Manganese Tricarbonyl Complexes with Asymmetric 2-Iminopyridine Ligands: Toward Decoupling Steric and Electronic Factors in Electrocatalytic CO2 Reduction

Mechanistic insights of electrocatalytic CO2 reduction by Mn complexes: synergistic effects of the ligands

The electrocatalytic mechanisms of CO2 reduction catalyzed by pyridine-oxazoline (pyrox)-based Mn catalysts were investigated by DFT calculations. In-depth comparative analyses of pyrox-based and bipyridine-based Mn complexes were carried out. C-OH cleavage is the rate-determining step for both the protonation-first path and the reduction-first path. The free energy of CO2 activation (ΔG1) and the electrons donated by CO ligands in this step are effective descriptors in regulating the C-OH cleavage barrier. The reduction of carboxylate complex 6 (E6) is the potential-determining step for the reduction-first path. Meanwhile, for the protonation-first path, the initial generation (E2) or the regeneration (E8) of active catalyst might be potential-determining. Hirshfeld charge and orbital contribution analysis indicate that E6 is definitely based on the heterocyclic ligand and E2 is related to both the heterocyclic ligand and three CO ligands. Therefore, replacement of the CO ligand by a stronger electron donating ligand can effectively boost the catalytic activity of CO2 reduction without increasing the overpotential in the reduction-first path. This hypothesis is supported by the mechanism calculations of the Mn complex in which the axial CO ligand is replaced by a pyridine or PMe3.

Analyzing Structure-Activity Variations for Mn-Carbonyl Complexes in the Reduction of CO2 to CO

Contemporary electrocatalysts for the reduction of CO₂ often suffer from low stability, activity, and selectivity, or a combination thereof. Mn-carbonyl complexes represent a promising class of molecular electrocatalysts for the reduction of CO₂ to CO as they are able to promote this reaction at relatively mild overpotentials, whereby rare-earth metals are not required. The electronic and geometric structure of the reaction center of these molecular electrocatalysts is precisely known and can be tuned via ligand modifications. However, ligand characteristics that are required to achieve high catalytic turnover at minimal overpotential remain unclear. We consider 55 Mn-carbonyl complexes, which have previously been synthesized and characterized experimentally. Four intermediates were identified that are common across all catalytic mechanisms proposed for Mn-carbonyl complexes, and their structures were used to calculate descriptors for each of the 55 Mn-carbonyl complexes. These electronic-structure-based descriptors encompass the binding energies, the highest occupied and lowest unoccupied molecular orbitals, and partial charges. Trends in turnover frequency and overpotential with these descriptors were analyzed to afford meaningful physical insights into what ligand characteristics lead to good catalytic performance, and how this is affected by the reaction conditions. These insights can be expected to significantly contribute to the rational design of more active Mn-carbonyl electrocatalysts.

Photocatalytic Reduction of CO2 to CO in Aqueous Solution under Red-Light Irradiation by a Zn-Porphyrin-Sensitized Mn(I) Catalyst

This work demonstrates photocatalytic CO₂ reduction by a noble-metal-free photosensitizer-catalyst system in aqueous solution under red-light irradiation. A water-soluble Mn(I) tricarbonyl diimine complex, [MnBr(4,4′-{Et₂O₃PCH₂}₂-2,2′-bipyridyl)(CO)₃] (1), has been fully characterized, including single-crystal X-ray crystallography, and shown to reduce CO₂ to CO following photosensitization by tetra(N-methyl-4-pyridyl)porphyrin Zn(II) tetrachloride [Zn(TMPyP)]Cl₄ (2) under 625 nm irradiation. This is the first example of 2 employed as a photosensitizer for CO₂ reduction. The incorporation of −P(O)(OEt)₂ groups, decoupled from the core of the catalyst by a −CH₂– spacer, afforded water solubility without compromising the electronic properties of the catalyst. The photostability of the active Mn(I) catalyst over prolonged periods of irradiation with red light was confirmed by ¹H and ¹³C{¹H} NMR spectroscopy. This first report on Mn(I) species as a homogeneous photocatalyst, working in water and under red light, illustrates further future prospects of intrinsically photounstable Mn(I) complexes as solar-driven catalysts in an aqueous environment.

