Electrophoretic NMR Characterization of Charged Side Chain Cationic Polyelectrolytes and Their Interaction with the Anionic Surfactant, Sodium Dodecyl Sulfate

Distribution of polyelectrolytes and counterions upon polyelectrolyte complexation

HYPOTHESIS

Understanding polyelectrolyte complexation remains limited due to the absence of a systematic methodology for analyzing the distribution of components between the polyelectrolyte complex (PEC) and the dilute phases.

EXPERIMENTS

We developed a methodology based on NMR to quantify all components of solid-like PECs and their supernatant phases formed by mixing different ratios of poly(allylamine hydrochloride) (PAH) and poly(acrylic acid)-sodium salt (PAA). This approach allowed for determining relative and absolute concentrations of polyelectrolytes in both phases by 1H NMR studies. Using 23Na and 35Cl NMR spectroscopy we measured the concentration of counterions in both phases.

FINDINGS

Regardless of the mixing ratio of the polyelectrolytes the PEC is charge-stoichiometric, and any excess polyelectrolytes to achieve charge stoichiometry remains in the supernatant phase. The majority of counterions were found in the supernatant phase, confirming counterion release being a major thermodynamic driving force for PEC formation. The counterion concentrations in the PEC phase were approximately twice as high as in the supernatant phase. The complete mass balance of PEC formation could be determined and translated into a molecular picture. It appears that PAH is fully charged, while PAA is more protonated, so less charged, and some 10% extrinsic PAH-Cl- pairs are present in the complex.

Interactions in Aqueous Mixtures of Cationic Hydroxyethyl Cellulose and Different Anionic Bile Salts

It is known that the reduction of blood cholesterol can be accomplished through foods containing a large number of dietary fibers; this process is partially related to the binding of bile salt to fibers. To gain new insights into the interactions between dietary fibers and bile salts, this study investigates the interactions between cationic hydroxyethyl cellulose (catHEC) and sodium deoxycholate (NaDC) or sodium cholate (NaC), which have a similar structure. Turbidity measurements reveal strong interactions between catHEC and NaDC, and under some conditions, macroscopic phase separation occurs. In contrast, the interactions with NaC are weak. At a catHEC concentration of 2 wt %, incipient phase separation is approached at concentrations of NaC and NaDC of 32.5 and 19.3 mM, respectively. The rheological results show strong interactions and a prominent viscosification effect for the catHEC/NaDC system but only moderate interactions for the catHEC/NaC system. Both cryogenic transmission electron microscopy and small-angle X-ray scattering results display fundamental structural differences between the two systems, which may explain the stronger interactions in the presence of NaDC. The surmise is that the extended structures formed in the presence of NaDC can easily form connections and entanglements in the network.

Relevance of the Cation in Anion Binding of a Triazole Host: An Analysis by Electrophoretic Nuclear Magnetic Resonance

Triazole hosts allow cooperative binding of anions via hydrogen bonds, which makes them versatile systems for application in anion binding catalysis to be performed in organic solvents. The anion binding behavior of a tetratriazole host is systematically studied by employing a variety of salts, including chloride, acetate, and benzoate, as well as different cations. Classical nuclear magnetic resonance (1H NMR) titrations demonstrate a large influence of cation structures on the anion binding constant, which is attributed to poor dissociation of most salts in organic solvents and corrupts the results of classical titration techniques. We propose an approach employing electrophoretic NMR (eNMR), yielding drift velocities of each species in an electric field and thus allowing a distinction between charged and uncharged species. After the determination of the dissociation constants KD for the salts, electrophoretic mobilities are measured for all species in the host-salt system and are analyzed in a model which treats anion binding as a consecutive reaction to salt dissociation, yielding a corrected anion binding constant KA. Interestingly, dependence of KA on salt concentration occurs, which is attributed to cation aggregation with the anion-host complex. Finally, by the extrapolation to zero salt concentration, the true anion-host binding constant is obtained. Thus, the approach by eNMR allows a fully quantitative analysis of two factors that might impair classical anion binding studies, namely, an incomplete salt dissociation as well as the occurrence of larger aggregate species.

