Steering Selectivity in the Four-Electron and Two-Electron Oxygen Reduction Reactions: On the Importance of the Volcano Slope

Conventional versus Unconventional Oxygen Reduction Reaction Intermediates on Single Atom Catalysts

The oxygen reduction reaction (ORR) stands as a pivotal process in electrochemistry, finding applications in various energy conversion technologies such as fuel cells, metal-air batteries, and chlor-alkali electrolyzers. Hereby, a comprehensive density functional theory (DFT) investigation is presented into the proposed conventional and unconventional ORR mechanisms using single-atom catalysts (SACs) supported on nitrogen-doped graphene (NG) as model systems. Several reaction intermediates have been identified that appear to be more stable than the ones postulated in the conventional mechanism, which follows the *OOH, *O, and *OH intermediates. This finding particularly holds for adsorbed *O2, which can have different adsorption geometries, ranging from η1Ο2 or η2Ο2 superoxo complexes as well as sin and anti complexes, with the two O-related ligands binding on the same or opposite sides, respectively. In the case of M@NG (M = Sc, Ti, V, Cr, Mn, Fe, Co, Ni, Cu, Zn, and Pt), the ORR follows these unconventional *O2 intermediates, whereas for Cr@NG and Cu@NG classical and unconventional *O2 intermediates compete. We approximate the electrocatalytic activity using the concept of the thermodynamic overpotential and demonstrate that the conventional mechanism gives rise to a smaller overpotential compared to mechanisms following unconventional intermediates during the four proton-coupled electron transfer steps. Our trend study indicates that transition metals with fewer d electrons reveal smaller electrocatalytic activity due to a larger thermodynamic overpotential. Among the investigated SAC systems, Co emerges as a promising candidate, with thermodynamic overpotential and limiting potential values of 0.38 and 0.85 V vs the standard hydrogen electrode, respectively, with the conventional mechanism being favored, and with Cu appearing as the second-best candidate.

Design Criteria for Active and Selective Catalysts in the Nitrogen Oxidation Reaction

The direct conversion of dinitrogen to nitrate is a dream reaction to combine the Haber-Bosch and Ostwald processes as well as steam reforming using electrochemistry in a single process. Regrettably, the corresponding nitrogen oxidation (NOR) reaction is hampered by a selectivity problem, since the oxygen evolution reaction (OER) is both thermodynamically and kinetically favored in the same potential range. This opens the search for the identification of active and selective NOR catalysts to enable nitrate production under anodic reaction conditions. While theoretical considerations using the computational hydrogen electrode approach have helped in identifying potential material motifs for electrocatalytic reactions over the last decades, the inherent complexity of the NOR, which consists of ten proton-coupled electron transfer steps and thus at least nine intermediate states, poses a challenge for electronic structure theory calculations in the realm of materials screening. To this end, we present a different strategy to capture the competing NOR and OER at the atomic scale. Using a data-driven method, we provide a framework to derive generalized design criteria for materials with selectivity toward NOR. This leads to a significant reduction of the computational costs, since only two free-energy changes need to be evaluated to draw a first conclusion on NOR selectivity.

Steering acidic oxygen reduction selectivity of single-atom catalysts through the second sphere effect

Natural enzymes feature distinctive second spheres near their active sites, leading to exquisite catalytic reactivity. However, incumbent synthetic strategies offer limited versatility in functionalizing the second spheres of heterogeneous catalysts. Here, we prepare an enzyme-mimetic single Co-N4 atom catalyst with an elaborately configured pendant amine group in the second sphere via 1,3-dipolar cycloaddition, which switches the oxygen reduction reaction selectivity from the 4e- to the 2e- pathway under acidic conditions. Proton inventory studies and theoretical calculations reveal that the introduced pendant amine acts as a proton relay and promotes the protonation of *O2 to *OOH on the Co-N4 active site, facilitating H2O2 production. The second sphere-tailored Co-N4 sites reach optima H2O2 selectivity of 97% ± 1.13%, showing a 3.46-fold enhancement to bare Co-N4 catalyst (28% ± 1.75%). This work provides an appealed approach for enzyme-like catalyst design, bridging the gap between enzymatic and heterogeneous catalysis.

