Methane Activation by Iron-Carbide Cluster Anions FeC6(-)

Reaction of size-selected iron-oxide cluster cations with methane: a model study of rapid methane loss in Mars' atmosphere

We report gas-phase reactions of free iron-oxide clusters, FenOm+, and their Ar adducts with methane in the context of chemical processes in Mars' atmosphere. Methane activation was observed to produce FenOmCH2+/FenOmCD2+ and FenOmC+, where the reactivity exhibited size and composition dependence. For example, the rate coefficients of methane activation for Fe3O+ and Fe4O+ were estimated to be 1 × 10-13 and 3 × 10-13 cm3 s-1, respectively. Based on these reaction rate coefficients, the presence of iron-oxide clusters/particles with a density as low as 107 cm-3 in Mars' atmosphere would explain the rapid loss of methane observed recently by the Curiosity rover.

Methane Activation by [OsC3]+: Implications for Catalyst Design

Gas-phase reactions of [OsC₃]⁺ with methane at ambient temperature have been studied by using quadrupole-ion trap mass spectrometry combined with quantum chemical calculations. The comparison of [OsC₃]⁺ with the product clusters revealed significant changes in cluster reactivity. In particular, with different ligands, the cluster may produce multiple products or, alternatively, just a single product. Theoretical calculations reveal the influence of electronic features such as molecular polarity index, charge and spin distribution, and HOMO-LUMO gap on the reactivity of the Os complexes. Fundamentally, it is the polarity of the clusters that leads to the cluster reactivity in the methane activation. Furthermore, reducing the local polarity of the catalyst active site may be one means of reducing the number of byproducts in the reaction.

Role of Magnetization on Catalytic Pathways of Non-Oxidative Methane Activation on Neutral Iron Carbide Clusters

Methane has emerged as a promising fuel due to its abundance and clean combustion properties. It is also a raw material for various value added chemicals. However, the conversion of...

Quadruple C-H Bond Activations of Methane by Dinuclear Rhodium Carbide Cation [Rh2C3]. JACS AU 2021;1:1631-1638. [PMID: 34723266 PMCID: PMC8549038 DOI: 10.1021/jacsau.1c00265]

The structure of the [Rh₂C₃]⁺ ion and its reaction with CH₄ in the gas phase have been studied by infrared photodissociation spectroscopy and mass spectrometry in conjunction with quantum chemical calculations. The [Rh₂C₃]⁺ ion is characterized to have an unsymmetrical linear [Rh-C-C-C-Rh]⁺ structure existing in two nearly isoenergetic spin states. The [Rh₂C₃]⁺ ion reacts with CH₄ at room temperature to form [Rh₂C]⁺ + C₃H₄ and [Rh₂C₂H₂]⁺ + C₂H₂ as the major products. In addition to the [Rh₂C]⁺ ion, the [Rh₂ ¹³C]⁺ ion is formed at about one-half of the [Rh₂C]⁺ intensity when the isotopic-labeled ¹³CH₄ sample is used. The production of [Rh₂ ¹³C]⁺ indicates that the linear C₃ moiety of [Rh₂C₃]⁺ can be replaced by the bare carbon atom of methane with all four C-H bonds being activated. The calculations suggest that the overall reactions are thermodynamically exothermic, and that the two Rh centers are the reactive sites for C-H bond activation and hydrogen atom transfer reactions.

The Reactive Sites of Methane Activation: A Comparison of IrC3+ with PtC3. Molecules 2021;26:molecules26196028. [PMID: 34641573 PMCID: PMC8512126 DOI: 10.3390/molecules26196028]

