Evaluation of Photocatalysts for Water Splitting through Combined Analysis of Surface Coverage and Energy-Level Alignment

Aqueous Titania Interfaces

Water-metal oxide interfaces are central to many phenomena and applications, ranging from material corrosion and dissolution to photoelectrochemistry and bioengineering. In particular, the discovery of photocatalytic water splitting on TiO2 has motivated intensive studies of water-TiO2 interfaces for decades. So far, a broad understanding of the interaction of water vapor with several TiO2 surfaces has been obtained. However, much less is known about liquid water-TiO2 interfaces, which are more relevant to many practical applications. Probing these complex systems at the molecular level is experimentally challenging and is sometimes possible only through computational studies. This review summarizes recent advances in the atomistic understanding, mostly through computational simulations, of the structure and dynamics of interfacial water on TiO2 surfaces. The main focus is on the nature, molecular or dissociated, of water in direct contact with low-index defect-free crystalline surfaces. The hydroxyls resulting from water dissociation are essential in the photooxidation of water and critically affect the surface chemistry of TiO2.

Key Ingredients for the Screening of Single Atom Catalysts for the Hydrogen Evolution Reaction: The Case of Titanium Nitride

A computational screening of Single Atom Catalysts (SACs) bound to titanium nitride (TiN) is presented, for the Hydrogen Evolution Reaction (HER), based on density functional theory. The role of fundamental ingredients is explored to account for a reliable screening of SACs. Namely, the formation of H2-complexes besides the classical H* one impacts the predicted HER activity, in line with previous studies on other SACs. Also, the results indicate that one needs to adopt self-interaction-corrected functionals. Finally, predicting an active catalyst is of little help without an assessment of its stability. Thus, it is included in the theoretical framework the analysis of the stability of the SACs in working conditions of pH and voltage. Once unconventional intermediates and stability are considered in a self-interaction corrected scheme, the number of potential good catalysts for HER is strongly reduced since i) some potentially good catalysts are not stable against dissolution and ii) the formation of unconventional intermediates leads to thermodynamic barriers. This study highlights the importance of including ingredients for the prediction of new systems, such as the formation of unconventional intermediates, estimating the stability of SACs, and the adoption of self-interaction corrected functionals. Also, this study highlights some interesting candidates deserving of dedicated work.

Water effect on the band edges of anatase TiO2 surfaces: A theoretical study on charge migration across surface heterojunctions and facet-dependent photoactivity

The charge migration mechanism across the surface heterojunction constructed on an anatase TiO2 nanocrystal is still under debate. To solve this longstanding question, we present a systematic study of the band edges (vs. standard hydrogen electrode, SHE) of aqueous TiO2 interfaces with anatase (101), (100) and (001) surfaces, using a combination of density functional theory-based molecular dynamics (DFTMD) and efficient computational SHE (cSHE) methods. Our calculations show that the conduction band minimum (CBM) of the (101) surface is lower than that of (001) and (100) surfaces, which is thermodynamically favorable for electrons migrating to the (101) surface through the surface heterojunction, while the hole preferentially accumulates on the (100) surface due to its highest valence band minimum (VBM). In addition, we qualitatively explore the facet-dependent photocatalytic activity of anatase TiO2. Due to the possession of both the beneficial atomic structure (with 100% undercoordinated Ti5c atoms at the surface) and electronic structure (more strongly oxidizing holes in the VBM and efficient electron-hole spatial separation separation), the (001) surface exhibits the most efficient photocatalytic performance for water oxidation. Furthermore, it is confirmed that the use of simplified theoretical models neglecting the detailed atomic structures of water at the aqueous interface is inadequate to predict the band alignment of semiconductors relative to water redox potentials, so that it may result in substantial errors in evaluating the photocatalytic performance of materials to be used for water splitting.

Influence of Excess Charge on Water Adsorption on the BiVO4(010) Surface

We present a combined computational and experimental study of the adsorption of water on the Mo-doped BiVO₄(010) surface, revealing how excess electrons influence the dissociation of water and lead to hydroxyl-induced alterations of the surface electronic structure. By comparing ambient pressure resonant photoemission spectroscopy (AP-ResPES) measurements with the results of first-principles calculations, we show that the dissociation of water on the stoichiometric Mo-doped BiVO₄(010) surface stabilizes the formation of a small electron polaron on the VO₄ tetrahedral site and leads to an enhanced concentration of localized electronic charge at the surface. Our calculations demonstrate that the dissociated water accounts for the enhanced V⁴⁺ signal observed in ambient pressure X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy and the enhanced signal of a small electron polaron inter-band state observed in AP-ResPES measurements. For ternary oxide surfaces, which may contain oxygen vacancies in addition to other electron-donating dopants, our study reveals the importance of defects in altering the surface reactivity toward water and the concomitant water-induced modifications to the electronic structure.

The Fermi level as an energy reference in liquid jet X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy studies of aqueous solutions

To advance the understanding of key electrochemical and photocatalytic processes that depend on the electronic structure of aqueous solutions, X-ray photoemission spectroscopy has become an invaluable tool, especially when practiced with liquid microjet setups. Determining vertical ionization energies referenced to the vacuum level, and binding energies referenced to the Fermi level, including the much-coveted reorganization energy of the oxidized species of a redox couple, requires that energy levels be properly defined. The present paper addresses specifically how the vacuum level "just outside the surface" can be known through the energy position of the rising edge of the secondary electrons, and how the Fermi level reference is uniquely determined via the introduction of a redox couple. Taking the case of the ferricyanide/ferrocyanide and ferric/ferrous couples, this study also tackles issues related to the electrokinetic effects inherent to the production of a liquid jet in a vacuum, which has become the standard water sample environment for photoemission experiments.

A bias-free CuBi2O4–CuWO4 tandem cell for solar-driven water splitting

An all-copper-based oxide tandem cell based on CuBi₂O₄ and CuWO₄ films has been fabricated which shows promising water splitting photocurrents under simulated solar insolation without an external bias.