Computational Study for CO2-to-CO Conversion over Proton Reduction Using [Re[bpyMe(Im-R)](CO)3Cl]+ (R = Me, Me2, and Me4) Electrocatalysts and Comparison with Manganese Analogues

Computational Modeling of Electrocatalysts for CO2 Reduction: Probing the Role of Primary, Secondary, and Outer Coordination Spheres

ConspectusIn the search for efficient and selective electrocatalysts capable of converting greenhouse gases to value-added products, enzymes found in naturally existing bacteria provide the basis for most approaches toward electrocatalyst design. Ni,Fe-carbon monoxide dehydrogenase (Ni,Fe-CODH) is one such enzyme, with a nickel-iron-sulfur cluster named the C-cluster, where CO2 binds and is converted to CO at high rates near the thermodynamic potential. In this Account, we divide the enzyme's catalytic contributions into three categories based on location and function. We also discuss how computational techniques provide crucial insight into implementing these findings in homogeneous CO2 reduction electrocatalysis design principles. The CO2 binding sites (e.g., Ni and "unique" Fe ion) along with the ligands that support it (e.g., iron-sulfur cluster) form the primary coordination sphere. This is replicated in molecular electrocatalysts via the metal center and ligand framework where the substrate binds. This coordination sphere has a direct impact on the electronic configuration of the catalyst. By computationally modeling a series of Ni and Co complexes with bipyridyl-N-heterocyclic carbene ligand frameworks of varying degrees of planarity, we were able to closely examine how the primary coordination sphere controls the product distribution between CO and H2 for these catalysts. The secondary coordination sphere (SCS) of Ni,Fe-CODH contains residues proximal to the active site pocket that provide hydrogen-bonding stabilizations necessary for the reaction to proceed. Enhancing the SCS when synthesizing new catalysts involves substituting functional groups onto the ligand for direct interaction with the substrate. To analyze the endless possible substitutions, computational techniques are ideal for deciphering the intricacies of substituent effects, as we demonstrated with an array of imidazolium-functionalized Mn and Re bipyridyl tricarbonyl complexes. By examining how the electrostatic interactions between the ligand, substrate, and proton source lowered activation energy barriers, we determined how best to pinpoint the SCS additions. The outer coordination sphere comprises the remaining parts of Ni,Fe-CODH, such as the elaborate protein matrix, solvent interactions, and remote metalloclusters. The challenge in elucidating and replicating the role of the vast protein matrix has understandably led to a localized focus on the primary and secondary coordination spheres. However, certain portions of Ni,Fe-CODH's expansive protein scaffold are suggested to be catalytically relevant despite considerable distance from the active site. Closer studies of these relatively overlooked areas of nature's exceptionally proficient catalysts may be crucial to continually improve upon electrocatalysis protocols. Mechanistic analysis of cobalt phthalocyanines (CoPc) immobilized onto carbon nanotubes (CoPc/CNT) reveals how the active site microenvironment and outer coordination sphere effects unlock the CoPc molecule's previously inaccessible intrinsic catalytic ability to convert CO2 to MeOH. Our research suggests that incorporating the three coordination spheres in a holistic approach may be vital for advancing electrocatalysis toward viability in mitigating climate disruption. Computational methods allow us to closely examine transition states and determine how to minimize key activation energy barriers.

Pre-equilibrium reactions involving pendent relays improve CO2 reduction mediated by molecular Cr-based electrocatalysts

Homogeneous earth abundant transition-metal electrocatalysts capable of carbon dioxide (CO2) reduction to generate value-added chemical products are a possible strategy to minimize rising anthropogenic CO2 emissions. Previously, it was determined that Cr-centered bipyridine-based N2O2 complexes for CO2 reduction are kinetically limited by a proton-transfer step during C-OH bond cleavage. Therefore, it was hypothesized that the inclusion of pendent relay groups in the secondary coordination sphere of these molecular catalysts could increase their catalytic activity. Here, it is shown that the introduction of a pendent methoxy group favorably impacts a pre-equilibrium protonation prior to the catalytic resting state, resulting in a significant increase in catalytic activity without a loss of product selectivity for generating carbon monoxide (CO) from CO2. Interestingly, combining the pendent methoxy group with a cationic acid causes a positive shift of the catalytic reduction potential of the system, while maintaining increased activity and quantitative selectivity. This work suggests that tuning the secondary coordination sphere with respect to cationic proton sources can result in activity improvements by modifying the kinetic and thermodynamic aspects of proton transfer in the catalytic cycle.

Room Temperature Construction of Vicinal Amino Alcohols via Electroreductive Cross-Coupling of N-Heteroarenes and Carbonyls

Despite the widespread applications of α-hydroxyalkyl cyclic amines, direct and diverse access to such a class of unique vicinal amino alcohols still remains, to date, a challenge. Here, through a strategy of electroreductive α-hydroxyalkylation of inactive N-heteroarenes with ketones or electron-rich arylaldehydes, we describe a room temperature approach for the direct construction of α-hydroxyalkyl cyclic amines, which features a broad substrate scope, operational simplicity, high chemoselectivity, and no need for pressurized H₂ gas and transition metal catalysts. The zinc ion generated from anode oxidation plays a crucial role in the activation of both reactants by decreasing their reduction potentials. The strategy of electroreduction in combination with substrate activation by Lewis acids in this work is anticipated to develop more useful transformations.

