Hydrogen Evolution Catalysis by a Sparsely Substituted Cobalt Chlorin

Fluorinated chlorin chromophores for red-light-driven CO2 reduction

The utilization of low-energy photons in light-driven reactions is an effective strategy for improving the efficiency of solar energy conversion. In nature, photosynthetic organisms use chlorophylls to harvest the red portion of sunlight, which ultimately drives the reduction of CO2. However, a molecular system that mimics such function is extremely rare in non-noble-metal catalysis. Here we report a series of synthetic fluorinated chlorins as biomimetic chromophores for CO2 reduction, which catalytically produces CO under both 630 nm and 730 nm light irradiation, with turnover numbers of 1790 and 510, respectively. Under appropriate conditions, the system lasts over 240 h and stays active under 1% concentration of CO2. Mechanistic studies reveal that chlorin and chlorinphlorin are two key intermediates in red-light-driven CO2 reduction, while corresponding porphyrin and bacteriochlorin are much less active forms of chromophores.

Switching Electrocatalytic Hydrogen Evolution Pathways through Electronic Tuning of Copper Porphyrins

The electronic structure of metal complexes plays key roles in determining their catalytic features. However, controlling electronic structures to regulate reaction mechanisms is of fundamental interest but has been rarely presented. Herein, we report electronic tuning of Cu porphyrins to switch pathways of the hydrogen evolution reaction (HER). Through controllable and regioselective β-oxidation of Cu porphyrin 1, we synthesized analogues 2-4 with one or two β-lactone groups in either a cis or trans configuration. Complexes 1-4 have the same Cu-N4 core site but different electronic structures. Although β-oxidation led to large anodic shifts of reductions, 1-4 displayed similar HER activities in terms of close overpotentials. With electrochemical, chemical and theoretical results, we show that the catalytically active species switches from a CuI species for 1 to a Cu0 species for 4. This work is thus significant to present mechanism-controllable HER via electronic tuning of catalysts.

Diversifying the functions of heme proteins with non-porphyrin cofactors

Heme proteins perform diverse biochemical functions using a single iron porphyrin cofactor. This versatility makes them attractive platforms for the development of new functional proteins. While directed evolution and metal substitution have expanded the properties, reactivity, and applications of heme proteins, the incorporation of porphyrin analogs remains an underexplored approach. This review discusses the replacement of heme with non-porphyrin cofactors, such as porphycene, corrole, tetradehydrocorrin, phthalocyanine, and salophen, and the attendant properties of these conjugates. While structurally similar, each ligand exhibits distinct optical and redox properties, as well as unique chemical reactivity. These hybrids serve as model systems to elucidate the effects of the protein environment on the electronic structure, redox potentials, optical properties, or other features of the porphyrin analog. Protein encapsulation can confer distinct chemical reactivity or selectivity of artificial metalloenzymes that cannot be achieved with the small molecule catalyst alone. Additionally, these conjugates can interfere with heme acquisition and uptake in pathogenic bacteria, providing an inroad to innovative antibiotic strategies. Together, these examples illustrate the diverse functionality that can be achieved by cofactor substitution. The further expansion of this approach will access unexplored chemical space, enabling the development of superior catalysts and the creation of heme proteins with emergent properties.

Tetraphenylporphyrin electrocatalysts for the hydrogen evolution reaction: applicability of molecular volcano plots to experimental operating conditions