The activation reactions of methane mediated by metal carbide ions MC₃⁺ (M = Ir and Pt) were comparatively studied at room temperature using the techniques of mass spectrometry in conjunction with theoretical calculations. MC₃⁺ (M = Ir and Pt) ions reacted with CH₄ at room temperature forming MC₂H₂⁺/C₂H₂ and MC₄H₂⁺/H₂ as the major products for both systems. Besides that, PtC₃⁺ could abstract a hydrogen atom from CH₄ to generate PtC₃H⁺/CH₃, while IrC₃⁺ could not. Quantum chemical calculations showed that the MC₃⁺ (M = Ir and Pt) ions have a linear M-C-C-C structure. The first C-H activation took place on the Ir atom for IrC₃⁺. The terminal carbon atom was the reactive site for the first C-H bond activation of PtC₃⁺, which was beneficial to generate PtC₃H⁺/CH₃. The orbitals of the different metal influence the selection of the reactive sites for methane activation, which results in the different reaction channels. This study investigates the molecular-level mechanisms of the reactive sites of methane activation.

Activation of Carbon Dioxide by CoCDn- (n = 0-4) Anions

Laser ablation generated CoCD_n^- (n = 0-4) anions were mass selected and then reacted with CO₂ in an ion trap reactor. The reactions were characterized by mass spectrometry and quantum chemical calculations. The experimental results demonstrated that the CoC^- anion can convert CO₂ into CO. In contrast, the bare Co^- anion is inert toward CO₂. Coordinated D ligands can modify the reactivity of CoCD_1-4^- in which CoCD_1-3^- can reduce CO₂ into CO selectively and CoCD₄^- can only adsorb CO₂. The crucial roles of the coordinated C and D ligands to tune the reactivity of CoCD_n^- (n = 0-4) toward CO₂ were rationalized by theoretical calculations. Note that the hydrogenation process that is usually observed in the reactions of gas-phase metal hydrides with CO₂ is completely suppressed for the reactions CoCD_n^- + CO₂. This study provides insights into the molecular-level origin for the observations that CO can be selectively generated from CO₂ catalyzed by cobalt-containing carbides in heterogeneous catalysis.

Theoretical insights into C-H bond activation of methane by transition metal clusters: the role of anharmonic effects

In heterogeneous catalysis, the determination of active phases has been a long-standing challenge, as materials' properties change under operational conditions (i.e. temperature (T) and pressure (p) in an atmosphere of reactive molecules). As a first step towards materials design for methane activation, we study the T and p dependence of the composition, structure, and stability of metal oxide clusters in a reactive atmosphere at thermodynamic equilibrium using a prototypical model catalyst having wide practical applications: free transition metal (Ni) clusters in a combined oxygen and methane atmosphere. A robust methodological approach is employed, where the starting point is systematic scanning of the potential energy surface (PES) to obtain the global minimum structures using a massively parallel cascade genetic algorithm (cGA) at the hybrid density functional level. The low energy clusters are further analyzed to estimate their thermodynamic stability at realistic T, p _O2 and p _CH4 using ab initio atomistic thermodynamics (aiAT). To incorporate the anharmonicity in the vibrational free energy contribution to the configurational entropy, we evaluate the excess free energy of the clusters numerically by a thermodynamic integration method with ab initio molecular dynamics (aiMD) simulation inputs. By analyzing a large dataset, we show that the conventional harmonic approximation miserably fails for this class of materials, and capturing the anharmonic effects on the vibration free energy contribution is indispensable. The latter has a significant impact on detecting the activation of the C-H bond, while the harmonic infrared spectrum fails to capture this, due to the wrong prediction of the vibrational modes.

Mechanistic insights into the C–H activation of methane mediated by the unsupported and silica-supported VO2OH and CrOOH: a DFT study

The direct activation and conversion of methane has been a topic of interest in both academia and industry for several decades. Deep understanding of the corresponding mechanism and reactivity mediated by diverse catalytic clusters, as well as the supporting materials, is still highly desired. In this work, the regulation mechanism of C–H bond activation of methane, mediated by the closed-shell VO₂OH, the open-shell CrOOH, and their silica supported clusters, has been investigated by density functional theory (DFT) calculations. The hydrogen-atom transfer (HAT) reaction towards methane C–H bond activation is more feasible when mediated by the unsupported/silica-supported CrOOH clusters versus the VO₂OH clusters, due to the intrinsic spin density located on the terminal O_t atom. The proton-coupled electron transfer (PCET) pathways are regulated by both the nucleophilicity of the O_t site and the electrophilicity of the metal center, which show no obvious difference in energy consumption among the four reactions examined. Moreover, the introduction of a silica support can lead to subtle influences on the intermolecular interaction between the CH₄ molecule and the catalyst cluster, as well as the thermodynamics of the methane C–H activation.

