Structural Determinants of Phosphopeptide Binding to the N-Terminal Src Homology 2 Domain of the SHP2 Phosphatase

Fluorescent Labeling Can Significantly Perturb Measured Binding Affinity and Selectivity of Peptide-Protein Interactions

Peptide-based drugs are powerful inhibitors of therapeutically relevant protein-protein interactions. Their affinity and selectivity for target proteins are commonly assessed using fluorescence-based assays such as anisotropy/polarization or quantitative microarrays. This study reveals that labeling can perturb peptide/protein binding by more than 1 order of magnitude. We have recently developed inhibitors targeted to the N-terminal Src homology 2 (SH2) domain of oncogenic phosphatase SHP2. Despite their high activity and selectivity, these molecules demonstrated an undesired interaction with the SH2 domain of another protein, known as APS, in a fluorescence microarray assay. Fluorescence anisotropy measurement in solution showed that the dissociation constant was significantly influenced by labeling (∼10 times), and the effect depended on the specific fluorophore and SH2 domain. Notably, displacement assays performed with unlabeled peptides were successfully used to eliminate these artifacts, demonstrating that the inhibitors' affinity for their target is over 1,000 times higher than for APS.

The pathogenic T42A mutation in SHP2 rewires the interaction specificity of its N-terminal regulatory domain

Mutations in the tyrosine phosphatase Src homology-2 domain-containing protein tyrosine phosphatase-2 (SHP2) are associated with a variety of human diseases. Most mutations in SHP2 increase its basal catalytic activity by disrupting autoinhibitory interactions between its phosphatase domain and N-terminal SH2 (phosphotyrosine recognition) domain. By contrast, some disease-associated mutations located in the ligand-binding pockets of the N- or C-terminal SH2 domains do not increase basal activity and likely exert their pathogenicity through alternative mechanisms. We lack a molecular understanding of how these SH2 mutations impact SHP2 structure, activity, and signaling. Here, we characterize five SHP2 SH2 domain ligand-binding pocket mutants through a combination of high-throughput biochemical screens, biophysical and biochemical measurements, and molecular dynamics simulations. We show that while some of these mutations alter binding affinity to phosphorylation sites, the T42A mutation in the N-SH2 domain is unique in that it also substantially alters ligand-binding specificity, despite being 8 to 10 Å from the specificity-determining region of the SH2 domain. This mutation exerts its effect on sequence specificity by remodeling the phosphotyrosine-binding pocket, altering the mode of engagement of both the phosphotyrosine and surrounding residues on the ligand. The functional consequence of this altered specificity is that the T42A mutant has biased sensitivity toward a subset of activating ligands and enhances downstream signaling. Our study highlights an example of a nuanced mechanism of action for a disease-associated mutation, characterized by a change in protein-protein interaction specificity that alters enzyme activation.

The pathogenic T42A mutation in SHP2 rewires the interaction specificity of its N-terminal regulatory domain

Mutations in the tyrosine phosphatase SHP2 are associated with a variety of human diseases. Most mutations in SHP2 increase its basal catalytic activity by disrupting auto-inhibitory interactions between its phosphatase domain and N-terminal SH2 (phosphotyrosine recognition) domain. By contrast, some disease-associated mutations located in the ligand-binding pockets of the N- or C-terminal SH2 domains do not increase basal activity and likely exert their pathogenicity through alternative mechanisms. We lack a molecular understanding of how these SH2 mutations impact SHP2 structure, activity, and signaling. Here, we characterize five SHP2 SH2 domain ligand-binding pocket mutants through a combination of high-throughput biochemical screens, biophysical and biochemical measurements, and molecular dynamics simulations. We show that, while some of these mutations alter binding affinity to phosphorylation sites, the T42A mutation in the N-SH2 domain is unique in that it also substantially alters ligand-binding specificity, despite being 8-10 Å from the specificity-determining region of the SH2 domain. This mutation exerts its effect on sequence specificity by remodeling the phosphotyrosine binding pocket, altering the mode of engagement of both the phosphotyrosine and surrounding residues on the ligand. The functional consequence of this altered specificity is that the T42A mutant has biased sensitivity toward a subset of activating ligands and enhances downstream signaling. Our study highlights an example of a nuanced mechanism of action for a disease-associated mutation, characterized by a change in protein-protein interaction specificity that alters enzyme activation.