Recent years have seen an increasing interest in molecular electrocatalysts for the hydrogen evolution reaction (HER). Efficient hydrogen evolution would play an important role in a sustainable fuel economy, and molecular systems could serve as highly specific and tunable alternatives to traditional noble metal surface catalysts. However, molecular catalysts are currently mostly used in homogeneous setups, where quantitative evaluation of catalytic activity is non-standardized and cumbersome, in particular for multistep, multielectron processes. The molecular design community would therefore be well served by a straightforward model for prediction and comparison of the efficiency of molecular catalysts. Recent developments in this area include attempts at applying the Sabatier principle and the volcano plot concept - popular tools for comparing metal surface catalysts - to molecular catalysis. In this work, we evaluate the predictive power of these tools in the context of experimental operating conditions, by applying them to a series of tetraphenylporphyrins employed as molecular electrocatalysts of the HER. We show that the binding energy of H and the redox chemistry of the porphyrins depend solely on the electron withdrawing ability of the central metal ion, and that the thermodynamics of the catalytic cycle follow a simple linear free energy relation. We also find that the catalytic efficiency of the porphyrins is almost exclusively determined by reaction kinetics and therefore cannot be explained by thermodynamics alone. We conclude that the Sabatier principle, linear free energy relations and molecular volcano plots are insufficient tools for predicting and comparing activity of molecular catalysts, and that experimentally useful information of catalytic performance can still only be obtained through detailed knowledge of the catalytic pathway for each individual system.

Syntheses and Properties of Metalated Tetradehydrocorrins

The monoanionic tetrapyrrolic macrocycle B,C-tetradehydrocorrin (TDC) resides chemically between corroles and corrins. This chemical space remains largely unexplored due to a lack of reliable synthetic strategies. We now report the preparation and characterization of Co(II)- and Ni(II)-metalated TDC derivatives ([Co-TDC]⁺ and [Ni-TDC]⁺, respectively) with a combination of crystallographic, electrochemical, computational, and spectroscopic techniques. [Ni-TDC]⁺ was found to undergo primarily ligand-centered electrochemical reduction, leading to hydrogenation of the macrocycle under cathodic electrolysis in the presence of acid. Transient absorption (TA) spectroscopy reveals that [Ni-TDC]⁺ and the two-electron-reduced [Ni-TDC]^- possess long-lived excited states, whereas the excited state of singly reduced [Ni-TDC] exhibits picosecond dynamics. The Co(I) compound [Co-TDC] is air stable, highlighting the notable property of the TDC ligand to stabilize low-valent metal centers in contradistinction to other tetrapyrroles such as corroles, which typically stabilize metals in higher oxidation states.

Covalent Metalloporphyrin Polymer Coated on Carbon Nanotubes as Bifunctional Electrocatalysts for Water Splitting

Metalloporphyrins have exhibited excellent electrocatalytic activities for the hydrogen evolution reaction (HER) and the oxygen evolution reaction (OER). In order to improve the efficiency and conductivity, these molecular catalysts need to be immobilized on conductive electrode materials. Herein, a facile "one-pot" strategy was developed to coat a covalent metalloporphyrin polymer on a carbon nanotube (CNT) as bifunctional catalysts [denoted as MTIPP@CNTs, H₂TIPP = 5,10,15,20-tetra(4-(imidazole-1-yl)phenyl)porphyrin)] for water splitting in alkaline solution. MTIPP@CNTs have shown excellent electrocatalytic activities for both the HER and OER when metalloporphyrin's central metal is optimized as well as the amount of catalysts that is loaded on the CNT. The overpotential (η₁₀) of NiTIPP@CNT-2 for the OER is only 320 mV at a current density of 10 mA cm^-2 in 1.0 M KOH, and CoTIPP@CNT-1 exhibited an excellent electrocatalytic activity for the HER (η₁₀ = 450 mV for 10 mA cm^-2). Furthermore, the remarkable bifunctional electrocatalytic performance (a cell voltage of 2.04 V with a current density of 10 mA cm^-2) was also explored in the overall water splitting test.

Through-Space Electrostatic Effects of Positively Charged Substituents on the Hydrogen Evolution Reaction

Elucidating the effects of various structural components on energy-related small molecule activation is of fundamental and practical significance. Herein the inhibition effect of positively charged substituents on the hydrogen evolution reaction (HER) was reported. With the use of Cu porphyrins 1-5 containing different numbers and locations of positively charged substituents, it was demonstrated that their electrocatalytic HER activities significantly decreased when more cationic units were located close to the Cu ion: the i_cat /i_p (i_cat is the catalytic peak current, i_p is the one-electron reduction peak current) value decreased from 38 with zero cationic unit to 15 with four closely located cationic units. Inspired by this result, Cu porphyrin 6, with four meso-phenyl groups each bearing a negatively charged para-sulfonic substituent, was designed. With these anionic units, 6 outperformed the other Cu porphyrins for electrocatalytic HER under the same conditions.