A Mn(I) bipyridyl tricarbonyl complex, where the diimine ligand is functionalized with water-solubilizing phosphonate ester groups, has been prepared and is shown to catalytically convert CO₂ to CO in aqueous solution following photosensitization from a water-soluble Zn(II) porphyrin under red-light irradiation.

Metal-ligand cooperative approaches in homogeneous catalysis using transition metal complex catalysts of redox noninnocent ligands

Catalysis offers a straightforward route to prepare various value-added molecules starting from readily available raw materials. The catalytic reactions mostly involve multi-electron transformations. Hence, compared to the inexpensive and readily available 3d-metals, the 4d and 5d-transition metals get an extra advantage for performing multi-electron catalytic reactions as the heavier transition metals prefer two-electron redox events. However, for sustainable development, these expensive and scarce heavy metal-based catalysts need to be replaced by inexpensive, environmentally benign, and economically affordable 3d-metal catalysts. In this regard, a metal-ligand cooperative approach involving transition metal complexes of redox noninnocent ligands offers an attractive alternative. The synergistic participation of redox-active ligands during electron transfer events allows multi-electron transformations using 3d-metal catalysts and allows interesting chemical transformations using 4d and 5d-metals as well. Herein we summarize an up-to-date literature report on the metal-ligand cooperative approaches using transition metal complexes of redox noninnocent ligands as catalysts for a few selected types of catalytic reactions.

Effect of the 2-R-Allyl and Chloride Ligands on the Cathodic Paths of [Mo(η3-2-R-allyl)(α-diimine)(CO)2Cl] (R = H, CH3; α-diimine = 6,6'-Dimethyl-2,2'-bipyridine, Bis(p-tolylimino)acenaphthene)

The new, formally Mo(II) complexes [Mo(η3-2-R-allyl)(6,6'-dmbipy)(CO)2Cl] (6,6'-dmbipy = 6,6'-dimethyl-2,2'-bipyridine; 2-R-allyl = allyl for R = H, 2-methallyl for R = CH3) and [Mo(η3-2-methallyl)(pTol-bian)(CO)2Cl] (pTol-bian = bis(p-tolylimino)acenaphthene) share, in this rare case, the same structural type. The effect of the anionic π-donor ligand X (Cl- vs NCS-) and the 2-R-allyl substituents on the cathodic behavior was explored. Both ligands play a significant role at all stages of the reduction path. While 2e--reduced [Mo(η3-allyl)(6,6'-dmbipy)(CO)2]- is inert when it is ECE-generated from [Mo(η3-allyl)(6,6'-dmbipy)(CO)2(NCS)], the Cl- ligand promotes Mo-Mo dimerization by facilitating the nucleophilic attack of [Mo(η3-allyl)(6,6'-dmbipy)(CO)2]- at the parent complex at ambient temperature. The replacement of the allyl ligand by 2-methallyl has a similar effect. The Cl-/2-methallyl ligand assembly destabilizes even primary radical anions of the complex containing the strongly π-accepting pTol-Bian ligand. Under argon, the cathodic paths of [Mo(η3-2-R-allyl)(6,6'-dmbipy)(CO)2Cl] terminate at ambient temperature with 5-coordinate [Mo(6,6'-dmbipy)(CO)3]2- instead of [Mo(η3-2-R-allyl)(6,6'-dmbipy)(CO)2]-, which is stabilized in chilled electrolyte. [Mo(η3-allyl)(6,6'-dmbipy)(CO)2]- catalyzes CO2 reduction only when it is generated at the second cathodic wave of the parent complex, while [Mo(η3-2-methallyl)(6,6'-dmbipy)(CO)2]- is already moderately active at the first cathodic wave. This behavior is fully consistent with absent dimerization under argon on the cyclic voltammetric time scale. The electrocatalytic generation of CO and formate is hampered by the irreversible formation of anionic tricarbonyl complexes replacing reactive [Mo(η3-2-methallyl)(6,6'-dmbipy)(CO)2]2 along the cathodic route.