Molecular recognition of ITIM/ITSM domains with SHP2 and their allosteric effect

Src homology 2-domain-containing tyrosine phosphatase 2 (SHP2) is a non-receptor protein tyrosine phosphatase that is widely expressed in a variety of cells and regulates the immune response of T cells through the PD-1 pathway. However, the activation mechanism and allosteric effects of SHP2 remain unclear, hindering the development of small molecule inhibitors. For the first time, in this study, the complex structure formed by the intact PD-1 tail and SHP2 was modeled. The molecular recognition and conformational changes of inactive/active SHP2 versus ITIM/ITSM were compared based on prolonged MD simulations. The relative flexibility of the two SH2 domains during MD simulations contributes to the recruitment of ITIM/ITSM and supports the subsequent conformational change of SHP2. The binding free energy calculation shows that inactive SHP2 has a higher affinity for ITIM/ITSM than active SHP2, mainly because the former's N-SH2 refers to the α-state. In addition, a significant decrease in the contribution to the binding energy of certain residues (e.g., R32, S34, K35, T42, and K55) of conformationally transformed SHP2 contributes to the above result. These detailed changes during conformational transition will provide theoretical guidance for the molecular design of subsequent novel anticancer drugs.

Discovery of 5-Azaquinoxaline Derivatives as Potent and Orally Bioavailable Allosteric SHP2 Inhibitors

SHP2 has emerged as an important target for oncology small-molecule drug discovery. As a nonreceptor tyrosine phosphatase within the MAPK pathway, it has been shown to control cell growth, differentiation, and oncogenic transformation. We used structure-based design to find a novel class of potent and orally bioavailable SHP2 inhibitors. Our efforts led to the discovery of the 5-azaquinoxaline as a new core for developing this class of compounds. Optimization of the potency and properties of this scaffold generated compound 30, that exhibited potent in vitro SHP2 inhibition and showed excellent in vivo efficacy and pharmacokinetic profile.

6-Mercaptopurine potently inhibits recruitment of SHP2 by phosphorylated PD-1 to inhibit PD-1 signalling and enhance T cell function

Antibody inhibitors that block PD-1/PD-L1 interaction have been approved for oncological clinics, yielding impressive treatment effects. Small molecules inhibiting PD-1 signalling are at various stages of development, given that small molecular drugs are expected to outperform protein drugs in several ways. Currently, a significant portion of these small molecular inhibitors achieve this purpose by binding to a limited region of the PD-L1 protein, thereby limiting the choice of chemical structures. Alternative strategies for developing small-molecular PD-1 inhibitors are urgently needed to broaden the choice of chemical structures. Here, we report that 6-mercaptopurine (6-MP) inhibits PD-1 signalling, activates T cell function in vitro and in vivo and shrinks tumours by activating cytotoxic T cells. Mechanistically, 6-MP potently inhibited PD-1 signalling by blocking the recruitment of SHP2 by PD-1. Considering that 6-MP is a chemotherapeutic agent already approved by the FDA for childhood leukaemia, our work revealed a novel anti-tumour mechanism for this drug and suggests that 6-MP warrants further clinical evaluation for other tumour types.

Study on the allosteric activation mechanism of SHP2 via elastic network models and neural relational inference molecular dynamics simulation

As a ubiquitous protein tyrosine phosphatase, SHP2 is involved in PD-1/PD-L1 mediated tumor immune escape and undergoes substantial conformational changes. Therefore, it is considered an ideal target for tumor intervention. However, the allosteric mechanisms of SHP2 binding PD-1 intracellular ITIM/ITSM phosphopeptides remain unclear, which greatly hinders the development of novel structure-based anticancer allosteric inhibitors. In this work, the open and closed structural models of SHP2 are first constructed based on this knowledge; next their motion modes are investigated via elastic network models such as the Gaussian network model (GNM), anisotropic network model (ANM) and adaptive anisotropic network model (aANM); and finally, a possible allosteric signaling pathway is proposed using a neural relational inference molecular dynamics (NRI-MD) simulation embedded with an artificial intelligence (AI) strategy. In GNM and ANM, the N-SH2, C-SH2 and PTP domains all exhibit distinct dynamics partitions, and the N-SH2/C-SH2 regions show a rigid rotation relative to PTP. According to a series of intermediate snapshots given by aANM, N-SH2 is first identified with pY223 specifically, inducing a D'E-loop to change from β-sheets to random coils, and then, C-SH2 serves as a fulcrum to drive N-SH2 to rotate 110° completely away from the original active sites of PTP. Finally, a possible allosteric signaling-transfer path for SHP2, namely R220-R138-T108-R32, is proposed based on NRI-MD sampling. This work provides a possible allosteric mechanism of SHP2, which is helpful for the following design of novel allosteric inhibitors and is expected to be used in clinical synergies with PD-1 monoclonal antibody.

