Dynamics of Rayleigh Fission Processes in ∼100 nm Charged Aqueous Nanodrops

Are Hydroxyl Radicals Spontaneously Generated in Unactivated Water Droplets?

Spontaneous ionization/breakup of water at the surface of aqueous droplets has been reported with evidence ranging from formation of hydrogen peroxide and hydroxyl radicals, indicated by ions at m/z 36 attributed to OH⋅-H3O+ or (H2O-OH2)+⋅ as well as oxidation products of radical scavengers in mass spectra of water droplets formed by pneumatic nebulization. Here, aqueous droplets are formed both by nanoelectrospray, which produces highly charged nanodrops with initial diameters ~100 nm, and a vibrating mesh nebulizer, which produces 2-20 μm droplets that are initially less highly charged. The lifetimes of these droplets range from 10s of μs to 560 ms and the surface-to-volume ratios span ~100-fold range. No ions at m/z 36 are detected with pure water, nor are significant oxidation products for the two radical scavengers that were previously reported to be formed in high abundance. These and other results indicate that prior conclusions about spontaneous hydroxyl radical formation in unactivated water droplets are not supported by the evidence and that water appears to be stable at droplet surfaces over a wide range of droplet size, charge and lifetime.

Does the Formation of a Taylor Cone in a Pulsating Electrospray Directly Impact Mass Spectrometry Signals?

Electrospray ionization (ESI) remains the dominant technique in mass spectrometry (MS)-based analyses. Here, we investigated the relationship between a crucial aspect of ESI, the formation of the Taylor cone, and the MS ion current by utilizing a triple quadrupole (QqQ) mass spectrometer coupled with a streaming high-speed camera and a 3-ring electrode system. In one test, ion current over a 30-s plume gate (a ring electrode) opening was compared with the Taylor cone occurrence analyzed offline, with Spearman's correlation coefficients consistently near 0 despite parameter variations. In another test, real-time detection of Taylor cones was synchronized with QqQ-MS, selectively opening (de-energizing) the plume gate based on the Taylor cone status. This approach enabled matching the ion current with the Taylor cone occurrence. There was no apparent difference between the MS signals recorded in the presence and absence of a Taylor cone. Additionally, a Faraday plate was employed as a detector in offline experiments, revealing agreement between the frequency of liquid meniscus (Taylor cone) oscillation (∼1.92 kHz)-measured by high-speed imaging-and the frequency of spray current (∼1.93 kHz). We suggest that the lack of positive correlations in the MS experiments is due to intrinsic ion carryover during transit from the ion source to the detector and due to the insufficient data acquisition rate of the mass spectrometer, which erases short-term fluctuations of ion current.

High-Throughput Single-Particle Characterization of Aggregation Pathways and the Effects of Inhibitors for Large (Megadalton) Protein Oligomers

Protein aggregation is involved in many human diseases, but characterizing the sizes and shapes of intermediate oligomers (∼10-100 nm) that are important to the formation of macroscale aggregates like amyloid fibrils is a significant analytical challenge. Here, charge detection mass spectrometry (CDMS) is used to characterize individual conformational states of bovine serum albumin oligomers with up to ∼225 molecules (15 MDa). Elongated, partially folded, and globular conformational families for each oligomer can be readily distinguished based on the extent of charging. The abundances of individual conformers vary with changes in the monomer concentration or by adding aggregation inhibitors, such as SDS, heparin, or MgCl2. These results show the potential of CDMS for investigating intermediate oligomers in protein aggregation processes that are important for understanding aggregate formation and inhibition mechanisms and could accelerate formulation buffer development to prevent the aggregation of biotherapeutics.

Complementary Nanoparticle Characterization by Resistive-Pulse Sensing, Electron Microscopy, and Charge Detection Mass Spectrometry