The support effect of silica was studied with DFT for the C–H bond activation of methane on a V(v) or a Cr(iii) site. Both of the PCET and HAT mechanisms were computationally characterized.

The reactivity of Nbn+ clusters with acetylene and ethylene to produce a cubic aromatic metal carbide Nb4C4+

The reactions of niobium cationic clusters with acetylene and ethylene under sufficient gas collision conditions give rise to dominant dehydrogenation and produce a main metal carbide Nb4C4+ which is associated with cubic aromaticity.

C/C Exchange in Activation/Coupling Reaction of Acetylene and Methane Mediated by Os+: A Comparison with Ir+, Pt+, and Au. J Phys Chem Lett 2020;11:8346-8351. [PMID: 32885973 DOI: 10.1021/acs.jpclett.0c02068]

The activation and coupling reactions of methane and acetylene mediated by M⁺ (M = Os, Ir, Pt, and Au) have been comparatively studied at room temperature by the techniques of mass spectrometry in conjunction with theoretical calculations. Studies have shown that Os⁺ and Ir⁺ can mediate the activation/coupling reaction of CH₄ and C₂H₂, while Pt⁺ and Au⁺ cannot, which could be explained by the number of empty valence orbitals in the metal atom. In addition, there are different competition channels for the reaction mediated by Os⁺ and Ir⁺: an expected dehydrogenation and an unexpected C/C exchange. We find that if the rare C/C exchange reaction takes place, there are symmetric carbon atoms in the reaction intermediate and the C/C exchange reaction is favored kinetically. The C/C exchange reaction must be considered, which will affect the yield of the products in the primary reaction. This study shows the molecular-level mechanisms which include the C/C exchange reaction in the activation and coupling reaction of organic compounds mediated by different metals.

Boosting the activity of transition metal carbides towards methane activation by nanostructuring

Molybdenum carbide breaks methane by going nano.

Structures and bonding properties of CPt2 -/0 and CPt2H-/0: Anion photoelectron spectroscopy and quantum chemical calculations

We present a combined anion photoelectron spectroscopic and quantum chemical investigation on the structures and bonding properties of CPt₂ ^-/0 and CPt₂H^-/0. The experimental vertical detachment energies of CPt₂ ^- and CPt₂H^- are measured to be 1.91 ± 0.08 and 3.54 ± 0.08 eV, respectively. CPt₂ ^- is identified as a C_2v symmetric Pt-C-Pt bent structure, and CPt₂ has a D_∞h symmetric Pt-C-Pt linear structure. Both anionic and neutral CPt₂H adopt a Pt-C-Pt-H chain-shaped structure, in which the ∠PtCPt and ∠CPtH bond angles of CPt₂H^- are larger than those of CPt₂H. The Pt-C bonds in CPt₂ ^-/0 and CPt₂H^-/0 exhibit covalent double bonding characters. The Pt=C bonds are much stronger than the C-H bond that may explain why the C atom CPt₂H^-/0 prefers to form Pt=C bonds rather than C-H bonds. It may also explain why platinum can insert into the C-H bond to activate the C-H bond as reported in the literature.

Geometric and Electronic Structures of VB40/+ Clusters and Reactivity of the Cationic Cluster with Methane from Quantum Chemical Calculations

Quantum chemical methods have been employed to study the geometric and electronic structures of VB₄^0/+ clusters and the mechanism of the reaction of the cationic clusters with methane. It was found that the ground states of the neutral and cationic clusters were ⁴A' and ³A' of a planar isomer in C_s symmetry in which vanadium atom side-on binds to the rhombic B₄ moiety. The ionization energy of the neutral cluster was calculated to be 7.13 eV at the CCSD(T) level. The reaction pathways on the triplet and quintet potential energy profiles of the dehydrogenation and elimination of V⁺ in the reaction of VB₄⁺ cluster with methane were established based on the BPW91 functional calculations. Both of the dehydrogenation and elimination of V⁺ in the reaction of VB₄⁺ cluster with methane were initiated by the B₄ moiety of the VB₄⁺ cluster, and these two reaction channels were thermodynamically and kinetically favorable. The dehydrogenation and elimination of V⁺ in the reaction of VB₄⁺ cluster with methane were exothermic processes.

