First-Principles Reaction Dynamics beyond Six-Atom Systems

A quasi-classical study in a quantum spirit of mode specificity of the H + HOD abstraction reaction

Quantum benchmark calculations of the H + HOD abstraction reaction [B. Zhao et al., Phys. Chem. Chem. Phys., 2018, 20, 17029-17037] provide an opportunity to test approximate methods, such as quasi-classical trajectories (QCTs) with Gaussian binning. However, the large mode-specific enhancements of this reaction lead to special challenges and unphysical QCT cross-section artifacts. We propose and apply a general backward-forward-backward (BFB) trajectory procedure to avoid cross-section artifacts arising from vibrational motion delocalization of the initially prepared reactants. We also develop and apply a general hybrid weighting scheme, in which vibrationally adiabatic products receive unit weights, while vibrationally non-adiabatic products are Gaussian weighted. Motivated by examination of the product vibrational actions, the hybrid weighting is necessary to avoid large cross-section errors. These QCTs with Gaussian weighting extensions are general and are recommended for future polyatomic reaction simulations.

Dynamics of the HCl + C2H5 Multichannel Reaction on a Full-Dimensional Ab Initio Potential Energy Surface

We report a full-dimensional ab initio analytical potential energy surface (PES), which accurately describes the HCl + C2H5 multichannel reaction. The new PES is developed by iteratively adding selected configurations along HCl + C2H5 quasi-classical trajectories (QCTs), thereby improving our previous Cl(2P3/2) + C2H6 PES using the Robosurfer program package. QCT simulations for the H'Cl + C2H5 reaction reveal hydrogen-abstraction, chlorine-abstraction, and hydrogen-exchange channels leading to Cl + C2H5H', H' + C2H5Cl, and HCl + C2H4H', respectively. Hydrogen abstraction dominates in the collision energy (Ecoll) range of 1-80 kcal/mol and proceeds with indirect isotropic scattering at low Ecoll and forward-scattered direct stripping at high Ecoll. Chlorine abstraction opens around 40 kcal/mol collision energy and becomes competitive with hydrogen abstraction at Ecoll = 80 kcal/mol. A restricted opening of the cone of acceptance in the Cl-abstraction reaction is found to result in the preference for a backward-scattering direct-rebound mechanism at all energies studied. Initial attack-angle distributions show mainly side-on collision preference of C2H5 for both abstraction reactions, and in the case of the HCl reactant, H/Cl-side preference for the H/Cl abstraction. For hydrogen abstraction, the collision energy transfer into the product translational and internal energy is almost equally significant, whereas in the case of chlorine abstraction, most of the available energy goes into the internal degrees of freedom. Hydrogen exchange is a minor channel with nearly constant reactivity in the Ecoll range of 10-80 kcal/mol.

First-principles mode-specific reaction dynamics

Controlling the outcome of chemical reactions by exciting specific vibrational and/or rotational modes of the reactants is one of the major goals of modern reaction dynamics studies. In the present Perspective, we focus on first-principles vibrational and rotational mode-specific dynamics computations on reactions of neutral and anionic systems beyond six atoms such as X + C2H6 [X = F, Cl, OH], HX + C2H5 [X = Br, I], OH- + CH3I, and F- + CH3CH2Cl. The dynamics simulations utilize high-level ab initio analytical potential energy surfaces and the quasi-classical trajectory method. Besides initial state specificity and the validity of the Polanyi rules, mode-specific vibrational-state assignment for polyatomic product species using normal-mode analysis and Gaussian binning is also discussed and compared with experiment.

Imaging the Ion-Molecule Reaction Dynamics of O- + CD4

While neutral reactions involved in methane oxidation have been intensively studied, much less information is known about the reaction dynamics of the oxygen radical anion with methane. Here, we study the scattering dynamics of this anion-molecule reaction using crossed-beam velocity map imaging with deuterated methane. Differential scattering cross sections for the deuterium abstraction channel have been determined at relative collision energies between 0.2 and 1.5 eV and ab initio calculations of the important stationary points along the reaction pathway have been performed. At lower collision energies, direct backscattering and indirect complex-mediated reaction dynamics are observed, whereas at higher energies, sideways deuterium stripping dominates the reaction. Above 0.7 eV collision energy, a suppressed cross section is observed at low product ion velocities, which is likely caused by the endoergic pathway of combined deuteron/deuterium transfer, forming heavy water. The measured product internal energy is attributed mainly to the low-lying deformation and out-of-plane bending vibrations of the methyl radical product. The results are compared with a previous crossed-beam result for the reaction of oxygen anions with nondeuterated ̧methane and with the related neutral-neutral reactions, showing similar dynamics and qualitative agreement.