Using Polymer-Surfactant Charge Ratio to Control Synergistic Flocculation of Anionic Particulate Dispersions

This study investigates the flocculation induced destabilization of particulate dispersions by oppositely charged polymer−surfactant complexes, with a particular focus on controlling interactions by modulating the charge ratio Z, (where Z = [+polymer]/[−surfactant]) via [−surfactant] at fixed Cpolymer. Cationic hydroxyethyl cellulose (cat-HEC) polymer-sodium dodecylsulfate (SDS) complexes were prepared with either excess polymer (Z > 1) or surfactant (Z < 1) charges. Anionic particulate dispersions (Ludox and polystyrene-butadiene Latex) were then exposed to the complexes, and solvent relaxation NMR was used to characterize the particle surfaces before and after exposure. In both particulate dispersions, flocculation induced destabilization was enhanced after exposure to cat-HEC-SDS complexes with Z > 1, leaving any excess particle surfaces uncoated after gentle centrifugation. However, complexes with Z < 1 showed no adsorption and destabilization in the Ludox dispersions and only slight destabilization in the Latex dispersions due to possible hydrophobic interactions. Substituting SDS for non-ionic surfactant (C12E6) showed no additional destabilization of the dispersions, but post-centrifugation relaxation rates indicated preferential adsorption of C12E6 onto the particle surfaces. Since the dominant forces are electrostatic, this study highlights the possibility of controlling the interactions between oppositely charged polymer−surfactant complexes and particle surfaces by modulating Z through [−surfactant].

Probing Selective Adsorption in Cationic-Polymer Induced Aggregation of Binary Anionic Particulate Dispersions Using Solvent Relaxation NMR

NMR solvent relaxation has been used to characterize the surfaces present in binary anionic particle dispersions, before and after exposure to a cationic polymer. In the polymer-free case, it is shown that the measured specific relaxation rate of the solvent is a population-weighted average of all surfaces present, enabling preferential adsorption to be explored. The addition of the oppositely charged polymer led to phase separation, which was accelerated by gentle centrifugation. The measured relaxation rates and the equilibrium particle concentrations indicate that the cationic hydroxyethylcellulose polymer (HEC LR) exhibited no significant preference for either latex or laponite in binary blends with silica, but a strong preference for TiO2. This study illustrates the versatility of solvent relaxation to probe surface area, surface type and dispersion composition in complex formulations.

Stimuli-responsive polyelectrolyte surfactant complexes for the reversible control of solution viscosity

Interactions of polyelectrolytes with oppositely charged surfactants can give rise to a large variety of self-assembled structures. Some of these systems cause a drastic increase in solution viscosity, which is related to the surfactant forming aggregates interconnecting several polyelectrolyte chains. For these aggregates to form, the surfactant needs to be sufficiently hydrophobic. Here, we present a system consisting of the anionic surfactant sodium monododecyl phosphate and the cationic cellulose-based polyelectrolyte JR 400. The hydrophobicity of the surfactant can be controlled by the solution's pH. At pH > 12, the surfactant headgroup bears two charges. As a consequence, the solution viscosity decreases drastically by up to two orders of magnitude, while it can be as high as 10 Pa s at lower pH. In this paper, we investigate the changes of the mesoscopic structure of the system which lead to such drastic changes in viscosity using small angle neutron scattering and neutron spin-echo spectroscopy. Such systems are potentially interesting as they allow for a modular design where stimuli responsiveness is introduced by relatively small amounts of surfactant reusing the same simple polyelectrolyte.