Selective Activation of the C-H Bond in Methane by Single Platinum Atomic Anions

Mass spectrometric analysis of the anionic products of interaction between platinum atomic anions, Pt^- , and methane, CH₄ and CD₄ , in a collision cell shows the preferred generation of [PtCH₄ ]^- and [PtCD₄ ]^- complexes and a low tendency toward dehydrogenation. [PtCH₄ ]^- is shown to be H-Pt-CH₃ ^- by a synergy between anion photoelectron spectroscopy and quantum chemical calculations, implying the rupture of a single C-H bond. The calculated reaction pathway accounts for the observed selective activation of methane by Pt^- . This study presents the first example of methane activation by a single atomic anion.

Formation of Acetylene in the Reaction of Methane with Iron Carbide Cluster Anions FeC3- under High-Temperature Conditions

The underlying mechanism for non-oxidative methane aromatization remains controversial owing to the lack of experimental evidence for the formation of the first C-C bond. For the first time, the elementary reaction of methane with atomic clusters (FeC₃^- ) under high-temperature conditions to produce C-C coupling products has been characterized by mass spectrometry. With the elevation of temperature from 300 K to 610 K, the production of acetylene, the important intermediate proposed in a monofunctional mechanism of methane aromatization, was significantly enhanced, which can be well-rationalized by quantum chemistry calculations. This study narrows the gap between gas-phase and condensed-phase studies on methane conversion and suggests that the monofunctional mechanism probably operates in non-oxidative methane aromatization.

Thermal activation of methane by vanadium boride cluster cations VBn+ (n = 3–6)

A new type of active species, transition metal boride cluster cations [VB_n⁺ (n = 3–6)], has been experimentally identified to dehydrogenate methane under thermal collision conditions. The B₃ unit in VB₃⁺ cluster is polarized by the V⁺ cation to activate CH₄.

Methane Activation by Tantalum Carbide Cluster Anions Ta2C4. J Phys Chem Lett 2017;8:605-610. [PMID: 28088857 DOI: 10.1021/acs.jpclett.6b02568]

Methane activation by transition metals is of fundamental interest and practical importance, as this process is extensively involved in the natural gas conversion to fuels and value-added chemicals. While single-metal centers have been well recognized as active sites for methane activation, the active center composed of two or more metal atoms is rarely addressed and the detailed reaction mechanism remains unclear. Here, by using state-of-the-art time-of-flight mass spectrometry, cryogenic anion photoelectron imaging spectroscopy, and quantum-chemical calculations, the cooperation of the two Ta atoms in a dinuclear carbide cluster Ta₂C₄^- for methane activation has been identified. The C-H bond activation takes place predominantly around one Ta atom in the initial stage of the reaction and the second Ta atom accepts the delivered H atom from the C-H bond cleavage. The well-resolved vibrational spectra of the cryogenically cooled anions agree well with theoretical simulations, allowing the clear characterization of the structure of Ta₂C₄^- cluster. The reactivity comparison between Ta₂C₄^- cluster and the carbon-less analogues (Ta₂C₃^- and Ta₂C₂^-) demonstrated that the cooperative effect of the two metal atoms can be well tuned by the carbon ligands in terms of methane activation and transformation.

How far away are iron carbide clusters from the bulk?