Nanotechnology has provided novel modalities for the delivery of therapeutic and diagnostic agents. In particular, nanoparticles (NPs) can be engineered at a low cost for drug loading and delivery. For example, silica NPs have proven useful as a controlled release platform for anti-inflammatory drugs. Despite the wide-ranging potential applications for NPs, robust characterization across all size ranges remains elusive. Electron microscopy (EM) is the conventional tool for measuring NP diameters. However, imitations in throughput and the inability to provide comprehensive information on physical properties, such as mass and density, without underlying assumptions, hinder a complete analysis. In addition, assessing sample heterogeneity, aggregation, or coalescence in solution by traditional EM analysis is not possible. Resistive-pulse sensing (RPS) provides a high throughput, solution-phase method for characterizing particle heterogeneity based on volume. Complementing these methods, charge detection mass spectrometry (CD-MS), a single particle technique, provides accurate mass information for heterogeneous samples including NPs. By combining EM, RPS and CD-MS, accurate volume, mass, and densities were obtained for silica NPs of various sizes. The results show that the density for 20 nm silica NPs is close to the density of fused silica (2.2 g/cm3). Larger silica NPs were found to have densities that were either smaller or larger, while also falling outside the range of densities usually found for silica colloids and NPs (1.9-2.3 g/cm3). Lower densities are attributed to pores (i.e., porous particles). For one sample, the mass distribution showed two components attributed to two populations of particles in the sample with different densities. The synergistic combination of EM, RPS, and CD-MS measurements outlined here for NP samples, allows much more extensive information to be obtained than from any of the techniques alone.

Charge Detection Mass Spectrometry Enables Molecular Characterization of Nucleic Acid Nanoparticles

Nucleic acid nanoparticles (NANPs) are increasingly used in preclinical investigations as delivery vectors. Tools that can characterize assembly and assess quality will accelerate their development and clinical translation. Standard techniques used to characterize NANPs, like gel electrophoresis, lack the resolution for precise characterization. Here, we introduce the use of charge detection mass spectrometry (CD-MS) to characterize these materials. Using this technique, we determined the mass of NANPs varying in size, shape, and molecular mass, NANPs varying in production quality due to formulations lacking component oligonucleotides, and NANPs functionalized with protein and nucleic acid-based secondary molecules. Based on these demonstrations, CD-MS is a promising tool to precisely characterize NANPs, enabling more precise assessments of the manufacturing and processing of these materials.

Charge Detection Mass Spectrometry Reveals Conformational Heterogeneity in Megadalton-Sized Monoclonal Antibody Aggregates

Aggregation of protein-based therapeutics can occur during development, production, or storage and can lead to loss of efficacy and potential toxicity. Native mass spectrometry of a covalently linked pentameric monoclonal antibody complex with a mass of ∼800 kDa reveals several distinct conformations, smaller complexes, and abundant higher-order aggregates of the pentameric species. Charge detection mass spectrometry (CDMS) reveals individual oligomers up to the pentamer mAb trimer (15 individual mAb molecules; ∼2.4 MDa) whereas intermediate aggregates composed of 6-9 mAb molecules and aggregates larger than the pentameric dimer (1.6 MDa) were not detected/resolved by standard mass spectrometry, size exclusion chromatography (SEC), capillary electrophoresis (CE-SDS), or by mass photometry. Conventional quadrupole time-of-flight mass spectrometry (QTOF MS), mass photometry, SEC, and CE-SDS did not resolve partially or more fully unfolded conformations of each oligomer that were readily identified using CDMS by their significantly higher extents of charging. Trends in the charge-state distributions of individual oligomers provides detailed insight into how the structures of compact and elongated mAb aggregates change as a function of aggregate size. These results demonstrate the advantages of CDMS for obtaining accurate masses and information about the conformations of large antibody aggregates despite extensive overlapping m/z values. These results open up the ability to investigate structural changes that occur in small, soluble oligomers during the earliest stages of aggregation for antibodies or other proteins.

Compaction, Relaxation, and Linearization of Megadalton-Sized DNA Plasmids: DNA Structures Probed by CD-MS

High purity plasmid DNA is a raw material for recombinant protein production as well as an active ingredient in DNA vaccines. There are four primary plasmid structures that can be observed in a typical plasmid formulation: supercoiled, relaxed (circular), linearized, and condensed. Determining what structures are present in a sample is important, as the structure can affect activity; the supercoiled structure has the highest activity, and >90% supercoiled is desired for industry standards. Recently, charge detection mass spectrometry (CD-MS) was used to distinguish two of the structures, supercoiled and condensed, by measuring the charge deposited on the ions by positive mode electrospray. Here, CD-MS is used to probe the structures of DNA plasmids during compaction with polycations, and through enzymatic treatment to relax and linearize plasmids. We find that all four structural types for plasmid DNA have unique charging profiles that can be distinguished using CD-MS. The extent of mechanical shearing of the DNA plasmids during electrospray is strongly influenced by the structural type.