Setting sail: Maneuvering SHP2 activity and its effects in cancer

Since the discovery of tyrosine phosphorylation being a critical modulator of cancer signaling, proteins regulating phosphotyrosine levels in cells have fast become targets of therapeutic intervention. The nonreceptor protein tyrosine phosphatase (PTP) coded by the PTPN11 gene "SHP2" integrates phosphotyrosine signaling from growth factor receptors into the RAS/RAF/ERK pathway and is centrally positioned in processes regulating cell development and oncogenic transformation. Dysregulation of SHP2 expression or activity is linked to tumorigenesis and developmental defects. Even as a compelling anti-cancer target, SHP2 was considered "undruggable" for a long time owing to its conserved catalytic PTP domain that evaded drug development. Recently, SHP2 has risen from the "undruggable curse" with the discovery of small molecules that manipulate its intrinsic allostery for effective inhibition. SHP2's unique domain arrangement and conformation(s) allow for a truly novel paradigm of inhibitor development relying on skillful targeting of noncatalytic sites on proteins. In this review we summarize the biological functions, signaling properties, structural attributes, allostery and inhibitors of SHP2.

MUC1-C is necessary for SHP2 activation and BRAF inhibitor resistance in BRAF(V600E) mutant colorectal cancer

Colorectal cancers (CRCs) harboring the BRAF(V600E) mutation are associated with aggressive disease and resistance to BRAF inhibitors by feedback activation of the receptor tyrosine kinase (RTK)→RAS→MAPK pathway. The oncogenic MUC1-C protein promotes progression of colitis to CRC; whereas there is no known involvement of MUC1-C in BRAF(V600E) CRCs. The present work demonstrates that MUC1 expression is significantly upregulated in BRAF(V600E) vs wild-type CRCs. We show that BRAF(V600E) CRC cells are dependent on MUC1-C for proliferation and BRAF inhibitor (BRAFi) resistance. Mechanistically, MUC1-C integrates induction of MYC in driving cell cycle progression with activation of the SHP2 phosphotyrosine phosphatase, which enhances RTK-mediated RAS→ERK signaling. We demonstrate that targeting MUC1-C genetically and pharmacologically suppresses (i) activation of MYC, (ii) induction of the NOTCH1 stemness factor, and (iii) the capacity for self-renewal. We also show that MUC1-C associates with SHP2 and is required for SHP2 activation in driving BRAFi-induced feedback of ERK signaling. In this way, targeting MUC1-C in BRAFi-resistant BRAF(V600E) CRC tumors inhibits growth and sensitizes to BRAF inhibition. These findings demonstrate that MUC1-C is a target for the treatment of BRAF(V600E) CRCs and for reversing their resistance to BRAF inhibitors by suppressing the feedback MAPK pathway.

Fluorescence Anisotropy and Polarization in the Characterization of Biomolecular Association Processes and Their Application to Study SH2 Domain Binding Affinity

Fluorescence anisotropy (or polarization) is a powerful technique to study biomolecular association processes, by following the rotational motions of one of the two partners in the interaction, labeled with a fluorophore. It can be used to determine dissociation constants in solution, down to nM values, and unlabeled ligands can be characterized, too, by using competition experiments. In this chapter, we introduce the basic principles of the technique, compare it with other experimental approaches, and discuss the experimental details with specific examples regarding SH2 domain/phosphopeptide association processes. The experimental protocols to be used in binding experiments and displacement studies are described, as well as the caveats to be considered in performing accurate measurements.

Computational Evaluation of Peptide-Protein Binding Affinities: Application of Potential of Mean Force Calculations to SH2 Domains

Many biological functions are mediated by protein-protein interactions (PPIs), often involving specific structural modules, such as SH2 domains. Inhibition of PPIs is a pharmaceutical strategy of growing importance. However, a major challenge in the design of PPI inhibitors is the large interface involved in these interactions, which, in many cases, makes inhibition by small organic molecules ineffective. Peptides, which cover a wide range of dimensions and can be opportunely designed to mimic protein sequences at PPI interfaces, represent a valuable alternative to small molecules. Computational techniques able to predict the binding affinity of peptides for the target domain or protein represent a crucial stage in the workflow for the design of peptide-based drugs. This chapter describes a protocol to obtain the potential of mean force (PMF) for peptide-SH2 domain binding, starting from umbrella sampling (US) molecular dynamics (MD) simulations. The PMF profiles can be effectively used to predict the relative standard binding free energies of different peptide sequences.