Combining the basin hopping structure searching algorithm and density functional theory, the iron carbide clusters, Fe_xC_y (x ≤ 8 and y ≤ 8), and clusters with various stoichiometries (Fe_2nC_n, Fe_3nC_n, Fe_nC_2n, Fe_nC_3n and Fe_nC_4n (n = 1-7), Fe_5nC_2n, and Fe_4nC_n (n = 1-5)) are predicted. The stable structures of iron rich carbide clusters are composed of C-C dimers or single C atoms on the surface of the clusters, which are remarkably different from their corresponding bulk structures, where the carbon atoms are atomically distributed in the iron matrix. The most stable carbon rich clusters are highly diverse in topology (bowl, basket, plane, shoe, necklace, etc.) with long carbon chains. The Bader charge analysis shows that the size effect on iron carbide clusters is an electronic tuning. Large carbon-rich clusters appear even under low carbon chemical potentials, whereas small iron-rich clusters are only energetically stable in high carbon chemical potentials, which indicates that changing the carbon chemical potential can tune the morphology (size and stoichiometry) of the iron carbide clusters. These results may help us understand the catalytic activity of iron and iron carbides in reactions such as the Fischer-Tropsch synthesis and the carbon nanotube formation process.

A nine-atom rhodium-aluminum oxide cluster oxidizes five carbon monoxide molecules

Noble metals can promote the direct participation of lattice oxygen of very stable oxide materials such as aluminum oxide, to oxidize reactant molecules, while the fundamental mechanism of noble metal catalysis is elusive. Here we report that a single atom of rhodium, a powerful noble metal catalyst, can promote the transfer of five oxygen atoms to oxidize carbon monoxide from a nine-atom rhodium-aluminum oxide cluster. This is a sharp improvement in the field of cluster science where the transfer of at most two oxygen atoms from a doped cluster is more commonly observed. Rhodium functions not only as the preferred trapping site to anchor and oxidize carbon monoxide by the oxygen atoms in direct connection with rhodium but also the primarily oxidative centre to accumulate the large amounts of electrons and the polarity of rhodium is ultimately transformed from positive to negative.

Penetrating the Elusive Mechanism of Copper-Mediated Fluoromethylation in the Presence of Oxygen through the Gas-Phase Reactivity of Well-Defined [LCuO](+) Complexes with Fluoromethanes (CH(4-n)Fn, n = 1-3)

Traveling wave ion mobility spectrometry (TWIMS) isomer separation was exploited to react the particularly well-defined ionic species [LCuO](+) (L = 1,10-phenanthroline) with the neutral fluoromethane substrates CH(4-n)Fn (n = 1-3) in the gas phase. Experimentally, the monofluoromethane substrate (n = 1) undergoes both hydrogen-atom transfer, forming the copper hydroxide complex [LCuOH](•+) and concomitantly a CH2F(•) radical, and oxygen-atom transfer, yielding the observable ionic product [LCu](+) plus the neutral oxidized substrate [C,H3,O,F]. DFT calculations reveal that the mechanism for both product channels relies on the initial C-H bond activation of the substrate. Compared to nonfluorinated methane, the addition of fluorine to the substrate assists the reactivity through a lowering of the C-H bond energy and reaction preorganization (through noncovalent interaction in the encounter complex). A two-state reactivity scenario is mandatory for the oxidation, which competitively results in the unusual fluoromethanol product, CH2FOH, or the decomposed products, CH2O and HF, with the latter channel being kinetically disfavored. Difluoromethane (n = 2) is predicted to undergo the analogous reactions at room temperature, although the reactions are less favored than those of monofluoromethane. The reaction of trifluoromethane (n = 3, fluoroform) through C-H activation is kinetically hindered under ambient conditions but might be expected to occur in the condensed phase upon heating or with further lowering of reaction barriers through templation with counterions, such as potassium. Overall, formation of CH(3-n)Fn(•) and CH(3-n)FnOH occurs under relatively gentle energetic conditions, which sheds light on their potential as reactive intermediates in fluoromethylation reactions mediated by copper in the presence of oxygen.

Reactions of metal cluster anions with inorganic and organic molecules in the gas phase

Progress on the activation and transformation of important inorganic and organic molecules by negatively charged bare metal clusters as well as ligated systems with oxygen, carbon, and nitrogen, among others.