No Headache for PIPs: A PIP Potential for Aspirin Runs Much Faster and with Similar Precision Than Other Machine-Learned Potentials

Assessments of machine-learning (ML) potentials are an important aspect of the rapid development of this field. We recently reported an assessment of the linear-regression permutationally invariant polynomial (PIP) method for ethanol, using the widely used (revised) rMD17 data set. We demonstrated that the PIP approach outperformed numerous other methods, e.g., ANI, PhysNet, sGDML, and p-KRR, with respect to precision and notably with respect to speed [Houston et al., J. Chem. Phys. 2022, 156, 044120]. Here, we extend this assessment to the 21-atom aspirin molecule, using the rMD17 data set, with a focus on the speed of evaluation. Both energies and forces are used for training, and the precision of several PIPs is examined for both. Normal mode frequencies, the methyl torsional potential, and 1d vibrational energies for an OH stretch are presented. We show that the PIP approach achieves the level of precision obtained from other ML methods, e.g., atom-centered neural network methods, linear regression ACE, and kernel methods, as reported by Kovács et al. in J. Chem. Theory Comput. 2021, 17, 7696-7711. More significantly, we show that the PIP PESs run much faster than all other ML methods, whose timings were evaluated in that paper. We also show that the PIP PES extrapolates well enough to describe several internal motions of aspirin, including an OH stretch.

Alternating Stereospecificity upon Central-Atom Change: Dynamics of the F- +PH2 Cl SN 2 Reaction Compared to its C- and N-Centered Analogues

Central-atom effects on bimolecular nucleophilic substitution (SN 2) reactions are well-known in chemistry, however, the atomic-level SN 2 dynamics at phosphorous (P) centers has never been studied. We investigate the dynamics of the F- +PH2 Cl reaction with the quasi-classical trajectory method on a novel full-dimensional analytical potential energy surface fitted on high-level ab initio data. Our computations reveal intermediate dynamics compared to the F- +CH3 Cl and the F- +NH2 Cl SN 2 reactions: phosphorus as central atom leads to a more indirect SN 2 reaction with extensive complex-formation with respect to the carbon-centered one, however, the title reaction is more direct than its N-centered pair. Stereospecificity, characteristic at C-center, does not appear here either, due to the submerged front-side-attack retention path and the repeated entrance-channel inversional motion, whereas the multi-inversion mechanism discovered at nitrogen center is also undermined by the deep Walden-well. At low collision energies, 6 % of the PH2 F products form with retained configuration, mostly through complex-mediated mechanisms, while this ratio reaches 24 % at the highest energy due to the increasing dominance of the direct front-side mechanism and the smaller chance for hitting the deep Walden-inversion minimum. Our results suggest pronounced central-atom effects in SN 2 reactions, which can fundamentally change their (stereo)dynamics.

Theoretical Insights into the Dynamics of Gas-Phase Bimolecular Reactions with Submerged Barriers

Much attention has been paid to the dynamics of both activated gas-phase bimolecular reactions, which feature monotonically increasing integral cross sections and Arrhenius kinetics, and their barrierless capture counterparts, which manifest monotonically decreasing integral cross sections and negative temperature dependence of the rate coefficients. In this Perspective, we focus on the dynamics of gas-phase bimolecular reactions with submerged barriers, which often involve radicals or ions and are prevalent in combustion, atmospheric chemistry, astrochemistry, and plasma chemistry. The temperature dependence of the rate coefficients for such reactions is often non-Arrhenius and complex, and the corresponding dynamics may also be quite different from those with significant barriers or those completely dominated by capture. Recent experimental and theoretical studies of such reactions, particularly at relatively low temperatures or collision energies, have revealed interesting dynamical behaviors, which are discussed here. The new knowledge enriches our understanding of the dynamics of these unusual reactions.

Δ-Machine Learned Potential Energy Surfaces and Force Fields

There has been great progress in developing machine-learned potential energy surfaces (PESs) for molecules and clusters with more than 10 atoms. Unfortunately, this number of atoms generally limits the level of electronic structure theory to less than the "gold standard" CCSD(T) level. Indeed, for the well-known MD17 dataset for molecules with 9-20 atoms, all of the energies and forces were obtained with DFT calculations (PBE). This Perspective is focused on a Δ-machine learning method that we recently proposed and applied to bring DFT-based PESs to close to CCSD(T) accuracy. This is demonstrated for hydronium, N-methylacetamide, acetyl acetone, and ethanol. For 15-atom tropolone, it appears that special approaches (e.g., molecular tailoring, local CCSD(T)) are needed to obtain the CCSD(T) energies. A new aspect of this approach is the extension of Δ-machine learning to force fields. The approach is based on many-body corrections to polarizable force field potentials. This is examined in detail using the TTM2.1 water potential. The corrections make use of our recent CCSD(T) datasets for 2-b, 3-b, and 4-b interactions for water. These datasets were used to develop a new fully ab initio potential for water, termed q-AQUA.