Transition Metal Complexes as Catalysts for the Electroconversion of CO2 : An Organometallic Perspective

The electrocatalytic transformation of carbon dioxide has been a topic of interest in the field of CO2 utilization for a long time. Recently, the area has seen increasing dynamics as an alternative strategy to catalytic hydrogenation for CO2 reduction. While many studies focus on the direct electron transfer to the CO2 molecule at the electrode material, molecular transition metal complexes in solution offer the possibility to act as catalysts for the electron transfer. C1 compounds such as carbon monoxide, formate, and methanol are often targeted as the main products, but more elaborate transformations are also possible within the coordination sphere of the metal center. This perspective article will cover selected examples to illustrate and categorize the currently favored mechanisms for the electrochemically induced transformation of CO2 promoted by homogeneous transition metal complexes. The insights will be corroborated with the concepts and elementary steps of organometallic catalysis to derive potential strategies to broaden the molecular diversity of possible products.

Strong Impact of Intramolecular Hydrogen Bonding on the Cathodic Path of [Re(3,3'-dihydroxy-2,2'-bipyridine)(CO)3Cl] and Catalytic Reduction of Carbon Dioxide

Herein, we present the cathodic paths of the Group-7 metal complex [Re(3,3'-DHBPY)(CO)₃Cl] (3,3'-DHBPY = 3,3'-dihydroxy-2,2'-bipyridine) producing a moderately active catalyst of electrochemical reduction of CO₂ to CO. The combined techniques of cyclic voltammetry and IR/UV-vis spectroelectrochemistry have revealed significant differences in the chemistry of the electrochemically reduced parent complex compared to the previously published Re/4,4'-DHBPY congener. The initial irreversible cathodic step in weakly coordinating THF is shifted toward much less negative electrode potentials, reflecting facile reductive deprotonation of one hydroxyl group and strong intramolecular hydrogen bonding, O-H···O^-. The latter process occurs spontaneously in basic dimethylformamide where Re/4,4'-DHBPY remains stable. The subsequent reduction of singly deprotonated [Re(3,3'-DHBPY-H⁺)(CO)₃Cl]^- under ambient conditions occurs at a cathodic potential close to that of the Re/4,4'-DHBPY-H⁺ derivative. However, for the stabilized 3,3'-DHBPY-H⁺ ligand, the latter process at the second cathodic wave is more complex and involves an overall transfer of three electrons. Rapid potential step electrolysis induces 1e^--reductive cleavage of the second O-H bond, triggering dissociation of the Cl^- ligand from [Re(3,3'-DHBPY-2H⁺)(CO)₃Cl]^2-. The ultimate product of the second cathodic step in THF was identified as 5-coordinate [Re(3,3'-DHBPY-2H⁺)(CO)₃]^3-, the equivalent of classical 2e^--reduced [Re(BPY)(CO)₃]^-. Each reductive deprotonation of the DHBPY ligand results in a redshift of the IR ν(CO) absorption of the tricarbonyl complexes by ca. 10 cm^-1, facilitating the product assignment based on comparison with the literature data for corresponding Re/BPY complexes. The Cl^- dissociation from [Re(3,3'-DHBPY-2H⁺)(CO)₃Cl]^2- was proven in strongly coordinating butyronitrile. The latter dianion is stable at 223 K, converting at 258 K to 6-coordinate [Re(3,3'-DHBPY-2H⁺)(CO)₃(PrCN)]^3-. Useful reference data were obtained with substituted parent [Re(3,3'-DHBPY)(CO)₃(PrCN)]⁺ that also smoothly deprotonates by the initial reduction to [Re(3,3'-DHBPY-H⁺)(CO)₃(PrCN)]. The latter complex ultimately converts at the second cathodic wave to [Re(3,3'-DHBPY-2H⁺)(CO)₃(PrCN)]^3- via a counterintuitive ETC step generating the 1e^- radical of the parent complex, viz., [Re(3,3'-DHBPY)(CO)₃(PrCN)]. The same alternative reduction path is also followed by [Re(3,3'-DHBPY-H⁺)(CO)₃Cl]^- at the onset of the second cathodic wave, where the ETC step results in the intermediate [Re(3,3'-DHBPY)(CO)₃Cl]^•- further reducible to [Re(3,3'-DHBPY-2H⁺)(CO)₃]^3- as the CO₂ catalyst.