Charge Detection Mass Spectrometry Reveals Favored Structures in the Assembly of Virus-Like Particles: Polymorphism in Norovirus GI.1

The main capsid protein (CP) of norovirus, the leading cause of gastroenteritis, is expected to self-assemble into virus-like particles with the same structure as the wild-type virus, a capsid with 180 CPs in a T = 3 icosahedron. Using charge detection mass spectrometry (CD-MS), we find that the norovirus GI.1 variant is structurally promiscuous, forming a wide variety of well-defined structures, some that are icosahedral capsids and others that are not. The structures that are present evolve with time and vary with solution conditions. The presence of icosahedral T = 3 and T = 4 capsids (240 CPs) under some conditions was confirmed by cryo-electron microscopy (cryo-EM). The cryo-EM studies also confirmed the presence of an unexpected prolate geometry based on an elongated T = 4 capsid with 300 CPs. In addition, CD-MS measurements indicate the presence of well-defined peaks with masses corresponding to 420, 480, 600, and 700 CPs. The peak corresponding to 420 CPs is probably due to an icosahedral T = 7 capsid, but this could not be confirmed by cryo-EM. It is possible that the T = 7 particles are too fragile to survive vitrification. There are no mass peaks associated with the T = 9 and T = 12 icosahedra with 540 and 720 CPs. The larger structures with 480, 600, and 700 CPs are not icosahedral; however, their measured charges suggest that they are hollow shells. The use of CD-MS to monitor virus-like particles assembly may have important applications in vaccine development and quality control.

Characterization of Mass, Diameter, Density, and Surface Properties of Colloidal Nanoparticles Enabled by Charge Detection Mass Spectrometry

A variety of scattering-based, microscopy-based, and mobility-based methods are frequently used to probe the size distributions of colloidal nanoparticles with transmission electron microscopy (TEM) often considered to be the "gold standard". Charge detection mass spectrometry (CDMS) is an alternative method for nanoparticle characterization that can rapidly measure the mass and charge of individual nanoparticle ions with high accuracy. Two low polydispersity, ∼100 nm diameter nanoparticle size standards with different compositions (polymethyl methacrylate/polystyrene copolymer and 100% polystyrene) were characterized using both TEM and CDMS to explore the merits and complementary aspects of both methods. Mass and diameter distributions are rapidly obtained from CDMS measurements of thousands of individual ions of known spherical shape, requiring less time than TEM sample preparation and image analysis. TEM image-to-image variations resulted in a ∼1-2 nm range in the determined mean diameters whereas the CDMS mass precision of ∼1% in these experiments leads to a diameter uncertainty of just 0.3 nm. For the 100% polystyrene nanoparticles with known density, the CDMS and TEM particle diameter distributions were in excellent agreement. For the copolymer nanoparticles with unknown density, the diameter from TEM measurements combined with the mass from CDMS measurements enabled an accurate measurement of nanoparticle density. Differing extents of charging for the two nanoparticle standards measured by CDMS show that charging is sensitive to nanoparticle surface properties. A mixture of the two samples was separated based on their different extents of charging despite having overlapping mass distributions centered at 341.5 and 331.0 MDa.

Long term online desalting analysis of MS/LC-MS using thermal assisted recrystallization ionization

Mass spectrometric analysis of non-volatile salts containing samples remains challenging due to salt-induced ion suppression and contamination. This challenge is even more pronounced for a liquid chromatography-mass spectrometry analysis, where the accumulation of salts in the transmission system poses an ongoing problem. In this study, a novel thermal assisted recrystallization ionization mass spectrometry (TARI-MS) device was developed to achieve efficient on-line desalting and prolonged analysis of saline samples. The core component of this device was a heated plate positioned between the electrospray unit and the MS inlet. The desalting mechanism was demonstrated as the spontaneous separation of target molecules from salts during the "crystallization" process. After optimization, the angle between the nebulizer and the heated plate was 45°; the distance between the front end of the heated plate and the MS inlet was 2 mm; the distance between the front edge of the heated plate and the center of the sample spray projected onto the heating plate was 3 mm; the distance between the emitter of nebulizer and the heated plate was 3 mm. TARI-MS realized direct analysis of eight drugs dissolved in eight commonly used non-volatile salts solutions (up to 0.5 mol/L). The high sensitivity, repeatability, linearity, accuracy, and intra- and inter-day precision of TARI-MS confirm its reliability as a robust tool for the analysis of saline samples. Furthermore, TARI-MS allowed continuous analysis of salty eluates of LC for up to nearly 1 h without maintenance and verified the feasibility of LC-MS analysis through detecting a five-drug mixture and a crude aripiprazole product. Finally, six impurities in the crude aripiprazole product were successfully detected by LC-TARI-MS. The established method holds promise for applications across academic and pharmaceutical domains.