Quantitative Assessment of Ligand Substituent Effects on σ‐ and π‐Contributions to Fe−N Bonds in Spin Crossover Fe II Complexes

The effect of para‐substituent X on the electronic structure of sixteen tridentate 4‐X‐(2,6‐di(pyrazol‐1‐yl))‐pyridine (bpp^X) ligands and the corresponding solution spin crossover [Fe^II(bpp^X)₂]²⁺ complexes is analysed further, to supply quantitative insights into the effect of X on the σ‐donor and π‐acceptor character of the Fe‐N_A(pyridine) bonds. EDA‐NOCV on the sixteen LS complexes revealed that neither ΔE_orb,σ+π (R²=0.48) nor ΔE_orb,π (R²=0.31) correlated with the experimental solution T_1/2 values (which are expected to reflect the ligand field imposed on the iron centre), but that ΔE_orb,σ correlates well (R²=0.82) and implies that as X changes from EDG→EWG (Electron Donating to Withdrawing Group), the ligand becomes a better σ‐donor. This counter‐intuitive result was further probed by Mulliken analysis of the N_A atomic orbitals: N_A(p_x) involved in the Fe−N σ‐bond vs. the perpendicular N_A(p_z) employed in the ligand aromatic π‐system. As X changes EDG→EWG, the electron population on N_A(p_z) decreases, making it a better π‐acceptor, whilst that in N_A(p_x) increases, making it a better σ‐bond donor; both increase ligand field, and T_1/2 as observed. In 2016, Halcrow, Deeth and co‐workers proposed an intuitively reasonable explanation of the effect of the para‐X substituents on the

T_1/2 values in this family of complexes, consistent with the calculated MO energy levels, that M→L π‐backdonation dominates in these M−L bonds. Here the quantitative EDA‐NOCV analysis of the M−L bond contributions provides a more complete, coherent and detailed picture of the relative impact of M−L σ‐versus π‐bonding in determining the observed T_1/2, refining the earlier interpretation and revealing the importance of the σ‐bonding. Furthermore, our results are in perfect agreement with the ΔE(HS‐LS) vs. σ_p⁺(X) correlation reported in their work.

Bimetallic copper nickel sulfide electrocatalyst by one step chemical bath deposition for efficient and stable overall water splitting applications

Transition metal sulfides have been intensively investigated as an effective catalyst for overall water splitting application due to their inexorable bifunctional oxygen evolution reaction (OER) and hydrogen evolution reaction (HER) activity. However, the chalcogenides are oxidised during the OER process and hence limit the stability of the electrocatalyst. The synthesized materials should have a higher oxidation state corresponding to the active species in order to improve the stability. In this study, we have employed a one-step chemical bath deposition (CBD) route to synthesis bimetallic copper nickel sulfide (CuNiS) electrocatalyst. We have accomplished a superior OER electrocatalytic activity with a lower overpotential of 337 mV at 10 mA/cm² current density and a small Tafel slope of 43 mV/dec. Also, we have achieved an excellent HER activity with a very low overpotential of 99 mV at 10 mA/cm² and a Tafel slope of 63 mV/dec. The constructed electrolyzer attained a lower cell voltage of only 1.55 V to reach the current density of 10 mA/cm²_. The stability test carried at a high current density of 200 mA/cm² for 50 h showed less than 5% increase in Ni³⁺ active species at the surface ensure the stable performance nature. Thus, this work provides a promising methodology for the synthesis of bimetallic sulfides for enhanced electrocatalytic water splitting with exceptional reliability.