Charge Modification as a Mechanism for Tunable Properties in Polymer-Surfactant Complexes

Oppositely charged polymer-surfactant complexes are frequently explored as a function of phase space defined by the charge ratio Z, (where Z = [+polymer]/[-surfactant]), commonly accessed through the surfactant concentration. Tuning the phase behaviour and related properties of these complexes is an important tool for optimising commercial formulations; hence, understanding the relationship between Z and bulk properties is pertinent. Here, within a homologous series of cationic hydroxyethyl cellulose (cat-HEC) polymers with minor perturbations in the degree of side chain charge modification, phase space is instead explored through [+polymer] at fixed Cpolymer. The nanostructures were characterised by small-angle neutron scattering (SANS) in D2O solutions and in combination with the oppositely charged surfactant sodium dodecylsulfate (h- or d-SDS). Scattering consistent with thin rods with an average radius of ∼7.7 Å and length of ∼85 Å was observed for all cat-HEC polymers and no significant interactions were shown between the neutral HEC polymer and SDS (CSDS < CMC). For the charge-modified polymers, interactions with SDS were evident and the radius of the formed complexes grew up to ∼15 Å with increasing Z. This study demonstrates a novel approach in which the Z phase space of oppositely charged polymer-surfactant complexes can be controlled at fixed concentrations.

Interaction of Low Molecular Weight Poly(diallyldimethylammonium chloride) and Sodium Dodecyl Sulfate in Low Surfactant-Polyelectrolyte Ratio, Salt-Free Solutions

Coacervation is widely used in formulations to induce a beneficial character to the formulation, but nonequilibrium effects are often manifest. Electrophoretic NMR (eNMR), pulsed-gradient spin-echo NMR (PGSE-NMR), and small-angle neutron scattering (SANS) have been used to quantify the interaction between low molecular cationic poly(diallyldimethylammonium chloride) (PDADMAC) and the anionic surfactant sodium dodecyl sulfate (SDS) in aqueous solution as a model for the precursor state to such nonequilibrium processes. The NMR data show that, within the low surfactant concentration one-phase region, an increasing surfactant concentration leads to a reduction in the charge on the polymer and a collapse of its solution conformation, attaining minimum values coincident with the macroscopic phase separation boundary. Interpretation of the scattering data reveals how the rodlike polymer changes over the same surfactant concentration window, with no discernible fingerprint of micellar type aggregates, but rather with the emergence of disklike and lamellar structures. At the highest surfactant concentration, the emergence of a weak Bragg peak in both the polymer and surfactant scattering suggests these precursor disk and lamellar structures evolve into paracrystalline stacks which ultimately phase separate. Addition of the nonionic surfactant hexa(ethylene glycol) monododecyl ether (C₁₂E₆) to the system seems to have little effect on the PDADMAC/SDS interaction as determined by NMR, merely displacing the observed behavior to lower SDS concentrations, commensurate with the total SDS present in the system. In other words, PDADMAC causes the disruption of the mixed SDS/C₁₂E₆ micelle, leading to SDS-rich PDADAMC/surfactant complexes coexisting with C₁₂E₆-rich micelles in solution.

Surfactant-Modulation of the Cationic-Polymer-Induced Aggregation of Anionic Particulate Dispersions

Commodity formulations contain many chemically distinct components and their mutual interactions define the beneficial characteristics of the formulation. Mixing oppositely charged polymers and surfactants invariably induces macroscopic phase separation, to a degree dependent on the prevailing polymer and surface charge densities, and the interaction can be modulated by added ionic surfactants. Here, it is shown that a general universality exists between the charge present on a series of cationic-modified cellulose polymers—the charge being controlled either by the degree of cationic modification of the polymer itself or through the subsequent level of anionic surfactant binding—and its capacity to remove anionic colloidal material from solution, be that silica particles or polystyrene-butadiene lattices. Particulate material not removed from solution bears no adsorbed polymer, i.e., the particle surface is bare. Addition of nonionic surfactant does not negate this universality, implying that the nonionic surfactant is largely a spectator molecule or structure (micelle) in these systems, and that the dominant force is an electrostatic one.