Efficient X-ray Attenuation Lead-Free AgBi2I7 Halide Rudorffite Alternative for Sensitive and Stable X-ray Detection

Exploring Non-Toxic Lower Dimensional Perovskites for Next-Generation X-Ray Detectors

Owing to their extraordinary photophysical properties, organometal halide perovskites are emerging as a new material class for X-ray detection. However, the existence of toxic lead makes their commercialization questionable and should readily be replaced. Accordingly, several lead alternatives have been introduced into the framework of conventional perovskites, resulting in various new perovskite dimensionalities. Among these, Pb-free lower dimensional perovskites (LPVKs) not only show promising X-ray detecting properties due to their higher ionic migration energy, wider and tunable energy bandgap, smaller dark currents, and structural versatility but also exhibit extended environmental stability. Herein, first, the structural organization of the PVKs (including LPVKs) is summarized. In the context of X-ray detectors (XDs), the outstanding properties of the LPVKs and active layer synthesis routes are elaborated afterward. Subsequently, their applications in direct XDs are extensively discussed and the device performance, in terms of the synthesis method, device architecture, active layer size, figure of merits, and device stability are tabulated. Finally, the review is concluded with an in-depth outlook, thoroughly exploring the present challenges to LPVKs XDs, proposing innovative solutions, and future directions. This review provides valuable insights into optimizing non-toxic Pb-free perovskite XDs, paving the way for future advancements in the field.

Molecular Design of Layered Hybrid Silver Bismuth Bromine Single Crystal for Ultra-Stable X-Ray Detection With Record Sensitivity

Nowadays, weak interlayer coupling and unclear mechanism in layered hybrid silver bismuth bromine (LH-AgBiBr) are the main reasons for limiting its further enhanced X-ray detection sensitivity and stability. Herein, the design rules for LH-AgBiBr and its influence on X-ray detection performance are reported for the first time. Although shortening amine size can enhance interlayer coupling, its detection performance is severely hampered by its easier defect formation caused by enlarged micro strain. In contrast, an appropriate divalent amine design endows the material with improved interlayer coupling and released micro strain, which benefits crystal stability and mechanical hardness. Another contribution is to increase material density and dielectric constant; thus, enhancing X-ray absorption and carrier transport. Consequently, the optimized parallel device based on BDA2 AgBiBr8 achieves a record sensitivity of 2638 µC Gyair -1 cm-2 and an ultra-low detection limit of 7.4 nGyair s-1 , outperforming other reported LH-AgBiBr X-ray detectors. Moreover, the unencapsulated device displays remarkable anti-moisture, anti-thermal (>150 °C), and anti-radiation (>1000 Gyair ) endurance. Eventually, high-resolution hard X-ray imaging is demonstrated by linear detector arrays under a benign dose rate (1.63 µGyair s-1 ) and low external bias (5 V). Hence, these findings provide guidelines for future materials design and device optimization.

Halide Perovskites and Their Derivatives for Efficient, High-Resolution Direct Radiation Detection: Design Strategies and Applications

The past decade has witnessed a rapid rise in the performance of optoelectronic devices based on lead-halide perovskites (LHPs). The large mobility-lifetime products and defect tolerance of these materials, essential for optoelectronics, also make them well-suited for radiation detectors, especially given the heavy elements present, which is essential for strong X-ray and γ-ray attenuation. Over the past decade, LHP thick films, wafers, and single crystals have given rise to direct radiation detectors that have outperformed incumbent technologies in terms of sensitivity (reported values up to 3.5 × 106 µC Gyair -1 cm-2 ), limit of detection (directly measured values down to 1.5 nGyair s-1 ), along with competitive energy and imaging resolution at room temperature. At the same time, lead-free perovskite-inspired materials (e.g., methylammonium bismuth iodide), which have underperformed in solar cells, have recently matched and, in some areas (e.g., in polarization stability), surpassed the performance of LHP detectors. These advances open up opportunities to achieve devices for safer medical imaging, as well as more effective non-invasive analysis for security, nuclear safety, or product inspection applications. Herein, the principles behind the rapid rises in performance of LHP and perovskite-inspired material detectors, and how their properties and performance link with critical applications in non-invasive diagnostics are discussed. The key strategies to engineer the performance of these materials, and the important challenges to overcome to commercialize these new technologies are also discussed.