Probing the generality of spin crossover complex T½vs. ligand 15N NMR chemical shift correlations: towards predictable tuning

A study of 6 families (42 members) demonstrates that within a family the easily calculated 15N-NMR values of ligands enable predictable tuning of T1/2 in the corresponding complexes, except for 2 families with weakly influencing meta-substituents.

Quantitative and Chemically Intuitive Evaluation of the Nature of M-L Bonds in Paramagnetic Compounds: Application of EDA-NOCV Theory to Spin Crossover Complexes

To improve understanding of M-L bonds in 3d transition metal complexes, analysis by energy decomposition analysis and natural orbital for chemical valence model (EDA-NOCV) is desirable as it provides a full, quantitative and chemically intuitive ab initio description of the M-L interactions. In this study, a generally applicable fragmentation and computational protocol was established and validated by using octahedral spin crossover (SCO) complexes, as the transition temperature (T1/2 ) is sensitive to subtle changes in M-L bonding. Specifically, EDA-NOCV analysis of Fe-N bonds in five [FeII (Lazine )2 (NCBH3 )2 ], in both low-spin (LS) and paramagnetic high-spin (HS) states led to: 1) development of a general, widely applicable, corrected M+L6 fragmentation, tested against a family of five LS [FeII (Lazine )3 ](BF4 )2 complexes; this confirmed that three Lazine are stronger ligands (ΔEorb,σ+π =-370 kcal mol-1 ) than 2 Lazine +2 NCBH3 (=-335 kcal mol-1 ), as observed. 2) Analysis of Fe-L bonding on LS→HS, reveals more ionic (ΔEelstat ) and less covalent (ΔEorb ) character (ΔEelstat :ΔEorb 55:45 LS→64:36 HS), mostly due to a big drop in σ (ΔEorb,σ ↓50 %; -310→-145 kcal mol-1 ), and a drop in π contributions (ΔEorb,π ↓90 %; -30→-3 kcal mol-1 ). 3) Strong correlation of observed T1/2 and ΔEorb,σ+π , for both LS and HS families (R2 =0.99 LS, R2 =0.95 HS), but no correlation of T1/2 and ΔΔEorb,σ+π (LS-HS) (R2 =0.11). Overall, this study has established and validated an EDA-NOCV protocol for M-L bonding analysis of any diamagnetic or paramagnetic, homoleptic or heteroleptic, octahedral transition metal complex. This new and widely applicable EDA-NOCV protocol holds great promise as a predictive tool.

First-row transition metal porphyrins for electrocatalytic hydrogen evolution — a SPP/JPP Young Investigator Award paper

A series of first-row transition metal complexes of tetrakis(pentafluorophenyl)porphyrin (1), denoted as 1-M (M [Formula: see text] Mn, Fe, Co, Ni, Cu, and Zn), were synthesized and examined as electrocatalysts for the hydrogen evolution reaction (HER). All these transition metal porphyrins were shown to be active for HER in acetonitrile using trifluoroacetic acid (TFA) as the proton source. The molecular nature and the stability of these metal porphyrins when functioning as HER catalysts were confirmed, and all catalysts gave Faradaic efficiency of >97% for H2 generation during bulk electrolysis. Importantly, by using 1-Cu, a remarkably high turnover frequency (TOF) of 48500 s[Formula: see text] 1-Cu the most efficient among this series of metal porphyrin catalysts. This TOF value also represents one of the highest values reported in the literature. In addition, electrochemical analysis demonstrated that catalytic HER mechanisms with these 1-M complexes are different. These results show that with the same porphyrin ligand, the change of metal ions will have significant impact on both catalytic efficiency and mechanism. This work for the first time provides direct comparison of electrocatalytic HER features of transition metal complexes of tetrakis(pentafluorophenyl)porphyrin under identical conditions, and will be valuable for future design and development of more efficient HER electrocatalysts of this series.