Ultrafast Spectroscopy of [Mn(CO)3] Complexes: Tuning the Kinetics of Light-Driven CO Release and Solvent Binding

Manganese tricarbonyl complexes are promising catalysts for CO₂ reduction, but complexes in this family are often photosensitive and decompose rapidly upon exposure to visible light. In this report, synthetic and photochemical studies probe the initial steps of light-driven speciation for Mn(CO)₃(^Rbpy)Br complexes bearing a range of 4,4'-disubstituted 2,2'-bipyridyl ligands (^Rbpy, where R = ^tBu, H, CF₃, NO₂). Transient absorption spectroscopy measurements for Mn(CO)₃(^Rbpy)Br coordination compounds with R = ^tBu, H, and CF₃ in acetonitrile reveal ultrafast loss of a CO ligand on the femtosecond time scale, followed by solvent coordination on the picosecond time scale. The Mn(CO)₃(^NO₂bpy)Br complex is unique among the four compounds in having a longer-lived excited state that does not undergo CO release or subsequent solvent coordination. The kinetics of photolysis and solvent coordination for light-sensitive complexes depend on the electronic properties of the disubstituted bipyridyl ligand. The results indicate that both metal-to-ligand charge-transfer (MLCT) and dissociative ligand-field (d-d) excited states play a role in the ultrafast photochemistry. Taken together, the findings suggest that more robust catalysts could be prepared with appropriately designed complexes that avoid crossing between the excited states that drive photochemical CO loss.

A bis(thiosemicarbazonato)-copper complex, a new catalyst for electro- and photo-reduction of CO2 to methanol

A bis(thiosemicarbazonato)-copper complex, a new catalyst for electro- and photo-reduction of CO₂ to methanol.

Sterically hindered Re- and Mn-CO2 reduction catalysts for solar energy conversion

Novel molecular Re and Mn tricarbonyl complexes bearing a bipyridyl ligand functionalised with sterically hindering substituents in the 6,6'-position, [M(HPEAB)(CO)3(X)] (M/X = Re/Cl, Mn/Br; HPEAB = 6,6'-{N-(4-hexylphenyl)-N(ethyl)-amido}-2,2'-bipyridine) have been synthesised, fully characterised including by single crystal X-ray crystallography, and their propensity to act as catalysts for the electrochemical and photochemical reduction of CO2 has been established. Controlled potential electrolysis showed that the catalysts are effective for electrochemical CO2-reduction, yielding CO as the product (in MeCN for the Re-complex, in 95 : 5 (v/v) MeCN : H2O mixture for the Mn-complex). The recyclability of the catalysts was demonstrated through replenishment of CO2 within solution. The novel catalysts had similar reduction potentials to previously reported complexes of similar structure, and results of the foot-of-the-wave analysis showed comparable maximum turnover rates, too. The tentative mechanisms for activation of the pre-catalysts were proposed on the basis of IR-spectroelectrochemical data aided by DFT calculations. It is shown that the typical dimerisation of the Mn-catalyst was prevented by incorporation of sterically hindering groups, whilst the Re-catalyst undergoes the usual mechanism following chloride ion loss. No photochemical CO2 reduction was observed for the rhenium complex in the presence of a sacrificial donor (triethylamine), which was attributed to the short triplet excited state lifetime (3.6 ns), insufficient for diffusion-controlled electron transfer. Importantly, [Mn(HPEAB)(CO)3Br] can act as a CO2 reduction catalyst when photosensitised by a zinc porphyrin under red light irradiation (λ > 600 nm) in MeCN : H2O (95 : 5); there has been only one reported example of photoactivating Mn-catalysts with porphyrins in this manner. Thus, this work demonstrates the wide utility of sterically protected Re- and Mn-diimine carbonyl catalysts, where the rate and yield of CO-production can be adjusted based on the metal centre and catalytic conditions, with the advantage of suppressing unwanted side-reactions through steric protection of the vacant coordination site.

Electro- and Solar-Driven Fuel Synthesis with First Row Transition Metal Complexes

The synthesis of renewable fuels from abundant water or the greenhouse gas CO2 is a major step toward creating sustainable and scalable energy storage technologies. In the last few decades, much attention has focused on the development of nonprecious metal-based catalysts and, in more recent years, their integration in solid-state support materials and devices that operate in water. This review surveys the literature on 3d metal-based molecular catalysts and focuses on their immobilization on heterogeneous solid-state supports for electro-, photo-, and photoelectrocatalytic synthesis of fuels in aqueous media. The first sections highlight benchmark homogeneous systems using proton and CO2 reducing 3d transition metal catalysts as well as commonly employed methods for catalyst immobilization, including a discussion of supporting materials and anchoring groups. The subsequent sections elaborate on productive associations between molecular catalysts and a wide range of substrates based on carbon, quantum dots, metal oxide surfaces, and semiconductors. The molecule-material hybrid systems are organized as "dark" cathodes, colloidal photocatalysts, and photocathodes, and their figures of merit are discussed alongside system stability and catalyst integrity. The final section extends the scope of this review to prospects and challenges in targeting catalysis beyond "classical" H2 evolution and CO2 reduction to C1 products, by summarizing cases for higher-value products from N2 reduction, C x>1 products from CO2 utilization, and other reductive organic transformations.