Portable Models for Entropy Effects on Kinetic Selectivity

Differences in entropies of competing transition states can direct kinetic selectivity. Understanding and modeling such entropy differences at the molecular level is complicated by the fact that entropy is statistical in nature; i.e., it depends on multiple vibrational states of transition structures, the existence of multiple dynamically accessible pathways past these transition structures, and contributions from multiple transition structures differing in conformation/configuration. The difficulties associated with modeling each of these contributors are discussed here, along with possible solutions, all with an eye toward the development of portable qualitative models of use to experimentalists aiming to design reactions that make use of entropy to control kinetic selectivity.

The MD17 datasets from the perspective of datasets for gas-phase “small” molecule potentials

There has been great progress in developing methods for machine-learned potential energy surfaces. There have also been important assessments of these methods by comparing so-called learning curves on datasets of electronic energies and forces, notably the MD17 database. The dataset for each molecule in this database generally consists of tens of thousands of energies and forces obtained from DFT direct dynamics at 500 K. We contrast the datasets from this database for three “small” molecules, ethanol, malonaldehyde, and glycine, with datasets we have generated with specific targets for the potential energy surfaces (PESs) in mind: a rigorous calculation of the zero-point energy and wavefunction, the tunneling splitting in malonaldehyde, and, in the case of glycine, a description of all eight low-lying conformers. We found that the MD17 datasets are too limited for these targets. We also examine recent datasets for several PESs that describe small-molecule but complex chemical reactions. Finally, we introduce a new database, “QM-22,” which contains datasets of molecules ranging from 4 to 15 atoms that extend to high energies and a large span of configurations.

Current Status of the X + C2H6 [X ≡ H, F(2P), Cl(2P), O(3P), OH] Hydrogen Abstraction Reactions: A Theoretical Review

This paper is a detailed review of the chemistry of medium-size reactive systems using the following hydrogen abstraction reactions with ethane, X + C₂H₆ → HX + C₂H₅; X ≡ H, F(²P), Cl(²P), O(³P) and OH, and focusing attention mainly on the theoretical developments. These bimolecular reactions range from exothermic to endothermic systems and from barrierless to high classical barriers of activation. Thus, the topography of the reactive systems changes from reaction to reaction with the presence or not of stabilized intermediate complexes in the entrance and exit channels. The review begins with some reflections on the inherent problems in the theory/experiment comparison. When one compares kinetics or dynamics theoretical results with experimental measures, one is testing both the potential energy surface describing the nuclei motion and the kinetics or dynamics method used. Discrepancies in the comparison may be due to inaccuracies of the surface, limitations of the kinetics or dynamics methods, and experimental uncertainties that also cannot be ruled out. The paper continues with a detailed review of some bimolecular reactions with ethane, beginning with the reactions with hydrogen atoms. The reactions with halogens present a challenge owing to the presence of stabilized intermediate complexes in the entrance and exit channels and the influence of the spin-orbit states on reactivity. Reactions with O(³P) atoms lead to three surfaces, which is an additional difficulty in the theoretical study. Finally, the reactions with the hydroxyl radical correspond to a reactive system with ten atoms and twenty-four degrees of freedom. Throughout this review, different strategies in the development of analytical potential energy surfaces describing these bimolecular reactions have been critically analyzed, showing their advantages and limitations. These surfaces are fitted to a large number of ab initio calculations, and we found that a huge number of calculations leads to accurate surfaces, but this information does not guarantee that the kinetics and dynamics results match the experimental measurements.

Time-dependent quantum dynamics study of the F + C2H6 → HF + C2H5 reaction

The reaction probabilities, integral cross sections, energy efficiency and rate constants are investigated for the F + C₂H₆ reaction using the quantum reaction dynamics, wave packet method. The ground-state integral cross section calculated using a six-degree-of-freedom approach is in very good agreement with the quasi-classical trajectory results. We find that the H-CH₂CH₃ stretching motion has the largest enhancement to reactivity, followed by the H-CH₂-CH₃ bending motion. However, the stretching motion between CH₂ and CH₃ slightly hinders the reactivity. The energy-form efficacy based on an equal amount of total energy shows that translational energy is more effective in enhancing the reactivity than vibrational energy of the H-CH₂CH₃ stretching motion at a relatively lower translational energy, while the reverse is true at a relatively high translational energy. An energy-shifting method is employed to calculate the full-dimensional rate constants. The quantum rate constants agree well with one of the two main experimental measurements, and the activation energy has an excellent agreement with the one calculated using canonical variational transition-state theory.