MD Simulations of Peptide-Containing Electrospray Droplets: Effects of Parameter Settings on the Predicted Mechanisms of Gas Phase Ion Formation

Electrospray ionization (ESI) mass spectrometry is widely used for interrogating peptides, proteins, and other biomolecular analytes. A growing number of laboratories use molecular dynamics (MD) simulations for uncovering ESI mechanisms by modeling the behavior of highly charged nanodroplets. The outcome of any MD simulation depends on certain assumptions and parameter settings, and it is desirable to optimize these factors by benchmarking computational data against experiments. Unfortunately, benchmarking of ESI simulations is difficult because experimentally generated gaseous ions do not generally retain any features that would reveal their formation pathway [e.g., the charged residue mechanism (CRM) or the ion evaporation mechanism (IEM)]. Here, we tackle this problem by examining the effects of various MD settings on the ESI behavior of the 9-residue peptide bradykinin in acidic aqueous droplets. Several parameters were found to significantly affect the kinetic competition between peptide IEM and CRM. By systematically probing the droplet behavior, we uncovered problems associated with certain settings, including peptide/solvent temperature imbalances, unexpected peptide deceleration during IEM, and a dependence of the ESI mechanism on the water model. We also noted different simulation outcomes for different force fields. On the basis of comprehensive tests, we propose a set of "best practice" parameter settings for MD simulations of ESI droplets. The strategies used here should be transferable to other types of droplet simulations, paving the way toward a more solid understanding of ESI mechanisms.

Real-Time Monitoring of the Evaporation and Fission of Electrospray-Ionized Polystyrene Beads and Bacterial Pellets at Elevated Temperatures

This study uses real-time monitoring, at microsecond time scales, with a charge-sensing particle detector to investigate the evaporation and fission processes of methanol/micrometer-sized polystyrene beads (PS beads) droplets and bacterial particles droplets generated via electrospray ionization (ESI) under elevated temperatures. By incrementally raising capillary temperatures, the solvent, such as methanol on 0.75 μm PS beads, experiences partial evaporation. Further temperature increase induces fission, and methanol molecules continue to evaporate until PS ions are detected after this range. Similar partial evaporation is observed on 3 μm PS beads. However, the shorter period of the fission temperature range is necessary compared to 0.75 μm PS beads. For the spherical-shaped bacterium, Staphylococcus aureus, the desolvation process shows a similar fission period as compared to 0.75 μm PS beads. Comparably, the rod-shaped bacteria, Escherichia coli EC11303, and E. coli strain W have shorter fission periods than S. aureus. This research provides insights into the evaporation and fission mechanisms of ESI droplets containing different sizes and shapes of micrometer-sized particles, contributing to a better understanding of gaseous macroion formation.

Single-Ion Mass Spectrometry for Heterogeneous and High Molecular Weight Samples

In charge detection mass spectrometry (CD-MS) the mass of each individual ion is determined from the measurement of its mass to charge ratio (m/z) and charge. Performing this measurement for thousands of ions allows mass distributions to be measured for heterogeneous and high mass samples that cannot be analyzed by conventional mass spectrometry (MS). CD-MS opens the door to accurate mass measurements for samples into the giga-Dalton regime, vastly expanding the reach of MS and allowing mass distributions to be determined for viruses, gene therapies, and vaccines. Following the success of CD-MS, single-ion mass measurements have recently been performed on an Orbitrap. CD-MS and Orbitrap individual ion mass spectrometry (I2MS) are described. Illustrative examples are provided, and the prospects for higher resolution measurements discussed. In the case of CD-MS, computer simulations indicate that much higher resolving powers are within reach. The ability to perform high-resolution CD-MS analysis of heterogeneous samples will be enabling and disruptive in top-down MS as high-resolution m/z and accurate charge measurements will allow very complex m/z spectra to be unraveled.