A Highly Active N-Heterocyclic Carbene Manganese(I) Complex for Selective Electrocatalytic CO2 Reduction to CO

We report here the first purely organometallic fac-[MnI (CO)3 (bis-Me NHC)Br] complex with unprecedented activity for the selective electrocatalytic reduction of CO2 to CO, exceeding 100 turnovers with excellent faradaic yields (ηCO ≈95 %) in anhydrous CH3 CN. Under the same conditions, a maximum turnover frequency (TOFmax ) of 2100 s-1 was measured by cyclic voltammetry, which clearly exceeds the values reported for other manganese-based catalysts. Moreover, the addition of water leads to the highest TOFmax value (ca. 320 000 s-1 ) ever reported for a manganese-based catalyst. A MnI tetracarbonyl intermediate was detected under catalytic conditions for the first time.

Homogeneously Catalyzed Electroreduction of Carbon Dioxide-Methods, Mechanisms, and Catalysts

The utilization of CO₂ via electrochemical reduction constitutes a promising approach toward production of value-added chemicals or fuels using intermittent renewable energy sources. For this purpose, molecular electrocatalysts are frequently studied and the recent progress both in tuning of the catalytic properties and in mechanistic understanding is truly remarkable. While in earlier years research efforts were focused on complexes with rare metal centers such as Re, Ru, and Pd, the focus has recently shifted toward earth-abundant transition metals such as Mn, Fe, Co, and Ni. By application of appropriate ligands, these metals have been rendered more than competitive for CO₂ reduction compared to the heavier homologues. In addition, the important roles of the second and outer coordination spheres in the catalytic processes have become apparent, and metal-ligand cooperativity has recently become a well-established tool for further tuning of the catalytic behavior. Surprising advances have also been made with very simple organocatalysts, although the mechanisms behind their reactivity are not yet entirely understood. Herein, the developments of the last three decades in electrocatalytic CO₂ reduction with homogeneous catalysts are reviewed. A discussion of the underlying mechanistic principles is included along with a treatment of the experimental and computational techniques for mechanistic studies and catalyst benchmarking. Important catalyst families are discussed in detail with regard to mechanistic aspects, and recent advances in the field are highlighted.

Synthesis and coordination chemistry of the PPN ligand 2-[bis(diisopropylphosphanyl)methyl]-6-methylpyridine

The synthesis and crystal structure of the multidentate PPN ligand 2-[bis(diisopropylphosphanyl)methyl]-6-methylpyridine (L), C19H35NP2, are described. In the isostructural tetrahedral Fe and Co complexes of type LMCl2 (M = Fe, Co), namely {2-[bis(diisopropylphosphanyl)methyl]-6-methylpyridine-κ2 P,N}dichloridoiron(II), [FeCl2(C19H35NP2)], and {2-[bis(diisopropylphosphanyl)methyl]-6-methylpyridine-κ2 P,N}dichloridocobalt(II), [CoCl2(C19H35NP2)], the ligand adopts a bidentate P,N-coordination, whereas in the case of the octahedral Mn complex {2-[bis(diisopropylphosphanyl)methyl]-6-methylpyridine-κ2 P,P′}bromidotricarbonylmanganese(I), [MnBr(C19H35NP2)(CO)3], the ligand coordinates via both P atoms to the metal centre.

Chelated [Zn(cyclam)]2+Lewis acid improves the reactivity of the electrochemical reduction of CO2by Mn catalysts with bulky bipyridine ligands

This communication reports the use of a soluble Lewis acid complex, [Zn(cyclam)]²⁺(cyclam = 1,4,8,11-tetraazacyclotetradecane) as a co-catalyst coupled with Mn(Mesbpy)(CO)₃Br (Mesbpy = 6,6′-dimesityl-2,2′-bipyridine) for the electrochemical reduction of CO₂to CO.