Machine-Learning-Assisted Screening of Nanocluster Electrocatalysts: Mapping and Reshaping the Activity Volcano for the Oxygen Reduction Reaction

In computational heterogeneous catalysis, Sabatier's principle-based activity volcano plots provide an intuitive guide to catalyst design but impose a fundamental constraint on the maximum achievable catalytic performance. Recently, subnano clusters have emerged as an exciting platform, offering high noble metal utilization and superior performance for various reactions compared to extended surfaces, reflecting a complex structure-activity relationship in the non-scalable regime. However, understanding their non-monotonic catalytic activity, attributed to the large configurational space and their fluxional identity, poses a formidable challenge. Here, we present a machine learning (ML) framework that captures the non-monotonic trends in oxygen reduction reaction (ORR) activity at the subnanometer scale, attributed to their dynamic fluxional characteristics. We demonstrate a size-dependent shifting and reshaping of the ORR activity volcano, with Au replacing Pt at the peak. Leveraging only upon the non-ab initio geometric and electronic properties, our trained ML model accurately captures the site-specific adsorption energies of intermediates at the subnanometer regime. To account for the inconsistent trend in activity, we analyzed the correlation between electronic and geometric properties. Our findings reveal that the d-filling and coupling matrix of the neighboring metal atom significantly influences the intermediate adsorption on the local chemical environment compared to the d-band center. Following this analysis, we utilized ML to map the catalyst distribution in the activity volcano and identified the five best sub-nano electrocatalysts, demonstrating overpotential values lower than or comparable to the Pt(111) surface for the ORR. This study provides intuitive guidelines for the rational designing of highly efficient electrocatalysts for fuel cell applications while modifying the activity volcano plots for electrocatalysts at the subnanometer regime.

Oxygen doping regulation of Co single atom catalysts for electro-Fenton degradation of tetracycline

Electro-Fenton is an effective process for degrading hard-to-degrade organic pollutants, such as tetracycline (TC). However, the degradation efficiency of this process is limited by the activity and stability of the cathode catalyst. Herein, a temperature gradient pyrolysis strategy and oxidation treatment is proposed to modulate the coordination environment to prepare oxygen-doped cobalt monoatomic electrocatalysts (CoNOC). The CoNOC catalysts can achieve the selectivity of 93 % for H2O2 with an electron transfer number close to 2. In the H-cell, the prepared electrocatalysts can achieve more than 100 h of H2O2 production with good stability and the yield of 1.41 mol gcatalyst-1 h-1 with an average Faraday efficiency (FE) of more than 88 %. The calculations indicate that the epoxy groups play a crucial role in modulating the oxygen reduction pathway. The O doping and unique N coordination of Co single-atom active sites (CoN(Pd)3N(Po)1O1) can effectively weaken the O2/OOH* interaction, thereby promoting the production of H2O2. Finally, the electro-Fenton system could achieve a TC degradation rate of 94.9 % for 120 min with a mineralization efficiency of 87.8 % for 180 min, which provides a reliable option for antibiotic treatment. The significant involvement of OH in the electro-Fenton process was confirmed, and the plausible mineralization pathway for TC was proposed.

From 2e- to 4e- pathway in the alkaline oxygen reduction reaction on Au(100): Kinetic circumvention of the volcano curve

We report the free energy barriers for the elementary reactions in the 2e- and 4e- oxygen reduction reaction (ORR) steps on Au(100) in an alkaline solution. Due to the weak adsorption energy of O2 on Au(100), the barrier for the association channel is very low, and the 2e- pathway is clearly favored, while the barrier for the O-O dissociation channel is significantly higher at 0.5 eV. Above 0.7 V reversible hydrogen electrode (RHE), the association channel becomes thermodynamically unfavorable, which opens up the O-O dissociation channel, leading to the 4e- pathway. The low adsorption energy of oxygenated species on Au is now an advantage, and residue ORR current can be observed up to the 1.0-1.2 V region (RHE). In contrast, the O-O dissociation barrier on Au(111) is significantly higher, at close to 0.9 eV, due to coupling with surface reorganization, which explains the lower ORR activity on Au(111) than that on Au(100). In combination with the previously suggested outer sphere electron transfer to O2 for its initial adsorption, these results provide a consistent explanation for the features in the experimentally measured polarization curve for the alkaline ORR on Au(100) and demonstrate an ORR mechanism distinct from that on Pt(111). It also highlights the importance to consider the spin state of O2 in ORR and to understand the activation barriers, in addition to the adsorption energies, to account for the features observed in electrochemical measurements.

General Design Concept of High-Performance Single-Atom-Site Catalysts for H2O2 Electrosynthesis

Hydrogen peroxide (H2O2) as a green oxidizing agent is widely used in various fields. Electrosynthesis of H2O2 has gradually become a hotspot due to its convenient and environment-friendly features. Single-atom-site catalysts (SASCs) with uniform active sites are the ideal catalysts for the in-depth study of the reaction mechanism and structure-performance relationship. In this review, the outstanding achievements of SASCs in the electrosynthesis of H2O2 through 2e- oxygen reduction reaction (ORR) and 2e- water oxygen reaction (WOR) in recent years, are summarized. First, the elementary steps of the two pathways and the roles of key intermediates (*OOH and *OH) in the reactions are systematically discussed. Next, the influence of the size effect, electronic structure regulation, the support/interfacial effect, the optimization of coordination microenvironments, and the SASCs-derived catalysts applied in 2e- ORR are systematically analyzed. Besides, the developments of SASCs in 2e- WOR are also overviewed. Finally, the research progress of H2O2 electrosynthesis on SASCs is concluded, and an outlook on the rational design of SASCs is presented in conjunction with the design strategies and characterization techniques.

