molecular Mechanism of Cobalt Porphyrin Catalyzed CO2 Electrochemical Reduction in Ionic Liquid by In-Situ SERS

This study explores the electrochemical reduction in CO₂ using room temperature ionic liquids as solvents or electrolytes, which can minimize the environmental impact of CO₂ emissions. To design effective CO₂ electrochemical systems, it is crucial to identify intermediate surface species and reaction products in situ. The study investigates the electrochemical reduction in CO₂ using a cobalt porphyrin molecular immobilized electrode in 1-n-butyl-3-methyl imidazolium tetrafluoroborate (BMI.BF4) room temperature ionic liquids, through in-situ surface-enhanced Raman spectroscopy (SERS) and electrochemical technique. The results show that the highest faradaic efficiency of CO produced from the electrochemical reduction in CO₂ can reach 98%. With the potential getting more negative, the faradaic efficiency of CO decreases while H₂ is produced as a competitive product. Besides, water protonates porphyrin macrocycle, producing pholorin as the key intermediate for the hydrogen evolution reaction, leading to the out-of-plane mode of the porphyrin molecule. Absorption of CO₂ by the ionic liquids leads to the formation of BMI·CO₂ adduct in BMI·BF₄ solution, causing vibration modes at 1100, 1457, and 1509 cm^-1. However, the key intermediate of CO2-· radical is not observed. The υ(CO) stretching mode of absorbed CO is affected by the electrochemical Stark effect, typical of CO chemisorbed on a top site.

Substituent Effects in Iron Porphyrin Catalysts for the Hydrogen Evolution Reaction

For a future hydrogen economy, non-precious metal catalysts for the water splitting reactions are needed that can be implemented on a global scale. Metal-nitrogen-carbon (MNC) catalysts with active sites constituting a metal center with fourfold coordination of nitrogen (MN₄ ) show promising performance, but an optimization rooted in structure-property relationships has been hampered by their low structural definition. Porphyrin model complexes are studied to transfer insights from well-defined molecules to MNC systems. This work combines experiment and theory to evaluate the influence of porphyrin substituents on the electronic and electrocatalytic properties of MN₄ centers with respect to the hydrogen evolution reaction (HER) in aqueous electrolyte. We found that the choice of substituent affects their utilization on the carbon support and their electrocatalytic performance. We propose an HER mechanism for supported iron porphyrin complexes involving a [Fe^II (P⋅)]^- radical anion intermediate, in which a porphinic nitrogen atom acts as an internal base. While this work focuses on the HER, the limited influence of a simultaneous interaction with the support and an aqueous electrolyte will likely be transferrable to other catalytic applications.

Amine Groups in the Second Sphere of Iron Porphyrins Allow for Higher and Selective 4e-/4H+ Oxygen Reduction Rates at Lower Overpotentials

Iron porphyrins with one or four tertiary amine groups in their second sphere are used to investigate the electrochemical O₂ reduction reaction (ORR) in organic (homogeneous) and aqueous (heterogeneous) conditions. Both of these complexes show selective 4e^-/4H⁺ reduction of oxygen to water at rates that are 2-3 orders of magnitude higher than those of iron tetraphenylporphyrin lacking these amines in the second sphere. In organic solvents, these amines get protonated, which leads to the lowering of overpotentials, and the rate of the ORR is enhanced almost 75,000 times relative to rates expected from the established scaling relationship for the ORR by iron porphyrins. In the aqueous medium, the same trend of higher ORR rates at a lower overpotential is observed. In situ resonance Raman data under heterogeneous aqueous conditions show that the presence of one amine group in the second sphere leads to a cleavage of the O-O bond in a Fe^III-OOH intermediate as the rate-determining step (rds). The presence of four such amine groups enhances the rate of O-O bond cleavage such that this intermediate is no longer observed during the ORR; rather, the proton-coupled reduction of the Fe^III-O₂^- intermediate with a H/D isotope effect of 10.6 is the rds. These data clearly demonstrate changes in the rds of the electrochemical ORR depending on the nature of second-sphere residues and explain their deviation from linear scaling relationships.

Silver nanostructure-modified graphite electrode for in-operando SERRS investigation of iron porphyrins during high-potential electrocatalysis

In-operando spectroscopic observation of the intermediates formed during various electrocatalytic oxidation and reduction reactions is crucial to propose the mechanism of the corresponding reaction. Surface-enhanced resonance Raman spectroscopy coupled to rotating disk electrochemistry (SERRS-RDE), developed about a decade ago, proved to be an excellent spectroscopic tool to investigate the mechanism of heterogeneous oxygen reduction reaction (ORR) catalyzed by synthetic iron porphyrin complexes under steady-state conditions in water. The information about the formation of the intermediates accumulated during the course of the reaction at the electrode interface helped to develop better ORR catalysts with second sphere residues in the porphyrin rings. To date, the application of this SERRS-RDE setup is limited to ORR only because the thiol self-assembled monolayer (SAM)-modified Ag electrode, used as the working electrode in these experiments, suffers from stability issues at more cathodic and anodic potential, where H₂O oxidation, CO₂ reduction, and H⁺ reduction reactions occur. The current investigation shows the development of a second-generation SERRS-RDE setup consisting of an Ag nanostructure (AgNS)-modified graphite electrode as the working electrode. These electrodes show higher stability (compared to the conventional thiol SAM-modified Ag electrode) upon exposure to very high cathodic and anodic potential with a good signal-to-noise ratio in the Raman spectra. The behavior of this modified electrode toward ORR is found to be the same as the SAM-modified Ag electrode, and the same ORR intermediates are observed during electrochemical ORR. At higher cathodic potential, the signatures of Fe(0) porphyrin, an important intermediate in H⁺ and CO₂ reduction reactions, was observed at the electrode-water interface.

Through-Space Electrostatic Effects of Positively Charged Substituents on the Hydrogen Evolution Reaction

Elucidating the effects of various structural components on energy-related small molecule activation is of fundamental and practical significance. Herein the inhibition effect of positively charged substituents on the hydrogen evolution reaction (HER) was reported. With the use of Cu porphyrins 1-5 containing different numbers and locations of positively charged substituents, it was demonstrated that their electrocatalytic HER activities significantly decreased when more cationic units were located close to the Cu ion: the i_cat /i_p (i_cat is the catalytic peak current, i_p is the one-electron reduction peak current) value decreased from 38 with zero cationic unit to 15 with four closely located cationic units. Inspired by this result, Cu porphyrin 6, with four meso-phenyl groups each bearing a negatively charged para-sulfonic substituent, was designed. With these anionic units, 6 outperformed the other Cu porphyrins for electrocatalytic HER under the same conditions.

Introducing Water-Network-Assisted Proton Transfer for Boosted Electrocatalytic Hydrogen Evolution with Cobalt Corrole

Proton transfer is vital for many biological and chemical reactions. Hydrogen-bonded water-containing networks are often found in enzymes to assist proton transfer, but similar strategy has been rarely presented by synthetic catalysts. We herein report the Co corrole 1 with an appended crown ether unit and its boosted activity for the hydrogen evolution reaction (HER). Crystallographic and 1H NMR studies proved that the crown ether of 1 can grab water via hydrogen bonds. By using protic acids as proton sources, the HER activity of 1 was largely boosted with added water, while the activity of crown-ether-free analogues showed very small enhancement. Inhibition studies by adding (1) external 18-crown-6-ether to extract water molecules and (2) potassium ion or N-benzyl-n-butylamine to block the crown ether of 1 further confirmed its critical role in assisting proton transfer via grabbed water molecules. This work presents a synthetic example to boost HER through water-containing networks.