Lead-Free Halide Perovskites for Direct X-Ray Detectors

Lead halide perovskites have made remarkable progress in the field of radiation detection owing to the excellent and unique optoelectronic properties. However, the instability and the toxicity of lead-based perovskites have greatly hindered its practical applications. Alternatively, lead-free perovskites with high stability and environmental friendliness thus have fascinated significant research attention for direct X-ray detection. In this review, the current research progress of X-ray detectors based on lead-free halide perovskites is focused. First, the synthesis methods of lead-free perovskites including single crystals and films are discussed. In addition, the properties of these materials and the detectors, which can provide a better understanding and designing satisfactory devices are also presented. Finally, the challenge and outlook for developing high-performance lead-free perovskite X-ray detectors are also provided.

Selective Photochromic Response to Low-Dose X-ray Radiation Detection in One-Dimensional Cadmium-Viologen Complexes

Photochromic viologen-based materials have emerged as one of the most promising candidates for the development of X-ray light detection applications, including medical diagnosis and treatment, environmental radiation inspection, and industrial crack detection. However, the design and construction of low-dose X-ray-sensitive complexes remains an immense challenge, especially for the in-depth dissection of their response mechanisms. Herein, by using N,N'-4,4'-bipyridiniodipropionate (CV) as functional sensitive structural units and cadmium as heavy atoms, two cadmium-viologen complexes with one-dimensional chained structures, namely, [Cd₂Cl₄(CV)(H₂O)₂]_n (1) and [CdBr₂(CV)]_n (2), have been constructed, which exhibit a remarkable and selective photochromic response to low-dose X-ray radiation detection. Compound 1 is visually sensitive to both X-ray and UV light due to the more accessible photoinduced electron transfer (ET) pathways, while compound 2 only shows a slight color-changing process in response to UV light, in conformity with UV-vis absorbance analyses and kinetic studies. Surprisingly, compound 2 has longer ET pathways than 1, but not in response to high-energy X-ray light, seeming to contradict the previous phenomena. On further analysis, the key point in achieving X-ray-sensitive behavior should be a good balance among the electron donor-acceptor distance, intermolecular interaction, and X-ray absorbing capacity, as verified by density functional theory (DFT) and X-ray absorption strength calculations, X-ray photoelectron spectra, electron paramagnetic resonance measurements, and independent gradient model analysis. In particular, compound 1 is unprecedentedly sensitive to soft X-ray radiation, accompanied by an X-ray detection limit of as low as 2.91 Gy. These findings push forward the further development of low-dose X-ray sensing materials.

Realizing nearly-zero dark current and ultrahigh signal-to-noise ratio perovskite X-ray detector and image array by dark-current-shunting strategy

Although perovskite X-ray detectors have revealed promising properties, their dark currents are usually hundreds of times larger than the practical requirements. Here, we report a detector architecture with a unique shunting electrode working as a blanking unit to suppress dark current, and it theoretically can be reduced to zero. We experimentally fabricate the dark-current-shunting X-ray detector, which exhibits a record-low dark current of 51.1 fA at 5 V mm^-1, a detection limit of 7.84 nGy_air s^-1, and a sensitivity of 1.3 × 10⁴ μC Gy_air^-1 cm^-2. The signal-to-noise ratio of our polycrystalline perovskite-based detector is even outperforming many previously reported state-of-the-art single crystal-based X-ray detectors by serval orders of magnitude. Finally, the proof-of-concept X-ray imaging of a 64 × 64 pixels dark-current-shunting detector array is successfully demonstrated. This work provides a device strategy to fundamentally reduce dark current and enhance the signal-to-noise ratio of X-ray detectors and photodetectors in general.