Phosphorus-Ligand Redox Cooperative Catalysis: Unraveling Four-Electron Dioxygen Reduction Pathways and Reactive Intermediates

The reduction of dioxygen to water is crucial in biology and energy technologies, but it is challenging due to the inertness of triplet oxygen and complex mechanisms. Nature leverages high-spin transition metal complexes for this, whereas main-group compounds with their singlet state and limited redox capabilities exhibit subdued reactivity. We present a novel phosphorus complex capable of four-electron dioxygen reduction, facilitated by unique phosphorus-ligand redox cooperativity. Spectroscopic and computational investigations attribute this cooperative reactivity to the unique electronic structure arising from the geometry of the phosphorus complex bestowed by the ligand. Mechanistic study via spectroscopic and kinetic experiments revealed the involvement of elusive phosphorus intermediates resembling those in metalloenzymes. Our result highlights the multielectron reactivity of phosphorus compound emerging from a carefully designed ligand platform with redox cooperativity. We anticipate that the work described expands the strategies in developing main-group catalytic reactions, especially in small molecule fixations demanding multielectron redox processes.

Why efficient bifunctional hydrogen electrocatalysis requires a change in the reaction mechanism

Hydrogen evolution reaction (HER) and hydrogen oxidation reaction (HOR) are both two-electron processes that culminate in the formation or consumption of gaseous hydrogen in an electrolyzer or a fuel cell, respectively. Unitized regenerative proton exchange membrane fuel cells merge these two functionalities into one device, allowing to switch between the two modes of operation. This prompts the quest for efficient bifunctional electrode materials catalyzing the HER and HOR with reasonable reaction rates at low overpotentials. In the present study using a data-driven framework, we identify a general criterion for efficient bifunctional performance in the hydrogen electrocatalysis, which refers to a change in the reaction mechanism when switching from cathodic to anodic working conditions. The obtained insight can be used in future studies based on density functional theory to pave the design of efficient HER and HOR catalysts by a dedicated consideration of the kinetics in the analysis of reaction mechanisms.

Importance of the Walden Inversion for the Activity Volcano Plot of Oxygen Evolution

Since the birth of the computational hydrogen electrode approach, it is considered that activity trends of electrocatalysts in a homologous series can be quantified by the construction of volcano plots. This method aims to steer materials discovery by the identification of catalysts with an improved reaction kinetics, though evaluated by means of thermodynamic descriptors. The conventional approach for the volcano plot of the oxygen evolution reaction (OER) relies on the assumption of the mononuclear mechanism, comprising the * OH, * O, and * OOH intermediates. In the present manuscript, two new mechanistic pathways, comprising the idea of the Walden inversion in that bond-breaking and bond-making occurs simultaneously, are factored into a potential-dependent OER activity volcano plot. Surprisingly, it turns out that the Walden inversion plays an important role since the activity volcano is governed by mechanistic pathways comprising Walden steps rather than by the traditionally assumed reaction mechanisms under typical OER conditions.

On the mechanistic complexity of oxygen evolution: potential-dependent switching of the mechanism at the volcano apex

The anodic four-electron oxygen evolution reaction (OER) corresponds to the limiting process in acidic or alkaline electrolyzers to produce gaseous hydrogen at the cathode of the device. In the last decade, tremendous efforts have been dedicated to the identification of active OER materials by electronic structure calculations in the density functional theory approximation. Most of these works rely on the assumption that the mononuclear mechanism, comprising the *OH, *O, and *OOH intermediates, is operative under OER conditions, and that a single elementary reaction step (most likely *OOH formation) governs the kinetics. In the present manuscript, six different OER mechanisms are analyzed, and potential-dependent volcano curves are constructed to comprehend the electrocatalytic activity of these pathways in the approximation of the descriptor G_max(U), a potential-dependent activity measure based on the notion of the free-energy span model. While the mononuclear description mainly describes the legs of the volcano plot, corresponding to electrocatalysts with low intrinsic activity, it is demonstrated that the preferred pathway at the volcano apex is a strong function of the applied electrode potential. The observed mechanistic complexity including a switch of the favored pathway with increasing overpotential sets previous investigations aiming at the identification of reaction mechanisms and limiting steps into question since the entire breadth of OER pathways was not accounted for. A prerequisite for future atomic-scale studies on highly active OER catalysts refers to the evaluation of several mechanistic pathways so that neither important mechanistic features are overlooked nor limiting steps are incorrectly determined.