Synthesis of Hangman Chlorins

Two complementary rational synthetic routes have been developed in order to synthesize hangman chlorins, which differ with regard to the order of the installation (pre- and post-formation of the chlorin macrocycle) and position of the xanthene backbone about the chlorin periphery. The versatility of the synthetic method is demonstrated with the preparation of ten new hangman chlorins bearing a xanthene backbone and a pendant carboxylic acid. Cyclic voltammograms of hangman chlorins exhibit a hangman effect derived from intermolecular proton transfer. This hangman effect is manifested in catalytic hydrogen evolution production.

Investigation of the demetallation of 10-aryl substituted synthetic chlorins under acidic conditions

The acidic demetallation of a series of sparsely substituted Zn(II) chlorins is reported. The chlorins were functionalized in the 10-position with substituents ranging from strongly electron donating mesityl and p-methoxyphenyl to electron-withdrawing p-nitrophenyl and pentafluorophenyl groups. The demetallation kinetics were investigated using UV-Visible absorption spectroscopy. Demetallation was carried out by exposing the metallochlorins dissolved in CH₂Cl₂ to an excess of trifluoroacetic acid. Reasonable correlation was found between the Hammett constant of the 10-substituent and the rate constant of the loss of the metal ion. The largest differences were observed between the p-methoxyphenyl and p-nitrophenyl-substituted Zn(II) chlorins, undergoing loss of Zn(II) with pseudo first order rate constants of 0.0789 × 10^-3 and 3.70 × 10^-3 min^-1, respectively. Taken together, these data establish the dramatic influence even subtle changes can have in altering the electronic properties of chlorins, which in turn impacts metallochlorin function.

Convenient Immobilization of Cobalt Corroles on Carbon Nanotubes through Covalent Bonds for Electrocatalytic Hydrogen and Oxygen Evolution Reactions

Two different methods were used to immobilize Co corroles on carbon nanotubes (CNTs) through covalent bonds. The resulting CNTs engineered with Co corroles were used as electrocatalysts for the hydrogen evolution reaction (HER) and the oxygen evolution reaction (OER) in aqueous solutions of pH 0, 7, and 14. For both HER and OER in all solutions, the hybrids obtained by attaching Co corroles on CNTs through amidation coupling showed better performance. This is likely because the large surface area and good electrical conductivity of CNTs can be well preserved during the amidation reaction under mild conditions.

Boosting hydrogen evolution by using covalent frameworks of fluorinated cobalt porphyrins supported on carbon nanotubes

A covalent framework using fluorinated cobalt porphyrins is synthesized and shows significantly improved efficiency for the hydrogen evolution reaction in aqueous solution.

Electrocatalytic hydrogen evolution with gallium hydride and ligand-centered reduction

Ga^III porphyrin is active for electrocatalytic hydrogen evolution with unusual features, including ligand-centered electron transfer and formation of post-transition metal hydride.

Ga^III chloride tetrakis(pentafluorophenyl)porphyrin (1) was synthesized and shown to be a highly active and stable post-transition metal-based electrocatalyst for the hydrogen evolution reaction (HER). Electrochemical and spectroscopic studies indicate that both the first and second reduction events of 1 are ligand-centered. The 2e-reduced form 1^2– reacts with a proton to give Ga^III–H species (1–H), which undergoes protonolysis with Brønsted acids to produce H₂. The identification of key intermediates 1^–, 1^2–, and 1–H leads to a catalytic cycle, which is valuable for the fundamental understanding of the HER. This study presents a rare but highly active HER electrocatalyst with unusual features, including ligand-centered electron transfer and formation of post-transition metal hydride.

A mechanism study on the hydrogen evolution reaction catalyzed by molybdenum disulfide complexes

Water-mediated intermolecular H⁺/H⁻ coupling between two- or three-electron reduced sulfur hydride complexes with a hydrated proton is preferred to produce H₂ rather than intramolecular couplings between sulfur hydride and metal hydride complexes.

Cobalt Schiff-base complexes for electrocatalytic hydrogen generation

Two cobalt(iii) complexes containing inexpensive Schiff-base ligands have been found to be active for proton reduction at low overpotentials.