Ion emission from 1-10 MDa salt clusters: individual charge state resolution with charge detection mass spectrometry

Salt cluster ions produced by electrospray ionization are used for mass calibration and fundamental investigations into cluster stability and charge separation processes. However, previous studies have been limited to relatively small clusters owing to the heterogeneity associated with large, multiply-charged clusters that leads to unresolved signals in conventional m/z spectra. Here, charge detection mass spectrometry is used to measure both the mass and charge distributions of positively charged clusters of KCl, CaCl2, and LaCl3 with masses between ∼1 and 10 MDa by dynamically measuring the energy per charge, m/z, charge, and mass of simultaneously trapped individual ions throughout a 1 s trapping time. The extent of remaining hydration on the clusters, determined from the change in the frequency of ion motion with time as a result of residual water loss, follows the order KCl < CaCl2 < LaCl3, and is significantly lower than that of a pure water nanodrop, consistent with tighter water binding to the more highly charged cations in these clusters. The number of ion emission events from these clusters also follows this same trend, indicating that water at the cluster surface facilitates charge loss. A new frequency-based method to determine the magnitude of the charge loss resulting from individual ion emission events clearly resolves losses of +1 and +2 ions. Achieving this individual charge state resolution for ion emission events is an important advance in obtaining information about the late stages of bare gaseous ions formation. Future experiments on more hydrated clusters are expected to lead to a better understanding of ion formation in electrospray ionization.

Combined Multiharmonic Frequency Analysis for Improved Dynamic Energy Measurements and Accuracy in Charge Detection Mass Spectrometry

The ability to determine ion energies in electrostatic ion-trap-based charge detection mass spectrometry (CDMS) experiments is important for the accurate measurement of individual ion m/z, charge, and mass. Dynamic energy measurements throughout the time an ion is trapped take advantage of the relationship between ion energy and the harmonic amplitude ratio (HAR) composed from the fundamental and second harmonic amplitudes in the Fourier transform of the ion signal. This method eliminates the need for energy-filtering optics in CDMS and makes it possible to measure energy lost in collisions and changes in ion masses due to dissociation. However, the accuracy of the energy measurement depends on the signal-to-noise ratio (S/N) of the amplitudes used to determine the HAR. Here, a major improvement to this HAR-based dynamic energy measurement method is achieved using HARs composed of higher-order harmonics in addition to the fundamental and second harmonic to determine ion energies. This combined harmonic amplitude ratios for precision energy refinement (CHARPER) method is applied to the analysis of a 103 nm polystyrene nanoparticle ion (359.7 MDa, m/z = 308,300) and the energy resolution (3140) and effective mass resolution (730) achieved are the best yet demonstrated in electrostatic ion-trap-based CDMS. The CHARPER method applied to an ensemble of several thousand adeno-associated virus ion signals also results in higher mass resolution compared to the basic HAR method, making it possible to resolve additional features in the composite mass histogram.

Dynamic Energy Measurements in Charge Detection Mass Spectrometry Eliminate Adverse Effects of Ion-Ion Interactions

Ion-ion interactions in charge detection mass spectrometers that use electrostatic traps to measure masses of individual ions have not been reported previously, although ion trajectory simulations have shown that these types of interactions affect ion energies and thereby degrade measurement performance. Here, examples of interactions between simultaneously trapped ions that have masses ranging from ca. 2 to 350 MDa and ca. 100 to 1000 charges are studied in detail using a dynamic measurement method that makes it possible to track the evolution of the mass, charge, and energy of individual ions over their trapping lifetimes. Signals from ions that have similar oscillation frequencies can have overlapping spectral leakage artifacts that result in slightly increased uncertainties in the mass determination, but these effects can be mitigated by the careful choice of parameters used in the short-time Fourier transform analysis. Energy transfers between physically interacting ions are also observed and quantified with individual ion energy measurement resolution as high as ∼950. The mass and charge of interacting ions do not change, and their corresponding measurement uncertainties are equivalent to ions that do not undergo physical interactions. Simultaneous trapping of multiple ions in CDMS can greatly decrease the acquisition time necessary to accumulate a statistically meaningful number of individual ion measurements. These results demonstrate that while ion-ion interactions can occur when multiple ions are trapped, they have negligible effects on mass accuracy when using the dynamic measurement method.