Vertically Oriented Porous PET as Template to Integrated Metal Halide for High-Performance Large-Area and Ultra-Flexible X-Ray Detector

High-performance X-ray detectors have immense potential in medical and security inspections. However, the current X-ray detectors are limited in flexible, high-spatial-resolution large-scale detection, and integration for imaging. Here, nuclear track-etched porous polyethylene terephthalate (PET) is developed as the template for preparing uniform, large-area (≥10⁵ cm² ), and flexible metal halide (MH)-based X-ray detectors. Adjustable high-density vertically oriented porous PET with adjustable thickness can provide proper physical support for flexible thick absorption film, thus improving X-ray absorption ability with excellent bending stability. Moreover, vertical channels can block the ion migration, lateral charge diffusion, and water/oxygen attacks, increasing activation energy for ionic transport, charge collection rate of electrodes, and environmental stability. Hence, the related detectors eventually obtain large sensitivity (6722 µC Gy_air ^-1 cm^-2 ), low detection limit (1.87 nGy_air s^-1 ), and high spatial resolution (5.17 lp mm^-1 ) compared to the detectors without porous PET template. Meanwhile, the device shows no degradation after storage or working under various thermal attacks. MH-filled-PET is also monolithically integrated on the bottom circuit with different MHs and it is applied to single-pixel mode and fast linear-array imaging in a broad range of X-rays photon energy (20 to 160 keV).

Ultralow Detection Limit and Robust Hard X-ray Imaging Detector Based on Inch-Sized Lead-Free Perovskite Cs3Bi2Br9 Single Crystals

Halide perovskites are promising candidates for soft X-ray detection (<80 keV) owing to their high X-ray absorption coefficient, resistivity, and mobility lifetime product. However, the lack of large high-quality single crystals (SCs) renders it challenging to manufacture robust hard X-ray imaging systems (>100 keV) with a low detection limit and stable dark current. Herein, high-quality inch-size two-dimensional (2D) Cs₃Bi₂Br₉ (CBB) single crystals are grown from a melt via the Bridgman method. The crystal quality is enhanced by eliminating inclusions of CsBr-rich phases and restraining the trap-state density, leading to an enhanced resistivity of 1.41 × 10¹² Ω cm and a mobility lifetime product of 8.32 × 10^-4 cm² V^-1. The Au/CBB/Au single-crystal device exhibits a high sensitivity of 1705 μC Gy_air^-1 cm^-2 in all-inorganic bismuth-based perovskites and an ultralow detection limit of 0.58 nGy_air s^-1 in all of the bismuth-based perovskites for 120 keV hard X-ray detection. The CBB detector exhibits high work stability with an ultralow dark current drift of 2.8 × 10^-10 nA cm^-1 s^-1 V^-1 and long-term air environment reliability under a high electric field of 10 000 V cm^-1 owing to the ultrahigh ionic activation energy of the 2D structure. The proposed robust imaging system based on CBB SC is a promising tool for X-ray medical imaging and diagnostics.

Oriented 2D Perovskite Wafers for Anisotropic X-ray Detection through a Fast Tableting Strategy

2D perovskite single crystals have emerged as excellent optoelectronic materials owing to their unique anisotropic properties. However, growing large 2D perovskite single crystals remains challenging and time-consuming. Here, a new composition of lead-free 2D perovskite-4-fluorophenethylammonium bismuth iodide [(F-PEA)₃ BiI₆ ] is reported. An oriented bulk 2D wafer with a large area of 1.33 cm² is obtained by tableting disordered 2D perovskite powders, resulting in anisotropic resistivities of 5 × 10¹⁰ and 2 × 10¹¹  Ω cm in the lateral and vertical directions, respectively. Trivalent Bi³⁺ ions are employed to achieve a stronger ionic bonding energy with I^- ions, which intrinsically suppress the ion-migration effect. Thus, the oriented wafer presents good capabilities in both charge collection and ion-migration suppression under a large applied bias along the out-of-plane direction, making it suitable for low-dosage X-ray detection. The large-area wafer shows a sensitive response to hard X-rays operated at a tube voltage of 120 kV_p with the lowest detectable dose rate of 30 nGy s^-1 . Thus, the fast tableting process is a facile and effective strategy to synthesize large-area, oriented 2D wafers, showing excellent X-ray detection performance and operational stability that are comparable to those of 2D perovskite single crystals.