A comprehensive review of SHP2 and its role in cancer

Src homology 2-containing protein tyrosine phosphatase 2 (SHP2) is a non-receptor protein tyrosine phosphatase ubiquitously expressed mainly in the cytoplasm of several tissues. SHP2 modulates diverse cell signaling events that control metabolism, cell growth, differentiation, cell migration, transcription and oncogenic transformation. It interacts with diverse molecules in the cell, and regulates key signaling events including RAS/ERK, PI3K/AKT, JAK/STAT and PD-1 pathways downstream of several receptor tyrosine kinases (RTKs) upon stimulation by growth factors and cytokines. SHP2 acts as both a phosphatase and a scaffold, and plays prominently oncogenic functions but can be tumor suppressor in a context-dependent manner. It typically acts as a positive regulator of RTKs signaling with some inhibitory functions reported as well. SHP2 expression and activity is regulated by such factors as allosteric autoinhibition, microRNAs, ubiquitination and SUMOylation. Dysregulation of SHP2 expression or activity causes many developmental diseases, and hematological and solid tumors. Moreover, upregulated SHP2 expression or activity also decreases sensitivity of cancer cells to anticancer drugs. SHP2 is now considered as a compelling anticancer drug target and several classes of SHP2 inhibitors with different mode of action are developed with some already in clinical trial phases. Moreover, novel SHP2 substrates and functions are rapidly growing both in cell and cancer. In view of this, we comprehensively and thoroughly reviewed literatures about SHP2 regulatory mechanisms, substrates and binding partners, biological functions, roles in human cancers, and different classes of small molecule inhibitors target this oncoprotein in cancer.

Dissecting protein tyrosine phosphatase signaling by engineered chemogenetic control of its activity

Protein tyrosine phosphatases (PTPases) are critical mediators of dynamic cell signaling. A tool capable of identifying transient signaling events downstream of PTPases is essential to understand phosphatase function on a physiological time scale. We report a broadly applicable protein engineering method for allosteric regulation of PTPases. This method enables dissection of transient events and reconstruction of individual signaling pathways. Implementation of this approach for Shp2 phosphatase revealed parallel MAPK and ROCK II dependent pathways downstream of Shp2, mediating transient cell spreading and migration. Furthermore, we show that the N-SH2 domain of Shp2 regulates MAPK-independent, ROCK II-dependent cell migration. Engineered targeting of Shp2 activity to different protein complexes revealed that Shp2-FAK signaling induces cell spreading whereas Shp2-Gab1 or Shp2-Gab2 mediates cell migration. We identified specific transient morphodynamic processes induced by Shp2 and determined the role of individual signaling pathways downstream of Shp2 in regulating these events. Broad application of this approach is demonstrated by regulating PTP1B and PTP-PEST phosphatases.

Phase-Separated Subcellular Compartmentation and Related Human Diseases

In live cells, proteins and nucleic acids can associate together through multivalent interactions, and form relatively isolated phases that undertake designated biological functions and activities. In the past decade, liquid–liquid phase separation (LLPS) has gradually been recognized as a general mechanism for the intracellular organization of biomolecules. LLPS regulates the assembly and composition of dozens of membraneless organelles and condensates in cells. Due to the altered physiological conditions or genetic mutations, phase-separated condensates may undergo aberrant formation, maturation or gelation that contributes to the onset and progression of various diseases, including neurodegenerative disorders and cancers. In this review, we summarize the properties of different membraneless organelles and condensates, and discuss multiple phase separation-regulated biological processes. Based on the dysregulation and mutations of several key regulatory proteins and signaling pathways, we also exemplify how aberrantly regulated LLPS may contribute to human diseases.