Vibrational mode-specific dynamics of the F(2P3/2) + C2H6 → HF + C2H5 reaction

We investigate the competing effect of vibrational and translational excitation and the validity of the Polanyi rules in the early- and negative-barrier F(²P_3/2) + C₂H₆ → HF + C₂H₅ reaction by performing quasi-classical dynamics simulations on a recently developed full-dimensional multi-reference analytical potential energy surface. The effect of five normal-mode excitations of ethane on the reactivity, the mechanism, and the post-reaction energy flow is followed through a wide range of collision energies. Promoting effects of vibrational excitations and interaction time, related to the slightly submerged barrier, are found to be suppressed by the early-barrier-induced translational enhancement, in contrast to the slightly late-barrier Cl + C₂H₆ reaction. The excess vibrational energy mostly converts into ethyl internal excitation while collision energy is transformed into product separation. The substantial reaction energy excites the HF vibration, which tends to show mode-specificity and translational energy dependence as well. With increasing collision energy, direct stripping becomes dominant over the direct rebound and indirect mechanisms, being basically independent of reactant excitation.

Detailed quasiclassical dynamics of the F- + CH3Br reaction on an ab initio analytical potential energy surface

Dynamics and mechanisms of the F^- + CH₃Br(v = 0) → Br^- + CH₃F (S_N2 via Walden inversion, front-side attack, and double inversion), F^- + inverted-CH₃Br (induced inversion), HF + CH₂Br^- (proton abstraction), and FH⋯Br^- + ¹CH₂ reactions are investigated using a high-level global ab initio potential energy surface, the quasiclassical trajectory method, as well as non-standard configuration- and mode-specific analysis techniques. A vector-projection method is used to identify inversion and retention trajectories; then, a transition-state-attack-angle-based approach unambiguously separates the front-side attack and the double-inversion retention pathways. The Walden-inversion S_N2 channel becomes direct rebound dominated with increasing collision energy as indicated by backward scattering, initial back-side attack preference, and the redshifting of product internal energy peaks in accord with CF stretching populations. In the minor retention and induced-inversion pathways, almost the entire available energy transfers into product rotation-vibration, and retention mainly proceeds with indirect, slow double inversion following induced inversion with about 50% probability. Proton abstraction is dominated by direct stripping (evidenced by forward scattering) with CH₃-side initial attack preference, providing mainly vibrationally ground state products with significant zero-point energy violation.

Vibrational mode-specificity in the dynamics of the Cl + C2H6 → HCl + C2H5 reaction

We report a detailed dynamics study on the mode-specificity of the Cl + C₂H₆ → HCl + C₂H₅ H-abstraction reaction. We perform quasi-classical trajectory simulations using a recently developed high-level ab initio full-dimensional potential energy surface by exciting five different vibrational modes of ethane at four collision energies. We find that all the studied vibrational excitations, except that of the CC-stretching mode, clearly promote the title reaction, and the vibrational enhancements are consistent with the predictions of the Sudden Vector Projection (SVP) model, with the largest effect caused by the CH-stretching excitations. Intramolecular vibrational redistribution is also monitored for the differently excited ethane molecule. Our results indicate that the mechanism of the reaction changes with increasing collision energy, with no mode-specificity at high energies. The initial translational energy mostly converts into product recoil, while a significant part of the excess vibrational energy remains in the ethyl radical. An interesting competition between translational and vibrational energies is observed for the HCl vibrational distribution: the effect of exciting the low-frequency ethane modes, having small SVP values, is suppressed by translational excitation, whereas a part of the excess vibrational energy pumped into the CH-stretching modes (larger SVP values) efficiently flows into the HCl vibration.

Fifty years of nucleophilic substitution in the gas phase

Bimolecular nucleophilic substitution ( S N 2 ) reactions have become a model system for the investigation of structure-reactivity relationships, stereochemistry, solvent influences, and detailed atomistic dynamics. In this review, the progress during five decades of experimental and theoretical research on gas phase S N 2 reactions is discussed. Many advancements of the employed methods have led to a tremendous increase in our understanding of the properties and the dynamics of these reactions. For reactions involving six atoms a quantitative agreement of the differential reactive scattering cross sections has already been achieved, in the future it is expected that even larger polyatomic reactions systems become tractable. Furthermore, studies with higher precision, improved reactant control, and a more accurate theoretical treatment of quantum effects are envisioned.