Analysis of Density-Functional Errors for Noncovalent Interactions between Charged Molecules

Revisiting Artifacts of Kohn-Sham Density Functionals for Biosimulation

We revisit the problem of unphysical charge density delocalization/fractionalization induced by the self-interaction error of common approximate Kohn-Sham (KS) density functional theory functionals on simulation of small to medium-sized proteins in a vacuum. Aside from producing unphysical electron densities and total energies, the vanishing of the HOMO-LUMO gap associated with the unphysical charge delocalization leads to an unphysical low-energy spectrum and catastrophic failure of most popular solvers for the KS self-consistent field (SCF) problem. We apply a robust quasi-Newton SCF solver [ Phys. Chem. Chem. Phys. 2024, 26, 6557] to obtain solutions for some of these difficult cases. The anatomy of the charge delocalization is revealed by the natural deformation orbitals obtained from the density matrix difference between the Hartree-Fock and KS solutions; the charge delocalization not only can occur between charged fragments (such as in zwitterionic polypeptides) but also involves neutral fragments. The vanishing-gap phenomenon and troublesome SCF convergence are both attributed to the unphysical KS Fock operator eigenspectra of molecular fragments (e.g., amino acids or their side chains). Analysis of amino acid pairs suggests that the unphysical charge delocalization can be partially ameliorated by the use of some range-separated hybrid functionals but not by semilocal or standard hybrid functionals. Last, we demonstrate that solutions without the unphysical charge delocalization can be located even for semilocal KS functionals highly prone to such defects, but such solutions have non-Aufbau character and are unstable with respect to mixing of the non-overlapping "frontier" orbitals. Caution should be exercised when unexpectedly small (or vanishing) HOMO-LUMO gaps and atypical SCF convergence patterns (e.g., oscillatory) are observed in KS DFT simulations in any context (bio or otherwise).

To Pair or not to Pair? Machine-Learned Explicitly-Correlated Electronic Structure for NaCl in Water

The extent of ion pairing in solution is an important phenomenon to rationalize transport and thermodynamic properties of electrolytes. A fundamental measure of this pairing is the potential of mean force (PMF) between solvated ions. The relative stabilities of the paired and solvent shared states in the PMF and the barrier between them are highly sensitive to the underlying potential energy surface. However, direct application of accurate electronic structure methods is challenging, since long simulations are required. We develop wave function based machine learning potentials with the random phase approximation (RPA) and second order Møller-Plesset (MP2) perturbation theory for the prototypical system of Na and Cl ions in water. We show both methods in agreement, predicting the paired and solvent shared states to have similar energies (within 0.2 kcal/mol). We also provide the same benchmarks for different DFT functionals as well as insight into the PMF based on simple analyses of the interactions in the system.

Comparison of Density-Functional Theory Dispersion Corrections for the DES15K Database

While density-functional theory (DFT) remains one of the most widely used tools in computational chemistry, most functionals fail to properly account for the effects of London dispersion. Hence, there are many popular post-self-consistent methods to add a dispersion correction to the DFT energy. Until now, the most popular methods have never been compared on equal footing due to not being implemented in the same electronic structure packages. In this work, we performed a large-scale benchmarking study, directly comparing the accuracy of the exchange-hole dipole moment (XDM), D3BJ, D4, TS, MBD, and MBD-NL dispersion models when applied to the recent DES15K database of nearly 15,000 molecular complexes at both expanded and compressed geometries. Our study showed similarly good performance for all dispersion methods (except TS) when applied to neutral complexes. However, they all performed worse for ionic complexes, particularly those involving dications of alkaline earth metals, due to systematic overbinding by the base PBE0 density functional. Investigation of the largest outliers also revealed that only the MBD and MBD-NL methods demonstrate surprising errors for complexes involving alkali metal cations at compressed geometries where they tended to significantly overbind. As we would expect minimal dispersion binding for such complexes, we further investigated the origins of these errors for the potential energy curve of a model cation-π complex. Overall, there is little choice between the XDM, D3BJ, D4, MBD, and MBD-NL dispersion methods for most systems. However, the MBD-based methods are not recommended for complexes involving organic species and alkali or alkaline earth metal cations, for example when modeling Li+ intercalation into graphite.

Energetics and J-coupling constants for Ala, Gly, and Val peptides demonstrated using ABEEM polarizable force field in vacuo and an aqueous solution

The development of an atom-bond electronegativity equalisation method at the σπ-level (ABEEM) polarisable force field (PFF) for peptides is presented. ABEEM PFF utilises a fluctuating charge model to explicitly describe...

The complex between molecular oxygen and an organic molecule: modeling optical transitions to the intermolecular charge-transfer state

The collision complex between the ground electronic state of an organic molecule, M, and ground state oxygen, O2(X3Σg-), can absorb light to produce an intermolecular charge transfer (CT) state, often represented simply as the M radical cation, M+˙, paired with the superoxide radical anion, O2-˙. Aspects of this transition have been the subject of numerous studies for ∼70 years, many of which address fundamental concepts in chemistry and physics. We now examine the extent to which the combination of Molecular Dynamics simulations and electronic structure response methods can model transitions to the toluene-O2 CT state. To account for the experimental spectra, we consider (a) the distribution of toluene-O2 geometries that contribute to the transitions, (b) a quantitative description of intermolecular CT, and (c) oxygen-induced local transitions in toluene that complement the CT transitions, specifically transitions that populate toluene triplet states. We find that the latter oxygen-induced local transitions play a prominent role on the long wavelength side of the spectrum commonly attributed to the intermolecular CT transition. Our calculations provide a new perspective on the seminal discussion between R. S. Mulliken and D. F. Evans on the nature of O2-dependent transitions in organic molecules, and bode well for modeling transitions to excited states with CT character in noncovalent weakly-bonded molecular complexes.

Application of XDM to ionic solids: The importance of dispersion for bulk moduli and crystal geometries

Dispersion corrections are essential in the description of intermolecular interactions; however, dispersion-corrected functionals must also be transferrable to hard solids. The exchange-hole dipole moment (XDM) model has demonstrated excellent performance for non-covalent interactions. In this article, we examine its ability to describe the relative stability, geometry, and compressibility of simple ionic solids. For the specific cases of the cesium halides, XDM-corrected functionals correctly predict the energy ranking of the B1 and B2 forms, and a dispersion contribution is required to obtain this result. Furthermore, for the lattice constants of the 20 alkali halides, the performance of XDM-corrected functionals is excellent, provided that the base functional's exchange enhancement factor properly captures non-bonded repulsion. The mean absolute errors in lattice constants obtained with B86bPBE-XDM and B86bPBE-25X-XDM are 0.060 Å and 0.039 Å, respectively, suggesting that delocalization error also plays a minor role in these systems. Finally, we considered the calculation of bulk moduli for alkali halides and alkaline-earth oxides. Previous claims in the literature that simple generalized gradient approximations, such as PBE, can reliably predict experimental bulk moduli have benefited from large error cancellations between neglecting both dispersion and vibrational effects. If vibrational effects are taken into account, dispersion-corrected functionals are quite accurate (4 GPa-5 GPa average error), again, if non-bonded repulsion is correctly represented. Careful comparisons of the calculated bulk moduli with experimental data are needed to avoid systematic biases and misleading conclusions.