Targeting Oncogenic Src Homology 2 Domain-Containing Phosphatase 2 (SHP2) by Inhibiting Its Protein-Protein Interactions

We developed a new class of inhibitors of protein-protein interactions of the SHP2 phosphatase, which is pivotal in cell signaling and represents a central target in the therapy of cancer and rare diseases. Currently available SHP2 inhibitors target the catalytic site or an allosteric pocket but lack specificity or are ineffective for disease-associated SHP2 mutants. Considering that pathogenic lesions cause signaling hyperactivation due to increased levels of SHP2 association with cognate proteins, we developed peptide-based molecules with nanomolar affinity for the N-terminal Src homology domain of SHP2, good selectivity, stability to degradation, and an affinity for pathogenic variants of SHP2 that is 2-20 times higher than for the wild-type protein. The best peptide reverted the effects of a pathogenic variant (D61G) in zebrafish embryos. Our results provide a novel route for SHP2-targeted therapies and a tool for investigating the role of protein-protein interactions in the function of SHP2.

Discriminating between competing models for the allosteric regulation of oncogenic phosphatase SHP2 by characterizing its active state

The Src-homology 2 domain containing phosphatase 2 (SHP2) plays a critical role in crucial signaling pathways and is involved in oncogenesis and in developmental disorders. Its structure includes two SH2 domains (N-SH2 and C-SH2), and a protein tyrosine phosphatase (PTP) domain. Under basal conditions, SHP2 is auto-inhibited, with the N-SH2 domain blocking the PTP active site. Activation involves a rearrangement of the domains that makes the catalytic site accessible, coupled to the association between the SH2 domains and cognate proteins containing phosphotyrosines. Several aspects of this transition are debated and competing mechanistic models have been proposed. A crystallographic structure of SHP2 in an active state has been reported (PDB code 6crf), but several lines of evidence suggests that it is not fully representative of the conformations populated in solution. To clarify the structural rearrangements involved in SHP2 activation, enhanced sampling simulations of the autoinhibited and active states have been performed, for wild type SHP2 and its pathogenic E76K variant. Our results demonstrate that the crystallographic conformation of the active state is unstable in solution, and multiple interdomain arrangements are populated, thus allowing association to bisphosphorylated sequences. Contrary to a recent proposal, activation is coupled to the conformational changes of the N-SH2 binding site, which is significantly more accessible in the active sate, rather than to the structure of the central β-sheet of the domain. In this coupling, a previously undescribed role for the N-SH2 BG loop emerged.

Phosphotyrosine couples peptide binding and SHP2 activation via a dynamic allosteric network

SHP2 is a ubiquitous protein tyrosine phosphatase, whose activity is regulated by phosphotyrosine (pY)-containing peptides generated in response to extracellular stimuli. Its crystal structure reveals a closed, auto-inhibited conformation in which the N-terminal Src homology 2 (N-SH2) domain occludes the catalytic site of the phosphatase (PTP) domain. High-affinity mono-phosphorylated peptides promote catalytic activity by binding to N-SH2 and disrupting the interaction with the PTP. The mechanism behind this process is not entirely clear, especially because N-SH2 is incapable of accommodating complete peptide binding when SHP2 is in the auto-inhibited state. Here, we show that pY performs an essential role in this process; in addition to its contribution to overall peptide-binding energy, pY-recognition leads to enhanced dynamics of the N-SH2 EF and BG loops via an allosteric communication network, which destabilizes the N-SH2-PTP interaction surface and simultaneously generates a fully accessible binding pocket for the C-terminal half of the phosphopeptide. Subsequently, full binding of the phosphopeptide is associated with the stabilization of activated SHP2. We demonstrate that this allosteric network exists only in N-SH2, which is directly involved in the regulation of SHP2 activity, while the C-terminal SH2 domain (C-SH2) functions primarily to recruit high-affinity bidentate phosphopeptides.

An allosteric interaction controls the activation mechanism of SHP2 tyrosine phosphatase

SHP2 is a protein tyrosine phosphatase (PTP) involved in multiple signaling pathways. Mutations of SHP2 can result in Noonan syndrome or pediatric malignancies. Inhibition of wild-type SHP2 represents a novel strategy against several cancers. SHP2 is activated by binding of a phosphopeptide to the N-SH2 domain of SHP2, thereby favoring dissociation of the N-SH2 domain and exposing the active site on the PTP domain. The conformational transitions controlling ligand affinity and PTP dissociation remain poorly understood. Using molecular simulations, we revealed an allosteric interaction restraining the N-SH2 domain into a SHP2-activating and a stabilizing state. Only ligands selecting for the activating N-SH2 conformation, depending on ligand sequence and binding mode, are effective activators. We validate the model of SHP2 activation by rationalizing modified basal activity and responsiveness to ligand stimulation of several N-SH2 variants. This study provides mechanistic insight into SHP2 activation and may open routes for SHP2 regulation.