Understanding the Role of Inter- and Intramolecular Promoters in Electro- and Photochemical CO2 Reduction Using Mn, Re, and Ru Catalysts

Recycling of carbon dioxide to fuels and chemicals is a promising strategy for renewable energy storage. Carbon dioxide conversion can be achieved by (i) artificial photosynthesis using photoinduced electrons; (ii) electrolysis using electricity produced by photovoltaics; and (iii) thermal CO₂ hydrogenation using renewable H₂. The focus of our group's research is on molecular catalysts, in particular coordination complexes of transition metals (e.g., Mn, Re, and Ru), which offer versatile platforms for mechanistic studies of photo- and electrochemical CO₂ reduction. The interactions of catalytic intermediates with Lewis or Brønsted acids, hydrogen-bonding moieties, solvents, cations, etc., that function as promoters or cofactors have become increasingly important for efficient catalysis. These interactions may have dramatic effects on selectivity and rates by stabilizing intermediates or lowering transition state barriers, but they are difficult to elucidate and challenging to predict. We have been carrying out experimental and theoretical studies of CO₂ reduction using molecular catalysts toward addressing mechanisms of efficient CO₂ reduction systems with emphasis on those containing intramolecular (or pendent) and intermolecular (solution phase) additives. This Account describes the identification of reaction intermediates produced during CO₂ reduction in the presence of triethanolamine or ionic liquids, the benefits of hydrogen-bonding interactions among intermediates or cofactors, and the complications of pendent phenolic donors/phenoxide bases under electrochemical conditions.Triethanolamine (TEOA) is a common sacrificial electron donor for photosensitizer excited state reductive quenching and has a long history of use in photocatalytic CO₂ reduction. It also functions as a Brønsted base in conjunction with more potent sacrificial electron donors, such as 1,3-dimethyl-2-phenyl-2,3-dihydro-1H-benzo[d]imidazole (BIH). Deprotonation of the BIH^•+ cation radical promotes irreversible photoinduced electron transfer by preventing charge recombination. Despite its wide use, most research to date has not considered the broader reactions of TEOA, including its direct interaction with CO₂ or its influence on catalytic intermediates. We found that in acetonitrile, TEOA captures CO₂ in the form of a zwitterionic adduct without any metal catalyst. In the presence of ruthenium carbonyl catalysts bearing α-diimine ligands, it participates in metal hydride formation, accelerates hydride transfer to CO₂ to form the bound formate intermediate, and assists in the dissociation of formate anion from the catalyst ( J. Am. Chem. Soc. 2020, 142, 2413-2428).Hydrogen bonding and acid/base promoters are understood to interact with key catalytic intermediates, such as the metallocarboxylate or metallocarboxylic acid during CO₂ reduction. The former is a high energy species, and hydrogen-bonding or Lewis acid-stabilization are beneficial. We have found that imidazolium-based ionic liquid cations can stabilize the doubly reduced form of the [ReCl(bpy)(CO)₃] (bpy = 2,2'-bipyridine) electrocatalyst through both hydrogen-bonding and π-π interactions, resulting in CO₂ reduction occurring at a more positive potential with a higher catalytic current ( J. Phys. Chem. Lett. 2014, 5, 2033-2038). Hydrogen bonding interactions between Lewis basic methoxy groups in the second coordination sphere of a Mn-based catalyst and the OH group of the Mn-COOH intermediate in the presence of a Brønsted acid were also found to promote C-(OH) bond cleavage, enabling access to a low-energy protonation-first pathway for CO₂ reduction ( J. Am. Chem. Soc. 2017, 139, 2604-2618).The kinetics of forming the metallocarboxylic acid can be enhanced by internal acids, and its proton-induced C-OH bond cleavage to the metallocarbonyl and H₂O is often the rate-limiting step. Therefore, proton movement organized by pendent hydrogen-bonding networks may also accelerate this step. In contrast, during electrolysis, OH groups in the second coordination sphere are deprotonated to the oxyanions, which deter catalytic CO₂ reduction by directly binding CO₂ to form the carbonate or by making an M-O bond in competition with CO₂ binding ( Inorg. Chem. 2016, 55, 4582-4594). Our results emphasize that detailed mechanistic research is critical in discovering the design principles for improved catalysts.

Mechanistic Study of Tungsten Bipyridyl Tetracarbonyl Electrocatalysts for CO2 Fixation: Exploring the Roles of Explicit Proton Sources and Substituent Effects

Tungsten bipyridyl tetracarbonyl complexes were shown to reduce CO2 to CO in acetonitrile [Chem. Sci., 2014, 5, 1894-1900]. Here, we employ density functional theory (DFT) calculations to investigate the electronic structure and reactivity of a series of tungsten electrocatalysts, [W(bpy-R)(CO)4] (where R = H, CH3, tBu, OCH3, CF3, and CN), for the CO2 reduction reaction (CO2RR). Our proposed mechanism suggests that initial reduction of the starting material by two electrons is required to access the active catalyst upon CO dissociation, which is slightly endergonic, consistent with the slow product release observed experimentally. The doubly reduced species, which has a closed-shell singlet ground state, can bind CO2 via an η2-CO2 binding mode to yield the metallocarboxylate intermediate. Based on the energy span model, CO2 addition is the TOF-determining transition state (TDTS) in the presence of water as the proton source. Different substituents at the 4,4'-positions of the bipyridine ligand in [W(bpy-R)(CO)4] (R = H, CH3, tBu, OCH3, CF3, and CN) were considered to comprehend the substituent effects for CO2RR. DFT results show that electron-withdrawing substituents, such as CN and CF3, do not yield efficient CO2 reduction catalysts due to the necessity of forming high energy intermediates for the protonation steps, resulting in low TOFs and high overpotentials. Among electron-donating groups, the parent compound and tert-butyl substituted complex are the most active catalysts for CO2RR due to higher TOFs at low overpotentials. Overall, based on the energy span model and theoretical Tafel plots, our computational approach provides quantitative information for designing CO2 reduction electrocatalysts.