Perovskite materials: from single crystals to radiation detection

Pb- and Bi-based perovskite materials have high potential for detecting ionizing radiation but an enhanced research effort is needed to achieve large-size, high-performance single crystals at a competitive cost to accelerate this development.

Solvent Free Laminated Fabrication of Lead Halide Perovskites for Sensitive and Stable X-ray Detection

The halide perovskite X-ray detector can meet the urgent needs of low-dose medical imaging by X-rays. However, there is still a pressing challenge in lacking robust methods for large-scale fabrication of high-quality perovskite films with tunable thickness. Here we report a laminated fabrication of polycrystalline MAPbI₃ by using solvent-free liquid perovskite molten-salt (PMS), that offers reduced toxic issue, scalable fabrication, and highly tunability in film thickness. Nylon membrane was chosen as a scaffold for the infiltration of PMS, which simultaneously acts as a physical barrier to suppress the ionic migration in the MAPbI₃-nylon composite (denoted as MAPbI₃-LLP). The enhanced material properties result in good stability and high performance of X-ray detectors that show low detection limit and high sensitivity. Additionally, single gamma-ray photon detection was realized by MAPbI₃-LLP detectors. The promising performance characteristics of such polycrystalline detectors can accelerate the adoption of polycrystalline perovskites in X-ray imaging and gamma-ray detection.

Zero-Dimensional Lead-Free FA3Bi2I9 Single Crystals for High-Performance X-ray Detection

Direct X-ray detectors based on metal halide perovskites and their derivatives exhibit high sensitivity and low limit of detection (LoD). Compared with three-dimensional (3D) hybrid lead halide perovskites, low-dimensional A₃Bi₂I₉ perovskite derivatives (A = Cs, Rb, NH₄, CH₃NH₃(MA)) present better stability, greater environmental friendliness, and comparable X-ray detection performance. Here, we report FA₃Bi₂I₉ (FA= CH(NH₂)₂) single crystals (SCs) as a new member of the A₃Bi₂I₉ series for X-ray detection, which were prepared by the nucleation-controlled secondary solution constant temperature evaporation (SSCE) method. Centimeter-sized FA₃Bi₂I₉ SCs show a full width at half-maximum (fwhm) of 0.0096°, which is superior to that of recently reported Cs₃Bi₂I₉ (0.058°) and MA₃Bi₂I₉ SCs (0.024°) obtained by inverse temperature crystallization (ITC). The as-grown FA₃Bi₂I₉ SC shows a large resistivity of 7.8 × 10¹⁰ Ω cm and a high ion migration activation energy (E_a) of 0.56 eV, which can guarantee a low noise level and good operational stability under a large external bias. The FA₃Bi₂I₉ SC detector exhibits a LoD of 0.2 μGy_air s^-1, a sensitivity of 598.1 μC Gy_air ^-1 cm ^-2, and an X-ray detection efficiency of 33.5%, which are much better than those of the commercialized amorphous selenium detector. Results presented here will provide a new lead-free perovskite-type material to achieve green, sensitive, and stable X-ray detectors.

Highly Sensitive and Stable X-ray Detector Based on a 0D Structural Cs4PbI6 Single Crystal

Lead halide perovskite single crystals with a high X-ray stopping power and large μτ product have been successfully used for X-ray detection. However, poor air stability and ionic migration lead to the degradation of the devices for long-term operations. Here, we report a solution-processed lead 0D bulk Cs₄PbI₆ single crystal, which have I atoms in isolated [PbI₆]^4-. This 0D Cs₄PbI₆ single crystal has a μτ product of 9.7 × 10^-4 cm² V^-1 and an activation energy of 321.28 meV. We have fabricated a photoconductor device with a symmetric Au/Cs₄PbI₆/Au sandwich structure, which exhibits a high sensitivity of 451.49 μC Gy^-1 cm^-2 under 30 keV X-ray irradiation at an applied voltage of 30 V. After storing the device in air at room temperature for three months, the device retains nearly the same sensitivity as the original. These results demonstrate that this 0D Cs₄PbI₆ perovskite single crystal has great potential for practical X-ray detection applications.